A24 horror film in which Rory Kinnear plays multiple roles / FRI 11-15-24 / Unchanged when multiplied by itself, from the Latin for "same" and "power" / Activewear brand with a name inspired by flight / Teacups and pirate ships / Gets rid of, as the oldest item in a programming cache / Tech journalist Kara / Operating system with a penguin mascot named Tux

Friday, November 15, 2024

Constructor: Alina Abidi

Relative difficulty: Medium 


THEME: none 

Word of the Day: IDEMPOTENT (24D: Unchanged when multiplied by itself, from the Latin for "same" and "power") —

Idempotence (UK/ˌɪdɛmˈptəns/,US/ˈdəm-/) is the property of certain operations in mathematics and computer science whereby they can be applied multiple times without changing the result beyond the initial application. The concept of idempotence arises in a number of places in abstract algebra (in particular, in the theory of projectors and closure operators) and functional programming (in which it is connected to the property of referential transparency).

The term was introduced by American mathematician Benjamin Peirce in 1870 in the context of elements of algebras that remain invariant when raised to a positive integer power, and literally means "(the quality of having) the same power", from idem + potence (same + power). (wikipedia)

• • •

[the only IMAN I know]
I rated this "Medium" but technically I failed. For the first time in I can't remember how long, I finished the puzzle but did not get the "Congratulations" message. Usually when this happens, it's because I've left a typo somewhere and I have to track it down. But today ... nope, no typo. Error. Errors, actually. When I finally found said errors, it was so disheartening, because they happened on precisely the kind of answer that I'd complained about out loud while I was solving: "... so many names. Too many names." And sure enough, it was a name that got me, and the kind of name that's most likely to be outside my field of vision—namely, some actor in some Marvel movie. I had no way of knowing that name, so I relied on crosses, and that ... didn't work today. Because with the "T" in place, I looked at 31A: Amount often added (TIP) and without hesitation wrote in TAD. "Confirmed" this with DING, which I realize now is more of a microwave sound than an "Online notification sound," but in the moment, it seemed fine. And I never went back and checked the Marvel name because I didn't know the Marvel name anyway, so any combination of letters might've been right, for all I know. Somebody named AMAN? Shrug, why not? As I say, I was already thinking, midsolve, that the puzzle was leaning way, way too heavily into names. Also into extreme online-ness. Just name after name and online thing after online thing. Every damn square from TARTT over to IMAN is involved in a name—a 22-square formation that encompasses TARTT, SWISHER, CARL SAGAN, and IMAN, and that's in addition to ERMA / MARA, LUCE / GERTRUDE, and NIN / MEN. And the extreme computery online-ness extended from PING to SENT to EVICTS (43A: Gets rid of, as the oldest item in a programming cache) to LINUX to tech journalist SWISHER to RERUN (as clued) (28D: TV term that's becoming obsolete in the streaming era) to whatever the hell IDEMPOTENT is (it's a term from mathematics and computer programming; see "Word of the Day," above). So it's only (grimly) fitting that I got kneecapped at Marvel-actor-meets-online-notification-sound. A different clue on either TIP or PING and there's no problem. Oh well.


Some of the longer answers are nice. UP IN THE AIR / "DON'T TELL ME" is a solid little stack, and "YOU'RE NOT WRONG" and "I CAN SEE YOU" have a playful colloquial verve. Enjoyable. But too much of the marquee space was used on ho-hum stuff like TÊTE-À-TÊTES or on phrases that seem overly niche ("EVER HEARD OF IT?") or slightly off—the spelling on slangy phrases in crosswords often makes me cringe because it seems so improvised, a hybrid of formal and informal spelling choices. The phrase is RARIN' TO GO, as I've always heard it. It's not like anyone uses "raring" in formal contexts (or in any context where it isn't followed by "to go"). It's RARIN'. It's so RARIN' that RARIN' has appeared in the NYTXW 19 times! Now, RARING has also appeared, but ... I don't like it. The colloquial energy comes from the elision. RARING just seems stodgy. Then there's "I'VE GOTTA GO," ugh. First of all, two long "ending-in-GO" phrases in the same grid? Why? Just ... No. Second, spelling "I'VE GOTTA GO" was an adventure. The phrase that this answer wants to be is "I GOTTA GO." That's the tightest and most realistic version of that phrase. If you're changin' "got to" to one word (GOTTA), then you're definitely dropping that "apostrophe VE" in "I'VE." Because of I'VE, I assumed an slightly elevated formality to the phrasing, so wrote in GOT TO GO instead of GOTTA GO. Good thing I checked that cross (CAMI beats COMI, for sure) (36A: Simple pajama top, casually). As for "EVER HEARD OF IT?," I know this "facetious question" from precisely one place: The Office. It's Andy on The Office, every time he mentions that he went to Cornell. I mean ... I watched every ep of that show, so I don't hate remembering Andy, but the phrase doesn't resonate for me beyond that one example.



As with every clue that involves a contemporary actor name or a computer term or golf or some other crap I don't care about, I don't resent that the clue exists. Things exist that I don't know, same as it ever was. What I resent is the relentless return to one field. The same crap over and over. Changing a simple word like MEN to an A24 movie when you've already got two other proper names from contemporary movies (IMAN, MARA), why? I literally have no idea who "Rory Kinnear" is, so "in which Rory Kinnear plays multiple roles" did not help at all (19A: A24 horror film in which Rory Kinnear plays multiple roles). I have (vaguely) heard of the movie title MEN, thank god, because I had no idea if the cross was IRAN or IRAQ (3D: Country that uses the Jalali calendar rather than the Gregorian), and if I hadn't known the simple word MEN was the title, I can imagine a scenario where MEQ seems plausible. Why else would you clue the word in this weird proper noun way?, I might've reasoned. Must be some weird name or phrase I've never heard of. I mean, if MCQ can be a movie title (and it can), then why not MEQ!? Anyway, when a puzzle leans heavily and repeatedly into its own little cultural / generational pocket, that's what I don't like. Even when I live in that pocket, I don't love it. You shouldn't be able to feel the puzzle riding a particular hobby horse.


Notes:
  • 16A: Activewear brand with a name inspired by flight (AVIA) — I guess that makes sense. Half of the word "AVIAtion." I weirdly never made the connection. Who knows where brand names come from? Well, if you want to find out, turns out you can. Asics is an acronym of the Latin phrase anima sana in corpore sano (a variation on the better known Latin phrase mens sana in corpore sano). Hoka comes from a Maori phrase meaning "to fly." I could go on, but I don't want to.
  • 46A: Macy's or Wendy's, for instance? (HERS) — this was slightly cute. Looks like a retail establishment and fast food chain, but nope, just the possessive form of women's names.
  • 53D: Fan of the Bulldogs (ELI) — this clue is referring to Yale, EVER HEARD OF IT?
  • 45D: Hair raiser? (CLIP) — I wanted GLOP (like ... some kind of hair gel?) and FLIP (like ... when you "raise" your hair out of your face?) before the much simpler and more plausible CLIP.
  • 8D: Minuscule quantities (SOUPÇONS) — the problem with diacritics in English crosswords is that they're invisible—you can't write them in because they make a mockery of the cross. No cedille on the "C" in IÇEBOX! Anyway, without the cedille, SOUPCON looks like a convention sponsored by Progresso or a restaurant scene that got cut out of The Grifters.
See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]

27 comments:

Mark 5:56 AM  

I agree, there were lots of names and fuzzy colloquialisms and I didn’t enjoy the puzzle as much as I’d hoped because of them. I don’t even know what an A24 movie is, but I guess it’s something. I have another bone to pick with the puzzle too. I don’t think that the definition of idempotent was correct. I didn’t know the word and looked it up. All the definitions refer to functions operating on themselves. But the actual puzzle definition in the puzzle says multiplied by itself, which is not the same. Maybe some mathematician reader who knows more about idempotency than I do can comment.

Anonymous 6:05 AM  

Surprisingly (given Rex’s review), this was the easiest Friday for me in a very long time. Everything just fell into place, even the long answers.

Conrad 6:17 AM  


Challenging for me. Liked it even less than OFL did. The south put up somewhat less resistance than the north.

Overwrites:
INSIGne(?) before INSIGHT at 5D
@Rex I'VE GOT To GO before GOTTA (10D) made CAMI (36A) hard to see
aero before AVIA at 16A
TsP before TIP at 31A, because you often add a teaspoon of something to a recipe
oahU before PERU at 56A (my first choice for a four-letter place name ending in U)

WOEs:
The memoir WILD at 9A
The film MEN at 19A (and while we're at it, I didn't understand the significance of "A24" in the clue)
IDEMPOTENT at 24D (would've been easy if I'd known the Latin words for "same" and "power")
ERMA Franklin at 25D
IMAN Vellani at 32D
OISEAU at 41D (no French scholar I)

Anonymous 6:28 AM  

Really terrible puzzle—names, names and names which I can only speculate were intended to make the puzzle harder. I guess the editor simply phoned in a Wednesday puzzle and added names to make it worthy of a Friday. I guess some of the long answers were passable. But other than that I can not write a single positive thing about what turned into a slog.

Burghman 6:40 AM  

Same thoughts as Rex… 32D to 42D (8 clues) was 6 names (and Shakespeare!) and 1 French word. Names are gonna be there, but that’s a pretty dense section of name clues.

Eric NC 6:41 AM  

A24 is a movie studio known for its horror movies

Rick Sacra 6:54 AM  

Thanks, @rex, that makes me feel better. Definitely very difficult for me--had to google the birthplace of Mr. Alarcon. That french word was a complete WOE. And then I got deceived at the Tad for TIP corner and also Naticked at the ERtA/tARA cross! So multiple mess-ups for me today. too many names.... Oh well. DNF, first time in a while.

Wanderlust 6:58 AM  

Also fell in the Tad trap and had to come here to find out what I had wrong. Grrr…

Ann Howell 7:13 AM  

Same here! Despite not knowing quite a few of the names, the crosses made everything click.That's two days in a row that I've had a completely opposite solve than Rex (I found yesterday's excruciating...)!

Anonymous 7:14 AM  

Why would you put IMAN in your puzzle when OMAN is right there?! Insane choice.

Anonymous 7:17 AM  

I had TAD and TSP in that horrible corner, TIP never crossed my mind.

kitshef 7:18 AM  

raring to GO/ive gotta GO
Ive gotta go/I can see you
i can see YOU/YOUre not wrong

Early voting is most often not by mail - that's absentee voting. I usually vote early, but almost never by mail.

The clue for 41D seems like the answer should be "un oiseau".

EXT. I guess is 'exterior'?

WoEs: ERMA, IDEMPOTENT, SWISHER, whatever the hell an A24 film is. Wish it was a WoE: TARTT (The Goldfinch is the worst book I've read in the past ten years).

A very unpleasant and poorly edited puzzle. That clue for MEN is an absolutely perfect example of what never to do - clue a common word with a tricky cross via an obscure piece of PPP. See also WILD.

Anonymous 7:18 AM  

Hi Rex, I read this blog most days after finishing the puzzle (If.. I finish the puzzle). I just started solving in the last couple years and I am getting to the point where I can finish most Saturdays, eventually.
I was wondering why you don't (and if you could) publish your solving times as some of your contributors do? I'd love to be able to compare myself to such a stalwart of the puzzle community.

Anonymous 7:19 AM  

In my vernacular a “deal sealer” is an element of the deal that makes it compelling (”throwing in a signing bonus sealed the deal”) while a CLOSER is the person brought in to close the deal.

Anonymous 7:30 AM  

Had the same trouble spot as Rex, having no clue about Ms. Marvel, but my “amount often added” was TsP (thinking recipes) so I was able to spot the error when sMAN made no sense.

Anonymous 7:34 AM  

Yes, if only they’d clued it better I’d have surely gotten idempotrentic or whatever it was.

Anonymous 7:38 AM  

The word IDEMPOTENT comes from multiplication (as the clue says, Latin for "same" and "power", and repeated multiplications are powers), but it can apply to more complicated mathematical operations, such as composition of functions.

It's not that interesting of a concept with normal multiplication because the only idempotent real numbers are 0 and 1. If your operation is, say, to multiply and then take only the last digit of the result (the fancy word for that is multiplication modulo 10) then you get other idempotent numbers (5 and 6).

Anonymous 7:46 AM  

my tad tip trap was baited with tsp. rough spot for sure.

mmorgan 7:47 AM  

Yeah, lots of (unknown) names and weird terms, but for some reason I found this super-easy and got through it quickly and unscathed. I guess it helped to see TIP right away and not fall into the traps that tripped up Rex.

Anonymous 7:49 AM  

I needed almost all the crosses for "Gets rid of, as the oldest item in a programming cache" and was surprised to get EVICTS. Technical language changes over time---I have a B.S. and a Ph.D. in computer science (from a few decades ago) and I'd never heard of cache eviction before today.

Dr.A 7:58 AM  

Same. i guess you either know some of the “proper nouns” or you don’t. Usually I don’t. Today I knew enough to get by!

Lewis 8:01 AM  

The conversational phrases were my favorite part of the puzzle. They made it feel comfy. And, it turns out, they gave it pop, as four of them – EVER HEARD OF IT, I CAN SEE YOU, I’VE GOTTA GO, and YOU’RE NOT WRONG, have never appeared in the NYT crossword before. It’s sweet when just one chatty debut appears in a grid, but four? Alina has a talent for this.

A pair of happy PINGs were triggered by answers.
• When I filled in ICE BOX, I instantly flashed on my great-grandma Ethel, who never said “refrigerator”; it was always ICEBOX. I adored Grandma Ethel, so my heart melted when this answer showed up.
• IDEMPOTENT drew out another mathy word that has slumbered in my memory for decades – “asymptote” – a word that made me smile when I met it in high school because it looked and sounded cool, and it made me smile again today.

Lovely PuzzPair© in OISEAU and UP IN THE AIR. I also liked seeing the mini-word-ladder of LACE / LUCE / LUTE.

So, coziness, warmth and pleasure abounded in the box today, and I’m filled with gratitude for this puzzle of yours, Alina. Thank you!

Sam 8:02 AM  

More challenging for me than a typical Friday. TSP before TIP. Agree, lots of names.

Anonymous 8:07 AM  

Fed up, fed up, fed up with names. I want a crossword, not a trivia contest where you can just look up the answers. Please someone pass it on to NYT, there are enough of us who feel the same.

Anonymous 8:21 AM  

To add to what the previous anon said: within mathematics, composition of functions from a space to itself *is* a way of multiplying them. This is what motivates the definition of matrix multiplication, for example. The clue is correct.

Ted 8:22 AM  

As a software developer, IDEMPOTENT to me is used mainly to refer to things like database scripts, where the script might be run once or might be RERUN multiple times during testing/deployment but we don't want to end up with different results after running it twice or three times.

But, also as a software developer, I've never used EVICTS in that context, and I didn't know Kara SWISHER.

ncmathsadist 8:34 AM  

This was a real name bomb. I'm a mathematician; I liked IDEMPOTENT.

  © Free Blogger Templates Columnus by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP