1995 Coolio song featured in the film "Dangerous Minds" / THU 7-13-23 / Scarlett's first love in Gone With the Wind / Effecting fundamental changes to perceptions / Group of computers commandeered by a cyberattack / Pataky of the Fast & Furious franchise / Mayberry boy of classic TV

Thursday, July 13, 2023

Constructor: Hanh Huynh

Relative difficulty: Medium


THEME: PARA- to "Pair of" — words that start with "PARA-" are clued straight but represented in the grid as a visual pun, where the latter part of the word is literally a "pair of" ... something. Each "pair" appears as side-by-side rebus squares:

Theme answers:
  • "GANGSTA'S DIE DIE" (i.e. "Gangsta's Paradise") (16A: 1995 Coolio song featured in the film "Dangerous Minds")
  • LOGICAL DOC DOC (i.e. "logical paradox") (23A: "This statement is false," for one)
  • BULL BULL OF JESUS (i.e. Parables of Jesus) (46A: "The Good Samaritan" and "The Prodigal Son," for example)
  • SHIFTING DIME DIME (i.e. "shifting paradigms") (57A: Effecting fundamental changes to perceptions)
Word of the Day: NISEI (5D: American-born Japanese) —
Nisei (二世, "second generation") is a Japanese-language term used in countries in North America and South America to specify the ethnically Japanese children born in the new country to Japanese-born immigrants (who are called Issei). The Nisei are considered the second generation, and the grandchildren of the Japanese-born immigrants are called Sansei, or third generation. (Ichi, ni, san are Japanese for "one, two, three"; seeJapanese numerals.) (wikipedia)
• • •

In college, my friend Malcolm and his friend John invented a drinking game called WITNEY. I don't remember how you played, but I remember it as elaborate, and I remember it involved dice. The main way I remember it involved dice was that Malcolm actually had WITNEY merchandise made, specifically, bumper stickers. The bumper stickers read: "WITNEY: When You Say It, Play It" (a play on "When You Play It, Say It" stickers that would appear on promotional copies of music to remind DJs to tell the audience what they were playing). Now, when Malcolm ordered the bumper stickers, he told the printer what it should say, and then said that following the slogan, there should be "two dice"— that is, a picture of a pair of dice. But what came back from the printers didn't have a picture of dice. Instead, the bumper stickers read, "WITNEY: When You Say It, Play It — TWO DICE!" With "TWO DICE!" written out like that. Ridiculous. Nonsensical. Perfect. I had one on my car for 16 years. Anyway, I smiled hard when I got the first themer today, both because I thought the concept was great, and because it reminded me of being young and stupid. 


The first two themers are stronger than the last two. Something about the phrase "Parables of Jesus" feels clunky—the OF JESUS part specifically. I know they're parables, I knew the word would be "parables," but the phrase "[Parables] OF JESUS" ... yes, it's a thing, but it just didn't seem as tight as the first two themers. The "of Jesus" part feels slightly redundant. Also, I went looking for the "parables" at the end of the phrase, since that's where the pairs appeared up top. After getting the [Parables] one, I thought for sure the last themer would have its pair at the beginning of the answer too, to make it all even out. But no. Back to the end of the answer, making the [Parables] answer that much clunkier. I also don't love SHIFTING [Paradigms] because the phrase—the phrase that everyone knows, the phrase that would look great in any grid—is "paradigm shift." That is a thing. "SHIFTING [Paradigms]" feels like a thing that was granted "thing" status only after much special pleading by lawyers. And yet even the drop in themer quality from top to bottom couldn't significantly diminish my enjoyment of this puzzle. The theme is bold and silly and inventive. Tricky, but not overly so. Good clean fun!


I got the concept very early because I knew the Coolio song. Dead to rights, without question. And it wouldn't fit (obviously). And so I started doubting that I knew the Coolio song. "How are they gonna get 'paradise' in there? Is "Eden" involved somehow? What the hell...?" And then the puzzle just handed me the answer by making one of the "DIE" crosses an absolute gimme: I've watched Groundhog Day more times than I can count, so ANDIE MacDowell is a very familiar name (and face) (6D: Actress MacDowell). So she gave me the "DIE"—and revealed the theme concept to me. I thought "they can't keep up this 'paradise' thing for a whole puzzle, can they? Where are they gonna go? DIE DIE LOST? DIE DIE BY THE DASHBOARD LIGHTS?" But no, they went on to other pairs, probably for the best. 


Hardest part wasn't really hard, just kind of sloggy, and it had everything to do with that stupid "[Parables] of JESUS" answer (sorry, Jesus). Well, it connected to that, anyway. I had -US at the end of that word and couldn't do anything with it, and I also couldn't bring the cavalry down out of the middle to help out because I was stuck on 36A: Like Canadian provinces vis-à-vis U.S. states. I had the -WER part but ??? ... LOWER (in temperature)? RAWER (... in temperature)? Normally I had musical key clues, and I probably still do, but today EMAJ ended up being the key (...!) to my setting the center straight (37D: Key of Rossini's "William Tell" Overture: Abbr.). Once I got RNA, I knew the key had to be MAJ, which meant that "J" was solid, which meant JESUS came to me (hallelujah). Also, the second letter in -WER had to be "A" or "E" and as soon as I entertained "E," I considered NEWER (???) but finally alit on FEWER. What a bizarre clue for FEWER. Especially bizarre since it gave me way more trouble than the tricky theme element. 


FANFESTS was a bit hard because I just think of nerdy gatherings as just "cons" now (36D: New York Comic Con and Treklanta, for two). FANFESTS is kind of a generic term, but it's a term alright, and I like it ... just couldn't get hold of it for a bit (partly because it runs right through the Canadian province and Jesus trouble spots, see above). IS OFF, the answer that comments on itself! Nice. But yeah, not great. I wanted DESKS before BUSES (41A: School lineup). Didn't know ELSA but did know RAINN so it all balances out somehow. In the end, difficulty level normal, enjoyment level high. Really wish there had been a plausible way to work SAUL SAUL into the grid, but it's pretty good as is. That's all. See you tomorrow.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]

106 comments:

frankbirthdaycake 6:30 AM  

I thought this puzzle was a lot of fun. It took me a minute to figure out the gimmick, and the rest flowed nicely. I believe this is the first NYT crossword for the constructor – it that’s true, bravo!

Anonymous 6:37 AM  

For some reason I tried to get the last themed to be SHIFTINGparagons. So I had trouble w 50D and 51D as I attempted to fit “gone” somehow. Same as Rex for 46A - I knew these were parables and tried to put BULL at the end . I actually am familiar with GANSTSTASPARADISE only because Weird Al Re did it as Amish Paradise. Got the theme from ANDIE and EDDIEBAUER , they were easy enough. After that I, too, was gearing up for a Meatloaf song. Great puzzle , perfect Thursday. Thanks Hanh.

SouthsideJohnny 7:03 AM  

Ugh, I don’t know how many of us will be in the “down on this one” category today, but boy oh boy it was just not for me. Starting off with a trivia question at 1A never seems to be a good omen for me. Then parsing my way through more trivia (a song title that I never heard of to arrive at the two trivial rebus downs AUDIE and EDDIE) and it was pretty much game over. I floundered through the “normal” Xword stuff until the BULLS OF JESUS pretty much stuck the fork in it.

Too bad, it probably could have been fun, but oh so not on my wavelength today.

Anonymous 7:05 AM  

Yes, a lot of fun—especially the full MONTY!
I didn’t know Gangsta’s Paradise, but the downs had to be ANDIE and EDDIE BAUER, so that fell into place easily. Thanks, Hanh Huynh. I hope we see more from you soon.

kitshef 7:10 AM  

Today I learned that the 'Monty' in the full Monty is not spelled the same as in three-card monte. DNF with that + ASHLEY being unknown to me, although I probably should have realized that ASHLEe was a more modern spelling.

Very enjoyable theme. Yes, knowing GANGSTAS PARADISE helped get it early. Unlike Rex, I actually put in nEWER for Canadian Provinces vs. US States, and correcting that when nANFESTS looked so odd was my last square.

Conrad 7:11 AM  


I hate Thursday puzzles, largely because I hate rebodes. I wasn't familiar with GANGSTA'S PARADISE, but I got GANGSTAS[DIE][DIE] and figured GANGSTAS DIE was a reasonable name for a Coolio song and the theme was going to be "Rebodes duplicated for no reason." I then solved it as a Thursday themeless, ignoring the clues for the long acrosses. It wasn't until after the happy music that I got what it was all about. Medium for a Thursday.

According to Allan Sherman:
A Paranoia is a bunch of mental blocks
And when Ben Casey meets Kildare that's called a paradox.
...
[T]wo canaries make a pair -- they call it a parakeet.
A paramecium is not a pair.
A parallelogram is just a crazy square.

Bob Mills 7:24 AM  

Very clever.

Anonymous 7:25 AM  

Even after reading Rex’s explanation I still don’t get it. Ah well…

Son Volt 7:28 AM  

Fantastic Thursday- neat trick and fun to solve. Had issues with 47d - they’re the “Dawgs” and no idea with RAINN but for the most part well filled and splashy. LUAUS and SANTA x GUAVA is neat and liked the SINE - TRIG combo.

MOBY Grape

Andy Freude 7:34 AM  

I’m with @Conrad on rebodes/rebi/rebuses — and on Allan Sherman.
Glad Rex had an opportunity to remember being young and stupid. I get those reminders regularly, about as often as I get reminders that I’m now old and . . . never mind.

Lewis 7:35 AM  

Oh, a very impressive debut, with a strong presence of smart/tough cluing, hardly a whiff of junk, and a shimmering theme. That theme brought not only a huge aha when I discovered it, but also a huge grin at the “para” wordplay.

I liked Hanh’s decision to go with actual words to put into the rebus squares, for instance, having DIME/DIME instead of DIGM/DIGM, or BULL/BULL rather than BLE/BLE.

I also like that only one of the theme answers, BULL/BULL OF JESUS, had the rebuses come at the answer’s start rather than the end. That was a lovely misdirect for me, making it harder to get, because I was looking in the wrong place for those rebuses to appear. So, when I finally got it, it brought a huge oho along with the aha.

Far from a whoosh solve for me, even after cracking the theme, making for well-earned satisfaction at the end. This felt much more like the work of a pro than tyro, astonishingly so, actually, with its stamp of talent and intelligence. I want more, and please give me more, Hanh! Congratulations, sir, on your NYT debut, and thank you for an eye-opening and sweet-to-solve outing!

Mack 7:40 AM  

I for one love rebuses, so this went over well with me (I'm in what seems to be that weird minority who prefers themed puzzles over themeless).

Only quibbles I recall:
I don't love SHIFTING PARADIGMS, partly because of Rex's point (the phrase is "paradigm shift") and partly because it feels weird as a verb phrase. It seems much more natural to me to read it as adjective-noun, so the clueing made me strangely uncomfortable.

The clue for AUTO also threw me off. Is it common for NYT to clue a prefix that way? I'm used to seeing "Self (pref.)".
It made me think there was an editorial error and the clue was meant to be "Self-driving _____".

Phillyrad1999 7:46 AM  

DIE, DOC AND DIME were fairly easy and obvious. But BULL tied me up in knots because DAWGS actually fit where BULLDOGS was required os initially went with DAWGS instinctively. Took me a bit of time to unwind that. I also overthought the whole thing as I thought there might be some sort of double reveal since the first three I solved for were DIE, DOC and DIME. Was looking for another D-word for the last rebus. Clever concept. A little meh on the puzzle as a whole for a Thursday for me,

Anonymous 8:07 AM  

Hated the theme with white hot passion. Close to my average solve time, but never got the theme - just spent the entire solve not understanding the point of the double rebuses. Had to come here to get an explanation of the theme and…yawn. When you can solve the puzzle without ever understanding the gimmick, it’s a bad puzzle. Yuck.

Wanderlust 8:09 AM  

I loved this unreservedly! I got the double DIEs relatively early, but I thought the Coolio song must be GANGSTAS DIE TWICE. But when I got the double DOCs, I realized LOGICAL DOC TWICE made no sense whatsoever, so I kept going. I finally figured it out at PAIRA BULLS OF JESUS (which, unlike Rex, I adored because it’s so wacky). And then I realized that I do know the song GANGSTA’S PAIRA DICE (I like writing the answers that way). And SHIFTING PAIRA DIMES (which sounds like a real thing to me) was icing on the cake.

There was a lot to love besides the theme as well. Lots of PPP, which will get a lot of hate, but I knew all of it today except ELSA. I love RAINN Wilson. Nice cluing, such as for SANTA, MONTY and LURE. I like learning factoids from puzzles, such as that GROG is diluted rum and that ORCAS eat squid (When they are not ramming fishing boats off the coast off Spain). I would have thought that orcas hunt near the surface and 🦑 live at the bottom.

ATE ALONE - I am somewhat of an introvert, and I like to travel alone sometimes because I can do whatever I want when I want. I love travel photography, which is much easier to do alone. No one ever wants to get up at dawn for the good light, pull over every time there’s a nice view, or spend a couple of hours hanging out with and shooting ice fishermen or longhorn cattle. Anyway, when I started doing this, I was embarrassed to be eating alone at restaurants, but now I do it without shame. Eat at the bar and meet people or eat at a table and read a good book. Like many people, I am embracing my quirks as I age instead of trying to hide or overcome them.

Anonymous 8:32 AM  

I love rebuses, but this one was Saturday- difficult for me! My main problem was that I didn’t know that the prefix “para” meant “pairs”. Sheesh!

Dr.A 8:38 AM  

Definitely knew things were not fitting, knew POST DOC and AN DIE so figured it was REBUS and then started looking out for those and it flowed but even when I was done I had to work to figure out PARA and I even knew the song, Gangstas Paradise very well. Anyhoo, super cute, I knew neither RAINN nor ELSA, so I had to google but now I do! Well I knew RAINN existed but didn’t think of him because I had Lucas and Owen running through my head.

Anonymous 8:40 AM  

Sorry. This is a total theme fail. I solved it fully but then needed several minutes to figure out that in this puzzle unlike the entirety of the English language, "pair " and "par" (as in parody)are pronounced the same way. I guess if I hire a law firm, I am just as likely to be represented by 1 lawyer as by two paralegals. Sound alikes in puzzles rarely work

bocamp 8:43 AM  

Thx, Hanh; great puz! 😊

Med+

Catching on to the trick late in the game helped with the solve. Loved the 'pair' idea.

OUTSHOWN (is that even a word?) before OUTSHONE; DawGS before DOGS.

Fun romp; liked it a lot! :)
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness ~ Freudenfreude ~ Serendipity ~ & a DAP to all 👊 🙏

GAC 8:45 AM  

This is a great puzzle with a great gimmick.I applaud the constructor for having the skill to put this one together. I got the theme with ANDIE and EDDIE, although it took a little while for it to click in. It was challenging for me, but time (40 minutes) well spent. Hope to see more puzzles from Hanh Huynh with editing by Will Shortz. Do not understand Rex's extended rant about the PARABLES OF JESUS. But then I rarely understand REx's rants.

Rich Glauber 8:45 AM  

I couldn't figure out the 'pair of' trick, so it was basically a mystery. DNF
But when I saw the constructor's name, I wanted to write him a letter.

'Dear Hanh Huynh,
Hunh?'

CWT 8:50 AM  

I too was fearing the worst when greeted by a piece of trivia right of the bat at 1A. But I soldiered on and soon realized with Andie (whom I had a monster crush on) that this was a rebus-day. Took me a little longer to realize that “die die” was a “pair of dice”and that “doc doc” was a “pair a docs”, but enjoyed the cleverness. Found the lower half to be a little harder with the “bull” sh-t and the two dimes, but finished I due time and had to admire the constructors skill. My favorite part of the whole thing, however, was finding my brother Ashley’s name in the New York Times! Alas, he is not with us anymore but loved to do crossword puzzles and is probably solving this one up in Crossword Heaven with the likes of Merle Reagle and others. “Ashley” was a family name of some renown, going back to my great great great great grandfather Chester Ashley, an early pioneer and the first U.S. Senator from the state of Arkansas. Growing up I had not only a brother Ashley but also an uncle Ashley, a grandfather Ashley and several cousins Ashley’s. Nowadays it is also a girls name, which I consider a gross violation of the rules.
Congratulations and thanks to anyone out there who managed to read this screed to the end!

Tim 8:52 AM  

Same mistake as Phillyrad1999 for me. Put in DAWGS on first pass and just couldn't figure out the SW because of that.

alexscott68 9:00 AM  

I have the feeling you loved or hated this puzzle based on whether you got the Para theme. I spotted the DOC DOC rebus right away, then the DIE DIE, then spent the rest of the puzzle confused as to what that could mean. Dice? Two dice? Docs? Never in a million years would have put the “pair of”/“para” thing in there. So I finished slowly and didn’t understand what the hell BULLS OF JESUS or SHIFTING DIMES meant until I read Rex’s write-up. So put me in the hated it category, unfortunately.

pabloinnh 9:08 AM  

Caught on early because the "pair of docs" "paraqdox" kind of joke has been around forever. It took a while to figure out what was supposed to go in the box, tried DR, uh, no. Finally got that straightened out but some WTF's slowed things down, the Coolio song, RAINN, ELSA as cluedm and taking forever to see "paradigms" after "shifting", which it seems gave a lot of us trouble. Also started with DAWG, which was singularly unhelpful.

Props to myself for remembering NESEI instanter. I learned that in high school so I guess it made a lasting impression.

Thought this was a wicked cool Thursday, HH. Huzzah and Hosanna, congrats on the debut, and thanks for all the fun.

Anonymous 9:19 AM  

The pronunciation of "para" as the theme really ruined it for me. I cannot be the only native New Yorker doing this puzzle who grew up pronouncing "para" NOT as "pair-uh" but as "par-uh". I would say "parity" but never "pare-ity". "Pair"-a-dice is rather a West Coast pronunciation. Any New Yorker out there named "Tara" who suffers through the mispronunciation of her name as "Tare-uh"?? Ugh. Similarly bothered me the other night on Jeopardy when the "Homonym" clue rhymed "naughty" with "knotty." No way!!!!! These words do not rhyme! That's why a generation of kids growing up on West Coast-produced TV think the expression is "all for not" rather than "all for naught."

Anonymous 9:24 AM  

I feel like it’s been a while since we’ve gotten a good rebus puzzle. I liked this one.

Margot 9:27 AM  

I wonder how many other faith traditions would appreciate their leader’s tales as “bull.”

RooMonster 9:31 AM  

Hey All !
Almost a [MOUNT][MOUNT] puz, but my sticking point is the one Themer with the pair-a's at the beginning, when the other three are at the end. Dang. Too bad Hanh couldn't find another phrase that double started PARA.

But, still an overall neat idea. Got the DOCDOC one first, the ole brain saying, "Two DOCs? Something DOC DOC? Double DOC? Pair of DOCs? Aha! Paradox!" Went back to my DIE from ANDIE, said, "If I put in another DIE, I get Pair-a-DIES. Paradise! GANGSTAS PARADISE!" And felt all smart and everything.

Took a minute in the BESTIE/BUNT spot, because, of course, it should be at the end, especially after I figured out the last Pair before getting the front part of the answer. (Thought to myself, "what else is pair of something? Aha, DIMEs!") Once I finally succumbed to the fact the Downs worked regularly, finally saw JESUS (praise the Lord, I saw Jesus! 😁), realizing the Pair would be at the front. Which made that SW section hold me up but good.

Had NEWSalert for a bit, and hoyaS (sorry, Georgia fans, I'm not big into College sports!), and blanking on everything else in that little 4x4 corner. Eventually pulled PARA-BULLS from somewhere in the dusty recesses of the mind, saw the BULLETIN/BULLDOGS, and was able to finish.

Tricky Double-Rebi puz. Made me talk to myself more than normal (and that's saying something!)

Fun clues for MONTY and SANTA.

To [PHRASE][PHRASE], a nice puz. 😁

Four F's
RooMonster
DarrinV

Greater Fall River Committee for Peace & Justice 9:36 AM  

I happen to be performing the William Tell Overture in two weeks, in the Dudley Buck transcription for organ (on the 1911 Ernest Skinner orchestral organ in my church). So I dropped in fMAJ quite confidently. It actually starts in d minor, but the first tune you actually remember is the one for oboe, in F. Yeah, there's that other tune later. But what an incompetent clue.

andrew 9:37 AM  

Great debut! Didn’t understand the PARA till after solving (but before coming to this blog - important to me to figure out for myself!) anDIE and edDIE showed the way of the rebus and duplicating pairs, though was off in my guess of opED EDItors for SPINDOCTORS.

+1 (ironically) for Wanderlust’s preference of eating/traveling alone. Though with my ipad or Kindle, never really dine alone. Half the cost of dating with typically better company!

Reminds me of this brilliant Seinfeld scene on the man-made prison known as marriage.

Kramer: “You can forget watching TV while you’re eating, because it’s Dinner Time, and you talk about your day!”

Anonymous 9:39 AM  

Rebodes???

Gary Jugert 9:46 AM  

Downs made sense. Acrosses not so much. This is why 🦖 is the greatest human ever. Even with PARA- in mind ya gotta be from Bahston ta make 'em sound rightly. Escaped me completely. Oh well, feels like it's been awhile since we did a rebus.

It Thursed just fine.

I did look up GANGSTA... because it crossed two unknowns: NISEI and ANDIE and AVGS has a ridiculous clue.

Still no A/C, but the dog is improving.

Dwight Schrute in the house.

Tee-Hee: ANAL

Uniclues:

1 Dining Hall.
2 Transport for losers 50% of the time.
3 Emulate Juliet.
4 Breaking fakery from up north.
5 Mister Magoo crew zoos.
6 Beta mattress discomfortizers.

1 MONTY ATE ALONE
2 BOWL GAME BUSES
3 PLEDGE MONTAGUE
4 SANTA NEWS BULLETIN
5 TOON FANFESTS
6 TEST PEAS SEDIMENT

My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Gathering of disgruntled people who aren't going to do anything about it. IDLE GALL RODEO

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Elena 10:10 AM  

I finished the puzzle without ever understanding what exactly was going on. If not for Rex, I still wouldn't know. I don't have the patience to sit there and figure it out once it's over. Thanks, Rex!

Nancy 10:12 AM  

Okay. I've scrolled down this blog with my eyes closed (literally) so that I will not discover what the bleep is going on until I've shared with you where I stand right now, Where I stand is in a sea of utter bafflement.

Here's what I've got, I think:

GANSTA DIE DIE
LOGICAL DOC DOC
BULL BULL OF JESUS
SHIFTING DIME DIME

If these Acrosses are correct, all the Down answers would work. But not a single Across answer makes any bleepin' sense to me.

Damn! I sure could use a revealer!!!

Off now to find out 1) what I'm missing and 2) if my Across answers are even right.

Anonymous 10:16 AM  

I put in BULL BULL but thought it was bi-bull (bible) for a while before getting the “para-“ pattern!

Nancy 10:27 AM  

I see it now! It's very clever. VERY, VERY clever!!!

But I pronounce PAIR so very differently from the PARA of PARABLE, PARADISE, PARADIGM and PARADOX that it made it perhaps harder for me than for those of you whose pronunciations are more similar. At least that's my story and I'm sticking to it.

So while I filled in the grid successfully -- perhaps even MORE of an achievement when you're getting no help from the theme -- I did not successfully "solve" this puzzle. Off now to see how everyone else did.

Bob Mills 10:29 AM  

For the puzzle to have been both clever and FAIR, some kind of revealer was needed regarding the puns. DIEDIE and the other pairs make no sense when standing alone, but "pair-a-dice" leads to "paradise."

Georgia 10:32 AM  

Me too! Dooley's Dawgs!

EasyEd 10:37 AM  

I’m with @Nancy, never got the theme until I read Rex. In retrospect really admire/like what the author did, but while doing the puzzle was too focused on getting the across/downs to work and suffered from being a NewYorker who does not pronounce “para” as “paira”. Not exactly whimsy today, but free-wheeling dealing with the language both acoustically and visually. Found the “BULL” part tough becauseI was looking for another three letter “D—“ combination.

bocamp 10:37 AM  

@Nancy (10:12 AM): rooting for you! 🤞

I'm betting on you getting a flash of inspiration. I was in the same boat until, somewhat ironically, my light bulb went on at the JESUS one. 💡
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness ~ Freudenfreude ~ Serendipity ~ & a DAP to all 👊 🙏

Carola 10:39 AM  

Easy until it got hard, fun all the way. I didn't know the song title, but the crossing DIEs came quickly - which meant I thought the song was GANGSTA, DIE! DIE! (ill-fated career path). So the neighboring DOCs in the next theme answer brought me up short for a minute, until I understood the "pair o' = para" idea. The third one gave me the most trouble. I knew that they were parables but, like others here, expected the two BULLs to be at the far end. Plus, my crosses at the start seemed right: NEWS Break and, like others, dawGS. I had to vacate the area and head for the fourth one, also a little harder because of the 4-letter rebus square. Back to that gnarly third one: eventually I got to JESUS (I thought BESTIR and IS OFF were hard) and sorted out the BULLETIN and BULLDOGS. A very enjoyable Thursday.

Alice Pollard 10:40 AM  

I have a quick question. I was solving online last night. NYT App. I normally solve in the actual newspaper in the morning. But last night I tried online. So I realized what was going on w/ Paradise/Paradox/etc. But I just thought it would be easier to solve on paper in terms of fitting more than one letter in a square. So I stopped. This morning I completed the hard copy. Great puzzle, btw. So my question is... how DO you solve something like this on the app. How do you fit more than once letter (DIE/DOC/BULL/DIME) in a square? thx...

Mary McCarty 10:40 AM  

@Nancy- Me, too…had the DIE,DIE and DOC, DOC, but still in the dark til BULL,BULL because I knew we must be talking about parables (pair-a-bulls). The great AHA! Immediately after came the great HAHA with DIMES.

I wonder if LIE,LIE-D could’ve been worked in for “immobile with fear”?
FRAY-FRAY =“restated”?

thfenn 10:41 AM  

Great puzzle. The DIES went in first, then the DIES. The BULLS turned up when I abandoned NEWSflash and Dawgs. And then I tripped and fell on the DIMES. Just couldn't see RUDIMENT or SEDIMENT and tried SHIFTING everything but paradigms. Big ugly DNF. But a fun challenge that just plain OUTSHONE me.

Gary Jugert 10:45 AM  

@Alice Pollard 10:40 AM
Bottom left of keyboard has a button with three dots. Hit that and enter whatever.

dragoo 10:46 AM  

Editor here: "Normally I HAD musical key clues, and I probably still do, but today..." would make more sense if "had" were "hate", which is (I'm sure) what you meant to type.

Also, I had a friend in grad school who did a 7-year medical school degree in which he earned a PhD in medicine and an MD. As soon as he finished the program, he got himself a personalized license plate: PARADOCS

(Enjoyed today's writeup.)

andrew 10:49 AM  

Alice - hit REBUS key (lower right), type in letters (or on occasion, #s) and hit REBUS again.

With my handwriting especially, easier to do it on ipad than on paper…

Son Volt 10:51 AM  

@Alice - the “More” button in the lower left corner will bring you the rebus fill option

SimonSays 10:56 AM  

Not my cup: over-the-top gimmickry, basement-level PPP, weird clueing.
The worst clues: a PAIR of Southern sports teams. Texas A&M, in particular, is a disgrace. Read the article in yesterday’s NYT about the Black journalism professor who was treated like s**t by the college. No surprises these days when it comes to Texas, sad.

Kate Esq 10:56 AM  

Good Thursday fun puzzle, though the theme was easy to figure out for me. (I got to it exactly the way RP did, though how I retrieved Gangsta’s Paradise from the recesses of my mind I do not know). Also got hung up on Fewer (Newer?) and struggled a bit in the NE corner because PostDoc eluded me and I hadn’t stopped to think through Paradox. Good theme was important though, because the rest of the fill was - fine. Solid, not a lot of filler, well-clued, just not sparkling. Fave answer/clue was MONTAGUE.

Kate Esq 10:58 AM  

In the “More” menu on the keyboard, there is a “rebus” button. If you hit that, you can enter multiple letters in one square.

Alice Pollard 11:01 AM  

Thanks SunVolt, Andrew, and Gary Jugert. I will go back into the app and futz around with it. It’s kind of funny, lately I have been solving online at 10pm. You *do* solve alot faster than hardcopy. I do not care at all about time and streaks... I think I just like to tackle it as soon as it is available. BUT even if I solve online the night before I still fill in the puzzle the next day in the paper. I know it’s weird but I can’t help myself lol.

Newboy 11:08 AM  

lax lax fill in spots, but more than compensated by the wonderfully asymmetrical rebus gimmick: PEAS, HENS, OPIE, NAE & ole friend ORCA are not entries to DIE for on a Thursday, but those PARAs get the full MONTY indeed! Welcome Mr. Huynh to the elite constructor club. Congratulations on your debut and looking forward to more of your grids.

Hack mechanic 11:13 AM  

Much preferred the answer
"Bull of Jesus" than all that para rubbish.

jae 11:23 AM  

Easy-medium. I caught the theme early and mostly breezed through it. NEWS stories until the theme fixed it and emos before HENS were it for hiccups. Fun Thursday, liked it.


Did not know ELSA as clued.

jberg 11:26 AM  

Well, I did figure out the theme, but only after looking up RAINN, whom I'd never heard of. Until I saw those 2 Ns in his surname, I thought we were looking for a DIMEN rebus spread over two squares. Also, I had not quite figured out that all the doubled elements were a PAIR 'O something or other. (No problem with the pronunciation for me -- I grew up in Wisconsin and spent the last 58 years in Massachusetts, and never para said any other way.)

So I had three PARA answers so it dawned on me that the song must involve PARADISE. The theme helped there, or else I'd have had to look it up.

I went through the same scramble as Rex to come up with FEWER. I would have stuck with nEWER, but it dawned on me that some of them are actually older. And I was saved from NEWS flash by the HENS, which could be nothing else.

CAit before CATE, for maybe the 17th time, and it was really hard for me to accept EDDIE BAUER as a J.Crew competitor -- not because it isn't, but because I'm old enough to remember when it was an outdoor outfitter, like LL Bean or REI, which are both transitioning too, but not as fast.

I enjoyed struggling to get the theme, despite my failure on RAINN. It was a good warmup for the Out of Left Field cryptic, which should be sitting in my inbox right now.

Anonymous 11:28 AM  

Bull bull

Anonymous 11:33 AM  

I am a Tara. I am so used to my name being pronounced differently from how I say it. Now that I live outside of New England, I rarely hear Marry, Mary, and Merry pronounced as the three separate AND separate sounding words they are, so I wasn’t put off by the disparity in pronunciation of Para and Pair of. Of course they sound different. It’s a joke.

Sadly, the sound wasn’t my hangup. My brain wasn’t finding the very simple Find, nor the more difficult Nisei. And, i did not know anywhere in the recesses of my aging brain Gangstas Paradise. I googled, and, unfortunately that gave away the theme. I had been staring at the double Docs, knowing something clever was going on, and too quickly the cheat gave it all away.

mathgent 11:43 AM  

Saw the gimmick at the two DOC rebus squares. I've seen that pun before. Then had a lot of fun finding the other "pairs."

Despite the restrictive gimmick, there was a goodly amount of sparkle here. Very impressive puzzle.

jb129 11:44 AM  

When I got Andie (McDowell) right away I thought "okay it's a Thursday rebus - I can do it."

But I had to cheat so that means it wasn't enjoyable for me. My loss I guess.

Robyn W. is at The New Yorker today.

GILL I. 11:53 AM  

I was close to calling @Nancy and asking her if I could toss a puzzle on her wall.
Coolio...You start me off with a song I don't know. I did, though, and very slowly, pen in DIE DIE. GANGSTER DIE twice? Good gravy....Move on.
Next!
Is that a BULL BULL lurking at the bottom? It had to be NEWS(BULL)ETIN and (BULL)DOG. What did JESUS have to do with two BULLs? There goes my misguided brain...again! Think. Don't get overly clever...Stare....Get up and eat something...Come back and take a deep breath.
It worked.
Pairs of something actually a PARA of something. Do I pronounce it correctly? My accent can be funny.
JESUS did it for me. PARABLE! JESUS is a PARABLE....Amen.
Back to fill the others - hopefully - ....;
DIE DIE, DOC DOC, BULL BULL and DIME DIME. Wow. Pretty nifty. Let's fit you into your smart boxes. I did.
This idea and concept it really genius. I had some moments, thought. I'm not up on my FAN FARE BOT NET RAINN, but I did like the rest of you.
I'll WOW it again and tell @Nancy I won't be needing her wall after all.

Whatsername 11:55 AM  

Great Thursday trick! Fooled me for a while because even though I had the rebuses filled in I didn’t make the connection to the pair=par. Not being a rap fan, I thought the first one might be parsed as GANGSTA 2 DIE. The double SPIN DOCS gave me nothing but finally saw it at the pair of paraBULLS. Very nicely done and I liked that there was no hint or revealer. Congratulations on an excellent debut!

Anonymous 12:16 PM  

Slower than average solve time for a Thursday. Medium-challenging for me, as Thursdays go, but gettable. I enjoyed it! I wonder if we’ll get challenging puzzles tomorrow and Saturday, too.

Masked and Anonymous 12:30 PM  

Yep, I can really dig this theme mcguffin.
{Meta's Threads and Musk's Twitter} = _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (rebus)(rebus) *

staff weeject pick: STS. Plural abbreve meat, right down there at the puzbottom, where it can buy @AnoaBob a coupla nifty POC's.

OK, so I kinda figured out early-on that that there first themer said GANSTASDIEDIE, but the song was a no-know, and -- like others here -- decided it might be GANGSTAS DIE Twice. Had to pause and do research on the song, to wise up.

some fave stuff: SANTA clue. BOWLGAME. SPINDOCTORS. BESTIR's tasty dash of ow de speration.
I don't recall seein a single ?-marker clue today. Mighty unusual, for a ThursPuz.

Thanx for the fun paraphrases, Mr. Huynh dude. And congratz on a great debut.

p.s.
* = WARRINGPARASITES. har [scores double-entendre points]

Masked & Anonymo8Us


**gruntz**

CT2Napa 12:32 PM  

@REX You don't need a lawyer, you need NGRAM.

shifting paradigms

One of the books referenced might be hlpful in your work -

Early English Performance: Medieval Plays and Robin Hood Games
Shifting Paradigms in Early English Drama Studies

CT2Napa 12:56 PM  


Would have preferred clue for 16A to be "Coolio song parodied by Weird Al"

Amish paradise

Anonymous 1:17 PM  

Nope. Never got the theme. Rex had a head start with that bumper sticker. DNF. DNE. (Did Not Enjoy)

Anonymous 1:18 PM  

Use the Rebus key.

Photomatte 1:42 PM  

I got stuck very early on, due to an error in the puzzle. Having been married to a woman whose parents were Nissei (2nd generation immigrants from Japan), I wondered where the second S was and thought there must be a rebus somewhere. That NYT error caused me no end of headache! Doesn't anyone spellcheck anymore?

okanaganer 2:00 PM  

Right after I finished the puzzle, I turned on Radio Paradise (!!!) and by a huge coincidence, Stevie Wonder's "Pastime Paradise" was playing (the original of Coolio's song). True!!

Themer typeovers: NEWS FLASH before [BULL]ETIN, and TENET before RU[DIME]ENT.

I hate college sports clues, so I hated the tag team of [BULL]DOGS and AGGIE.

@CT2Napa, but note this comparison to validate Rex's point.

[Spelling Bee: Wed 0, took a while to get that pangram.]

Eniale 2:05 PM  

I'm absolutely with @anonymous 8:40. The way I pronounce "para" is with a short a. So when I was working on those two identical squares I was thinking "two" and "couple" Duh.

Anonymous 2:25 PM  

Well, not many, since a Papal bull is a catholics-only thing ;-)

SharonAK 3:01 PM  

I was confused by the theme, especially "bull bull of Jesus" (That sounded amusingly rude and heretical) until "shifting dimes dimes" . The I got the implied "Pair a" and went back to read the others.
Was amused and thought it a clever theme. But, did the constructor have to start with a song I've never heard of ?

Anonymous 3:26 PM  

😂

Jim Finder 3:32 PM  

No problem with the theme, since I usually get the puns.
Reminds me of us college Gilbert & Sullivan fans endlessly flogging a shaggy-dog story about archaeologists finding two mummified renowned ancient physicians, culminating with, "Yes, Frederic, it's a musty genius pair of docs."

A 3:52 PM  

Stopped in to wish @ttrimble a Happy Birthday, though it’s been so long I don’t know if he still keeps up with the gang. If so I hope he liked the LOGICAL Pair o’ DOCs. Also, he now shares a birthday with Naomi Osaka’s baby girl.

So no one else who was ignorant of the Coolio song thought the first themer was GANSTAS PARODIES? After all, the DIEs going down are pronounced that way. Looks like that answer might fit the Weird Al version?

My niece went to UGA so hand up for dawGS - but at least it gave me TRIG. Also hand up for trying to FIND the rebus at the end of the third themer and for nEWER before FEWER.

Loved the Two Dice story and the fact @Rex proudly displayed the bumper sticker for so long.

So long, so long, so long…..

andrew 3:57 PM  

@simonsays 10:56 -

I (reluctantly) moved to Texas from Connecticut when Texas A&M liked my web design in 2002 and hired me to do many of theirs.

What I found in College Station.were some of the warmest, most generous people I have ever met. They’re a little too Aggie football crazy, conservative and religious for me, but by all indications, they were decent to people of all races.

Before you broadly trash the citizens of an entire state (plus Georgia, to boot), you might want to look at some of your own prejudices and pre-judgements…

johnk 4:02 PM  

A PARANOIDEAS held me back for quite a while: ELSA & RAINN.

MattBridgewater(official) 4:12 PM  

"Para" sounds like "pair of". So, "pair of docs" = "paradox", "pair of bulls" = "parables", etc. To be honest, I completed the puzzle without figuring out the connection between "para" and "pair of," so I know how you feel. I kept on thinking "para" might've been Latin for "two" or something. Lol

Gary Jugert 4:41 PM  

@andrew 3:57 PM
Examined my prejudices, here's the trash:

Warm and generous people are everywhere, but...

Texas = Bad
Florida = Bad
Anything South of the Mason-Dixon = Bad
Midwest = Pretty Bad
Montana & Idaho = Pretty, but Bad
Arizona = Can't help but be Bad
New England = Good
Except New Hampshire = Bad
And northern Maine = Bad
And New Jersey = Bad

🙂🇺🇸

OISK 4:55 PM  

Happy to see the G and S reference above - A most ingenious paradox! There are some other chemists here; I liked to draw a hexagon with a circle in the middle, with the letters MD at the top, and at the bottom. Paradox!

I enjoyed this one very much.

Anonymous 5:05 PM  

It doesn't. In America English it's pronounced that way. Kinda. For a Brit it def isn't. So that made it harder for some of us.

egsforbreakfast 5:26 PM  

I had a friend who won a lympics lympics medal.

I chuckled at the clue for 30D (Name before Dick). Sounds like a corollary to “Age before beauty.”

Loved the theme idea and execution. Congrats on a great debut, Hanh Huynh.

Anonymous 5:51 PM  

Hand up for Gangstas Die Twice. Messed me up for a long time.

Anonymous 5:54 PM  

Of a bunt isn’t a swing, why is it called a strike if missed?

Anonymous 5:54 PM  

My favorite puzzle in a while. Well constructed, was impressed how the theme was pulled off without any real groan-worthy answers. I liked all 4 themers, was more of a fan than Rex.

Camilita 6:03 PM  

My favorite puzzle in a long time. Especially since I was slow to get the theme but when I did, WoW!!!!!

Anonymous 6:29 PM  

Dawgs bulldogs hung me up for a long time... Plus was looking for the para at the end, not front of the answer

Nancy 6:49 PM  

@A (3:52) -- I got the reference!!! I GOT THE REFERENCE!!! I knew what the song would be!!!

Now I just have to figure out why you posted the link. Can't find any connection to today's puzzle.

BTW, I clicked on the link and listened to the song. There are few songs that have ever made me sadder. It always leaves me with a huge lump in my throat -- even though I, personally, don't miss the subject of the song in the least. The strange power of music...

Sandy McCroskey 7:15 PM  

Well, folks, Merriam-Webster gives PAIR and the first syllables of PARADISE, PARADOX, PARABLE, PARADIGM to be identical.
FWIW!

Sandy McCroskey 7:21 PM  
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous 7:38 PM  

Five Fs!

Sandy McCroskey 7:42 PM  

@Photomatte
I spellcheck by using a dictionary.
I consulted Merriam-Webster, Dictionary.com and Collins online, and only found "Nisei," with one S.

A 8:00 PM  

@Nancy, the power of music can be downright scary. As with any power, one should use it wisely.

There was no connection to the puzzle, just to my observation of how funny that @OFL kept the reminder (the bumper sticker that said Two Dice) of miscommunication for "so long." I actually had the link at the end of that PARAgraph at first but decided to make a new paragraph so it would stand out.

Really glad it resonated with you!

Joe Dipinto 9:20 PM  

@A & @Nancy – you can pretend the song link was connected to "Bye for now"/TTYL.

Peter P 11:19 PM  

Loved it. Figured-out (more or less) the theme at the Coolio clue. Such a formative song for me (I was mid-college when it came out), along with the Weird Al parody, "Amish Paradise."

I can understand never having heard of it, but that song was everywhere at one time. I spent most of my 20s in Budapest, Hungary. In 1998, I took a job as photographer for a local English language business newspaper, and I was getting my bearings as a stranger in a strange land with a strange language. One of my first memories is sitting in my flat, sick, alone, watching a video of Smurfs singing in Hungarian over Coolio’s “Gangsta’s Paradise.” What surreality have I walked into?

Like I said, he seemed to be everywhere in those mid-to-late 90s.

Oh, overall? Loved this puzzle. Absolutely tickled everything I like about crosswords.

dgd 11:27 PM  

Don’t know if anyone will ever see this, but I wonder where in Massachusetts. (There is a lot of variation depending). I am flabbergasted by your comment.
I have lived in RI my whole life and locals in Southeastern Massachusetts & RI most definitely pronounce para unlike pair uh (of). (I am not talking about the Boston accent which is quite distinct I don’t remember how they pronounce paradox). . I think more than one native New Englander above agree with me.
I am not complaining but while I filled the boxes in correctly, I gave up and came here without understanding the theme. My accent did me in! I am sure I have seen the pun before but it doesn’t work for me so I forget about it.

dgd 11:37 PM  

Really. The power of one’s own accent. I was totally unaware of that. I will continue to pronounce pair differently. And continue to miss this pun!

Anonymous 12:36 PM  

Is parables pronounced pair of bulls? Not I. Dang difficult. I pronounce all of these differently than the gimmick demanded.

Anonymous 3:59 PM  

Great puzzle! Took me a while as I am not familiar with rap songs but when I got to spin doctors that was the trick! Loved it! Thanks so much NYT

Tony 11:46 PM  

Late in the game on this one, so if I may have the honor of the last word, let it be: Ugh.

Robert Oxenburgh 7:55 PM  

I got, after 45 minutes of fun, all the paras. But made no connection to pair of. Must be the American pronunciation!

Anonymous 4:55 PM  

My first double was docdoc. So immediately, my mind said to me, is this going to be a docdoc here, a docdoc there, here a doc, there a doc, everywhere a docdoc?!

Anonymous 5:20 PM  

Hated it. The outlier third themer with the gimmick at the front screwed me up for far too long. And the SE corner was my downfall with LaTT instead of LETT. AGGIE was a WOE and having it cross with RAINN (who is that?) made it really unfair. Took forever to figure out the gimmick and the effort was hardly worth it.

Anonymous 5:27 PM  

That Coolio song sounds a lot like the theme song to the TV series Succession.

  © Free Blogger Templates Columnus by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP