Features of gathering clouds? / THU 10-1-26 / Sneaker brand whose logo features the "Formstrip" / Migratory fish with exceptionally sensitive hearing / Patriotic recitation since 1892 / Obsolescent credit card feature / Term of affection in the U.K.

Thursday, October 1, 2026

Constructor: Jill Singer

Relative difficulty: Easy

THEME: STUMBLING BLOCKS (55A: Obstacles ... or a hint to three squares in this puzzle) — a rebus puzzle with three "stumbling blocks" (i.e. squares containing synonyms for "stumble"):

Theme answers:
  • PLEDGE O[F ALL]EGIANCE (17A: Patriotic recitation since 1892) / BE[FALL] (7D: Happen to)
  • PAY[S LIP] SERVICE (27A: Expresses support without meaning it) / [SLIP]-ONS (28D: Moccasins and loafers, e.g.)
  • MAGNETIC S[TRIP]E (44A: Obsolescent credit card feature) / ACID [TRIP]S (32D: Hallucinatory experiences)

Word of the Day: PAIUTE (9D: Great Basin tribe) —

Paiute (/ˈpaɪjuːt/; also Piute) refers to three non-contiguous groups of Indigenous peoples of the Great Basin. Although their languages are related within the Numic group of Uto-Aztecan languages, these three languages do not form a single subgroup and they are no more closely related to each than they are to the Central Numic languages (Timbisha, Shoshoni, and Comanche) which are spoken between them.

The term "Paiute" does not refer to a single, unique, unified group of Great Basin tribes, but is a historical label comprising:

• • •

This was excellent. Too easy, for sure, but the theme is very clever and perfectly executed. It's almost too neat, too on-the-nose. STUMBLING BLOCKS ... blocks meaning "stumble" ... that's it, that's the theme! But its elegant simplicity is the key to its charm. It's just so nice to see someone hit on a good theme concept and then absolutely stick the landing. All three of the "stumbling blocks" are neatly tucked away inside totally solid, believable, even colorful phrases, and because there are just three of them, the grid has room to breathe. Yes, it's a little heavy on the 3-4-5s, which makes for a lot of common answers, but those answers never get really ugly or tiresome, and there are lots of vibrant 6s and 7s to keep things interesting (CHISEL STABBED ENIGMA MUMBAI ZAPATA DRUM KIT etc.). The whole thing is just so ... clean. "Crafted," I think, is the word I'm looking for. Or maybe "polished." Feels like someone took the time to make sure that theme and fill were both as smooth as possible. Yes, I personally would've preferred a harder puzzle, but I still really appreciate how well-built this puzzle is.


Moving through this one felt like a circuitous stroll through a park or garden. I could tell it was going to be on the easy side early on, so I decided to just ... meander, rather than rush to the finish. I went where the fill took me, which meant I got the top and the bottom before I had much of anything in between. Got the rebus trick pretty quickly...


... and then just kind of ... stumbled to the bottom of the grid. Like falling down a southwest-running staircase, though a little more controlled ... 


And then from there, the revealer came pretty quickly, which both allowed me to appreciate why "FALL" was in its own block up top (not a seasonal puzzle, it turns out!) and gave me some idea of what I needed to look for with the remaining two themers. I was so happy when the next rebus square that turned up was not also "FALL"—I was half-dreading I'd get three "FALL"s, which would've been ... less impressive. But no, I got a TRIP and a SLIP, making a perfect stumbling triumvirate. I was gonna say that I was glad the constructor didn't try to force in a fourth block, but I'm not sure what that block could plausibly be. "FALL" "SLIP" "TRIP" (in order) are the top three synonyms Merriam-Webster dot com gives for "stumble," and none of the other offerings on their list would work nearly as well. So, yet another thing in this puzzle's favor—it included all the plausible "blocks" and didn't try to force a clunker.

[synonyms for "stumble"]

No difficulty to speak of today. I had NIKE, of course, at 1A: Sneaker brand whose logo features the "Formstrip" (PUMA), even though I knew (or thought I knew) that their logo was the Swoosh. I considered PUMA, but in my head, all I could see, logo-wise, was the leaping PUMA. I forgot about the stripey thing on the shoes:


But the "N" from NIKE wasn't working with 1D: Doc seen for an annual checkup (PCP). I still can't quite get used to PCP as an abbrev. for "primary-care physician." You'll always be a drug to me, PCP. But once I got the "U" from URL (2D: Address letters), I gave into PUMA (and PCP), and then everything was much easier from there on out. The only green ink on my puzzle print-out is on the ACID part of ACID [TRIP]S—I wrote DRUG there at first. Easily fixed.


Bullets:
  • 16A: Features of gathering clouds? (AEIOU) — those vowels appear, in order, in the phrase "gathering clouds" (with no repetitions); I like that this answer crosses the Old MacDonald answer (11D: Cry heard by Old MacDonald = OINK). You know, because "Old MacDonald had a farm / A-E-I-O-U..."
  • 65A: The Black Knights of the N.C.A.A. (ARMY) — I never think about their mascot as they are not serious contenders in any of the major college sports. I saw "Black Knights" and my mind went to Vegas, why? Is that their ... hockey team? Ah, close—those are the Golden Knights. Ice hockey in Vegas still seems preposterous to me, but that's probably because when I was growing up, almost all the teams were in real cold-weather places. Los Angeles was the outlier. Here are the team locations for the 1980-81 season (when I'd've been in sixth grade):
[L.A. = only location here where it never snows]
  • 31D: Writer Gay (TALESE) — fun fact: TALESE and ROXANE have the same number of letters
  • 41D: French composer who refused the Legion of Honour in 1920 (RAVEL) — been listening to him a lot. Posted this just two days ago:
 
  • 64A: Migratory fish with exceptionally sensitive hearing (SHAD) — lol the idea that I know anything about fish hearing. Did they give them hearing tests? That must've been fun. Do SHAD like RAVEL? Play this for the SHAD in your life and see!

That's all for today. See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

P.S. gah, I almost forgot my best mistake, the one that (briefly) made me So Mad at this puzzle. I had the GRA- solidly in place at 19D: Words that might come before a meal, and, well ... this happened:

  

The indignation. "GRAB A!?!?!!? That's your fill!? That's the worst partial I've ever seen. 'GRAB A meal!?' The clue's not even worded correctly: if you put GRAB A before 'a meal' you've got 'GRAB A a meal,' which is nonsense. How in the world..." etc. In my defense, the clue did say "words," plural. And it said they "might come" before a meal, not that they were "said" (which would've got me to GRACE easily). Sigh. OK, I'm off to GRAB A coffee now. Bye.

[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️: 
  • Venmo (@MichaelDavidSharp)]
=============================
✏️Upcoming Crossword Tournaments✏️:
=============================
📘 My other blog 📘:

30 comments:

Anonymous 6:16 AM  

I must be sleep-deprived because this was a challenge. I don’t remember ever seeing PAIUTE in a puzzle and getting the STUMBLING BLOCKS correctly inserted was hard.

Conrad 6:18 AM  


Super Easy. I got the first rebus at 7D, BE[FALL], and didn't read the across clues for any of them. Liked it a lot less than @Rex did, mainly because it was too easy for a Thursday. And I don't like rebus puzzles generally.
* * _ _ _

Overwrites:
I don't know what a "Formstrip" is so my 1A sneaker brand was nike before it was aviA before it was PUMA.
I thought woodpecker food was a grub, but I had too much of SUET in place before I saw the clue (13D).

WOEs:
The PAIUTE tribe of the Great Basin and 9D.
Couldn't recall "Queen of Salsa" CELIA Cruz (39A).

Anonymous 6:23 AM  

Ate over? 5D

Rick Sacra 6:23 AM  

Enjoyed this one too.... 3 different rebus words, connected by meaning, in asymmetrical unpredictable spots..... nice! Couldn't figure out what the PL.... was going to be (I spelled PAyUTE with a Y and so it just wasn't looking right...) but I finally got it at SLIPONS and SLIPSERVICE.... CHISEL took me a long time to see today. I guess I was thinking of clay, pliable material sculpting, not rock. I still wind up swiping cards...especially my FSA card since it doesn't have a chip. So I guess I don't think of those MAGNETICSTRIPES as obsolete. SB to the rescue today for TUTTI! Thanks, Jill, this was great fun!!!! : )

Anonymous 6:40 AM  

I was surprised @Rex didn't mention that TRIP doesn't break across two words the way FALL and SLIP do, and that we saw a GAIA variant (GAEA) earlier this week. But I enjoyed the puzzle almost as much as OFL. I, too, thought it would be seasonal but then got SLIP and realized what was going on. I didn't get the revealer until I already had two of the themes and I found it medium rather than easy, but it was an enjoyable puzzle nonetheless.

Anonymous 6:54 AM  

I got Naticked on the CELIA and TALESE cross.

Both more obscure to me than the actual town of Natick. But you can blame growing up outside of Boston for that one.

Anonymous 6:58 AM  

My stumbling block was the SW corner. Never heard of Ravel or Lumet. I am not a music person so I did not know Tutti either.

Christopher 6:59 AM  

Given all day I would have never pulled LUMET out of my ass. Same with RAVEL. And LUV. And whether 41 across was RNA or DNA was, as often is true even with a scientifically correct cluing, ultimately just the toss of a coin..

This was mostly very easy. but that knot of junk trivia described above really sucked all the fun out of the room, and I had to cheat to finish. Blech.

Dr Random 7:04 AM  

After TRIPping up on GAEA earlier this week, I entered that first for GAIA today, and that error stayed until the end since I didn’t know KIM Possible. Another STUMBLING BLOCK was not knowing RAVEL, which made the crossing with RNA a coin toss with DNA, and combining that with not knowing LUMET made LUV hard to see. But all told, this was a lovely Thursday. I enjoy a good rebus, and as Rex avers, this one was indeed good.

Son Volt 7:06 AM  

Fun - liked the trick but it could have used another themer. The spanning revealer is fantastic. PAYS LIP SERVICE is the standout.

Elizabeth COOK

Overall fill was fine - agree with the big guy that it trended more early week but no complaints here. Read TALESE’s book on the Verrazano last winter. Another LUMET sighting so soon? The OPUSES - ZAPATA stack is wonderful.

ENIGMA

Enjoyable Thursday morning solve. Now - on to Tampa.

The Saddest Story Ever Told

Anonymous 7:06 AM  

I loved the Great Brain book series when I was a kid, so PAIUTE was a gimme.

Anonymous 7:10 AM  

Magnetic sTRIPe
Acid TRIPs

Lewis 7:22 AM  

This theme has never been done before (I’ve checked), and it’s so perfect – stumbles in blocks – so crossword iconic, you’d think someone would have come up with it before. But no, and high credit to Jill for seeing it first.

But then it had to be brought to fruition, and this was done masterfully.

It’s a tight theme – there aren’t many good synonyms for “stumble” that are short enough for rebuses.

Then you have to find phrases to embed them in, where these three words don’t have their “stumble” meaning. FALL, for instance, doesn’t mean “stumble” in PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE.

Jill not only found them, but they are colorful, and with letter counts that fit grid symmetry. It's uber-tough to make that happen.

And here’s the kicker. Those three non-revealer theme answers bring sweet freshness to the box. All of them are Times debut answers!

So, wow, Jill. This was a gem of a theme in concept and execution, and its beauty beautified my day. Thank you!

Lewis 7:23 AM  

[You won't get dirty growing plants this way]




HY(DROP)ONICS

Glen Laker 7:25 AM  

Agree. I was surprised Rex didn’t downgrade the rating for that. Maybe he’s getting soft in his 3rd decade

kitshef 7:25 AM  

Really good puzzle. It does give the trick away too early, as PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE is such a gimme, but remained very entertaining. Well, you have to ignore ATEOVER, but the rest was entertaining.

Anonymous 7:26 AM  

Not usually a “how do you not know…?” person but three people so far have said they’ve never heard of RAVEL and Im sincerely stunned. One of the most famous composers of the 20c. “Bolero” alone for gods sake. SMH. And ok fine if you don’t know him but Calling him “junk trivia” makes you sound like an idiot.

Anonymous 7:27 AM  

Same! And got tripped up by MERC for a few minutes (live in the DC area and was thinking MARC like the train system). Once I figured that out, had to letter run to get the music. Did not love it as much as Rex for that reason.

Anonymous 7:32 AM  

Breaking across words is not important for rebuses. Circled-square stuff, sure, but the breaking issue has never been important for rebus squares. Those squares involve (by necessity) very short words that have to work in both directions. Whether they break across words is not that important.

Anonymous 7:34 AM  

Only an “L” can go in that square. Nothing else is plausible for CE-IA. Not a Natick.

Twangster 7:41 AM  

Missed opportunity to post the classic soul blues tune "Slipped, Tripped and Fell in Love."

Sam 7:45 AM  

Very easy but TALESE/CELIA/MERC was a little Natick-y for me. I inferred the E and the L from C__IA, but I wasn’t familiar with any of the three answers. Just gotta learn more things, I guess.

Anonymous 7:52 AM  

Thanks for the "GRAB A" rant at the end; that gave me a good chuckle.

Lynn 7:54 AM  

When I was in 6th grade the NHL was Bruins, Rangers, Red Wings, Black Hawks, Maple Leafs, and Canadiens. That's it. 6 teams. It stayed that way until I was in college, 1967. Now, 16 teams make the playoffs. ( 1/2 of the league-ridiculous)

Anonymous 8:07 AM  

Agree with this being a Natick. Feel like with a foreign name a bunch of letters are plausible for CE-IA. Why not N or R?

Andy Freude 8:08 AM  

I agree, Anonymous. Personally, I save my idiotic rants for names of athletes, TV personalities, and TikTok influencers.

Things I know = Things everyone should know
Things I don’t know = Junk trivia

David Grenier 8:11 AM  

Not blaming you for not knowing Sidney LUMET, but want to put a plug for having a LUMET marathon sometime. The guy is one of the greatest American filmmakers. Dog Day Afternoon, 12 Angry Men, Serpico, Network…… so many great films.

Anonymous 8:13 AM  

LOVED this puzzle! Clever clues….

David Grenier 8:15 AM  

I liked this one. I feel like it’s been a while since we’ve had a good rebus puzzle (or at least since I have… life has been chaos and I haven’t confidently made time for the NYTXW). Simple straightforward concept. Could tell which across answers would be themers but still had to work out where the rebus would be.

Like others I got killed on some of the names and trivia. The entire NE was a no-go for me between PAIUTE, SUET (which I only know as a hog call) and the vowels that I didn’t understand till I saw the explanation here.

Anonymous 8:18 AM  

Celia is a name. Ceria? Cenia?? My computer won’t even let me type those. Keeps “correcting” me to CELIA. (or Xenia haha)

  © Free Blogger Templates Columnus by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP