Famous palindrome starter / SAT 1-18-25 / Arabic for "prayer" / Chest-beating sort / Informal hookups / Memorable title role of a 1941 film / Avian symbol of good fortune in Celtic culture / Person partial to humour? / City that's the "heart of Africa's art scene," per National Geographic / Female rapper with the 2008 hit "Paper Planes" / Fish with a shy-sounding name

Saturday, January 18, 2025

Constructor: Scott McMahon

Relative difficulty: Extremely Easy


THEME: none 

Word of the Day: MAHÓN (2D: Capital and second-largest city of Minorca) —

[flag of Minorca—love an insignia that looks like a video game villain]

Mahón (Spanish: [maˈon]), officially Maó (Catalan: [məˈo], locally [ˈmo]; formerly spelled Mahó), and also written as Mahon or Port Mahon in English, is the capital and second largest city of Menorca. The city is located on the eastern coast of the island, which is part of the archipelago and autonomous community of the Balearic Islands.

Mahón has one of the longest natural harbours in the world: 5 kilometres (3 miles) long and up to 900 metres (3,000 feet) wide. The water is deep but remains mostly clear due to the port's enclosed nature. Mayonnaise is considered to have originated in Mahón.

Its population in 2021 was estimated to be 29,125. (wikipedia)

• • •

One of those puzzles where I kinda wish I was still speed-solving, still timing myself and going as fast as I can, because I swear I could've dropped this one in about 3 (roughly my average Monday time, back when I was keeping track). Crushing a personal best would've given me at least a little rush, which is more sensation than I got out of solving this one at a relaxed pace. When you stack 15s, you ... well, you can't expect much in the way of fill excitement. It's hard just to get those damn 15s to stack in such a way that the crosses don't suck. Expecting scintillation from such a construction is probably not fair. At best you're going to top out at "smooth," which I think this one does, mostly. CARE TO ELABORATE and CHRISTMAS SPIRIT are pleasant enough; all the other 15s (save one) are at least solid. Then there's the palindrome ... partial? Oof. Not a category of fill I'd aspire to draw from. Easy to get (very easy), but ugly, compared to all the others. If you knew the palindrome, then that one was a gimme, and of course getting 1-Across in a puzzle like this is a huge momentum-booster, as now you've got the front ends of allllll the crosses. I thought I might have some trouble navigating from one section of this puzzle to the next, as the passageways are pretty narrow, but nope, it was easy. Continuity of the solve never broke, from the opening gambit:


To the transition to the middle:


To the very bottom of the grid:


I guess I kinda sorta broke continuity when the only answer I was able immediately to drop into the bottom was KNELT, and I was not able to confidently cross it with anything (so many birds are four letters and end in "N"—I thought maybe SWAN) (48A: Avian symbol of good fortune in Celtic culture), and so I checked one those four-letter Downs in the SW to see if they could help, and one of them immediately did (ROTE) (49D: ___ learning). From ROTE, I got WREN and ... well, immediately f'd up by writing in WISP instead of WHIT at 48D: Slightest amount, but that was easily corrected. After that, no resistance. Puzzle over.


Quick start on this one, as ACCRA was a gimme (or the first thing I thought of, anyway) (1D: City that's the "heart of Africa's art scene," per National Geographic), and ANY and ROAN confirmed it very quickly. The palindrome was obvious from there, and the top third went down in a flash. Stunned that I was able to drop all four long Downs into the middle third of the grid off just their first letters. I literally beat my chest here at my desk trying to conjure the type of guy who acts like that, and I thought "so he's like a GORILLA ... wait! No, he *is* a GORILLA ... or it's a literal GORILLA, whatever" (22D: Chest-beating sort). WINSLET and TUNED IN, no sweat. I probably needed the "M" from MUM to get "I'M ALIVE," actually. But still, zero trouble there. Middle went down so fast I literally never looked at the clue for *two* of those 15s (SPANISH OMELETTE, SATELLITE DISHES). Just filled them in easily after tearing through so many of the crosses. The one sticking point today, if you can call it that, which you cannot (credibly), came at the middle-bottom, when I stalled out on both the Arabic word for "prayer" (starting "S") and the Netflix category (starting "A"). Had no guesses for the latter, and thought maybe the former was SANA'A (!?), but was (wisely) not willing to commit to that. Waited for the rush of answers to come over from the SW, and sure enough, those 15s flooded the zone and SALAH and ANIME became clear, though I needed every cross for SALAH, the last of which came from CAN, which had a hard (toilet) clue.


Bullets:
  • 2D: Capital and second-largest city of Minorca (MAHÓN) — look, I'm sure it's tempting to sign your puzzle like this—probably feels winky and cute and clever—but when you have to rely on geographic obscurity in order to do it, maybe don't. "Capital" is a funny word since not only is Minorca not a country (it belongs to Spain), it's not even a province. I don't really know what it is, administratively. Anyway, if you didn't know MAHÓN, I'm here to absolve you of any feelings of geographic inadequacy or failure. There's no reason you should know it (only been in the puzzle two other times ('03, '15, both Sundays)).
  • 19A: Female rapper with the 2008 hit "Paper Planes" (MIA) — a classic. An absolute banger. One of the most iconic hip-hop songs of the '00s (in that I was largely checked out of contemporary music for that decade, but that song still got through to me, loud and clear). MIA is Tamil (born in Britain to Sri Lankan parents). Last I heard of her, she was appearing at RFK, Jr. rallies. Life is long and weird and sometimes tragic.
[mkay ...]
  • 31A: One of 12 for Katharine Hepburn (OSCAR NOMINATION) — first of all, technically there are three (3!) "Kates" in this puzzle, only one of them's a Katharine (often called "Kate") and the other is a CATE (presumably pronounced "Kate") (33D: ___ Tiernan, author of the "Immortal Beloved' trilogy). Second, in a weird coincidence, I've been reading the new book Box Office Poison, about spectacular movie flops throughout history, and not only was Katharine Hepburn featured prominently (for her role in the not-at-all-successful Sylvia Scarlett), but so was Orson Welles—not for Citizen KANE (26D: Memorable title role of a 1941 film), but for The Magnificent Ambersons (though there's a lot of info on KANE in that chapter). I liked that KANE crossed the Hepburn answer, is what I'm saying. Felt like the puzzle was speaking to me (or spying on me). 
  • 8D: ___ LeRoy Locke, "Father of the Harlem Renaissance" (ALAIN) – in yet another bizarre reading coincidence, I held an ALAIN Locke book in my hand just last week. Pulled it off the shelf at Autumn Leaves in Ithaca and perused a few pages, thinking "man, he's a really good writer. I should make time to read him sometime soon." And here we are. OK, universe, you win. I'll put him on the To-Read pile.
  • 41A: Informal hookups (IVS) — "Informal" here just means "abbreviated"
  • 42A: Half a candy bar? (KAT) — love a good KOI KAT candy bar ...
  • 53A: Hit 1976 album whose title track won the Grammy for Record of the Year (HOTEL CALIFORNIA) — I'm an unapologetic Eagles fan—I was raised on Greatest Hits, Vol. 1, so it would be a kind of betrayal of my heritage if I tried to pretend I was too cool for the Eagles—but even I don't really like (the song) "HOTEL CALIFORNIA." 
  • 10D: Required safety feature on cars, in brief (ABS) — Anti-lock Braking System. Did not know these were actually"required" (presumably on new cars only)
  • 27A: It's the word (MUM) — if you don't know the expression "MUM's the word," this clue will be awfully strange.
  • 52D: Person partial to humour? (BRIT) — the spelling on "humour" is the giveaway here. If you're British (or Canadian, or Kiwi, or etc.), it's possible that that might not have registered.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

P.S. Last week during my yearly fundraising drive I decided to add Zelle as a payment method on the last day, which worked fine ... until it didn't. Several contributions were mysteriously rejected. It is not a big deal, but if you contributed that way, it's possible it didn't go through (this applies to only like a dozen of you). The problem was on my end ("MY BAD!"). I apologize. The bank and I have spoken. I should have the kinks ironed out for next year. For now, it's still just PayPal, Venmo, and snail mail. Thanks! 

[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook]

110 comments:

Bob Mills 5:49 AM  

I'm sure almost everyone will make the same mistake I made...starting out with "Able was I ere I saw Elba" instead of AMANAPLANACANAL. Very clever construction tactic to find two classic palindromes with the same number of letters. Otherwise a fairly easy Saturday, albeit I needed to cheat to get Kate WINSLET (I had "Winston") and had "tis" instead of TIL (even though "tis" isn't an adverb).

Conrad 5:54 AM  


Super Easy for a Saturday, mostly because the nine(!) grid-spanners were all straightforward, in-the-language and easily inferable from crosses.

Overwrites:
LEt ME before LEMME at 7D
SALAm before SeLAH before SALAH at 43D (my Arabic is more than a little rusty)
Cur before CAD at 55D

WOEs:
MAHON at 2D
ALAIN LeRoy Locke at 8D
MIA at 19A (I don't remember what I was doing in 2008 but I wasn't listening to hip-hop, apparently)
CATE Tiernan at 33D
TESS Gerritsen at 36D

Lewis 6:14 AM  

I was speechless when the answer to [It’s the word] hit me.

Jacke 6:21 AM  

Wrote in the B off a_s thinking air bags, did not realize till now ABS was something else. Also tried ABLEIWAS... first. It's weird to consistently agree with Rex about difficulty--this was record-settingly easy for me--even though I know half the trivia he does and my times are triple his. I guess he is good at calibrating to a more general audience!

Efficacious Sloth 6:37 AM  

Nope. A man, a plan etc. was the first palindrome that came to mind. I was delighted that it fit. It’s my go-to example of a palindrome.

Anonymous 6:39 AM  

Your mum hit you? Were you being cheeky?

Rug Crazy 6:40 AM  

ALAIN / MIA was my last cross, as I didn't know either

Anonymous 6:46 AM  

Flew through this at record speed until I hit the Throne/Lingo cross. Can anyone explain how CANT equates to Lingo? And maybe somewhere vaguely I remember CAN being slang for a toilet but it’s certainly not a term I’ve heard in decades at least. Or maybe in old movies. Had to run the alphabet to be the completion.

Anonymous 6:59 AM  

Can someone please explain the palindrome? It’s obviously one I’ve never heard of and it really slowed me down

Ellen 7:01 AM  

First Saturday I enjoyed in ages. Gulped when I saw nine spanners. Anticipated that the crosses would be even uglier Found just enough to gain an early foothold.

Son Volt 7:06 AM  

Nice grid - love a good tri-stack puzzle. Agree that the top is a little awkward with the palindrome entry but I’ll look past that.

TIL Tuesday

Some obscure trivia for sure here - thankfully the spanners were all pretty simple making the crosses fair. Liked the GORILLA/WINSLET and TUNED IN/I’M ALIVE down pairs. If I remember right there is a BRIAR pipe reference in Tom Bombadil.

The WREN Song

Enjoyable Saturday morning solve. Lester Ruff’s Stumper provides a trickier grid with crossing center spanners - it will keep you a little longer than this one.

OHIO River Boat Song

katepattersondesign 7:16 AM  

I think Hotel California was 1977. Capt and Tenille won in 1976.

SouthsideJohnny 7:19 AM  

This was by far the easiest time I’ve ever had on a Saturday (and yes, it felt good for a change). The beauty of this one for a non-elite solver is the fact that, as @Conrad mentioned, the grid-spanners were all straightforward and in-the-language. Personally, I didn’t mess around with the palindrome, but the other eight gave me enough to work with.

So this one reduced to just needing to parse together the (mostly) trivia that I don’t recognize like MAHON, SALAH, ACCRA and OSSO (as clued) - in that regard it felt a bit like a Wednesday. I’m not out to deny anyone their Saturday “crunch” opportunities, but it would be nice to see one at this difficulty-level on a weekend every now and then.

Anonymous 7:26 AM  

How could anyone be too cool for the Eagles?

Anonymous 7:32 AM  

Also, the clue called for the start of a palindrome, not a complete one.

JJK 7:37 AM  

The bottom two-thirds of this were relatively easy but because I don’t really know this palindrome, the top third was hard and I had to cheat on the capital of Minorca in order to get any traction. I also didn’t have any idea on ALAIN or MIA, guessed the I and it turned out to be right.

Loved MUM for ‘it’s the word’, what a great clue and answer.

Anonymous 7:40 AM  

I don’t watch the Grammys, but how could a title track win record of the year?

Lewis 7:42 AM  

Even after all my years of solving, there’s still something magical to me when I’m looking at a long answer with a paucity of crosses, and with a huge KAPOW the answer hits me. That flash of seeing -- it’s one of my favorite Crosslandia moments.

Today that happened a good number of times, and when a solve is stuffed with that much giddiness, well, I spontaneously feel buoyant and grateful, and I don’t care what the day is, the puzzle did its job.

CARE TO ELABORATE, OSCAR NOMINATION, SPANISH OMELETTE, ITALIAN AMERICAN, and TESTED THE WATERS are lovely spanners, bringing beauty to the box.

Plus, more loveliness from a couple of clues that misdirected me in [Chest beating sort] and [Cry after a close shave], not to mention a pair of sweet crosses in MUM / MIME, and CAN / CANT.

It’s so very hard to create a triple stack whose crossing answers have hardly a whiff of junk, much less *three* triple stacks, and, IMO, that’s just what Scott did – in his debut puzzle. Wow!

You rule today, Scott. Congratulations and enjoy your Debut Day. Thank you for a splendid outing, and please, don’t be a stranger!

Andy Freude 7:54 AM  

As soon as I saw the grid, I went straight for the downs. Certain that 1D was Lagos, I was off on the wrong foot. (Must have been thinking of Nollywood movies.) Then I thought the range would be gamut, not ARRAY. When I got around to reading the clue for 1A, the L and the G made me think of lasagna. (I often think about lasagna, but that’s another story.) So the palindrome that came to mind, even though it couldn’t fit, was “Go hang a salami, I’m a lasagna hog.”

Even with that stuttering start, I finished this one in near-record time. Those bottom spanners dropped right in with hardly a cross.

Anonymous 7:54 AM  

Do not get "they share keys with 2s" ? ATS

Lewis 7:54 AM  

A bit of context regarding spanner stacks, should you be interested.

Over the years in the Times crossword there have been:
• 13 quadruple double-stacks.
• 23 triple triple-stacks.
• 21 single quad-stacks.
• 13 double quad-stacks.
• 1 quintuple-stack – Joe Krozel, 12/29/12 (in an asymmetric grid).

You’re welcome.

Anonymous 7:58 AM  

@@@

Anonymous 8:04 AM  

For Anonymous: The full palindrome is AMANAPLANACANALPANAMA. The clue made it clear that the answer didn't represent the entire text. Without PANAMA at the end, the number count was identical to ABLEWASIEREISAW (Elba), 15 letters.

Anonymous 8:06 AM  

Literally every time there’s an Oscar or Grammy clue, people think there’s an error and there NEVER is. The Awards ceremony in a given year honors records (Grammys) or movies (Oscars) FROM THE PREVIOUS YEAR. Captain & Tenille won in the calendar year 1976 for a song released IN 1975. So theirs was the *1975* Record of the Year. Today’s clue is correct. Please take this knowledge into all future clues. Please. Thank you. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/18th_Annual_Grammy_Awards

Anonymous 8:07 AM  

Record not album

Anonymous 8:08 AM  

Just start typing into a search engine. Or work it out for yourself. Either option is so easy.

Rick 8:09 AM  

agreed with JJK. The structure of this one is really 3 separate puzzles. The upper one was separated by a rapper name - if you know hip-hop, you were good. (and it was crossed by ALAIN - not a common name). The top part was much harder for me, as I've never memorized palindromes. So 2/3 easy, 1/3 very hard.

DrSparks 8:10 AM  

In the SE, did anyone else initially think swaN (for 48A [as did OFL]), get HOTELCALIFORNIA, ITALIANAMERICAN, and TESTEDTHEWATERS and think, "Holy shit, 48D-(Slightest Amount) is SHIT as in "I don't give a shit"? Just me? Really? OK, never mind.

smalltowndoc 8:21 AM  

A MAN A PLAN A CANAL (Panama) has a whole new connotation these days. Ugh

Anonymous 8:24 AM  

Dish in the clue for “Spanish omelette” with “dishes” in the answer immediate below it!?!?

Anonymous 8:27 AM  

Does Anime and Crime count as a kealoa?

Anonymous 8:37 AM  

The single was released in 1977, but the album was released in late 1976, and the single won in 1978. The clue references album release year. Confusing, but correct.

Todd 8:40 AM  

I absolutely tried able was I first. But I was sure 13 down was narc so switched to the only other palindrome I know. Probably personal best for a saturday.

pabloinnh 8:45 AM  

Yep, easiest Saturday in a long time. Actually started in the middle with OSCARNOMINATIONS but the other spanners weren't much harder, and with those kinds of toeholds the rest goes quickly.

Had to explain to students that a tortilla in Spain is not like a tortilla in Mexico, and what a "tortilla espanola" might be. I've eaten a lot of those and they're delicious.

SALAH I sort of know from knowing the Liverpool star Mohammed SALAH, but I didn't realize how entirely religious his name is.

Fun breezy Saturday, SMM. Some Merry Moments along the way, and thanks for all the fun.

Gary Jugert 8:48 AM  

Un hombre. Un plan. Una antena parabólica.

Grid spanners always make quick work of a puzzle as long as you've heard of the long phrase. Of course I hadn't heard the "famous" canal palindrome so there was some struggle with it. Otherwise pleasant.

As yesterday, we enjoy another roster of mostly D-list names ruining the experience. The commentary here is usually laudatory of the obscure while we pillory the most popular. Snobbery is our hobb(er)y.

I rode in an Uber with a driver from Accra recently and he was delighted I knew the city (only from crosswords). He loves it there and insisted if I ever visited I'd find the people warm and inviting.

Veins don't output ore, miners do. WHIT is having a good week.

It was suspenseful waiting to see if it would be KIT or KAT and I love the funny clue. And the wonderful ATS clue kept me flummoxed a good long while.

My four-word German crossword dictionary continues to come in handy.

Propers: 7
Places: 3
Products: 2
Partials: 4
Foreignisms: 4
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 20 of 72 (28%)

Funnyisms: 2 😕

Tee-Hee: CAN.

Uniclues:

1 A pony playing hide and seek.
2 When your hips do your talking.

1 ROAN MIA ACTS
2 LETS ONE'S JEANS

My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Killer killin' at the cathedral. ORCA ACES AMENS.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Anonymous 8:52 AM  

Took me a bit longer. I thought the African city might be Cairo, “confirmed” by ROAN and oNe (one day, one way, one more). Also guessed “I can handle this” was “got it,” so the top set of spanners took a while.

Casey C. 8:56 AM  

One of the definitions of cant is "language peculiar to a specified group or profession".

Anonymous 8:59 AM  

While I’m familiar with the palindrome featured herein, it is not among the first to come to my mind. Weird Al has a song appropriately entitled “Bob”. The song is in the style of Bob Dylan and every line is a palindrome. 4 versus. There’s no narrative structure but still I think this is his cleverest contrivance. And not featured in his plethora of palindromes…AMANAPLANACANALPANAMA.

RooMonster 9:00 AM  

Hey All !
Not an easy task to get actual words to cross your triple stacks, let alone triple-triple stacks. So bravo on that, Scott. Even has crossing 7's in the center stack (4 of them!) Wow.

Wasn't Rex's "extremely easy", but did find it on the easy side. Which is fantastic for me. Sometimes triple stacks have you flummoxed on crossers, thereby having no hope on getting the long answers. I'm not a fan of ridiculously tough puzs like that. This one gives you a fighting chance, even with some unknown names. This is a prime example of how to fill a triple stacker smoothly.

ABS is strangely not clued as the muscles. Maybe to toughen up the clue? The C of CAN/CANT (cool cross, btw) was my last letter in. A guess, really, but seemed the most logical. The ole brain couldn't get from Throne to CAN, so thanks to Rex for pointing out the toilet meanings. Thought about a B for BANT, but BAN wasn't cutting it.

Neat to see a triple triple. Can't remember the last time we had one. I'm sure it wasn't as good as this one.

Hope y'all have a good Saturday! Go (insert your favorite sports team here)! Any Super Bowl matchup guesses?

One F
RooMonster
DarrinV

DrBB 9:11 AM  

I mean if it was a Quigley puzzle, yeah...

RooMonster 9:16 AM  
This comment has been removed by the author.
DrBB 9:26 AM  

I *tried* to make it a little harder by not going with my initial guesses, but the puzzle just didn't want to cooperate. South was a little hard to get into with only KNELT to get in there, and SWAN just not sounding ANYway Irish enough, so I hung on trying not to just fill in OSCARNOMINATIONS without more confirmation. Caught the Brit-spelling hint of "humour" but figured there had to be some kind of comical aspect to the answer. Couldn't just be BRIT, could it? Yup, it could. Oh heck, have your OSCARNOMINATIONS then and what else am I going to do with my Saturday morning now.

Anonymous 9:29 AM  

...Panama

SethC 9:35 AM  

ABLEWASIEREISAW is 15. I had that in first before fixing.

DrBB 9:36 AM  

"CANT" (no apostrophe) n. refers to high-sounding but empty verbiage, usually with specious moral overtones. Formulaic, with no real thought behind it.

Anonymous 9:36 AM  

Nope. Filled in 1A with no crosses. As mentioned, the clue asked for the start of a palindrome, so I certainly hope “almost everyone” didn’t read the clue incorrectly!

Anonymous 9:37 AM  

Why wait for a response to a comment when Google’s right there?

Anonymous 9:38 AM  

Someone’s never seen The Big Lebowski.

Anonymous 9:39 AM  

Yes, I had ABLEWASIEREISAW at first. It didn't take long for me to figure out that was wrong, though. With so many grid-spanning entries going Across, it meant the Downs were pretty short, and I was able to figure out enough of them that I could get the 15-letter answers pretty easily.

Anonymous 9:39 AM  

Seven minutes flat. Never thought that would happen on a Saturday.

EasyEd 9:45 AM  

Had only a few words until I got to the last line and filled in TESTEDTHEWATERS from two letters. Worked my way back up from there but found the going slow due to much PPP that I did not know. Not remembering the Panama palindrome was a bummer. In a way weird that for me the spanners were needed to get the short fill and not vice-versa. MUM’s the word is a beauty.

Greater Fall River Committee for Peace & Justice 9:46 AM  

AMANAPLANACANAL panama read it backwards

Anonymous 9:46 AM  

I think the required safety system refers to air bags.

I hate the fing eagles man.

andrew 9:47 AM  

Whenever someone alludes to a sign from the universe, think of Tobias Funke grasping for anything that justifies his bad decision to give up being doctor at Mass General to become an actor.

Leading him to be scammed by Carl Weathers (among others).

Universe, you’ve done it again!

Anonymous 9:48 AM  

Obviously, Will Shortz doesn't have a problem with it, but I thought it was kind of bold to put your own name in such a prominent place in your debut grid, especially since it was clued in a way that probably close to zero solvers could figure it out, making it really stick out as a strain to include. If it had been clued as "Ed Mc____," it would have blended in. As it stands, it felt kind of tacky to me, like it was more important to give the constructor his ego trip than to give the solvers a fair entry. (I realize that the constructor could well have submitted Ed McMahon's name and Will Shortz changed it.)

Anonymous 9:54 AM  

Hotel California won the Grammy in 1978, released in 1977.

Anonymous 10:00 AM  

plays harder if 1A is a natick to you

Nancy 10:00 AM  

As soon as NEIN went in, all thoughts of writing in ABLE WAS I ERE I SAW went right out the window. But there was no write-over mess -- I know enough, and especially on a Saturday, never to write in any answer, especially a long one, without first checking one or more letters.

As I worked my way eastward, CANAL appeared and I had my palindrome.

I love stacks -- so I wanted to love these pretty easy ones unreservedly. But my arm was definitely cocked in the "throw-against-wall" position as I encountered the ALAIN/MIA/KANE/CATE/WINSLOW section. Do stacks necessitate the use of names as compromise fill because they're so hard to pull off? Or was this a deliberate choice by a constructor who likes giving us names? For me, as always, it lessened the pleasure of the puzzle. But at least I didn't have to cheat.

I liked ITALIAN AMERICAN where you're expecting either --------YANKEE or YANKEE ------------. I liked using Jimmy Carter to clue JEANS and I wonder if that clue was altered upon the occasion of his death. A nice, if easy Saturday with the exception of all those names clumped together.

Anonymous 10:20 AM  

Yesterday's puzzle was probably the closest I've ever come to a Friday DNF (many unknown answers, and me just not vibing with the cluing at all) and today's was a Saturday that I managed to do in hard Monday/easy Tuesday time. Odd themeless weekend.

Crossword reflex made me think of TERN, not SWAN, from the N.

RooMonster 10:31 AM  

Was going to say ..
I agree with @Anonymous 8:06. A prime example, @katepattersondesign (and others who complain of the same thing), is that in this year, 2025, the Oscars/Grammys are to be awarded for 2024. So the winners of the 2024 Awards will be handed out in 2025, but will be winners for 2024. Got it?

RooMonster Hate To Mansplain, But ... Guy

Anonymous 10:34 AM  

"Able was I ere I saw" is what would fit in 15 letters, so the clue does work for both palindromes.

egsforbreakfast 10:35 AM  


What did the Dark Lord of the Sith's doctor say as he began transfusing him? "May the IVS be with you".

A range of dorm resident assistants is an RA ARRAY.

I personally thought that 10D (Required safety feature on cars) was ABS answer. I guess muscle cars might have ABS.

While it's true that some do overs are LETS, a really great player WINSLET more often than not.

You know that crossword staple answer "ISH" that we see now and then? Why, our own Malaika used it not too long ago in a puzzle, with the clue being "or thereabouts". Welp, did you ever wonder how those ISHes get from Will Shortz' desk to the printing plant? They do it by means of geosynchronous communications devices orbiting far above us! Yes, when they finally make it into print, they're SATELLITEDISHES.

I think a reference to Pink Pony Club instead of "Coloring sometimes confused with dun" might have brought a bit more excitement to ROAN and to the whole puzzle. An impressive construction that took about my usual Tuesday time and left me wishing for more. But thanks and congrats on the debut, Scott McMahon.

Mothra 10:38 AM  

Yes, same!

jae 10:47 AM  

Yep, very easy, Wednesday’s was tougher. I was pretty sure I knew 1a and a couple of crosses confirmed that it did. After that it was off to the races.

No erasures.

I did not know MAHON, CATE, TESS and. SALAH.

It’s been a while since I’ve seen three triple stacks and this one was well done. Solid, smooth, not much junk and some fun answers but it was way too easy. Liked it.

Anonymous 10:50 AM  

Extremely easy? The entire NW corner is a total Natick for me. How can I infer a color I've never heard of (ROAN?!) crossing two cities I've never heard of crossing an allegedly famous palindrome I've never heard of? I've never even heard of Minorca and I am supposed to somehow know the capital? Literally impossible to just "solve" this trivial nonsense.

Sam 10:50 AM  

Not

Sam 10:52 AM  

Accidentally hit “Publish” before

Not my fastest ever Saturday solve, but close to. Want more bite. This was a let-down.

Anonymous 11:07 AM  

Thanks for explaining. I couldn’t quite parse the clue.

Beezer 11:24 AM  

My daughter spent a semester in Spain in college (Spanish major). My SIL, sister and I met her there during a break and spent 10 days going from Madrid, Toledo, Cordoba, Sevilla, Granada. My daughter was shocked when she realized her aunt had always thought that Spanish food was essentially the same as Mexican cuisine. I just thought it was hilarious and, well, not surprising.

puzzlehoarder 11:56 AM  

I've never solved a grid spanning stack puzzle that had much in the way of resistance but this one sets a new low. Yesterday's solve was so boring I couldn't bring myself to comment or even visit this blog. Today's solve was only 2 minutes longer. Puzzle wise it's been a blah weekend.

Anonymous 12:04 PM  

Please explain, anybody, how Amanaplanacanal is a Palindrome. It does not read the same from the front and back.
I am German, maybe I just don’t ‘get ‘it. Thanks!

Anonymous 12:05 PM  

Couldn’t agree more! Fantastic job, Scott!!!

Chip Hilton 12:16 PM  

I love 15 stacks, so seeing this grid had me juiced. About 20 minutes later, I was wondering what else I could do during the NFL playoff games. Stunningly easy puzzle, but congrats on the construction. Longest time needed on a 15: Yogi & Joe, because I figured YANKEE had to be in there somewhere.

Carola 12:34 PM  

Easy and fun to solve...I mean, A MAN A PLAN.....that put me in the right SPIRIT to. enjoy the rest. I liked KOI next to MUM and the constructor's inclusion of 5/7 of his last name - there can't be too many ways to clue MAHON. I thought the grid-spanners were all really good - none with the dreaded "one's" (like the old and creaky "A lot on one's plate" that we used to see).

jb129 12:43 PM  

What can I say about a Saturday debut puzzle when the first answer is AMANAPLANACANAL (an anagram I never heard of BTW ?).
Easier than most Saturdays but maybe I'm being a prude - I thought CAN was in poor taste.

M and A 12:57 PM  

Extremely easy at times, but not in that ALAIN/MIA/GWEN passageway from stack #1 to stack #2. Thankfully, OSCARNOMINATION was pretty much a stack #2 gimm&e, at our house.

staff weeject pick: POT. A nursery the sells pot? I want to go to there.

Each of the three stacks was kinda like a Wiener Dog Runt Puzzle. But alas, the crossers weren't near desperate enough, to qualify.

Luved the NEIN clue. The clue for LEMME didn't seem loose-goosy enough, to m&e.
CAN/CANT was maybe about as desperate a cross as I could find. Nice fillins job, overall.

Thanx, Mr. McMahon dude. Nice debut, with a SatPuz no less, includin with yer bonus Mc-less MAHON signature entry. And a happy OSSO SALAH ORA, to all.

Masked & Anonymo1U [s]

... care to [be less] elaborate? ...

"Runt Interference" - 7x7 themed runt puzzle:

**gruntz**

M&A

Rusty Trawler 12:58 PM  

Back-to-back Xanadu clips! Here's hoping tomorrow's puzzle includes a Gene Kelly reference...

Anonymous 1:11 PM  

Stay out of Malibu, deadbeat!

Anonymous 1:26 PM  

It’s not and the clue doesn’t say it is

Ellen 1:48 PM  

I guess it sucks to be you this weekend. Not sure which is more glaring: bragging about your time & xword prowess when it comes to stacked spanners or criticizing a debut puzzle. "Mum's the word" was applauded for a reason.

Anonymous 2:12 PM  

For Anonymous...AMANAPLANACANALPANAMA is the palindrome. The clue did indicate that the answer was an incomplete palindrome.

Anonymous 2:12 PM  

The clue tells you it wants the start …
The full palindrome is “A man, a plan, a canal, Panama” and refers to Teddy Roosevelt who envisioned and built the canal. It could be argued that TR was a lunatic - but a very different kind of lunatic to another *politician* who appears to have *a plan* for Panama…

okanaganer 2:16 PM  

Who was the constructor who specialized in stacks like these? It was a few years ago. Nice to do one again after all this time.

I got a bad start with the first two downs being Unknown Names... Arrrgh!... but fortunately it got better. Not record fast but pretty quick for a Saturday. Only typeovers I can remember were LETME before LEMME, ONE before ANY "day, way, or more", and SPEAR for the "Long weapon".

Anonymous 2:22 PM  

MIA is MAGA? That’s really disappointing.

OISK 2:28 PM  

It reads "Palindrome STARTER". It leaves out the last word, which is "Panama," which makes it a palindrome.

Anonymous 2:30 PM  

I like your puzzle analysis, but you are a pathological braggart.

OISK 2:34 PM  

Was delighted to smash through both yesterday's and today's, only to discover that they were easy, and VERY easy. Yes, this was my fastest Saturday in a very long time, and I enjoyed it. But isn't the Missouri considerably larger than the Ohio?

Anonymous 2:37 PM  

I always thought it was “a man a plan Panama”

Sandy McCroskey 3:06 PM  

As the clue says, it's only the start of one. The last part is PANAMA! Rather topical!

ChrisS 3:07 PM  

I also don't know much about hip-hop but MIA is not really a hip-hop artist. From Wikipedia "Her music combines elements of alternative, dance, electronic, hip hop and world music with electronic instruments and samples". And before today when I found out about her crazy politics I was a bit of a fan.

Gary Jugert 4:25 PM  

@egsforbreakfast 10:35 AM
To satellite
-I satellite
-You satellite
-We just watch the game
-I satellited, am satelliting, will have been satellited.
-adv, satellitely: We watched the game satellitely.
-rel, satellitish: The fuzzy reception seemed satellitish.
pl: satellitipode.

Adam S 4:29 PM  

Absolutely!

On the same clue with only the leading A in place, I asked myself whether Netflix now had an Adult section. Thankfully, it seemed unlikely enough that I decided to wait for crosses.

Gary Jugert 4:31 PM  

@jb129 12:43 PM
I'm guessing with Joel back on the slush pile, we CAN expect more CAN-adjacent "humor." I'll grab the pearls.

Anonymous 4:44 PM  

Anonymous 10:50 AM
The palindrome IS famous
I have known it since I was a kid.
Just because you don’t know it doesn’t mean it isn’t well known. That’s crosswords.
Note that most here knew it.
Ditto ROAN.
MAHON is the only obscure one.
ACCRA is crosswordese. It has been in this puzzle innumerable times.

ghostoflectricity 4:53 PM  

Easiest Saturday in recent memory, for sure.

Hugh 4:59 PM  

I for one welcome an easy(ish) Saturday. Yet another time when I looked at the blank puzzle and thought, "cool grid!"
The center and south went very quickly for me and I loved each long stack. First to fall was ITALIANAMERICAN and all the rest in those regions fell without much drama. Unlike others, 1A was the last to click, not sure why. I know the palindrome but I didn't have enough downs to help me out. I was absolutely nowhere with the geography entries which really had me stalled and I had some fairly silly goofs. I thought that FLIP was a good enough answer for "How to turn down a Hamburger" until I finally noticed the "H" was capitalized, then I very much appreciated the mis-direct. Was not familiar with ALAIN but now I'm very happy to have learned about him and will likely do some reading (how great are crosswords?!)
I think my favorite long one was CARETOELABORATE, I just like the way it sounds and it looks quite elegant in the grid. But I thought they were all great, and when you have three stacks of three - that's quite the feat.
Not a ton of other clever/cute mis-directs but I got a kick out of the cluing for BRIT and especially ATS (They share keys with 2's) which I got from the crosses but didn't understand until I came here! So those two and FLIP gave me my fill for the day - more than satisfied!
Thanks Mr. McMahon for the fun Saturday romp.

Beezer 5:53 PM  

So…I was supposed to travel today and spent most of the morning figuring out if I could return home Sunday (on wheels) safely. Alas no…I missed a 70th bday surprise…only 2 hours away. So. Given my mood…this puzzle brightened my day. Was it easy…yes…”for a Saturday.” Did I mind? Hell no. Unlike a few people here, about the only palindrome stuck in my mind is the “Able I am ere I saw Elba” biz, but I the Teddy Panama biz came to me with crosses. For whatever reason, the proper names today didn’t give me heartburn so I was a happy camper! Great debut, IMO.

Anonymous 6:02 PM  

@pablo and that is in fact why, early on i just wrote SPANISH and waited for crosses to see if it would be tortilla or omelette at the end! delicious, any way you slice it :)

-stephanie.

sundromos 6:16 PM  


When potential hit songs were released on 45's (rpm), as the A-side song.

Teedmn 7:35 PM  

This was a very fast solve. I was totally shocked that I was finished so soon because there were so many unknowns in the top triple (Accra as clued, Mahon, Alain) that it felt like I was crawling along.

Like Rex, I wasn’t listening to hip-hop in the aughts (or any other time) but when I checked out the Paper Planes song on the web, turns out I've heard it many, many times on the college rock station I listen to. Never knew the title.

But although the solve was smooth, it was not flawless. I had LEtME for 7D. When it came time to write in CHRISTMAS SPIRIT, I entered CHRISTtMSSPIRIT leaving me with ALmIN, not ALAIN. And I never fixed it, sigh.

I liked MUM's the word clue. And I determined whether 48A was swan or WREN using the same method as Rex, with ROTE nailing it.

HOTEL CALIFORNIA has been played so many times, I can’t say I like it any more. I'd prefer to hear Tequila Sunrise, which has such wonderful chord changes and harmonies.

Thanks, Scott McMahon, nice Saturday puzzle.

CDilly52 8:19 PM  

My granddaughter’s dance concerts are this weekend and I am helping corral kiddos backstage and am mostly just being so, so proud of Grace. She is 12 now and truly accepts that she’ has a forever family who loves her and whom she loves and trusts. She absolutely sparkled on stage. Joyful, confident and capable, and a soloist in her jazz number. We would not have believed that this undernourished, frightened and completely distrustful and nearly silent little girl that my kids fostered and finally adopted after almost five years of trying to get all the legalities figured out would blossom into the beautiful young person she has become. We hoped, and my kids worked so hard and were so patient with “the system” and with Grace and now she is eager to live life and explore. She believes she has possibilities. And is already talking about attending UCLA as
she said just the other day” because I don’t want to go far from home and and I am NEVER leaving California!” The distance from the Bay Area to LA is apparently far enough. And of course we shall see.

I worked for over 30 years spending all my pro bono time with tough young clients trying to force the system to work harder to give the kids who, through no fault of their own had no real family, little hope of happiness and very little help to treat their trauma from abuse and neglect.

All this to get up on my soapbox and say that never in the history of the world has a child ever asked to be born. Yet, in every state in America the justice system provides so few resources, human, financial, therapeutic and otherwise to give abused and neglected children what they need not merely to survive but to thrive. On the rare occasions when one of these young Americans receives the opportunity to receive what our Grace now has, it truly is cause for celebration and more than that, for continued support. If any of you, your friends or family need a good cause, look no further than your local youth services opportunities. Helping a child will never disappoint you.

And I found this puzzle difficult to get any flow going until OSCAR NOMINATION and SPANISH OMELETTE gave me some traction. Had trouble with some names and the palindrome took me a bit simply because it was “part” of the whole and the “whole” has so many ridiculous variations that I felt it was used just to make the top challenging rather than to add a really good clue and answer. And that's all I have today, time to get ready for the second show!

MetroGnome 8:21 PM  

I'm sure it's too late to get an answer for this (just got home, so I just did the puzzle) -- but how can ARIAL be a COP??!!

JC66 9:30 PM  

@Metro

NARC is the COP.

jae 10:24 PM  

13d is NARC which is referenced by 11d. 12d is ARIAL.

Anonymous 12:12 AM  

Absurdly easy for a Saturday

Anonymous 12:36 AM  

A good reason you “should” know Mahon is that you should be reading Patrick O’Brian’s beautifully written Aubrey Maturin series, wherein the two protagonists meet! You can thank me later.

Anonymous 8:57 AM  

Well I guess you told me! Crosswordese should be banned, and the constructors who lean it as crutches are not very talented. Some of us have other hobbies and can't memorize every obscure nonsensical word that ONLY ever appear in crosswords. ROAN is absolutely obscure. ACCRA? Obscure. The palindrome is obscure if you've never heard it or don't bother to memorize palindromes. Just because everybody on the crossword blog is familiar with crosswordese doesn't mean all solvers are going to be. This is what makes these puzzles inaccessible and frustrating to casual solvers. It shouldn't have to be an exclusive club of people who can solve them just because there is a secret language that only you know.

Stan Wagon 9:13 PM  

Yup, that struck me as plain wrong and I checked and the Missouri is indeed the largest tributary of the Mississippi. The Missouri is also longer than the Mississippi, but it has less flow.

kitshef 8:53 PM  


99% sure the Missouri is the longest tributary of the Mississippi.

Coincidentally, I'm currently working on a puzzle where one of the entries is CARE TO ELABORATE. Fortunately it is otherwise utterly different from this puzzle.

Really, really expected to find PANAMA somewhere herein. Accepting a partial palindrome as a key entry seems like a very poor editorial decision.

kitshef 8:59 PM  

Ah, but when ABLEWASIEREISAW is confirmed by both ACCRA and ATIT, it goes in with great confidence.

  © Free Blogger Templates Columnus by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP