Rhyming toys with colored pegs / SUN 12-22-24 / Online initialism of excitement / Head-to-toe Islamic garment / Hybrid dog breed with curly hair / Cocktail made from peach nectar and Prosecco / Solidify, as a jiggly dessert / Frozen yogurt chain with a fruity name / Jazz standard with the lyric "I'm so tired of paying my dues" / Reality show about the perils of crabbing in the Bering Sea / Medicare section that cover ambulance services / Drink brand with lizards in its logo

Sunday, December 22, 2024

Constructor: Adrian Johnson

Relative difficulty: Easy


THEME: "Go With the Flow" (a Sunday Themeless) 

Word of the Day: MÁLAGA (81D: Spanish city where Picasso was born) —

[Britannica]

Málaga (/ˈmæləɡə/Spanish: [ˈmalaɣa]) is a municipality of Spain, capital of the Province of Málaga, in the autonomous community of Andalusia. With a population of 591,637 in 2024, it is the second-most populous city in Andalusia and the sixth most populous in the country. It lies in Southern Iberia on the Costa del Sol ("Coast of the Sun") of the Mediterranean, primarily in the left bank of the Guadalhorce. The urban core originally developed in the space between the Gibralfaro Hill and the Guadalmedina. (wikipedia)
• • •

[they still make these?]
As you know if you've been reading me for a while, these are not my favorite, these themeless Sundays. Beyond the structural limitations of a 15x15 grid, a themeless puzzle seems ... pointless. I guess this is a low word-count puzzle, but I wouldn't know. I know that 15x15 themelesses max out at 72 words—the word count is a meaningful limitation. Here, shrug, I don't know. Sure, stack 16s over 15s over 14s, who's stopping you? But also, who cares? Are the answers good? Yes, I guess, many of them. But in this ocean-sized grid, the accomplishment is somehow diminished. The answers can't shine. There are people who love these themeless Sundays, but I don't get it at all. Especially after yesterday's rather accomplished tough offering, this themeless seems tepid. It's just ... big. It's good, as Sunday themelesses go, but my point is that Sunday themelesses can't go much of anywhere. I flew through this, without much of any feeling or opinion (except that LITE BRITE should never, ever be in the plural, oof, what the hell?) (43A: Rhyming toys with colored pegs). With the exception of PERISH THE THOUGHT, there was nothing that really sizzled. I think the longer answers are all solid, and EQUATORIAL GUINEA is certainly ... long (91A: Only African nation where Spanish is an official language). Splashy, as country names go. I like PORE STRIP just fine (it's original, at any rate—this is its debut). But I would've liked to see more life, more pizzazz, less BRO CODE, less DOLLAR TREE (both of which are depressing, in different ways). The good thing for me, today, is I don't really have to spend a lot of time talking about it. If you liked it, great, if not, great. There's just not much to say about it.


JELL will always look wrong to me (42A: Solidify, as a jiggly dessert). Like it should be three letters, or have an "-O" after it, or something. Actually, GEL is the only spelling of that word that doesn't look insane to me. Doesn't GEL also mean solidify??? Yes! It means to "set," and in fact is listed at merriam webster dot com as an alternative to JELL. I would say it's the preferred spelling. Speaking of that "J," JOG TROT? (42D: Relaxed gait). That feels redundant. How many trots are there (besides fox and turkey)? JOG TROT feels like something an overstuffed wordlist coughed up. Beyond that (and whatever else I've whined about already), I don't have any significant complaints about the fill today. It's very solid, for the most part. Well, SCHNOODLE feels ridiculous, but most hybrid dog breed names feel at least a little ridiculous (never heard of a SCHNOODLE, but with the SCHN- in place, the -OODLE was really not hard to infer) (8D: Hybrid dog breed with curly hair). I had a number of tiny errors today. Had the drink as a BELLONI (?!) (33D: Cocktail made from peach nectar and Prosecco). I had trouble thinking of *any* European city that fit the pattern _ERL__, which in retrospect seems insane, but that's what happened. You can see in my finished grid that the very last letter I got was the "B" in PART B because how in the world do I know? I'm not on Medicare yet. I don't even know how many "parts" there are. And I wasn't sure at first if BURQA or NIQAB or HIJAB was the "head-to-toe" garment the clue was looking for (all five letters!) (76D: Head-to-toe Islamic garment). So I left that square blank and waited. Then time passed. Then the puzzle was over.


Anything else?:
  • 1A: Reality show about the perils of crabbing in the Bering Sea (DEADLIEST CATCH) — like most reality shows—never seen it. But I've certainly heard of it. Has ICE-ROAD TRUCKERS been in a puzzle? [checks] Yes!? Nine years ago, on a Tuesday. Surprisingly, neither REALHOUSEWIVES nor THEREALHOUSEWIVES has ever appeared in the NYTXW (the latter is less surprising, as it would only fit in a Sunday-sized grid).
  • 46A: Online initialism of excitement (FTW) — this one was a mini-adventure. Wanted OMG but the crosses wouldn't work, then had it down to -TW and thought, "BTW??? That's not exciting ... unless you're excited about the next thing you're going to say ... hmm ... maybe?" No. It's FTW, which I haven't seen much in recent years, but which used to be all over social media. It stands for "For the Win!" and it originated in video games (Half-Life and Dark Age of Camelot message boards get cited a lot) but before that, as an expression, "For the win..." was probably popularized by either Hollywood Squares or sports announcing.
  • 55A: Frozen yogurt chain with a fruity name (PINKBERRY) — got the PINK but blanked on the BERRY. I don't understand frozen yogurt. I mean, it's edible, I've eaten it, but ... ice cream is so good. Can't imagine wanting froyo when I could have ice cream.
  • 16D: Second-smallest U.S. state capital by population, after Montpelier (PIERRE) — also the only U.S. state capital to be named after a Maurice Sendak book (after Where the Wild Things Are, Kansas lost its bid to Topeka)
  • 69A: Travel-size makeup bag VANITY CASE — daughter is home for the holidays, and though she does not have a VANITY CASE (I don't think...), there is something in the bathroom now called "Vanicream." First thought was that it seemed weird to associate your product with "vanity," but then I realized the "Vani-" part probably stood for "vanishing." Do not take a vanishing case with you when you travel, you'll just lose it.
  • 23D: Emotion picture? (TEARJERKER) — so ... a motion "picture" designed to stir your "emotions."
  • 92D: Holiday in which bánh chung cakes are eaten (TET) — if it's a three-letter holiday, it's TET (unless it's EID, which I learned the hard way while solving a cryptic crossword recently)
  • 79D: Jazz standard with the lyric "I'm so tired of paying my dues" ("MOANIN'") — whoa, a "jazz standard" that I've never heard of. At least I don't think I have. Let's listen and find out... OK, this is familiar.

There's also a great instrumental version by Art Blakey


Hopefully this puzzle didn't have you MOANIN' too much. That's all I got. Except Holiday Pet Pics, I got some of those, for sure (again, submissions are closed for this year—don't make me reject Fluffy! It's not fair!).

Here's Gypsy Rose Tyson Fury, who I believe is the first pet ever to appear on this blog in pillow form
[Thanks, Ron]

Here's Orion (seen here without his belt), helping make Christmas cookies. Who's a good quality control officer!? Yes, that's right, it's you, good boy!
[Thanks, Judith]

I'm told that Autumn (age 10) is kind of intimidated by the tree, so here's a rare pic of her doing a cautious walk-by. So brave. Stay strong, Autumn!
[Thanks, Robert]

Streak and Freckles are too young to really understand Christmas yet. "Is this tree? Am I present?" Yes, and yes.
[Thanks, Carole]

And finally ... look, I told Scruffy that he's already been featured once this year, and that's all the attention any holiday pupper can expect, but then he ran up and started yelling at me and honestly it's just easier to post more of his pics
["Hey, hey, hey ... REX, HEY! WAIT UP!"]

["Put me on again!" "Buddy, I already..." "PUT ME ON AGAIN! I'M ADORABLE, WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE IT'S NOT LIKE YOU HAVE STANDARDS COME ON JUST DO IT DO IT DO-" "Yeesh, OK, OK"] [Thanks (again), Donna]

That's all from pet land today. 

One last thing: today's constructor, Adrian Johnson, has put together a second collection of Puzzles for Palestine, which has lots of very familiar names on its constructor and editor roster (Erik Agard, Evan Birnholz, Natan Last, Will Nediger, etc.). Here's Adrian's pitch:
Puzzles for Palestine 2 is a collection of twenty-two original crossword puzzles that celebrate and uplift the rich history, people and culture of Palestine— constructed, edited, and tested by the best people in the business. Twenty of those puzzles are American-style crosswords ranging in shapes and sizes from 9x9 to 21x21, including one two-part crosswordThe pack also includes one 11x11 cryptic and one variety puzzle. These puzzles are available in exchange for any tax-deductible donation to the PFP2 fundraiser, coordinated with the Palestine Aid Society of America to raise money for water tanks and large pots of food (to feed 100-125 people), in addition to meeting ongoing medical and educational needs among folks in Gaza.

This is the second installment of Puzzles for Palestine— the first raised $13,100 for four humanitarian aid organizations (and can be received with a $40+ donation to PFP2). Puzzles are now available for pre-order, with a release date of the first weekend of 2025. A perfect gift for those who love crosswords and want to make a difference.
OK, now we're done. Take care. See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook]

43 comments:

Conrad 6:32 AM  


I'm not a huge fan of Sunday themeless puzzles, but I Liked this one better than @Rex did. Few if any overwrites but lots of WOEs, all of which were fairly crossed so they weren't too WOEful.

I knew PIERRE (16D), BERLIN (50D), MALAGA (81D) and EQUATORIAL GUINEA (91A) but I didn't know the trivia in the respective clues. Crosswords are for learning.

Never heard of or didn't remember ESTELLE (8D), PORE STRIP (27A), JOG TROT (42D), the BELLINI recipe (33D), PINKBERRY (55A) or MOANIN' (79D).

Anonymous 6:34 AM  

How did we go from last weeks amazing art heist theme that took a lot of thought to this boring themeless puzzle that was way too easy for a Sunday?

Anonymous 6:55 AM  

this was super easy

Son Volt 7:14 AM  

Talk about a vibe killer - fresh off of one of the best back to backs in years and we get a themeless Sunday? I couldn’t agree with Rex more - why this? It’s basically an oversized Wednesday level grid with nothing to tie it together. Evan Birnholz has mastered the large-scale themeless but in lesser hands they become tedious.

BERLIN

PERISH THE THOUGHT and LETTERS TO SANTA save those massive corners from complete drudgery. The crossing plural BOLOS x THESES is rough. LITE BRITES is nostalgic and fun.

Dan Bern

I wonder whether they just don’t get enough quality themed Sunday entries or do they really think these are what solvers want? It’s 14 out this morning and this one did nothing to warm me up.

Arbolito de Navidad

Kent 7:18 AM  

A themeless Sunday needs a little more bite, zing, pizzazz—something. The clueing on this one was pretty tepid, and very easy. I finished in less than half of my Sunday average.

Anonymous 7:33 AM  

Enjoyed the pictures of your pets more than this puzzle. I'm with you, it seemed unrewarding to not have a theme to figure out today.

Lewis 7:56 AM  

This felt smooth as butter to me. Relaxing. I didn’t fly through it, as I often do early in the week, which can feel electric, but not tranquil. Nor was It full of hitches, like driving on a rutty road.

No, this was soothing, like tubing down the river. And that felt good. Enough resistance to keep interest and motivation, enough open doors to make the forward progress feel like a glide. Ahhh.

What helped was kind cluing and the low number of out-of-wheelhouse answers, at least for me.

I love the swirly grid design – never used before in the Times puzzle -- even with the suggestion of a Superman S in the middle, and with many long answers (the normal Sunday has 140 words, this one has 124). Even with the long answers, it’s cleanly filled, a testament to Adrian’s grid-building chops.

Lovely answers enhanced the journey: PERISH THE THOUGHT, VANITY CASE, SCHNOODLE, TEARJERKER, PEWTER, and the fetching EQUATORIAL GUINEA. I liked seeing FORA near FORABIT, and ALTERNATE ENDING abutting the actual ending.

You sent me peacefully and placidly into my day, Adrian, for which I’m most grateful. Thank you!

Rug Crazy 8:00 AM  

ez. schnoodle?

Fun_CFO 8:01 AM  

Yeah, I think publishing this was just a nod to the constructor and not going a calendar year without a themeless Sunday.

Not a huge fan of these either. Puzzle overall is ok, but just too big. Quite a bit of trivia. Too much stuff with little payoff, which isn’t unusual on Sundays, but just magnified.

LITEBRITES is an awful POC.
Sure it’s a “me” problem, but clues referencing each other as the only clue (SRS, JRS), just grinds my gears. So uninspired. Annoying.

Congrats to constructor on getting a Sunday before year-end.

Ellen 8:07 AM  

It seems I'm an outlier. This themeless Sunday puzzle looked more daunting than it was but was a welcome treat after an overwhelming week. Perhaps the PTB served this up because they knew many folks are busy shopping, traveling, gift-wrapping or baking cookies this weekend. IMHO, a Sunday puzzle without bite can be a confidence booster. Happy that Scruffy forced his way into the pictures; it proves that Rex isn't a total curmudgeon this Sunday.

SouthsideJohnny 8:08 AM  

There were enough chip shots and two-footers that it was easy to get plenty of toeholds and basically “dabble” at the rest. A forensic cruciverbalist would have a field day with this one, as it has NYT DNA everywhere - plenty of foreign words and places, a small section filled up with garbage that few of us have heard of or care about, such as FORA, FRIDA, MOANIN, MALAGA . . .

I suspected a few months ago when the editor started more enthusiastically embracing textisms that he wouldn’t know when enough is enough - so today we get FTW (and Joel F gets a BOLO award).

This one got kind of boring - I didn’t detect the theme, and the title seemed ambiguous, so I figured OFL would explain it to me (except that there was nothing to explain, so I just wondered around back-filling stuff like MORT, TARTAN, PINK BERRY and of course, PORE STRIP by Biore).

mmorgan 8:10 AM  

Wow, I spent the longest time trying to figure out the theme. I wouldn’t give up on the idea that a puzzle titled “Go with the Flow” couldn’t possibly be a themeless. Ouch.

My daughter had a Schnoodle. Very cute, but he had some issues.

Benbini 8:11 AM  

THESES are not “musts” for masters degrees.

Anonymous 8:24 AM  

I almost completed this in one pass. Which made it a total snooze fest, despite several sparkling answers.

Pamela 8:32 AM  

Sigh. Will S, if you're paying attention, p!ease stop. What a waste, esp on a holiday weekend!

Anonymous 8:45 AM  

I don’t know it for a fact but I’m thinking the whole point of this Sunday themeless was to hit a record number of Times debuts. Perhaps someone has that data point to share here? Mission accomplished for the constructor, unsatisfying experience for the solver. Moving on.

RooMonster 8:51 AM  

Hey All !
Not a fan of Themeless SunPuzs. That said, this one was decent. And quick. Flew through it like I imagine Rex and other fast solvers solve. Although, time was probably slower than that!

My crazy computer likes to fail at staying connected, but I finished with the start of the Happy Music, only to be cut off, and had to restart computer. Now it has the grid completed and the timer stopped, but the main page has it as incompleted. Silly computer.

Some nice answers and some good clues, but again, I side with Rex on the "what's the point of a Themeless SunPuz?" side. I don't remember putting in a Z for the Pangram ... Lemme check (Insert Final Jeopardy music here) ... Nope, no Z. Try harder next time. Har.

Gonna add COCOAS as an iffy plural to Rex's LITEBRITES. I had a LITE BRITE as a kid. It came with sheets of paper you put over the screen, some were pre-patterened, as in the clown face you see on the box. It told you what colored lights to put in the slots and where. Then you turned the light on to see your masterpiece. It also had blank sheets, so if you were the artistic type, you could come up with your own design.

Gotta JOG TROT away now, Happy Sunday!

Five F's
RooMonster
DarrinV

kitshef 8:54 AM  

Very easy Sunday. Title is just meaningless?
CAnape before CAVIAR
spies before MAFIA (never heard of it)
moWED before HEWED (thinking even as I entered it that it could be either)
WRiER before WRYER (thinking even as a I entered it that it looked wrong)

JOG TROT is pretty awful.

Anonymous 9:08 AM  

Loved LITE BRITE and LOG RIDE in the same puzzle - two childhood favs! Throw in a little PINKBERRY (which is hard to find these days) and LETTERS TO SANTA and I thought this had some nice feel-good answers. I wish the constructor could’ve found a way to work in Caboodle for VANITY CASE - ladies of the 80s, you know what I’m talking about!

andrew 9:12 AM  

Never EVER have I encountered an easier Sunday NYTXW! Only temporary setbacks were BURkA (thought must be EkUATORIAL must be spelled in an Afrikaan way and dRYER as more sardonic). Otherwise, way too little resistance and no theme to keep me engaged, even with a DIVA at my side waiting for her 30 second “just pee already” morning “walk” (baby, it’s cold outside - let’s hurry this up!)

Niallhost 9:17 AM  

Anyone else DNF on the MiLAGA/FORi square? In retrospect FORA makes more sense but felt certain that the city in Spain had an "I" in it, maybe because of the Beanfield Wars? I don't know. Seems to happen to me all the time. Fly through a puzzle then get hung up on one square. Feels like high school all over again...

Anonymous 9:20 AM  

10 minutes flat. Far too easy for a Sunday puzzle, but hey, new personal record!

Paul & Kathy 9:59 AM  

I suppose this means you weren't interested in the Super Mega puzzle that the Times put out for its paper subscribers? I ordered it (thanks to Rex, wouldn't have known otherwise) and it just arrived yesterday. Started on the super mega but that is going to take awhile. It's not very hard though. About like today's puzzle.

egsforbreakfast 10:02 AM  

I saw the title (Go with the flow) and fairly early on (30A) came to FLOES. Okay, sez I, the theme is variations on "flow". I guess soon enough I'll be seeing the ever-popular Flo from Progressive. Or maybe "Nightingale to her chums". Maybe they'll even throw in a "FLUIR" (Spanish for flow) just to get a rise from @Southside Johnny. But no, I guess the title is telling me to not worry about things and just do the humongous themeless. Roger that!

His fiancé said he'd be cut down if he dallied any more, so HEWED.

As the proud owner of a Labradoodle named Baffi (Italian for mustache) I was all over the SCHNOODLE. Made me think of the New Yorker cartoon a few weeks ago wherein two NY dog owners are crossing paths while walking their mutts. One is a normal looking dog and the other appears to be a full size triceratops with curly hair all over its body. "Triceradoodle" says the owner.

Guest: Is this drink with lizards on the label the only drink you've got?
Waiter: Afraid so. Would you like one?
Guest: SOBE it.

I'm partial to themed puzzles, so a themeless this large was not my cuppa. But I thought the puzzle was fine for what it was. Thanks, Adrian Johnson.

Anonymous 10:04 AM  

I am solidly on Team Lewis today(7:56). I love the big themeless much more than most Sundays.

Anonymous 10:36 AM  

Too many plural answers ending with s. Seems lazy to me.

Anonymous 10:36 AM  

Ditto. Thought the long stacks were going to be hard, but these fell in relatively easily and made me smile.

For me there was just enough holiday spirit for an end of year puzzle. LETTERS TO SANTA, BELLINI one of our go to holiday drinks, LITE BRITES a great kids gift, RED NOSE (Rudolph), COCOAS a classic holiday drink, TET isn't too far off, FUR (many a Christmas tree), COAL (Frosty's eyes), and VANITYCASE in honor of Rex's daughter being home for the holidays.

I guess this puzzle was either "Bah Humbug!!!"
or "Happy Christmas to all, and to all a good night."

Bob Mills 10:38 AM  

I don't care if I'm in the minority...a themeless puzzle on Sunday is a breath of fresh air. It was easy, yes; but only in comparison with puzzles that subordinate rhetoric and etymology (words) to visual trickery.

Anonymous 10:41 AM  

Just kind of meh. And done in disappointingly record time. I like to linger over a Sunday puzzle but no extra anything needed today.

Carola 10:48 AM  

Like @mmorgan 8:10, I was sure that there was a theme, and I spent a fair bit of time racking my brain over it. And feeling dumb that I couldn't see it. But that's the only thing I didn't like about solving the puzzle. I thought the wealth of long answers was one gift after another, and, really, after TEAR JERKER and PERISH THE THOUGHT, what more do you need?

Blue Stater 10:49 AM  

Well, just to assert the other side of the discussion, I thought this puzzle was elegant and fair, and i don't often say this about WS-era NYTXWs. I was particularly pleased by the themelessness. Themed puzzles are to me a distraction from what I regard as the center of crosswords: knowledge of fact and language. This puzzle called on that knowledge, and I loved it.

Mike Titlebaum 10:51 AM  

Because I am a nerdy jazz professor: the instrumental recording of Art Blakey band playing Moanin’ came first. The Lambert, Hendricks & Ross arrangement is called a vocalise, when singers add lyrics to an instrumental piece. Enjoy!

Teedmn 10:54 AM  

The grid art must be the theme. It looks like a Pachinko game. I should know - my Dad bought a Pachinko game and I spent most of my winter school break pulling the lever and watching the ball make its way down to the bottom. There was no payoff and I can't even remember what result I was aiming for. I just know I can never go to a casino - I would spend all my money on slot machines.

This felt easy but took me about average time. I think, with no theme, there was no chance to guess ahead at what the answer might be on the long answers. It seems cleanly done but there's no Sunday wackiness or wordplay, which I miss. Still, no one can complain that the theme doesn't work :-).

Thanks, Adrian Johnson!

Anonymous 10:56 AM  

Do you mean 10 minutes and every blank filled? correctly? So fast!

Nancy 11:00 AM  

Actually, this was pretty flow-y -- so I went with the flow wherever I could. And while a great theme on Sunday is always preferable to a themeless puzzle -- giving you a macro solution along with a lot of micro ones -- a nice flow-y themeless that requires some thought is preferable to a drab, tepid theme that allows your mind to wander. I enjoyed this and was never either bored or impatient.

There was plenty I never heard of: LITES RITES; PORESTRIP (why does that sound sort of unappetizing?); SOSE; ESTELLE (does she ever get confused with Adele?); MOANIN; and even SCHNOODLE (I wanted some sort of DOODLE, but I assume it's a cross between a schnauser (sp?) and a poodle. And, btw, how the heck do you spell schnauser? Don't want to leave the page.)

Which reminds me: Is SOSE correct? I forgot to look.

Have you ever heard anyone say JOGTROT?. I certainly haven't.

One of the more enjoyable Sunday puzzles, but not one of the most memorable. But it kept me engaged on a bitterly cold morning when I'm not going anywhere.

I thought the cluing here succeeded in being interesting, but only one clue was truly tricky. Loved the clue for TEARJERKER.



bigsteve46 11:01 AM  

Since I pay no attention to who constructs a puzzle or keep track of how long it took me to do it or think of crossword puzzles as anything more than a nice little lagniappe in my daily newspaper, this was right down my alley.

Anonymous 11:11 AM  

After finishing the puzzle, I came here to find out the theme. I was so looking forward to Rex Parker explaining the clever theme to me, which I had somehow missed while rushing through the puzzle….

jae 11:16 AM  

Yep, very easy. Almost zero resistance. I put in DEADLIEST CATCH and just kept going (I too have never seen the show but I have seen the promos).

LITEBRITES, BELLINI, and MOANIN were it for WOEs and hAt before CAP and naNaS before aunts were my only erasures.

Nice to have a breezy pre-holiday solve with a bit of sparkle, liked it.

Nancy 11:28 AM  

Just looked. SOsE is not correct! Neither is LITEsRITES. Oh well.

Anonymous 11:34 AM  

FTW = For the Win. There is also FTD = Fresh to Death. The meaning of each phrase is close enough. I got badly stuck because my brain didn't pick up that DRYER is not DRIER. (The word needed was WRYER.)

Alice Pollard 11:38 AM  

Sorry, I got up real early Saturday morning (hard copy) looking forward to a cool Christmas themed puzzle. A let down. "Did Santa skip over our house?" kinda feel. Regardless, finished it rather quickly so I got a jump on Christmas errands.

thefogman 11:40 AM  

Note to Joel Fagliano: Sundays should always be themed. Especially the puzzle that runs just a few days before Xmas. Also, Sundays should be quite a bit more challenging than your average Monday.

PS - When is Will Shortz coming back?

Anonymous 11:42 AM  

Is there any point to the title? Instead of a title it should have simply stated “Themeless”. Another lunchbag letdown.

  © Free Blogger Templates Columnus by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP