Woman in dire need? / SAT 9-14-24 / Puppy chow ingredient / Trying way too hard, in modern slang / Apollo was conceived in them / Sister label of Volt Records / Baseball mascot with fluffy green snout / Highly rated French vineyards

Saturday, September 14, 2024

Constructor: Christina Iverson

Relative difficulty: Medium


THEME: none 

Word of the Day: Puppy chow (51D: Puppy chow ingredient => CHEX) —
Puppy chow
, also known as monkey munchmuddy buddiesmuddy munchreindeer chow, or doggy bag, is the name for a homemade candy made in the United States, primarily in the Midwestern States. The recipe's name and ingredients can differ depending on the version, but most recipes will typically include cereal, melted chocolate, peanut butter (or other nut butters), and powdered sugar. Nut free versions can be made using nut butter alternatives, like Notnuts or sun butter. Corn, wheat, or rice cereal can be used, usually Chex and/or Crispix. The true origins of the candy are not known.
• • •

Considered making this whole write-up just a list of bullet points, since seemingly every clue is, well, SO EXTRA (12D: Trying way too hard, in modern slang). Feels like lots of things might need explaining today. We'll see. In what feels like a late-week trend for me lately, I totally washed out in the NW at first pass. Yes, ESSO, I got that, but otherwise, zilch. I was thinking of the Phillie PHANATIC when I read the mascot clue, but I've only ever heard him (him?) referred to by his whole name, and anyway didn't really know that you spelled it in that phunny way. ASHAMED seems obvious in retrospect (1A: Red in the face, say), but after BLUSHED (?), I had no ideas. Abandon ship. Finally got traction with FIR FISTS IDAHO IDES STAX, and you'd think that "X" would've sent me flying out of that corner, but no, "modern slang" (unsurprisingly) held me up. There's just so damn much of it, and it keeps changing, and I'm really hoping that millennials and even Gen Z are beginning, now and then, to feel that feeling of "wait, the kids are saying what now?" because it's a special feeling. Pfft. I've actually heard "SO EXTRA" plenty, I think, but I wasn't sure exactly how "modern" we were talking and I took one look at that clue (12D: Trying way too hard, in modern lingo) and was like "SO-X---? The clue says 'Trying,' so ... Something-ING? SOXXING? Are people SOXXING now?" 


Might've busted out of the NE more easily except I got fooled by the (unexpectedly) cryptic clue on RENEE (18A: Woman in dire need?) (i.e. the woman's name found inside the phrase "dire need"). The "?" had me wondering where the wordplay was in "dire" or "need," but there's no play, or no play related to word meaning. Just consecutive letters. So I had to work for that first corner, but I got through, and then (finally) was able to throw WINDOW WASHER into the middle of the grid (27A: Job that anyone could see themselves doing?), and then a couple longer answers off of that, and so that awful feeling of "am I even gonna be able to do this?" (which I often feel on Saturdays, actually) went away, or abated, at any rate (even if you're making good progress on a late-week puzzle, you never know when some corner, some cross, is gonna leap out and bite you)

[I like that YODELERS is coming down from on high ... like a yodel (34D: Some long-distance callers)]

The only Weaving I know in the world of acting (or anywhere) is Hugo Weaving, so SAMARA was a ??? but she weirdly posed very little problem. Had her as SAHARA for a hot second, but SMALL CRAFT eventually took care of that (29D: Kind of boat affected by a wind advisory). As pop culture clues go, SAMARA was not nearly as brutal as LOTTA Sea Lice, a 2017 album that was on a lot of "Best of" lists that year but still, yikes. I say "yikes" as someone who has actually heard of the album, someone who has listened to Courtney Barnett (if not Kurt Vile) a great deal. I'm 100% certain that a huge chunk of you won't recognize even the names of the artists, let alone the name of the album. Its chart success was extremely modest (51 on the US album chart), so if you're not an indie rock fan, I feel for you today. The crosses all seem fair, so there's that.


Anyway, after escaping the NE and getting into the middle of the grid, there were no terrible trouble spots, just a steady Saturday struggle. Backed into the NW—the -THS got me POLYMATHS—and made pretty short work of it. The SW was a little tougher. I actually blanked on FINCHES, though that's really a gimme, or should've been (36D: "To Kill a Mockingbird" family). I could picture the "family" but the only name coming to me was "Scout." Anyway, easy with a few crosses, but the FITS part of FITS IN, not easy (36A: Doesn't stick out). ART STUDIO, not easy (30D: Setting for a sitting)—I had ART SCHOOL! Then there was "CHUG!" which I (of course?) had as "TOGA!" (showing my age, I s'pose) (48A: When repeated, college party chant). So there was futzing to be done in there, but nothing too hard. Finished in the SE ... sadly, I finished with CHEX, which I didn't understand at all. In the end, I reasoned that there must be some kind of snack called "puppy chow" made with CHEX that I'd just never heard of ... and I was right (see Word of the Day, above). Supposedly a midwestern thing. I lived in the "midwest" for the better part of a decade, never heard of it. There are many midwests, you learn, if you live long enough.


Bullets:
  • 1D: Gala, e.g. (APPLE) — obviously a very vague clue, so I needed help from crosses. But even after I got it, I thought Gala was an Apple product, like the iPad... then I remembered no, it's an honest-to-god edible apple variety.
  • 59A: Apollo was conceived in them (SIXTIES) — needs the "the," but OK. "Apollo" here is the space program.
  • 4D: Where the average American lives (ANYTOWN, USA) — Because PEORIA, IL wouldn't fit.


  • 5D: Word with the same meaning in English, Swahili and Mandarin, among other languages (MAMA) — interesting, but the clue was initially no help at all. 
  • 42A: It once ran the headline "Santa Dies on Xmas Trip": Abbr. (NYT) — I don't get it. Like, I don't get the joke or reference or anything. I guess it's funny but ... why? Is this a known headline? I guess they wanted to make it sound (kinda?) like The Onion, so you wouldn't immediately think "oh, you're talking about yourself, good one, NYT." [Looks up headline] ... Oh. Oh wow. You are not prepared, I promise you, for how maudlin or mawkish or one of those "m"-words this story is—from the front page of the Christmas Day edition, 1913 ... I give you this apparently legendary story about a dude w/ TB who died doing cosplay for the neighbor boy:

Annnnnyway, Merry Christmas, everybody! See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]

85 comments:

Conrad 6:02 AM  


Medium for a Saturday. I had trouble pulling some sections (e.g., the NW) together but there were parts where I whooshed.

Overwrites:
okay before MAMA at 5D
idle before SLOW at 17D
@Rex toga before CHUG at 48A

WOEs:
In my high school we called 7D skip DAY, not DITCH DAY.
SO EXTRA at 12D. Who can keep track of our "fellow youth"?
19A LOTTA Sea Lice
SAMARA Weaving (and the movie Babylon) at 31A

I got 18A RENEE from crosses but didn't understand how it fit the clue until I came here.

Anonymous 6:28 AM  

I had - - O - followed by a whole lotta nothing for [soda fountain purchase] and confidently wrote in ROOT BEER FLOAT. It fit! I was so proud of myself. Had never gotten a grid spanning long one like that with virtually no crosses! But no… I never thought a CHOCOLATE MALT would be disappointing, but I guess I was in the mood for a float today.

Ride the Reading 6:38 AM  

Felt like a proper Saturday from a decade ago, at least in terms of how long it took me to finish. Things I didn’t know, or had multiple possible answers, slowed me down. Laugh if you will - had deities before SIXTIES at 59A. Choler before ANNEAL at 30A. Had ____FORT at 57A but couldn’t suss the front half.

As happened Friday, finally got traction in the south - the southeast, in particular, even with wrong or missing parts of two of the words mentioned above.

Unknown names - Laa-laa. Samara. Lotta, as clued. Oh, and a gripe about a Mini clue, 12A - the answer for bowling is a failure of sorts, not a feat. Converting or picking it up might be a feat.

Anonymous 6:52 AM  

I was surprised that the clue for 42 across has “Santa” in it and the answer to 10 down is “Santa Hats.” I thought there was some tacit constructor rule that this type of repeating a key word is not to be done because it obliquely offers help to solvers.

P. U. Litzer 6:53 AM  

The Santa headline from 1913 would fit perfectly among all the clickbait headlines that comprise the digital version of the New York Times in 2024.

Phil 6:53 AM  

Had the same dire experience as Rex at NW corner and wondering it it will be bad as it was going. Glad he explained RENEE. Sorry to say didn’t know the word POLYMATH, now i do but last square had to run the alphabet again sorry to say. MA?A. thought maybe MAIA, hoping it was not MAGA yikes. Anyway had to do a lot of skipping to progress. Good Saturday

Son Volt 6:54 AM  

Seemed to like this more than the big guy - although I had some of the same takes throughout. It never really felt like it was trying too hard.

Difficulty bordered on Friday level cluing - I loved POLYMATHS, SANTA HATS and ELEPHANTS. Totally backed into SAMARA.

Jason and the Scorchers

It was always senior “skip” DAY where I came from. CHOCOLATE MALT right down the center was neat and filled a lot of real estate. CRUS is a brutal plural and Teletubbies shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near a grid that is supposed to be taken seriously. Sea Lice was one of the critic’s darlings - my youngest son was in college then and tried to get me to listen to it.

Enjoyable Saturday morning solve. Stella has her groove on in today’s Stumper and gives us a cute spanning cocktail.

The War on Drugs

SouthsideJohnny 7:11 AM  

My downfall was the yellow Teletubby crossing the actress who was crossing the slang in the same neighborhood as my old friend RENEE (was sorry to see the version that Rex went with lol, although I do admit the Left Banke crafted a masterpiece with that one).

I enjoyed the SE the most with some nice cluing for ELEPHANTS, TREE FORT and the SIXTIES.

Barry 7:12 AM  

I realize that the word of the day is subjective, but I would much rather learn something about polymaths than about puppy chow. Just my two cents.

kitshef 7:20 AM  

Hand up for ART School before ART studio, for having no idea about LOTTA Sea Lice or SAMARA or CHEX or SO EXTRA, for wanting toga before CHUG.

The other hand up for calling it ‘senior skip day’ – not that I ever participated.

irenE before RENEE - I can't be the only one.

On the other hand, my entry was ASHAMED/MAMA.

REV 7:22 AM  

Wow. You were right. I really was not prepared for that article. Neither the content nor the writing.

Why is HALTS is PULLS UP?

Anonymous 7:30 AM  

@ anonymous 6:52. Agree. That seems to be happening a lot lately and I think it's sloppy

Lewis 7:39 AM  

I’ll start with the lovely bones. What a gorgeous looking grid, with its pairs of diagonal blocks and opposing stairsteps. A design never been done before in the Times, and one that allows for flow, with no near-detached islands.

The bones include how the grid is filled. This is an uber-low 66-word grid, with hardly a whiff of junk, a most difficult task beautifully pulled off. And such variety in the answers – sports, history, arts, colloquialisms, geography, and more.

And what fleshes out these bones?

Freshness, for one. Pop. The answer set has eight debuts, including the lovely ANYTOWN USA, CHOCOLATE MALT, DITCH DAY, IT’S A DONE DEAL, and SMALL CRAFT. How fresh overall? Get this – one out of four answers have been used less than five times in the Times puzzle’s 80 year history!

And cluing. OMG, what stellar/devilish cluing today. I was won over by three of her original clues, those for SIXTIES, RENEE, and the marvelous [Job that anyone could see themselves doing?] for WINDOW WASHER.

All these elements clicked together just right, Christina. Your puzzle was top quality, and, for me, an A-1 experience, including the grit and play my brain loves. Thank you so much for your talent and for making this!

Lewis 7:42 AM  

Speaking of Christina’s cluing, here’s one I’m still smiling at from February: [Wind up alone?].






FLUTE SOLO

Gary Jugert 7:47 AM  

Estas vacunas me están volviendo loco.

Got my flu and covid vaccines yesterday and I always have a hardcore reaction to these things. Now it's 3 am and I am suffering as usual and trying not to leap out of the window into the koi pond.

Opened up the puzzle because there's nothing misery loves more than a Saturday offering from the NYTXW crew. Gotta admit I'm in no mood for characters in old musicals or whoever this Renee person is, but outside of those two horrible women, the grid filled in at high speed. Maybe they're lovely women, I didn't take time to check.

And, um, just to be an insufferable pedant, RESTS come in more variety than the three they list.

However, as an old white man, may I remind this woke generation that it's vanilla malt. Not Anything Else. I know they have 31 flavors now. I know they have vegan oat and coconut offerings. I know they let you taste everything before you commit. But no. Stop it. The sole litmus test for every soda shop (and by the way, those aren't a thing except in movies) is not a chocolate malt, it's a vanilla malt, unless you're fine with society going to the iPhoners. The DQ vanilla malt is the bar to beat, and it's a low bar, and if your hemp milk boba malt can't beat DQ, then open an espresso shop because you apparently can serve whatever ghastly gloop you want and call it espresso and baby boomers on bicycles will come by to slurp it up. I bought a chocolate shake yesterday for my mother-in-law and she loved it, so there you go. Not even a malt.

Man I don't feel good.

❤️ PHANATIC. [Trailer homes.] [50/50.] [Puppy chow ingredient.]

Let's count some stuff.

Propers: 6
Places: 3
Products: 4
Partials: 6
Foreignisms: 2
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 21 of 66 (32%)

Funnyisms: 6 😅

Tee-Hee: CHUG.

Uniclues:

1 The ones with no face markings on them after the fight.
2 Pharmhouse for phormer Philadelphia phieldhands with phirearms.
3 Duty of junkyard worker.
4 Action by one avoiding tyranny.
5 Gets dressed.
6 Pale lady.
7 Yeeeeeeeeeeeeee hooooooooooers.
8 𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽𝄽

1 ASHAMED FISTS
2 PHANATIC IDAHO
3 FITS IN TOTALS
4 SHOOS CITY HALL
5 HALTS ART STUDIO
6 INSIDE TAN MAMA (~)
7 SLOW YODELERS
8 SO EXTRA RESTS

My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Whiskey flask. CLOAKED OIL CAN.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Anonymous 7:51 AM  

Look it up, it’s an ordinary word (whereas “puppy chow” is strange, at least to me)

Andy Freude 7:58 AM  

I was grateful for the word of the day, because I kept wondering why anyone would feed Chex to a dog.

EasyEd 7:59 AM  

Evil cluing, but isn’t that what Saturday is all about? Like Rex wiped out in the NW, but in the NE started with SOulTRA and had no idea for LAALAA, so that was a goner too.Finally got started in the SE and was struggle from there. For some unknown reason FINCHES came to mind in the NW to give me some small help there. Enjoyed finally seeing CHUG—overall a tough puzzle for me.

Mickey Bell 8:31 AM  

Still laughing at Rex’s “dude w/ TB doing cosplay for the neighbor boy” comment. This was like, some deranged Jeopardy question… “I’ll take NYT DUMB HEADLINES for $200, Alex…” to find an answer phrased as a question, to get to this clue. The most woefully over-engineered clue to an NYT answer ever. I did get it fast but boy there is trivia, and then there is truly useless info.

Also lost many many minutes on “CHUG” - I knew what the Belushi video was and don’t need to watch it to feel validated for the misdirect.

Me no likey.

Anonymous 8:32 AM  

Agree 100%. Best Saturday solving experience in a long time.

MaxxPuzz 8:39 AM  

Also never heard of puppy chow. Long Wisconsin and Ohio background and currently back in Ohio. Oh well, wrong part of Midwest.

Anonymous 8:46 AM  

When a runner “pulls up” in a race, s(he) stops running.

Anonymous 8:49 AM  

I think many of us would have preferred “LOTTA” with a Nicolette Larson or Neil Young reference rather than an indie album that didn’t crack the top 50.

pabloinnh 8:55 AM  

A wavelength thing today, as in wavelength with most other solvers. NE especially problematical, with RENEE and SOEXTRA leading into the mysterious SAMARA, but got 'er done. Agree with everyone about skipDAY and had FINCHES but didn't trust myself because of the obvious TOGA which of course was the also obvious CHUG.

Always forget that a gala is an APPLE but I have seen LAALAA in another puzzle and it's such a ridiculous combination of letters that it is not easily forgotten.

@Gary J-You're making me rethink my upcoming appointment for the simultaneous flu/covid shot, and I hope you feel better, but when I read the clue for the soda shop purchase, I instantly thought of CHOCOLATEMALT, which is MY favorite. I'm hoping reasonable people can disagree on something of such vital importance.

Very nice Saturday indeed, CI. Cleverly Imagined and thanks for all the fun.

M@ 8:57 AM  

I was stuck in the SW for far too long knowing that both FINCHES and RADLEYS would fit. It took a while to hit on a cross, but once I did, that corner came together. Also, Puppy Chow is such an American thing... though as a Canadian I was gifted two clues so I can't complain.

Escalator 8:58 AM  

Still hoping Loren Muse Smith is OK. She has not posted in a long while and miss her witticism……

puzzlehoarder 9:03 AM  

Today's difficulty rating is right on the nose. What stood out for me was the evenness of the resistance throughout. No one section struck me as particularly easy or hard just a steady half hour of late week solving.

I did notice the SANTA dupe. It doesn't really bother me but I'm accustomed to them being stricter about that sort of thing.


yd -0. QB20

Dr.A 9:06 AM  

Definitely not my favorite. I had to look up almost all the trivia to get anywhere with this one which I normally do not have to do even if I don’t know the trivia. However POLYMATH is one of my fave words so that makes up for a lot of the other stuff. SO EXTRA doesn’t seem like slang to me. But I have a 15 year old so anything that looks like English doesn’t seem like slang to me.

Anonymous 9:22 AM  

Two tough Saturdays in a row! Thank you NYT.

Worked it bottoms up, CHOCOLATEMALT reverse whoosh got it going. Thank heavens for IDAHO, MAMA (good guess) ANNEAL and FINCHES which led the way

Nice cluing, too -- tough but (except RENEE) fair and solvable.

Keep it up!

Bob Mills 9:23 AM  

I had to cheat once, to get SAMARA the actress. After that it was trial-and-error to get SOEXTRA. I also forgot that "gala" was a kind of apple, and only tried BOOTS after having "fires" from the beginning. And RENEE was clued very unfairly. Not an enjoyable Saturday.

ChrisR 9:28 AM  

My time was about 2/3 of my average for Saturdays, despite getting off to a rough start. SAMARA, LOTTA, and SO EXTRA were out of my wheelhouse, while--because of where I've lived--PHANATIC and SLOAN--were in it.

At some point, my brain said, "OK, stay loose" in interpreting the clues. I started on other paths with RENEE, ANNEAL, TOTALS, SIXTIES, APPLE, FIR, SANTA HATS, THEATERS, and especially the diabolically-clued ONE. Appropriate for a Saturday.

Nancy 9:38 AM  

I was clapping myself on the back for getting IRENE immediately (I'm a big fan of Cryptic crosswords) for "woman in dire need" -- and I never realized that there was a big fat trap I had just fallen into. IRENE instead of RENEE kept me from making the mistake of thinking 3/15 was a DATE or ODDS -- but it also kept me from seeing IDES...and IDAHO...and FIR. (I had LEI where FIR should have been. Do you trim a LEI? I don't know -- I've never had a LEI.)

So well done on IRENE/RENEE, Christine. But can there be any excuse for crossing the actress with the record label with the teletubby with the modern lingo? Did you really think that I would be able to finish the NE corner? Did you care? In fact, did you think about me at all, Christine?

Also: WINDOW WASHER seems oddly clued. To "see yourself", I think you'd have to be cleaning a MIRROR. And "metaphorically speaking", ELEPHANTS are only hard to ignore when they're IN THE ROOM. Yes?

A really hard Saturday -- sometimes in a very good and interesting way and sometimes not so much.

Anonymous 9:48 AM  

Yes, this! Had root beer float which wrecked me for a while

andrew 9:49 AM  

ESSO saved my (Canadian) bacon and gave me something/anything with which to work. Changing its name to the EXXON American counterpart would be (es)SO EXXTRA!

Had to Google SAMARA - otherwise, a clean, challenging solve.

Greater Fall River Committee for Peace & Justice 9:50 AM  

DITCH DAY? I've heard of senior skip DAY, I considered beaCH DAY. In my school it was Patty Murphy day, in honor of a legendary long-ago senior who skipped school to go to the beach and drowned. So the story went. We all skipped school and went to the beach, anyhow.

Liveprof 9:52 AM  

Genie working in a malt shop.

Customer: Make me a malted.

Genie: Poof, you're a malted.

Beezer 9:57 AM  

Gary, my husband has always had a problem with the CoVid vax and I was surprised when he decided to double up like you. Chills all night. Good news…this too shall pass.

RooMonster 10:00 AM  

Hey All !
Joel has brought back the tough Themelesses. Had to Goog about three or four times to finish, plus a Check Puzzle click! Goodness. Thankfully no streak to be concerned about.

Funny, Rex's starting point (NE) was my toughest spot. NW no picnic either. Had steAMED for 1A, didn't want to let it go until my Check Puzzle crossed out the STE.

Knew how to spell CHOCOLATE. A lot of people miss the central O, spelling it CHOCLATE.

Weekend. Let's hope it lasts longer than 12 seconds. Happy Saturday!

Three F's
RooMonster
DarrinV

Diane Joan 10:09 AM  

Although I don’t doubt its Midwestern origins, I had puppy chow once as prepared by a decidedly East Coast mom for a tailgate at an East Coast college. Now the grand-dog and I are enjoying more senior fare. I just discovered that there is dog food for “senior dogs” these days.

Thanks for posting the NYT article Rex! I can only hope that the philanthropist didn’t bring a healthy dose of tuberculosis along with his sled of presents for the Harris family!

Hope you’re feeling better Rex.

Beezer 10:14 AM  

Wow. This puzzle was extremely tough in portions and semi-easy in others (for me). I thought it was fun sorting it out and THOUGHT I might have completed with “no cheats” but when I put in the last letter up in NW corner (my extremely tough WOE), no dice. So. I hit check puzzle. AARGH. I had GIsA/ELIsA!

Ah well. Fun puzzle, and thanks @Rex for RENEE and CHEX explanation.

frankbirthdaycake 10:16 AM  

So, “anneal” is good enough for the crossword but not good enough for Spelling Bee. (I could swear I’ve used that word on Spelling Bee in the past, but I could be mistaken.) Good puzzle for me. Nothing too exciting but nothing bad. I wanted something with “Peoria” for anytown. On second thought, “so extra” is a bit grating. I know I’m showing my age, but it sounds lazy to my ear — I’m probably due for a hearing aid, truth be told, due to too much loud music and playing the drums.

PHL PHIL 10:19 AM  

Here in the Philadelphia area we phrequently refer to the aphorementioned mascot by the phamiliar. That is, the stand alone "The Phanatic". No need to identify the city every time. After all, we need to save time so we can boo santa.

jberg 10:23 AM  

I'm getting here late, partly because our paper was not delivered and I had to print it out, and partly because I left a sink full of dishes when I went to bed last night, and needed to clean them up before I did anything else. And then it was a slow start, with fluSHED, abaSHED, and abAsED before I finally got to ASHAMED, no idea about the baseball mascot, thinking it might be Denim DAY (what on earth is DITCH DAY? Is that what we used to call Skip Day?), and no idea about the non-Sigourney Weaver or either the color or the name of any Teletubby. I finally worked out everything except the aforementioned Natick, and I guessed the A, correctly, because LAALAA sounded better than any other vowel there.

Aside from that, it was a pretty good puzzle.

Now often do take my morning constitutional, find out why the tire warning light is on, and do a little ingredient shopping to make a batch of pesto Genovese later today.

Sam 10:31 AM  

Got what they were going for at 18A but had IRENE before RENEE

egsforbreakfast 10:35 AM  

Trump University: ITS A DON E-DEAL.

Having an extramarital affair with your personal trainer might qualify as a FITSIN.

4D made me wonder, does anyone live in ANYTOWN anymore anyway?

Tough but delicious Saturday. Thanks, Christina Iverson.

RYB57 10:50 AM  

A very good, hard slog for me, just what you'd expect for a Saturday. My woe was "ditch day", which was new to me. Going to HS in rural Wisconsin, I do recall sliding into a ditch a couple times when I drove myself to school during the winter of my senior year.

Anonymous 10:57 AM  

Same on Irene

Hack mechanic 11:15 AM  

Too many unknowns in the NW, phanatic, lotta, mama, ditchday plus 4 possible for 1a viz enraged, blushed, ashamed meant no dice for me. Thought the rest rather good by comparison

LeRoi Valet 11:25 AM  

Easiest Saturday E V E R. Usually on Saturday I hunt around looking for something I am pretty sure of. One across seemed too easy for a Saturday, But got "apple" and never slowed down.

Anonymous 11:33 AM  

Not really fun here. Clueing was too obscure or too cute, or both. Some answers ain’t things. Couldn’t get into this.

Newboy 11:41 AM  

Well, that Christmas tale was worth the price of admission today. I am continually amazed at how our fearless leader is able to dig out these obscure newspaper articles, and other trivia to brighten my morning. And during the middle of the night?

Didn’t take a WINDOW-WASHER to see through most of the grid, but like Rex, I was left totally at sea by that damn low-hanging fruit at one down. Nice way to start the weekend 🎯

jb129 11:46 AM  

Very challenging from the constructor of Friday's 'Easy Mode' (which makes me feel smart after I do the "real thing" on Friday). I really liked RENEE, had Heads for FISTS for bumped things, PHANATIC for
1A - opening clue? And followed by POLYMATHS?
Regarding Chocolate Malt, my parents owned what was "Bay Ridge Stationery" which had a fountain, toys, cards, newspapers, comics & the best EGG CREAM in Brooklyn, followed only by my mother's Malted made with real ice cream :)

Suzie 12:13 PM  

I went to a show on that Barnett/Vile tour and still couldn't remember the name of the album.

Anonymous 12:15 PM  

6 days since our last rap-themed clue.

3 missed opportunites for fill-in-the-blanks rap clues today:

Tony YAYo (of G Unit)
Krs-ONE
Cold CRUSh Brothers (whose members are in their SIXTIES)

Not rappy enough today. Shout-out to STAX though. Hundreds of rap samples from STAX artists (probably hundreds from the Bar-Kays alone).

Anonymous 12:18 PM  

On Rex's comment about hoping millennials and Gen Z are starting to have the "wait, the kids are saying what now?" feeling: https://youtu.be/R8a3VzAsZ0E?si=_KDgJvWSTwUqpOjW&t=215

Whatsername 12:40 PM  

Can’t say I was a real PHANATIC of this one. Just a difficult slog from start to finish, about as painful as having ENAMEL scraped off my teeth. And I have lived most of my life in the southern, northern, middle and western Midwest states but never heard of any candy called puppy chow.

Anonymous 12:58 PM  

Finished without help but hated every second of it. No fun to be had here, just a grueling slog of obscurity. None of the proper nouns were people I've ever heard of. Looking forward to a lazy Sunday that won't raise my blood pressure.

M and A 1:11 PM  

Ah, yes ... The Jaws of Themelessness wreath. Pretty puzgrid.
And pretty tricky NW, chock-full of debut words.
And pretty tricky crossins, at SAMARA/LAALAA/SOEXTRA.
And them clues! phunatic!

staff weeject pick, from only 9 candidates: ONE. Primo 50/50 clue. Made M&A side-eye that there 3/15 clue, later on.

other fave stuff: THEATERS clue. ITSADONEDEAL. INSIDE/FITSIN. CHOCOLATEMALT [tho prefer BANANAMALTs, personally].
And the schlock flick fan in M&A woulda preferred: WITCHDAY. With spellin tourneys.

Thanx, Ms. Iverson darlin. U are clearly the MAMA of feisty-clue rodeos, in anytownanywhere.

Masked & AnonymoUUs

apt puzgrid matcher:
**gruntz**

okanaganer 1:27 PM  

For the second day in a row this felt quite easy! 14.5 minutes, and I am not a fast solver. The clueing was consistently tricky, and the dreaded Unknown Names (SAMARA LAALAA GIZA ELIZA) were gotten fairly from crosses. Thank gof that Atticus FINCH is such a memorable name.

Got a brief happy moment at APPLE since I used to live in an apple orchard. About half of it was Gala and the other half Red Delicious (which the owner cut down and replaced with Ambrosia because they sold for 3 times the price.)

I had CHAI before MAMA. Do you have any idea in how many languages tea is either "cha" or "chai"? Go to translate.google.com and just try it: Chinese, Russian, Hindi, it goes on and on...

[Spelling Bee: yd 0; streak 13]

mathgent 1:46 PM  

Just in case anyone is keeping score, I didn't like it. Not that it was hard to guess, but the clue for NYT was cheap. So were several others.

Anonymous 1:54 PM  

Where’s the SANTA dupe rage? Rex catches every last ON or UP that’s duped, so I expected him to blow a gasket on this far more glaring and easily fixable faux pas. And it did affect the solve, because I knew SANTAHAT but thought it couldn’t be right because of crossword custom.

jberg 2:14 PM  

Oops! Weaving, now Weaver. Better to clue it as "winged seed."

jberg 2:22 PM  

I'm never sure when Rex is trolling us, and when he is actually mixed up about something. The image he posts with his word of the day is of the actual Purina Puppy Chow, which is food for actual puppies (notice the chicken drumstick in the picture), not the home-made candy, which presumably heisted the title from Purina--maybe because that company was the original and long-time maker of Rice CHEX, as well.

GIZA is where the Great Pyramid is located, so not all that unknown as a place.

jae 2:30 PM  

On the easy side for me. ASHAMED, PHANATIC, FISTS, and IDAHO went in very quickly and the rest went fairly smoothly. Although I needed to pause and dredge up Gregory Peck to remember FINCHES, on the other hand LAALAA required zero extra effort.

I did not know SAMARA and LOTTA

A solid, junk free, kinda whooshy Saturday, with a smattering of sparkle, liked it.

Whatsername 2:55 PM  

Have a nice vanilla malt, maybe it’ll help. Hope you feel better soon.

Anonymous 3:44 PM  

ABASHED right away before ASHAMED.
IRENE before RENEE.

Les S. More 4:08 PM  

Had AbashED at 1A, was pretty sure of PHANATIC at 16A, and really wanted POLYMATHS for the Renaissance guys but had idle instead of SLOW at 17D. And that's the way the puzzle went for me; a little fix here, a little fix there, and I clawed my way through. CHOCOLATEMALT, something I've never had, broke things open, Saturday mornings are fun when they're like this.

This DITCHDAY thing is kind of interesting to me because it describes any old day I didn't feel like going to school. In grade ten (junior high) I booked off 25 days in a row to work on my game at Modern Billiards. Checked back in with a forged note citing a bout of bronchitis. Worked fine until,. about 3 days later, I was summoned to the office by Mr. Cooper, a hall of fame vice principal, who pointed out all the differences between my forgery and my father's actual signature. Did he suspend me or expel me? No. What good would have that done? Instead, he assigned me an extra 90 minutes each day of classwork each afternoon of work prepared by my various teachers (thank you, various teachers; I know it was extra work for you) and we moved on. As far as I know, he never even reported me to my parents. Hooray for tuned-in vice principals!

And, though it improved a bit, my billiards game never reached the stellar level I hoped it would.

Les S. More 4:34 PM  

Nothing to do with tje puzzle, really. More to do with your name, Frank. But I was recently on a fishing trip with my sons on the Elk river in southwestern BC and the trout were ignoring my meticulously tied Parachute Adams so I asked my oldest to tie on a rather gaudy fly I'd brought back from New Zealand (my eyes are crap, I need the help). Two or three casts later I was hooked up with a 16 inch cutthroat. Son looked over with that WTF look and I shouted, "It's birthday cake time!"

Anonymous 4:37 PM  

I had a strong start with APPLE x ASHAMED and SHOOS but then I couldn’t get much else in the NW. In the NE I got IDES, then guessed IDAHO crossing it. Then I didn’t even see that RENEE is hidden in DIRE NEED, so I assumed that IDES/IDAHO was wrong, typed in IRENE, and got stuck until I was able to back into the NE from below and fix IRENE. And later on I had A DEAL IS A DEAL which prevented me from seeing CITY HALL and ART STUDIO. Overall, I had a somewhat fast time for a Saturday but there was enough challenge.

Anonymous 4:39 PM  

I was wondering if a MIRROR washer was a thing - vowels in the right place. WINDOW eventually insisted

Anonymous 4:59 PM  

Anonymous 6:52AM et al
About dupes
It actually has been going on for years Starting with Shortz.
Apparently if there ever was a rule it has been Shortz got rid of it
My point is, it isn’t sloppy when it is not a rule and can be intentional.
The Times doesn’t think it is a problem
It bothers me not at all.

jazzmanchgo 5:00 PM  

The Left Banke's "Renee" is, indeed, a classic, but let's add a shout-out to the Four Tops' version as well -- Levi took Renee off that empty sidewalk and carried her right to church (no idea how to create a link here -- if I could, I would).

Anonymous 5:35 PM  

third for the rootbeer float, i counted the letters and couldn't believe my luck. alas! then, for a long time i knew it was some kind of MALT but couldn't think of a single thing. at some point, with C-----ATE, i even invented the CarbOnATE MALT. then finally i realized it was so simple...so banal...CHOCOLATE. delicious yet landed with kind of a thud for me.

-stephanie.

Anonymous 5:40 PM  

never set foot in the midwest, born and raised in RI and lived in the boston area for 20+ years and i'm very familiar with puppy chow. usually given out in little party favor type bags at christmas. my aunt makes a version with white chocolate and it's called white trash😄

along with the two other santa clues, a little christmassy vibe in september.

-stephanie.

Teedmn 6:03 PM  

I do know both Courtney Burnett and Kurt Vile and that they made an album together, but the name of the album, no. My local college station used to start its broadcasting day every morning with Kurt Vile's “Wakin' on a Pretty Day”, probably because it’s a 9:30 minute song which took up about half of my commute.

Reading Rex's write-up and looking back on the puzzle makes me misremember it as being harder than it was. FISTS crossing IDES got the NE off to a good start after APPLE/ESSO gave little traction in the NW. then it was just moving clockwise with one writeover at 53D's die vs. TAN.

An aha on the front half of POLYMATHS got me to the finish line. It sure wasn’t going to happen at PHANATIC, a no-know for me!

An easy puzzle for a Christina Iverson oeuvre but fun.

Anonymous 6:10 PM  

Same— if it was a mirror it would explain why everyone could see themselves, as opposed to seeing someone else.

Anoa Bob 6:14 PM  

When crosses gave the contiguous WWs in the middle of the 12 letter 27 Across slot, I thought OH COOL, that has to be WINDOW WASHER. YAY!

Most boat owners are all too familiar with SMALL CRAFT Warnings from local weather reports.

I did notice that there was a significant amount of what I think of as "non-nutritional" filler in this one, entries that take up valuable grid real estate without adding much of interest or value to the puzzle. Yeah, most of this was in the form of the plural of convenience (POC) when FIST, SHOO, HALT, SANTA HAT, THEATER, POLYMATH, LAT, CRU, YODELER, TOTAL, FIT IN, FINCH, REST, ELEPHANT and SIXTY all needed help filling their slots.

Anonymous 7:40 PM  

Had “FIG” for the thing that was trimmed after purchase— did not think of the alternate meaning of “trim”— and so wasted quite some time trying to legitimize “GENEE” as the woman in dire need. Alternate spelling of “genie”? Movie character I’d never heard of?

Les S. More 8:02 PM  

@frank
Love your nom de blog because it a) is fun and b) reminds me of a nice exchange between me and my oldest son on a recent fishing trip. I was getting no takes on a #16 Parachute Adams (a meticulous tie from one of my other sons) so I asked him if he would tie on this gaudy thing from our New Zealand trip of a few years ago - irridescent green body with a bushy white wing and he asked me why. Well, because they don't seem to want anything that looks like dinner, maybe they want dessert. Two casts later I had a 16 inch cutthroat on the line and he looked at me like WTF and I just said Birthday Cake! It was a beautiful fish.

Nat 8:37 PM  

I was indignant at 'temper' being used as a clue for 'anneal' since my understanding was that tempering makes metals hard - useful for swords - whereas annealing makes them softer and more flexible - useful for springs. But I decided to look it up, and apparently the clue is accurate, strictly speaking.
The rapid cooling of metals, which I thought was tempering, is actually called quenching. Tempering is bringing the metal back up to fairly high heat which makes it less brittle. Annealling then requires slow cooling.
So the clue isn't actually misleading, even though I think my misunderstanding is pretty common.
So the clue

dgd 9:21 PM  

Very late as usual
Liked the puzzle. Agreed with Rex it was a medium but disagreed. about the clueing. I did have trouble with the NW but this is a Saturday after all. I think Rex really wants easy. What else is whoosh but easy?
I looked at REN and thought RENEE but what? Then I finally realized. I like clues like that. Fortunately I already had FIR so iRENE wasn’t a problem.
Funny I had agt in for quite a while and I am a retired ATT.
Some people thought WINDOW WASHER was wrong But a lot of office building windows are mirrored on the outside. Also any window on the outside can act like a mirror if the light is right. That was a big help to me.
I am not a big fan of chocolate especially chocolate ice cream. When I was a child I never heard anyone refer to never mind order a malted. I still at 72 never had one. So it took me a while.
Elephant. The clue refers to something used as a metaphor. It did not ask for the whole phrase. Nothing wrong with that answer. The whole point of a puzzle is to give you a hint after all.

Gary Jugert 9:37 PM  

@pabloinnh 8:55 AM
Okay, go with chocolate, but when I see you, expect nothing more than a polite nod. 🙄

Tom F 2:25 AM  

Clearly a successful puzzle if they get in a SANTA dupe and it passes OFL’s write-up ;)

Anonymous 5:01 AM  

You’re right, I was not prepared. Finished this annoying puzzle after a few particular low quality clues I came here to gripe about…then read that Santa story (which answer I got just fine but background had no idea). Holy f—literally choked on my wine and said out loud (fully alone in my apt) some approximation of “geezfkwha..!” Gripes forgotten.

Anonymous 1:28 AM  

Thank you for digging up the NYT article! First time I’ve seen your blog and liked the breakdown of the clues. I couldn’t figure out the meaning of RENEE until I came here. The Santa article was SO EXTRA, but in a good way.

  © Free Blogger Templates Columnus by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP