One tapped by leadership? / SUN 3-2-25 / Armada vessel / Sydneysider's salutation / ___ Rebellion (19th-century Chinese conflict) / Encryption code, in computer science lingo / Spinoff of a popular lecture series / Expecting, informally / Binary pronoun options / "Don't take offense," nowadays / On the safe side, nautically / Super Mario character also known as King Koopa / Modest bouquet
Sunday, March 2, 2025
Constructor: Adam Wagner
Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium
Theme answers:
- BURG (1A: Town)
- ASEA (19A: Mid-voyage)
- NODS (23A: Go-ahead responses)
- SOHO (16A: N.Y.C. neighborhood where the Cronut was invented)
- IRAN (22A: Neighbor of Pakistan)
- EASE (26A: Move gingerly)
- GNAT (30A: Winged pest)
- PREGGO (35A: Expecting, informally)
- GALLEON (42A: Armada vessel)
- GYRATE (49A: Go in circles)
- REEF (55A: Maritime hazard)
- ALPE (61A: Mont Blanc, par exemple)
- PLOT (68A: Narrative arc)
- POSY (73A: Modest bouquet)
- ROYALWE (77A: Pompous "I")
- MAGNET (56A: It's simultaneously attractive and repulsive)
- GRAY (62A: Like much limestone)
- MEETS (69A: Athletic competitions)
- ALEE (74A: On the safe side, nautically)
- GRINDS (79A: Makes mincemeat of)
- ABBA (70A: Band whose name is a rhyme scheme)
- COLT (75A: Derby entry)
- TRUE (81A: Verifiable)
- TWINES (85A: Packaging cords)
- TAIPING (92A: ___ Rebellion (19th-century Chinese conflict))
- ORNATE (101A: Showy)
- TEDX (106A: Spinoff of a popular lecture series)
- ATIT (112A: Fighting)
- LOGO (116A: Nike's swoosh or McDonald's golden arches)
- SOON (120A: Not quite yet)
- CANTEVEN (97A: Is too overwhelmed with emotion to speak)
- SIRI (105A: iPhone speaker?)
- COON (111A: Actress Carrie of HBO's "The Leftovers")
- OLDE (115A: Word on a shoppe sign)
- PEER (119A: Equal)
- ETDS (123A: Some flight tracker data, for short)
The Taiping Rebellion, also known as the Taiping Civil War or the Taiping Revolution, was a civil war in China between the Manchu-led Qing dynasty and the Hakka-led Taiping Heavenly Kingdom. The conflict lasted 14 years, from its outbreak in 1850 until the fall of Taiping-controlled Nanjing—which they had renamed Tianjing "heavenly capital"—in 1864. The last rebel forces were defeated in August 1871. Estimates of the conflict's death toll range between 20 and 30 million people, representing 5–10% of China's population at that time. While the Qing ultimately defeated the rebellion, the victory came at a great cost to the state's economic and political viability.The uprising was led by Hong Xiuquan, an ethnic Hakka who had proclaimed himself to be the brother of Jesus Christ. Hong sought the religious conversion of the Han people to his syncretic version of Christianity, as well as the political overthrow of the Qing dynasty, and a general transformation of the mechanisms of state. Rather than supplanting China's ruling class, the Taiping rebels sought to entirely upend the country's social order. The Taiping Heavenly Kingdom located at Nanjing managed to seize control of significant portions of southern China. At its peak, the Heavenly Kingdom ruled over a population of nearly 30 million people. (wikipedia)
- 9A: "Don't take offense," nowadays ("NO SHADE") — "No offense" turned into this phrase a while back, among people younger than ... well, me, that's for sure. Still, very familiar to me, for many years, unlike "NO CAP" ("no lie," "for real"), which I learned only just last year, from a crossword (I think) and then my students, who confirmed, yes, old man, it's a thing. (They didn't say the "old man" part, and if they thought it, I'm sure it was affectionate)
- 16A: N.Y.C. neighborhood where the Cronut was invented (SOHO) — are cronuts still things? For like six months there, everyone was all cronut this, cronut that, but now ... the very term feels like a relic. A 2010s relic. "Time magazine named the Cronut one of the best inventions of 2013," LOL "invention."
- 24A: The humanities, traditionally (ARTS AND LETTERS) — been in the humanities (specifically, English departments) my entire adult life and yet this phrase did not come naturally at all. ARTS AND SCIENCES wouldn't fit ... and so I was stuck until I got some crosses. I realize that "sciences" are not "humanities," but if you Match Game me with "ARTS AND ___," there's only one word I'm going to want. Well, two. There's ARTS AND CRAFTS, but that doesn't seem to fit the context, somehow.
- 44A: One tapped by leadership? (SIR) — think "knight," as in "I dub thee, SIR Mix-A-Lot, Defender of Big Butts" or whatever, and then tap tap with a sword on either shoulder, and then rise and assume your title.
- 74A: On the safe side, nautically (ALEE) — one of the weirdest things about the extended NYT Games universe is that ALEE is ultra-common in the crossword, but Spelling Bee does not recognize its existence.
- 111A: Actress Carrie of HBO's "The Leftovers" (COON) — would've been a massive "???" to me except I listen occasionally to Marc Maron's "WTF" podcast and she was a very recent guest on that show (Feb. 24), so even though I haven't listened to that interview yet, her name was right in front of my face, and somehow it stuck.
- 16D: Longtime host Robert of NPR's "All Things Considered" (SIEGEL) — good memories of a time I was still able to listen to NPR (I gave up almost all news-related and even news-adjacent radio and TV, including any and all late night shows, the moment the Creep came to power in 2016—it's hard for me even to listen to my local classical station, as I have to remember to turn the channel at the top of every hour so I don't have to endure hearing about whatever inevitable horror the day has to offer) (I'll fill myself in, on my own time, in as brief a way as possible). (note: Sebastian STAN is stealth Creep content (82A: Actor Sebastian ___ of the "Avengers" movies)—he's up for Best Actor (tonight!) for playing a young Creep in last year's The Apprentice).
- 42D: Sydneysider's salutation ("G'DAY, MATES") — a little weird in the plural, maybe, but I'll allow it, if only for the experience of the word "Sydneysider," which would be a *good* debut, if you could manage to squeeze it into a grid.
- 48D: Super Mario character also known as King Koopa (BOWSER) — ... and the Nintendification of the puzzle continued unabated ...
- 79D: Single-player and multiplayer, for two (GAME MODES) — a little weird in the plural, once again, but this video game term, I didn't mind, as it did not require me to be proficient in any single video game's lore.
- 114D: Popular wood for American whiskey barrels until a 20th-century blight (ELM) — huh. I did not know this. Oak is the most common wood for such barrels today. Always up for some whiskey history in my puzzle. I assume the "blight" in question is "Dutch Elm Disease"
[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook]
114 comments:
Easy-Medium. I got the theme early but somehow the overall experience wasn't as much fun as it should have been. Maybe my dislike of rebus puzzles spilled over unfairly into this one. I found it admirable that the theme answers made sense even without the "rainbow" letters.
I had a surprising number of Overwrites and WOEs for a puzzle that I didn't think gave me much trouble.
Overwrites:
My 3D fill-up was a GAS STATION mart before it was FOOD
My Pelicans were from pitt (thinking Penguins) before they moved to NOLA (9D)
ARTS AND science before LETTERS at 24A
My records at 25D were set by a DeE-j before they were DJED (both nonsense words)
My 32A binary pronoun options were HE OR him before SHE, ignoring the "Binary" part of the clue
Wanted BOss(something) before BOWSER at 48D
My Taiwanese tech firm was Acer before it was ASUS at 51A
Took a couple of tries to get 72A Michelle YEOH's spelling correct
WORD game before PLAY at 86D
Memo header was As To before it was ATTN (109D)
WOEs:
Robert SIEGEL at 16D
NAN Goldin at 34A
RYE IPA at 58A (I need to drink more)
Sebastian STAN (82A) and SERT (82D). The S was my last entry.
DILI (83A)
TA[I]PING Rebellion (92A) - Everything I know about Chinese history I learned from @Rex :)
Bill PAXTON at 94D
Carrie C[O]On at 111A
My app did not show the colored lines. Making this a lot harder. Plus entered them all as rebuses which were then rejected. Infuriating
SLOG
Worst solving experience of the year. Walked away from the puzzle after a few minutes and did one circa World War II. Absolute dreck.
I also entered them all at first as rebuses, and it took me way too long to figure out that I didn’t need to include the color names. I hate when that sort of formatting ambiguity makes me think there’s an error in my solutions.
Major league BAD ASS chops needed to build this one. The big guy hits on most of the key aspects - the grid is so segmented due to the construction constraints that we are presented these oddball long verticals and loads of short color based fill.
D. Boon
The trick fell early and it was a slog just to fill in due to the magnitude of the thing. GRAPPLING, EMANATED, STETSON etc. are all top notch.
I especially liked that the non-color themers are all real words also - I’m assuming it was planned that way.
Not a truly enjoyable Sunday morning solve - but I will bend the knee. Like Rex I am off for a run and freeze my ass off.
IRON &Wine
Since Arts and Letters comprise the Humanities, wouldn't it be more consistent if, instead of being referred to as STEM, the fields of science, technology, engineering and math were understood to comprise the Inhumanities?
I did it on paper and I only have a.black and white printer so it was much more difficult. Had I printed it in color, it would have been much easier
100% agreed with Rex here. Theme was instantly obvious and then what remained was incredibly boring and annoying PPP-heavy fill backed by some very questionable cluing. That WHYISIT clue is awful. This one definitely does not pass with flying colors.
Rainbow puzzles have been made before – but never like this. Credit to Adam for coming up with this concept. Credit to him for much more, which I’ll get to in a moment.
First, though, the most important question: How was the solve? For me, it brought much pleasure, as there were a good number of areas that puzzled me, that I had to return to, and that I was able to crack. I get much pleasure out of figuring things out.
Now, dear reader, look at the build of this grid:
• The lines that include color are symmetrical!
• The colors are in the order of the rainbow’s colors!
• Every theme word is legitimate as well as that word with the color letter inserted, such as CANTEEN and CANTE(V)EN!
• Those theme words are stacked in a certain order to spell the names of the colors!
• Those theme words interlock!
Are you kidding me? This is a bow-down wow build. And bravo to you, Adam, for pulling it off.
So, my brain thanks you, and that part of me that loves beauty, such as the beauty in this construction, thanks you. This was a stellar outing!
If it makes you feel any better “encryption code” (whatever that even means) is not a very accurate clue for HASH.
Yep, no colors for me nor any indication of where the colors would fall, so this played very hard - a lot of the puzzle was enforced downs-only solving until eventually I hit the revealer, and then I could start to make some sense of all the entries "missing" letters.
I really like that the colors are presented (l-r, top-bottom) in reverse order of the standard rainbow mnemonic of VIBGYOR.
Also, notice that ever word that incorporates the colors is also a word (or a word combo you might see in a crossword) without the color. That is, BUrG is a word, and BUG is also a word. GALLeON is a word, and so is GALLON.
Sweet way to tie the week together:
Second puzzle this week to be inspired by the constructors' activities with their children (as described in the constructor notes), the first being Greg Snitkin's Monday puzzle.
Second puzzle this week where, rather than actually filling them in, you imagined the letters in the grid, the first being David Steinberg's Thursday puzzle, where the letter U represented a pocket, and the solver imagined the letters in the U square rather than filling them in.
This puzzle was an absolute feat of construction. So cool - in perfect order with every themed viable with and without the rainbow. Gorgeous revealer as well.
The puzzles corridor structure as Rex said did make the fill not great. I was much more impressed with this puzzle than I enjoyed it. So A+ for construction and design and C- for enjoyability.
Discerning themes is not my strong suit, so I had the grid half-filled before the light bulb went off - it’s nice to have stuck it out for the aha moment for a change. The second half was pretty smooth sailing after that.
My nits are the familiar ones relating to form/convention - crossing two names (STAN x SERT) and crossing a person with a foreign word or phrase just feels disrespectful (LANDIS x CUANDO). There are only a few of us who consider that a big deal though, so I guess that’s just a personal idiosyncrasy of mine.
I had GDAYMATEY as if all Australians are pirates.
As soon as it became obvious what was happening - which was in the very first moments of beginning in the northwest, the rest was pretty much just fill-in-the-blanks. Not a bad puzzle. And I do appreciate the really neat trick of making sure that the shortened words that resulted were all valid crossword entries on their own. But for me it was more tedious than it was challenging or captivating.
I wonder if constructors are picking up an unspoken message that if they employ the Puzzle app's cutesy new technology tricks in their construction, they have a better chance of having the puzzle accepted. This is not the first time that I have felt a puzzle served the interests of the app developers at the expense of the interests of solvers.
Put me done as a BOOER!!!. The made up stuff was bad enough. I am compelled to write an (ARTSAND)LETTER to Mr. Shortz. Whaaaaaat? That was bad enough on it own but having figured out the gimmick immediately I assumed it was a REBUS puzzle so spelled out the actual colors. What a bummer when I got to the end and the little tune didn’t play. Spent a little time checking all the answers and then it hit me. Undid “my mistake” and VIOL(ET)A!
Not sure i the need to have ATEIN appear with relentless frequency is because the constructor gets stuck or is NYT trying to subliminally tell me to cut down. on the food app deliveries.
Peace.
Stan and Sert is a native
My heart always beats a little faster when I open the puzzle and see that it's constructed by Roy G. Biv. Remember when he did that one that mixed all the letters of the colors together and the revealer was RAINBOWCOALITION? So here's another one. Yay!!!
What did the Australian sergeant say to his troops before invading Normandy? DDAYMATES.
Editor's advice to his offspring: When in doubt, STETSON.
If Thailand is full of Thais, then John LANDIS........
I've gotta say that a puzzle where I've cracked the theme after reading two three-letter clues in the NW is a bit too easy for the NYTXW Sunday Puzzle. Or maybe it's not anymore. Nice idea. Love that all the words with missing letters are clueable words themselves. I respect all aspects of this feat of construction. But man was this easy. Anyway, thanks, Adam Wagner (something you'll never hear from Zelenskyy).
As a Sydneysider, I can with confidence say that "G'day, mate" is *never* made plural: the greeting to a crowd would simply be "G'day". That said, neither form is frequently used nowadays ("Hi" being much more common).
Why make a crossword with answers that aren’t words? Quite annoying because it looks wrong. Hated this.
Help please on 37A “One of two, in this clue”, ANAPEST. Derived from crosses but don’t see the gimmick. Thanks.
This felt like a chore. And an endless parade of names. Names crossing names. Names nobody has ever heard of. Am I supposed to learn the name of every photographer who ever existed? Every actor in the 500+ Avengers movies? This puzzle was not for me. Cute trick I guess, but not for me.
I enjoyed the theme, with its really interesting construction. Very appreciated that two different - but viable - answers emerge whether you include the color letter or not. So, many of these 3-letter answers Rex is unhappy with, are actually 4-letter answers. I don't know that you can have long answers without very short ones, at least not for a Sunday-level difficulty. Clusters of PPP held me up, like at 76A-82A-82D. Also held up around MADEMEN-MOSEYS-ASUS because silly me, I thought limestone was GRITty. Finally, bumps in the south included MOTORMAN (84D) and INRE (109D) before I saw the light...
Judging from the comments, it seems the online versions never work as well as the print. This is a consistent NYT failing.
I agree with Rex that the Taiping Rebellion is an important event, and that there are "gaping" holes in our knowledge! Unfortunately, the focus of history courses in the US is what had been referred to as "Occidental Civilization" - Western history. At least when I was growing up (1970's). Essentially nothing about Asian or African history, and nothing to help us understand the conflicts in the Middle East. I recognize that much of our way of life has been shaped by European and US history, yes, but this makes for a rather myopic worldview. Perhaps it's better now? -- but I didn't see much improvement along these lines in our kids' educations.
A puzzle for other constructors, not solvers. An architectural achievement but overlooking the actual qualities of doing the crossword.
I had a real problem with determining whether the across extra letters for the vertical colors (which I got right away though didn’t know indigo was an official rainbow hue) were to the right or to the left of each vertical letter as in burg or brig. It was
It was not consistent with extra columns to the left of red but to the right of orange.
Same
Yes, it’s a NATICK
Hey All !
Neat alternative way of using Rainbow colors in a grid. Also neat that each Rainbow crossing word turns into an actual thing, not just jibberish like HDRO (HYDRO). Personally, I didn't think it necessary to have them be actual things, but it's a nice extra, a commitment to puz making. I'm sure it made the puz extra-tough to fill, so thanks for your sacrifice, Adam.
I forgive junky fill (which this was light on) and extraneous Blockers to be able to pull off a cool puz, like this one. There are 90 Blockers (!), with normal max of 78 on a SunPuz. High, hence the high threes-fours entries. But if you factor in the extra letters in the Rainbow lines, it evens out (for me, at least).
Impressed by this. Took the depleted celled brain a minute to grok the Rainbow crossers, as have to mentally supply the letters. Typical male here in that I'm more visual than (whatever the other word is that I can't think of! 😁).
@A, in case ya missed it YesterComments, thanks for the cover of the follow up question on my post. Glad you seemed to enjoy the book(?).
Hope y'all have a great Sunday!
Four F's
RooMonster
DarrinV
A magnificent feat of construction and a dull, tedious solve. I’ve got a typo in there somewhere but am too worn down to find it and fix it, so chalk up another streak-breaking DNF for me.
I always come here first on Sundays - not to "cheat" but to read (?). So I'll be back - puzzle looks interesting.
I hope you enjoyed your 5-mile walk in 9-degree weather, Rex. I did - it was a beautiful, if chilly, morning :)
Once again, way too many names. Some incredibly obscure.
What app are you using? I have the NYT app and they all showed up.
I felt like this is a slog. Once you get the “theme” it’s just ok, plug in a letter here and here etc. I also felt like I’d never heard GDAY MATES in the plural as stated by our Anonymous Australian friend.
Ruined my Sunday solving experience. I knew halfway down I wasn't going to get it. I have a postgraduate degree and worked for 40 years. I'm not stupid.
I use the stupid nytimes games app and it never shows animations or colored lines or any of this crap. I'm so sick of it. How is the actual app the worst solving experience. Where am I supposed to go to solve so this stops happening to me. I HATED this puzzle. what a joyless experience.
Each half of the clue is a phrase that features the ta-da-DUM rhythm of the anapest foot in poetry.
so many three (or four) letter answers--just choppy and awful.
Same, except biometrics.
TELL ME HOW TO SEE THE STUPID COLORS/ANIMATIONS/ETC. THis puzzle was impossible when I thought the words HUNG into the black boxes, and then that didn't make sense over with preggo and galleon, and then I just wanted to quit. Not a fun puzzle without the lines saying where the stupid letters were supposed to be missing.
A very fast Sunday solve--for me. I guessed the theme gimmick before I even entered a single letter and confirmed that I was correct immediately in the NW. All that was left was to make a good guess on the S in SERT/STAN, the last entry of the solve.
I had to look it up also. It’s a linguistic meter term. Per the Poetry Foundation an anapest is a metrical foot consisting of two unaccented syllables followed by an accented syllable. The words “underfoot” and “overcome” are anapestic. Lord Byron’s “The Destruction of Sennacherib” is written in anapestic meter.
It’s how you stress the syllables. Two unstressed followed by one stressed.
I solve using the NYT app in an iPad and the colored lines absolutely were there. As is pretty much any cutesy trick they pull these days.
This was massively HARD for me. Took me dramatically longer to figure out than the rest of you (the revealer got it for me) but I ran into what were for me a bunch of Naticks with the names in the north. Could not parse the whole top middle of the puzzle, though the bottom fell quickly.
I wish those inscrutable crosses hadn’t been there for me because I loved the concept. So weird, sometimes I find Rex’s “challenging” puzzles a cinch, but today this one took me forever.
Yes same for me. Made this hard.
Maybe a minority report here, but I loved this puzzle. For me it was an ideal blend of having fun solving it while admiring the how-did-he-do-that? construction feat, with each theme Across working two ways. Each of those provided a little moment of pleasure for me. I solved top to bottom and for some reason hadn't been thinking there would be a reveal, so that was an added treat. Lovely WORDPLAY there. Plus we got GAS STATION FOOD, ARTS AND LETTERS, a JACOBIN, and an ANAPEST. A top-notch Sunday for me.
A tough one for me because of proper names I did not know, and more so because for the life of me I could not come up with indigo for the darker purple color. Had the color scheme immediately in the NE so that part was over early. Oh yes, ANAPEST was also a problem. MADEMEN was easy because am in midst of watching Sopranos reruns. Overall, imaginative construction but some obscure clues/references.
A sumptuous feast of challenge, but with no suffering. For all of you who think you hate Sundays and for all of you who think you hate rebuses, here's a puzzle I highly recommend.
Well maybe there was some suffering for me in the name-riddled SE -- but once I got the slyly clued SPACE TELESCOPE, even the most unknowable names fell into place.
Oh to know my INDIGO from my VIOLET. It was so thrilling when those two interchangeable colors became clear. The other colors were easy -- and once I had the trick, I found myself writing them into the squares closest to the color lines first. They helped me solve many answers.
What revealer would explain what I was doing? I got to the revealer clue, saw the "L", and blurted out "INSIDE THE LINES". Perfect!
The hardest part of my solve was seeing the teensy tiny letters I had jammed into a space much too small for them. I'm having issues with my eyesight anyway, and this was almost impossible to see. In the case of this puzzle, an app might have helped me.
But a riveting and compelling solving experience. Kudos to Adam for coming up with a puzzle that was as challenging and entertaining to solve as I imagine it was to create.
Didn’t matter if you placed the color names to the right or left of the vertical color lines. The across answers read the same and the color names read vertically as stand alone words, on either side.
The iPhone nyt app has them too, mostly. Infuriating when it doesn’t.
OK, I have not read all the comments yet but I thought this was a great puzzle. I saw the colored lines and dove into it without really looking at the title. I was working the SW and like a dunce I saw a PURPLE line (not VIOLET) and was coming up with things like SuRI (and said to myself, I thought that name was SIRI, oh well and I forged ahead). Finally I saw Rainbow Connection and remembered our old friend ROY G BIV.... This may have been mentioned, but anyone have Acer before ASUS (which I have never heard of)? I had WHoISIT before WHYISIT and I hesitated at GDAYMATES for a nanosecond as I thought the clue should have indicated plural. I really like the fact that if you took out the color letter the answers were all legitimate spellings. And I erroneously assumed "What an E on a guage means" would begin with an E. I straightened all that out and finished with no errors. Great puzzle, Adam Wagner. A little north of Medium for me. Really enjoyed it
Agreed...cheated just to keep my streak
Started as rebus. Was a slog for me
Too bad I’m not into TED talks or actors’ names. Ended the puzzle with PATTON crossing TE(D)T, and since “Tet” was a plausible (non)-answer, I just couldn’t see the problem. Oh well. I otherwise enjoyed it and particularly appreciated the subtle GAY, FEM, and gender pronoun references in a puzzle with the rainbow.
I do have the NYT app on iPad and it did not see the lines either
watched No Way Out as part of my Gene Hackman legacy week, and was pleased as punch to hear ALEE used outside of a crossword puzzle. I still always type it into the Bee, hoping someplace some algorithm will finally give in
I naticked right there (LANDIS/CUANDO). I don't know Spanish or...uh....the director of a video that came out 41 years ago. I also struggled with STAN/SERT but there at least S was the only letter that was plausible. Boo.
Only after updating the NYT Crossword app did I see the lines
Re your last paragraph. This is something that both you and Lewis noticed and I didn't. Which is one of the joys of coming here.
I graduated from Northwestern a long time ago and we called it the school of Arts and Crafts.
I never read the titles of Sunday puzzles and I’m colorblind. I could tell there were colors, but not what they were, so had to hack my way through a few (more than you might expect) before I figured out it was Roy G. Biv. I got the red easily enough, but was initially certain the orange line was green. It wasn’t until I reached the SW, having moved sort of clockwise around the puzzle, and was like, “Seriously? Blue, violet, AND indigo???” (those are literally identical to me) that I finally had the aha moment. So yeah, slog is right, but all the more so.
For a lot of us, the standard rainbow mnemonic is ROY G BIV, and following that, the colors were in order, as Rex said.
Comida de gasolinera.
Kinda recommend you don't chew on your baby whether HE OR SHE is a TEETHER or not.
So a medium sized giraffe weighs ONE TON, eh????!
There's no requirement for a knight to have a horse.
Theme: Pretty fun.
Fill: Uneven.
Naticky: Kinda.
Humor: Not nearly enough.
My Day: We have mist in the air this morning (which is a New Mexico deluge) so I hope to survive the torrent. Going to buy a raft.
Taping Rebellion: When you switch to using gift bags.
😫 NO SHADE. TWINES.
❓ MADEMEN. [Formicary.]
People: 17
Places: 3
Products: 11
Partials: 13
Foreignisms: 4
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 48 of 145 (33%)
Funnyisms: 4 😕
Tee-Hee: GYRATE.
Uniclues:
1 Fruit related slip and falls chart at an insurance actuary.
2 The Big Easy stank of dank.
3 Missed Connections.
4 Seattle's D-line.
1 BANANA IRONY TOTALS
2 NOLA EMANATED HASH
3 SIT ONE OUT WORDPLAY
4 NINER'S ONE TON AGONY (~)
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: What cement-mixer trucks are good for. MAZDA MASH.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I liked this puzzle. I solved on hard copy (the puzzle in the NYT Magazine) so the colors were there and I got the theme easily. I did have to slowly chip away at the fill, but I don't mind that as long as there aren't impossible-to-get naticks. Had "within the lines" before I got "inside the lines" and that hung me up for a bit. Had "arts and science," too. But eventually it came together. I think it was a real accomplishment for the theme answers to make sense with or without the colored letters!
This was a solving TEETHER. As per usual I ignored the theme until it was forced on me. Hacking as blindly as possible through the fill gives me a chance to make up for all the solving I miss by avoiding the early week puzzles.
The SE and SW corners were especially difficult as I tried to make PURPLE work for both of them until the light bulb went off. That was doing it in the actual magazine section that's in color. When I got done I remembered there's an acronym that helps with that but while solving I couldn't recall it.
As always I had some write overs creating extra speed bumps. BEG/BUG, ACER/ASUS, MATEY/MATES, MOBSTER/MADEMEN, HIM/SHE and OILY/EELY
A good Sunday-level chanllenge.
A tad tougher than medium for me, partly because it’s takes longer to track down typos in Sunday sized grid and partly because I needed to pause to spell out the rainbow colors to get the answers correct after I caught on to the theme about a third of the way through.
I did know 2 of the 5 trivia answers WS cited in his comment.
Cute, liked it.
I completely agree. I loved this puzzle!!!!! Thanks, Adam for a lovely morning.
Same here. Rebus he’ll. Longest Sunday solve by a long shot.
I did imagine the letters in the Steinberg puzzle. But not in this one. I painstakingly wrote all the letters of the rainbow in in all the answers -- a big mistake. Because then they were so teensy-tiny I couldn't bloody see them!
Where I learned all my scientific facts, including VIBGYOR.
Too cute by half. Did it; absolutely hated it. What a waste of time;.
I filled out this puzzle with the colors spelled inside a rebus, e.g. 1a, 10a, and 23a were entered as B[UR]G, A[SE]A, N[OD]S so that they read correctly as answers going across, and the R-E-D was spelled out as the second (and next-to-the-colored-line) word going down… Rejected.
Re-entered all the rebuses with a slash as sometimes is necessary, B[U/R]G, A[S/E]A, and N[O/D]S, … rejected.
Resorted to Googling all the people whose names I’d phonetically guessed on fill letters because I didn’t actually 100% know who they were, … They were all correct.
So I was supposed to LEAVE OUT the color words and just have mangled across clues with implied letters in them? WTH. If the puzzle requires rebus-ing, ACCEPT ALL FORMS OF INPUT REBUS ANSWERS, I lost 20 mins on my solve time before a friend of mine clued me in that “today the rebuses are implied missing letters for entry”
@kitshef -- I had a blighted childhood. No one ever played me that song. Indeed no one ever taught me the ROY G BIV mnemonic at all. So where did I learn it? Here, of course.
I enjoyed this fine puzzle more than any Sunday in a long time. But when I saw the color lines my first thought was "MYGOD now what?" Cheers to Wett Genstein for 'inhumanities'.
@Rex. Your description of avoiding news programming is something I could have written. I'm a more recent convert, however. I just can't stand it.
Clue; 'Marvin, for example'*
*Ans; ALEE
Easy/medium. Finished with no errors, though I was sure ANAPEST was somehow wrong. Didn’t know that was a word. Very impressive feat of construction. All of the across answers work with and without the hidden letters.
Not easy-medium for me. So many answers I didn't know... ANAPEST, HAREM pants, JACOBIN. Oof.
Entered it all as rebuses, and it worked. Why no happy music. It cost me a 56-day streak.
Comic Rita Rudner used to complain about her husband waiting too long before filling up the gas tank, making her very anxious. He claimed that the E stood for "enough".
Complete agreement here with your name(less)sake.
This computer science professional agrees. A weak try at being tech-cool.
I’m already in a lousy mood and this one just irked me to no end. Natick at the cross of STAN and SERT. The degree to which I need to follow current popular culture or NYC trivia to solve the puzzle annoys me. Then, my completed grid wasn’t accepted because a rebus’ed all the theme squares and the app said no solve. Had to de-rebus 36 squares. And the app makes the indigo and blue indistinguishable. Grrrr…
Ugh, what a slog. The timer says 34 minutes but it felt like hours. Of course I put in all the color letters as rebuses and they were all rejected as incorrect but I don't care.
I'm still waiting to hear what Rex's Ella is up to.
Another poem in anapestic meter starts “‘Twas the night before Christmas…”
Spent the AM reading Comments on the NYT website about DJT/ZELINSKKIY (sp?) 'meeting' so maybe I was pissed when I started the puzzle.
This puzzle was my worst nightmare. A Sunday grid with what I thought was a Rebus. So after trying to solve it as such by squeezing in squares, it was a no go. Was going to throw it against MY wall, but I was determined to finish it after spending so much of my late am/early afternoon on it. Now I'm looking for my typo. I'm frustrated, to say the least, but it turned out to be more interesting than I originally thought much earlier this morning & I wouldn't give up on it & so, I thank you, I think, Adam :)
Yeah, this was a cute (and surprisingly challenging) gimmick but YET AGAIN the “rules” involving rebuses are “whatever we feel like that day.” I’m supposed to just intuit how they want the entries entered? And somehow be able to see/get all the acrosses without using/being able to see one of the letters that I know is part of the word. This one sucked.
Totally agree. Really enjoyed it ... Felt like a true solve especially after the rebuses didn't work as such!
@Roo, I did enjoy it! Very imaginative, which is no surprise, given your posts here. You need to write a sequel (or would that be a prequel?). Or a whole series of them - each one could explore the circumstances around a particular “decision.” ;-) (I think that was vague enough not to need a spoiler alert!)
Fortunately my printed version had all the colors when the puzzle emerged, I was worried it might not and I would have to do this electronically. But all was fine, ROYGBIV was in the proper order, the gimmick showed up instanter, and filling things in was not the most fun I've ever had but not that bad either.
Is ARTSANDLETTERS totally obsolete? I read the clue and filled in the answer. NOSHADE, on the other hand....
A smattering of unknown names but fair crosses, so not too many nanoseconds lost there. BOWSER should be the bass in Sha Na Na and not another Nintendo reference, thank you very much.
I found your Sunday offering impressively creative AW and strongly disagree with those who found this A Waste of time. Well done you and thanks for all the fun.
No coloured lines in my interface on the NYT app either. Likely because I'm on an older phone that can't update to the latest IOS and/or version of the app. That made it 47 minutes tougher than my Sunday average.
Based on 'rainbow connection' prompt, I figured it had to be ROYGBIV and finally found it with indigo, followed by yellow, green, violet and orange. They were all contained in discrete segments.
But where were red and blue? Did they just start willy nilly somewhere? Yes they did.
TL:DR did not like.
When the mafiosi go to war and "take to the mattresses," are those "made beds?"
How to spoil a Sunday puzzle...set it up so rebuses are needed, then refuse to acknowledge that the solver succeeded by using them. What a colossal waste of several hours. I'm giving up Sunday puzzles for Lent this week.
Perhaps app needs updating? My iPad app showed the coloured lines, and always show other graphics as well.
That was, well, less than fun.
In addition to frustrating users whose apps don’t show colors this one fails users who don’t see colors (or see anything only with difficulty if at all). A basic fact about building web sites and physical sites for accessibility is that the effort usually ends up making everyone’s experience better. This is not the first time a NYT crossword has excluded the visually impaired, but I’m hoping constructors and editors will be more mindful in the future.
Phillyrad1999
I noticed Rex had trouble with Arts and Letters. It is in fact a thing But it is old and out of style. So again an age issue. . For this Boomer, it was a gimme
"BOWSER should be the bass in Sha Na Na and not another Nintendo reference, thank you very much."
I wouldn't have known your preferred BOWSER, @pabloinnh, any better than their BOWSER. Maybe a pooch?
re 74 a Not only extremely weird but damned annoying. I actually consulted a couple of print dictionaries a well as those on-line after the first time Spelling Bee refused to acknowledge "alee".
I liked the puzzle. But boy. Lot of strong negatives. Fortunately, when I opened the phone app I decided eyes were tired to read it so I switched to the dead tree edition. Fortunate Choice. Didn’t get mixed in the rebus question! I did find the puzzle harder than many. I never learned the mnemonic l; while I am not colorblind I had no clue about the last 2 colors. Purple? Also my mind got confused between the colors and the answers. So.a bit of a struggl but I finished it.
Again as Pedroinnh noticed, Arts & Letters a gimme for us but not for Rex and younger. Another old expression bites the dust!
Sert has not been in the puzzle recently, but he is an old standby. I do know Rockerfeller Center is Art Deco and that is how Sert is usually clued. So the light dawned. Oh Four letter Deco artist.
In crosswords he is not that obscure.
@Lewis, this was indeed a masterful, nay, astonishing feat of creative construction. Although I caught on to the trick immediately (because I like the word BURG) and checked the downs in the NW corner, I failed to notice that all of the “missing letter” answers were also words without the “missing letter” until I finished and deliberately looked back over the grid to mentally and enthusiastically congratulate Adam on his work. Just wow!!!
And as always, @Lewis, your kindness in critique style never fails to brighten my day.
Alas, the Sha Na Na singer spells it Bowzer. BOWSER is also the last name of the president of Nintendo, which is probably no better. Locally, Murial BOWSER would be the choice. She's the mayor of DC, but probably not well-known elsewhere. We have not had a globally famous DC mayor since Marion Barry.
Sign me up for Camp Liked It.
I print the puzzle on a black-and-white printer, so this could have been rough, but I stared at the screen long enough to remember which colors were where.
Oftentimes I’ll see a random clue and begin my solve there, EMANATing outward. Today the last line of WS’s notes sent me to 107A, so I got to the nearby revealer before doing much else. Usually I try to avoid that, but in this case I think I had more fun by paying closer ATTN to the gimmick.
When I began entering the theme answers and they also made sense as acceptable puzzle fare without the missing letter, I thought, wait they can’t all be like that, can they? So each themer became a mini suspense story, and in the end, yes they all work with and without their color letters. Too cool, and definitely worth the price of admission! Bravo, @Adam Wagner!
Pretty sure, even with all the MOTORIng I do, I’ve never filled up on GAS STATION FOOD. Hard to get that much of it down. With one notable exception. There’s a place near the AL/MS state line called the Kewanee One Stop that has amazing BBQ ribs.
Keeping up with current events, the grid is bracketed by IRONY and AGONY.
Embarrasingly, I had AENEaD before AENEID.
Also:
WHoISIT -> WHYISIT
GDAYMATEy ->GDAYMATES
sET -> NET
qUANDO -> CUANDO. Anyone else learn that from the Beatles “Sun King”?
"We just started joking, singing ‘Quando para mucho’. So, we just made it up. Paul knew a few Spanish words from school, you know, so, we just strung any Spanish words that sounded vaguely like something. And, of course, we got ‘Chicka ferdy’ in. That’s a Liverpool expression, just sort of, it doesn’t mean anything to me, but ‘Na, na, na, na, na.’ The one we missed, we should have had, was ‘Paranoia’. We forgot all about it. We used to call ourselves ‘Los Paranoias’. ‘Cake and eat it,’ is a nice line too. They have something similar in Spanish. ‘Sun King’ was just half a song I had that I never finished, and it was one way of getting rid of it. The medley went, and we wanted a change of atmosphere, so, ‘Here comes the Sun King,’ and ‘Here he comes,’ and ‘Everybody’s happy.’"
John Lennon – From “The Beatles: Off the Record” by Keith Badman
So, my reply to @Lewis pretty much says it all for me today. This is what I call a construction tour de force and I’d love to sit with Adam over any beverage of choice and listen to his process. Alas, while technology does allow us to communicate as if we are neighbors, its shortcoming can be the distance which frustrates in-depth communication.
My absolute favorite part of my 40+ year career as a lawyer has been meeting and working with people and learning from them, mostly through the process of sharing information through conversation and disagreement and through questions and answers and discovering that no answer exists and therefore having to craft an answer. This process, I think is not unlike what constructing a complex crossword must be like today’s puzzle also exemplifies why I am not a constructor. Even my brain at its most analytical is a solving brain, not a constructing one.
Today hit all the Sunday boxes for me. Often, when a puzzle post-solve feels too dependent on unusual tricks and conceits, but fails to deliver on the fin spectrum, I remark that it’s a “constructor’s puzzle,” one that only true constructors could love. For me though, this puzzle can appeal across the board. With caveats: 1) if the solver doesn’t care for the oddities, tricks and sometimes cheap gimmicks and over the top puns and miscellaneous cuteness of a big Sunday NYTXW, then this is not a good Sunday and 2) if the solver is a paper solver the limitations occasioned by the paper grid black and white (or a misbehaving app) today may not deliver much enjoyment.
For me, the solve was much as the eloquent (and much admired) @Lewis sets forth. To Adam - just wow!! This me giving you the HUZZAHAS you deserve (alas there’s no emoji for huzzah) 🥳 Just is NOT sufficient for today.
Try googling “ American Academy of Arts and Letters.”
I'll pile on here and acknowledge the architectural mastery of this puzzle, though I was stymied for a bit in the same area Rex describes as a "smashup" (great choice of words, Rex!). This just shows the editor is slipping a bit... this kind of PPP chunking should be strictly prohibited. I was constantly amazed by the residual letters in the themer forming legitimste words in their own right. Just clever, clever, clever!
Well, hey -- Colorful puztheme, if not especially humorous.
fave color line: the INFRARED one, off to the left of of BANANA.
staff weeject pick: BUG. One in a ginormous cache of weeject stacks, all undergoin colorful alterations. To BURG [aka RED BUG], in BUG's case.
I'm kinda late gettin here today, due to one thing or another that slowed down the solvequest. sooo ... color m&e late. And brief.
Thanx, Mr. Wagner dude. Real nice job.
Masked & Anonymo4Us
... and, for somethin Dif-errant:
"What's the Dif?" - 7x7 12 min. themed run puzzle:
**gruntz**
M&A
Did not enjoy this one at all.
NAN Goldin has been in before, thats how I know it
Although I am not as kind as @Lewis, and while I believe every “HE AND SHE”is entitled to his or her opinion, I am truly astonished at the number of negative reviews for this puzzle. Putting aside the technology glitches which can be aggravating enough to diminish the enjoyment, this was a spectacular concept brilliantly executed. I think it was the best and most rewarding Sunday puzzle in an EON. Enough so that I showed and explained it to several non-crossword friends. . A total marvel. Just sayin’
John Landis also directed Animal House, Coming to America, The Blues Brothers, Three Amigos, Reading Places and other famous comedies. You didn’t need to know he directed that one specific video to know a director whose last name is LAN_IS.
The answers without the letters have all been in crosswords plenty of times.
Sebastian Stan is literally up for an Oscar tonight.
Post a Comment