Genre for Gabriel García Márquez and Haruki Murakami / FRI 6-23-23 / Game played on yaks in Mongolia and Pakistan / Target of a biometric scanner / by that kiss I vow an endless bliss Keats / Quick impression as of a person / Frankincense and myrrh but not gold

Friday, June 23, 2023

Constructor: Kunal Nabar

Relative difficulty: Easy


THEME: None 

Word of the Day: ASMARA (39D: Capital of Eritrea) —
Asmara
 (/æsˈmɑːrə/ əs-MAHR), or Asmera, is the capital and most populous city of Eritrea, in the country's Central Region. It sits at an elevation of 2,325 metres (7,628 ft), making it the sixth highest capital in the world by altitude and the second highest capital in Africa. The city is located at the tip of an escarpment that is both the northwestern edge of the Eritrean Highlands and the Great Rift Valley in neighbouring Ethiopia. In 2017, the city was declared as a UNESCO World Heritage Site for its well-preserved modernist architecture. The site of Asmera was first settled in 800 BC with a population ranging from 100 to 1,000. The city was then founded in the 12th century AD after four separate villages unified to live together peacefully after long periods of conflict. Under Italian rule the city of Asmara was made capital of Eritrea in the last years of the 19th century. [...] In 1952, the United Nations resolved to federate the former colony under Ethiopian rule. During the Federation, Asmara was no longer the capital city. The capital was now Addis Ababa, over 1,000 kilometres (620 miles) to the south. The national language of the city was therefore replaced from the Tigrinya language to the Ethiopian Amharic language. In 1961, Emperor Haile Selassie I ended the "federal" arrangement and declared the territory to be the 14th province of the Ethiopian Empire. Ethiopia's biggest ally was the United States. The city was home to the US Army's Kagnew Station installation from 1943 until 1977. The Eritrean War of Independence began in 1961 and ended in 1991, resulting in the independence of Eritrea. Asmara was left relatively undamaged throughout the war, as were the majority of highland regions. After independence, Asmara again became the capital of Eritrea. (wikipedia)
• • •

I had some idea that this puzzle was going to be easy because yesterday I had seen this astonishingly condescending tweet from @NYTGames:

I would never have seen the tweet, but friends of mine were rightly mocking it, which is basically what Twitter is now (i.e. stuff you'd rather not see but your friends keep pointing at it going "Can you believe this ****!?"). Anyway, telling your subscribers not to try, LOL, that is one hell of a marketing strategy. I guess the "Ted Lasso" backlash really has begun. "Do Not Believe ... that you can do the Thursday puzzle!" And Thursday's puzzle was actually the *perfect* opportunity to ease newer solvers into the whole concept of the rebus puzzle, since as you know, the puzzle was pretty damn easy, as rebuses go. Surely there is a way to help newer solvers tackle tougher puzzles besides telling them simply to pass and wait for the next easy puzzle to come down the pike. And surely there's a way to sell today's (quite nice!) puzzle to solvers without saying "Hey, you'll like it, we dumbed it down for you!" I hear that there's some scheme afoot in the NYT Games newsletter to offer themeless puzzles up with clues that have been completely rewritten by in-house staff (gutting the original constructor's cluing voice completely, without their consent). Editors change clues all the time, of course, but that's ... editing. Not wholesale rewriting. Maybe I have misunderstood, and the plan is less heavy-handed and constructor-unfriendly. But I'm not liking this marketing trend that says "new solvers are impatient dummies who need to be coddled so that we get more engagement on the app." And today's puzzle deserves much better framing than "not as challenging as your typical Friday solve." What's remarkable about it isn't that it's easy, but that it's good, and fun. No reason you can't hype its quality and relative accessibility while also leaving the poor Thursday puzzle completely out of the conversation.


This puzzle is built in such a way that the whoosh-whoosh comes early and dramatically ... and then the puzzle settles down to a more regular Friday pace. This is because all of your very long answers originate in the NW corner, which (if you're me, a reasonably normal human solver) is where you start. I don't start with the long stuff. I got right to the short stuff in order to hack at the long stuff, so that when I finally look at the long stuff, I have some reasonable hope of getting it. I tried 1A: Like some knowledge and commitments, but that makes this clue basically a "word that can go with"-type clue, and as I told you yesterday, my brain cannot handle those. Today was no different. But the Downs were much friendlier. POLO RNA IOTAS bam bam bam. Wanted OPEN-something and ROCK-something for the next two Downs, but wouldn't commit. Saw that 12A: Playbills? seemed to open with MONO- but couldn't do anything with that. Eventually committed to OPEN MIC and ROCK ON and then decided to check the "M" in 1A's (apparent) MONO- by looking at the Down cross. And that ... that was the moment the roller coaster car crested ... and dropped!


That's a 14-letter answer I could've gotten with no letters in place. You say "Gabriel Gar-" and I'm already shouting "MAGICAL REALISM" back at you (12D: Genre for Gabriel García Márquez and Haruki Murakami). What a beautiful answer to have as your initial grid-buster, the answer that goes shooting across the grid, opening up ... A Whole New World (I know, Aladdin is not technically MAGICAL REALISM, just go with it). MAGICAL REALISM / MONOPOLY MONEY followed by PEOPLE PLEASER / PALATE CLEANSER was like getting the big fireworks finale at the beginning of the fireworks show. So many beautiful explosions! And then that's it for the long stuff. The grid has mirror symmetry on the diagonal, which means we don't have to work our way to the other side of the grid to get our symmetrical long answers—both pairs of long answers instead come flying out of that one point in the NW. As for the rest of the grid—to its credit, it's not a letdown. I mean, nothing's gonna beat that initial burst of highly alliterative goodness, but the middle and SE corners are still pretty dynamic, and loaded with solid and interesting answers. The colorful KOI PONDS and the UNCTUOUS TIME LOOP. There's even a weird little [Apt cry...] pair stacked one atop the other in the dead center of the grid. One big joy up front and then a host of little joys thereafter. This ticks all my Friday boxes. And I think it's a debut (?!). So next time, NYT Games, try hyping the quality (and the constructor!) and not just the easiness. Also, show more respect for tough puzzles—and for the newer solvers who aspire to solve them.


Other things:
  • 29A: Quick impression, as of a person (READ) — all the difficulty for me today came in small packages. This answer, for instance. I was thinking of something "doing" impressions, not "getting" them. 
  • 25D: Like many gift packages and old messages (TAPED) — this one too, oof, just couldn't get it. "Gift packages" had me thinking something like "gift baskets," and "old messages"—that could've been a million things. I considered TYPED (!?). 
  • 47A: Drones, e.g. (MALES) — again, tough by reasons of vagueness (today's drones are bees)
  • 44D: Oil and film, for two (MEDIA) — I like this clue a lot. Again, toughness through vagueness.
  • 13D: Spanish American cowboy (LLANERO) — I knew LLANO (South American grasslands) but not the dudes who ride them! Was able to infer the -ERO ending relatively easily by analogy with ... I dunno, "ranchero" "caballero" etc.
  • 23D: City formerly known as Christiania (OSLO) — in a bizarre coincidence, just last night I read aloud to my wife a short blurb about Nobel Prize-winning author Knut Hamsun (who was Norwegian), and in that blurb was this exact bit of trivia. Kind of a depressing read (Hamsun wrote about despair, and also ended up a Nazi sympathizer), but at least I got a crossword answer out of it!
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]

87 comments:

Bob Mills 6:28 AM  

It must have been easy, because I solved it in less than an hour without cheating once. The misdirect clues weren't too difficult to handle...once I came up with MONOPOLYMONEY I felt confident. PEOPLEPLEASER was the hardest, because "peppleperson" seemed more logical.

Weezie 7:16 AM  

What a sweetheart of a puzzle. I too was delighted by MAGICAL REALISM - there is a *lot* of Murakami and Calvino and Márquez and Roy on my shelves and also newer comers like Marlon James, K-Ming Chang, Jesmyn Ward, and C Pam Zhang. Especially before I started to break down my snobbery and let myself read more genre fiction (N.K. Jemisin was my gateway drug), magical realism has provided some much needed dreamy escapes from this really challenging world.

Anyway. What a lovely Friday. So many misdirects but none too devilish, and just gorgeous fill on the whole. I have zero nits or notes which is super rare for me. UNCTUOUS is a *great* word. Loved to see how the ACLU was clued - I’m dear friends with their Digital Comms Director so I’ll be letting her know! I’m also in community with Chase Strangio, the ACLU lawyer who leads a lot of their trans justice work, and they just had a huge win in Arkansas, in which a federal court ruled that bans on gender affirming care for young people are unconstitutional. So, nice timing, and way to lift up important work during Pride month.

And yes, what a fantastically weird take from the NYT. As a newer solver, the only way over the hump is through. A friend who’s even newer than I said she was having trouble finishing puzzles after Tuesday and did I have any tips and mostly it was just, keep going, let yourself look up an anchor answer if you’re feeling stumped so you start to get the feel of a harder puzzle, etc. And two weeks ago she texted me about finishing the Friday puzzle! It’s doable. There are tons of super easy crosswords out there, and the reason people come to the NYT is because they *want* the challenge.

Okay, long ramble this morning. I’m off to get another long ramble in (a hike up Windham Mountain) before this rainy weekend.

Anonymous 7:21 AM  

Lots of fun answers all over the grid! Enjoyed this one, if not quite as toothsome as I hope for on Fridays.

Serena 7:22 AM  

Relax. It’s just a marketing department trying to sell a crossword puzzle. Nothing more. Nothing less.

Taylor Slow 7:39 AM  

Also enjoyed this puzzle and wonder what the hell is going on over there in the crossword editors' minds. "Hey, people who might want to start doing crosswords: Tomorrow's puzzle is too hard for you, and you'll feel triggered by not being able to do it in under an hour. But Friday, which is usually challenging? Pfffffft! Piece of cake! Easy as the USA Today puzzle, gnome sayin'? You'll get a better score!" WTAF? That is a terrible attitude. See @Weezie for an attitude upgrade.

My solve experience was similar to Rex's, with the lovely MAGICAL REALISM going in without any help. However, I think of Isabel Allende first when I hear that term. @Bob Mills, I also tried PEOPLE Person at 14D. 12A and 14A--also lovely answers, clued deliciously. UNCTUOUS! And the two theme-adjacent downs--ROCK ON and KEEP IT UP. 20D: Missed that one on first pass because "holiday" leads my brain directly to Christmas. Good one! Just a lovely, enjoyable puzzle from start to finish. Nice job, Kunal, and sorry that some moron at NYT attempted to rain on this happy parade.

Son Volt 7:47 AM  

Elegant symmetry - well filled but midweek level difficulty. Pleasant solve overall.

MC5

SouthsideJohnny 7:49 AM  

During the solve I was thinking that the puzzle was pretty straightforward and well constructed so I suspected that Rex would pan it for being too easy - and instead he vigorously defended it for just that reason. Personally, I would be a big fan of more Fridays like these.

Light on trivia (on the NYT scale), with the symmetrically placed ASMARA and TYRESE as the esoteric headliners today. Some may include LLANERO in that category as well (I believe it was a first for me). Hopefully that one will be easy to remember and will make a return appearance soon. ASIDE: DREIDEL made it to my 3x5 card probably the first week that I started solving perhaps 10 years ago - I dropped it in today like it was nothing.

Some here (and I’m sure elsewhere) have suggested that the Times could offer an easy/hard choice of puzzles on certain days, so I’m guessing that it’s hardly a blasphemous idea. Personally, I would be overjoyed if they would throw the arcane trivia and constant foreign language stuff overboard and just publish puzzles like this one everyday. The theory being: If you lose the gimmicks and the crap, then you obviate the need to publish a version of your puzzle without the gimmicks and the crap. Will be interesting to see how it plays out over the next few weeks/months.

Kent 7:56 AM  

Yes, easy (half my average Friday time) and yes, delightful. My solving experience was similar to Rex, except MONOPOLY MONEY was the first long answer I committed to. Answer after answer brought a smile.

I missed the NYT tweet - Rex’s invocation of “I’ve Never Been to Me” led me to shut down the app for the day. :) But yeah, what a weird way to promote your product. Insult your audience and your constructors in one fell swoop.

Lewis 8:06 AM  

Two related crossword thoughts:

Number One, regular crossword solving develops the skill of seeing answers with fewer and fewer crosses. It’s not a skill that is useful in everyday life, but boy, it helps in filling in a grid.

And Number Two, one of the great crosswording solving experiences is The Avalanche. When you suddenly go from lento to presto, when “Wha?” turns into “Whee!”, when that briar patch opens like the Red Sea, when you can’t fill in squares fast enough, and when after you fill in that last square, you jump from your seat, and pump your fist. For this to happen, the puzzle needs to initially provide a fight, not be easy from square alpha to square omega.

Number One enables Number Two. An answer begets the cross that breaks open another, then that answer begets another, and all of a sudden boom boom boom the question marks fall in a flood, the stop signs disappear, and you enter Whoosh City.

It doesn’t happen often to me, but it did today, and as always, was fist-pump thrilling.

Added to that today were fresh fantastic answers. In my Venn diagram intersection of Debut Answers and Answers I Loved were MONOPOLY MONEY, PALATE CLEANSER, KOI PONDS, PEOPLE PLEASER, and the gorgeous gorgeous UNCTUOUS.

Kunal, congratulations on your debut, and I so hope to see more from you. Thank you. You gave me beauty and thrill today – what a gift!

Nancy 8:07 AM  

Delicious long answers going in two different directions. Lots and lots of white space. And some lovely and original clues like "playbills" for MONOPOLY MONEY and "refresher course" for PALATE CLEANSER. And the wonderful DREIDEL clue. But my favorite clue of all was "apt encouragement to a pilot" for KEEP IT UP.

And there are pretty much no proper names!!!!! Yes, it can be done if you really want to do it and I sure wish more constructors really wanted to do it.

This puzzle was a PEOPLE PLEASER on so many levels. The fact that it may have been a bit on the easy side for a Friday didn't hurt either: it manages to be fresh, interesting and engaging without causing any undue late-week suffering. I really, really enjoyed it!

Dr.A 8:18 AM  

As usual, agree! This puzzle was a pleasure in that it kept things interesting but was not a stumper. I loved Magical realism too, but I’m more of a Murakami fan! Same exact flow and also ones that took longer for me. I never joined Twitter and now I’m glad.

Anonymous 8:47 AM  

Liked this one. No Harry Potter, Star Wars, or rap references. No crosswordese.

bocamp 8:48 AM  

Thx, Kunal, nothing to SNEER at with this one; great work! 😊

Easy.

Pretty much on the right wavelength all the way.

Nice misdirection on PASS. Was thinking of something smaller, e.g., trail, etc.

Good connection with SEGO cornering OSMOND, both being Utah products.

Speaking of SEGO, sold the diet drink when a salesman for PET Milk back in the sixties.

Never tire of watching 'Groundhog Day'; def one of my all time faves!

Currently reading 'A Strange Loop' by Douglas R. Hofstadter; all kinds of weird LOOPs in that one.

MAGICAL REALISM:

From ChatGPT:

"Magical realism is a literary genre that combines elements of the fantastical or magical with everyday reality. It originated in Latin American literature in the mid-20th century, particularly with the works of authors such as Gabriel García Márquez, Isabel Allende, and Jorge Luis Borges, but has since gained global recognition.

In magical realism, fantastical or supernatural events are presented in a matter-of-fact manner, as if they are simply a natural part of the world. The magical elements coexist with the ordinary, and there is often a blurring of the boundaries between reality and imagination. This genre frequently incorporates elements of folklore, mythology, and surrealism.

One of the key aspects of magical realism is that the magical elements are not questioned or explained in a rational or scientific manner. They are accepted as a normal part of the narrative, allowing the reader to experience a sense of wonder and explore deeper themes and symbolism. Magical realism often serves as a vehicle to comment on social, political, or cultural issues, while also exploring the mysteries and complexities of human existence.

By intertwining the magical and the real, magical realism offers a unique and enchanting storytelling style that challenges conventional notions of reality and expands the reader's imagination."

Fun fri. puz; loved it! :)
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness, Freudenfreude, Serendipity & a DAP to all 👊 🙏

Carola 8:50 AM  

Easy, and a PLEASER. Starting out, PRIOR and AGHAST provided some nice Down opportunities and MAGICAL REALISM the same for the Acrosses. Fun all the way. I hope the constructor will give us a brain-racker next time.

Do-overs: ROCK on, And before AYE, NEWS desk. Help from previous puzzles: WIE, ASMARA. No idea: TYRESE.

@Uni-clue writers: Please tell us what happened at the monastery (PRIOR AGHAST).

@Weezie, I join you in celebrating the Arkansas ruling.

CE 8:55 AM  

Yard of ale was a new one for me. But it worked out and I loved this puzzle.

Anonymous 9:05 AM  

Can anyone explain 30d to me?

andrew 9:11 AM  

[An ASIDE: Don’t you hate when composing a comment, someone else says the exact same thing first? Especially since the “I’m not a robot” identification of crosswalks, cars, cats, traffic lights etc. is slowing down your posting? And then you wonder why have I been having to do all theses grueling picture puzzle tests when I once only had to hit the check mark? What am I, Al Qaeda?

Anyway, my post pretty much mirrors @Lewis 8:06. And by the time I identify all the trucks in the stupid tic tac toe security test ,it will probably reflect several others. Why don’t I just say #DITTO or #METOO? Ok, end of long winded ASIDE]

So many great “unique” answers - MONOPOLYMONEY, PEOPLEPLEASER, KOIPONDS, PALATECLEANSER, TIMELOOP, DRIESOUT, MAGICALREALISM and (my favorite, for some reason) UNCTUOUS! In a new NYTXW debut!!

Any time I break the 10 minute mark on a Friday suggests it’s a tad easy for that day. Nonetheless, an auspicious start for Kunal Nabar. Well done, sir!

Nancy 9:20 AM  

I can think of thousands of reasons to avoid the cesspool that is Twitter -- as I assiduously do -- that are far more egregious than the NYT having warned novice solvers off the Friday puzzle. But still I too am pretty turned off by the condescension and smugness involved in issuing such a warning. Good post, @Weezie!

I strongly suspect that Will Shortz never even saw this tweet, much less approved it. But if he did see it, I can only imagine him slamming several blistering and very angry forehands into the corner of the table tennis table in response. I pity his opponent.

jberg 9:21 AM  

This puzzle helped me finally understand what Rex means by 'flow' and 'swoop;' expressed beautifully today by @Lewis as well. I got MAGICAL REALISM from just the clue (I had the G, but hadn't noticed it) and PALATE CLEANSER from the PAL, and in each case it was a thrill.

I'm really curious about POLO on yaks, however. Is it like donkey baseball, which is fun precisely because it's awkward? Or are yaks actually easy to ride, so it's just another way to play polo?

The hardest part of the puzzle was thinking the musical family must be the OSMONDs, which doesn't fit. Second hardest was TIME warP before LOOP, but the crosses fixed that quickly. Third hardest part was mixing up Michelle WIE West with Kristen Wiig, and putting in WIi. Fourth hardest, which wasn't very hard, was wondering if you could really say that RYE was an "ingredient" in rye flour. But I guess you can ("it has only one ingredient") and of course there are multi-grain flours, as well.

@Weezie, genre fiction? One of those two won the Nobel Prize, and I think you could read either one without renouncing literary snobbery. For me, "genre" would mean Zane Grey, or crossword favorite Erle Stanley Gardner.

Fortunately, I no longer look at Twitter very much. Not proud of that, it's just what I do.

RooMonster 9:21 AM  

Hey All !
Well, my time ended up as being in the Easy realm, 27 mins, but it sure felt like it was tougher and took longer. Neat, but odd.

Noticed @M&A's Jaws of Themlessness in the NW corner, but no symmetrical conuterJaws. Then saw the Diagonal Symmetry. Aha, says I.

Had DEmS for DELS, and could not come off it, even though SEEMmY made no sense. My one-letter DNF.

When did Michelle WIE get married? Behind in my news (well, I don't watch the News, so that's probably why.) I'm hoping it wasn't KANYE she married...

Got MONOPOLYMONEY off just the first N, second M, second Y, so that's something. ANKA went in, but then came out, turned out correct. Had SeenRED for SNEERED, funny how the first four letters were correct, just in the wrong order. Had OPEN___, and couldn't get Golf or Tennis out of the ole brain. OPEN set? OPENish? OPEN hit? Har.

Oh, and NEWSdesk to NEWSROOM.

Alright, y'all, Friday. ROCK ON!

No F's (I'm AGHAST!)
RooMonster
DarrinV

MeJojo 9:24 AM  

Can someone explain why the answer to Parties is DOS?

jberg 9:25 AM  

@Nancy -- I missed your question yesterday, but @Beezeer pretty well summed up what my textbook had said.

Nancy 9:31 AM  

@andrew -- but you're in blue! You shouldn't have to solve a captcha at all. Never even once. You should just be able to hit "Publish your comment" -- and just like MAGICREALISM -- your comment will be published.

(There will probably be many other responses just like mine about to appear.)

Anonymous 9:33 AM  

Fine puzzle. Just curious what DOS means for Parties on30D? Is a party really a "DO"? Is it DOS as in two in Spanish? or is it some hairstyle thing?

RooMonster 9:36 AM  

@Andrew 9:11
Might be the 10th time someone has said this, however...
You are a blue name, you Do Not have to prove you aren't a robot. You just have to hit "Publish". No Captcha involved.

RooMonster Non-Robotic Guy

burtonkd 9:38 AM  

In either the big end-of-year games compendium in the NYT, or in the NYer games/puzzles issue, they publish a puzzle with 2 sets of clues. The "impossible" one leaves you thinking it is all obscure, foreign words you've never heard of, then the "easy" one is TV guide level fill in the blanks for the same grid. I can't imagine they would want to do that on a daily basis.

@andrew, I once complained about having to do the Captcha, and someone helpfully pointed out that since my name is in blue (as is yours), all you have to do is hit the "publish" button. Give it a try, and beat that dastardly take-stealing Lewis to the punch tomorrow:)

1/3 of the earth's surface is DESERT for now, rapidly expanding with climate change. I'm so used to the 2/3 being water figure, my autobot brain put in OCEANS, then read the clue more carefully.

At least it is not the editors telling people not to try. The comments on that Twitter thread are the usual combination of idiocy, attention seeking, and some genuine cleverness/creativity. One poster imagined the tweet in the style of Clippy the old MS Word "helper".

Anonymous 9:42 AM  

I’ll take an easy Friday with my coffee anytime.

burtonkd 9:47 AM  

late Ethan yesterday was hilarious with the correction to the earlier Rebus fail post: "I must have typed in SSH when I meant to type in SSH".

mathgent 9:48 AM  

Nice puzzle but sorta bland.

I was going to complain about PEOPLEPLEASER. Green paint, I thought. But I looked it up and it seems to be a well-established term. Why have I never heard it? FOMO.

andrew 9:53 AM  

What does “in blue” mean? Is it like INAREA? My insurance covers me?

Ok, here goes nothing…going to try PUBLISH without proving I’m not robotic…

(Though may miss doing the reCaptcha puzzle, which is always more challenging than the daily Mini!)

Whatsername 9:53 AM  
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous 9:54 AM  

Shouldn't 12A be clued as two words ? Greg

Whatsername 9:57 AM  

Really nice, smooth Friday. I certainly didn’t see anything easy starting out, but once I got into a rhythm it filled in without too much resistance. One of the best Friday debuts I can recall. So ROCK ON, Mr. Nabar. When it comes to constructing, I’m hoping you’ll KEEP IT UP and we’ll see you again soon.

LLANERO was NEW to ME. I’m thinking maybe that’s a combination of a cowboy and vaquero. I had my anchor sitting at a NEWS DESK at first but had to PASS on that when my DVD turned into a VCR. I think whoever decided MIC is a good way to say mike ought to be smacked with a boom. And RYE made me think fondly of @Z. I wonder how his Placebo & Tentacle Lounge is fairing.

Liveprof 9:58 AM  

RooMonster -- Since you asked -- Michelle Wie married Jonnie West, the Director of Basketball Operations for the Golden State Warriors, -- he is the son of legendary NBA player Jerry West. Wow. Stephen Curry attended the ceremony, but only gave them a blender as a wedding gift. (I made up the last part of that sentence: I'm sure he was quite generous.)

Wie and West have a gorgeous little girl named Makenna Kamalei Yoona West. She's two years old and dribbles (except when using a sippy cup).

BobL 10:01 AM  

Anchor's place = sea floor. Nope, news desk. Nope.

Caryn R 10:04 AM  

Completely agree with you Rex - how else are newer solvers supposed to learn if not by challenging themselves. Yesterday AND today's puzzles were terrific - cannot believe the Times would sell either short!

burtonkd 10:20 AM  

Another reason not to react to stuff on Twitter: here is the source from Deb Amien at Wordplay. It is specifically addressing the statistical drop-off of solvers for late week puzzles, then goes on to praise the quality of the puzzle itself.

"...but we see a considerable drop-off in solving after Wednesday.

But if you would like to challenge yourself by trying a late-week puzzle without feeling as if you’ve been set up to lose, here’s a subversive suggestion: Skip the Thursday puzzle and go right to Friday’s.

Yes, the clues will be harder, but the solving mojo required will feel much more familiar. You will still need to think laterally for the trickier clues, but at least you won’t have to write outside the grid or perform acts of origami on your puzzle.

I bring this up because today’s puzzle by Kunal Nabar is not only his New York Times Crossword debut, but also a really good example of the kind of grid that I think professed Monday-through-Wednesday solvers should try. It’s not terribly difficult, but there is a huge payoff in terms of lively entries and creative clues. More about that after the spoiler alert..."

Diane Joan 10:20 AM  

I’m not new at crosswords and I was feeling pretty good about my quicker solve today…UNTIL I saw the tweet in this blog! Oh well it still was a fun puzzle especially “magical realism”! So that’s what those amazing books are based on! I know a good book when I read it but I’m not up on the myriad types of genres. Nice way to start the weekend.

burtonkd 10:27 AM  

@andrew - you're golden, or blue as the case may be(web browser highlights names in blue).

@Whatsername, MIC vs MIKE does make me pause, and I'm pretty sure both are legit. However, since it is short for MICrophone, make sure that boom doesn't swing back around and thwack you.

Trina 10:28 AM  

MEJOJO - “DO’ is a slangy synonym for party - “there’s a big DO at the country club tonight…”

Gary Jugert 10:33 AM  

I'd been through the puzzle twice and had only a few wild stabs, so I looked up the capital of Eritrea since I wasn't sure where Eritrea is located, and I thought maybe we'd seen it in a puzzle recently, and also I enjoy looking through Google images of cities in the crosswords. Once ASMARA went in, the entire rest of the puzzle filled in quickly and easily. One cute town that's a bit over proud of the art deco Fiat building was the key to everything else. Once PEOPLE PLEASER went down I felt I could do no wrong.

I had great time putting it all together. Plenty of nice long answers without strained clues. Somebody obviously tried to make this right. Wheelhouse solve after a tragic start. We'll have some "too easy" comments today, but whatevs.

Paul ANKA is having a great run lately. He's touring America, well, old-people America, starting in October. Better get tickets now as the matinées will sell out fast. I didn't check the OSMOND website as I can only stand bemused ironic web surfing once per day.

"Apt cry" twice in a column. There are no apt cries, no "cries" at all outside of the overacting in Lord of the Rings. The only apt cry I know about is when you can't pay the rent so you cry in your apartment.

Uniclues:

1 The menu at Village Inn.
2 Dads' den dirty dramas.
3 That scene in every sci-fi where they remind themselves and the audience how messing with history can have disastrous effects.
4 The armory of lotions my wife buys.
5 Hawt rawk.
6 Caballero"s laptop screen.
7 What every old man is convinced the government did to them.
8 Our kitchen around 6 pm.

1 PLASTIC READ
2 MALES' PIT VCRS
3 TIME LOOP ASIDES (~)
4 UNCTUOUS RESINS
5 OPEN MIC TEMP
6 LLANERO RETINA
7 GMAN TAPED VETS
8 ANSWER NEWSROOM

andrew 10:40 AM  

Hey, it worked! And I take it “in blue” is my name is in blue - pre-authorized by my Google account? (Update: just confirmed by @BurtonKd) Not that I necessarily live in a blue state nor take the blue pill re The Matrix (though I typically do before sex)? Or as Tobias Funks, Arrested Development’s would be Blue Man Group understudy says about his preparation, “I Blue myself”…

Still see pictures of cats though. Wait - that’s in some of the Rex write ups! So all the time I’ve been clicking on his cats, I could have solved a year’s worth of daily Minis? (JK -that would have been a D’OH and I’m not yet that DUH! Getting there with each birthday, though).

And while I’m asking lingo questions, what is a Don Knotts? The greatest supporting character in Tv history (Barney Fife, not Mr. Furley) - how does he relate to NYTXW?

egsforbreakfast 10:47 AM  

I wonder if Rex also got the tweet I did from the NYT:

A tip for older solvers: The puzzles for the remainder of June and all of July are not really worth doing. You might want to try the New Yorker and/or the Washington Post. Even the Wall Street Journal would probably be better than doing some of the stinkers we’ve got coming.

Don’t perform on OPENMIC nights and expect to be paid the PRORATE.

What a sweet, smooth debut. Congrats and thanks, Kunal Nabar.

Anonymous 11:00 AM  

Nice answers but I mean yeah, absurdly easy. Not what I look forward to on Fridays

Joseph Michael 11:06 AM  

Apt cry of encouragement for Kunal Nabar: Keep constructing! From MONOPOLY MONEY to MAGIC REALISM, this was a Friday gem.

jae 11:08 AM  

Easy-medium. The East side was easier than the West where I struggled a bit in the SW...REALIty before ISM, play before SEND...

Lots of interesting/fun stuff plus diagonal symmetry, liked it a bunch or what @Rex said. A fine debut!

Beezer 11:13 AM  

I can only echo the praise that everyone has heaped on this puzzle! I confess when I first looked at the grid, I thought…”uh-oh”…but when I could plop in MAGICALREALISM I relaxed and it was “off to the races”! In fact, I think the ONLY incorrect initial answer was “take” instead of READ but crosses fixed that in a jiffy.

Haha @Andrew! To ME the only reason why I would create the “genuine” blogger identity is to get past reCaptcha! I will say that I can often go for days not having to check off crosswalks or bicycles!

@Weezie made some good points for newer solvers! I dunno. Before I knew I could do the NYT games subscription I only got “the paper” on Sunday and at that time only worked the Sunday puzzle. I remember being shocked…SHOCKED I tell you…when I found out that Sunday was NOT the hardest puzzle! At any rate, I had NO problem doing a “cheat” to get a toe-hold when I first started doing the Thursday, Friday, and Saturday puzzles on-line!

pabloinnh 11:40 AM  

Q:What's better than a puzzle with an OTTER?
A: A puzzle with OTTERS!

What a treat this was. I think the hardest answer to come up with was PRIOR, and upon reflection have decided that was because I had no letters in place. I'll continue to test this theory on future puzzles.

Hand up for all the long whooshes. Whee! LLANERO and TOI checked the Romance Language box and I only met one real stranger all day. How do you do, TYRESE?

I fear our long-running hootenanny is becoming an OPENMIC session with lots of solos replacing songs that everyone knows. This may be due to the simple fact that a younger crew has started showing up and knows songs that us more, um, seasoned performers are not as familiar with. I did a nice Peter Paul and Mary piece on Monday and one of these whippersnappers said, yeah, I've heard of them. I mean really.

@Andrew-I still remember the thrill of finally skipping right to posting. You never forget your first time, right?

What a great debut, KN. Kinda Nice doesn't begin to do it justice, and I'm looking for lots more like this. Thanks for all the fun.

GILL I. 11:44 AM  

Yes...it was easy for me. And yes....it was delightful.
I didn't want to whoosh through this; I wanted to enjoy each word I penned in.
I like to glance around after I get my 1A and my 1D. PRIOR POLO. Easy on the eye. I will keep to the left and see what I can do. Ah...MAGICAL REALISM. I know you well. Some of you grace my book shelves. And so I wander. My favorite: "Like Water For Chocolate." Laura Esquivel was able to weave fantasy into my thoughts... and I still have them.
PEOPLE PLEASER: another pause as I wondered if I might be that one person always giving people what they want. I do that with my grandkids. Is that bad?
And so it went...
After getting MONOPOLY MONEY and PALATE CLEANSER I went my ow way to look for other delights. I did. My favorite, and perhaps the hardest, was finally finishing up with an UNCTUOUS TIME LOOP.

And so the NYT wants to dumb down some Friday pleasures. Go ahead, if you can publish some gems like this one. I'm not new at this; it has taken me many moons to climb up to the primo Friday/Saturday puzzle. Fond memories of sitting under a tree at Central Park and working the Sunday. Pencil in my mouth wondering if the handsome chap sitting next to me on BART would know a baseball clue. Sitting in waiting rooms with nothing to do other than a puzzle....The list is endless. I hope new solvers never give up.
I've always been a VAQUERA but my favorite is being called "El Cowboy."

jb129 11:58 AM  

A great Friday puzzle. Monopoly money made me smile along with others :)

Anonymous 12:04 PM  

Agreed. And I think it’s a good idea to have a beginner-level set of clues for some of the trickier themeless puzzles. It took me about six months of concerted effort to get through the ‘barrier of entry’ with NYTXW crosswordese. I’m glad I put in the effort, but I also believe it shouldn’t require that much willpower. It should be fun! Let people step up to the challenge of a real Saturday when they’re ready for it.

Anonymous 12:07 PM  

MONOPOLY MONEY should have clued as two words - Play bills? - rather than one. Playbills are a specific thing having nothing to do with play money, even with the question mark.

Smith 12:09 PM  

@Andrew 9:11 You're blue... why is captcha still captcha-ing you?

But yes, had the same thought. When I'm over here @Rex hasn't posted by the time I do the puzzle, and then when we get back from our day you all have said it all!

Allison W 12:16 PM  

I lurk here regularly but am compelled to write today. As Rex said well, “show more respect for tough puzzles—and for the newer solvers who aspire to solve them.” I am a newer-ish solver. The most challenging days for me are Friday and Saturday. When I finish one of those days without help, I feel accomplished. That’s how I felt today. And then I opened the blog and saw the tweet. Gee, thanks, NYT for taking away that feeling of accomplishment. The fun of puzzles is figuring them out. If you make all of them easy, then what’s the point? Where does the sense of accomplishment come from? I don’t want a participation trophy. This really pisses me off as a newer solver.

ghostoflectricity 12:22 PM  

Tuesday level of difficulty on a Friday, long answers/low word count notwithstanding.

Joe Dipinto 12:23 PM  

The birds and bees
With all of their vast
Amorous past
Gaze at the human race aghast!


Oh that was last month, never mind.

My beefs with this puzzle are: a) it was too easy, and b) it contains two terms that I find annoying: PALATE CLEANSER and MAGICAL REALISM. I avoid "magical realism" stories like the plague. Actually PEOPLE PLEASER is pretty annoying too. So that's 3/4 of its marquee answers.

On the other hand it was fun to see ASMARA because I frequently guess Asmara when trying to pinpoint the Mystery Capital of the Day in the Globle: Capitals game.

Anoa Bob 12:37 PM  

Is this the new math? Today we learn from the New York Times crossword puzzle at 38 Across that "Roughly one-third of the earth's surface " is DESERT. And I just saw this from the U.S. Geological Survey: "About 71 percent of the Earth's surface is water-covered".

I'm AGHAST! That adds up to about 104%, which seems a tad high, even for new math.

Maybe it would have been more SEEMLY if the NYTXW clue had said "land mass" rather than "earth's surface".

Masked and Anonymous 12:39 PM  

Really liked the puzgrid's tilty symmetry. Different. Can't help wonder if this kinda symmetry makes it easier or harder for the constructioneer to fill his/her grid.
Anyhoo, any time and way a themeless puz can do somethin different, M&A is on board for the whole ride.

staff weeject pick: PSA. Kinda liked its rhymy clue.

some fave stuff: TIMELOOP [always enjoy schlocky stuff]. MONOPOLYMONEY [always luv board games]. UNCTUOUS [It scored all 3 of the puz's U's, just in the nick of time]. And agree with @Nancy, on admirin that there KEEPITUP clue.

No big problems with no-know answers. TYRESE was about the only item of total mystery.

Thanx for the fun and the token Jaw of Themelessness, Mr. Nabar dude. And congratz on a great debut.

Masked & Anonymo3Us


And here's why M&A knew 39-Down today:
**gruntz**

Camilita 12:39 PM  

@allison I know, I'm a newish solver too. I've been doing the Fridays in about 30 to 60 minutes on my own for about a year. My first year it took 1 to 2 hours. This took me 38 minutes, which is about typical for me. I didn't think it was Easy Easy , I got stuck in a few places, had to work my brain. Bottom west corner was hard . Came here, thought I'm definitely getting better at these and was proud of myself. But the perspective of a solver like Rex and people doing these 10 to 30 years is very different from the 2 to 3 year crowd.
Clues like HONED ASIDES GMAN STET went in pretty quickly, where I used to have no idea, and I'm sure older solvers take one millisecond for those answers to go in. It's all relative. My family thinks I'm a genius because I finish these without help. Compared to Rex, and some here, I'm a complete DOLT.

Anonymous 1:06 PM  

I’ve been solving theses NYT xwords for a long time. Whether a puzzle is easy, medium or hard depends on so many factors. I found this one very difficult. @Allison W shouldn’t feel bad. A lot of experienced people, I’m sure, found this puzzle difficult and we’re quite proud of solving it. Don’t pay much attention to the comments about how easy one is. I read the comments for laughs. Today someone said they avoided assiduously the “cesspool” of Twitter. How in the world do they know if it is a cesspool if they assiduously avoid it? Osmosis? I got a big kick outta that comment.

Michael R. 1:15 PM  

Has anyone mentioned a subtle, nice touch in the Friday puzzle? It is symmetrical along the diagonal axis from NW to SE. I don't think I've seen that too often.

David G 1:18 PM  

I'm a pre-pandemic solver (and reader). The fact is that post-pandemic, us OG crossword solvers are in the minority, and ensuring that the broader audience, which prefers more digestible fare, is more important than ever. They know us dedicated daily solvers aren't going away--why would they worry about us?

You can see it in the proliferation of mini-games like Wordle, Connections, Spelling Bee and Digits and the unceremonious axing of the Acrostic and Variety puzzles, which had run for literally decades.

You can see it in the striking number of angry comments on the NYT website on Ryan McCarty's puzzle from last Saturday, which was indeed tough, though quite gettable for a long-time solver. I loved getting the work in for once, personally.

I hope they'll keep publishing truly tough puzzles like last Saturday's. But the way things are going, I'm not holding my breath.

okanaganer 1:53 PM  

Amazing debut by Kunal! Yes those long answers really went in fast, starting with MONOPOLY MONEY. Never heard of MAGICAL REALISM but enjoyed learning it. Liked DESERT crossing DRIES OUT.

TIME LOOP movies are one of my favorite types; eg Looper and Live, Die, Repeat.

Typovers: KOI POOLS before PONDS, and hands up for NEWS DESK.

The first few paragraphs by @Lewis 8:06 am are some lovely writing.

[Spelling Bee: Thurs 0, took me AGES to get the pangram!]

Teedmn 2:35 PM  

I do associate Gabriel Garcia Marquez with MAGICAL REALISM but didn't know Murakami was also considered to be in that genre. I just read my first Murakami novel, "Killing Commendatore" and was charmed by its off-the-wall-ness. I will definitely try more of his works. Marquez, well I know this will probably get me labeled as an ignoramus, but I didn't finish "One Hundred Years of Solitude". I just couldn't get into the characters (I'm not into multi-generational sagas). Ah well, it's not the first highly regarded book I didn't like.

I had a typo DNF today, wrote in MONOPOPY MONEY and wondered why I had never heard of pLANEROS. D'oh.

I loved how UNCTUOUS filled in - with trepidation. I had UNCT in place and took out VETS because it just didn't look right but filled the rest in from the back and VETS got back in at 50D.

Congratulations, Kunal Nabar, on your NYT debut!

okanaganer 3:18 PM  

@Teedmn, I had the same experience with One Hundred Years of Solitude. Sometimes, no matter how renowned a book is, I just can't get through it for some reason. Ellroy's LA Confidential is another one.

Anonymous 3:31 PM  

vaquERO before LLANERO

Menidia 3:50 PM  

A STEM clue would have been nice.

Anonymous 4:15 PM  

Having been a Spanish Lit major as an undergraduate (oh, so many years ago) the magical realism was easy. Also played so many games of monopoly as a kid in the 1950s. Easy for a Friday. Expect tomorrow to be a real doozy!

Beezer 5:13 PM  

@burtonkd…thanks for putting in the full perspective of “the Tweet that rocked the world.” My guess is that Shortz et al get a lot of communications that aren’t in this blog. I will say that in the years I’ve worked crossword puzzles, it never occurred to me that anyone was “setting me up to fail.”

@Teedmn and @Okanaganer…hand up for NOT being able to “get through” One Hundred Years of Solitude.” Maybe Marquez was setting ME up to fail? And btw…I DO like Murakami, also. My first, was Kafka on the Shore.

And yes. @Allison W. Should NOT feel bad. Many times people on the blog throw the word “easy” around. I’ve learned it’s ALL relative and has to do with “experience” or being “outside your wheelhouse.” Some peeps don’t do well with certain types of clues and others “eat’em up.” @Rex mentioned the type of clues he has a hard time with (btw…I do too!). At any rate, when reading this blog, I’ve learned to take many comments with (as my Dad used to say) “a pinch of snuff”!

dgd 5:17 PM  

The usage is a bit old, but do can mean party. Another usage disappearing Amon the younger generations? Anyway it still shows up in the Times puzzle so it would pay to remember it

dgd 5:45 PM  

Mike is much older than mic It follows the same pattern as Michael to Mike. We even do it when the c is originally soft as in bicycle. As for MIC musicians started spelling it mic. The latter spelling migrated to the general population sometime in the last 50 years when I wasn’t looking and I had to learn the new spelling from crosswords I personally don’t like it but it’s dominant now. Anyway nothing odd about mike at all

Weezie 6:04 PM  

I agree with you that those folks don’t count as genre fiction! Sorry about that - to clarify, I meant that magical realism (and the authors I listed) gave me a fantastical fix *before* I let myself read true genre fiction (mostly fantasy and sci-fi, though my partner is a horror writer and voice actor, funnily enough).

Anonymous 6:20 PM  

I don’t get it either.

Anonymous 7:07 PM  

I feel like Rex and I have very different interests, but I'm glad to see we both felt joy after seeing the names Gabriel García Márquez and Haruki Murakami in today's grid.

Harry 8:40 PM  

Nifty puzzle, for all the reasons cited. It's quite a feat ... except for one thing: all of the short fill was practically of Mon/Tue difficulty. It's Friday!!

VETS could have easily been good for a pause; instead we get, "participants in a November parade"?? Maybe if there had been a 4 letter short form of "santas". INERT is frequently clued in a manner that sometimes requires the solver to "up" their perspective. Not this time ("Unmoving").

The only "short" I had to tussle with was the clue for RESINS. (Having resolved this one, I later was compelled to read up where frankincense and myrhh are sourced.)

We've seen a workweek of Easy/Medium. Fingers crossed that Saturday's puzzle keeps me engaged much longer!!

Jenny O 9:17 PM  

That tweet was maddening. I was able to complete Friday's puzzle without having to take breaks and come back to it later. Which usually does mean that all y'all would say it's on the easy side ... But still! Let me feel good about it! I'm still shocked when I can complete a puzzle with such long answers. (And I can do it by trying and failing harder for a long time ... And, of course, following this blog!)

Allison W 9:52 PM  

I want to clarify that no one on this blog has ever made me feel bad. It’s the NYT tweet that was insulting and made me angry. I think it is cool and inspiring how so many of you are so great at puzzles. It’s awesome. And I’ve learned a lot and improved by reading your remarks. This community is great.

Prof. Buddha 10:44 PM  

Dos does look weird. It’s the plural of “do” (as in, “My family threw a big do for my birthday”). The Google dictionary says it’s informal and chiefly British.

Prof. Buddha 10:46 PM  

noun
1.
INFORMAL•NORTH AMERICAN
short for hairdo.
2.
INFORMAL•BRITISH
a party or other social event.
"the soccer club Christmas do"

Anonymous 12:53 AM  

Time loop is a plot device, not a narrative device. 1/3 of earth's surface is desert only if you don't count water. Magical realism is a terrible genre.

Anonymous 6:57 PM  

Wince... I think they meant "...more than 7." since PH 7.0 is actually neutral not base. The plural "bases" also makes the clue misdirect even more awkward given the intrinsic error.

The puzzle seems to be losing the technical finess in recent years. There are more and more instances of "well if you say so NTYXW" ...like this one or the recent Vespa/Moped cock-up. I may be losing faith.

kitshef 1:13 PM  

Certainly not easy for me ... in the harder 10% of Fridays, I'd say. Having loGICAL REALISM and no idea on TYRESE were probably my biggest problems, but also did not know LLANERO. And thought a key might provide Access. And had no idea what the clue for HONED meant. So ... a lot of issues in the NE and therefore the long acrosses.

kitshef 1:15 PM  

Definitely not easy for me. On the contrary, in the harder 10% of Fridays. loGICAL REALISM was , it turned out, a bad guess. Couldn't figure out the clue for HONED, thought a key would provide Access, don't know TYRESE or LLANERO. So the NE and therefore the long accrosses were problems.

Anonymous 7:01 PM  

This was meant for Saturdays xword...

spacecraft 11:27 AM  

@anon 12:07: Agree the 12a clue should be two words, but I got it anyway from just the _ONOP-- segment.

In fact, this was my easiest Friday ever. Couldn't believe how fast the NW--and hence the SW and NE--filled in. Some of the SE central and SE corner took a tad longer. NEWSROOM and NEWS desk form a new kealoa; I waited for crosses on that one. I did have one writeover: was going too fast with 12d and wrote MAGICALREALIty. Yikes, that doesn't even make sense.

KEEPITUP, Kumal, ROCKON! Birdie.

Wordle par.

Anonymous 11:33 AM  

Easy? You’re kidding us Rex. This one was at least medium or even medium-challenging even for a Friday.The grid design is a bit unorthodox but the solve was quite enjoyable. Plenty of nice long answers. Pretty good for a debut.

Anonymous 2:06 PM  

@dgd 5:45pm:
The real reason it went from mike to mic was because recording devices kept getting smaller and smaller.

  © Free Blogger Templates Columnus by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP