1992 novel set in 1920s Harlem / TUE 8-13-24 / 1970 novel exploring racism's effect on a young girl's self-esteem / 1981 novel about the interplay of privilege and poverty in a Caribbean romance / 1977 novel whose title references a lyrical Old Testament book / 1973 novel set in "the Bottom," a neighborhood slated to be demolished for a golf course / Covered veranda often equipped with a ceiling fan

Tuesday, August 13, 2024

Constructor: Benjamin Panico

Relative difficulty: Easy (or Challenging, depending on your familiarity with the puzzle's subject)


THEME: TONI MORRISON (55A: Author who received the Nobel Prize in Literature on the basis of her first six novels, all featured in this puzzle) — six novels by Toni Morrison:

Theme answers:
  • JAZZ (8A: 1992 novel set in 1920s Harlem)
  • THE BLUEST EYE (19A: 1970 novel exploring racism's effect on a young girl's self-esteem)
  • TAR BABY (30A: 1981 novel about the interplay of privilege and poverty in a Caribbean romance)
  • SONG OF SOLOMON (35A: 1977 novel whose title references a lyrical Old Testament book)
  • BELOVED (42A: 1987 Pulitzer-winning novel about the haunting of a formerly enslaved family's home)
  • SULA (65A: 1973 novel set in "the Bottom," a neighborhood slated to be demolished for a golf course)
Word of the Day: TONI MORRISON (55A) —

Chloe Anthony Wofford Morrison (née Chloe Ardelia Wofford; February 18, 1931 – August 5, 2019), known as Toni Morrison, was an American novelist and editor. Her first novel, The Bluest Eye, was published in 1970. The critically acclaimed Song of Solomon (1977) brought her national attention and won the National Book Critics Circle Award. In 1988, Morrison won the Pulitzer Prize for Beloved (1987); she was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1993.

Born and raised in Lorain, Ohio, Morrison graduated from Howard University in 1953 with a B.A. in English. Morrison earned a master's degree in American Literature from Cornell University in 1955. In 1957 she returned to Howard University, was married, and had two children before divorcing in 1964. Morrison became the first black female editor in fiction at Random House in New York City in the late 1960s. She developed her own reputation as an author in the 1970s and '80s. Her novel Beloved was made into a film in 1998. Morrison's works are praised for addressing the harsh consequences of racism in the United States and the Black American experience.

The National Endowment for the Humanities selected Morrison for the Jefferson Lecture, the U.S. federal government's highest honor for achievement in the humanities, in 1996. She was honored with the National Book Foundation's Medal of Distinguished Contribution to American Letters the same year. President Barack Obama presented her with the Presidential Medal of Freedom on May 29, 2012. She received the PEN/Saul Bellow Award for Achievement in American Fiction in 2016. Morrison was inducted into the National Women's Hall of Fame in 2020. (wikipedia)

• • •

First themer I got was THE BLUEST EYE and I thought, "wow, that's kind of a deep cut for a Tuesday puzzle." And then I got JAZZ and started to think the same thing but then immediately realized "oh, we're just doing TONI MORRISON novels, is that it?" And that was it. It's a list of her first six novels, which just happen to be symmetrically arrangeable in a crossword grid (when you throw Morrison's name in the mix as well). From a puzzle standpoint, this isn't much. It's a list. Here's the author. Here's six books she wrote. There's no wordplay, no tricks. Just titles. And it's not even an anniversary—Morrison's birthday, say (Feb. 18), or the anniversary of her Nobel Prize win, or anything. Just her name and her books. So ... ho-hum. And yet it's really hard for me to be mad at a grid that has one of my very favorite novels splashed right across the middle of it. If you're going to bore me with a list, I'd say this list about as interesting a way as there is to do it. I enjoyed taking the trip through Morrison's back catalogue. As an English major who was in college at the peak of Morrison's productivity and fame (i.e. just after BELOVED came out), these titles all came to me very, very easily. Lots of my friends were Women's Studies majors of one kind or another (English, Sociology, etc.), so I became very familiar with the Morrison bibliography very quickly, and though I've only read two of these books, I filled in every title in today's puzzle without any difficulty at all. Well, there was some difficulty with the first title (THE BLUEST EYE), since at that point I didn't know they would all be Morrison titles. But after the second title (JAZZ) ... whoosh! So I liked this puzzle insofar as I like TONI MORRISON and enjoyed briefly reminiscing about my college days, when she first came to my notice and when I first read her work. And yeah, SONG OF SOLOMON, man. It's a life-changer. A disturbing, even horrifying work, but a warm and wise one as well. And a page-turner! I might pick it up again soon...


There's not much going on today beyond the list of book titles. Those answers are inherently flashy and interesting. The rest of the grid, much less so. The "Z"s gave it some zing, but otherwise, it's pretty routine and unremarkable. It's also very easy—as it would have to be, since for many people there's probably going to be plenty of difficulty in the theme itself, the way there is always difficulty in working out proper nouns you've never heard of. I have no idea how familiar Morrison's catalogue is to the general public. Seems plausible that even very well read people might not know more than one or two titles. So there was no room for the non-thematic fill to get too hard or too cute. Gotta keep those crosses coming in clean so no one gets Naticked. I don't see any potential Naticks today. Only SULA and (to a lesser extent) TAR BABY have any chance of thwarting people with an uninferrable letter, and their crosses all seem clear to me. The "Y" in TAR BABY came from OYS (26D: Pained cries), which could easily have been OWS or even OHS, I suppose, but again, you can get the "Y" by inference, i.e. TARBABW is nonsense. That first "A" in TAR BABY comes from EVA, whose clue is unusual (21D: #bestfriends4___) but ultimately pretty straightforward. I don't see an ounce of difficulty in this puzzle outside the themers. I had some mild trouble working out the awkwardness of RETURN TO (4D: Pick up again, as a book). "Pick up" was ambiguous—I thought I was returning to the library to check it out again, or buying another copy, not simply coming back to it after having put it aside. But this resulted in mild hesitation, not actual confusion or stoppage. I always balk at VLOGS because that word has always seemed made-up and embarrassing, and now seems dated, but again, it's not like it was hard to come up with (43D: YouTube journals, essentially).  Conceptually, this puzzle wasn't particularly innovative or original or clever, but it did provide a welcome opportunity to remember a great author. Maybe that's enough. 


See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]

83 comments:

Conrad 5:51 AM  


I agree. Easy puzzle but reviewing a great author is, as @Rex says, "enough." Liked it. My only overwrite was OwS before OYS at 26D. I'm not as familiar with Ms. Morrison's work at OFL, so the novels JAZZ and SULA were unknown to me, but easily gettable.

Son Volt 6:04 AM  

A tribute list - so much fun. Like the big guy - I appreciate the subject but it’s still just a data set. Overall fill was fine - except for the brutal oddness of 37d.

We do get @Pablo’s OTTER - always a welcome sight. I learned from Dave Lemieux the other day that sea OTTERs are monogamous and because they sleep on their backs they hold hands while they sleep to keep from floating away from each other. Pretty neat stuff.

I need a little more thought process in a Tuesday theme.

Jessi Colter

Alfred N. 6:05 AM  

Seriously? A list of titles of books by an author for whom this date, as far as I can tell, has no special significance and for which i didn't need to read clues but could fill in merely by looking at the number of letters and getting a single down letter . Am I missing something?

Adam 6:16 AM  

I am unfamiliar with TONI MORRISON's oeuvre and therefore had to get most of the theme answers from crosses. THE BLUEST EYE and SULA were WOEs for me but were fairly crossed; the others at least I'd heard of. My time was a little above average but not by much. Nice tribute to a deserving (from what I hear) author, but otherwise, eh.

Fun_CFO 6:32 AM  

Yeah, easy. But pretty cool (coincidentally) to have 3 pairs (including author’s name) that work symmetrically, and the seventh that fits nicely in the grid center, in such a tight simple theme. Does seem a little weird to run this on a random Tuesday and not around a meaningful or relevant Toni M. date. Although, if it had, I wouldn’t have known during solve anyway and would have relied on Rex or someone to point out the relevance.

Anonymous 6:39 AM  

I have to agree with Rex, if you are not familiar with the book titles— and I think it may be more likely than not for some generations or demographics —the puzzle is a slog and more like a Wednesday or even an easy Thursday. It is similar in my mind to loading a puzzle down with sports or movies —yes some folks think movies are a waste of time and prefer opera , ballet , theater or a sporting event. It’s akin to food—believe it or not there are people out there who do not like chocolate. In short , like Rex said , if you are unfamiliar with the books , then this can be difficult.

SouthsideJohnny 6:40 AM  

I almost TITT when I realized it was just a list of books by an author that I recognized from CrossWorld but otherwise no nothing about. The saving grace for me was the fact that the crosses were Monday-level easy, so I plugged away and parsed together what appeared to be valid book titles. TAR BABY was the only real speed bump with the crossing OYS, EBON and that cryptic clue that appears to be associated with what I believe was once called the Twitterverse. I guess if you are a fan of Mrs. Morrison this one could be a treat. But for me, just meh.

Jack Stefano 7:04 AM  

Point of order: it cannot be “easy or challenging”. I know what you mean, but that description does nothing to objectively rate the puzzle. It’s like saying golf can be easy or challenging. Perhaps we should score these on a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being easy. I’d give this one a 3.

kitshef 7:19 AM  

Definitely a Monday puzzle, despite not not knowing half the novels. But the down clues were pretty much no-brainers. It does bother me a little that the books are not in order of publication.

Anonymous 7:21 AM  

I had this EXACT theme in my Theme Ideas google doc! This was executed so far beyond anything I could have achieved but therefore made for a strange solving experience.

andrew 7:26 AM  

Didn’t know most these titles but downs were Tuesday easy so no Woes.

Then, since I couldn’t sleep (get birthday insomnia, even though my family is dead and the only presents I’ll get today are things I forgot I ordered on Amazon), started thinking if TONI MORRISON’s name anagrammed out to something cool like MR MOJO RISIN’. All I got was IRON MONITORS and I INTRO MORONS.

The Lizard King’s anagram was better.

Bob Mills 7:27 AM  

Very easy until I got stuck on the THEBLUESTEYE/LAYER cross. I didn't know the book, but was sure it began with "theblues" or "theblue(something)." I had "latex" instead of LAYER, which complicated the problem. The cluing was quite straightforward, more like a Monday puzzle.

EasyEd 7:29 AM  

I have never read any of Ms Morrison’s novels (due to when she wrote and where I was at the time) but found it interesting that most of her titles were inferable once a few letters were captured in the crosses. And since the titles were new to me was not bored in deriving them. With the myriad of choices facing new constructors I felt this was an agreeable effort.

pabloinnh 7:32 AM  

This is a case of "I don't really know these books, but I know of them". Ms. Morrison is justly famous and maybe this will be the incentive to explore some of her work.

Titles were familiar and the fill was Monday easy. I tried EVR, which made more sense to me than EVA, non-texter that I am, and I thoroughly dislike the music clues that want you to know what key something is in, as in IN__. Please stop doing that.

Of course the highlight for me was OTTER (hi @Son Volt). Besides floating and holding hands, sea OTTERs use rocks on their tummies as tools to crack shellfish, and save them for later use. Mostly I like OTTERS because they just like to screw around.

Serviceable Tuesday, BP. Not the Best Possible day for a tribute puzz, but thanks for some fun.

Anonymous 8:07 AM  

But golf can be easy or challenging depending on the player. That’s what handicaps are for.

And 1-10 scales are equally subjective. Check out any review site on the internet…

Bill 8:13 AM  

Jack, “easy or challenging” is a fair, and clear, description of this puzzle with one large theme, one’s familiarity with determining if it plays easily or with difficulty.
Why you seem resolute on quantifying the difficulty through the false objectivity of a number assignment, displaying your enthrallment to a mythical positivism, is beyond me, but to do so by calling a point of order in the comments of someone else’s blog, while using the presumptive royal we, at least marries form to content.

Whatsername 8:13 AM  

A crossword puzzle with a literary theme! I couldn’t be more pleased, or more surprised. I’m so accustomed to swimming upstream thru the usual onslaught of Simpsons characters, video games, text speak and “modern lingo“ that this seemed like a soothing piano recital in a sea of rap music. And beyond the theme, hardly any other proper names or trivia. Amazing!

So this “just a list” Tuesday seemed more than adequate to me. Thank you Benjamin, for a refreshing and most elegant debut. I loved solving your puzzle and hope you’ll be back to play for us again soon.

Anonymous 8:32 AM  

I don’t think it possible to objectively evaluate a puzzle —it’s an opinion. What I think OFL is doing here is simply giving his opinion -which I believe is dead on —that a puzzle depending on experiences will be hard or easy. He is writing for tens of thousands of people at all levels of expertise wirh crosswords. For many of you, a puzzle is considered hard if it takes 6 minutes on a Saturday. For other of us, it’s 20 minutes. For example, when I first read Faulkner in HS, I thought he was incomprehensible. Now —I think he is pure genius. This would be a fun discussion over a cocktail.

Anonymous 8:41 AM  

Right in line with Rex for once. Not much of a puzzle but I loved recalling Toni Morrison's works. It makes me feel beyond old to see that some commenters aren't familiar with those books. Use this puzzle as inspiration to read them! You won't regret it.

Anonymous 8:49 AM  

Sad to see otherwise bright and curious people have not experienced Toni Morrison. Her novels combine stories of deep love, tragedy, and paranormal; they all stung me as a white man but I couldn't stop reading them.

Trina 8:50 AM  

Well, yes, it can be easy or challenging, depending on your frame of reference as Rex says. If you know Tony Morrison’s work, then it’s easy. If you don’t, then it’s probably challenging. Simply rating at a three ignores that complexity.

estivator 9:00 AM  

Damning with faint praise, as usual. I enjoyed it because I love Morrison. For a debut constructor I was impressed.

Anonymous 9:03 AM  

BELOVED changed my life when I read it in high school. Loved this theme and based on the comments am thrilled so many are apparently going to discover her through this!

RooMonster 9:05 AM  

Hey All !
Well, first, thanks to All for the Birthday wishes in YesterComments! @'s Gill, Beezer, kitshef, JC66, TomT, Gary Jugert, Carola, Les S Mor, andrew, A and pablo.
@andrew - Happy Birthday right back atcha! Congrats on your two milestones. You'll definitely out live the even mark!
@pablo - LOL! Yes, I agree. (Wink, Wink) You can take credit everytime an OTTER shows up. We'll just think of it as a pet named Pablo. 😁

Today's puz was nice. I am unfamiliar with TONI MORRISON, although her name rings a faint bell in the ole brain. As y'all know, I'm not the most read person around. Funny, since I finally wrote a book. You'd think I would be very well read, alas, not. I chalk it up to laziness! 😁

Pretty neat to get six of her books in, the first six, nonetheless. We have 44 Blockers, high, but since they are cheater squares (well, four of them, anyway), they don't seem to chop up the grid more than a regular TuesPuz. Fill pretty decent considering all the Themers frolicking about.

Would've liked a @Gill story out of this one. With TARBABY being a BELOVED MARTYR and the village JAZZ BUMS.

Happy Tuesday All!

Two F's
RooMonster
DarrinV

Anonymous 9:24 AM  

Look at it this way - Monday is easier than Friday no matter who you are. This puzzle really did vary based on personal experience.

Unknown 9:34 AM  

As a librarian, these puzzle was very easy for me. I also had OW for OY at first. One of my only mistakes.

Gary Jugert 9:43 AM  

I don't read many novels anymore. I start them, but rarely finish them. Once you find Shakespeare, it's hard to find time for the others. I knew all of these titles because you hear things on the street. Glad the theme wasn't books by Shannen Doherty or 50 Cent.

So many things THUD, but nothing is more THUDIER than the sound of the human body as it is the THUDIEST. ZAP and ZIT make lovely bedfellows. BUM yesterday BUMS today ... beware, this is how it starts.

❤️ [#bestfriends4___]

@GILL I.
Loved yesterday's story as always, IKEA you not. (That phrase is going to become a problem in my everyday conversations.)

@M&A
Where are you?

Propers: 1
Places: 2
Products: 7
Partials: 2
Foreignisms: 1
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 13 of 78 (17%) (wah hoo!)

Funnyisms: 1 🤨

Tee-Hee: AROUSE.

Uniclues:

1 Favorite location for the yoga obsessed.
2 Get a roll of quarters out of the safe.
3 Become a vegetarian.
4 Fox News.
5 Assonance accident.

1 BELOVED RAT MAT
2 EASE TILL OMENS
3 UNDO TUNA DEBT (~)
4 LYING VLOGS
5 ANO NANO MISHAP

My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: My stomach before a performance. BUTTERFLIES TOTEBAG.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Beezer 10:02 AM  

I consider myself fairly well-read, but I’m embarrassed to admit, like @Pablo, I’ve not read any Toni Morrison books. I DID watch the movie BELOVED and I had heard of all the books except two. @Rex’s comment has prompted me to put SONGOFSOLOMON as my next read. As for the puzzle, enjoyable, but until I could plunk in TONIMORRISON I was relying a lot on downs and I did think…”man, these down clues are super-easy”! All in all, a very nice debut puzzle.

For those that read a lot, I HIGHLY recommend “James” by Percival Everett. It is a “re-imagining” of The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, through the eyes of Jim. I think it is genius.

Btw…I MAY be getting used to writing in the bottom comment line now. Old habits die hard.

Sir Hillary 10:03 AM  

Frequently heard during 1970s Boston Bruins broadcasts: ORR'S IN MOTION :)

jberg 10:09 AM  

I knew THE BLUEST EYE right off, and as I saw the next two theme clues I was pretty sure they were TONI MORRISON novels, but I couldn't remember any of the other titles until I got to SULA. I've read BELOVED, but the title didn't come to me. And for a moment I thought her name was TONy, but that didn't last. Eventually I got them all from crosses, and the rest of the puzzle was pretty-- well, simple. Neither RETURN TO nor LEAD ROLE is a very exciting long answer. So most of my fun came from trying to guess a missing letter: will it be THUS or THUd? etc. (and later, it was THUD!)

That's all I've got--now I'll see what everyone else thought.

Beezer 10:13 AM  

Happy birthday Andrew! Sleep well tonight. And good one Sir Hillary..

Beezer 10:19 AM  

Oh my…Shakespeare, eh? Gary, if you drive around much (and your car has Bluetooth) or if you walk for exercise or just putter around the house, I suggest giving audiobooks a whirl. I speak from experience that they got me BACK into books after a dry spell.

Sir Hillary 10:22 AM  

As puzzles generally go, yeah, this is a bit ho-hum. But as tribute puzzles go, it's fantastic. First, what an amazing discovery that her first six novels and her name combine to make a symmetrical set. Second, TONIMORRISON is a titanic enough literary figure that a tribute puzzle is deserved. I have never read any of her work, but I recognized all of the novels except THEBLUESTEYE. I remember the hype when BELOVED was released, and if memory serves it was a frequent topper of many "best of late 20th century" lists that came out around the millennium.

And:
-- Not sure if was constructor-driven or editor-driven, but the clue for 4-D is perfect, given the theme. I would like to say I plan to RETURNTO TONIMORRISON's novels, but you can't RETURNTO someplace you've never been. Maybe I will simply TURNTO them.
-- Again given the theme(s) of both the puzzle and her novels, the TARBABY/EBON cross caught my eye.
-- A very sensate puzzle: ACHE (from a THUD?), AROUSE, TENDER, burning DESIRE.
-- ALOHAS on LANAI.

jberg 10:25 AM  

Since I have never knowingly heard a Taylor Swift song, I shouldn't be surprised that many have never read TONY MORRISON, but that sort of thing is always an eye-opener for me. I think it's what explains our politics today--everyone in the Democratic camp knows that Trump's mind, such as it is, is deteriorating badly, but his fans have no idea what we're talking about. We need to figure out how to bridge that gap, but we've been saying that for 8 years now. Maybe this time.

I'm also thinking that I used to read a lot more novels than I do today. Maybe I should cut back on crosswords!

egsforbreakfast 10:26 AM  

The relative scarcity of Tee-Hee's noted lately by @Gary Jugert may mean that we're entering the POSTIT era.
Ella and Louis may have liked to sing DUETS, but Bob Marley says he much preferred a SONGOFSOLOMON.

I was hoping that the SAD PLOD OOZE start in the NW wasn't indicative of how this puzzle would feel. In the end, I kinda liked it. Congrats, Benjamin Panico.

Anonymous 10:31 AM  

Not knowing the books I found this “challenging “
In addition many of the down clues I thought were not specific enough. For example to pick up a book - return to - could be applied to so many things .
What a photographer could be touching up also could be so many things in a photo.
I didn’t find the down clues easy enough to finish without knowing the book titles

Whatsername 10:33 AM  

Thanks for the book recommendation. I read a few reviews on that one and It looked intriguing, but I’ve not gotten to it yet.

Anonymous 10:36 AM  

I thought confer meant either to bestow something ( something that is permanent ) or discuss .
Doesn’t the word lend imply something temporary ?

Carola 10:37 AM  

First word in: SAD - which was also my reaction after finishing the puzzle and realizing I'd only read one of these novels (BELOVED). At first, I didn't recognize JAZZ and TARBABY as her titles; only with SONG OF SOLOMON did I have my "Wait a minute..." moment and catch on. A worthy tribute.

burtonkd 10:37 AM  

I skipped all the titles doing acrosses first, then after the Monday easy downs, they just filled right in. As someone said, I know of Toni Morrison more than I’ve read her. Titles all inferable and in the cultural zeitgeist.

I loved the Calvin & Hobbes discussion yesterday, and hadn’t seen the quote Emily provided. That unspoken, underlying conceit makes sense as the reason for the continuing magic of the strip.

Jeremy 10:39 AM  

How about encouragement for the youth to keep up the fight: RIOT ON, MINORS.

Happy birthday, Andrew! We're pulling for you to more than break even on your SSA gamble and to keep this comment section entertaining along the way.

burtonkd 10:43 AM  

@egs: “Song of solo, mon” a new high (or low, depending on your POV) in the puniverse.

Btw - RIP Joe DiPinto, who I just found out passed away in July (thank you, Nancy if you’re still reading). I met a mutual friend last night who worked with him, and had the most wonderful things to say about him.

Anonymous 10:49 AM  

Happy Birthday

Anonymous 10:51 AM  

Thank you Benjamin Panico for a beautifully constructed puzzle celebrating the mind, the humanity and the work of a brilliant artist, teacher and cultural phenomenon. Toni Morrison’s life was a contribution to the enrichment of those she touched and to the bending of the arc of justice. Her memory is a blessing.

Whatsername 10:53 AM  

Good to hear the different impressions of the novels under discussion. I recently read an excellent one with a racially themed story line. The Year Of Jubilee by Cindy Morgan is a fictional novel but loosely based on the author’s own background, set In Kentucky during the height of the civil rights movement. While narrated by a 13-year-old white girl and focusing primarily on the experiences of her family, the racial strife in the South during that time is a constant presence in the background. I’d say it would be particularly appealing to anyone who has memories of that turbulent time in history. It is rare that a book makes me laugh and cry before I finish with it but this one did, more than once.

Liveprof 10:59 AM  

Laughed at your Amazon line!

andrew 11:00 AM  

I had mentioned here a birthday or two ago that I was born on Friday the 13th - Joe D emailed me to say he would turn 70 on Friday the 13th of this December. Sadly, obviously, that didn’t come to pass.

JC66 11:03 AM  

I asked the same thing late yesterday and @kitshef reminded me that about a week ago M&A said he'd be gone for 3 weeks; so 2 weeks to go.

Anonymous 11:07 AM  

@jberg I can’t”bridge the gap” between Covid vaccination and bleach injections; J6, Jewish space lasers, Charlottesville and the exquisite mind and work of Toni Morrison. Some ideas and actions do not merit validation and must be discarded. I don’t think I’d compromise or negotiate with lunacy and fascism.

Tom T 11:14 AM  

Two Hidden Diagonal Word (HDW) clues for today's grid:

1. What "eye" do when feeling sarcastic

2. Their "knees" are the best

(Answers below)

Add me to the list of those who are familiar with most of these Morrison titles, but have not read them. And fittingly, I suppose, my only real hang-up in this solve was the DOS/SULA cross--because I did not read the DOS clue correctly.

Adding "Read a Toni Morrison novel" to the to-do list.

Had a small French vowels only theme in the Hidden Diagonal Word world today (EAU & OUI)!

Answers:
1. ROLL (starts with the R in 39D, OTTER, moves to SW--you might ROLL both eyes at this clue & answer)
2. BEES (B in 31D, BUMS ...tee-hee)

I can't call this puzzle the BEES KNEES, but I liked the concept and the construction.

kitshef 11:20 AM  

I do hope that you have a very nice birthday.

jb129 11:40 AM  

A nice tribute puzzle but no excitement - just filling in the grid.
Happy Birthday Andrew - I'm sure little Miss Diva has a kiss in store for you :)

jae 11:40 AM  

Medium mostly because I only knew half of the four MORRISON novels.

Me too for OwS before OYS.

Pretty good tribute puzzle, liked it.

Rich Glauber 11:45 AM  

I can't remember the last time I DNF on a Tuesday, but I was unfamiliar with the Bluest Eye, and I had LATEX for LAYER which gave me TAXBABY for TARBABY and AVA for EVA and BLUESTATE as the name of the book. Delightful misses as they all made sense. YEEHAH!

Anonymous 11:48 AM  

How many Taylor Swift fans, or, for that matter, non-Swifties, know that "Shake it Off" is IN G?

Gene 11:57 AM  

Proud of myself for completing this Downs Only. Recognized some titles on the way, but wasn't sure until I had enough crosses to fill in 55A.

Gary Jugert 12:03 PM  

@egsforbreakfast 10:26 AM
Seriously! The whole Tee-Hee paradigm has completely fallen apart during Joel's dictatorial rise to power. Either he was the slush pile editor and to amuse himself he purposefully sought out the LOO laughs, or, less likely, he's bought Thor's hammer on Ebay and is smashing the puzzles into ARSE-freeness. Whatever the source of the rapacious paucity ... can you tell I had breakfast with my goddaughter who's attending a wildly liberal college and parrots the lugubrious wordiness of her professors? ... whatever the reason, Tee-Hees in the puzzle are now coming almost exclusively from real grown-up words that I twist and torture into awkwardness. AROUSE, please, it's hardly worth trying when that's our raw (ehem) material.

A 12:07 PM  

I liked working a puzzle about Pulitzer Prize -winning literature. No complaints here. I wasn’t convinced this tribute puzzle was random, however, so I did a little investigating. The constructor probably wanted this to run last week, as a tribute to the 5th anniversary of TONI MORRISON’s death, August 5, 2019.

some of her quotes, as found on brainy quote.com:

“The ability of writers to imagine what is not the self, to familiarize the strange and mystify the familiar, is the test of their power.”

“If you're going to hold someone down you're going to have to hold on by the other end of the chain. You are confined by your own repression.”

“We die. That may be the meaning of life. But we do language. That may be the measure of our lives.”

Anonymous 12:50 PM  

The anniversary of her death was last Monday. Maybe the Editor decided it was too difficult for a Monday and THUS should run 8 days later - a typically SAD NYTXW editorial decision.

Teedmn 1:13 PM  

To my shame, I have never read a Toni Morrison novel. One excuse is that it's not sci fi/fantasy, my preferred genre. But mostly I think I need to become more mature in my reading. Perhaps once I'm retired (soon now, I hope) and now that I have a new library card, I can pursue these books I've failed to get into in the past.

So, like Rex, I liked the puzzle for its tribute to a worthy author. I didn't know JAZZ or TARBABY but the other works were familiar titles.

You don't see the word MARTYR in the grid often, MISHAP or SHUSH. And I enjoyed the Hawaiian bonus DUET of ALOHAS and LANAI (a word I always pass over too long in Spelling Bee).

Thanks, Benjamin Panico!

okanaganer 1:19 PM  

Solving down clues only I was totally mystified what the theme was until TONI MORRISON became evident. But then I thought: okay, 19 and 35 across are two of her books... pretty thin. But then I read the clue for the revealer and thought: holy moley, her first six books, and they are symmetrical! That is pretty amazing. All those other titles hiding in plain sight. Only TAR BABY was more than one word.

Les S. More 1:22 PM  

Like a number of commenters I know of TONIMORRISON but I have not read her. Working downs only I didn't even recognize most of the theme entries as book titles. SONGOFSOLOMON rang a bell but I wasn't sure why. And then, from a handful of crosses I filled in her name. Still couldn't see a theme. Words like JAZZ and BELOVED didn't jump out at me as book titles, just ordinary words. TARBABY, out of context, was quite jarring. THEBLUESTEYE was a total mystery and it wasn't until, like Rex, I finally plunked in RETURNTO, that I was able to fill in the U. SULA dropped in from crosses.

So I found it challenging, partly because of my ignorance of her body of work and partly due to my unfortunate decision to do this particular Tuesday downs only. But I enjoyed it and it was a nice tribute.

GILL I. 1:37 PM  

Am I blasphemous for not knowing any of these books other than BELOVED? And speaking of....That was my hardest one! I had BLOGS instead of VLOGS at 43D and so I stared for an eternity and wondered what she might've written about a BED? I know of TONI MORRISON through Oprah and I'm sure she writes beautifully but the last book I've had the time to read is George Stephanopoulos' "The Situation Room." Hardly any comparison.....or maybe there is?

So the huhs piled on. I don't know what a NANO iPad is. Why you clue a ZIT as a photographer focus. Why you clue ONLY as just. Who EVA is and why she's your BFF. So, I rated this weird....for a Tuesday....For moi...My experience ECHOes @pablito's. And now I want to play with an OTTER and hold hands and crack some fish on my belly with a rock and sing Kumbaya.

Les S. More 1:41 PM  

To clarify, I had THEBL_EST_YE, which made no sense until I got the U from RETURNTO.

A 1:54 PM  

Happy Birthday! If your recent "bucket list" adventures are any indication, you'll make the break even point!

bigsteve46 1:54 PM  

I am not an everyday reader of this blog ... but what happened to Nancy? She was by far the most interesting and likable of thedaily posters>

Jared 2:02 PM  

Who on Earth says "OY" when they're in pain? The only proper usage of "OY" is to get someone's attention (mainly in the UK or Australia), and in "oy, vey."

JC66 2:15 PM  

@Nancy quit the blog because she hates the new format.

Anonymous 2:16 PM  

What do you think OY, VEY means?

A 2:38 PM  

I'm so very sorry about Joe Dipinto. I found an obituary.

Thanks, @burtonkd, for letting us know. I'd been missing his posts, with his keen insights and quick wit. I always enjoyed his music links - they were eclectic and always top notch. He certainly helped to fill in some holes in my non-classical music education.

Here’s the audio link he had on his blogger profile page

The suggested (or maybe recently watched?) videos lower down the linked screen include two TED talks on the healing power of music and sound therapy. Coincidentally, I’ve been investigating vibration/sound/music therapies for a couple of friends, one of whom has Parkinson’s and the other has Ehlers-Danlos. Maybe Joe is continuing my education? Thanks, Joe.

BTW, also from his profile page is his favorite book, "The Green Paint Mystery.”

A 3:02 PM  

Found a comment by @Nancy on Joe's tribute page and immediately knew she must have told the group. Sure enough it was last month while I was traveling. Sorry for the late duplicate post, but I'll leave it in case others want to check out the link.

Anonymous 4:04 PM  

Perhaps it’s time for some folks to check out Toni Morrison? And perhaps that is the wish and prompt from the constructor? I am surprised by the lack of familiarity with her among this group of seemingly widely read folks.

jae 4:06 PM  

That should be six not four.

Anonymous 4:16 PM  

Yes, Rex, it's enough.

Anonymous 5:38 PM  

Heard of the author via crosswords, but have never heard of any of the books. All crossed fairly except in the NE, where I've also never heard of LANAI, and had EVR for #bestfriends4__, and thus couldn't parse ?A?E? (LAYER), THE BLUE STE?E nor TR?BABY. DNF on a Tuesday...first time in many months.

Anonymous 8:09 PM  

That was the easiest Tuesday for me ever. I read all of those books over 20 years ago.

Anonymous 10:17 PM  

This was one of my faster Tuesdays despite not having read any of her novels. The downs did it for me. Now I need to go read some TONI MORRISON.

RooMonster 10:53 PM  

@Teedmn
The greatest sci-fi book ever written is out now on barnesandnoble.com (OK, I'm sure Not the greatest... 😁) but it is written by me! Search Darrin Vail to find it. (It's called Changing Times.) It's a quick read at only 125 pages. I tried to make the story seem like it could maybe, sorta kinda happen, as in, it's not totally "sci-fi". I think I know what I'm trying to say!

Tell your friends, tell your family, hell, tell your enemies, go buy the book!

RooMonster At The Low Price of $15.95 Guy - Har.

Anonymous 5:18 AM  

Speaking of Martyr...I highly recommend Kaveh Akbar's book Martyr! So good and a unique writing style.

Jolan.False 11:21 AM  

Bless you, bless you, bless you for keeping Kirsty MacColl’s beautiful music in the conversation. Such a lovely voice from such a lovely soul. She deserves far more renown—by which I mean we as humans deserve to have all the joy that her music being more widely known would bring.

Anonymous 12:42 PM  

I’d heard of all six books except Jazz but didn’t know they were all by Toni Morrison. So that was a nice piece of information to learn from doing this puzzle; also I haven’t actually read any of the books in spite of some of them being highly acclaimed (not proud of this!) so learning what they are about was a plus too. Very nice to have a puzzle theme where you learn something worth knowing as opposed to some dumb puns or some such. So thank you Benjamin Panico!

Anonymous 2:28 AM  

I hate it when that happens!!

Anonymous 1:45 AM  

A soul?

  © Free Blogger Templates Columnus by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP