"Bad plan!," in Southern slang / SAT 1-6-24 / Unfiltered brew / Comment after a revealing moment / Out-of-focus effect in photography, from the Japanese for "blur" / Cells that handle low-light vision / Thin slice of silicon at the heart of an integrated circuit

Saturday, January 6, 2024

Constructor: Ben Tolkin and Julian Xiao

Relative difficulty: Easy


THEME: none 

Word of the Day: BOKEH (5A: Out-of-focus effect in photography, from the Japanese for "blur") —

In photographybokeh (/ˈbkə/ BOH-kə or /ˈbk/ BOH-kayJapanese: [boke]) is the aesthetic quality of the blur produced in out-of-focus parts of an image, caused by circles of confusion. Bokeh has also been defined as "the way the lens renders out-of-focus points of light". Differences in lens aberrations and aperture shape cause very different bokeh effects. Some lens designs blur the image in a way that is pleasing to the eye, while others produce distracting or unpleasant blurring ("good" and "bad" bokeh, respectively). Photographers may deliberately use a shallow focus technique to create images with prominent out-of-focus regions, accentuating their lens's bokeh.

Bokeh is often most visible around small background highlights, such as specular reflections and light sources, which is why it is often associated with such areas. However, bokeh is not limited to highlights; blur occurs in all regions of an image which are outside the depth of field.

The opposite of bokeh—an image in which multiple distances are visible and all are in focus—is deep focus.

• • •

Well this ended up being *much* easier than yesterday's puzzle, so people will undoubtedly like it more, but I don't know that it's any better. I should say that I actually *liked* yesterday's puzzle pretty well. Probably should've been a Saturday, but it was really well put together. Loved YOINKED and SMARTASS and the clue on DEAD BATTERY. All the longer answers were solid to sparkling. I feel like I got caught up in my struggles yesterday and neglected to say the positive things I felt. I thought about yesterday's puzzle as I was solving this one, which was much easier but felt less impressive. The long answers just missed me today, for the most part, and the puzzle's attempts to be fresh were hit-and-miss—a little TTH (trying too hard) at times. I loved HAZY IPA (10D: Unfiltered brew), but it's really hard to get excited about a brand name like ACUVUE or something as mundane as UNMUTES. As for BOKEH, that was just five random letters to me, I'll confess. I've probably seen it on my camera phone's needlessly detailed array of options, but it never sunk in. I can see how that answer might be exciting to some, though, so that's fine. The biggest issues I had were with the marquee longer answers—the crossing 15s. Hmmm, what order to take these in? ... So, how about the order in which I solved them. Probably easiest to show you my grid after my first encounter with 29A: "Bad plan!," in Southern slang:


And now a clip from "Futurama":


And now a Waylon Jennings song:


And finally, how about a clip of this guy? Remember this guy?


At first I couldn't remember what the dog won't do, but then I got the "H" from SIGH (21D: [Aw, jeez!]) and I remembered, oh right, THAT DOG WON'T HUNT. Little did it occur to me that my problem with the answer wouldn't be the last word, but the next-to-last (semifinal??) word. I can see that people have also said "THAT DOG DON'T HUNT" but this non-Southerner has only ever heard the "WON'T" version, so "DON'T" registered a huge clank in my ears for sure. And I have DR. FREUD to thank for helping me find and confront my error. You can imagine my bafflement when I looked at 11D: Comment after a revealing moment and then looked at the grid and saw: "PAGING W-------!" Who am I paging? Wario? Wonder Woman? Got the "F" from BFFS but that didn't help. "PAGING WAFFLES! Come in, Waffles!" (note to self: mmm, eat waffles today). Not sure when "DR. FREUD" eventually popped into view ("You rang!?!"), but I know that I changed that "W" to a "D" and then just stared at "THAT DOG DON'T HUNT." Then felt bad that I'd misremembered the Southern expression. Only after finishing the puzzle and looking up the expression did I feel good again. "WON'T" was a perfectly good answer there. Only DR. FREUD could tell you otherwise, and, you know, I'm not sure I 100% trust him. 


Also, do people still / really say "PAGING DR. FREUD?" That's the kind of cutesy thing that, thankfully, no one in my immediate vicinity has ever said. I wish I could be more excited about it. I was more excited about "DAYS OF OUR LIVES," to be honest. My wife's secret history involves her complete addiction to "AS THE WORLD TURNS" (15) (five NYTXW appearances, dating back to 1976), which I always confuse with "DAYS OF OUR LIVES" (14) (four NYTXW appearances, dating back to 2002). I kinda miss afternoon soaps, a staple of midday programming when I was a kid. In the '70s, my mom would put us down for a nap and then watch "Ryan's Hope." I think this was what they now call "Me Time." I also liked HUMAN PYRAMID today, and the fact that it's kinda sorta at the top of its own pyramid of answers (10A: Stunt for three, six or 10 people, typically). I mean ... yeah, if you squint and are feeling generous, that is a pyramid of answers that it's a part of.


Mostly, this puzzle was a breeze, with only BOKEH and that WON'T / DON'T confusion giving me any kind of resistance. I knew the proper nouns (NAPLES, ACUVUE, CLINT), I knew PROG rock (27A: Lead-in to rock). I got the first eight clues I looked at today, which is pretty much the inverse of yesterday.

[TATA, then all its crosses, in order, then HUMAN PYRAMID, DECAL, and ACE]

I hope this puzzle gave you renewed confidence after yesterday's ... well, from the comments, it looked like a bloodbath. Does anything need explaining today? ACE is a "big deal" (17A: It's a big deal) because it's the highest card in the deck (in most contexts). "Bars" are segments of a song, so that's why NATIONAL ANTHEM works for 13A: Olympic bars? An AISLE can be "long" and "divide" a theater or airplane or whatever (25A: Long division?). RESTS are marks on a musical score (38A: Some score marks). The Fool is a card in the TAROT deck (I lit-erally have a candle lit, right now, right next to my desk, depicting "The Fool," so that was fun—seeing that clue and then looking over and ... seeing that clue (19D: Fool's deck)):


That's all for now. Time for the penultimate posting of Holiday Pet Pics!

[Again, nothing really "holiday" about this picture of Booga, but it's hard not to admire a cat who does the crossword (thanks, Alice! Now come on, get Booga a pencil and some coffee!)]

[No "holiday" aspect here either, just a reader who wanted to use their beautiful dog Charlie to prove to me that "bog bridges" really do exist (I had expressed doubt late last year) (thanks, anonymous person!)]

[Orion with his name in the grid (thanks, Judith)]

[George smash cat. George rest now (thanks, Jackie!)]

[Kip stands accused of cat vandalism! Verdict: not guilty by reason of entrapment, provocation, and cuteness! (thanks, Adam)]

["Guh ... hello. What are we doing? Is it treats?" I don't know this baby's name! (thanks, Mark!)]

See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]

123 comments:

Ann Howell 4:48 AM  

Finished in 12 minutes with no hints, probably a Saturday record! Also had "won't hunt" before "don't hunt", and "irises" before "tutees", but both got corrected fairly quickly. Fun start to the day.

Conrad 4:59 AM  


Definitely easier than yesterday. I read the 1A clue ("Ciao"), saw four blanks and said to myself, "Could it be as simple as 'TATA'?" Turns out, yes it could.

rage before ACNE for the side effect at 23A
examS before TESTS at 34D. I was thinking along those lines due to the cross-reference clue at 39D
usn (U.S. Navy) before NSA at 47A
Needed 32D UNMUTES to resolve the LyrES/LUTES kealoa at 50A

BOKEH was a WOE, and I must not be as up on my Southern as @Rex because DON'T HUNT went right in at 29A.

Rick K 5:26 AM  

I had no clue on BOKEH and ACCUVUE, but otherwise this went pretty quickly for me.

One thing I noticed, though, is that there weren't many long answers: I counted only 6 answers of 8 or more letters (Friday and Saturday typically have a dozen or more.)

I definitely would have liked more longer, whoosh-y answers...

Anonymous 5:44 AM  

Concur entirely - even though I've never heard someone say "PAGING DR FREUD" it's something I can reason through and laugh at. More like this please.

Phaedrus 5:53 AM  

This felt more like a Tuesday than a Saturday.

Adam 6:07 AM  

Paging Captain Obvious I've heard; never heard of paging DR FREUD, but it was relatively easy to infer. I also had wONT HUNT (which I've heard) before DONT HUNT (which I haven't). Photography is a hobby of mine, so BOKEH went right in and I was thrilled to see it. My wife wears contact lenses so I was familiar with ACUVUE (although at first I tried spelling it ACCUVU, which clearly wasn't right). It was my best Saturday time ever AND I enjoyed the puzzle.

Ride the Reading 6:21 AM  

One of the easiest Saturday puzzles ever. Off to the races in the north, especially NE. BYLINE, ORALS and KANE went in with no effort, leading to BOKEH and EMT and HIHATS.

Not saying there weren’t stumbles along the way - had rage rather than ACNE at 23A. But TAROT for 19D led me to pull rage. Debated whether my Margherita pizza was being created in Naples or Napoli.

Writing this at about 2:30a. Now off to listen to some Prog Rock. Yes yesterday. Genesis today. Rush tomorrow.

Wanderlust 6:32 AM  

Yep, about 33 minutes yesterday compared to about 14 today, so they do seem to have switched Friday and Saturday. I don’t really care that much, but don’t they have people test them?

Yes to wON’T before DON’T but I kind of like the latter better because it’s ungrammaticalness makes it sound more stereotypically Southern. I liked PAGING DR FREUD.

I think my only mistakes besides the w/D were WRiEST and lImes before RINDS. Nice clue for AISLES.

I am feeling like Goldilocks testing beds - yesterday was too hard and today was too soft. Hoping tomorrow is just right.

Steve Mallam 6:39 AM  

I guess it’s a US-specific expression, but I’ve never in my life heard “that dog dont’t (or won’t) hunt”. It was literally the last clue I got, crossed with PDFs. Had all the other letters and still didn’t know!
Days of Our Lives also took a while and needed a lot of letters - don’t think it’s ever been shown here - but at least I’d heard of it!
The rest was fine

Anonymous 6:43 AM  

Ha, I’ve never heard anyone say That dog Won’t hunt!

Anonymous 6:55 AM  

Tuesday/Wednesday time. That dog don’t hunt is the expression I recall from the early 70s when I was in the Marines and heard it for the first of many times. Yet, I still had won’t hunt at first.

Telvo 7:19 AM  

Very proud of myself for doing a Saturday in 13 minutes -- until I disccovered that it wasn't 'Bests/Binds' at 38 but 'Rests/Rinds'. (I still think that's right enough.)

Son Volt 7:32 AM  

Like sand through the hourglass - the big guy nailed it as usual this morning. According to my archived app stats - my second fastest Saturday time. Not a lot of nuance here - but nothing ugly either for the most part. Liked HUMAN PYRAMID and YEAR END BONUS. KANE Brewing in NJ makes a wonderful HAZY IPA.

More fill in the blanks today. BFFS, TUTEES, WRYEST and DYERS are the side eye entries for me. Backed into the obscure trivia.

Pleasant enough Saturday morning solve. Stella’s Stumper SLAYs today.

PROG defined - courtesy of the great Steve Howe

Anonymous 7:41 AM  

I liked this one. It picked up speed in the bottom half. I really wish the constructors could find another piece of P.A.GEAR. There lots, but unfortunately everyone thinks that all band techs do is move AMPS!

SarahK 7:41 AM  

SIGH, the wind is back in my sails! Yesterday's puzzle was ick for me. I got stuck on NAPLES and I live outside of Naples (NY that is). We have a couple of pizza places, not bad. But I've never been to Italy, so can't compare. It's on the list! Along with waffles. Time for breakfast! And snow (fingers crossed)

SouthsideJohnny 7:50 AM  

At this point I just concede and grudgingly eat my peas with something like BOKEH - it’s the NYT, so even on Mondays there is going to be something that is, flirts with, or abuts gibberish territory - so just deal with it and move on (and a tip of the hat to the 1% of us that have heard of it before).

More troubling for me are sections like the SW where you have the brand name ACUVUE along with a PPP “icon” who I couldn’t pick out of a police lineup, and of course the NYT staple - LOI which I’m guessing is the word for “law” in whatever country Pascal denizenized (yes, I get to make up words too).

I would argue that SEMIFINALS are TESTS of skill and ability, usually against an opponent of similar caliber in an important event, frequently on a national stage (but even a local rec league semifinal would be considered a test by the participants). Close enough for CrossWorld but still seems a touch, how shall we say, AMISS to me.

Lewis 8:06 AM  

Best part of the puzzle to me was its freshness, with four NYT debut longs, each of which gave gifts:

PAGING DR. FREUD – Brought a genuine “Hah!”
THAT DOG DON’T HUNT – Never heard this before, so my brain got to do the labor it loves by uncovering it.
HUMAN PYRAMID – Pat-on-my-back boost at figuring this out with, I think, one cross.
YEAR END BONUS – The vague-to-me clue yielded more brain-loving labor.

I also liked:
• The cross of NO RUSH and OOZES.
• The echoes from yesterday’s puzzle with AGILE and ANTS.
• The fuzziness of BOKEH and HAZY IPA.
• The rare-in-crosswords five-letter semordnilap (DECAL).

More footholds than usual for me for Saturday, so lots of bounce, and I left the grid bubbling with verve. What a lovely way to start the day! Congratulations on your NYT debut Julian and on number two, Ben, and thank you both for this spry Saturday!

JD 8:06 AM  

Started out thinking this was going to be another yesterday, but it puzzled together. Almost always fall into the same traps as @Conrad. Today it was Lyres v. Lutes, settled w/Unmutes. Same thought on TaTa. However, Ache before Acne.

REUD had me going for a long time. Head slap at Rods. Loved National Anthem.

Days Of Our Lives sits there amongst Hazy IPA, BFFs, Bokeh, Prog, and Unmutes, wondering how it got there. Watched that show when I was visiting with my mother-in-law. It probably loves Occult and Tarot though.The devil showed up in a lot of plot lines. Absolutely nuts.

Twangster 8:08 AM  

Either the idea that the puzzle gets progressively harder through the week has been retired or Will Shortz is horrifically bad at judging the difficulty of a puzzle. Strange considering that according to the Vanity Fair article, he has a small army available to pre-test the puzzles and help with this kind of thing.

Eater of Sole 8:11 AM  

I always thought "that dog won't hunt" meant more "what you are claiming is not plausible" rather than "that's a bad plan." But I guess it works for either. I think I first heard it from Molly Ivins.

RYB57 8:11 AM  
This comment has been removed by the author.
Hal9000 8:13 AM  

Friday/Saturday this week should definitely have been reversed. To be clear, I never felt yesterday's was bad; I just wasn't on its wavelength. This may have been a tad too easy for a Saturday but after yesterday's rare DNF, my family's honor has been restored!

mmorgan 8:20 AM  

Yes, MUCH easier than yesterday’s, which created much head banging against the wall. I don’t know if that makes me like today’s more, but it’s strange when a Saturday is so much easier than the Friday right before. At least for me. The things I didn’t know today were soon gettable from crosses, while yesterday, endless white space stared at me for like forever.

beckiwithani 8:21 AM  

Definitely a relief to have a puzzle that was easier than Friday, but I agree it was a little too easy. Just under 17:00 (with 3 glasses of wine in me), more than 10:00 faster than my average Saturday. I wanted 7D to be a trick clue (“could it just be KANE? … yep, guess so”) and a bunch of other clues could’ve been cleverer but were just a little boring (e.g. NO RUSH, ISLE, ESSAYS, TOTE…).

Loved the cluing on RIND, RESTS, HUMANPYRAMID. Appreciated the delightfully nerdy clues for WAFER and ESP. Looked askance at DYERS. And SLAYED was maybe my favorite of the whole puzzle. Wondered if that particular meaning had ever been used before.

All in all, agreed with others that it felt more like a themeless Wednesday. Still fun, though, which I needed after yesterday.

Kid Phoneme 8:23 AM  

This one just didn't have any secrets.

I did decide on zen before TAO, and NAPoli before NAPLES, but avoided the whole wONT/DONT foofaraw. (I hit PAGING DR FREUD first). Is THAT DOG DONT HUNT, slang because it uses DONT instead of wONT?

We saw AGILE for the second day in a row, got ISLE and AISLE, and had nearly all the TESTS you can fit in a crossword. Felt like an unusual number of plurals as well. Here's a row: RESTS, BFFS, and AMPS.

Meh, I'm complain-y cause this solved like a themeless Wednesday--or Monday even. Didn't last Saturday's challenging solve get taken from us too?

I liked PAGING DR FREUD well enough. It was fun to connect the BOKEH with images I've seen using it in the past. The rest didn't have a lot of sparkle for me.

Eater of Sole 8:28 AM  

BOKEH was the first word I entered (yes, I am a semi-serious hobbyist photographer). You can find endless and mostly pointless discussions of BOKEH on photography blogs and review sites.

JJK 8:28 AM  

Wow, what an easy Saturday! My only slow-downs were with THISDOGDONTHUNT because I’ve never heard it before and for a long time had THISDOGDONTH___ and had no idea what THISDOGDONTdo. But the crosses fell into place when I decided that TESTS and not examS was right.

A small nit that I have is that I think “mystic” refers to a person, while OCCULT is a system of supernatural beliefs or practices (I confirmed this on google)

Anonymous 8:30 AM  

Thanks, Rex. Enjoyed reading your thoughts. You nailed all my comments in your write up.

Andy Freude 8:32 AM  

A couple of stats: Yesterday was my longest Friday ever, nearly twice as long as my average time. Today was my all-time fastest Saturday, just over one-third my average time. Whiplash!

beckiwithani 8:39 AM  

@JKK I think both “mystic” and OCCULT were being used with their adjectival definitions

Johnny Mic 8:41 AM  

I think this was the easiest Saturday I can remember. Didn't really get hung up on anything. Don't have anything interesting to add, just felt like I wanted that on the record.

Kid Phoneme 8:48 AM  

Sorry, apparently I'm not done yet. A twist is not a RIND. And a screwdriver gets garnished with a wheel, not a twist, and definitely not a RIND. I know it's a jokey clue and all, but the clue makes a screwdriver sound worse than it already is.

drwgl 8:56 AM  

I am a southerner who has never heard "don't" instead of "won't."

Ted 8:56 AM  

For a fun example of creative use of Bokeh, see Scott Pilgrim Vs the World.

https://www.reddit.com/r/MovieDetails/comments/83xqbj/in_scott_pilgrim_vs_the_world_while_discussing/

It's something that we've all seen but many didn't know there was a word for it.

Near record time today of just 7 minutes. Absolutely slayed.

Dr.A 8:59 AM  

I liked yesterday and today and DAYS OF OUR LIVES was my key to breaking in to this one’s long answers! I used to stay home, ALONE when I was sick and watch soaps in my mom’s bed. the funny thing about them is that no matter how long it had been since the last time I was sick, I could pick it right up. The plot never changes. Oh nostalgia for the wild and crazy 80s.
My kid is 14 and maybe NOW I’d leave her alone all day.
Anyhoo, fun nostalgia. Fun puzzle and super fun pet pics!!

feinstee 9:02 AM  

Strangely put 'paging MR Freud", which cause some delay.. especially when that erroneous M helped me 'see' the word MONTH in the 15....That Dog Month ...

Anonymous 9:03 AM  

As someone who designs computer chips for a living, I'll note that "WAFER" (44D) is technically incorrect. A wafer is a large disc of silicon containing many chips. A wafer must be cut apart into individual chips, each called a "die," before use. It's the die rather than the wafer that becomes "the heart of an integrated circuit" if one wants to use the proper jargon.

RooMonster 9:10 AM  

Hey All !
Aha, here's the FriPuz. Close to record PB time.

Didn't get a YEAR END BONUS from work, but still am employed, so that's something.

Nice puz. Easy, as has been said. Had teA in for IPA, getting me some HAZYteA. Thankfully, ESE for the clue didn't make sense as ESP did, so was able to swap out the drinks.

Oracle for OCCULT off just the O.
LIME - RIND
ragE-ACNE
dRYEST-WRYEST
epoch-AISLE
giFs-PDFS

Even with those writeovers, finished in 16 minutes. That's flames-shooting-from-tires quick for me on a SatPuz. My Streak of correct solved with no help is at 21!

Happy Saturday, y'all. Or in honor of the Southern Central 15-speak, all y'all.

Four F's
RooMonster
DarrinV

Tom F 9:14 AM  

Literally took me 2.5 times longer to complete yesterday compared to today. But I liked both puzzles.

alexscott68 9:16 AM  

What a strange Friday-Saturday combo. Yesterday’s puzzle took me nearly twice my average Friday time, today’s took less than half my usual Saturday time. Also had WON’T before DON’T. Except for HUMAN PYRAMID, the long answers didn’t do much for me. What kind of obnoxious jerk would say, PAGING DR. FREUD, after someone revealed something personal to them?

puzzlehoarder 9:23 AM  

The north half was early week easy but the southern half put it back into a normal Saturday range. After yesterday's ordeal it seemed effortlessly overall. I had CANT before DONT and LIME before RIND.

yd -0. that makes 10

pabloinnh 9:24 AM  

OK, easy Saturday or easiest Saturday ever? Maybe a wheelhouse thing but this was done before I started. Well, almost. Doing a quick scan, saw "unfiltered brew", and wrote in HAZYIPA without seeing if it fit, which it did. Doesn't hurt that I love me a HAZYIPA. And so it went, with the DON'T/WON'T problem easily solved, and the ? BOKEH filling itself in. Apparently those phone gadgets can take pictures too. I'll be.

Found out who ANNA Sui might be, but did I know good old CLINT Dempsey? Sure did.

At least this left lots of time to get our condo ready for a showing, as we'll be moving to a similar but one-floor unit in the same complex if we can get our asking price. Of course if we don't, then we don't have to move, so in some ways it's a win-win.

Nice enough Saturdecito, BT and JX. Would have preferred a Bit Thornier Saturday with something like Jackanapes or Xenophobic but no such luck today. Thanks for a Tuesday amount of fun.

On to the Saturday Stumper, where no doubt I'll get my comeuppance.

Niallhost 9:43 AM  

I'm guessing DONT is just the redneckier version of WONT
Finished in record time with one mistake. Had wIND before RIND and couldn't figure out the letter until I went through the alphabet. Finished in 15, but could have been 10. Very easy.

Anonymous 9:45 AM  

Easily my Saturday record by a mile - 17 minutes! I’m normally at like an hour or more for Saturdays! Made me feel great. Got HUMAN PYRAMID, NATIONAL ANTHEM, and DAYS OF OUR LIVES without any crosses. PAGING DR FREUD made me laugh cause I’m getting my masters in Psychology right now and am currently on the chapter about Dr Freud, so was nice serendipity. As a southerner, can confirm I’ve only ever heard THAT DOG wONT HUNT. The tense of the clue also feels like it means something in the future: “That’s a bad idea” infers a thing about to happen. So the proverbial “dog” *won’t* “hunt” whatever activity is about to take place. “Don’t” seems to imply something currently happening.

But those are nitpicks. Fun - if very easy - Saturday. A nice gift after yesterday’s impossible (unfun) massacre (for me anyway).

beverly c 9:51 AM  

Completely on board with you today, Rex. Yesterday’s bloodbath 😀 was more fun. I've never heard the Freud slam, thank goodness. Also had won't hunt. Never heard of BOKEH, but okay. Finished this in half my normal Saturday time.

Teedmn 9:52 AM  

BFFS did cure my wON'T problem, so I didn’t have to page DR. FREUD (which phrase I'd never heard and as Rex mentions, it's so cutesy, my teeth hurt.)

Lime in place of RIND gave me the only minor struggle today, oh yeah, and my last entry of SITE because I didn’t know CLINT and forgot LOI but what else could it be but SITE? Once it was in, I was no longer in doubt.

Well, there was that HAZY ale that slightly clogged up the NW but only for the briefest time. In any case, here was the Friday puzzle I missed yesterday. I would dub this a Robyn Weintraub Friday-Saturday. Two Saturdays in a row where my only challenge is likely to be the Stumper, where I’m headed now.

But thanks, Ben and Julian, it was a nice puzzle, just, you know…

Bob Mills 9:54 AM  

Easy except for the BOKEH/HIHATS cross. One question...is there really something called HAZYIPA? If so, I don't want to drink it.

Rich Glauber 10:00 AM  

As far as the 'undoubtedly' that we'd enjoy the easier puzzle... no way. The harder the better for me, and probably for many. This was way too easy for a Saturday, no fun when we're awaiting a Saturday challenge. Today's was Tues/Wed level. Oh well

Razergirl 10:02 AM  

As a lifelong southerner, I’ve only ever heard ‘that dog won’t hunt’ and I’ve never even heard that in casual conversation

Anonymous 10:14 AM  

Another southerner who has never heard "That dog don't hunt". It's "That dog won't hunt", but I'm not sure where I have heard it. Politicians trying to sound folksy, mainly. My Daddy had a lot of folksy sayings but this wasn't one of them. "She fell apart like a dollar watch," is the one I most remember.

EasyEd 10:16 AM  

Worked for years with a mid-westerner who used the phrase WON’T HUNT a least once a week in discussions about ideas, never in an obnoxious way. Completely blew the DRFREUD reference, which is fun in retrospect. Brain is atrophying.

Eh Steve! 10:17 AM  

ATLien here. If I've heard it, the dog doesn't hunt. That said, I wouldn't call it a particularly common expression.

I paused for a sec on the don't/won't question, but apparently for not much more than that. Set a personal record with my first sub-10 Saturday. Whoosh!

gfrpeace 10:32 AM  

Orion says thanks for posting his picture. Every time he's in the puzzle he gets his picture up on facebook, where he has quite a following. He also wants you to know he DONT HUNT either; he dislikes December because it is deer shotgun season and he doesn't get to run around in the woods lest he get shot.
Today's puz? I didn't quite finish because I had USN for the Annapolis museum, never heard of NSA, and that prevented me from seeing either RIND or SLAYED. And all I could think of for Emerald ___ was Emerald city, which was obviously wrong.

Nancy 10:37 AM  

Hard enough to be consistently interesting and entertaining, but not really "Saturday-hard". Also eminently fair in its cluing -- which makes a nice contrast to yesterday's bear. And full of colorful phrases like PAGING DR FREUD and THAT DOG DON'T HUNT.

I'm not familiar with the former. I've never said it to anyone and no one has ever said it to me. But I like it a lot and perhaps, if the circumstance ever presents itself, will try to work it into a conversation sometime.

As for the latter, I knew it (sort of) immediately and filled in: THis DOG -ONT HUNT. (I knew it was either DON'T or WON'T but didn't realize it was THAT.)

Let's add LUTE/LYRE to our kealoa list.

I immediately got the sly "twist" of the 38D clue, and wrote in LIME immediately. Then I thought: "What an awful-tasting screwdriver!"

What a great clue for NATIONAL ANTHEM! Is it original, Lewis?

Unknowns: BOKEH, ACUVUE, CLINT and WAFER, as clued. All fairly crossed. But basically a pretty easy Saturday, and a nice one.

Lewis 10:45 AM  

@Nancy -- Indeed it is! Another clue that has been made for it that I liked is [Country tune].

Anonymous 10:48 AM  

Having lived in Georgia for the past 40 years — and spent a lot of time in the rural areas, “that dog WON’T hunt” is frequently used to describe a poor plan. I don’t recall ever hearing that it “DON’T hunt” in that context. Big difference.

Even Wikipedia and other online slang and jargon dictionaries list it as “WON’T,” not “DON’T. But I guess it’s okay to simply change an established phrase if it fits the grid better.

https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/that_dog_won%27t_hunt

Anonymous 10:55 AM  

Yeah I drink Hazy IPAs all the time! They’re great!

TAB2TAB 10:58 AM  

That was the easiest Saturday we've ever solved by far, shaved our best time by one third. Felt like Monday-level resistance, and all the marquis answers went right in. Enjoyable, but was surprised when it ended - "was that it?"

Yesterday, however was brutal, double our usual solve time.

Big Abner 11:01 AM  

I am appalled, appalled I say, at the implicit bigotry one and all here are showing in their assumptions about the grammatical knowledge of our country brothers and sisters. Of course both DONT / WONT are commonly used, as the phrase is used in two different cases - are you talking about now, or in the future? Do you say "I don't be going tomorrow"? Neither do the so-called yokels you're all talking about.

GILL I. 11:03 AM  

Why was Friday hiding in my Saturday clothing.....I'm better dressed today.
I didn't exactly zip through this; I had fun just moseying along and picking up a word here, a phrase there and staring at BOKEH.
I never time myself....What's the fun?
Me time is when everyone is in bed and I have my favorite chair all to myself. I'll pour myself a good Pinot, have my downloaded puzzle and favorite pen in hand and whittle away.
I did.
I liked it all. TATA, you were my first. Is it going to be this easy? Not really. I decided to go down South and see what goodies were awaiting. DAYS OF OUR LIVES! Boy did you get me hooked. I was on maternity leave and watched you. When would Bo and Hope ever get married.....I think my son was about 20 when they finally did....Riding off towards the sunset on a horse. SIGH.
So the South was finished and I decided to go central. THAT DOG DON'T HUNT....Is it true? Is that you crossing PAGING DR. FREUD? It is. You took a while to appear but you finally did. Loved it.
Back up to the TATA area. The zip line is whooshing. Slow down....I want to enjoy this.
I did.


TAB2TAB 11:04 AM  

From the South here: Have heard 'that dog don't hunt' over 'that dog won't hunt'. Your clue is that the former is appropriately the incorrect tense, (vs. 'that dog *doesn't* hunt'). 'That dog won't hunt' is entirely too proper, and you would be called out on it.

egsforbreakfast 11:21 AM  

I briefly had gROG Rock. I thought it was probably Jimmy Buffet's genre.

Gotta wonder why ESSAY was cross referenced to TESTS, but ORALS wasn't. Maybe that would be too theme-like for a Saturday.

I think that a tiny cry of pain might be an OWLET.

Something is off about the clue for AMISS. But it's certainly as good as a mile.

I thought this dog hunted quite well. Thanks, Ben Tolkin and Julian Xiao.

Carola 11:24 AM  

It took 45 years, but those untold hours I wasted on soap operas as a grad student finally paid off, as "Like sands through the hour glass...." ran through my head. I agree with @Rex on "easy," although I ended with a DNF on "wON'T", never checking the cross. OOF! I enjoyed the musical "bars," and an OWLET will always get an "Awww" from me.

I missed yesterday's discussion, as it was a long travel day for me, but I enjoyed the (for me) challenging puzzle, with one tough nut to crack after another. tt kept me entertained for a good long while on the plane, a very welcome pastime and satisfying to finish.

Anonymous 11:27 AM  

Tarot question. Why the 3 of cups and Fool. Is one of those your signifiet

Mory 11:27 AM  

Had no issues with the puzzle, but in what world are semifinals not tests?

Anonymous 11:30 AM  

Half my usual time. I got DR FREUD before the long across, so avoided the DON’T/wON’T confusion.

Not to be pedantic, but isn’t this the SEMIFINAL posting of Holiday Pet Pics? :)

jae 11:41 AM  

Yep, extremely easy, Wednesday’s took me longer. I put in TATA and TUTEE and it was all whooshing from there. Me too for BOKEH being a WOE, but the crosses were solid.

Other minor hiccups - NAPoli before NAPLES and erR before WAR. I also did not know CLINT but I never got to the clue.

Lots to like about this one especially the 15s, but it’s just not a Saturday.

R Duke 11:43 AM  

A brewery in the Chicago suburbs makes a HAZYIPA called BOKEH Orbs. I thought it was just another stupid made up name for a beer until I saw the clue for 5A in today’s puzzle.

And Bob Mills, HAZYIPAs can be delicious!

Chip Hilton 11:49 AM  

I’m torn on this. Yes, it feels great to ACE a Saturday puzzle, but what do I do with the next part of my day? On balance, I think I preferred yesterday’s hammering. OOF! wONT & NAPoli just about the only delayers.

Waiting for the flakes in so. CT. I’m guessing five-ish inches. Be careful, everybody.

Suzy 11:59 AM  

Just finished— agree it was much easier than yesterday! @Rex— “don’t” is the word that makes it “Southern”

Photomatte 12:03 PM  

Very easy for a Saturday but also very satisfying. Not a lot of dreck. My only nit is with BOKEH. As a professional photographer since 2004, that word was very familiar to me ... but not as clued in this puzzle. It's not an "out of focus effect." That makes it sound like the photo is intentionally blurred, using bokeh, for artistic effect. This is not the case. Bokeh is used to highlight what's in focus - the subject - by placing everything else out of focus. Yes, bokeh refers to blur, but to simply clue it as an "out of focus effect" is to miss the point entirely, since the entire reason for the blur is to highlight what's not blurry.

Ben 12:04 PM  

I haven't watched a soap opera since my very early years, but I still remember "Like sands through the hourglass, so are the Days of our Lives!" Always gratifying to pull out a musty fact like that.

I don't know if it was intentional or not, but another interpretation of the "Fool's deck" for TAROT would be that tarot reading is something only a fool would buy into.

Finished in 8 minutes on the dot! Great way to start a Saturday.

Joe Dipinto 12:05 PM  

I've never heard "Paging Dr. Freud", but I have heard "Your Freudian slip is showing", which I like better.

Nothing much to say about this puzzle –I'll just nod in agreement with those who found it insanely easy.

B, S & T

Newboy 12:07 PM  

No waiting for GODOT today in a grid that filled in half the usual Saturday time if the NYT clock worked as well as its graphics app! Easy indeed. Well, I did keep seeing a room full of people instead of a ZOOM meeting for 32 down and believe me THAT DOG DONT HUNT! Cept for that today was a breeze. Nice selection of quotes to promote a thought or a little reading.

Congratulations to Julian on his debut and thanks to Ben for being here agin; y’all come back with another seven new words.

Masked and Anonymous 12:13 PM  

THATDOG **WONT** HUNT, in our neck of the woods. Definitely.

And altho I've never heard PAGINGDRFREUD before, still thought this was a much easier puz than yesterday's.
Only utter no-knows: BOKEH. LUIS. LOI [staff weeject pick]. CLINT. And that DONT-DOG, of course.

Only two fully-developed Jaws of Themelessness, in the four puzcorners.

HUMANPYRAMID and clue were quite nice.
Also very partial to the AISLE long division clue.

Thanx for gangin up on us, Tolkin & Xiao dudes. And congratz to Julian Xiao on his half debut.

Masked & Anonym007Us


**gruntz**

johnk 12:21 PM  

A too quick, but enjoyable, solve - unlike yesterday. I disagree with those who say that yesterday and today should have been switched. Yes, today's belonged to Friday. But yesterday's puzzle should have waited for GODOT, or for a DOG THAT DO HUNT.

Gary Jugert 12:24 PM  

Not that I am complaining, but a third of my usual Saturday time. The entire challenge was in grokking the "celebrity" names. Otherwise it was Tuesday cluing.

PAGING DR. FREUD is new to me, but something I'm hoping to use at breakfast today. Beware if you're joining me for pancakes.

BROKEH filled itself in thankfully, but we've seen it before. I listen to a lot of LUTE music on purpose.

WRYEST and TUTEE are begging for a rewrite of that section. Isn't that [Mystic] clue weird? LOI required a 🦖 explanation, but silence.

Uniclues:

1 Red Baron bleeds out.
2 Takes a break during garage band rehearsal.
3 Irish Republican Army's zeitgeist.
4 A t-shirt.
5 Diatribe by a dyslexic.
6 Got drunk on bad beer.
7 Begins the drum solo.
8 Bumper sticker from Florida or Italy.

1 AGILE ACE OOZES (~)
2 RESTS BFF'S AMPS
3 ISLE WAR OCCULT
4 DYERS' SITE
5 NO RUSH ESSAY
6 SLAYED HAZY IPA (~)
7 UNMUTES HI-HATS (~)
8 NAPLES DECAL (~)

My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Enjoy the French countryside in the slowest possible way. TRIKE THRU BRIE.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

jb129 12:24 PM  

Sorry to say this puzzle didn't give me "renewed confidence after yesterday's." In fact, I disliked it as much & although Rex rated it as "easy" - it wasn't - at least, not for me.

Who would ever guess "THIS DOG DON'T HUNT?"

Oh well - on to Sunday - ???

DigitalDan 12:40 PM  

I also needed the questionable "D" for "W" to get Mr. Happy Pencil. I wondered for the longest time how Sigmund became W. R. SIGH.

okanaganer 1:09 PM  

Very fast; a third of yesterday's time. The only typeovers I recall are CIA before NSA and NAPOLI before NAPLES. I've been into photography for a while so BOKEH was a welcome gimme. It's part of "depth of field".

Hands up for DON'T HUNT. (I'm not sure I've ever heard the WON'T version, but then I live in Western Canada so whadda I know.) I think it sounds better because of the DOG DON'T alliteration. Alliteration always makes things sound better. Also, DON'T implies in the past and the future; i.e. always. Remember Robert Duvall in Apocalypse Now: "Charlie don't surf!".

[Spelling Bee: Fri 0; plus yesterday I had another shot at Thurs and got from -3 to 0 so I'm counting my streak at 5.]

Anoa Bob 1:09 PM  

There's a "Certain pseudoscience" mini-theme in this one starting with the answer to that pseudoscience clue, 26A ESP. We also get TAROT, OCCULT and the long ago leader of a dark pseudoscience CULT, DR FREUD.

When I saw that the grid had 42 black squares, I did a little mental SIGH thinking, OOF, here comes a salvo of short stuff. Having a big chunk of the black squares in the corners mitigated that somewhat but not entirely.

The grid fill gets quite a bit of help from POCs (plurals of convenience) with some TUTEES and HI HATS here and some BFFS and AMPS there. It also gets a lot MORE help from five of the ultra convenient two-for-one POCs where a Down and an Across both get a grid-filling, letter count boost by sharing a single S at their ends. This happens with ORAL/IN, PDF/REST, ANT/ROD, TEST/LUTE and BATON/DYER. Five two-for-one POCs is a lot for any puzzle, especially a themeless one. The POC Committee was split over whether the grid deserved a POC Assisted vs POC Marked rating.

Anonymous 1:11 PM  

Why is LOI "Pascal's law? ?"

woolf 1:14 PM  

hard-baked Alabamaian expat here. I have never in my life heard "That dog don't hunt." Always "won't," most often in the context of automotive repair.

Gene 1:30 PM  

Never even thought of ...WONT..., although that's obviously OK. I always heard ...DONT... Although I'm not a Southerner, so maybe that doesn't count?

Anonymous 2:43 PM  

Thanks @Big Abner for bringing some sanity. Country resident x 30yrs, have heard WONT about three times more often, but hear DONT from time to time-- maybe alliteration easier for those speakers. Mostly hear this phrase nowadays when someone is disgusted with their dog!

Nice Wednesday puzzle with some fresh clues and answers.

Anonymous 2:44 PM  

Really should have swapped Fri/Sat, I finished this in 8 mins flat, 20 minutes faster than yesterday's

camilof 2:49 PM  

What the heck am I going to do with the rest of the hour I had allocated to today's puzzle?!? Going to huddle with the 13-minute crowd I guess...

Newboy 3:01 PM  

My second least liked uncle from the Ozarks raised coon hounds. He always said “ THAT DOG WONT HUNT” as he shouldered his shotgun and led an unmotivated Red Bone into the oaks.

EricStratton 3:10 PM  

Well, I am a Southerner and the expression definitely is "that dog won't hunt." Never heard anyone say "don't". Not once.

JJK 3:12 PM  

@Anonymous 1:11 - LOI is the French word for law, and Pascal was French.

Anonymous 3:24 PM  

Loi is French for law.

Anonymous 3:26 PM  

And pascal is French…..

Dan P 3:28 PM  

Got tripped up by choosing ESt instead of ESP (remember that loon Erhard?), especially after forgetting that the square above could be either Y or I. Doesn't HAZIITA sound like something they might drink in Japan?

bocamp 3:39 PM  

Thx Ben & Julian, for this worthy challenge! 😊

Downs-o in progress.

Only the lower right quad to go, but proving very stubborn! 🤞
___
Made a bit of progress on yd's downs-only (9 hrs in) :)
___
On to Stella Zawistowski's Sat. Stumper. 🤞
___
Alex Eaton-Salners' NYT 'Going Too Far' puz was a welcome change up! Quite unique (at least to me). :)
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness ~ Freudenfreude & a DAP to all 👊 🙏

Anonymous 3:50 PM  

“Paging Dr Freud” was a line in the movie Best in Show.

burtonkd 3:52 PM  

Too easy for a Saturday.

@Nancy - I guessed right, then corrected, then re-edited LUTE/lyre/LUTE

Not crazy about the plural HIHATS. It is a single component of a drum kit, having one pedal that controls 2 cymbals (technically one, since the bottom one is stable).

Loi, is French for law, as Pascal the Frenchman would say it.

Anonymous 4:21 PM  

Very easy until… I spent nearly half of my solving time trying to figure out how to un-Natick myself in two squares in the NE. When I saw “It’s a big deal” my mind immediately went to Biden and the hot mic at the ACA signing. When crosses showed AC_ I put in the last A with a lot of confidence. Then I was left with STA_ for “One might get a lead” and MA_E for “Only” The lead/lead homophone was so confounding that it took me forever to see STAR and then fix the A/E error above. Yuck…

Anonymous 4:32 PM  

😆

Anonymous 4:40 PM  

@Anon 1:11PM - Pascal was French and LOI is the French word for “law”

gregmark 5:20 PM  

@alexscott68 I doubt anybody says PAGINGDRFREUD in any context in which there likely is a freaky sexual component of the sort that might have interested the good doctor. Rather, it would be used where such a component could be inferred via double-entendre and as means to lighten the mood. More importantly, the deliverer of such pointed jibes almost certainly would be a friend with whom a jokey reparte is the norm.

Anonymous 7:17 PM  

An interesting easter egg is that Pascal who makes an appearance in 53D invented a triangle that contains the “triangular numbers”—1, 3, 6, 10,…–in its second diagonal, corresponding to the human pyramid numbers in 10A, see here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pascal%27s_triangle#Diagonals

Anonymous 9:03 PM  

Anonymous 3:50 PM
Thanks for the info about paging Dr. Freud. Saw the movie didn’t remember the line.

Anonymous 9:09 PM  

Son Volt made a comment about the fill in the blanks today. After his rant yesterday I thought Rex would complain again today. But they’re a lot easier.

Anonymous 9:24 PM  

Southside Johnny said that the Times is making up words
But LOI is a word in another language and the clue hinted that fact. It is completely fair for a Saturday. I understand he hates words from other languages as answers ( everyone has their own bugaboos) but to call them made up sounds a little jingoistic.
PPP like ACUVUE are words made up by marketing departments but are words nonetheless. We can hate them but a huge segment of the adult population uses contact lenses ( I don’t) so it isn’t obscure

Anonymous 9:32 PM  

drwgi
Southerner who never heard the expression. That dog don’t hunt. You didn’t say either way but that doesn’t mean the answer is wrong. The South is a very big place after all!

Anonymous 9:56 PM  

The dog on that game looks a lot like Mr Peanutbutter

Anonymous 10:05 PM  

I am not a Southern but a general comment to those Southerners who said they never heard DON’T hunt, “South” covers a lot of territory and a lot of people, with much variation in way of speaking and expressions. Just because you haven’t heard it, doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist! Just read the whole blog. Some Southerners said they heard it

BlueStater 10:17 PM  

Is Mark's dog (last pet picture) a Border collie? If so, he's a good student of breeds. We've had them for 50 years. Smart, affectionate, loyal, great watchdogs.

Dave S 11:08 PM  

Totally agree with Rex. I had to set Friday's puzzle aside for a good long while and come back to it, while today I sped (for me, at least) through it with barely a hitch, and the hitch that bared itself was that random W in 11 down. But I felt better for having solved Friday and it had more surprising moments.

Jono 1:34 PM  

You know the fill is atrocious when INIDLE doesn't even get a mention! Just awful.

Anonymous 2:18 PM  

Hi, while I loathe to join the grammar police, if I were to utter the phrase I would say, "that dog doesn't hunt," as dog is singular. Using "don't" instead does make the saying sound a bit bumpkinish.

Sian 3:28 PM  

I ended up really enjoying this. When I lived in Georgia I remember being taught the dog expression by a gnarly old gentleman from Alabama and it was definitely "that dawg don't hunt". Tickled me then and fun to encounter it now

kitshef 5:34 PM  

Vastly much easier than yesterday's despite two WoEs (BOKEY, PAGING DR FREUD) and the shocking "that dog don't hunt" where "that dog won't hunt" belongs.

spacecraft 10:09 AM  

Hand up for wONT, my single letter writeover. I agree with most that these last two days should have been reversed. The across longballs--all of them--went zooming with only a few scattered letters to help. The down one: not so much. I personally never heard anyone say that comment. Too snarky.

Bleedover: AGILE. I used it as my starter Wordle guess and it yielded a birdie. I'd use it again today if it weren't for AISLE; S is way better than G. We'll see. For good luck, make today's puzzle a birdie.

Anonymous 10:54 AM  

This one should have traded places with yesterday’s puzzle which was one of the hardest Fridays in ages. Today’s is one of the easiest Saturdays in ages. Mr. Shortz misfiled these two.

Anonymous 11:00 AM  

Add me to the list of solvers who never heard the expression PAGINGDRFREUD. How did that get past the editor(s)?

Diana, LIW 1:41 PM  

Coming up with THATDOGDON'THUNT was my equivalent of winning downright. (Tho the dog said he "won't" hunt, at first.)

Took a while to finish the Steinbeck quote - as is so often the case, he made sense with that one.

A few other errors, but a fun Sat Puz.

Diana, Lady-in-Waiting for Crosswords

Burma Shave 3:12 PM  

END OF DAYS?

The DAYSOFOURLIVES are TESTS
ANDSO OFT THAT means it's WAR.
I'd SAY A HUMAN gets NO RESTS,
THATDOGDON'THUNT NO MORE.

--- DR. LUIS MATEO KANE

Burma Shave 4:13 PM  

BTW - yesterday was the 9th anniversary of Burma Shave verse. So BS verse is now in its tenth year. At least 1 verse per day for 3,289 consecutive days as of today. Only 364 days until 10 years complete.

Anonymous 5:10 PM  

@Burma Shave 4:13pm:
365. It's a leap year.

Anonymous 5:14 PM  

So the NYT pulls the old switcheroo. At least today's puzzle made the remnants of yesterday's headache finally disappear.

Burma Shave 7:20 PM  

First puz was Feb 9, 2015. Completed years end on Feb 8. Anniversary each year is Feb 9. I have done the first and second puzzles of the tenth year, which has 366 days due to leap year. So 364 left.

Anonymous 10:10 AM  

To BS. As of Feb. 10, 2024 your consecutive days are 3,288 days and not 3,289 days

  © Free Blogger Templates Columnus by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP