Onetime capital of the Mughal Empire / THU 9-25-25 / Traveler's aid, familiarly / "Pardon me," in Padua / Anaheim ballplayers / The Chicago Bulls had a pair of them in the 1990s / Shipwreck locales often / Replace the sod of / Property owner subject to a legal claim

Thursday, September 25, 2025

Constructor: Jesse Goldberg

Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium


THEME: SKIM OFF THE TOP (20A: Illegally siphon funds) — you have to "skim" the FIRST TWO LETTERS (52A: What each Down answer needs from its clue in order to make sense) off the "top" (i.e. from the front) of each Down answer. The "skimmed" letters of every Down answer are identical to the first two letters of their respective clues. So, for example, 31D: Determined is ADSET (i.e. (De)ADSET)

Theme answers:
  • all the Downs
Word of the Day: (Sh)INOLA (30D: Shoe polish brand) —
Shinola
 is a defunct American brand of shoe polish. The Shinola Company, founded in Rochester, New York in 1877, as the American Chemical Manufacturing and Mining Company, produced the polish under a sequence of different owners until 1960. "Shinola" was a trade name and trademark for boot polish. The suffix -ola is a popular component of trade names in the United States. It was popular during the first half of the 20th century and entered the American lexicon in the phrase, "You don't know shit from Shinola," meaning to be ignorant. The brand name was acquired by the retail company Shinola in 2011. [...] In 2011, venture capitalist Tom Kartsotis bought the rights to the brand name, and created a new retail company. The company was founded in 2012, and produces watches and leather goods. (wikipedia)
• • •


The SKIM OFF THE TOP bit is kind of cute ("white collar" crime pun!), but otherwise this one was a chore to solve. Not a particularly hard chore, just an unpleasant one. The missing letters aren't doing anything but missing. It was nice to find out (halfway through) that those letters could be found at the beginning of their answer's respective clues, but that just made the rest of the puzzle easier, not more enjoyable. The fill itself is very much on the dull side. LIENEE? (SH)ORTTONS? (RE)TURF?? Almost all the fill is short. None of the Across fill (besides SKIM OFF THE TOP) is interesting, and only a few of the longer Down answers are things I'd enjoy seeing in a regular puzzle (e.g. (ST)RAIGHTEN UP, (ST)EAMER TRUNK, (SH)RUG IT OFF). This was one of those puzzles where I thought, "this is getting tedious, I should just jump to the revealer down at the bottom so I can figure out what's going on," but I resisted and just plowed through until I came to that revealer "naturally" (i.e. without breaking (ST)RIDE, working off crosses the whole way). All I needed was the first few letters and bam ...


From there on out, as I say, the puzzle got a lot easier (because it just handed me the first two letters of every single remaining Down). There are no particularly hard parts in this puzzle, and no answers that really seem worth commenting on. It's a structural stunt with nothing much going for it, entertainment-wise, except SKIM OFF THE TOP; at least that answer involved wordplay. All the other theme business just involved word manipulation. Word chopping. And the revealer couldn't have been less playful if it tried. Literal in the extreme. 


I went through three stages of "understanding" this theme. The first was Wild. I could see that the Down answers wouldn't fit, but I didn't think they were missing—I thought they were contained in rebus squares. I should've known right off the bat that the [Onetime capital of the Mughal Empire] was AGRA (site of the Taj Mahal, as every longtime solver knows), but since I couldn't remember that immediately, I ended up with this insane answer there instead:


Ah yes, who can forget the ancient city of BLAANGSTRSTA! But when [TEM]PEST wouldn't work (because SKIM OFF THE TOP had to be right), I realized I wasn't dealing with three-letter rebus squares, but rather just two missing squares. Could not see how that was interesting, but thought, whatever, and just started solving Downs with the understanding that the first two letters of those answers would be missing. Weirdly, the puzzle was pretty doable despite my not knowing where or what those missing letters were. So first it was a rebus, then it was a "first two letters" missing, then (after the revealer), all was clear—first two letters found, rest of the puzzle easy, and bland. Paint-by-numbers bland.


Anything else?:
  • 2D: Anaheim ballplayers ((AN)GELS) — this made me laugh, as many people in the comments section yesterday claimed never to have heard of this team or its abbrev. (LAA). And yet, here they are ... again! (AN)GELS is the "A" in LAA. Side note: LAA has been used as a baseball abbrev. ten times since 2013. In the Shortz Era, it's also been clued two other ways: ["___ note to follow..."] (toughie!), and [When doubled, one of the Teletubbies] 
  • 15A: "Pardon me," in Padua ("SCUSI") — I wrote this in as "SCUSE" as you can see in that first partial grid I posted, above. I watch a lot of Italian films, but since the subtitles are obviously English, I don't get a chance to see how any of the Italian is spelled.
  • 16A: Home of Minor League Baseball's SeaWolves (more than 350 miles from the ocean!) (ERIE) — this clue is weird. It seems to think it's doing some kind of "gotcha" or pointing out some apparent irony, but ERIE is on a Great Lake (guess which one!), and the Great Lakes have long been called "the inland seas." "Because of their sea-like characteristics, such as rolling waves, sustained winds, strong currents, great depths, and distant horizons, the five Great Lakes have long been called inland seas" (wikipedia)So since ERIE is on one of said "inland seas," the SeaWolves seems like a highly appropriate name, actually. They're not called the damned OceanWolves, after all.
  • 26D: Traveler's aid, familiarly ((TR)IPLE A) — absolutely not. It's AAA. You say "(TR)IPLE A," but it's written exclusively as AAA. I will give you (TR)IPLE A as a baseball answer ((TR)IPLE A is the class of baseball just before the majors) (the SeaWolves are DOUBLE-A). Baseball and [Top credit rating], and [Narrow show width] are the only ways (TR)IPLE A has ever been clued ... before today. 
  • 40D: The Chicago Bulls had a pair of them in the 1990s ((TH)REEPEATS) — when you win the championship three times in a row (for the Bulls, '91-93 and '96-'98) (Jordan took time off in between to try to play baseball; he made it as far as ... DOUBLE-A)
  • 55D: Shipwreck locales often ((SH)OALS) — one of the few Down answers where knowing the first two letters didn't give the whole answer away. Had to wait for crosses here to make sure it wasn't (SH)ORES (which seemed plausible).
That's it. See you next time. Oh, and Happy 19th birthday to ... this blog! Although, technically ... though the Monday, Sep. 25, 2006 puzzle was the first one I ever blogged, I didn't blog it until Wednesday the 27th, LOL. Timely! Literally no one read that post, as no one knew the blog existed (how could they?). Anyway, that first post is an experimental mess written by someone with no expectation of an audience. You can "enjoy" it here—Lynn Lempel! (the comments on that first write-up are particularly hilarious)


Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️: 
  • Venmo (@MichaelDavidSharp)]
=============================
✏️ Upcoming Crossword Tournaments ✏️
=============================
📘 My other blog 📘:

81 comments:

Conrad 6:07 AM  


Challenging-Easy. Like OFL, I initially thought the downs all started with rebus squares but I couldn't make sense of the acrosses. After a bit of futility, I "cheated" and read the clue for 52A. That told me the down answers needed something from the clue, and it didn't take much to realize it was the FIRST TWO LETTERS. After that the puzzle was Easy.

Only one very minor overwrite after erasing the rebuses: ON me before ON IT at 61A. I did consider BEER cAp before HAT at 48A.

No WOEs except for AGRA as clued.

Anonymous 6:22 AM  

BLAANGSTRSTA, ancestral home of the god OOXTERPLENON

Rex Parker 6:23 AM  

😀

Wanderlust 6:28 AM  

Very different solve for me. Once I got that the top row of answers were all missing two letters, and then got SKIM OFF THE TOP, I noted the long revealer at the bottom and thought it would be something like LOP OFF THE BOTTOM. Which would mean two letters off the bottom of any answer that ended in the last row. So I put STEAMER TRU for the storage item on ocean voyages. That held me up for a while because I was sure of it but the crosses weren’t working.

I also tried briefly to make sense of the missing letters at the top, as if they were going to spell something. BLANSTST wasn’t going anywhere so I abandoned that. Like Rex I got a nice surprise when I saw that the first two letters of down clues were the missing letters and then I sped through the rest, making up for my steamer trunk delay.

Thought Rex would post the great Bill Withers song USE ME, in which he is definitely not saying “I’m here to help.”

bulgie 6:34 AM  

I loved it, but I tend to like easy ones. Lots of whoosh and swoosh. Started to twig to the theme immediately (the easy half), didn't get where the missing letters came from until the revealer. I love when a revealer actually helps.

5 stars, brilliant.

Anthony in TX 6:42 AM  

What an awful puzzle (for me personally). Even when I figured out the gimmick, my brain just refused to work out the missing two letters on so many downs. I struggled mightily with the acrosses, too. Took me nearly 10 minutes longer than my average Thursday time. Oh well. On to Friday.

Rick Sacra 6:43 AM  

16 minutes for me this morning--had exactly the same NW corner as @REX did, then just started poking around, looked for the revealer and started to work down in the bottom part of the grid--that seemed easier. Finally figured out that the trick applied to all the downs and got the revealer.. I was hoping that all the entries were still valid, but they're not. I definitely liked it more than Rex did, I'm not sure I've seen a theme just like this before and so I'll give in an "A" for ingenuity! Thanks, Jesse! Anybody got a clue what the pretty fruit bowl is doing in the middle of the grid?

Anonymous 6:50 AM  

Total slog. I figured out early on that I had to add two letters to each down clue. So when I got to the revealer, all I could say was "That's it???"

Anonymous 6:56 AM  

I can appreciate the effort that goes into constructing one of these, while still hating the experience of solving it, and finding the grid hideous when there are so many more non-words than in your typical gimmicky puzzle. Ugh.

Son Volt 7:12 AM  

Fun to start - once the trick fell it was fill-in-the-blanks easy. SKIM OFF THE TOP is outstanding.

The Derailers

Rex highlights most of the issues here - the fill lacks the splash the puzzle needed to put it over the top. I’m sure the grid construction does not help but what we get is a bunch of oddball letter strings in places that fall flat. Liked STEAMER TRUNK but STRAIGHTEN UP missed the mark.

When you’re following an ANGEL

Ambitious build no doubt and fun to start but it tailed off quickly. Overall though - a pleasant enough Thursday morning solve.

The newest member of the OPRY

JJK 7:32 AM  

This went from hard (“I don’t get this at all!”) to easy as soon as I got the FIRSTTWOLETTERS answer. Which took awhile I must say. But I enjoyed it, and it must have been a construction feat.

Good thing we had yesterday’s LAA situation and the comments on it, since I now know that the ANGELS are from Anaheim!

Surprised Rex didn’t mention that there are two OFFs.

Eh Steve! 7:36 AM  

I knew something was up but couldn't get enough traction to figure out what it was. SKIMOFFTHE TOP helped and by the time I got the full revealer, I really didn't care anymore.

Super hard, until it wasn't. The sloggiest of slogs.

Anonymous 7:36 AM  

I was blown away by it and found it super fun to solve. Something different and unexpected! I didn’t know what was going on for a while (also tried rebuses) and concentrated on acrosses so i didn’t know SKIM OFF THE TOP was a themer. It seemed extra sly to me after the fact. I normally am pretty aligned w Rex but i absolutely loved this puzzle.

Anonymous 7:37 AM  

Morning all! I really enjoyed solving this puzzle! Once I figured out the plan, my brain really got a workout! Thank you!

Anonymous 7:40 AM  

I had the same “chore” feeling. Once you know the first two letters of each answer, the thrill is gone. It’s just a matter of filling in the squares. Only real difficulty came at the end with SHINOLA/ELAND. I correctly inferred the N.

SouthsideJohnny 7:44 AM  

I noticed something was amiss with just the first two entries (BLARE and ANGELS) and almost went down the rebus rabbit hole similar to OFL. Instead, I went straight to the reveal and saved myself a lot of time and effort. From there it was pretty easy (except for the minor annoyance of having to reread every down clue to pick up the initial two letters).

I frequently struggle discerning the theme, so having one gifted to me for a change was kind of nice. From there it became borderline Mon/Tues level plug and chug - not a complaint, but I can see how some people might find it boring and repetitive. I had more fun with this one than a rebus though, simply because it’s easier and didn’t task my feeble mind with the chore of determining where the rebus squares would go - so YMMV.

Andy Freude 7:46 AM  

Amen, brother/sister/sibling! I futzed with rebuses for a while, saw that they got me nowhere, realized the grid would be filled with gibberish, and bailed halfway through. An utter waste of time.

Anonymous 7:48 AM  

Agreed! And I don’t like the feeling when you realize early on that you’re going to have to guess what the “correct” way is to enter the answers (rebus? First letter?)

Anonymous 7:48 AM  

Wow! I guess I just skimmed the revealer clue and completely missed that the first two letters came from the clue. I just thought they were missing. Was a pretty difficult solve for me!

Anonymous 7:49 AM  

Once you get the gimmick pretty easy. That said, if I stared at this puzzle for an hour it would be hard for me to find something to like. Why? Skim of the top was not enuf too make me even so much as begin to crack a smile. Between the gimmick itself and things like LIENEE it was just annoying. Stop it.

Rakesh 7:51 AM  

Took me longer than I care to admit. 21 minutes for a Thursday is a bit shameful. Loved the puzzle though.

tht 7:53 AM  

Was utterly baffled until I wasn't. @Conrad's rating was for me the correct one: challenging-easy. Time taken was 50% greater than that of a typical Thursday.

Never heard of ASUS. Big name, you say? (SH)INOLA, pfft.

I expect this was challenging to construct. I'm sorry to say it didn't give me a lot of pleasure to solve. There's this little invitation that appears when you complete the puzzle on the NYT website and your time is displayed: "Admire your puzzle". Eh, IPASS.

(There's something a little too self-congratulatory about "admire your puzzle". Sure, I might want to review the puzzle, but that's not the same thing. Actually, what I do is open a new tab and open with a fresh copy of the completed puzzle, because I find that the software keeps adding seconds and minutes to the timer, and sometimes hours over the course of a day, so that if I hit the X button on the congratulations message, then I will no longer see the correct time it took. Not a big deal, since the correct time will be there in stats [I trust], but I do find it slightly annoying.)

RooMonster 7:58 AM  

Hey All ?
I'm going to try to explain things about this puz nicely. Because it's impossible, and I had absolutely no clue on how to fill in the Downs.

If you cannot get Down crossers on your Acrosses, how on Earth are you going to figure out the Theme? I see Rex did, wondering what the over/under will be on everyone else. I'm betting the over that not too many understood it.

And 52A Revealer should have started with "With 20 Across..." Yes, I needed that (hand-holding) if I were to ever figure out what in tarhooties was happening. As it is, never did grok anything. Is that me? How do you get FIRSTTWOLETTERS without getting any Downs?

Plus, most of the Down answers are non things/words. Granted, I'm sure this was difficult to construct, as having to have Actual Things in the Acrosses to jive with your SKIMmed Downs, but the effort to construct this is wasted in an indecipherable Theme.

Sorry, Jesse, appreciate the effort and time this took (like I said, very tough to construct), but puz not my cuppa. Had to fill puz in from Rex's sheet on many words, so a big fat DNF, just filling in the puz to finish to satisfy the APP.

Goodness.

Left/right symmetry. The puz I guess could be classified as a cryptic? My poor brain is smoking at the moment.

Welp, have a great Thursday!

Five F's
RooMonster
DarrinV

Lynda 7:59 AM  

Morning all! I really enjoyed this puzzle! Once I figured out the plan, my brain did the rest! Thank you!

Lewis 8:10 AM  

One of the great Crosslandia moments is The Great Aha, the magnificent Riddlecrack.

And sometimes, like today, it comes in the form of a rollercoaster moment, where you’ve been at the peak of struggle, like a rollercoaster slowly grinding up the huge hill, and then at the very top, where for a split second it sits still, the light bulb suddenly hits you, followed by the glorious and thrilling swoosh down.

Where you go from “Wha?” to “Whee!”, from clawing to soaring. This puzzle was made for that, and you can see that it played out like that for many solvers, based on the comments here and over at XwordInfo.

It sure did for me. Makes me grateful to be enmeshed in our marvelous pastime that can create thrilling rushes like this out of a box of letters.

Kudos to Jesse for taking a game that Will Shortz devised for the 2025 American Crossword Puzzle Tournament, and doing the remarkable grunt work of translating that idea into a flesh-and-blood puzzle. Kudos to Jesse, who in his notes generously credits Will for the idea.

Thank you, Jesse (and Will), for bringing thrill into the box today!

Mark 8:12 AM  

This is definitely a puzzle with mixed reviews. Personally, I really liked it. The theme was hard to crack, but once you did, it was easy to finish. I don’t mind that the grid doesn’t sparkle. I liked the challenge at the beginning and had a difficult but good time at the beginning.

Gary Jugert 8:17 AM  

Estoy aquí para ayudar.

Happy Birthday-ish Rex.

After a mild panic, I saw STEAMER TRUNK with its Ichabod Crane headlessness and knew the trick would be in the clue (thank you @Nancy) and the rest was duck soup. Even though I knew how to parse the answers, it's always enjoyable on Thursdays to see how each complication works itself out. Quite a fun little puzzle and over too soon.

TRIPLE A took me forever to see. I wanted to parse it TRIP LEA and I kept trying to imagine what a LEA was for on a trip.

Unusually, the gunk in the puzzle is almost entirely in the across answers. The verticals are jibberish at first glance, but the base words with their heads reattached are nice normal words. Quite unique.

❤️ BEER HAT. SHRUG IT OFF.

People: 6
Places: 3
Products: 7
Partials: 1
Foreignisms: 1
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 18 of 74 (24%)

Funny Factor: 1 🤨

Tee-Hee: NUDE. {Except they used Lennon to clue it, so less tee-hee and more eww.}

Uniclues:

1 When the pretty girl has a dead battery on her phone and her car.
2 Running naked while tugging a big box of clothes on a cruise ship.
3 The women who strap on the feed bags.
4 Give an honest answer to, "What do you think of my new hairstyle?"
5 Native rages.

1 ANGEL'S TRIPLE A CRISIS
2 STEAMER TRUNK STREAK (~)
3 STALLION'S HOSTESSES
4 START TEMPEST (~)
5 ALEUT SEETHES (~)

My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: How Igor keeps the monster regular. FRANK'S EXLAX.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Anonymous 8:19 AM  

did not enjoy that at all. maybe if i had caught onto the first lett of the clue is the missing letters it would have been a tiny bit better, but probably not.

EasyEd 8:20 AM  

In retrospect, great construction feat, but I really struggled with this because I didn’t get the full theme until too late. I kept trying to solve with rebus entries! We all know how that went…

Scot 8:21 AM  

John Oliver renamed the SeaWolves on an episode of Last Week Tonight earlier this season. They’re now (also?) the Moon Mammoths.

Bob Mills 8:26 AM  

Figured out the bizarre theme early, because 2-Down could only be ANGELS. But it took forever to finish because I was stuck on "Inuit" instead of alEUT, and "gross tons" instead of shORTTONS. One cheat told me shORTTONS was a valid measurement (don't know why you need "short," because "tons" and "short tons" are both 2,000 pounds).

kitshef 8:36 AM  

Really hard, and slow going as I kept entering rebuses. I did notice that the last letter of each rebus was used for the down clue. Then easy once I hit the revealer. Which is what the effect of revealers really ought to be every week.

andrew 8:43 AM  

Hit the “Turn ON Autocheck” button early, saw how GELS fit (Anaheim’s majorbteam) and was off to the proverbial races for the fun fill.

Nicely done - reminded me of the creative Thursdays of yore.

Anonymous 8:46 AM  

Tedious and boring. I hate it when the completed is filled with junk that are not words.

Anonymous 8:49 AM  

Annoying. Did not solve.

Anonymous 8:59 AM  

Agree. A waste of a Thursday. Sorry

Mary in NE 8:59 AM  

I puzzled over what kind of traveler's aid a (26D) TRIP LEA was for the longest time until my mind finally adjusted the spacing.

Anonymous 9:03 AM  

Am I missing something? When they build puzzles like this, aren’t the remaining letters supposed to also make words? These non-words are just arbitrary bundles of letters. And the whole “must have been difficult to construct” thing kind of falls apart when you figure out the constructed could just add two phantom squares and then delete them.

Puzzle was easier than a Monday when you figure out the “trick”.

Also, how was everybody able to intuit “SKIMOFFTHETOP” without crosses? Did no one try EMBEZZLEMONEY? It even matches the syntax of the clue.

pabloinnh 9:09 AM  

Of course I saw that the down answers were missing letters but my problem was that I at first thought they would be the same two letters, then thought they might spell something, then tried to see a pattern. In short, I made this a lot harder than it would have been if I could have figured out the revealer sooner. As it was, it was about the last thing I filled in. That will teach me to advocate for the revealer being late in the puzzle.

Would have helped if I had know PETER, remembered SETI, or had heard of ASUS, but none of these obtained.

Impressive feat of construction, JW (do I dare say "stunt puzzle>? O do). I Just Wish I had noticed the gimmick earlier, but thanks for a fair amount of thorny fun.

Anonymous 9:12 AM  

Inverse rebus... I just REW UP in my mouth a little.

Anonymous 9:22 AM  

Got it at “skim off the top” but never realized the missing letters started the clue until Rex told me

egsforbreakfast 9:27 AM  

After a little too much Smirnoff I had to SKIMOFFTHETOP of the puzzle and start over.

The top middle section presents a story in three words. It's the story of an Italian man who speaks broken English but finds himself in bed with a demanding American woman who just can't be satisfied: PETER SCUSI TIRES.

Well this was difficult to solve downs only. Thanks for the great aha! moment, Jesse Goldberg.

Anonymous 9:28 AM  

I hated this one. I always do all the across clues first then the downs, so the revealed didn’t mean anything at first. I did about six downs before I realized “Oh. Literally EVERY down clue is missing something.” But I wasn’t quite sure what. So I went back to the across and managed to fill in enough letters to figure out a couple of downs and get the revealer. After that it was easy (ish). But having the theme apply to half the puzzle made it so tedious. Worst one in a long time. If I’d been doing this on paper instead of the app where I could check answers I would have given up.

gfrpeace 9:36 AM  

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6fVaP6dM1fsThat would be stRAIGHTEN UP and fly right.

Anybody doing an ELM watch? Seems to me we've had at least 4 or 5 of them in thelast week.

Marty 9:48 AM  

I can think of another president who wasn’t born in the continental U.S….more like spawned.

Casarussell 9:52 AM  

BLAANGSTRSTA
noun

The state of mind that allows one to enter a string or strings of erroneous letters into a crossword in a vain attempt to solve it.
"He regretted his decision to solve in pen after suffering an episode of BLAANGSTRSTA."

Anonymous 9:53 AM  

I came here fully expecting a classic Rex Rant about how all answers need to stand alone as real words regardless of the theme. That’s my biggest beef with today’s puzzle, even more than all the bad crosswordese fill (LIENEE! ASUS! TSKS (plural)!)
What’s especially weird is that the first couple answers actually *were* irl words (ARE, GELS) but then steadily diminishing returns from REAK (maybe a real word if you squint) to ALLIONS (is that some kind of herb?) to … PSTORE.

Anonymous 9:53 AM  

I was convinced it was a rebus. Turns out I don't know shit from shinola.

Stuart 10:14 AM  

Ridiculously easy for a Thursday ... because I got the gimmick immediately. I happened to notice SKIM OFF THE TOP right after thinking that the Anaheim team must be the ANGELS, so bam! I'm off an running.

Anonymous 10:19 AM  

👏

burtonkd 10:19 AM  

I thought the song was about definitely USEME up even if it looks bad from the outside, and whatever I may have to put up with, it's definitely still worth it.
At any rate, thanks for making me think about it and getting the riff in my head on repeat:)

Anonymous 10:20 AM  

Agree completely. This is not a crossword puzzle. It’s a logic puzzle with words and gibberish. That’s fine. But not a crossword puzzle. It must have been tricky to construct, though I also wonder how much AI was used.

burtonkd 10:24 AM  

good one:)

burtonkd 10:26 AM  

I didn't see the trick until half way through, and had that great aha moment. So lost with what the themer was that it reminded me of my early solving experiences. I left the rebuses in and didn't get happy music, so hit my check puzzle and saw that I just needed to go back and use the last letters.
Went from tedious to a great aha!

mathgent 10:30 AM  

I saw the gimmick early, probably because I start by going through all the clues and fill in the gimmes. Not much fun after that.

jberg 10:32 AM  

Impossibly tough until I gave up and went looking for the revealer. Once I knew the answers needed something from the clues, it took only 4 or 5 guesses to come up with FIRST TWO LETTERS. Now, of course, I actually had the first two letters of every down answer, and it became very easy.

I guess SKIM OFF THE TOP is a second revealer, not at all needed but cute all the same. And congratulations to the constructor for finding new ways to clue both AGRA and ERIE!

There was still one difficulty for this non-Italian speaker: SCUS_. I should have known, but I tried A and then E before I.

Anonymous 10:34 AM  

SAME! I loved it. I figured it out early so I felt like I'd found the keys to the kingdom. I'm not letting anyone harsh my vibe :-)

Les S. More 10:36 AM  

Well that was a bitch. SCUSI, I meant to say e stato difficile. I was so confused by this thing I thought I might never finish. I knew something was up by the time I hit 2D which had to be Angels. Crosses pointed to GELS, but why? What kind of nonsense was going on here? I was, as they say in Crossworld, seriously at sea. By the time I figured out what was going on, all I could think is “what would cause anyone to think of this? Who hurt Jesse Goldberg so badly that he would do this to us?” But I must admit I was kind of enjoying the challenge.

The missing AN from ANGELS, the ST from STREAK, and again from STALLION, and then AP from APP STORE … where was the pattern?

It wasn’t until I skipped down to the revealer that I started to get a glimpse of the chicanery involved. There was no letter pattern, only the first two letters of each entry as explained at 52A were SKIMmed OFF THE TOP, as pointed out at 20A, when I finally worked it out. Sheesh! I’m afraid I may have concussed myself with the major dope slap.

Nice job, Jesse Goldberg. I loved it in a weirdly masochistic way.

JT 10:38 AM  

Before I read Rex's comments I thought to myself, "This felt like a chore."

I didn't fill in many Across answers until I got to the W/SW, and then I could see that 29D was supposed to be STRAIGHTEN UP. That led me to think that all the Downs would have an initial ST missing. Eventually I got STRAIGHTENED OUT about that, but finishing just felt like a slog.

Oh well, there's some satisfaction in working through it...I guess!

Sinfonian 10:44 AM  

Honestly, I really liked this puzzle. I didn't realize it was considered cheating (or at least questionable) to check a revealer at the start. Live and learn.

The Anaheim clue led me to either Angels or Ducks at first, so I went to (what I figured was) the revealer right away to make that decision. The rest was pretty much a breeze. Sorry for violating a norm, though.

jae 10:47 AM  

Tough then easy works for me too.

When I slowly and carefully explained the theme to my bride she said “What a pain in the ass that is”. I didn’t disagree.

jberg 10:49 AM  

@Roo, your comment got me wondering how I did get the revealer. I think it went as follows:

1. the clue let me know that there was SOMETHING missing from the down answers.
2. I had OBAMA and FILET, and 56-D had to be helmet, so I tried LMET.

3. the OF made me think 39-D would be (sh)RUG IT OFF.

4. At that point, I noticed the 'first two letters' of each clue thing.

Mostly, it was just luck!

hieutonthat 10:50 AM  

I kinda liked it. Always looking for the Thursday theme, and this one was different. I also started down the rebus path, but was clueless enough until the revealer. After that, pretty smooth sailing.

Also: happy birthday to the blog! You’ll find a little gift in Venmo. That’s how the kids are doing it…

jberg 10:53 AM  

British tons used to be "long tons" before they went metric.

tht 11:00 AM  

If I ever knew what this god stood for, I had forgotten. Googling this was problematic because it's supposed to be OOXTEPLERNON, the god of bad fill. Rex coined it off the center row of this puzzle from 2009. See also RP's faq.

jb129 11:01 AM  

I don't think I have ever come across a puzzle that I am less likely to want to figure out - forget about solving - than this. I couldn't make any headway at all & worse, I didn't want to. I'm glad I lost my streak on Sunday's rebus puzzle - now I can comfortably walk away from this one. I don't remember that happening in a very long time.
Happy BlogDay Rex :)

Anonymous 11:09 AM  

Hated it. Did not catch onto the first two letters being in the clue itself, ugh

Carola 11:14 AM  

This was a bear for me, for a very long time. For most of the grid, I wrote in the three-letter rebus squares that would give me the correct Down entry - and suspended judgment on the gibberish that resulted Across-wise. Fortunately, in 52A, I had enough "real" letters among the gibberish squares to let me see the phrase. After that, the puzzle turned into a lamb. I enjoyed both the extended rassling and the easy filling-in. Early on, I'd wondered if there were something tricky going on with the clues, but I couldn't see it. Love it when a puzzle fakes me out (but then I finally get it :) ).

Les S. More 11:19 AM  

@jae. Never discuss a crossword conceit with a non crossworder. They'll just tell you to seek professional counseling.

Whatsername 11:24 AM  

Yesterday only two theme clues. Today 37. The NYTXW has become like a box of chocolates; never know what you’re gonna get.

I wandered around almost through the entire top half before figuring out what was going on. At least I figured it out before I got to the revealer anyway. Even then, I did not expect every down clue to be missing letters, figured there would just be the usual handful of themers and the rest would be “normal.” That didn’t last long. But I still insisted on making it harder for myself than it needed to be because I didn’t grasp that the first two letters of the clues were the missing ones. Could’ve sailed through it a lot faster if only I’d paid attention. But in retrospect, I’m glad because knowing what the missing letters were would’ve taken all the fun out of it. As it is, the challenge was all in the construction.

Happy anniversary RP! I was a lurker back then and didn’t start posting for years after that, but I often found your blog to be a good source of reference when I was a rookie solver.

Anonymous 11:25 AM  

Same errors, figured it out on TE-MPEST. After that slogged down through revealer. Acrosses pretty good with even a few chuckles - impressive construction

JT 11:26 AM  

P.S. I never realized the first two letters of the Down clues were the first two letters of the answers. Maybe that's why filling them in wasn't such a breeze for me. :-\

Anonymous 11:35 AM  

Blech - just tedious imo... i definitely prefer a tough friday or saturday over a rinse-and-repeat thursday gimmick

Spaceman 11:42 AM  

Not a fan of Thursdays in general HOWEVER I am grateful for a new Thursday gimmick that's not a rebus for once

Georgia 11:52 AM  

Clever construction! This is what I love about puzzles.

Jared 11:57 AM  

I'm a lawyer and not only did I need every cross to get LIENEE, I've never even heard the word.

Anonymous 12:16 PM  

Embarrassed to admit that I finished the puzzle thinking “wtf is a TRIP PLEA?? A prayer for good connecting flights?”

Jess 12:27 PM  

I kind of enjoyed the themer. I’d figured out about a third of the way through that I was entering words sans their first couple letters - I just thought that they ALL started with “st” because I happened to solve a couple that DID start with “st” lol

Teedmn 12:32 PM  

LIENEE is one of those words that I try in Spelling Bee every time the letters offer the opportunity. So far, it's not been accepted for some reason.

I needed the revealer to get this trick. I was down in the far SW trying to fit a rebus into 52D's [in]FANT when I saw the clue for 52A and it all fell into place. As Rex says, once known, the trick makes the puzzle pretty easy but it still took me a while to finish. I had wasted a lot of time previous to my theme epiphany trying to confirm with down crosses some of my across guesses. Unable to get that confirmation, I just left everything blank and wandered the grid.

Only a few of the downs actually make real words. ISIS and TOMB, RIDE, TURF, GELS, ART, ARE. Can we please make RUG IT OFF a new saying?

Thanks, Jesse Goldberg, this was a new way to make Thursdays tricky.

Andy Freude 12:54 PM  

Ha! Thanks for the UGH!

Andy Freude 12:58 PM  

This puzzle wasn’t Shinola.

  © Free Blogger Templates Columnus by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP