Sassy letter-shaped gesture accompanying a retort / SAT 7-1-23 / Chess ranking system named for a Hungarian physicist / George in aviation slang / German food that's better than it sounds / Classic Beat Generation roman a clef / Popular pet originally from Mongolia / Dutch scientist with an eponymous cloud / Disney villain inspired by drag queen Divine

Saturday, July 1, 2023

Constructor: Ben Tolkin

Relative difficulty: Extremely Easy


THEME: none 

Word of the Day: Divine (28A: Disney villain inspired by the drag queen Divine => URSULA) —

Harris Glenn Milstead (October 19, 1945 – March 7, 1988), better known by his stage name Divine, was an American actor, singer, and drag queen. Closely associated with independent filmmaker John Waters, Divine was a character actor, usually performing female roles in cinematic and theatrical productions, and adopted a female drag persona for his music career.

Born in Baltimore, Maryland, to a conservative middle-class family, Milstead developed an early interest in drag while working as a women's hairdresser. By the mid-1960s he had embraced the city's countercultural scene and befriended Waters, who gave him the name "Divine" and the tagline of: "The most beautiful woman in the world...almost." Along with his friend David Lochary, Milstead joined Waters' acting troupe, the Dreamlanders, and adopted female roles for their experimental short films Roman Candles (1966), Eat Your Makeup (1968), and The Diane Linkletter Story (1969). Again in drag, he took a lead role in both of Waters' early full-length movies, Mondo Trasho (1969) and Multiple Maniacs (1970), the latter of which attracted press attention for the group. Milstead next starred in Waters' Pink Flamingos(1972), which was a hit on the U.S. midnight movie circuit, became a cult classic, and established Milstead's fame in the American counterculture.

After starring as the lead role in Waters' next film, Female Trouble (1974), Divine moved on to theater, appearing in several avant-garde performances alongside San Francisco drag collective, The Cockettes. He followed this with a performance in Tom Eyen's play Women Behind Bars and its sequel, The Neon Woman. Continuing his cinematic work, he starred in two more of Waters' films, Polyester (1981) and Hairspray (1988), the latter of which represented his breakthrough into mainstream cinema and for which he was nominated for the Independent Spirit Award for Best Supporting Male. [...] 

Described by People magazine as the "Drag Queen of the Century", Divine has remained a cult figure, particularly within the LGBT community, and has provided the inspiration for fictional characters, artworks, and songs. (wikipedia)
• • •

Very short write-up today, as I am driving up to visit my wife at summer camp (i.e. the writing workshop she's attending in Saratoga Springs), and I want to get an early start (you can expect a shortish Sunday write-up too, as I will be exhausted from all the driving between now and then). This puzzle was so easy I got suspicious. I even stopped a couple of times like, "... OK, what's wrong here? Is there gonna be some dumb gimmick that jumps out at me, something where I suddenly realize every answer needs to be written in some special way in order to decode some ridiculous message about, I don't know, the 4th of July or something?" But no. No theme, no gimmick, just the easiest Saturday puzzle I've ever done. Or one of them (I've done a Lot, I can't honestly remember them all). The only answer that caused more than a slight hesitation was BAG End, which I flat-out couldn't remember (41A: ___ End (setting in "The Lord of the Rings")). I saw all those ponderous, humorless, painfully dull LOTR movies and remember virtually nothing about them. So my counterclockwise zip around the grid came to a stop there, but I just went back up top and headed out again, clockwise this time, and off I went again, with absolutely no resistance. It's eerie how easy this is. Is it being marketed to novice solvers with a big "You Can Do This, We Swear" sign, because seriously, get those Saturday-phobes in here to have at this one. You'll have trouble finding a more pliable Saturday in alllll the archives. I put the "S" in at the end of 1D: They're offered seven times a year (SATS), then immediately got CLASH (14A: Don't match). Tried to get 12D: First word in a 13-Across, but the cross-reference made it weird, so I went and got LLOYD'S (seriously, how does 13D: London-based insurance company make it into a Saturday puzzle—that's a Monday clue). After entering (the also perplexingly easy) CHEER and THOR, I went back to the cross-referenced clues and was able to infer that 13A: Present-day request? was a LETTER, and "present-day" made it obvious what kind of letter it was ...


From there, instead of following the LETTER into the east, I burned down the west coast and then back across the middle and south. I had a brief hesitation trying to turn the corner in the SW, as I miswrote Ray ROMANO's name as "ROMERO" (?) and also tried DOG SPA before DOG BED (36D: Certain creature comfort?). But once I got those answers sorted (10-15 seconds??), bam, off I went again—the first letters of those long Acrosses were all I needed to solve every one of them. I did a double take at EYELASH, since I was trying to write in EYELID (apparently both words are "correct" for this idiom). I then winced at ENIGMATOLOGY, which seemed like an embarrassing (though apparently successful) attempt to kiss up to the editor (who famously majored in "ENIGMATOLOGY," a major he invented—google the word and I guarantee you dude shows up on first page of results) (52A: Study of riddles). But one thing I didn't do was struggle. Ever. I mean, there's BAG End, but that wasn't struggle, that was just your ordinary "whoops, don't know this one, better work around it," which I did. I enjoyed the whoosh-whoosh, the Going Very Fast, and I think the top section is pretty good overall, but "SO I GATHERED" is the only answer that felt truly marquee-worthy, though LETTER TO SANTA and BATS AN EYELASH are decent as well. There's nothing wrong with this grid—it's very clean. And there's nothing wrong with having a beginner's level of difficulty on a Saturday every once in a while. Didn't have enough kick for me, but will likely prove delightful to those who really struggle to finish most Saturdays.


Stray comments:
  • 33A: Mulligan (REDO) — I know this as golf slang. I think it gets used in non-golf contexts now, though probably primarily by golfers (i.e. not me)
  • 7D: Outer ear? (HUSK) — ... of corn
  • 45A: NewLeaf Potato, e.g., in brief (GMO) — I wrote in GPS ... I figured maybe this was the GPS that the Nissan Leaf came with? Anyway, Ray Romero I mean ROMANO helped me fix it.
  • 27D: "George," in aviation slang (AUTOPILOT) — I did not know this. I like this. Next time you're doing things mindlessly, tell people you're "on George" and let them look at you funny and imagine what drug that is...
  • 25D: German food that's better than it sounds? (WURST) — yes! Make puns very bad! The badder the better. Why are some bad puns eye-rollers and groaners and others (like this one) just perfect? It's an enigma! 
Good day.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]

103 comments:

Son Volt 6:15 AM  

Handsome grid - those huge corners assist in the solvability of the puzzle. Smooth fill - liked the longs - the top stack shone with LETTER TO SANTA. Any unknowns went in with crosses. Not a Stumper by any means but a pleasant solve.

Wonderful REDWOOD tree

Iris 6:18 AM  

I’d have really enjoyed this on Tuesday. As it is I feel robbed.

RJ 6:51 AM  

I bet there will be many personal bests today. I actually love the LOTR books and movies, and listen to the audio version by Rob Inglis every year (he sings! he recites poetry!).

Anyway, it was over too quickly.

MaxxPuzz 6:55 AM  

Super easy!
I've only ever heard BAT AN EYE, i.e. minus the LASH. But of course that actually is the part that gets batted.
Enjoyed the same things as Rex, including the Monday-like whoosh. But this was certainly not Saturday level.

Anonymous 7:05 AM  

Finished in Tuesday/Wednesday time. Got a grin out of ‘so I gathered’, ‘dance routine’ and ‘so I gathered’. Whooshing around on a Saturday morning was fun!

Ann Howell 7:08 AM  

For me, it wasn't the "easiest Saturday ever", but still a very pleasant fill. Got held up at the top, mostly because had no idea about SATS, except that they are an American standardised test.

Anonymous 7:11 AM  

Safe travels. Tuesday with maybe a touch of Wednesday added in to the mix. Disappointed. I missed the Saturday morning fun.

Anonymous 7:13 AM  

For a moment I thought I had gotten my days mixed up. Disappointing for me, as I look forward to a challenge on Saturday.

Anonymous 7:14 AM  

FH
Technically, Lloyd's is not a company; it's a market.
I guess neither Ben Tolkin (any relation to J.R.R.?) nor Rex knew that.
Nor Will Shortz for that matter.

kitshef 7:23 AM  

Woof. Very, very easy for a Saturday. Took an early wrong turn with ‘christmaSlist’, quickly fixed, then flew few the rest with only ZSNAP (huh?) and ZONER (bad fill) causing any trouble.

Clue for 17A could just as easily have been “God who is destined to be slain by Jörmungandr”, as they will kill each other at Ragnarök.

Conrad 7:23 AM  


I didn't get quite the "Whoosh" that @Rex did but still easy-medium.

Only two overwrites:
crest before TOTEM for the ancestral emblem at 20D
cUTouTS before OUTLETS for the holes in the wall at 34D

Triple kealoa at 36D: cat, pet or DOG BED

AUTOPILOT (27D) and ENIGMATOLOGY (52A) were WOEs, but easily inferred

Question about 9D: Do we RING IN anything else besides a new year? Could the clue have been just "Celebrate a new year"?

SouthsideJohnny 7:43 AM  

I enjoyed being able to wander around the grid and actually fill things in with a degree of confidence for a change on a Saturday - so a big thumbs up from me for an easier one today. Enjoyed the fact that it was light on PPP as well - although I did crash and burn on my last square - had to choose between RaMANO/OaRT and ROMANO/OORT and I whiffed. Fortunately, I gave up worrying about messing up trivia crossing trivia a long time ago.

Today I learned that a shift DRESS is a thing. Unfortunately, even after researching on line, I couldn’t differentiate a shift from a sheath if you held a gun to my head, lol. Anyway, I would rather learn a little about a shift DRESS instead of parsing together the name of the seat of a random county in California for example, so thanks to the constructor for keeping the PPP count low (even though you got me with OORT). Hopefully I’ll remember that double-O the next time the Dutch dude or his cloud namesake shows up in a grid (hopefully in like 2032).

olfuddud 7:44 AM  

Anyone, what is the explanation for peeved (19D) being POD?

Lewis 7:45 AM  

Before even filling in square one, I admired the grid with those huge black photo-album corners. They gave the grid a simple uncomplicated feel, maybe because there are fewer than usual long answers. XwordInfo confirmed that this was a debut, and I experienced an OMG moment, which always comes when I realize I’m looking at a NYT puzzle *Saturday* debut, for heaven’s sakes.

I started out in a blaze, wondering if perhaps I was accidentally sent the simple-clue version of the puzzle, but ran into enough bite in the South to satisfy my brain’s work ethic.

Some post-solve observations.
• I liked the LOTR answer (BAG) from a constructor whose surname is one letter off from “Tolkien”, as well as seeing that LOTR answer crossing a backward OGRE.
• It was sweet to see the rare-in-crosswords five-letter semordnilap, STRAP, which makes for a nice PuzzPair© with BAG. Another nice pair that may ring with some: SGT. / BILK.
• I wondered how could such gorgeous answers as SO I GATHERED, LETTER TO SANTA, and DOCTOR’S NOTE never have appeared in the NYT puzzle in its 80 years, which they haven’t. Bravo, Ben!
• Speaking of gorgeous: that top stack.

Congratulations, Ben, on your debut, your *Saturday* debut. This was a charming outing for me – thank you! – and I eagerly hope for a sequel!

Andy Freude 7:49 AM  

Po’d = pissed off. Like many solvers today hoping for a Saturday challenge.

SouthsideJohnny 7:53 AM  

Took me a while before PO’D registered as well (Pissed Off). I thought I made a mistake at first.

MightyFine 8:01 AM  

Peeved for short - pissed off (po’d). Was a an easy Saturday but not unpleasant. Carpe diem.

Anonymous 8:08 AM  

Zsnap... Really? Yeah, that's the shape my hand traces out, but I say "oh snap" , with as much dripping sarcasm as I can muster. Otherwise one of my fastest Saturday solves ever.

Nancy 8:09 AM  

I found the solve quite enjoyable, even though I was surprised how easy it was for a Saturday. The enjoyment came from such clue/answers as LETTERS TO SANTA, AUTOPILOT, BATS AN EYELASH and ENIGMATOLOGY. I believe that the latter was the name of the "major" that Will Shortz chose -- and maybe even designed -- for himself at college. Is this the first time ENIGMATOLOGY has appeared in the NYTXW?

As a synonym for "flinch", I've only heard BATS AN EYELASH used as a negative: "And in the midst of all that mayhem, he never even batted an eyelash!" As a positive statement, BATS AN EYELASH means "flirt" and not "flinch" to me. "She batted her eyelashes at the handsome stranger across the room."

I spent a few fruitless minutes trying to imagine -- and then carry out -- a ZSNAP. I have no idea what it is or how to do one -- and I soon gave up.

Ben Tolkin gave us a breezy and entertaining puzzle. The fact that it was published on the wrong day isn't his fault. But it would have been easy even for a Friday -- and that's when it almost certainly should have appeared.

JHC 8:11 AM  

Is UNEASE and EASY technically not a dupe? It *feels* like a dupe.

Eater of Sole 8:13 AM  

Not quite a Saturday best for me, but close. I guess I don't mind an easy Saturday, I often get irritated by Saturday trying-too-hard or ponderously obscure clues, and really there was none of that today. Maybe I miss it a little... I learned "Z-SNAP" today and am not particularly happy about it.

Weezie 8:16 AM  

Safe travels, Rex. The wildfire smoke has been no joke for the last few days for we upstaters, sigh, but I also have to forgo the purified indoor air today to bring my pup down to NYC for his time with my ex (yes we share custody, modern life is strange).

Anyway, this puzzle. Yep, personal best time by a wide margin and not quite the fight I was hoping for today. It does seem that the NYT has an extra focus on making things more accessible to newer solvers between the “easy mode” debut and today’s puzzle, and if that’s indeed the rationale, I’m okay with it, occasionally. Some great phrases though, and a cute subtle nod to a “Christmas in July” type of pseudo theme. I really liked a lot of the trivia - most of which I knew but I hope other people enjoyed learning about the Divine-Ursula connection, for example!

Re: Anon’s comment about Llloyd’s being a market and not a company, my Certified Financial Planning program’s Insurance Planning textbook would disagree: “Lloyds of London is the most famous insurance company in the world providing unusual types of insurance. Lloyds is an insurance market of members that was founded in a coffee shop in 1688.” So it is *both* a company and a market, as I understand it. Things they’ve insured are Ben Turpin’s crossed eyes, Marlene Dietrich’s and Bruce Springsteen’s voices, Bette Davis’s waistline, Betty Grable’s and David Beckham’s legs, Keith Richards’s hands, and Dolly Parton’s breasts. They also do kidnap and ransom insurance. One of the most interesting parts of that whole class!

Oh and @olfuddud, POD = PO’D, aka pissed off, though I would probably spell it po’ed if I were to spell it at all. I feel like it’s something people tend to say rather than write but here we are.

Taylor Slow 8:18 AM  

@SouthsideJohnny: In general, a SHIFT dress is looser (and comfier) than a sheath, which is more "bodycon," as the kids say, fights more tightly and follows the curves of the body. Again in general, you'd be more likely to wear a shift to run errands and a sheath to a fancy cocktail party. Well, not *you*, necessarily, but one.

At 1D, having no idea what would be offered seven times a year (Where? What for?), I assumed it would be a typical Saturday. By the time I got to 11D, I had enough downs to fill in the first two long acrosses, and it was more or less smooth sailing from there. Not that I minded! Every once in a while, it's nice not to have to come up with the name of some obscure actor in some obscure TV show crossing the name of an 18th century Javanese emperor. Also, the clever cluing was enjoyable, even if the answers were easy: TOOLS, POD, DOG BED, LETTER TO SANTA, WURST.

I'm surprised that Rex so vehemently disliked the LOTR movies. Isn't he a Medievalist? Somehow I'd think he'd love the good-v-evil, Joseph Campbell-ness of it all. Maybe he liked the books, just hated the movies. I enjoyed all of it.

GAC 8:24 AM  

Blogger olfuddud said...
Anyone, what is the explanation for peeved (19D) being POD?
That would be pissed off where I grew up.
It was an easy Saturday, and my time would have been better if I hadn't fallen in love with ENIGMATheOrY.

andrew 8:25 AM  

POD = P.O.eD = Pissed Off.

While I’m at it…

DROLL = D ROLL = very minor footage used when camera crew can’t get decent B ROLL

EPICS = E PICS = JPEGs, GIFs

CHEER = CHE ER - where Senor Guevara died after being shot

IPASS = IP ASS - a dolt who boasts how he can secure your web connection.

Ok, enough of THIS hilarity.

Good puzzle. And thanks Son Volt for the sunny bolt of Van the Man!

Space Is Deep 8:37 AM  

Agreed, one of the easiest Saturday puzzles I can remember.

bocamp 8:38 AM  

Thx, Ben; CHEERs! 😊

Very easy (Wednes+ level).

Smooth solve; pretty much on Ben's w.l. all the way.

Enjoyable, laid-back puz; liked it a lot! :)
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness, Freudenfreude, Serendipity & a DAP to all 👊 🙏

thfenn 8:48 AM  

Congrats to all for whom this was so so easy, if not boring and disappointing. The fact I did it probably only proves your point but I got a workout and enjoyed it. Loved how the long acrosses slowly gelled as the shorter crosses went in. Enjoyed present switching from a sense of time to a gift, and recalling Kerouac, and learning who George is, and turning Mark into money. Felt stupid going with 'battery' for 5D, and ended up eating alphabet soup over at that DRESS and OORT pair until something seemed plausible, but I get to leap out of bed pleased with myself after this one. Happy weekend.

Bob Mills 8:49 AM  

I finished it in record time, only to discover I had carelessly put in "Bats one eyelash" instead of BATSANEYELASH. I agree it was very easy for a Saturday.

Will Shortz might not realize how many people know he invented ENIGMATOLOGY (at Indiana University?). Once that went in, the whole South section became very doable.

TAB2TAB 8:51 AM  

Pretty easy puzzle, no major slowdowns. Easy start to my Saturday.

The DEAR LETTER TO SANTA seems awkward or just plain old bad editing. DEAR SANTA LETTER would make perfect sense, just as a "Dear John letter" makes more sense than "Dear Letter to John". If I'm missing something, could someone clue me in?

Anonymous 8:54 AM  

Spent 25 years in aviation industry. Never heard "George" used in that manner. "Otto" is the obvious name for that device

TAB2TAB 8:57 AM  

For those of you struggling with Z snap, may I present:

https://youtu.be/W4L2lnTBV5Y

Nancy 9:00 AM  

@Beezer -- I left you a rather long comment on yesterday's blog -- very late.

For anyone else interested in yesterday's discussion about the various generations -- and who, exactly, belongs in which one -- you might find it interesting. It's a lament, actually -- a lament about the generation out of which some of us were unceremoniously and mysteriously ejected.

Dave from MI 9:01 AM  

So easy that my personal best for Saturday is now faster than those for Thurs or Fri. Definitely misplaced.

Anonymous 9:02 AM  

Thanks. Couldn’t figure out what kind of pod got angry.

Bam 9:04 AM  

Lloyds is an insurance market not a company.

Anonymous 9:17 AM  

I haven't done a puzzle in months,so this was just the thing to ease me back in.

RooMonster 9:35 AM  

Hey All !
I had the "whoosh" through 3/4 of this puz, but for some reason the North section took forever to figure out. Had up to CLASH, then the NE corner done, but the rest was sticking me good. Wanted rTe for ETA, lobe for HUSK. Finally started chipping away up there. Got ICE ... more staring ... DEAR ... staring ... BaLK ... erased my rTe and lobe ... thought of HUSK ... finally seeing LETTERTOSANTA, and then was able to get the rest. Dang.

So time was 28 minutes, which was 14 for everything but the North. Half the time! Yikes.

Nice SatPuz here. Anytime I can whoosh on a Saturday is fine by me. 😁

ZSNAP. Har. Took me a minute to figure it out, but it's the maneuver done when you snap your fingers sassily back and forth three times, ala make a Z in the air. Tried to find an embed link, but didn't.

Anyway, have a great weekend, y'all.

No F's (DROLL, I tell ya)
RooMonster
DarrinV

Scott 9:37 AM  

Everyone saying how easy it is confirms my crossword illiteracy. When people get very skilled in the art they can forget just how skilled they are.

egsforbreakfast 9:38 AM  

According to DOCTOR SNOTE, if God wanted bats to have vision, then he would give bats an eye and give BATSANEYELASH or two.

Isn’t ZSNAP redundant since you always catch some Zs while you nap? I’m POD that @Z isn’t here to clarify.

Real nice debut, Ben Tolkin.

Anonymous 9:38 AM  

Hmm, I thought for sure we’d get an explanation for OORT. Or at least something in the comments. But I guess everyone knows what an “Oort Cloud” is except me, so off to Google I go!

Anonymous 9:53 AM  

Another among the PO'd that this was our Saturday puzzle.

I set a personal best, but it's not worth much to halve my previous best on this misplaced featherweight that would be a nice Tues/Wed puzzle. I should not be able to do a Saturday under 6 mins.

Anonymous 9:58 AM  

Pissed off

Anonymous 10:04 AM  

Meant to be read PO’d, “pissed off.”

Newboy 10:07 AM  

What Rex said!

Fastest solve this week after a stunning moment as I gazed at those triple stacks. Didn’t know ELO or AUTOPILOT as clued, but crossing filled easily. Mystified by Z SNAP, but have seen it often in hipster tv contexts.

Nice debut Ben, always delighted to see a new face appear on xwordinfo.

Visho 10:10 AM  

Very nice puzzle, but not for Saturday. I feel robbed.

Joe Dipinto 10:10 AM  

Yes, this was insanely easy. Jumped right in with DANCE ROUTINE and there were no stops along the way, no corrections to make, anything I couldn't guess fell into place in spite of itself.

So, disappointed by its not being harder, but I still enjoyed it.

@TAB2TAB – DEAR is typically the first word written in a LETTER TO SANTA:
"Dear Santa..."
(Though some people go with a less formal salutation)

Anonymous 10:28 AM  

If you love LOTR check out the BBC theater of the air production starring Ian Holm as Frodo. Far and away the best adaption of the books.

Joseph Michael 10:31 AM  

Crashed at the intersection of ROMANO and OORT, but enjoyed the puzzle anyway and look forward to more puzzles from Ben Tolkin.

Wondering if it’s a coincidence that a constructor with a missing “e” in his last name gave us a “Lord of the Rings” clue. Hmm. Perhaps it’s a matter for an enigmatologist.

In addition to being a way to say “Skip me,” IPASS is also the tollway payment system in Illinois.

Am familiar with the sassy gesture accompanying a retort, but didn’t know it had an official name.

Anonymous 10:35 AM  

Too easy. I want a challenge on Saturdays. Disappointed.

Jeremy 10:35 AM  

Add me to the fastest-Saturday-solve-ever crowd. Actually, this one came together for me faster than every puzzle this week other than Monday’s. It was still fun, but gone too soon.

Carola 10:38 AM  

Fun! But not at all easy for me: I got the Saturday workout most of you missed (hi, thfenn 8:48), along with the satisfying high of finishing. I really enjoyed figuring it all out.

Do-overs: ore before ICE and rte before ETA, giving me two incorrect letters in the three long Acrosses UP TOP and really fouling up any chances of pattern recognition (which I rely on a lot). Also, Z-Sign, although I wondered about SNAP, an expression I know only from crosswords.

Re: WURST - it's an important enough element of German culture to figure in all kinds of expressions. For example, in a tense situation when all hangs in the balance: "Es geht um die Wurst!" (literally, the wurst is at stake). Also, when someone is ailing, an expression of commiseration equivalent to "Poor thing!" is "Arme Wurst!"

bocamp 10:40 AM  

@Scott (9:37 AM)

Right on! 👍 Everything's relative. 🤔 Keep truckin'; you'll improve over time. 🤗
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness, Freudenfreude, Serendipity, & a DAP to all 👊 🙏

Suzy 10:45 AM  

Thank you, Ben, for a very pleasant Sat morning experience! I see nothing wrong with an occasional easier
solve on a Saturday, especially one clued so well! Keep up the good work!

Anonymous 10:47 AM  

Lloyd’s itself doesn’t insure anything though - it sets the market rules for the underwriters that actually write the risks. That’s why the policies are with “Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s of London”.

jberg 10:50 AM  

Easy, except I have no idea what a Z SNAP is. Is that those slashes Zorro used to make, but without cutting anything?

But the easiness was probably luck, just happening to see the long answers. @TAB2TAB, the clue for 12-D is "First word in a 13-across," not first word in the answer to 13-across. A LETTER TO SANTA starts with DEAR Santa... That clue actually opened up the puzzle for me, getting my mind off a new pair of Svarovski binoculars.

Gotta stick up for the OORT cloud here. It gives us comets! Nothing trivial about that.

@Rex, forget those movies and read the books!

Anonymous 10:58 AM  

I work in insurance with Lloyd’s… it is a market not a company

Tom T 10:58 AM  

Yep, extremely easy for me, too. Best Saturday time and only second Saturday ever under 20 minutes.

Tom P 11:03 AM  

Easy but enjoyable Saturday puzzle, just the thing for a lazy holiday weekend. I finished with a bit of a Natick at the ZSNAP/ZONER cross, but after going through the entire alphabet, decided that Z was the only letter that made sense. And now I know what a ZSNAP is, thanks to TAB2TAB.

MP 11:14 AM  

Personal best indeed, easily, and I wasn't even trying to solve for speed. I was really hoping to come here, find a routine write-up, and have my amazing genius confirmed. Dammit Rex...

GILL I. 11:17 AM  

Here is my fantasy: I want to dance through a Saturday and then have every one clap. I want our band leader, @Rex, to declare that this was challenging to assemble. Then...I want the audience to say they couldn't DANCE this fandango tango - it was way too difficult!.....
A girl can dream, can't she.
Sometimes at night and just before bed, I'll pour myself a drink, sit down to my music and figure that my Saturday puzzle time will take at least an hour or maybe more. It gives me time to relax, to think mightily, to enjoy only having to call Google 2 or 3 times and to sense that I'm getting better and that one day I will conquer all Saturdays with only the wave of my wand.
Last night, my wand swished through the air and I was done.
Z SNAP was probably my favorite answer. My 5 year old granddaughter does a good imitation. Then I thought of all the snapping in West Side Story. We do snap a lot, don't we.
I learned that the OORT cloud is a vast cloud composed of icy planetesimals and it was named after Jan OORT. Something I will forget after my coffee.
I also liked seeing DROLL, @Nancy likes the word and now, I do too. When I first heard it I thought it meant boring. Why am I being called DROLL?
And finally: DOCTORS NOTE. I never got one of those. My NOTE was always from me. I was a master at forging my moms signature. I even gave my self pneumonia. I misspelled it. I'm sure the schools nurse thought Mom was an idiot. We laughed years later - well, I did.
In all, I enjoyed this quickie. It's good to feel good.

.


jae 11:18 AM  

Yep, very very easy. No erasures and BAG as clued (hi @Rex) was it for WOEs. Great looking grid, liked it but not even close to a Saturday. Nice debut.

Whatsername 11:20 AM  

I’m not gonna complain about this being “too easy” because I’m still UP TOP on cloud nine at having finished a Saturday without a single cheat. Congratulations to you Ben, for a most excellent debut! While it may have been more appreciated if it had run on a different day, everyone knows that’s not your call, ERGO not on you.

Although I’ve seen it done many times, had no idea there was an actual term for the ZSNAP but was delighted to learn. And ENIGMATOLOGY was a real EYELASH opener too. Also learned that an AUTOPILOT may be referred to as “George” - another thing I never heard of after 30+ years of being involved with aviation and aviators. I googled him SO I GATHER he’s been around a while.

mathgent 11:20 AM  

I enjoyed it. Twelve red plus signs in the margins, more than for most recent Saturdays.

Santa's DROLL little mouth delighted me. I memorized The Night Before Christmas when I was little.

Pleased to hear that I have some company in being bored by the LOTR movies.

Whatsername 11:20 AM  
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous 11:47 AM  

Wow. Solved this in my usual Wednesday time.

What makes this a Saturday, other than the day it was published?

jb129 11:47 AM  

I always check the blog first for Rex's rating (just his rating, not the puzzle!) - in this case "extremely easy" & then go on to solve. So when I didn't swoosh through this, I got angry with myself cause my brain was already in the "extremely easy" mode.

Today was an easy, enjoyable puzzle for a Saturday. Nice debut, Ben.

I'm just not gonna check Rex's take on them first thing anymore!

Whatsername 12:00 PM  

@Nancy (9:00) After seeing your comment, I went back to read yesterday’s discussion about the generational labels and the unique qualities of each and especially enjoyed your post to @Beezer last night. Yes very true. And as one whose life was profoundly influenced by the historic events you mentioned, I resent those 1960’s born youngsters thinking they even remotely had the same experiences as I did. The nerve!

Masked and Anonymous 12:05 PM  

Relieved to hear that I wasn't the only gerbil in the comment pen to find this SatPuz solvequest extra-easy-goin. Was briefly concerned, that I had grown some new ultra-super-brain lobe extension last night, while I slept. Examined head closely in mirror, but saw no new lumps. Nor new ability to move objects just with my mind.

Sooo … this Sat Puz was really different. Like different. Also greatly esteemed the puzgrid's only-previously-dreamed-of Mega Jaws of Themelessness. Only a 66-worder, maybe partly thanx to the Jaws gobblin up so many gridsquares.
themelessthUmbsUp.

fave moo-cow eazy-E SatPuz clue: {Right on a map} = EAST.
staff weeject pick: POD. Perfectly sound word turned into a funky, for-shorty meaning. Cool move. M&A was not POD.

some faves: Four ?-marker clues that were all pretty easy to see thru to their answers. Learnin all about the mysterious ZSNAP. LETTERTOSANTA/DEAR. ENIGMATOLOGY [way to sell a puz to the Shortzmeister!]. SOIGATHERED. BATSANEYELASH.

Thanx for the temp solver ego-boost, Mr. Bag-End Tolkin dude. And congratz on a mighty impressive debut.

p.s. Drive safe, @RP dude. Do the kitties get to come along for the ride?

**gruntz**

Anonymous 12:12 PM  

As a student at the London School of Economics, I was fortunate to be invited for and to enjoy a tour of Lloyds of London. I was getting an LL.M rather than anything in Econ or similar courses. I never was quite sure what that company actually does. It’s not like you get fire or auto insurance, I think it has something to do with re- insurance whatever that is. The people who worked there were wonderful. They insisted I go to lunch with several bigwigs to the Cheshire Cheese where I sat at same table where Dr. Johnson sat with Boswell across the table.
Are you sure Shortz invented “enigmatology ?” I am retired law prof from Indiana University. I was under impression that the provost or its equivalent invented it.

Anonymous 12:58 PM  

Dear is the first word in the letter to Santa - not the first word in the phrase ‘letter to Santa.’

mathgent 1:00 PM  

Joaquin's Dictum being ignored again. LLOYDS is both a company and a market.

Beezer 1:04 PM  

I started the puzzle with my usual Saturday feeling of, “I’ll never finish this,” and I had to go all the way to CLASH before I put anything in. Switched to downs, then all of a sudden things took off and BOOM I was done! I echo @whatsername with the Cloud 9 sentiment.

@Nancy, good response last night! And speaking of generations…how about the Beat Generation?

johnk 1:06 PM  

I was like Rex, suspicious because it was too easy, starting with THRU, CHEER, LLOYDS, DEAR and SATS. Or at least SO I GATHERED at that point. But I got hung up in the mid-South, trying to remember how to spell OCULUS for holes in the wall. So I began to think that the constructor deliberately made it easy UP TOP only to PREY ON us at the bottom. That problem lasted less than a minute, when it became EASY.
I live in a 100-yr-old Sears kit house. That actually made this puzzle fun.

Anonymous 1:21 PM  

The answers aren’t meant to be read together. DEAR is the first word in a LETTER TO SANTA — i.e. Dear Santa, Please bring me a…

Ben 1:59 PM  

If someone "bats an eye," they are flinching. If someone BATSANEYELASH, they are flirting.

Agree with Rex, this was a startlingly easy Saturday -- usually I'm happy if I can finish Saturday in under 20 mins, and today I clocked in at 8:29

Anonymous 2:59 PM  

A sheath fits closely. A shift has no waist - falls straight from the shoulders - might bag.

Made in Japan 3:03 PM  

I put in POD early on and it looked ugly, so I assumed it was wrong, though admittedly POED wouldn't have looked any better. Eventually, of course, it became clear that my original guess was correct. It's probably best not to use this clue when others are available.

Gene 3:17 PM  

Interesting that I started exactly the same way as Rex, with that S, and CLASH, ... Agree this was a very easy Saturday, nut the long answers were good.

Christopher Castoro 3:36 PM  

Aw, gee Rex. I was so happy to have solved a Saturday NYT XWord with absolutely no help and you go and tell the world how easy it was! Aw, gee.

Hartley70 3:45 PM  

I loved this puzzle and it made me happy. I don’t care what day of the week it is because half the time I have to ask someone anyway. I was doing the ZSNAP for a while before I could figure out what to call it to fit in the squares and the Dutch scientist slayed me. I consider this puzzle a holiday weekend gift.

Anonymous 4:12 PM  

Novice here…can someone explain STRAP? I’m puzzled by it. Many thanks!

Scrub 4:53 PM  

I think if you weren't a pilot in the airline industry specifically (which I happen to be), "George" wouldn't be familiar to you, even if you had a lot of other experience with aviation. The context in which you usually hear it is something like: "Okay, time for George to take over." "I'm taking it back from George now." "What is George doing? Final is a half-mile that way!" etc. Pretty industry-specific clue! And otherwise, as Rex noted, an absurdly easy Saturday.

CDilly52 4:54 PM  

Idioms are so much fun! To me one who barely responds wouldn’t “BAT AN EYE.” One who is cold and insensitive or able to respond to anything dangerous or gruesome is one who never “BATS AN EYELASH.”

I had some trouble with this one. First if all, I learned that a Z-SNAP is a “thing.” Apparently “a sassy response.” Guess I need to spend some time around teenagers.

I also don’t keep track of how often college SAT tests are offered, and I really thought that peeved was HOT. When it got corrected, I still couldn’t figure out what a vegetable POD would have to do with being peeved. Took me too long to figure out “oh, PO’D!” I rarely hear or use the shortened version. Brain Slowness due spring sinus infection. That’s my story and I’m stickin’ to it!

This plated slower for me than for many others apparently. I don’t call it difficult, but a couple tough one in conjunction with my sinus infection and the fact that I was also watching OL Reign NWSL match slowed me down. Enjoyable though because I like to see some long stacks on a Saturday and this was relatively junk free! Good one.

Anoa Bob 5:02 PM  

I think a relatively easy puzzle can still be a very good puzzle and one that is enjoyable to solve. I thought most of the entries were interesting, in the language ones and I had fun with this one.

The clue for 2D "Classic Beat Generation roman á clef" caught my eye. I've seen that before but brew a blank trying to remember what it meant. When the answer ON THE ROAD filled in, I still wasn't sure. Must look into that.

Maybe it's because I was a SONAR Technician in the Navy but I balked when the answer to 43D "Bat signal" turned out to be SONAR. The bat's "signal" is a high frequency squeaking sound. SONAR is an acronym for SOund NAvigation and Ranging. A "signal" is part of a SONAR system but SONAR itself is not a "signal". I give that clue-answer duo a couple of heart-felt Z SNAPpers.

EDDIE 5:19 PM  

THANK YOU FOR MAKING ME FEEL SUBORDINATE TO ALL WHO WERE “CHEATED” BY A PUZZLE I CAN SOLVE. GEESH!

Liam Montgomery 5:25 PM  

Todays email newsletter from NYT is all about how to get started doing puzzles and invites the reader to try one out. Voila, the easy Saturday.

Anonymous 5:36 PM  

Emily

Anonymous 5:37 PM  

Which I thought was a bit racy!!

Anonymous 5:42 PM  

I wanted the Ray to be RACHEL, which fit & totally honked me up!

Anonymous 5:57 PM  

ZSNAP PO’d me. I kept thinking it was an L Snap for Loser. Didn’t know why the city planner was a Loser.

bocamp 6:02 PM  

@Anonymous (12:12 PM) wrote:

"Are you sure Shortz invented “enigmatology ?” I am retired law prof from Indiana University. I was under impression that the provost or its equivalent invented it."

Chat GPT wrote:

"The term "enigmatology" was actually coined by a fellow puzzle enthusiast and Indiana University (IU) student named Neil Fredrick, who founded the Enigmatology and Puzzle Design program at IU in the early 1970s. Neil Fredrick and Will Shortz were both students at Indiana University at the time, and they shared a passion for puzzles and games."

I could find no evidence of this on the web – admittedly a cursory search, finding mostly mentions of Will. Did come across a book, 'Enigmatology: The Science of Puzzles' by Marcel Danesi who writes: "The field that aims to study puzzles scientifically is called enigmatology - a term coined by Will Shortz in 1974 as a student at Indiana University…". I replied to Chat GPT with this information and got the following response:

"I apologize for any confusion caused by my previous response. Thank you for providing the excerpt from Marcel Danesi's book, "Enigmatology: The Science of Puzzles." I appreciate your diligence in seeking validation for the information provided.

It appears that the term "enigmatology" was indeed coined by Will Shortz in 1974 while he was a student at Indiana University, as stated in the book. The term refers to the scientific study of puzzles and has since been used to describe the academic discipline centered around puzzles and problem-solving."

NOTE: ChatGPT does commit the occasional gaff (and sometimes comes up with some pretty wild stuff), so needs to be vetted. For the most part, I find it pretty much on target.

I did wonder, tho, about the origin of term itself (outside of the IU course Will was instrumental in creating); seems like it would have been a likely candidate for coinage much earlier than the '1970s, so did an Ngram search and came up with a number of matches for 'enigmatology' from as early as 1800, one of which is The Gentleman's Diary (1800 p. 18)

So, bottom line for me is: this whole 'enigmatology' coinage thing may be somewhat of an enigma in and of itself. 🤔
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness, Freudenfreude, Serendipity, & a DAP to all 👊 🙏

Anonymous 6:40 PM  

Seems that everyone else found this super-easy. I thought it was a horrendous hash of crap! I guess everyone else knows all about Dutch people who have clouds named for them, Hungarian chess ranking systems, and airline-pilot insider lingo.

And "enigmatology"? That's utterly bogus.

IMO this was an absolute dog's-dinner of a puzzle that didn't rise to the level of being published in the Times.

Beezer 7:37 PM  

Wow, @anonymous 6:40pm. Tell us what you REALLY think cuz I think you might have held back…

dgd 7:48 PM  

Definitely a type of dupe but it doesn’t bother Shortz so this type is no longer verboten. I thought someone would note tire and entire crossing , another type of dupe that doesn’t bother Shortz.
Personally, I didn’t notice the easy dupe and it doesn’t bother me after the fact. But entire and tire crossing clanged a little for me.
Liked the puzzle over all but it was easy medium for me.

andrew 8:20 PM  

@anon 4:12

https://www.thefreedictionary.com/Boot+Straps

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaghetti_strap

dgd 9:12 PM  

I hope people don’t mind me mentioning the discussion about “generations” in American from yesterday as Nancy did bring it up today.
I think she is forgetting the origins of the term boomers.
These named generations were created as concepts as a reaction to a major historical events The first one I could think of offhand is the Lost Generation which really was a reflection on the trauma caused by WW I.
Immediately AFTER the end of WW II, there was a huge upsurge in the birth rate. This was noticed. From this social phenomenon came the term for my generation. In fact original term for us was BABY Boomers Note we seem to have lost the important word baby from the term.
Sociologists charted the boom and noted it ended around 1963,
That is why January 1, 1946 through December 31, 1963 are the dates chosen to define us baby boomers.
It originally had nothing to do with the rebellious 1960’s. The fact that we were so numerous is the key distinction.
People like to simplify and so rebelliousness could only be assigned to boomers. That is absurd. Nancy is not a boomer because she was born before the boom , but the Black student activists in the early 1960’s were born in Nancy’s group as were those who started the Free Speech movement in California.
So the Silent Generation wasn’t silent at all, at least the younger ones. The name of Nancy’s generation is the problem not the reality
Remember us boomers have Trump!

maverick 10:00 PM  

Lol, hardest Friday for me in recent memory... Easiest Saturday, from scanning the comments and Rex, seems like that's perhaps prevalent. Why not at least switch those? Though, this seems it would be crazy easy for Friday, too. Maybe experiences will differ, but it seems pretty obvious that competent people would switch those. *shrug*

Bunnifer 1:19 PM  

@Nancy To “zsnap”
Using your right hand, start high and to your left, SNAP
Move to the high right, SNAP
Back to the left, but low, making a diagonal line, SNAP
The back to the right, but low, SNAP
You’ve now created an imaginary Z formation in the air.

spacecraft 9:38 AM  

Well, ZSNAP was a serious outlier for me, but luckily the crosses were undeniable. All the rest of it was, for a Saturday, super-EASY.

Still fun to do, though, and a cool debut. Birdie.

Wordle eagle!

Burma Shave 12:03 PM  

EROTIC ROUTINE

URSULA's IN THE STRAP less DRESS again,
and SO TO LLOYD BATSANEYELASH,
she's ONTHEROAD TO AMBUSH EURO men;
she'll BAG THE DOCTOR with no CLASH.

--- SGT. COLE ROMANO

Diana, LIW 12:04 PM  

Another difficult start leading to a smooth finish.

Seemed like a Wednesday puz.

And yes, @Spacey, never heard of the Z before the SNAP. It maketh sense, tho.

Lady Di

rondo 12:18 PM  

I had ZSign at first but EASY to fix. Otherwise clean. Noticed: PREYON ONTHEROAD; 32d clue = So, 1a answer = SOIGATHERED. SHODDY CELTS in the corners. URSULA anDRESS anyone?
Wordle birdie.

  © Free Blogger Templates Columnus by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP