THEME: WINTER MIGRATION (40A: Seasonal phenomenon depicted six times in this puzzle) — the tail (!) ends of six answers are birds: that part of the answer turns down ... or "flies south," which is what many birds do for the "winter":
Theme answers:
WES CRAVEN (1A: Director who said "Horror films don't create fear. They release it")
"I AM NOT A CROOK" (37A: Infamous presidential denial)
DICK CLARK (49A: "The $10,000 Pyramid" host)
MOHAWK (6A: Center cut?)
HALF INCH (9A: Length just over one centimeter)
IN ESCROW (58A: How some money is held)
Word of the Day: ROOK (39D: Corner piece) —
The rook (Corvus frugilegus) is a member of the family Corvidae in the passerine order of birds. It is found in the Palearctic, its range extending from Scandinavia and western Europe to eastern Siberia. It is a large, gregarious, black-feathered bird, distinguished from similar species by the whitish featherless area on the face. Rooks nest collectively in the tops of tall trees, often close to farms or villages, the groups of nests being known as rookeries.
Rooks are mainly resident birds, but the northernmost populations may migrate southwards to avoid the harshest winter conditions. The birds form flocks in winter, often in the company of other Corvus species or jackdaws. They return to their rookeries and breeding takes place in spring. They forage on arable land and pasture, probing the ground with their strong bills and feeding largely on grubs and soil-based invertebrates, but also consuming cereals and other plant material. Historically, farmers have accused the birds of damaging their crops, and have made efforts to drive them away or kill them. Like other corvids, they are intelligent birds with complex behavioural traits and an ability to solve simple problems. (wikipedia)
• • •
I like birds. I never used to notice them, then I married someone from New Zealand who knew a thing or two about birds, then time passed, then the pandemic hit, and *then* I really started paying attention to the absolute Wild Kingdom that is my neighborhood. Now I'm that guy with his Merlin app open, standing on the sidewalk, wandering into the street, staring at the trees, trying to identify and see whatever bird is making that noise. Merlin (a bird sound ID app) said there was something on my block yesterday called a "brown-headed cowbird," what the hell? It's like a space alien was visiting. I didn't see it, but there's still time. Maybe. Anyway, birds, man. They're great. My main thought about this puzzle was "Whoa, so many corvids!" My first two birds were RAVEN and ROOK and I really thought we were gonna get some kind of spooky Halloweenesque black bird / murder of crows / quoth the raven-type of puzzle. And a CROW actually does show up eventually! But then a dang LARK comes along and ruins the party, but it's fine. And that's my feeling about the theme here: it's fine. It's an odd assortment of birds. Would've been cool if they'd all been migratory, particularly south-flying, but they're not. I mean, some crows migrate, but many don't, and anyway they don't "fly south for the winter." Finches, also, not terribly migratory. Again, the only thing that's important for the theme is that you've got bird names, and that those bird names "fly south," i.e. turn down. I like that those bird names were clued in non-bird ways, and so you had to figure out they were also the tail ends of Acrosses. I found this out very early, when the only horror directors I could think of off the top of my head were Hitchcock, Eli Roth, and WES CRAVEN. None of them fit ... until one of them did.
[Don't ask how many ways I spelled NEGEV before I hit on the "correct" spelling—too many (17A: Desert near Sinai)]
I got the MIGRATION part of the revealer easily enough but had a Taylor Swiftian blank space where WINTER should go (Taylor SWIFT—missed opportunity!). Hard for me to think of WINTER MIGRATION because, well, it's not WINTER. Hell, it only turned fall ... [checks watch] ... [looks out window] ... [checks calendar] ... wait a minute, it's still summer!? Crazy. OK, so, it's really not WINTER, so the WINTER part threw me (one of the few parts of the puzzle that did). But I like the concept here, and the birds were fun and easy to pick up. The "flying south" aspect was subtle, i.e. implicit, not clumsily spelled out somehow. It's a phrase for you to discover in your own mind. I like that.
[Only just now learned that she isn't singing about
"Starbucks lovers" (who'll tell you she's insane)]
I did not like the fill so much. ALAI AMOI ATNINE ORDOC IDIG etc. I'm not that surprised that a puzzle with six (6) themers (all of which go in two (2) directions), plus a grid-spanning revealer, would have fill that was, uh, compromised. In fact, given the thematic constraints, I'd say the grid actually looks halfway decent. Not much interest in the fill, but you do get a nice MINOR CHORD to bring you into a wintery mood (31D: D-F-A is one, in music). Watch the crows amass out your back window. Feel melancholy. Listen to sad music. Sip your coffee. Contemplate mortality. Get into the holiday spirit, basically. I DIG.
[45A: Desire for a lonely hart? (DOE)]
I got nice whoosh-whoosh feeling today when I hit "I AM NOT A CROOK," the very best of the theme answers. Just wham, straight across—and then down—the grid. My earliest political memory is seeing some guy dressed in a Nixon mask and a black-and-white-striped old-timey jailbird suit on the Mall in Washington, D.C. I was ... must've been four? Anyway, "I AM NOT A CROOK" was a much made-fun-of line when I was a kid (basically the go-to line if you were parodying Nixon), so that was easy, and fun, and thematic. It had everything. The other bird answers were a bit more cramped. Smaller spaces, less whoosh. But still a pleasure to uncover. Really glad I saw 6A: Center cut? very late, because that would've been very hard even without the turning-south trickery. Because I came it at late, I knew the theme, and had the HAWK part (8D: Peddle), which made the answer obvious. The idea that a MOHAWK was a hair "cut" that runs down the "center" of one's scalp ... would not have been obvious otherwise. Also tricky: the clue on ONES (24A: Capital of Washington?). "Capital" here is money, and Washington (the president) appears on ONES (i.e. one dollar bills). I had trouble understanding the clue on ALAI, since I've never heard of a "rhyming game" called Jai ALAI. I wasn't even sure what a "rhyming game" was supposed to be. Then it turns out that I was totally misreading the clue. They didn't want the name of a "rhyming game," they wanted a game with a rhyming name. Half of that. Half of Jai ALAI. So just ALAI. I see. Now. Hope you flew through this one, and had a good time doing it. See you tomorrow.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
P.S. WINGED MIGRATION!!! 2001 documentary! That should’ve been the title!
Easy yet I got Naticked because I totally missed MOHAWK and had the issue with the rhyming game. I still enjoyed the puzzle, although I have a hard time in my head with the single GALOSH. That word was old when I was a kid in the 60s.
Absolutely lovely theme. Congratulations, Dan Caprera, you hit on a gem.
'Southern' migration would have been more apt as a revealer, but of course would not fit. And not all these birds migrate. But these are nits that don’t detract from the wonderfulness of the concept.
Not too hard or tricky for a Thursday. HALFINCH, was 1st themer I got (well, actually, it was MOHAWK. I completed that center top section first, and figured MOH was something I’d come here for explanation, before I grokked the theme).
Had the same experience as Rex on the IAMNOTACROOK. Great feeling to just slap that in without looking at confirmatory down clue.
With theme really segmenting the grid and isolating the corners, bound to have some unfortunate 3 and 4 letter fill.
Agree that the little section in the north with MOHAWK and ALAI was definitely a tough nut to crack. For some reason I thought the DICK CLARK clue was a little unfair (granted, he is probably the most famous one). It’s like cluing “The Tonight Show” host and having the answer be Jay Leno - it just seems like there should be a “former” in there somewhere.
The saving grace for the theme was that it wasn’t overly cryptic, so it was discernible and not a burden contributing to a slog-like solve. The HALF INCH and I AM NOT A CROOK jumped out for me for example. I imagine those who got the WES CRAVEN up in the NW would have had a real advantage in this one (if they consider an easier solve to be an “advantage” - I know some of you linguistic masochists out there like the challenge to last a little longer and put up more resistance).
I had to google the meaning of “hart” to confirm the deer connection to DOE, which probably seemed pretty trivial, to y’all - but unlike OFL, I wouldn’t know a ROOK from a LARK in the wild (until today, I didn’t even know that a ROOK is a bird).
Loved this theme and the puzzle. NEGEV looks wrong, why have I never heard of that? Never knew that about NERO and the fiddle, you learn something new every crossword. MOHAWK was tougher than it should have been, I will thinking a center cut of beef or the like. Fun Thursday! Lets go Giants tonight Thursday Night Football vs the Niners
Cute theme well executed. My one trouble spot: sAL “de mer” rather than MAL, and I didn’t recognize 6A as a themer, so sOH made as much sense as MOH. Changed the answer and got the happy music but still didn’t recognize the themer until I came here.
Zip, zip. Sailed right through this one, despite having no idea what a MOH could be (until after I’d finished) and slowing down a moment for a MINOR triaD. Lovely theme, much better than average Thursday, even if on the easy side.
One revelation after another today. A kapow puzzle!
First, hah! I had such tunnel vision, trying to figure out the revealer with as few crosses as possible, that yes, I saw the answers turning down, right from the start, but I was so focused on cracking that revealer, I didn’t even notice that the down segments were birds! Triple hah! The things right in front of our eyes that we miss!
Finally, after filling in the grid (and seeing the birds), I looked closer at the construction, and fell in to a huge revelatory wow. Six turn-down answers, a spanner in the middle – 66 total theme squares -- do you know how tough this is to pull off?
But the biggest revelation was a personal one – [“The $10,000 Pyramid” host]. I was on that show! With DICK CLARK! I got to the pyramid, then solved that, and left after 15 minutes with $5,000, which was a fortune! I don’t remember the name of my partner, a soap opera actress, but I do remember Dick, who was kind, generous, and good looking. Haven’t thought about this in decades, and now suddenly it’s like I’m there!
Big ol’ pile of kapow this morning, and I’m bursting into my day. Thank you so much for this, Dan!
Merlin and other bird apps are fun but not particularly accurate. I think a lot of bird calls must be similar to each other because they identify 🦅 that couldn’t be in my vicinity all the time.
OR DOC? Please. No that is not something people say. Ever. ER Doc? Sure. OR Doc? Yeah, no. You can tell I was annoyed with that one. Especially since medical clues tend to be my “specialty” and I do love puns, unreservedly. I sincerely hope I never see that ever again
As a fellow Merlin addict, it bothers me that the birds are not fly-southers. P.S. I’ve seen the cowbirds…their songs are more remarkable than their looks.
Easy, and then same as @RJ and Anon 6:59. Should've seen it.
At Rex, you can have some real fun observing Crows. Or just go to Youtube and see them making tools, solving problems using water displacement, etc.
"... recent research has shown that in birds, the neurons are smaller and more tightly packed ... total number of neurons in crows (about 1.5 billion) is about the same as in some monkey species ... overall intelligence of crows may be closer to that of Great Apes such as the gorilla." Smithsonian Mag
Hey OFL-"hope you FKEW through this one"-I see what you did there. Har.
Caught on to the around-the-corner trick with HALFINCH which made the themers pretty easy to find, but like @Lewis I didn't really think about all of the downs being birds. Probably going too fast. Should take time to stop and smell the roses, or watch the birds at least.
I'm with RJ on the singular GALOSH. I had a pair as a kid, the kind with buckles, and never said anything like "Where's my GALOSH?". Sounds weird.
Hand up for fond memories of IAMNOTACROOK. Anyone else making that claim today? Someone who may have been indicted? Anybody? Sounds vaguely familiar.
I thought the double play of bird names and going south was just elegant, and had me smiling all the way through this one. Well done you, DC. A Delightful Cruise through birdland, and thanks for all the fun.
So they go around the corner. Cute, but birds migrate in a more acute V pattern. They do the same thing for summer migrations too. Let's have a little summer love.
I've been threatening to buy a decent camera lens for bird photography for about 10 years, but phew-ee the price of those things. It's okay since finches are my favorite birds and they sit on my balcony railing in plain site.
Tee-Hee: LEWD DICK CLARK pocketed a little payola and now you think the songs you like are "good" and you're not the victim of predatory marketing. Congress in 1960 handled rock and roll questions, and the dress code in 2023. We live in a great country.
Uniclues:
1 Rain shoe for a peg-legged pirate. 2 Aging violinist wonders if he's ready for a major label. 3 A ham sandwich. 4 Hippy admits love for scalpel monkey.
Had fun with this one. WES CRAVEN popped quickly and the rest was smooth. Some oddball fill here and there but MINOR CHORDS, AMINO ACIDS, CREDOS etc are all solid.
The plurals were a little rough - OLES, LOGES, EMIRS all felt wrong. Just finished brewing iced TAZO green. SEAMEN always gives me a middle school chuckle.
@Southside 7:16a - I believe DC was the only host of the $10,000 version - they jacked up the pyramid value for the subsequent Pyramids.
Hey All ! Fill is actually quite decent, figuring Dan had to maneuver twixt all the theme elements. Consider that I AM NOT A CR is directly stacked onto WINTER MIGRATION. Fortuitous that the O lined up properly. I'm sure he left some hair on the floor trying to get decent fill.
That's the reason for the relatively closed off North Center and South Center. But everything else seems regular-puz-open.
Liked this, haven't had a Turn-the-Corner puz in a while. And no hand holding circles, which is nice. And amazingly, for me, not needed! Har.
SMILE next to ANGERS.
I'll leave the other spots where an Across ends going into a Down for those more clever than myself I do have one... Sailor alone on the deck? ONE SEAMAN. Like I said, those more clever... 😁
Nixon’s ‘I am not a crook’ foreshadowing claim was many years before his presidency, this clue seems to be as confused about this as most people who mistake it for being watergate related
So I had -ESCR going across at 1A and was wondering what the third most common Chinese -ONG name was. Was it JONG, as in Erica's first husband? FONG? And then it hit me: the name WES CRAVEN just jumped out at me and I saw the gimmick. WONG! Who knew?
You might be surprised that pop-culture-averse me knew the name of WES CRAVEN so quickly, but, hey, I know them all. Sam Raimi and Brian De Palma and John Carpenter...
Look, when you're determined to never ever see a horror flick -- not even a trailer for one -- you have to know the names to avoid, right?
Soon I had FINCH as well as RAVEN and knew we had birds. FALLING BIRDS? Hmmm. "Seasonal phenomenon". BIRDS IN THE FALL? Aha! I see ------------ATION out of the corner of my eye. FALL MIGRATION! That must be it!
Nope. Not long enough. WINTER MIGRATION. I wonder if Dan would have preferred FALL, only it didn't fit the grid?
Anyway, a nice theme, nicely done. My favorite themer was I AM NOT A CROOK. Brings back memories. And I also like the fact that all the birds are clued with non-bird clues. But extremely easy by Thursday standards -- though it did help with the difficulty level that the theme answers were asymmetrically placed.
Another near DNF, this time in the SW. Had IGLOu at 50D (apparently a real spelling, at least for a product name, which looks more like a catenary than my cartoon image of a snow hut), YEs at 63D (definitely makes sense), and SuDs at 75A (ditto). I cry FuUL!
@Alice Pollard, NEGEV translates to SOUTH in Hebrew which is geographically where the desert is in Israel, hence the name. While you must have stayed EAST remaining a New York FOOTBALL Giants fan, I migrated WEST to NORTHern Ca and get conflicted. Still, I never root for the BASEBALL Giants against my beloved, always disappointing Mets.
Wow! I wish my powers of puzzle praise could take flight. But I'll just say: what at terrific idea, what a feat of construction, what fun to solve. All the more so because my RAVEN and FINCH were hiding in plain sight as a color and an attorney until I got the reveal, saw the theme, and spotted the missing HAWK. The lower half went faster, with ROOK and CROW self-fill-ins and the LARK rescuing me for a name I only associate with "American Bandstand." Terrific Thursday.
@Rex, as often, you pointed out something I hadn't seen: today I saw that the birds were migrating but didn't appreciate that they're going south. Thank you.
Just catching up with yesterday's blog. Just saw the news. That's sad, @bocamp -- we'll miss you! I know I will. Hope that maybe you'll change your mind.
I’m sure that this WINTER, MIGRATION will be a hot topic in the the debates to determine who can be the most like Trump without the indictments. I’m also sure that they’ll be at pains to show that they’re MOHAWK than dove.
Fact that @Rex missed: Stingrays and their ilk actually thrive in cold, alpine environments. That’s why 21A/22D SKIMANTA is the 7th themer.
Another subtle theme-related revelation. I guess that NERO plucked while Rome burned, but I won’t harp on that.
I had seL de mer forever, which gave me sOHAWK, and somehow my brain just would not let me see the obvious answer. It was also the last thing I filled in.
I AM NOT A CROOK and birds, birds, birds....A wonderful song I could dance to. I loved this. I saw my first HAWK with its MOH right on top of the tree. Then I saw a sweet FINCH with its other HALF perching up there as well. Que fun. Who doesn't like birds? Well, I guess farmers and birds that live too close to the airport. Here in Sacramento, we have lots of rice fields. Where I live, they're a stones throw away. What the farmers do is let out this cannon sized boom every few seconds to scare them. The first time I heard it I thought someone's dropping a bomb... I wish Dan could've made something out of Geese. Oh, wait PORTU GEESE? We have a ton of Geese here and I have binoculars to watch them fly their V formation and head for our nearby park. I like LIVER but I don't eat it because I have anemia. I eat it because if cooked right, it's yummy. Bacon, onions, some port and beef liver gently cooked for about 3 minutes. I also love chicken LIVER. I make this Chicken Liver Mousse Mirabelle ( recipe -courtesy of some crazy French chef) that will make you sing. Delicioso!.... @JD. Hah! I like your BIRD DROPPING. You should see my patio! Thank you, Dan, for the clever entertainmen..
Yes, I did see @Rex's generous offer. See my 7:30 AM post. And, thx for your suggestion yd. 👍
@Nancy (10:23 AM)
Thx, Nancy; problem solved. See my earlier post. 😊 ___ Thx again to all who've been supportive! 🥰 ___ Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness, Freudenfreude & a DAP to all 👊 🙏
Easy-medium. I got the “turn down” part of the theme fairly quickly but I needed the reveal to see that they were all birds. Very clever, liked it a bunch!
On November 17, 1973, President Richard Nixon told 400 Associated Press managing editors that he had not profited from public service. "I have earned every cent. And in all of my years in public life I have never obstructed justice. People have got to know whether or not their president is a crook. Well, I'm not a crook," he declared.
Believe the bird people, Rex, you don’t want to see brown headed cowbirds in your neighborhood. They are parasites who lay their eggs in smaller birds’ nests. Their young then crowd out the smaller birds’ babies when they hatch. I think of them as bullies. And I hate to disappoint you but they don’t look anything like cows. 😜🐮🐦⬛
I always understood that birds fly south for winter during the fall migration. Incidentally, Ft. Tryon Park next to the Cloisters Museum is full of hummingbirds as well as photographers with huge lenses ready to capture them (on film). Nobody told the birds that fall starts on the 23rd this year.
Somehow I know “rookery” but not “rook” as a bird, go figure.
Nancy, you answered my question about how on earth you managed to know Wes Craven, then tripled down on other horror directors;) When we went to see Oppenheimer, somebody must have thought it was a genre film, because most of the trailers were for horror movies, including one for The Nun II that made me jump out of my seat even though I totally saw the jump scare coming.
The Merlin app listening feature has been a revelation! This summer, I heard , then saw an Indigo Bunting, a spectacular teal bird that I would have completely missed otherwise.
Checking off the box saying you are not a robot proves that you are not a robot because if you were a robot you would not check off the box saying you are not a robot because you are a robot. At least no self-respecting robot would. That leaves open the possibility of a rogue robot. But that's too dispiriting to contemplate -- let's not go there.
UGH. SaGe before SEGO, even though I was pretty sure it was wrong. WiNG? WaNG? WONG? Further confused by having had multiple ESL students, not same family, named Peng, so that crossed my mind, too. Plus I'm not really familiar with WES CRAVEN so the whole NW corner was a mess!
At HALFINCH I saw the southward turn but completely missed the birds! Although I was thinking Hitchcock...
And who says WINTER MIGRATION?
So not actually easy here, more mediumish. But a pleasant use of time,
That there WINTERMIGRATION revealer is definitely acceptable. I'd say @RP's WINGEDMIGRATION is also good stuff. But, given M&A's makeup, I'da had to go for more of a shot of humor, somehow. M&A's proposed revealer: TERNSGOINGSOUTH. Just sayin.
Quite a constructioneerin feat, here. After figurin out the NW corner fill, had the general "terns" idea nailed down. Then the North-Central's MOHAWK pretty much solidified the theme mcguffin. nw-btw: Got NEGEV off the first E, due to fond memories of that Lawrence of Arabia flick's trek across the Negev.
Fillins seemed pretty good, considerin what they were up against, in support of them corner-ternin themers. Nice scrabble-twerkin Z-X-K score in the South-Central region, especially. Plus, U got yer AMINOACIDS & MINORCHORD, too boot. Like.
staff weeject pick: HAW. Crossin HEMS. With neat, indecisive clues for both.
Did think that ORDOC is one outstandinly odd duck.
M&A used to collect lawnbirds, at our house. Adopted a budgie bird that a yardman we knew found durin a backyard project. Then soon after, we found a cockatiel sittin in another friend's front yard, as we were arrivin for a dinner. Suddenly went from zero birds to a genuine well-theres-yer-trouble situation. Budgie got named Bob, and we called the cockatiel Stopwatch [cuz he pulled out the stem on my watch, while I was carryin him into the house]. Both birds remained with us, and got to fly around the house way too much, for the rest of their scampy lives.
My PuzEatinSpouse has a real neat T-shirt with labeled pics of various catalogued bird droppins on it. @RP would no doubt want that.
Thanx for the primo bird droppins, Mr. Caprera dude. All them droppins reminded m&e of a Bob, a Stopwatch, and a T-shirt.
Well, now I’m late for my lunch date but it was worth it to finish this jewel of a Thursday. I’m a huge fan of birds and birdwatching, especially in the WINTER when they flock to my backyard feeders. Even the CROWS which are fascinating to watch and supposedly highly intelligent. Excellent theme and trickery. I was completely ROOKed until I started to see the revealer and got the MIGRATION part. Then it was a fun trip around the grid looking for those other beauties to drop. Love that there were six of them and HAWK was by far the most hardest one to see.
HEMS crossing HAW, UGH over CLOY and SMILE next to ANGERS were some nice pairings.
@egs 10:23 -- you reminded me of a visit I paid to my sister in Boston during which she took me to a harp recital. We were chatting with a harpist afterwards and I told her the one harp joke I know -- that harpists spend half their lives tuning their harps, and the other half playing them out of tune.
She may have heard it before. How else to explain her failing to explode with laughter?
Actually, I thought B$$$ asked a reasonable question question but wanted to say, "Don't look a gift horse in the mouth". I'm so happy when it accepts my checkmark and doesn't make me tick all the boxes of photos which are sometimes such long shots that I cant tell what they show.
I got the theme at HALF-INCH, then was disappointed when the other themers were not words in their across halves. If I'd got one of them first, I wouldn't have minded.
The toughest part for me was when I had WIN - - - MIGRATION, which was obviously going to be WINgEd, but I already had EMIRS, with every other letter confirmed by the cross. Then I got TUCK, and it was clear, but a little disappointing.
According to Seth Godin, robots are now better than humans at figuring out which boxes have traffic lights in them, etc.; people in the trade know this, but so far no one has wanted to commit the time and energy to changing how Captcha works.
Thank you adam12 for your NEGEV explanation. We were just in San Francisco a few weeks ago, visiting our daughter who goes to Stanford. The coldest baseball game I ever attended was at Candlestick park, a night game in early August!
Finally finished what I thought was gonna be one for the birds (gag).
I was up very early (earlier than Rex!) waiting for sunrise so I could do some laps on the track (yes, Rex, I'm walking now but without my Cinnamon :(.
So glad you're staying with us @bocamp - are you still playing Connections?
What's with the Times's propensity for ranked-Asian-surname clues? Typically it's Korean names – nine instances since 2014 – and the answer is KIM (most common) or LEE (second most common). On one occasion in 2020 the clue was
Fifth-most-common Korean surname, after Kim, Lee, Park and Jung Answer: CHOI
They don't do this with other ethnicities. Something's off-putting about it, like, yeah, their names are repetitious, just pick one you've heard of...
I'm with Rex at being a bit late to get into bird appreciation. When I was in high school, I pretty much had straight A's. Then, in biology class, we had to make a list of birds we observed (I think I saw 10) and also to listen to bird songs on tape and learn to identify them by call. It was on the test and I just couldn't make myself care one bit. I ended up getting a B in biology that semester. Now, I can't imagine why I was so against learning about birds.
When I was in my early twenties, we had a bird feeder and I started watching them assiduously. I found that if you put out that cheap millet seed, you will get amazing amounts of "junk" birds like grackles, starlings, and yes, Rex's brown-headed cowbird. We stick with sunflower seeds, suet and a mix of peanuts, pepitas and dried fruit and the FINCHes, bluejays, chickadees, nuthatches, cardinals, four kinds of woodpeckers, etc. etc. are in our backyard. Most of the migrators only stick around for a week or so before heading further north or south, depending on the season. I just love birds, not sure what changed.
So thanks, Dan Capera, for a sweet Thursday puzzle.
@SharonAK. At my age, there's no such thing as a reasonable question. But I agree with you on those photos --- all of a sudden everything in the world looks like part of a bicycle.
@Anonymous (9:22) Nixon might have said the same words before he was President, but his famous I AM NOT A CROOK quote was spoken in 1973 during his second term and was very much about Watergate.
@bocamp: I’m delighted to hear you’ve had a change of heart.
@RP: Re the last entry on yesterday’s comments - classy move. Extraordinarily classy.
I ended up moving down the right side, so looking at ----ERMIGRATION I saw CORNER MIGRATION which on the one hand makes some sense, but on the other hand is not a thing at all.
55 across, a tea starting with a T, I put in TETLEYS thinking it was a themer turning the corner because MOHAWK is in the symmetrical place.
I'm actually getting a bit annoyed with birds lately. They poop everywhere, they dig up my lawn, they will not stop cooing and chirping (especially the doves; sometimes I swear they do it for 12 hours non stop). The quail are such drama queens; they make a huge fuss if I so much as walk into my yard. The gulls, pigeons, ducks, and geese at the beach are real pests. Guess I'm just a grouch.
[Spelling Bee: Wed 0, again fairly quick and no goofy words!]
Had "sel de mer" because whatever, so MOHAWK wasn't easy. I honestly didn't notice all the down themers were birds, so that made it funny to come here and see Rex talking about birds for the first half of this post. I probably should have noticed, but it's an off day for me. Oh well! I figured out the way answers were curving with I AM NOT A CROOK, which made it fun for me.
Construction of this puzzle had to be really tough. It's a great puzzle, and I would think that Rex could ignore the fill in recognition of the effort. But he seems unable to do that. Too bad.
All the bird talk reminds me of my Dad's favorite bird story. He was a lineman for the power company, so he spent almost all of his working days outdoors, and he and a couple of crew members were avid bird watchers. The kept a field guide in the truck and referred to it as necessary. I think one of their crowning achievements was spotting a logger-headed shrike.
Anyway, one day they were working out in the country and a homeowner, who knew they were interested in birds asked them about a bird they had just seen. Of course the question was "what did it look like" and the answer was "it was a black bird with a red stripe on its wing". Apparently disbelief ensued when they were told it was a red-winged blackbird.
Even here in condo city, we had a peregrine falcon sighting a couple of days ago. Birds are here to make our lives more interesting.
Didn't see that anyone else had mentioned this, but perhaps I missed it.
I agree that birds head south in the Fall, not the winter, but for as long as I can remember (and that's about 65 years now), I only ever heard people saying that the birds were "headed south for the WINTER." I don't see a huge (yuge?) leap from "migrating for the winter" to "winter migration."
That said, I enjoyed the puzzle and thought it was a breezy solve. I was surprised to see my time rather slow for a Thursday.
Yet again, an “easy” was hard for me. Just never clicked with the constructor’s clueing. Once my slog was done I came here to figure out what the words turning corners had to do with WINTER MIGRATION. Then and only then I realized the bird part of the theme. Oh… It’s pretty clever I guess and sorry it went over my head.
See two other comments about my problem sOHAWK section. Looked forever trying to see the entries up there that we’re incorrect. Maybe there’s an var AUWK?? Anyway MOHAWK was a nice aha after so long
Realize no one will read a comment this late but…WINTER MIGRATION? Not really a thing. Maybe for a few species, but not a theme-level phenomenon. As others have hinted, the real deal is FALL migration. For most species if you need to migrate and wait till winter, you’re dead. So…I’m sort of happy about the bird-related theme, but too much of a pedantic birder to really enjoy.
Today’s theme resonated for me, as I’m on holiday in Maine watching the birds who haven’t migrated yet, and savoring the call to the eternal present moment of Maine poet Susan Conley. She describes a neighborhood graveyard that “isn’t really scary”, frequented by kids and animals. “…sometimes we get crows in the trees. One crow says to the other, Stop Here. This Is The Place.”
Okay theme but it could have been better. I would have liked to see DAVIDBECKHAM bend it around one of the corners. Too much junk fillL: LSAT crossing NSA is really bad.
A highly compartmentalized grid, with all six top & bottom "rooms" hard to navigate. I started in the SE with SCOT/OILER, and soon found myself staring at INESC. An instant later the bird was out of the cage. While this facilitated the solve greatly, there were still trouble spots, some deliberately created by the constructor.
CLOY/YEA? Could've been CLOT/TEA, or even CLOD/DEA, CLOP/PEA, etc. CLOY is very rarely seen as is; more often cloying, or cloyingly.
And TAZO/ZONE? Wow. I had to run the alphabet on that one...clear to the end! Why not just TACO/CONE? I guess he targeted it for a Thursday, what with the changes in direction, and wanted to amp up the fill.
I too had the MIGRATION part early, but wondered about the beginning. The migration itself--the actual departure--occurs typically in the fall, to beat the cold. WINTER is legit, but fall is what we think of first with that word.
Anyway, IAMNOTACROOK is worth the price of admission. BIRD-ie.
Wordle bogey--but with a ten-pointer seems more like a par.
Just wanna say "meh" to MOH(hawk - oops) - goofed up an otherwise done-deal Thursday. But the lack of a rebus made up for any lack of knowledge on my part. Go Thursday!
I have a left galosh, and a right galosh, that's what makes a pair of galoshes. Also, the correct way to put them on is, left galosh, first; right galosh second. That is the only correct way to put on galoshes. Sheldon has spoken!
A long time ago, I was solving this puzzle and got stuck at an unguessable (to me) crossing: N. C. WYETH crossing NATICK at the "N"—I knew WYETH but forgot his initials, and NATICK ... is a suburb of Boston that I had no hope of knowing. It was clued as someplace the Boston Marathon runs through (???). Anyway, NATICK— the more obscure name in that crossing—became shorthand for an unguessable cross, esp. where the cross involves two proper nouns, neither of which is exceedingly well known. NATICK took hold as crossword slang, and the term can now be both noun ("I had a NATICK in the SW corner...") or verb ("I got NATICKED by 50A / 34D!")
97 comments:
yEoMEN before SEAMEN at 26D.
At 36A I got ARI Melber confused with iRa Glass. The terminal "A" was confirmed by MajOR CHORD at 31D. D'oh!!
Easy yet I got Naticked because I totally missed MOHAWK and had the issue with the rhyming game. I still enjoyed the puzzle, although I have a hard time in my head with the single GALOSH. That word was old when I was a kid in the 60s.
Easy. But still DNF. Mohawk. And sadly my entire unit had one in the USMC in the early 70s.
Absolutely lovely theme. Congratulations, Dan Caprera, you hit on a gem.
'Southern' migration would have been more apt as a revealer, but of course would not fit. And not all these birds migrate. But these are nits that don’t detract from the wonderfulness of the concept.
Not too hard or tricky for a Thursday. HALFINCH, was 1st themer I got (well, actually, it was MOHAWK. I completed that center top section first, and figured MOH was something I’d come here for explanation, before I grokked the theme).
Had the same experience as Rex on the IAMNOTACROOK. Great feeling to just slap that in without looking at confirmatory down clue.
With theme really segmenting the grid and isolating the corners, bound to have some unfortunate 3 and 4 letter fill.
Overall, a solid, on the easy side, Thursday.
Agree that the little section in the north with MOHAWK and ALAI was definitely a tough nut to crack. For some reason I thought the DICK CLARK clue was a little unfair (granted, he is probably the most famous one). It’s like cluing “The Tonight Show” host and having the answer be Jay Leno - it just seems like there should be a “former” in there somewhere.
The saving grace for the theme was that it wasn’t overly cryptic, so it was discernible and not a burden contributing to a slog-like solve. The HALF INCH and I AM NOT A CROOK jumped out for me for example. I imagine those who got the WES CRAVEN up in the NW would have had a real advantage in this one (if they consider an easier solve to be an “advantage” - I know some of you linguistic masochists out there like the challenge to last a little longer and put up more resistance).
I had to google the meaning of “hart” to confirm the deer connection to DOE, which probably seemed pretty trivial, to y’all - but unlike OFL, I wouldn’t know a ROOK from a LARK in the wild (until today, I didn’t even know that a ROOK is a bird).
Loved this theme and the puzzle. NEGEV looks wrong, why have I never heard of that? Never knew that about NERO and the fiddle, you learn something new every crossword. MOHAWK was tougher than it should have been, I will thinking a center cut of beef or the like. Fun Thursday! Lets go Giants tonight Thursday Night Football vs the Niners
Cute theme well executed. My one trouble spot: sAL “de mer” rather than MAL, and I didn’t recognize 6A as a themer, so sOH made as much sense as MOH. Changed the answer and got the happy music but still didn’t recognize the themer until I came here.
Thx, Dan; this ONE was for the 'birds' (in a good way)! 😊
Med.
Loved the theme; 'twas actually helpful to the solve.
Toughest area was the upper Midwest.
Fun trip thru the aviary. 🕊
Many thx to the late yd supporters. 🥰
Slashing some excessive streaming services will do the trick. ∕∕🎥
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness, Freudenfreude & a DAP to all 👊 🙏
Brown headed cowbirds (and cuckoos) are brood parasites, which would make an excellent crossword clue.
Zip, zip. Sailed right through this one, despite having no idea what a MOH could be (until after I’d finished) and slowing down a moment for a MINOR triaD. Lovely theme, much better than average Thursday, even if on the easy side.
Nit: it's a fall migration. Nobody says winter migration AFAIK.
One revelation after another today. A kapow puzzle!
First, hah! I had such tunnel vision, trying to figure out the revealer with as few crosses as possible, that yes, I saw the answers turning down, right from the start, but I was so focused on cracking that revealer, I didn’t even notice that the down segments were birds! Triple hah! The things right in front of our eyes that we miss!
Finally, after filling in the grid (and seeing the birds), I looked closer at the construction, and fell in to a huge revelatory wow. Six turn-down answers, a spanner in the middle – 66 total theme squares -- do you know how tough this is to pull off?
But the biggest revelation was a personal one – [“The $10,000 Pyramid” host]. I was on that show! With DICK CLARK! I got to the pyramid, then solved that, and left after 15 minutes with $5,000, which was a fortune! I don’t remember the name of my partner, a soap opera actress, but I do remember Dick, who was kind, generous, and good looking. Haven’t thought about this in decades, and now suddenly it’s like I’m there!
Big ol’ pile of kapow this morning, and I’m bursting into my day. Thank you so much for this, Dan!
Isn't it a FALL MIGRATION? I know, I know.
Great clever puzzle.
Can someone explain to me how checking a box that says I'm not a robot somehow proves that I'm not a robot?
Merlin and other bird apps are fun but not particularly accurate. I think a lot of bird calls must be similar to each other because they identify 🦅 that couldn’t be in my vicinity all the time.
OR DOC? Please. No that is not something people say. Ever. ER Doc? Sure. OR Doc? Yeah, no. You can tell I was annoyed with that one. Especially since medical clues tend to be my “specialty” and I do love puns, unreservedly.
I sincerely hope I never see that ever again
As a fellow Merlin addict, it bothers me that the birds are not fly-southers. P.S. I’ve seen the cowbirds…their songs are more remarkable than their looks.
Easy, and then same as @RJ and Anon 6:59. Should've seen it.
At Rex, you can have some real fun observing Crows. Or just go to Youtube and see them making tools, solving problems using water displacement, etc.
"... recent research has shown that in birds, the neurons are smaller and more tightly packed ... total number of neurons in crows (about 1.5 billion) is about the same as in some monkey species ... overall intelligence of crows may be closer to that of Great Apes such as the gorilla." Smithsonian Mag
Ditto on the Merlin app..a whole other world out there
Hey OFL-"hope you FKEW through this one"-I see what you did there. Har.
Caught on to the around-the-corner trick with HALFINCH which made the themers pretty easy to find, but like @Lewis I didn't really think about all of the downs being birds. Probably going too fast. Should take time to stop and smell the roses, or watch the birds at least.
I'm with RJ on the singular GALOSH. I had a pair as a kid, the kind with buckles, and never said anything like "Where's my GALOSH?". Sounds weird.
Hand up for fond memories of IAMNOTACROOK. Anyone else making that claim today? Someone who may have been indicted? Anybody? Sounds vaguely familiar.
I thought the double play of bird names and going south was just elegant, and had me smiling all the way through this one. Well done you, DC. A Delightful Cruise through birdland, and thanks for all the fun.
So they go around the corner. Cute, but birds migrate in a more acute V pattern. They do the same thing for summer migrations too. Let's have a little summer love.
I've been threatening to buy a decent camera lens for bird photography for about 10 years, but phew-ee the price of those things. It's okay since finches are my favorite birds and they sit on my balcony railing in plain site.
Tee-Hee: LEWD DICK CLARK pocketed a little payola and now you think the songs you like are "good" and you're not the victim of predatory marketing. Congress in 1960 handled rock and roll questions, and the dress code in 2023. We live in a great country.
Uniclues:
1 Rain shoe for a peg-legged pirate.
2 Aging violinist wonders if he's ready for a major label.
3 A ham sandwich.
4 Hippy admits love for scalpel monkey.
1 ONE'S GALOSH
2 RCA? NERO ASKS.
3 EMIR'S LARK
4 I DIG O.R. DOC
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Santa admitting he loves the whole chimney gig. FLUES AMUSE.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Had fun with this one. WES CRAVEN popped quickly and the rest was smooth. Some oddball fill here and there but MINOR CHORDS, AMINO ACIDS, CREDOS etc are all solid.
The plurals were a little rough - OLES, LOGES, EMIRS all felt wrong. Just finished brewing iced TAZO green. SEAMEN always gives me a middle school chuckle.
@Southside 7:16a - I believe DC was the only host of the $10,000 version - they jacked up the pyramid value for the subsequent Pyramids.
Glad to hear @bocamp.
Enjoyable Thursday morning solve.
ROXY Music
Suggested theme reveal, Bird Droppings.
Hey All !
Fill is actually quite decent, figuring Dan had to maneuver twixt all the theme elements. Consider that I AM NOT A CR is directly stacked onto WINTER MIGRATION. Fortuitous that the O lined up properly. I'm sure he left some hair on the floor trying to get decent fill.
That's the reason for the relatively closed off North Center and South Center. But everything else seems regular-puz-open.
Liked this, haven't had a Turn-the-Corner puz in a while. And no hand holding circles, which is nice. And amazingly, for me, not needed! Har.
SMILE next to ANGERS.
I'll leave the other spots where an Across ends going into a Down for those more clever than myself
I do have one...
Sailor alone on the deck? ONE SEAMAN.
Like I said, those more clever... 😁
See ya!
One F
RooMonster
DarrinV
I have a photo of a little bird, feeding a big cowgirl baby.
Nixon’s ‘I am not a crook’ foreshadowing claim was many years before his presidency, this clue seems to be as confused about this as most people who mistake it for being watergate related
@bocamp
Did you see Rex's (I believe it was him) post under mine YesterComments?
Roo
So I had -ESCR going across at 1A and was wondering what the third most common Chinese -ONG name was. Was it JONG, as in Erica's first husband? FONG? And then it hit me: the name WES CRAVEN just jumped out at me and I saw the gimmick. WONG! Who knew?
You might be surprised that pop-culture-averse me knew the name of WES CRAVEN so quickly, but, hey, I know them all. Sam Raimi and Brian De Palma and John Carpenter...
Look, when you're determined to never ever see a horror flick -- not even a trailer for one -- you have to know the names to avoid, right?
Soon I had FINCH as well as RAVEN and knew we had birds. FALLING BIRDS? Hmmm. "Seasonal phenomenon". BIRDS IN THE FALL? Aha! I see ------------ATION out of the corner of my eye. FALL MIGRATION! That must be it!
Nope. Not long enough. WINTER MIGRATION. I wonder if Dan would have preferred FALL, only it didn't fit the grid?
Anyway, a nice theme, nicely done. My favorite themer was I AM NOT A CROOK. Brings back memories. And I also like the fact that all the birds are clued with non-bird clues. But extremely easy by Thursday standards -- though it did help with the difficulty level that the theme answers were asymmetrically placed.
Our northern hemisphere bias is showing... Only in the north do birds fly south for the winter. Is the southern hemisphere, it's reversed.
Another near DNF, this time in the SW. Had IGLOu at 50D (apparently a real spelling, at least for a product name, which looks more like a catenary than my cartoon image of a snow hut), YEs at 63D (definitely makes sense), and SuDs at 75A (ditto). I cry FuUL!
Thumbs up for “bird droppings”, @JD!
webwinger
@Alice Pollard, NEGEV translates to SOUTH in Hebrew which is geographically where the desert is in Israel, hence the name. While you must have stayed EAST remaining a New York FOOTBALL Giants fan, I migrated WEST to NORTHern Ca and get conflicted. Still, I never root for the BASEBALL Giants against my beloved, always disappointing Mets.
Wow! I wish my powers of puzzle praise could take flight. But I'll just say: what at terrific idea, what a feat of construction, what fun to solve. All the more so because my RAVEN and FINCH were hiding in plain sight as a color and an attorney until I got the reveal, saw the theme, and spotted the missing HAWK. The lower half went faster, with ROOK and CROW self-fill-ins and the LARK rescuing me for a name I only associate with "American Bandstand." Terrific Thursday.
@Rex, as often, you pointed out something I hadn't seen: today I saw that the birds were migrating but didn't appreciate that they're going south. Thank you.
@kitshef -- I forgot to mention that I thought of BIRDS GOING SOUTH as a possible revealer. But SOUTHERN MIGRATION is perfect.
Loved this puzzle
Just catching up with yesterday's blog. Just saw the news. That's sad, @bocamp -- we'll miss you! I know I will. Hope that maybe you'll change your mind.
I’m sure that this WINTER, MIGRATION will be a hot topic in the the debates to determine who can be the most like Trump without the indictments. I’m also sure that they’ll be at pains to show that they’re MOHAWK than dove.
Fact that @Rex missed: Stingrays and their ilk actually thrive in cold, alpine environments. That’s why 21A/22D SKIMANTA is the 7th themer.
Another subtle theme-related revelation. I guess that NERO plucked while Rome burned, but I won’t harp on that.
Really enjoyable puzzle. Thanks, Dan Caprera.
I had seL de mer forever, which gave me sOHAWK, and somehow my brain just would not let me see the obvious answer. It was also the last thing I filled in.
Those birds don't migrate. This theme is a dumb exercise in trying to be clever for the sake of being clever.
@bocamp 7:30 - Just catching up...I'm glad!
I AM NOT A CROOK and birds, birds, birds....A wonderful song I could dance to.
I loved this.
I saw my first HAWK with its MOH right on top of the tree. Then I saw a sweet FINCH with its other HALF perching up there as well. Que fun.
Who doesn't like birds? Well, I guess farmers and birds that live too close to the airport.
Here in Sacramento, we have lots of rice fields. Where I live, they're a stones throw away. What the farmers do is let out this cannon sized boom every few seconds to scare them. The first time I heard it I thought someone's dropping a bomb...
I wish Dan could've made something out of Geese. Oh, wait PORTU GEESE? We have a ton of Geese here and I have binoculars to watch them fly their V formation and head for our nearby park.
I like LIVER but I don't eat it because I have anemia. I eat it because if cooked right, it's yummy. Bacon, onions, some port and beef liver gently cooked for about 3 minutes. I also love chicken LIVER. I make this Chicken Liver Mousse Mirabelle ( recipe -courtesy of some crazy French chef) that will make you sing. Delicioso!....
@JD. Hah! I like your BIRD DROPPING. You should see my patio!
Thank you, Dan, for the clever entertainmen..
@RooMonster (9:33 AM)
Yes, I did see @Rex's generous offer. See my 7:30 AM post. And, thx for your suggestion yd. 👍
@Nancy (10:23 AM)
Thx, Nancy; problem solved. See my earlier post. 😊
___
Thx again to all who've been supportive! 🥰
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness, Freudenfreude & a DAP to all 👊 🙏
Easy-medium. I got the “turn down” part of the theme fairly quickly but I needed the reveal to see that they were all birds. Very clever, liked it a bunch!
Geographical error erasure - olav before ERIC.
I myself am an ER Doc and never ever ever would I say "page me the OR DOC, Stat!" That answer is one big L.
Agreed!!!
@anon 9:22
from loc.gov (Library of Congress)
On November 17, 1973, President Richard Nixon told 400 Associated Press managing editors that he had not profited from public service. "I have earned every cent. And in all of my years in public life I have never obstructed justice. People have got to know whether or not their president is a crook. Well, I'm not a crook," he declared.
Dick Clark is not the host of $10,000 Pyramid. He’s dead.
Believe the bird people, Rex, you don’t want to see brown headed cowbirds in your neighborhood. They are parasites who lay their eggs in smaller birds’ nests. Their young then crowd out the smaller birds’ babies when they hatch. I think of them as bullies. And I hate to disappoint you but they don’t look anything like cows. 😜🐮🐦⬛
I always understood that birds fly south for winter during the fall migration. Incidentally, Ft. Tryon Park next to the Cloisters Museum is full of hummingbirds as well as photographers with huge lenses ready to capture them (on film). Nobody told the birds that fall starts on the 23rd this year.
Somehow I know “rookery” but not “rook” as a bird, go figure.
Nancy, you answered my question about how on earth you managed to know Wes Craven, then tripled down on other horror directors;)
When we went to see Oppenheimer, somebody must have thought it was a genre film, because most of the trailers were for horror movies, including one for The Nun II that made me jump out of my seat even though I totally saw the jump scare coming.
The Merlin app listening feature has been a revelation! This summer, I heard , then saw an Indigo Bunting, a spectacular teal bird that I would have completely missed otherwise.
Went birdwatching the other day with my good friend HAL FINCH.
He was the first host of the show - while he was still alive.
Now, he still has an annual New Year's Eve show even though he's dead.
@JD (9:02) -- Love bird droppings!
@B$$$ (8:10):
Checking off the box saying you are not a robot proves that you are not a robot because if you were a robot you would not check off the box saying you are not a robot because you are a robot. At least no self-respecting robot would. That leaves open the possibility of a rogue robot. But that's too dispiriting to contemplate -- let's not go there.
UGH. SaGe before SEGO, even though I was pretty sure it was wrong. WiNG? WaNG? WONG? Further confused by having had multiple ESL students, not same family, named Peng, so that crossed my mind, too. Plus I'm not really familiar with WES CRAVEN so the whole NW corner was a mess!
At HALFINCH I saw the southward turn but completely missed the birds! Although I was thinking Hitchcock...
And who says WINTER MIGRATION?
So not actually easy here, more mediumish. But a pleasant use of time,
That there WINTERMIGRATION revealer is definitely acceptable. I'd say @RP's WINGEDMIGRATION is also good stuff. But, given M&A's makeup, I'da had to go for more of a shot of humor, somehow.
M&A's proposed revealer: TERNSGOINGSOUTH. Just sayin.
Quite a constructioneerin feat, here. After figurin out the NW corner fill, had the general "terns" idea nailed down. Then the North-Central's MOHAWK pretty much solidified the theme mcguffin.
nw-btw: Got NEGEV off the first E, due to fond memories of that Lawrence of Arabia flick's trek across the Negev.
Fillins seemed pretty good, considerin what they were up against, in support of them corner-ternin themers. Nice scrabble-twerkin Z-X-K score in the South-Central region, especially. Plus, U got yer AMINOACIDS & MINORCHORD, too boot. Like.
staff weeject pick: HAW. Crossin HEMS. With neat, indecisive clues for both.
Did think that ORDOC is one outstandinly odd duck.
M&A used to collect lawnbirds, at our house. Adopted a budgie bird that a yardman we knew found durin a backyard project. Then soon after, we found a cockatiel sittin in another friend's front yard, as we were arrivin for a dinner. Suddenly went from zero birds to a genuine well-theres-yer-trouble situation. Budgie got named Bob, and we called the cockatiel Stopwatch [cuz he pulled out the stem on my watch, while I was carryin him into the house]. Both birds remained with us, and got to fly around the house way too much, for the rest of their scampy lives.
My PuzEatinSpouse has a real neat T-shirt with labeled pics of various catalogued bird droppins on it. @RP would no doubt want that.
Thanx for the primo bird droppins, Mr. Caprera dude. All them droppins reminded m&e of a Bob, a Stopwatch, and a T-shirt.
Masked & Anonymo2Us
**gruntz**
with a plus one …
**gruntz**
p.s. Sure could use a @Muse bird darlin droppin by, sometime soon.
Well, now I’m late for my lunch date but it was worth it to finish this jewel of a Thursday. I’m a huge fan of birds and birdwatching, especially in the WINTER when they flock to my backyard feeders. Even the CROWS which are fascinating to watch and supposedly highly intelligent. Excellent theme and trickery. I was completely ROOKed until I started to see the revealer and got the MIGRATION part. Then it was a fun trip around the grid looking for those other beauties to drop. Love that there were six of them and HAWK was by far the most hardest one to see.
HEMS crossing HAW, UGH over CLOY and SMILE next to ANGERS were some nice pairings.
@egs 10:23 -- you reminded me of a visit I paid to my sister in Boston during which she took me to a harp recital. We were chatting with a harpist afterwards and I told her the one harp joke I know -- that harpists spend half their lives tuning their harps, and the other half playing them out of tune.
She may have heard it before. How else to explain her failing to explode with laughter?
@ Liveprof. Thanks for the laugh re the robots
Actually, I thought B$$$ asked a reasonable question question but wanted to say, "Don't look a gift horse in the mouth".
I'm so happy when it accepts my checkmark and doesn't make me tick all the boxes of photos which are sometimes such long shots that I cant tell what they show.
I got the theme at HALF-INCH, then was disappointed when the other themers were not words in their across halves. If I'd got one of them first, I wouldn't have minded.
The toughest part for me was when I had WIN - - - MIGRATION, which was obviously going to be WINgEd, but I already had EMIRS, with every other letter confirmed by the cross. Then I got TUCK, and it was clear, but a little disappointing.
According to Seth Godin, robots are now better than humans at figuring out which boxes have traffic lights in them, etc.; people in the trade know this, but so far no one has wanted to commit the time and energy to changing how Captcha works.
Thank you adam12 for your NEGEV explanation. We were just in San Francisco a few weeks ago, visiting our daughter who goes to Stanford. The coldest baseball game I ever attended was at Candlestick park, a night game in early August!
Finally finished what I thought was gonna be one for the birds (gag).
I was up very early (earlier than Rex!) waiting for sunrise so I could do some laps on the track (yes, Rex, I'm walking now but without my Cinnamon :(.
So glad you're staying with us @bocamp - are you still playing Connections?
A perfectly realized theme, what else is there to say?
Here are some comments from the stars of the puzzle
What's with the Times's propensity for ranked-Asian-surname clues? Typically it's Korean names – nine instances since 2014 – and the answer is KIM (most common) or LEE (second most common). On one occasion in 2020 the clue was
Fifth-most-common Korean surname, after Kim, Lee, Park and Jung
Answer: CHOI
They don't do this with other ethnicities. Something's off-putting about it, like, yeah, their names are repetitious, just pick one you've heard of...
I'm with Rex at being a bit late to get into bird appreciation. When I was in high school, I pretty much had straight A's. Then, in biology class, we had to make a list of birds we observed (I think I saw 10) and also to listen to bird songs on tape and learn to identify them by call. It was on the test and I just couldn't make myself care one bit. I ended up getting a B in biology that semester. Now, I can't imagine why I was so against learning about birds.
When I was in my early twenties, we had a bird feeder and I started watching them assiduously. I found that if you put out that cheap millet seed, you will get amazing amounts of "junk" birds like grackles, starlings, and yes, Rex's brown-headed cowbird. We stick with sunflower seeds, suet and a mix of peanuts, pepitas and dried fruit and the FINCHes, bluejays, chickadees, nuthatches, cardinals, four kinds of woodpeckers, etc. etc. are in our backyard. Most of the migrators only stick around for a week or so before heading further north or south, depending on the season. I just love birds, not sure what changed.
So thanks, Dan Capera, for a sweet Thursday puzzle.
I filled in winged migration early on and then realized guck & emids were not a thing
@SharonAK. At my age, there's no such thing as a reasonable question. But I agree with you on those photos --- all of a sudden everything in the world looks like part of a bicycle.
@Anonymous (9:22) Nixon might have said the same words before he was President, but his famous I AM NOT A CROOK quote was spoken in 1973 during his second term and was very much about Watergate.
@bocamp: I’m delighted to hear you’ve had a change of heart.
@RP: Re the last entry on yesterday’s comments - classy move. Extraordinarily classy.
I ended up moving down the right side, so looking at ----ERMIGRATION I saw CORNER MIGRATION which on the one hand makes some sense, but on the other hand is not a thing at all.
55 across, a tea starting with a T, I put in TETLEYS thinking it was a themer turning the corner because MOHAWK is in the symmetrical place.
I'm actually getting a bit annoyed with birds lately. They poop everywhere, they dig up my lawn, they will not stop cooing and chirping (especially the doves; sometimes I swear they do it for 12 hours non stop). The quail are such drama queens; they make a huge fuss if I so much as walk into my yard. The gulls, pigeons, ducks, and geese at the beach are real pests. Guess I'm just a grouch.
[Spelling Bee: Wed 0, again fairly quick and no goofy words!]
@B$$$ & @SharonAK
If you go blue, you can post your comments without proving you're a robot.
DNF on MOWhawk.
@jb129 (1:02 PM)
Ty jb! 😊
Yes, finding 'Connections' a nice change up to SB & Wordle.
@Whatsername (1:17 PM)
Thx Whatsername! 😊
Totally agree re: @RP's 'classy move' yd! 👍
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness, Freudenfreude & a DAP to all 👊 🙏
It appeared that Dick Clark continued to appear on TV for some time after his death.
Had "sel de mer" because whatever, so MOHAWK wasn't easy. I honestly didn't notice all the down themers were birds, so that made it funny to come here and see Rex talking about birds for the first half of this post. I probably should have noticed, but it's an off day for me. Oh well! I figured out the way answers were curving with I AM NOT A CROOK, which made it fun for me.
It has become a standing joke at our house. 90% of the time it's Carolina Wren!
Construction of this puzzle had to be really tough. It's a great puzzle, and I would think that Rex could ignore the fill in recognition of the effort. But he seems unable to do that. Too bad.
All the bird talk reminds me of my Dad's favorite bird story. He was a lineman for the power company, so he spent almost all of his working days outdoors, and he and a couple of crew members were avid bird watchers. The kept a field guide in the truck and referred to it as necessary. I think one of their crowning achievements was spotting a logger-headed shrike.
Anyway, one day they were working out in the country and a homeowner, who knew they were interested in birds asked them about a bird they had just seen. Of course the question was "what did it look like" and the answer was "it was a black bird with a red stripe on its wing". Apparently disbelief ensued when they were told it was a red-winged blackbird.
Even here in condo city, we had a peregrine falcon sighting a couple of days ago. Birds are here to make our lives more interesting.
I wanted to heartily second @Nancy’s “Lessons in Chemistry” recommendation and add that Apple + has a movie coming out next month based on the book.
@whatsername, thanks for pointing out the late RP post from yesterday. Agreed!
@joe I may not forgive you for sending me to that video yesterday…
Didn't see that anyone else had mentioned this, but perhaps I missed it.
I agree that birds head south in the Fall, not the winter, but for as long as I can remember (and that's about 65 years now), I only ever heard people saying that the birds were "headed south for the WINTER." I don't see a huge (yuge?) leap from "migrating for the winter" to "winter migration."
That said, I enjoyed the puzzle and thought it was a breezy solve. I was surprised to see my time rather slow for a Thursday.
You really don't want Brown-headed Cowbirds around, they're nest parasites, and can outcompete certain warblers and other small birds.
Yet again, an “easy” was hard for me. Just never clicked with the constructor’s clueing. Once my slog was done I came here to figure out what the words turning corners had to do with WINTER MIGRATION. Then and only then I realized the bird part of the theme. Oh… It’s pretty clever I guess and sorry it went over my head.
Negev crossed with sego and enero crossed with sere made this puzzle unsporting. Also some clues like "what you do just for grins" were asinine.
See two other comments about my problem
sOHAWK section. Looked forever trying to see the entries up there that we’re incorrect. Maybe there’s an var AUWK??
Anyway MOHAWK was a nice aha after so long
I’m pretty sure that the corner piece being referred to in 39d (rook) is the chess piece that starts the game in the corner of the board.
Obviously it’s clued as a chess piece. But thematically, it’s a bird
Realize no one will read a comment this late but…WINTER MIGRATION? Not really a thing. Maybe for a few species, but not a theme-level phenomenon. As others have hinted, the real deal is FALL migration. For most species if you need to migrate and wait till winter, you’re dead. So…I’m sort of happy about the bird-related theme, but too much of a pedantic birder to really enjoy.
Great write up! Thank you!
Same here. Had Sal De Mer (sea salt I assumed). No idea what Mal De Mer is.
Today’s theme resonated for me, as I’m on holiday in Maine watching the birds who haven’t migrated yet, and savoring the call to the eternal present moment of Maine poet Susan Conley. She describes a neighborhood graveyard that “isn’t really scary”, frequented by kids and animals. “…sometimes we get crows in the trees. One crow says to the other, Stop Here. This Is The Place.”
Sea sickness
What is a moh?
What about ONES and SEAMEN? It’s the only spot in the puzzle like the themers but how come it’s not a themer?
Thank you! Was driving me nuts. Checkers not chess
Okay theme but it could have been better. I would have liked to see DAVIDBECKHAM bend it around one of the corners. Too much junk fillL: LSAT crossing NSA is really bad.
A highly compartmentalized grid, with all six top & bottom "rooms" hard to navigate. I started in the SE with SCOT/OILER, and soon found myself staring at INESC. An instant later the bird was out of the cage. While this facilitated the solve greatly, there were still trouble spots, some deliberately created by the constructor.
CLOY/YEA? Could've been CLOT/TEA, or even CLOD/DEA, CLOP/PEA, etc. CLOY is very rarely seen as is; more often cloying, or cloyingly.
And TAZO/ZONE? Wow. I had to run the alphabet on that one...clear to the end! Why not just TACO/CONE? I guess he targeted it for a Thursday, what with the changes in direction, and wanted to amp up the fill.
I too had the MIGRATION part early, but wondered about the beginning. The migration itself--the actual departure--occurs typically in the fall, to beat the cold. WINTER is legit, but fall is what we think of first with that word.
Anyway, IAMNOTACROOK is worth the price of admission. BIRD-ie.
Wordle bogey--but with a ten-pointer seems more like a par.
LEWD ONE
IDIG how WESCRAVEN HAS moxy,
YET ASKS, "AM I NOT A demon?,
with A SMILE that ANGERS ROXY,
"Now I've COUNSELED you about SEAMEN."
--- DICK CLARK
LEWD ONE
IDIG how WESCRAVEN HAS moxy,
YET ASKS, "AM I NOT A demon?,
with A SMILE that ANGERS ROXY,
"Now I've COUNSELED you about SEAMEN."
--- DICK CLARK
Just wanna say "meh" to MOH(hawk - oops) - goofed up an otherwise done-deal Thursday. But the lack of a rebus made up for any lack of knowledge on my part. Go Thursday!
Diana, LIW
I have a left galosh, and a right galosh, that's what makes a pair of galoshes.
Also, the correct way to put them on is, left galosh, first; right galosh second. That is the only correct way to put on galoshes.
Sheldon has spoken!
turn down to add hawk = mohawk
Post a Comment