Basic linear expression / THU 1-11-24 / Mohammed's third and youngest wife / Finnish tech giant / Way down in the nether regions / Instrument notably featured in George Michael's 1984 hit "Careless Whisper"

Thursday, January 11, 2024

Constructor: Damon Gulczynski

Relative difficulty: Easy


THEME: Y = X (69A: Basic linear expression with a hint to answering the five starred clues in this puzzle) — change "y" to "x" in each of the starred clues; only then do their answers make sense:

Theme answers:
  • BAD BREAK-UP (17A: *Cause of irritated eyes) [Cause of irritated exes]
  • CAT PEOPLE (26A: *Many lovers, e.g.) [Manx lovers, e.g.]
  • "THE SHOW MUST GO ON" (38A: *Mayim of entertainment) [Maxim of entertainment]
  • BRAZILIAN (49A: *Way down in the nether regions) [Wax down in the nether regions]
  • DAS KAPITAL (59A: *Book of Mary) [Book of Marx]
Word of the Day: Chris REDD (18D: Former "S.N.L." comic Chris) —
 

Christopher Jerell Redd
 (born March 25, 1985) is an American stand-up comedian, actor, writer, rapper, and singer. After several years performing stand-up comedy, Redd was hired to join the cast of the NBC sketch comedy series Saturday Night Live ahead of the show's 43rd season in 2017, making his debut alongside Heidi Gardner and Luke Null, and serving as a cast member for five seasons until 2022. For his work on the show, he won a Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Original Music and Lyrics in 2018 for co-writing the SNL song "Come Back Barack". He is also known for his roles in Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping (2016), Disjointed (2017–2018), and Kenan (2021–2022). (wikipedia)
• • •

***ATTENTION: READERS AND FELLOW SOLVERS*** : Hello from Central New York and the first properly wintry week of the season! It's early January, which means it's time once again for my annual week-long pitch for financial contributions to the blog. Every year I ask readers to consider what the blog is worth to them on an annual basis and give accordingly. So ... 17 years ... not bad. At this time last year, I was recovering from COVID and still dealing with the very fresh grief brought on by the untimely death of my cat, Olive. I was very grateful for the blog at that point, since it grounded me in routine and gave me a place where I could lose myself in a pastime I love, and share that love with others. OK, yes, true, I don't always *love* crosswords. Sometimes it's more hate-love or love-hate or "Why are you being like this, you stupid puzzle!?" It ain't all positive vibes, as you know. But I realized last year that part of what makes this blog so fun for me, and what makes it a solace to many readers, is the sense of commiseration it provides. Sometimes the puzzle thrills you, and maybe I agree with you, and maybe I don't; and sometimes it infuriates you, and maybe I agree with you, and maybe I don't. But either way, the blog is here; it's *always* here. You get to have your feelings validated, or you get to shake your head at my errant judgment and often breathtaking ignorance, but either way, you get to share an experience that's an important part of your daily life, and maybe you learn something new. Above all, I hope you feel that there is a real person with a real life and real emotions and (very) real human flaws who's telling you what it was *really* like for him to solve the puzzle. I never wanted to be an expert, offering some kind of bloodless know-it-all advice and analysis. I wanted blood. Blood on the page. There will be blood! ... But also, music videos. And Words of the Day. And, if you hang around long enough, cat pictures. Like this one:


This is Ida (she put herself in the bin, I swear). Ida is the happy sequel to last year's grief. At the beginning of January, I was mourning. By the end of January, I was still mourning, but now I had a new companion (as did my other cat, Alfie, who *really* needed one). Why am I talking about my cats? Because they are constant, they give shape and rhythm to my day, and I love them even if they sometimes drive me crazy. Just like crossword puzzles! (See that! Segue! This is why you should pay me the big bucks!) 

However much I love writing this blog (and I do, a lot), it is, in fact, a job. This blog has covered the NYTXW every day, without fail, for 17 years, and except for two days a month (when my regular stand-ins Mali and Clare write for me), and an occasional vacation or sick day (when I hire substitutes to write for me), it's me who's doing the writing. Every day. At very ... let's say, inconvenient hours (my alarm goes off most mornings at 3:45am). Over the years, I have received all kinds of advice about "monetizing" the blog, invitations to turn it into a subscription-type deal à la Substack or Patreon. But that sort of thing has never felt right for me. I like being out here on Main, on this super old-school blogging platform, just giving it away for free and relying on conscientious addicts like yourselves to pay me what you think the blog's worth. It's just nicer that way. 

How much should you give? Whatever you think the blog is worth to you on a yearly basis. Whatever that amount is is fantastic. Some people refuse to pay for what they can get for free. Others just don't have money to spare. All are welcome to read the blog—the site will always be open and free. But if you are able to express your appreciation monetarily, here are three options. First, a Paypal button (which you can also find in the blog sidebar on the homepage):

Second, a mailing address (checks can be made out to "Michael Sharp" or "Rex Parker"):

Rex Parker c/o Michael Sharp
54 Matthews St
Binghamton, NY 13905

The third, increasingly popular option is Venmo; if that's your preferred way of moving money around, my handle is @MichaelDavidSharp (the last four digits of my phone are 4878, in case Venmo asks you, which I guess it does sometimes, when it's not trying to push crypto on you, what the hell?!)

All Paypal contributions will be gratefully acknowledged by email. All Venmo contributions will get a little heart emoji, at a minimum :) All snail mail contributions will be gratefully acknowledged with hand-written postcards. I. Love. Snail Mail. I love seeing your gorgeous handwriting and then sending you my awful handwriting. It's all so wonderful. My daughter (Ella Egan) has once again designed my annual thank-you cards, and once again those cards feature (wait for it) cats! My cats: Alfie & Ida. This year, an elegant set of five!



These really capture the combination of beauty and goofiness that I love in cats (and puzzles, frankly). I'd say "Collect All Five!" but every snail-mail contributor will get just one and (hopefully) like it! Please note: I don't keep a "mailing list" and don't share my contributor info with anyone. And if you give by snail mail and (for some reason) don't want a thank-you card, just indicate "NO CARD." Again, as ever, I'm so grateful for your readership and support. Please know that your support means a lot to me and my family. Now on to today's puzzle... 

• • •

Well this was fun, but really, really, dismayingly easy. The theme answers are, of course, going to give you some trouble for a while, but even before I knew what the gimmick was, I was able to put together BAD BREAK-UP from crosses without much trouble. I didn't *get* it—thought maybe there was some kind of sound change going on, the "real" answer was supposed to be BAD MAKE-UP (!?!?) (17A: *Cause of irritated eyes), but my point is that I could plow ahead without my theme incomprehension impeding my solve much at all. The fill was so easy that I just floated down the grid without even bothering with the themers at first. My solve ran like water down a staircase ... I don't like that simile, but that's how it felt. Down IBSEN and then across ASUNDER and then down EMO and across MEGA, down AUDEN and SAX and across EXACTED and down ATOP CHOIR until I hit the bottom of the staircase, which (magically!) was the location of the revealer. And this, for me, was the only part of the puzzle that was even remotely tough—figuring out what "Basic linear expression" meant in 69A: Basic linear expression with a hint to answering the five starred clues in this puzzle. I got the "Y" and "X" easily enough, but that box in between??? Somehow "expression" did not have me looking for an equation, so I had to rely on the cross to get that mystery box between "X" and "Y" and that cross ... was also not clear to me (62D: How peers should be treated). "Peers should be treated ... AS I ... am treated??? But then what the hell is YIX!? Is that come damn chess thing or coding thing or math thing I know zero about?" (this is always my first guess when I don't understand something—puzzle-makers lean heavy into chess/tech/math in a way that I ... do not; I did, as a child and teen, but then I ... drifted). I could tell that "Y" became "X" in the clues, but I still didn't understand the mystery box until I started thinking of words suggesting equivalency (Y IS X? Y TO X?) and then bam, there it was: EQUALS ("="). 


After getting the [EQUALS] trick, the puzzle had no more resistance to offer. I barely remember solving it. Except ... well, speaking of "barely" ... most of the themers didn't do much for me, in the way of amusement, but I will admit I laughed hard at BRAZILIAN, mainly because I thought "ah, ok, so *this* is the reason this puzzle exists! This answer right here! Well ... bravo, well played. Pubic grooming joke, noted!" The other "Y"-to-"X" changes were solid and well hidden —that is, the surface level meaning of the clue remained totally plausible—but none of them have the "wow, bold!" feeling that the BRAZILIAN clue did. Also, that [*Mayim of entertainment] clue was not gonna fool anyone. There's only one "Mayim of entertainment" that anyone knows, and her last name is not fifteen letters long. So if you didn't know something was wrong before that point, you should have then. Maybe this is where you figured out that "Y"-to-"X" gimmick. I don't know what it would've been like to figure it out on the fly because I didn't get the chance—hit the revealer too early. Might've been fun to suss it out without the revealer's help. But I enjoyed and appreciated the theme nonetheless.


The fill felt a little bit on the over-common (i.e. stale) side much of the time. HELI ORA ACAI HIREE IBIS NEATO ANODE EMO, that kind of thing. But nothing made me wince, and I never felt like my patience was being tried (perhaps because it was all so easy to move through). ASAHI, the official beer of Crossworld! (24D: Japanese beer). Did you know it's an anagram of AISHA? (53D: Mohammed's third and youngest wife). I did not, until this puzzle made me think about it, and there it was. There's some other doubling in this puzzle: the Steinbeck doubling ("EAST of EDEN") (27D: Steinbeck title starter / 67A: Steinbeck title ender) and then ... well, there's a bit of wedding doubling, I think (from WOO to BRIDE). And more doubleness at 21A: Inits. of (not one but) two schools in the Missouri Valley Conference] (ISU) (that's Illinois State and Indiana State). Beyond all this doubling, I don't know if there are any other remarkable features to point out today. REDD was the only answer that was not immediately familiar to me (there've been too many SNL cast members to count and I stopped paying attention to that show a better part of a decade ago, when political satire started seeing not only redundant and useless, but ... complicit, somehow). I just realized that this puzzle must've been strange to write, since you basically have to start with a list of "words that become other words when you swap 'Y' for 'X'" and work from there, trying to fashion "X" clues that lead to some set of theme answers (arranged symmetrically), while also maintaining a plausible "Y"-level surface meaning. The elegant simplicity of the gimmick masks (I think) a fairly complicated construction process. 


Just realized that yesterday really did mark the end of the Holiday Pet Pics! I'm kinda sad. Here are two last ones of reader Laura's late cat Ziggy. They weren't submitted as part of the Pet Pics extravaganza, just attached to regular old correspondence, but I think they capture the cozy, wintry vibe of the whole endeavor.

[Why would you make your cat shovel the walkway!? Seems both cruel and inefficient.]

[After a hard day of shoveling (and who knows what other household tasks his owners make him do!), Ziggy has truly earned his snack and crossword]

See you next time.  

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld 

P.S. I don't think I would've used "Supervillain" in my LEX Luthor clue (63D: Supervillain Luthor), what with SUPERLATIVE already in the grid. Seems ... I dunno, superfluous?

P.P.S. ROSE is [Flower girl?] simply because it's a "girl's" name that is also a "flower."

[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]

106 comments:

Conrad 5:48 AM  


I agree with OFL's Easy characterization, but I think I had more fun than he did, since I didn't read the clues for the long acrosses until after I'd finished. Quite a constructing accomplishment!

tompdavis 5:53 AM  

As a math geek, I spotted one thing in the grid that was, well, a bit auspicious.

The revealer is y=x, but there is a continuous diagonal from 1A to the final square, which is the line y = -x... so, a contradiction?

Anonymous 5:54 AM  

So proud to see Mayim’s name in the NYT puzzle, and hope she is too! (The big-headed boys at the top just will NOT include in their playbook a woman who is smarter than they are!)

Anonymous 5:55 AM  

Enjoyable solve, but I can’t figure out how to get an equals sign on my phone’s keyboard so I can’t finish 😭

Bruce Borchardt 6:10 AM  

I did a rebus "equals" which worked.

Eric NC 6:13 AM  

I used the rebus

Anonymous 6:14 AM  

Same for me, no = is available in the NYT puzzle app, my streak is in danger, help!

Anonymous 6:19 AM  

Same

Anonymous 6:20 AM  

You can use The NYTimes App to finish. It has the ability to insert the = symbol.

Bob Mills 6:24 AM  

Solved it backward. I got THESHOWMUSTGOON from the crosses, then knew "mayim" had to be "maxim." That meant CATPEOPLE referred to manx cats, and "Mary" had to stand for "Marx." I'm still not sure how BRAZILIAN relates to wax.

This is the first time since I've owned a computer (51 years) that I've ever used the = key.

Anonymous 6:25 AM  

I wrote "equals"and it worked fine!

Sinfonian 6:26 AM  

There may be an easier way, but EQUALS as a rebus worked for me (after trying a bunch of other punctuation).

Anonymous 6:27 AM  

Wow, good exe, @tompdavis (though I guess that's what you do)!

David F 6:52 AM  

@Bob Mills, a BRAZILIAN is a waxing of the "nether regions" to remove hair along the bikini line - so named because it's common in Brazil, I believe.

I shouldn't know that, but I do... :D

Anonymous 7:05 AM  

I have a serious streak going and would be having a mini freak out if this was happening to me! I used a rebus and wrote “equals” which I think works better with the down anyway.

Wanderlust 7:06 AM  

Good catch! Didn’t notice that.

Anonymous 7:07 AM  

Your write up helped me see why the revealer was a little off for me. As a math teacher “expression” is generally not an equation. I would have preferred “relationship.”

SouthsideJohnny 7:09 AM  

Sorry, way too cryptic for my taste. You basically get to slog through an entire grid with dark matter theme entries and nonsensical clues - then, if you’re lucky enough to figure out that basically the last entry is an equation of all things - then, POOF, all comes together and the puzzle magically turns into this wonderful solving experience. Give me a break.

CAT PEOPLE, MANX LOVERS, NIHIL . . . Geese, almost as unpleasant an experience as getting seasick.

Phillyrad1999 7:17 AM  

At the risk of being a super nerd I believe that the basic “linear” equation is y=mx + B. But at that point (pun intended) it was obvious so I guess no harm no foul, Wanted ACHY to be ACHE so spun my wheels there a bit but overall pretty easy.

Andy Freude 7:25 AM  

Ridiculously easy,* until you get to the last entry. There I spent a solid minute searching for the nonexistent = key in the NYT Games app (why??? just why???) and still finished well under my average time for a Thursday.

*Easy, that is, if you ignore the theme.

Wanderlust 7:26 AM  

I figured this would be a rare puzzle where everyone finished on the exact same square, but sounds like Rex worked out the revealer and then wrapped up other parts. I had no idea when I got to it, so I left it to the end. I also have little math knowledge so I was trying to work out the “peers” clue and for a little while feared I might Natick on that square. Finally “equals” came to me, but like other commenters, I searched in vain for an 🟰 sign on my phone keyboard. It doesn’t have one. (So how’d I just insert one? It came up as a suggestion when I typed in “equal sign.”) tried the rebus, and it worked.

Then I had the pleasure of going back to figure out the trick, since I filled in theme answers based on crosses, not knowing how they related to the clues. “Wait, there are no Xs or Ys in these answers.” Finally saw that the Ys were in the clues and loved the five aha moments - yes, especially for BRAZILIAN. Very fun and original.

Rock before REDD and ipa before ALE. How are Illinois and Indiana State universities in the Missouri Valley conference when they are east of the Mississippi? More like Ohio Valley. But I guess geography doesn’t matter anymore when California is in the Atlantic Coast Conference.

Lewis 7:35 AM  

Ah, a proper THursday, filled with many a “Wha?” and “Huh?”, and when the riddle is finally cracked, it’s with fireworks and the feel of the choir singing “Hallelujah!”

Took me way too long to think of looking at the clues for the trick. Man, I was parsing the theme answers every which way, and nothing was working. That was a gift, actually, because the size of the “Aha!” and the breadth of relief at the moment the curtains part is proportionate to the amount of failure that precedes it. Me, I went kaboom.

Sweet, sweet, sweet, Damon!

And clever. The clues to the theme answers are perfect – normal sounding clues that didin’t make me suspicious that they were the perpetrators.

Trickiness like this is why I love Thursdays. Payoffs like this are why I love Thursdays.

Damon, I haven’t had a boom like that in quite a while, and I’m extremely grateful. This was kapow city, and I loved it. Thank you in the highest, sir!

Anonymous 7:41 AM  

Thanks for the tip. I had it as equal without the s and then I was scratching my head looking for the = sign before coming here

Max W. 7:42 AM  

To play equally geeky devil’s advocate, the puzzle never defines a coordinate system, so that line *could* be y=x
;)
(Not saying it should be, of course haha)

Anonymous 7:43 AM  

Anyone else automatically put in tesla for 35 across?

Son Volt 8:00 AM  

Cute little puzzle - but definitely on the easy side. The chops are evident getting the DAS KAPITAL string to work and tucking that rebus into the revealer like that. The spanning themer is solid and the overall fill is slick.

I’m a sucker for a Tim Finn song.

The SW corner was SUPERLATIVE.

Pleasant Thursday morning solve.

There seems to be a lot of CAT PEOPLE here

Dr.A 8:01 AM  

Fun!! Also never heard of Chris Redd but now I know! Thanks to helping my daughter with her math homework, Y=X actually came pretty easily and then fit really well with AS =.
Yay, love that pic of the kitty with the puzzle.
There’s no real reason to stop.. maybe we need a Valentine’s Day kitty or a 4th of July pet?

Mr. Grumpypants 8:21 AM  

disappointing + dumb = today's puzzle

ac 8:31 AM  

love when a puzzle is even better in retrospect a lot of great words here and a great surprise reveal at the end if done top to bottom anyway... those of us who no Nihil about math gives us a sense of accomplishment

Anonymous 8:41 AM  

= = EQUALS

pabloinnh 8:45 AM  

First we get SH=C and now we have Y=X, and I have to say that today's was a lot more fun as the nonsensical answers suddenly became clear, which is a major Aha! and an elegant Thursday. The themers were all common words or expressions so I could fill them in without knowing why, and the revealer is in exactly the right place, so double yay!

Didn't know Mr. REDD, but did notice that ASAHI and AISHA are anagrams. I think I tried SONIA and SONYA before SONJA had to be right, but everything else was at least vaguely familiar. I remembered Ex NIHIL NILIL fit (I think that's right) from some long ago philosophy class. Rewarding.

Had no trouble making the = sign with my pencil. Highly recommended.

Well done indeed DG. Deliciously Gratifying solve, and thanks for all the fun.

SB-got to QB yesterday for the first time in a while (hi @Roo). I'd bet the pros at SB found yesterday's easy, but QB always fills me with an inordinate amount of self-satisfaction.

Rob LaRose 9:14 AM  


Aye, I think "linear expression" is factually incorrect. Put it on the NYTXW errata list. As I was taught, an expression is never an equation. If it has an equal sign, it's an equation.

I can see not wanting to use "equivalence" or any form of EQUALS but calculation, relationship, association are all perfectly fine words to use there.

RooMonster 9:22 AM  

Hey All !
Ah, you almost got me ruining my streak with your cheeky = sign! I had "equals" in as a Rebus, of course. Got the Almost There message, pored over the puz, not finding anything typo-ed. "Hmm", says I, "let's change that equals Rebus to just an E." Still got the Almost There. Said, whilst rolling up my sleeves, "OK, puz, gonna put an = sign in there." And then the Happy Music, to which I gave the screen a finger wag.

Got the X in the Revealer before any Themers, then saw the X in EXACTED (which I had as EXCiTED for a bit, throwing wrench's ASUNDER in that area), and thought that would be part of the Theme. Nope, just a red herring.

Figured out the trick finally when I said, "Those two Themers have to be correct!" for CAT PEOPLE and THE SHOW MUST GOON (DOOK!). "But how is that Y=X, when there's no Y or X in the answers?" Went back to the Mayim clue, and said, "Hey, there's a Y. If I change it to X, I get Maxim of entertainment, which, NEATO, first the clue!"

After that, reread each Themer, substituting the X for the Y, and voila, puz trick wrestled into submission. First pumping abounded!

(Is talking to myself that much a problem? 😁)

Pretty neat idea. Well hidden. Had some writeovers, but can't remember them! One good thing of a short memory ...

What was I saying?
Har

Supposed to snow a little here in Las Vegas today. Does so once in a while, when the temps get down below 30 (which they are this morning, and precipitation is called for, which is also on the menu for today. Good stuff.

No F's (BAD RAP)
RooMonster
DarrinV

Nancy 9:26 AM  

What a fabulous theme! It illustrates two of my most deeply held puzzle mayims:

1) A trick puzzle is almost always trickier when you put the trick in the clue rather than the answer.

2) A one-time-only rebus can be trickier than a recurring rebus because it's so unexpected.

This had both elements. And for me, the "Aha Moment" was huge.

But -- and I imagine you'll pretty much all agree -- the surrounding fill was much easier than usual for a Thursday. I think I would have preferred it quite a bit harder, but I can't be sure. I can only solve the puzzle I solved and not the imaginary puzzle I didn't solve. So I'm wondering: If you combined the trickiness of the theme with challenging fill all around it, would that have made the puzzle more frustrating than pleasurable?

I don't know. I adored the theme, but I sort of feel I got off pretty easy today.





Anonymous 9:27 AM  

lol sure

Ann Howell 9:28 AM  

Did not find it easy (more medium for a Thursday for me) and solved it as a themeless, because I was done by the time I got to the theme clue at the bottom. Felt good to solve, though, given that I had to completely guess the theme answers!

Anonymous 9:30 AM  

Hey Everybody, Damon Gulczynski here. Yes—the Damon Gulczynski. If Rex doesn’t mind me self-promoting in his comments section, I’m posting a link to my book of rejected crossword puzzles and personal anecdotes. Buy it! It’s not half bad!

Will Must Send Regrets: 101 Rejected Crossword Puzzles and the Stories Behind Them https://a.co/d/gIgs5Zr

Anonymous 9:35 AM  

Oh and ALSO -- years ago when my wife was just starting to do the crosswords, she once sent me a screenshot of a grid that was completely empty except for a single answer confidently entered in the middle of the puzzle : CATPEOPLE. I can't remember the clue, but she was thinking of the horror movie from the 80s and it was the only answer she could get, and she had complete confidence in it.

It was wrong, and though her crossword acumen has caught up to mine, I have never stopped teasing her about that answer.

Touché

Victoria 9:44 AM  

I'm clearly the only slow one this morning who stared at "SEN" and "one in a hundred" and it wasn't until after I'd finished the whole thing and stared in confusion ("it's right, but why???") that SENATOR dawned on me. Blush.

Fun_CFO 9:45 AM  

Fun puzzle. Definitely finished with rebus “EQUALS” square. Way below avg time.

Would have been a nice little flourish if those were the only “X” and “Y” in the grid, but no biggie. (“X” would have been easy to replace with “n”, “Y” not wasting my time).

Had “ETHos” first (and still think is more appropriate common language answer with the plural cluing).no one’s ever taken an “ETHIC” class. Again, no biggie, but really was the only place that gave a second or two hesitation until the revealer.

Anonymous 9:46 AM  

Loved this clever puzzle, I guess partly because the themers filled themselves in easily from crosses so I never felt frustrated. Actually figured out the y to x from the last theme answer (Mary-Marx) so the reveal was quick. Although I had Y2X first and had to look at the cross to get the =. Gotta love an easy Thursday!

Joel Palmer 9:47 AM  

Didnt get the theme at all but finished the fill anyway. Rex, just sent a Paypal and urge everyone to do the same !!

Diane Joan 9:50 AM  

It was easy for a Thursday until I entered the last boxes bottom right. I figured I’d just finish it and check here for the revealer. But it turns out I needed to figure out the revealer on my own to solve this. So first I came up with “ASI” for peers. Then what is a “YIX”? Have I entered Dr Seuss land? Then finally the correct answer dawned on me! Oh Thursday, how I love thee!

Steve Mallam 9:53 AM  

Use the “rebus” entry and type the entire word “equals”. Worked for me in the app

Fun_CFO 9:58 AM  

@Nancy - pondered the same thing, and pretty much settled on those themers needed to be irrefutable both in vernacular and strong confirmation with crosses as solve progressed to the revealer. I think there would be a lot more carping if those themers had some dodgy, ambiguous crosses. I also agree with Rex and others that was likely a tough/tricky construction. So, you kinda get you get.


Anonymous 10:08 AM  

First time ever I finished a Thursday crossword without a peek at… this blog! Do

Tina 10:09 AM  

I thought the rose answer should have been role. A flower girl is a role in a wedding party. II also could not find an equal sign on my NY APP keyboard. I also thought that the answer would have been ALL EQUAL.

Liveprof 10:16 AM  

Short note from yesterday on MILA. Joe Heller's great novel was going to be named Catch-18 originally, but when Mila-18 came out it was changed to Catch-22 to avoid confusion.

Also (unrelated), joke made up with g'daughter: What do snowmen have for breakfast? Ans: Frosted flakes.

Smith 10:17 AM  

I wrote EQUALS as a rebus and it worked, but if you want to type = you need to tap the button on your keyboard for alternate keys (mine is marked !#1) and you should see it. On android anyway, but I can't imagine iPhone isn't similar.

Smith 10:19 AM  

Update: in the nyt app at bottom left of the keyboard is a key marked #+= and you have to tap it *twice* to get the keyboard that shows the = sign.

Smith 10:29 AM  

Easy medium here but did not get the theme until reading OFL!! Early on I was very confused by someone named "Mayim" whose other name was ___GOON. Eventually got everything done, thx crosses, but even with Y EQUALS X, which was apparent from peers being treated as EQUALS, and even having recently done the SHARING IS CARING puzzle, *and* some time ago the one where m was rn *in the clues*, nope, didn't see it.

Hope my various keyboard explanations are helpful. They were replies but I forgot to ID them.

Whatsername 10:39 AM  

What a fun Thursday treat! I loved the trickery being in the clue instead of in the square. I did bog down just a little in the SE area with that themer and the proper name AISHA. Plus I kept trying to put something more midwestern than WACO in the Bible Belt. Agree it was it was an easy solve but oh that revealer made up for it. What a SUPERLATIVE aha moment! Thank you Damon, lots of fun.

I like the sweet clue for ROSE, but then I have a cat named Lily. Of course I also come from a long line of CAT PEOPLE.

@RP: Many thanks again for all the great animal pics and of course, for this little thing called your blog. Your tenacity at sticking with it so faithfully all these years is truly admirable. This old-school platform suits me fine and I’d hate to see it put ASUNDER. And as for what it’s worth, the check is in the mail. No really, IT IS.

Whatsername 10:39 AM  
This comment has been removed by the author.
Gary Jugert 10:52 AM  

Heck yeah! A proper Thursday. This was a heckuva lotta fun top to bottom. Triple heck. Weird answers, a little rebus action, and a puzzle after the puzzle. There's no way I would have uncovered the theme without the revealer, so A+ job. Where is the confetti programmer today? Couldn't that EQUALS turn into an = ?

Love VROOM... I think it should be reserved for scooters though. I kinda doubt anybody sleeps on the job at SERTA.

AHA: ASAHI AISHA ACAI AUDEN ACHY ASUNDER ALE ANODE AMPUP.

Tee-Hee: Waxing your nether regions. Let's just leave that here and wait for the screams. SCHTHWAP. Owwww! Heh heh. All clean.

Uniclues:

1 Flushed all images from Taylor Swift flop.
2 Name of beverage designed to help you sleep in a dumpster.
3 Why they hired Tom Cruise.
4 Direction to aesthetician while pointing at a thicket.
5 Whip It band's belief in enflowerment.
6 Go on a honeymoon (and lose control of a fork at the cruise buffet -- sheesk, that naughty mind of yours jumping ahead -- tsk tsk).
7 Best spitball ever.
8 Celebrated poet suffers epileptic spasms.
9 Cause loud squealing in Texas.

1 ERASED CAT PEOPLE
2 ASUNDER ALE
3 THE SHOW MUST GOON
4 BRAZILIAN ... THERE
5 DEVO ROSE ETHIC (~)
6 JAB EARTH BRIDE
7 WAD SUPERLATIVE
8 IBSEN SEIZES ON
9 AMP UP WACO SAX (~)

My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Hee b'dure hyoban yah. SWEDE LORE.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

beverly c 11:01 AM  

I solved the X blank Y last, and got the big surprise. But I didn’t find the rest of the puzzle as easy as many of you. I was stumped in the center top for a bit, due to REDD, ISU, NOKIA, VROOM. Further south AISHA, WACO and WOO were challenges. Not to mention DASKAPITAL.

Anonymous 11:06 AM  

@tompdavis

Well, that depends. The diagonal entries of a matrix (m_ij), going from top left to bottom right, are those where i = j.

GILL I. 11:06 AM  

Oooh...Que marvelous and entertaining and clever. All of which means I didn't understand a damn thing I really felt since I didn't understand a damn thing I was writing in.
A themeless on a Thursday????? Of course not.
What should I do? Go sniffing for the answer my friend. I did. I get to the bottom of the barrel and it's a math thingie. Ay Dios Mio. Math and my horrid spelling.
So, I had my Y then a blank then X. Like @Rex, I thought of AS I. Then the "NOBODY SAYS THAT!"....
=....IT'S EQUAL!. So Y = X.... Now what should I do with all this information that a 5 year old could probably figure out?
I finally did.
Go back to the theme answers...look at the clue. Is gadzookybobs a word? If not, it should be.
So, yes.....It might've been a tad easy, but then it wasn't. I spent way too much time staring at THE SHOW MUST GOON. Is that a theme?
So there you have it. My experience.
I had one lookie loo. REDD. I don't know you. Oh, wait. Another lookie loo was AISHA. I only checked to see about her spelling. I was correct, so that doesn't count...
Really clever, clever, clever, Damon. Once I figured you out I shouted with glee....

@Anony 7:43. HAH!...Good one!

Masked and Anonymous 11:20 AM  

@RP: Someone at the NYTPuz HQ musta agreed with U. My clue this mornin for LEX reads "Villainous Luthor".

Ahar! The dreaded hit-and-run rebus square revealer, and a replace-a-letter theme that works on the clue texts. Different. Like.

Y=X is indeed linear. It graphs out as a straight line, tilted to a 45-degree angle.

staff weeject picks: Easy. Y=X and AS=. Primo theme inclusion respect for the runt-words, today.

Had trouble out of the chute, with GAB instead of JAW. Also woulda helped if I coulda remembered IBSEN or how to spell SONJA. Sooo … more precious nanoseconds spent by M&A than for many other solvers here, I reckon. Themer #1 at 17-A made little sense, so M&A shamelessly headed directly to 69-A for advice. Got LEX down there right away, but that there Y=X took some time to crack, even for an old math major/teacher like m&e.

Thanx, Mr. Gulczynski dude. Nice job. And ysharing is xcaring, after all. or somesuch.

Masked & Anonymo5Us


**gruntz**

jae 11:20 AM  

Easy. My experience was very similar to @Rex’s. I did not know REDD, but then I stopped regularly watching SNL in the ‘70s. I had no idea what was going on until I hit the reveal at which point I had the puzzle pretty much done. So, no help from the reveal other than to make sense of the *clued answers that didn’t make sense.

Smooth grid, lively theme answers but a little too easy for a Thursday. Liked it.

burtonkd 11:27 AM  

@Damon - fun puzzle! Could we get a teaser for the book here?

Last time we had a rebus, I advised that you could just use the first letter in the box to represent the whole word. Not so today...had to spell out the whole "EQUALS" rebus.



Newboy 11:37 AM  

I’m in awe of people who fill a grid on their phones. I have a hard time finding mine……let alone using it….if it is charged.

This puzzle had STYLE for sure and that’s no surprise as Damon approaches the half century of NYT grids. Two tragic flaws today kept me from fully appreciating the solving experience: never thought to look at the X EQUALS Y in the clues nor did I pause for a second to consider that yeats was dead as 1939 began and probably shouldn’t get posthumously credited for that poem. Alas, my credit for Darcy OBrian’s Joyce/Yeats seminar should probably be rescinded although the statute of limitations at Claremont has no doubt expired. Still…….

After my embarrassment faded, I really thought this was a wonderful concept which I failed to fully appreciate.

BlueStater 11:39 AM  

Just awful. I think this sorry effort is a defining case of "cheap trickery." Stick to the 26 letters of the Roman alphabet.

JerryH 12:00 PM  

I cannot even imagine how the NYTIMES accomplished this heretofore never done feat, but the keyboard to today’s puzzle was missing the characters for equals sign.

Anonymous 12:09 PM  

Loved this Thursday theme. Was baffled until I got to the y=x which I had deliberately left to the end. A great payoff—tricky theme for me, but fair and clever. Thanks to Damon Gulczynski!

Carola 12:14 PM  

So fitting that SUPERLATIVE and NEATO appear in the grid, because this theme sure was both. I proceeded cluelessly through BAD BREAKUP and CAT PEOPLE, wondered if "Mayim" were a typo, couldn't get enough crosses for pattern recognition to get the fourth and fifth ones. Luckily I knew LEX and then pounced on = and TOY. What fun to go back and see the now revealed exes, Manx and maxim, uncover Marx, and have the grand payoff of the BRAZILIAN wax down in the nether regions. Too funny!

Do-overs: Rock before REDD, CardS before CREWS, dogma before ETHos before ETHIC. Help from previous puzzles: ASAHI. No idea: DEVO, AISHA. Favorite non-theme clue: Try to see? Nice clue writing for: SEIZES ON, EXACTED.

Anonymous 12:16 PM  

At the risk of being a super super nerd…this is just the simplest form of that equation (with m=1 and b=0).

Anonymous 12:30 PM  

Ah yes, noted vax questioner Mayim.

Ethan Taliesin 12:55 PM  

Yes, AISHA was the youngest.
"A preponderance of classical sources converge on Aisha being 6 or 7 years old at the time of her marriage, and 9 at the consummation; her age has become a source of ideological friction in modern times."
I appreciate the grid for giving us this to think about, even if it is too polite to call it out explicitly.

Anonymous 12:58 PM  

She’s anti vaccine

johnk 1:16 PM  

Easy solve as a themeless until the revealer corner. Then I had to actually think. But my math background came in handy there. Then I looked at the * clues and got it.
But if Y=X, then what are TOX and LEY doing in there? I suppose TOXLEY could be a future BBC series about the private boarding school of that name.

okanaganer 1:21 PM  

The theme was a fun idea, but that revealer (with a rebus as the very last word!) was the best part. And I didn't get the Y -> X trick until I hit BRAZILIAN, because unlike the other answers it immediately makes me think of the word in the clue, "wax".

Well, winter has really arrived here in the mild Okanagan. Our first real snowfall, and now blowing snow, with forecast temperature a record breaking -25 C (-13 F) tomorrow night.

[Spelling Bee: Wed 0; congrats pabloinnh!]

Anonymous 1:27 PM  

I see what you did there :)

JonP 1:30 PM  

I'm sorry but this didn't work for me in the least. I got to the revealer mid solve and couldn't understand why the theme answers I muddled into didn't seem to have any Xs or Ys. Nor why SAX and ACHY didn't have letter swaps.

And I would argue that a BAD BREAKUP could very well lead to irritated eyes (from, you know, crying) -- so the misdirection was easily read as straight.

I guess I'm dumb for not getting what the theme clue was telling me to do.

I also thought way too many clues were Friday-level vague.

Finally it didn't help that I had *just* heard Nashville referred to as the buckle of the Bible Belt. How many buckles are there anyway?

ChrisSaintH 1:34 PM  

Fun puzzle! Just tricky enough with a satisfying 'aha' moment.

Anoa Bob 1:55 PM  

No, you can't do that! It was one of the unequivocal, bedrock constants of existence throughout my early life: There are nine planets in our solar system. You can't just arbitrarily demote Pluto and say that 23D EARTH is "Third in a group of eight". I don't care who says otherwise. There always have been and always will be nine!

I had OGDEN for 34D "'September 1, 1939' poet" before crosses showed it had to be AUDEN. Then the "D'oh" moment followed when I remember OGDEN is poet Nash's first name.

I always enjoy seeing a Latin word or phrase in the grid. Today we get 11D "Nothing:Lat." NIHIL, the root word for the likes of "annihilate" and "nihilism". Now if crosswordworld would just use the Latin word "rebus" as it is used everywhere else, including language scholars who use it to explain the origin of abstract alphabets in "The Rebus Principle".

Today's offering is commendably restrained in its use of the plural of convenience (POC) to help filling the grid. Only a couple of isolated POCs like PENS and CREWS but none with the themers or longer entries. And there were none of the ultra helpful two for one POCs where a Down and an Across both get a letter count boost by sharing a final S. Exemplary!

Anonymous 2:45 PM  

The usual iOS keyboard has a #+= key the allows you to get the = sign. But the NYT uses a custom keyboard so there’s a rebus button. But that custom keyboard does not have the #+= button. So the EQUALS rebus is the only way in iOS.

jberg 3:25 PM  

We got home last night at midnight, after 12 days in England. It was cold and rainy there, but not as cold and rainy as it was here in Boston, so we were happy. But my wife convinced me I should read The Great Gatsby, and I didn't finish it during the flight, and couldn't put it down, so I was up to 2:30; I also discovered that our basement had flooded and the flame in the water heater had gone out, all of which is to explain that I woke up late and did not get right to the puzzle when I did wake up. But it's nice to be back here, solving in the actual paper (for which I have a special rollerball pen that will insert an = sign by drawing to parallel horizontal lines in the appropriate square).

Like @JonP, BAD BREAKUP made sense as clued, and I guess many lovers are, in fact CAT PEOPLE. I was even willing to give some latitude to the idea that Brazil was way down in the nether regions. But "mayim" gave it all away, and then I got the rest, and the revealer. Lots of fun!

I liked the parallels of "one out of 100" and "third of eight." @Anoa Bob, well there weren't always 9-- in Galileo's day there were only six, and today if we were to count dwarf planets there would be at least 11, probably more. And I liked working a 3-word Steinbeck title for two answers. Too bad it isn't legit to clue OF as "middle of a Steinbeck title."

And I learned an amazing new way to refer to WACO!

Our new cats are still hiding, although we do glimpse them on occasion; maybe next year they will be ready for holiday pictures.

bocamp 3:37 PM  

Thx Damon; SUPERLATIVE production! 😊 btw, just purchased your book from Amazon. Looking forward to it! :)

Downs-o (4x NYT Sat.) (oh so close)!

One double d'oh!! (RaBiD before ROBED) and one dunno (RuDD before REDD) originally had Rock).

Couldn't see any theme, altho getting AS EQUALS / Y = X led me to conclude that there must be an exchange of letters in the clues. Was quite pleased to see exactly that in the post-solve analysis.

Toughest area was NoCal, forgetting that the planets are considered to be 8, rather than 9 now (hi @Anoa), not being sure of the beer, and not sure if ASUNDER had two esses or one. Also, originally had sIREE before HIREE.

Correct initial entries: JAB, ACA, SVEN, ORA, NOKIA, JOUST, AMP UP, PIANO LEG, ESCAPE ROUTE, STYLE, IBSEN, EAST, ANODE, TONER, HELI, BRIDE, LADEd before LADEN, IRATE, ATOP, CHOIR, TOY, AS___, LEX.

Had to intuit the (I) for AISHA. Felt good about it, as just had AISHA Tyler recently (can't recall which xword it was in, tho).

Another exhilarating trip; very enjoyable! :)

@pablo 👍 for QB yd 😊

@Anonymous (10:08 AM) 👍

@okanaganer 1:21 PM

Time to break out the toque! 🥶
____
Neville Fogarty's New Yorker cryptic was very easy, but fun while it lasted! :)
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness ~ Freudenfreude & a DAP to all 👊 🙏

Vladimir Estragon 3:48 PM  

How about a permanent moratorium on acai. There are other types of berries, you know.

Anonymous 4:27 PM  

I don't get WACO as "buckle of the Bible belt". Wikipedia mentions the term and has 3 different cities (Abilene (TX), Nashville, and Tulsa). I see no one saying Waco.

Nancy 5:03 PM  

Anoa Bob (1:55) -- Re POCS: I'm always surprised when you refer to something as innocuous -- at least to me -- as "PENS" or "CREWS" as POCS. I'm sure I've seen them both in the plural IRL almost as often as I've seen them in the singular. It's just not something I would ever notice in a puzzle.

I'd say: Save your ire for the really egregious ones. I don't remember all the POCS that have made me cringe over the years, but I did track down the most recent one. I remembered that I had nominated it for "Worst POC ever" -- only I couldn't remember what it was. I fed "worst POC ever/Nancy" into Rex Parker and I found it on 11/25/23. (That's why I remember; it was so recent.) Want to guess what it was?
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
DNAS. Said no one ever.

Anonymous 5:38 PM  

DNF’d on =. Did not enjoy, even the math geek in me.

Anonymous 6:31 PM  

I loved "Cause of irritated eyes" as the first theme clue because "bad break up" can also = crying which can = irritated eyes, so it kept me away from figuring out the theme but in a way that felt clever to me.

pabloinnh 7:28 PM  

@okanaganer, @bocamp--Thanks for the congrats. Props from the pros are high props indeed.

Anoa Bob 7:46 PM  

@Nancy, there never is any ire about POCs. It's purely cerebral, no emotion involved. And it's not about whether the plural in question is ordinary or not. It's about plurals taking up more space in the grid and making it easier to fill without adding much of anything of value or interest to the puzzle. PENS takes up 33% more space than PEN. Does it add 33% more value to the puzzle? I don't think so, not even close.

I only noticed how adding a gratuitous -S, -ES or changing a Y to -IES boosts letter counts and makes it easier to fill the grid when I tried my hand at grid construction. I attempted to explain all this in my POC Doc blog 11 years ago and later saw POCs were just one kind of letter count inflation (LCI). I think when used excessively these LCIs, including POCs, can diminish the overall quality of a puzzle.

Escalator 8:05 PM  

Is this the first time a non-letter has been used as an answer …= sign ?

Parsist 8:13 PM  

@Anoa Bob

What's the plural of anal?

Unknown 8:44 PM  

This was brilliant.

Anonymous 9:22 PM  

I thought of you @Roo when I noticed that, but for the F, it’s a pangram. (If you use the rebus.)

Anonymous 9:28 PM  

Bought! Thank you for a fun puzzle, Damon. Looking forward to reading and solving the rejects.

Joe Dipinto 9:36 PM  

Late post today. We need to add ETHIC/ETHOS to the ever-growing list of kealoas.

I thoroughly enjoyed solving this, sailing through it pretty easily but not being able to figure out wtf the theme answers had in common until getting to the very last answer. Very inspired constructing job.

Alex 10:06 PM  

As a math nerd, I loved the Y=X clueing, which I skipped straight to when I skimmed the clues.

Didn’t care for the “S” in SEN flowing down in to another SEN in IBSEN.

CDilly52 11:58 PM  

It’s a bit risqué, look up “BRAZILIAN Wax”.

CDilly52 12:51 AM  

Took me all the way down to BRAZILIAN to get the Y EQUALS X trick, but it certainly made the final boxes easy to suss out. Not so much how to get the EQUALS sign into one square on the NYT app, so I tried the 🟰emoji but no. I went rebus and was rewarded with the happy 🎶! Perseverance paid off.

As a card carrying CAT PERSON, I really enjoyed the trick with the many(x) cat. I got this one after the BRAZILIAN way(x) because of my unusual solve route. It went top to bottom on the left and also top to bottom on the right. This puzzle was just pure fun and a delightful feat of construction.

Speaking of being a card carrying CAT PERSON, I am off to Santa Rosa Saturday morning to start my new chapter as Grandma! Before we went to California at Thanksgiving, I had an updated microchip implanted in my cat, Pip. I literally carry the “Home Again” information card with me in case she gets lost because her new Cali girl lifestyle allows her to go outside sometimes. Nirvana!

Experiencing “The Great Outdoors” has made Pip deliriously happy and she gets to eat as much grass as she wants which encourages her to leave her hairballs outside, which in turn makes my daughter deliriously happy. A win for everyone.

My granddaughter, Grace has been taking excellent care (read spoiling silly) of my Pip. She made Pip a “sleeping cubby” by cutting a round hole in a box and putting several of my old tees inside. Pip has a snug place in Grace’s room and feels safe at night. My kids’ two cats are huge 20 pounders to Pip’s mere 7 and while they all get along well during the day, there have been som rough housing incidents in the wee small hours events that were unsettling. The box hole is too small for the larger cats to get in and Grace reports there have been no nocturnal “disagreements” since Pip (as Grace says) “got her own room.”

I am so excited to see them both - and of course my kids. The last month has been total chaos. I am exhausted and not looking forward to unpacking all the boxes. My empty house made me very sad today. I felt a bit like I was leaving my dear husband behind, even though I know better. Wish me luck! Hopefully, I will get settled, unpacked and back to posting every day before too long.

You have all been keeping me company as I have dismantled my home and set sail for such a big new adventure. Thank you!

Whatsername 1:52 AM  

@CDilly: It’s rare for me to be up at this hour but we’re having a thunderstorm of all things in January and my dog who hates thunder is pacing the floor and whining. Anyway just read your post and wanted to wish you the very best as you begin your new venture. Moving is so stressful and if you’ve lived in a house very long, yes it’s sad to see it empty. But then tomorrow, you’ll head west into a new adventure and everything will look brighter. And from what you say, it sounds like you will be very happy once you get settled. Travel safely!

Anonymous 7:23 AM  

Great catch!

(Not sure what @Max W. is on about…the coordinate system isn’t a stretch to assume…)

Anonymous 9:03 AM  

She’s only asking questions! Lol

Leo E 9:04 AM  

I’m new to crosswords this year. I’d always shied away, thinking I’d never be clever enough. Then a new love said Nonsense, come on in, the water’s warm. Before long, I was hooked: to the puzzle’s thrills, satisfactions, and frustrations — and to seeing each day how my experience matched up with Rex’s. What a bizarre, genuine, daily joy. Thank you for writing!

kitshef 8:22 AM  

Liked it. No idea on the theme until I hit the revealer, then it all made sense.

Waxy in Montreal 11:05 AM  

Agree with OFL's rating of Easy but only once the reveal was solved. NAILed it after that. Only quibbles: ETHIC rather than ETHOS for guiding principles (plural) and Chris REDD (who?) - better 18D clue for me would have been ______ Foxx.

spacecraft 11:54 AM  

Yeah, the non-Foxx clue for REDD slowed me down too. Still there was BADBREAKUP, which definitely did NOT = the clue. So I went hunting. Found the revealer tucked away in the SE corner, saw the = sign right away, and then reexamined 17a. Only one Y existed--and it was in the clue! Oh wow. And THERE it was. After that it was a snap.

I liked the Steinbeck double. Way easier than yesterday, but more fun. Birdie.

Wordle birdie.

Burma Shave 12:47 PM  

CREW'S STYLE

BREAKUP THESHOW, IT IS SUPERLATIVE crap,
THE PEOPLE MUSTGO, to ESCAPE A BAD RAP.

--- LI'L AISHA

rondo 2:29 PM  

I saw REDD Foxx's live show in Vegas in 1987. Hilarious!
Not a huge fan of traditional xwords having the gimmick in the clues. But still better than a rebus. Noticed: 2 ONs 2 UPs.
Wordle eagle!!!

Anonymous 3:44 PM  

Pretty good gimmick. The hardest part of the puzzle was decypherin 69A. None of the theme answers made any sense at all until then. I can finally breathe ACAI of relief.

Diana, LIW 6:05 PM  

I got the puzzle, but not the trick. Then read the explanation.

Ugh..Why? Only slightly better than a rebus. Maybe.

That's my read (of the trick, not the puzzle).

Diana, Lady-in-Waiting for Crosswords

Wauhoo 2:42 AM  

GoBlue!

  © Free Blogger Templates Columnus by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP