THEME: RIPPED ABS (61A: Many a gymgoer's goal ... or what the starred clues in this puzzle must have for their answers to make sense?) — you have to "rip" the "abs" (i.e. the letters "ab") from the starred clues to make sense of them:
Theme answers:
EXPONENTS (17A: *They're found next to cabarets [carets])
Both before and after his canonization, Serra's reputation and missionary work during the Spanish occupation have been condemned by critics, who cite alleged mandatory conversions to Catholicism, followed by abuse of the Native American converts. (wikipedia)
• • •
I made this harder than it had to be by resolutely refusing to go down to the bottom of the grid and figure out the revealer early. I thought about it, after the first two themers didn't quite seem to match their clues, but the puzzle was so easy to fill in that I thought, nah, just let the revealer be the revealer—wait for it. And I did. And it was RIPPED ABS. Which did, in fact ... well, it "explained" more than "revealed." Is there a difference? I would say the effect of a true "revealer" is "wow" or "ooh" or some kind of at least low-key amazement or impressed reaction, whereas an "explainer" just has you going "oh, OK, I see now." As in "Oh, OK, I see now, I just take the "ab" parts out of the starred clues ... yes, that does help." The idiomatic use of RIPPED didn't quite work for me. Rip out? Rip off? "Rip" can mean copy (as when you "rip" a CD to your computer). But "Rip" meaning simply "steal" or "take" just feels slightly off to my ears. Maybe it's a recent IDIOM that just missed me. It feels right, I get it, but on some fundamental level it feels off. Otherwise, the concept here is pretty straightforward. The "ab"-less clues are sometimes a little awkward (e.g. "by talk" for ORALLY) but it's no surprise if they're a little contrived—it takes some contrivance to make all your fake clues contain an unnecessary "ab" but still look like plausible clues. The one weird thing about solving, pre-revealer, is that the original clues occasionally seemed to *almost* fit a couple of times. Like, I got PONZI SCHEMES and thought, "hmmm, those are 'investment plans,' I guess ... but 'Viable'? ... is the theme 'Sarcasm'?"). BELOW THE BELT also felt *close* to its original clue (49A: Like some nasty habits). The nastiness is there, at any rate. So the theme "works" just fine, but it didn't wow me, mainly because the revealer didn't quite stick the landing (didn't help that my first thought for the type of "ABS" a gymgoer might want was WASHBOARD ABS ("washboard" being way more ab-specific than mere "ripped," which can apply to a gymgoer's entire body).
I didn't groove too much on the fill today. It's a pretty dense theme today, so there's not a lot of room to do other interesting or fancy things. The longer answers are OK but not sparkling. The weirdest of them is probably VIA MEDIA, which I know only as a religious concept (I think)—the middle way, the middle path. But that's Buddhist, so ... not sure it would be expressed in Latin, ever. Oh, look, it's a more broadly religious concept—(but it still doesn't mean "middle ground," as we would use the term "middle ground." "VIA" is a road or path. So VIA MEDIA is more a "way" than a "place." It's a way of living that is between extremes, a way of moderation. Somehow "Middle ground" doesn't quite get at that. I'm just really mad at "ground" today. I'm not mad at much else, because nothing is really trying hard to make me mad. I didn't like the fact that NDAS and PDA were in the same grid. All those letters mean completely different things, so there's no real violation here, I just don't like it. If RDA and ADA were in the puzzle, maybe you'd begin to feel why. It's one thing to have a lot of abbrevs, and another (worse) thing to have them be so close to each other. I also didn't like the duped "E-" prefix (EMAILS, EFILE). It's a tiny thing ... but it's a thing. Any other grievances? Well, I'm not too big a fan of the "stylized" soda name (48D: Stylized name for a caffeinated soft drink). I know those are the letters on the can / bottle / box, but MTNDEW looks like you slammed your face on the keyboard—there's nothing lovely about it. Also, it has me imagining what "Mutton Dew" would taste like (It ain't good). I had the initial "M" here and wrote in MR. PIBB (which was sometimes "styled" as "Mr. PiBB" but which is now "Pibb Xtra" ... you know, for the kids! Kids can't relate to "Mr.," man ... they like names with "X" in them! 'Cause it's Xtreme!).
Outside the theme, the puzzle was Very easy. I made things harder on myself by misreading "cabarets" (in 17A: *They're found next to cabarets [carets]) as "cabernets," but I doubt it mattered much—"cabarets" wouldn't have gotten me any closer to EXPONENTS, at that point. Let's see, what else?
What else?:
7D: Spare, perhaps (LET LIVE) — I had LET FREE. I also had CITE before CLIP (36D: Excerpt). These are not very exciting mistakes, you're right. Let's move on.
43D: Where you might find yourself on edge? (ICE RINK?) — I don't get it. Is the idea that you are on the "edge" ... of the blade ... of your skate? Or are you hugging the edge of the rink because you know if you go more than a few steps out on the ice you're just gonna fall down?
39D: Fraud (IMPOSTER) — oh the ways I wanted to spell this. First, I imagined it was IMPOSTEUR (!?). That didn't fit (thank god), so I assumed it was IMPOSTOR. Something about IMPOSTER just seems wrong. Possible because POSTER has a completely different pronunciation as a standalone word. If it's spelled "POSTER," then I want to pronounce it "POSTER," but that's not how it's pronounced in IMPOSTER. Why does the "POST" in "IMPOSTER" rhyme with the "PAST" in "PASTA"? It's so weird. I object.
64A: [$@#%!] ("BLEEP!") — I thought I was supposed to write a swear word (or a word meaning "swear word"), not the sound covering the swear word. Grawlixes (those swear-word symbols in comics) aren't the same as BLEEPs. BLEEPs are used by censors; grawlixes are written/drawn by the artists themselves. BLEEPS are an audio effect; grawlixes are graphic. I guess they both hide or stand in for profanity, so OK. But also boo.
Need to go start my day. Gonna go make the coffee ... or chug some Mutton Dew, whichever. See you tomorrow.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
P.S. RIDGY? RIDGY? (42A: Like corduroy fabric). Apparently this is a perfectly valid word, appearing in dictionaries near you. Feels ridiculous, and I'd call corduroy fabric RIDGED, or even RIBBED, before I'd call it RIDGY (which, to be clear, I would never call it). But yes, it's an actual word.
Whoops! Forgot to post this yesterday. The month of gunk report for July.
The gunkiest puzzle in three months on July 2, with the diagonal circles pointing to YES, came in at a shocking 47% gunk rating and yet was lauded by Rex and called a "clean" grid. Meanwhile, you'll remember the weird "not my cup of tea" puzzle was ultra clean at 16% gunk and it received tepid reviews. So I guess it's gunk, unless you like the gunk.
The cost of gunk rose for the third month in a row and we're now paying and average of 4.75¢ per puzzle for gunk out of our 15¢ buy in, and you can thank Friday, Saturday and Sunday for this. In order to toughen puzzles up, they've amped up what most people would call "trivia" to prevent us from flying through the weekend. They could write better clues on better words, but let's not be confused how our hobby works.
My other favorite moment in gunk from July was on Sunday the 7th when we had the THUMB-INDEX-MIDDLE-RING-PINKY double digit thingy and that puzzle ... a Sunday! ... rolled in at 40% gunk with a whopping raw score of 56 words out of 140.
I kept track of how much food shows up in the puzzles, but this was unremarkable this month so I guess I'll just rage and storm privately. Bring back the extinct birds. I finally had them memorized.
Here's the score card (arrows compare results from previous month which had one less day):
People and Proper Nouns: 246 ↑ Places: 86 ↓ Products: 154 ↑ Partial Words and Initialisms: 233 ↑ Foreignisms: 96 ↓
Average Monthly Gunkiness: 32% (up for the last two months):
If I had one wish, it would be that the clue writers develop a sense of humor. I won't tell you how few funnyisms happened last month (whispers 107 as an aside), but out of 2560 chances, we'll say there's plenty of room for improvement. C'mon Joel, you found all those ARSES back in your slush pile days, you can amp up the comedy with the best of 'em.
The whole “reveal/explain” paragraph seems like a distinction without a difference. Very, very picky - as was the rest of the write-up. I found the puzzle challenging & clever.
My RIPPED ABS are also RIDGY like corduroy. I wish.
Nice concept, definitely a solid Aha when I finished the puzzle, looked again at the revealer, and went back to read the starred clues. The themers were a bit of a mixed bag - BELOW THE BELT worked perfectly, PONZI SCHEME was kind of clever, EMAILS was meh, ORALLY was awkward, and EXPONENTS was meaningless to me because … math (I think?)
PacE CARS before POLE CARS. I did not know Columbus thought he had found EDEN when he got to the New World. I thought he thought he was in Asia.
Unlike yesterday, which also had a theme that needed some “revealing” where the revealer gave you a kind of a cute aha moment, this one jumped completely into the NYT stunt/gimmick pool with a theme/reveal so convoluted that as usual, I needed Rex to explain it to me post-solve. So the whole experience was parsing cross after cross to get to stuff like EXPONENTS which had nothing to do with the clue.
Add in the usual stuff that may be real but gets used about once a decade in real life such as VIAMEDIA and you’re in pretty familiar NYT territory - a grid that is pretty much unsolvable unless you are a hard-core META fan, or perhaps a masochist who enjoys slogging through endless crosses in the hopes that you come up with something that looks like a viable word or phrase.
At least you pretty much know what you are in for on a Thursday with the Times, and in that regard they seemed to achieve their objective - I’m guessing the puzzle will be pretty well-received by the Thursday fans in the group, but for me at least, the whole gimmick soared about 50,000 feet over my head.
As one who played hockey till age 62, on edge means on skate blade, though it also could reflect the feeling I had when a younger bigger opponent with or without RIPPED ABS was barreling in on me. Though they were officially “no check”* leagues, I was carted off the ice in an ambulance with a broken collarbone and bruised ribs in one of my last seasons when a massive OGRE took an illegally aggressive approach. Sucks to get old and slow and become an easy target!
* cash and credit only (nyuk nyuk!)
Puzzle was fine, I guess, but didn’t notice the abs were in the clues even after the revealer. And BYTALK is beyond a groaner for ORALLY.
Best puzzle of the week so far. Figured the theme out at EMAILS – by far the most transparent themer - even though I already had PONZI SCHEMES and EXPONENTS filled in; I just didn't know why.
Looking forward to the uniclue for VIA MEDIA MTN DEW.
Columbus didn’t actually think he had found Eden, but he thought that the Orinoco river, which he found the mouth of, must originate in Eden.
Here’s a constructor who, in her debut, shows great promise. Somewhere along the line, Rajeswari came across the phrase RIPPED ABS and didn’t just move on; her brain tapped her on the shoulder and said, “Look closer!” That’s crossword constructor brain. She’s got it.
And she delivered. A bit into the puzzle, when I had uncovered one of the theme answers and knew it was correct, even though it didn’t fit its clue – well, that is one of Crosslandia’s great moments: where you know there’s a riddle to crack and an aha coming when you do. It brings a bounce to your brain’s step. I actually thought, “Oh I love this puzzle” at that moment.
Rajeswari sweetened the outing with beauty as well: MIDGE, PONZI SCHEMES, PLUMB, POLE CAR, BELOW THE BELT, RIPPED ABS, BLEEP, IMPOSTER. Plus, she included lovely vague clues and misdirects.
So yes, great promise evident here, IMO.
Two observations. First, I’m amazed that BELOW THE BELT had never appeared in a Times puzzle before today. Second, regarding RIDGY, which has drawn some raised eyebrows, well, I love this answer. It looks terrific, is fun to say, and has far more bounce than “ridged”. I’ve never thought of it before, never used it, and maybe never will, but I love it – thumbs up!
Rajeswari, congratulations on becoming a Times constructor, and please, forge on! Thank you for your splendid puzzle!
Rode the struggle bus throughout, and it drives me crazy when I find the revealer and I still don't get it ... until I get it later after an embarrassing amount of time. When I finally saw the ABS in the clues, not the answers, I let out a literal "OHO!" That's when BELOW THE BELT arrived majestically and I could finish the puzzle. Great theme idea.
The top of the puzzle came far more easily than the lower half and ELLA stopped me cold.
MIDGE reminded me of 10 glorious days in Scotland a few years ago. RIDGY is the last way I'd describe corduroy. ENNUI is my #1 favorite word. Read up on Junípero SERRA's crazy life.
Why is MTNDEW "stylized?" That's how they spell it.
Tee-Hee: HENRY Miller. I read both of his tropical tomes and I'd say he's way over appreciated. Maybe literary intellectuals need to DAB less POT when picking great writers. ZIT and WART in the same puzzle. Ah, childhood memories.
Uniclues:
1 Celebrate local ankle biter. 2 Unfortunate report from a family member when the green men didn't come in peace. 3 Made a phone call. (Remember those?) 4 Ranks rockin' bods. 5 Me, when I am trying to act mature. 6 One pathologically obsessed with getting high and scaring children.
I am shocked--shocked, I tell you!--to see SPA in a puzzle. Why, it feels like it's only been 5 whole minutes since we've seen that word! Seriously, it's a crutch akin to EKE and EPEE at this point. I get that there are common words, but it feels like we see it every other day at this point. Anyway, mostly fun little trick; not exactly Thursday-worthy, but had a nice early a-ha! moment. Looking forward to a little more challenge in the next couple of days.
Lots of "what OFL said" for me, especially waiting for the revealer (no idea), spelling IMPOSTER wrong (with another O), and thinking RIDGY was pure invention. Also "by talk" is just dreadful. What, I'm entering my comment by type? Come on man.
ELBOW took way too long as I kept thinking of "radius" in terms of geometry, which I'm sure was the constructors' intention. Score one for the constructor.
Not too many names today. I think we just had ELLA the Elephant somewhere, unless it was in a New Yorker or a Croce or a Stumper. Can be confusing. I knew Fr. SERRA immediately from my Spanish teaching days but I wonder if he's familiar to very many of us.
All in all a good theme which mostly landed and a nice aha! revealer, which is all I ask for on a Thursday, Nice job, RR. Your Risk Reward factor worked out nicely, and thanks for all the fun.
@andrew: It sucks to get old and slow and become an easy target even when you don't play hockey. Or any sport at all.
Puzzle was Easy-Medium, although I solved it as a themeless ignoring or not reading the themer clues, which were pretty much useless anyway. Didn't get the theme until I got here.
No overwrites, although I had to toss a coin at 8D to decide if my first try would be EdgES IN or EASES. Luckily it came up tails. And I did entertain ScAT before SKAT at 68A.
Didn't know ELLA the Elephant (35D) or Junipero SERRA (67A), and maybe RIDGY (42A) might count as an honorary WOE, as in "Please don't be RIDGY, please don't be RIDGY, please ..."
IMPOSTOR, not impostER. I objected at having to spell the word this way to complete the puzzle. I looked it up and found that it seems to be accepted as a variant..But I’m with Rex — it’s still a BOO from me.
Finally realized that the RIPPEDABS were supposed to be ripped from the clue. I had assumed that "AB" was to be subtracted from the answer. Once I got that right, the puzzle was fairly routine.
I agree with MazzPuzz and Rex Parker that IMPOSTER is a horrible misspelling. I also question EDEN as the place Columbus thought he had landed. Columbus thought he had reached India, which is why he (falsely) named the Caribbean islands he had reached as Indies (later called West Indies). It slowed me down, because I thought EDEN was India and that it was a rebus puzzle.
Never heard of the term “pole car“. Also, “racetrack leader“ would assume that the race has already started. The car in pole position is only in front before the start of the race. Ridgy? Ugh! Myope? Hmm. I remember the Yankees versus Indians playoff game in 2007 when Joba Chamberlain was attacked by MIDGES coming off of Lake Erie!
I found the puzzle difficult, not because of the theme which was excellent in my opinion, but just generally outside my wheelhouse. The one little quibble I have is with the “flower shop” clues. I find “bulbs” and “pots” in nearby plant nurseries or online. Flower shops are for house plants, bouquets, posies, cut flowers, centerpieces; basically more finished or arranged plant products. Otherwise I found the puzzle to be a good example of a Thursday crossword. Thanks to the creator for the fun!
Hey All ! Argh! NE corner! What kind of way to clue AVIAN is that? I wanted Aloft, inair, awaft (!), something. And MIDGE? Holy Moly, crossed by VIAMEDIA and NESTS as clued. Total brain meltdown up there. Had rest of puz done in about 14 minutes, finally ran to Goog for VIAMEDIA at the 22 minute mark. Dang. Do you AGREE about that corner?
Figured out the concept after getting PONZI SCHEMES. Was trying to insert ABS somewhere in EXPONENTS after getting that, but nothing was working. Saw the "ab" string in both clues, RIPPED them out, and got the Aha moment.
Good puz, beside the [$@#%!] NE corner. Can never remember if it's IE or EI in NIECE. Good RexRant on RIDGY. Gor a chuckle.
[Michael Caine voice] MYOPE is next Fursday is bettuh.
Didn't quite work for me. Yeah, I guess EXPONENTS are next to carets when no superscript is used, but that seems a stretch. "By talk" -- sorry, no. Not sure anyone really says POLECAR -- paceCAR and POLEsitter, sure, but POLECAR? And the less said about VIAMEDIA...well, you know.
Growing up about 20 miles from San Juan Capistrano, I was taught that Father SERRA was a great man. The missions he and others built are magnificent, but his legacy is way more complicated than what was presented to me as a kid.
IMPOSTER has enduring use in my family. 30+ years ago, when my best college friend came to stay with my family over the Christmas holidays, at one point he profusely thanked us and expressed hope that he was not an imposition. My sister replied, "Oh no, you're absolutely not an IMPOSTER!" They've been married since 1992, and we still call him that.
Best part about @Rex's write-up is the P.S. I can hear him screaming "RIDGY" in the Gene Wilder "SEDAGIVE?!?" voice.
Liked it. Easy seems right. Knew right away, well, at PONZI SCHEMES, that it would be something in the clues, since the answer was the exact opposite of the clue. No problem with IMPOSTER or the radius clue, since I had the E____ and recently broke that bone! (Hiking)
Clues for Hidden Diagonal Words in the grid today:
1. Blueprint
2. Arrive at LGA, perhaps
3. Ifs, ____ ...
Thought this was a clever Thursday puzzle, and I suspect that others shared my solving experience (I haven't read the comments yet): really hard until I hit the revealer, very easy afterwards.
Had to fix a "No-Happy-Music glitch at the end, because I had confidently entered PacE CAR instead of POLE CAR, and didn't notice the obviously incorrect crosses (ELBaW & cTS).
Answers: If you start with the P in 48A, MAPS, and move to the NW, you will find this string of letters: PLANDS, which contains consecutively the answer to the three HDW clues:
1. PLAN 2. LAND 3. ANDS (Add the S to LAND and get the only 5-letter HDW I noticed today. Moving the other direction on that letter thread produces DNA and ALP)
Lots of other HDWs today, including EMU, PEER, Six, HOSE, and "Unlikely expression at a Cardinals day game this month"--BRR
Medium for me, leaning to the easy side, but with enough effort required that I felt good about finishing. Still, the final mystery of the theme conceit wasn’t jumping out at me. I could see I needed to RIP out some ABS but studying the answers got me nowhere. Finally a lightbulb appeared over my head, and I remembered at @Nancy‘s brilliant advice the other day that if you can’t figure it out from the answer, go back to the clue. Specifically in this case, go back and read the clue for the revealer. “Eureka! The thrill of victory!” Followed swiftly by the agony of “Duh. How did I miss that?”
So thank you @Nancy, for your sideline coaching and thank you Rajeswari, for a gold medal debut. Not the easiest day to pull that off and you got me good, but it was a good get. I fully expect to see your name again, hopefully soon and often.
Liked it very much. When I saw "gymgoer's" and "goal" in 61A, I figured ABS must part of the gimmick. BELOWTHEBELT confirmed it and I crossed "ab" out of all the starred clues.
Junipero SERRA High School is a Catholic school in neighboring San Mateo. Barry Bonds went there.
Easy. This was a post-finish “oh, so that’s what’s going on” moment (hi @Rex). The * clue/answers were not making sense but they were pretty obvious so the solve was mostly whooshy. No erasures and I did not know VIA MEDIA and ELLA…so easy.
I knew almost immediately what the trick was, but not what the phrase would turn out to be.
And didn't I tell you all only just yesterday that "when there's a mismatch between the clue and the answer, the trick is in the CLUE."
Yesterday I was wrong, but today I was right!! Yay, me!!
I made this puzzle hugely enjoyable for myself once I figured out from getting PONZI SCHEMES and EXPONENTS that the ABs in the clues would go missing. I then filled in EMAILS and ORALLY with no crosses -- and in dark ink, mind you. I held off on the nasty not habits-but-hits clue because there are all kinds of nasty hits. But once I had just the W, I immediately filled in BELOW THE BELT -- once again in dark ink.
Aha -- RIPPED ABS! (Shouldn't they really be RIPPED OUT ABS?) No matter -- I had a wonderful time with this puzzle, which, btw, made me feel really, really smart. That's two very clever and very entertaining puzzle in a row. I'm a happy camper.
RP: “MTNDEW looks like you slammed your face on the keyboard.” Good one.
@Peamut (9:06) As a longtime racing fan, POLE CAR sounded wrong to me too. In fact, PACE CAR was my first thought. The terms pole position, pole winner, pole sitter, or just simply the pole, all seem more familiar.
@Sir Hillary (9:45) “Rex screaming RIDGY in his sedagive voice.” I’d buy a ticket to see that. 🤣
I'll give myself one point for suspecting that the trick was in the clues and subtract two for failing to see the common ABS. I needed the reveal to finish: the DAB-RIDGEY-HENRY-ORALLY AREA really flummoxed me. At least "By talk," as dreadful as it is, allowed me to get ORALLY and then the rest. Last in was the D in DAB x RIDGY, both of which I resisted until the bitter end. Otherwise, pleasingly challenging for me, enjoyed working on it.
I'm shocked that no one has pointed out the racist implications of MTNDEW. For those who don't read the news, JD Vance, the former Trump despiser who is currently (and I believe temporarily) weighing down the fast-sinking ship of Trump's campaign, was recently quoted as saying "I had a Diet Mountain Dew yesterday, and one today. I'm sure they're going to call that racist too.". So please, constructors, let's drop MTNDEW from your word lists.
I'm somehow charmed at the thought of communicating "by talk". It's like the next step after a few weeks of on-line chat on a dating app.
Why did the body builder fail in his quest for RIPPEDABS? There was just no WHEY.
Nice fun debut puzzle. Congrats, Rajeswari Rajamani.
MYOPE is new to me. I like it. It rhymes with dope. Speaking of dope, are flowers shops selling POT now?
RIDGY is also new. I guess you could say RIDGY is edgy.
This is my favorite puzzle of the week so far. Like OFL, I refused to look at the revealer until the end. At first I didn’t notice it said “the starred clues” must have the ABS RIPPED, not the entries. SLOPPY reading, dumb A. Got it eventually.
Wish I’d remembered @Nancy’s comment from the other day that when the answers don’t match the clues, the trick is in the clues. Think I’ll put that on a post-it note on my desk.
Anyway, I still enjoyed it because I enjoy a mystery, even if I can’t solve it. I also liked some of the clues, like “Like a kite” and “Endpoint of a radius.” Oh, and ICE RINK. Such a great image @Rex drew with his “hugging the edge of the rink” riff. Spot on.
Crafty work, Ms. Rajamani. Maybe I’ll be ready for your next one.
Yep, pole position, pacecar & just a tangent to the " ripped" theme. Has anyone seen these Facebook reels of Anatoly pranking weight lifters in the gym?
Solved this as a theme less - never got the gimmick until coming here and reading the explanation. I continue to just not jive with Thursdays. Fine as a theme less though.
Easy????? NOSIREEBOB. I said a few ay dios mios, cheated a lot, went to the reveal, still didn't get it until......Light Bulb Moment.!!!! I had one....at the end. Should've paid closer attention to @Nancy's advice.
So my first starred clue: EXPONENTS. Meant nothing and NADA. Zilch. Got frustrated and moved on. AVIAN is like a kite? ELBOW? Why are you clued that way? ICE RINK is where I might find myself on edge? What, pray tell, are NDAS and I've never seen a MTNDEW. See what I mean?
RIPPED ABS. I even looked at you twice because I kept seeing RIP PEDABS and thinking this was another made up word. Yikes on me. OK, so I stared. I went back up to BELOW THE BELT and saw that [HIT] was missing. Hmmm. Look at the clue. Oh....Like some nasty HITS! I erased the AB and lookie here....there's your answer. Finished.
Yes, I stuck to the puzzle although I wasn't enamored with it. I really want to dance a fandango tango on a Thursday. Today I did the Funky Chicken.
Overall I agree that this was easy/medium for a Thursday. I liked NDA and PDA. Also disliked RIDGY and came here to complain about it. Can someone explain NESTS to me?
The revealer clue does specify that it is something "the starred clues ... must have," but that's putting it pretty subtly. But like everyone else here (except @Nancy!) I first tried to take the ABS out of the answers. But another look at the clue straightened that out.
However, I got all the theme answers from crosses that left no other choices (I guess that's what some of you do with all the acrosses on Mondays). I did think, with PONZI SCHEMES, that the trick might be to add NON at the start of the clue, but that didn't work anywhere else. And I did think that for a nun to wear her habit BELOW THE BELT would be inappropriate, making it a 'nasty habit.' So I didn't know what was going on -- and then saw it with the revealer. Pretty neat in retrospect.
I had PacE car before POLE CAR. I really don't know from auto racing -- but aren't there some races where a race official leads the pack around for one lap, then drives off --- thereby letting all the cars start from the same speed. Now that I think, I've only seen that with trotting horses, where the pickup can suddenly accelerate ahead.
Yeah, if we're going to talk Latin, it should be terra MEDIA, which wouldn't fit.
Worked my way down systematically. Confused by the first two starred clues but 38 Across enabled me to figure out the need to remove AB from clues and it checked out for the earlier answers. I didn’t figure out the revealer until I got to it.
Also, I’m still sad about Poochie dying on the way back to him home planet.
I would swear that the first time I heard the term "ripping" in relation to copying the audio from a CD, about 30 years ago, it was explained to me that RIP stood for Raster Image Processing. But I can't find any citation to back that up.
For "Neighbor of Ursa Major", for the life of me I couldn't think of a 3 letter constellation. LEO, what's wrong with my brain?
OGRE's are not real, ergo the man-eating menace must be an Orca. Not until I got POLE CAR did I change 40D.
I agree with Rex on disliking "Middle ground" for 10D. I didn't think VIA meant ground (it doesn't) so the second half of the Latin phrase must be "terra"? The M of MOET kept me from putting that in the grid, but the clue sure didn't lead to MEDIA; I needed all the crosses.
Once again we're stuck with a pet SPA. I had SUN in there - SUNDAY, SUNDOG. Fie on SPA. I had a few mental BLEEPs when that showed up.
But the SE was what really got me. LEE a no-know, MTN DEW not a thing for me, and was Postmates acquired by eBay, perhaps? Finally the T of BELT got me to MTN DEW and the rest filled in. So where did Columbus land, that he thought he was in EDEN? Ah, Google says it was Venezuela.
All of the above to let you know that I found this puzzle quite challenging!
From Wikipedia "Ploceidae is a family of small passerine birds, many of which are called weavers, weaverbirds, weaver finches, or bishops. These names come from the NESTS of intricately woven vegetation created by birds in this family."
Edge is an essential skating and skiing concept. If you lean, you put weight on the edge of the ski or skate and you turn in that direction because of the shape of the ski or blade
There’s been a rash of these of late, puzzles easily finished (with the understanding something’s going on here) and then an anticlimactic understanding of what theme must have been, or not even caring. We need a term such as “Naticked” for this.
I did not enjoy solving this puzzle. Even after solving the “revealer” I didn’t understand it. Until I read this blog I didn’t realize that the “abs” were ripped from the clues not the answers. Corduroy is ridged or rugose, not ridgy. This puzzle would be better as a themeless with better clues.
I think most of the posters are too good at this nyt crossword stuff to appreciate the revealer. For me, I was completelely stuck with a puzzle that looked like Swiss cheese until I concentrated on the revealer. Once I figured that out, it was smooth sailing. Ripped the abs out and sprinted across the goal.
I’ll take an explainer — which tells you how to actually solve the themers — over a revealer — which tells you some dumb obvious but maybe cute thing about why the themers you already solved are related — anytime!
not even NASCAR heathens say POLE CAR. its POLE sitter; your sitting on the POLE position (also widely used). but, of course, NASCAR fans are total POLE CAtS
For POLE-CAR, Merriam-Webster has only “a railroad car sometimes used in pole switching”—nothing to do with racing. It doesn't seem to be British English (Collins) either. It's not even in Chambers.
With just a tweak to DAB, the constructER 😂 could have changed to POLECAT, replaced the vile RIDGY, and cleaned things up considerably (though commentary here would have been cut in half).
Hey Peamut, as a Red Sox fan, the Joba Chamberlain attack by midges is a lasting memory. Of course, I was rooting for the Indians.
Bravo on your debut RR but seriously, the substitute editor cannot allow clues such as 40A. If there is no workaround then scrap the idea entirely. I miss Will Shortz!
Sorry, but when I see an extra long clue, especially at the head of a column as it was today, my EYES just gravitate. So, something about bodybuilding. In puzzles, this usually turns out to be ABS, a handy "weeject." The first starred clue did have an -AB-word, so I quickly checked the next: yep, "viABle." So I tried subtracting, and there it was. Somewhat tame for a Thursday, but okay.
Hardest no-know: NDAS. Sure, non-disclosure, but I don't bandy the acronym about on a daily--or yearly--basis. I'm all for full disclosure, baby. NDA = what are you hiding?.
Re: ELLA the elephant: Ms. F. takes offense. AGREE that EFILE/EMAILS = at least one too many E-things. Par.
Wordle phew; I guess I need to widen my vocabulary.
Hey @WAXY - you made it in at 2d! I did not look ahead, so got the aha moment after completion. ANTS in the corners. Wordle birdie, and har har to @spacey.
A long time ago, I was solving this puzzle and got stuck at an unguessable (to me) crossing: N. C. WYETH crossing NATICK at the "N"—I knew WYETH but forgot his initials, and NATICK ... is a suburb of Boston that I had no hope of knowing. It was clued as someplace the Boston Marathon runs through (???). Anyway, NATICK— the more obscure name in that crossing—became shorthand for an unguessable cross, esp. where the cross involves two proper nouns, neither of which is exceedingly well known. NATICK took hold as crossword slang, and the term can now be both noun ("I had a NATICK in the SW corner...") or verb ("I got NATICKED by 50A / 34D!")
76 comments:
Whoops! Forgot to post this yesterday. The month of gunk report for July.
The gunkiest puzzle in three months on July 2, with the diagonal circles pointing to YES, came in at a shocking 47% gunk rating and yet was lauded by Rex and called a "clean" grid. Meanwhile, you'll remember the weird "not my cup of tea" puzzle was ultra clean at 16% gunk and it received tepid reviews. So I guess it's gunk, unless you like the gunk.
The cost of gunk rose for the third month in a row and we're now paying and average of 4.75¢ per puzzle for gunk out of our 15¢ buy in, and you can thank Friday, Saturday and Sunday for this. In order to toughen puzzles up, they've amped up what most people would call "trivia" to prevent us from flying through the weekend. They could write better clues on better words, but let's not be confused how our hobby works.
My other favorite moment in gunk from July was on Sunday the 7th when we had the THUMB-INDEX-MIDDLE-RING-PINKY double digit thingy and that puzzle ... a Sunday! ... rolled in at 40% gunk with a whopping raw score of 56 words out of 140.
I kept track of how much food shows up in the puzzles, but this was unremarkable this month so I guess I'll just rage and storm privately. Bring back the extinct birds. I finally had them memorized.
Here's the score card (arrows compare results from previous month which had one less day):
People and Proper Nouns: 246 ↑
Places: 86 ↓
Products: 154 ↑
Partial Words and Initialisms: 233 ↑
Foreignisms: 96 ↓
Average Monthly Gunkiness: 32% (up for the last two months):
Averages by Day:
M: 25% ↑
T: 31%
W: 29% ↓
R: 31%
F: 34% ↑
S: 36% ↑
U: 35% ↑
If I had one wish, it would be that the clue writers develop a sense of humor. I won't tell you how few funnyisms happened last month (whispers 107 as an aside), but out of 2560 chances, we'll say there's plenty of room for improvement. C'mon Joel, you found all those ARSES back in your slush pile days, you can amp up the comedy with the best of 'em.
The whole “reveal/explain” paragraph seems like a distinction without a difference. Very, very picky - as was the rest of the write-up. I found the puzzle challenging & clever.
My RIPPED ABS are also RIDGY like corduroy. I wish.
Nice concept, definitely a solid Aha when I finished the puzzle, looked again at the revealer, and went back to read the starred clues. The themers were a bit of a mixed bag - BELOW THE BELT worked perfectly, PONZI SCHEME was kind of clever, EMAILS was meh, ORALLY was awkward, and EXPONENTS was meaningless to me because … math (I think?)
PacE CARS before POLE CARS. I did not know Columbus thought he had found EDEN when he got to the New World. I thought he thought he was in Asia.
Unlike yesterday, which also had a theme that needed some “revealing” where the revealer gave you a kind of a cute aha moment, this one jumped completely into the NYT stunt/gimmick pool with a theme/reveal so convoluted that as usual, I needed Rex to explain it to me post-solve. So the whole experience was parsing cross after cross to get to stuff like EXPONENTS which had nothing to do with the clue.
Add in the usual stuff that may be real but gets used about once a decade in real life such as VIAMEDIA and you’re in pretty familiar NYT territory - a grid that is pretty much unsolvable unless you are a hard-core META fan, or perhaps a masochist who enjoys slogging through endless crosses in the hopes that you come up with something that looks like a viable word or phrase.
At least you pretty much know what you are in for on a Thursday with the Times, and in that regard they seemed to achieve their objective - I’m guessing the puzzle will be pretty well-received by the Thursday fans in the group, but for me at least, the whole gimmick soared about 50,000 feet over my head.
As one who played hockey till age 62, on edge means on skate blade, though it also could reflect the feeling I had when a younger bigger opponent with or without RIPPED ABS was barreling in on me. Though they were officially “no check”* leagues, I was carted off the ice in an ambulance with a broken collarbone and bruised ribs in one of my last seasons when a massive OGRE took an illegally aggressive approach. Sucks to get old and slow and become an easy target!
* cash and credit only (nyuk nyuk!)
Puzzle was fine, I guess, but didn’t notice the abs were in the clues even after the revealer. And BYTALK is beyond a groaner for ORALLY.
Best puzzle of the week so far. Figured the theme out at EMAILS – by far the most transparent themer - even though I already had PONZI SCHEMES and EXPONENTS filled in; I just didn't know why.
Looking forward to the uniclue for VIA MEDIA MTN DEW.
Columbus didn’t actually think he had found Eden, but he thought that the Orinoco river, which he found the mouth of, must originate in Eden.
Here’s a constructor who, in her debut, shows great promise. Somewhere along the line, Rajeswari came across the phrase RIPPED ABS and didn’t just move on; her brain tapped her on the shoulder and said, “Look closer!” That’s crossword constructor brain. She’s got it.
And she delivered. A bit into the puzzle, when I had uncovered one of the theme answers and knew it was correct, even though it didn’t fit its clue – well, that is one of Crosslandia’s great moments: where you know there’s a riddle to crack and an aha coming when you do. It brings a bounce to your brain’s step. I actually thought, “Oh I love this puzzle” at that moment.
Rajeswari sweetened the outing with beauty as well: MIDGE, PONZI SCHEMES, PLUMB, POLE CAR, BELOW THE BELT, RIPPED ABS, BLEEP, IMPOSTER. Plus, she included lovely vague clues and misdirects.
So yes, great promise evident here, IMO.
Two observations. First, I’m amazed that BELOW THE BELT had never appeared in a Times puzzle before today. Second, regarding RIDGY, which has drawn some raised eyebrows, well, I love this answer. It looks terrific, is fun to say, and has far more bounce than “ridged”. I’ve never thought of it before, never used it, and maybe never will, but I love it – thumbs up!
Rajeswari, congratulations on becoming a Times constructor, and please, forge on! Thank you for your splendid puzzle!
Rode the struggle bus throughout, and it drives me crazy when I find the revealer and I still don't get it ... until I get it later after an embarrassing amount of time. When I finally saw the ABS in the clues, not the answers, I let out a literal "OHO!" That's when BELOW THE BELT arrived majestically and I could finish the puzzle. Great theme idea.
The top of the puzzle came far more easily than the lower half and ELLA stopped me cold.
MIDGE reminded me of 10 glorious days in Scotland a few years ago. RIDGY is the last way I'd describe corduroy. ENNUI is my #1 favorite word. Read up on Junípero SERRA's crazy life.
Why is MTNDEW "stylized?" That's how they spell it.
Propers: 6
Places: 1
Products: 3
Partials: 11 (hiss)
Foreignisms: 1
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 22 of 78 (28%)
Funnyisms: 3 😐
Tee-Hee: HENRY Miller. I read both of his tropical tomes and I'd say he's way over appreciated. Maybe literary intellectuals need to DAB less POT when picking great writers. ZIT and WART in the same puzzle. Ah, childhood memories.
Uniclues:
1 Celebrate local ankle biter.
2 Unfortunate report from a family member when the green men didn't come in peace.
3 Made a phone call. (Remember those?)
4 Ranks rockin' bods.
5 Me, when I am trying to act mature.
6 One pathologically obsessed with getting high and scaring children.
1 HAIL AREA MIDGE
2 "ET'S EATEN NIECE"
3 EMAILS ORALLY
4 LISTS RIPPED ABS
5 SLOPPY IMPOSTER
6 OCD POT OGRE
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Tom in London (or a Catcerto). SIAMESE IN A FLAT.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I am shocked--shocked, I tell you!--to see SPA in a puzzle. Why, it feels like it's only been 5 whole minutes since we've seen that word!
Seriously, it's a crutch akin to EKE and EPEE at this point. I get that there are common words, but it feels like we see it every other day at this point.
Anyway, mostly fun little trick; not exactly Thursday-worthy, but had a nice early a-ha! moment. Looking forward to a little more challenge in the next couple of days.
@SouthsideJohnny : Amen brother
Lots of "what OFL said" for me, especially waiting for the revealer (no idea), spelling IMPOSTER wrong (with another O), and thinking RIDGY was pure invention. Also "by talk" is just dreadful. What, I'm entering my comment by type? Come on man.
ELBOW took way too long as I kept thinking of "radius" in terms of geometry, which I'm sure was the constructors' intention. Score one for the constructor.
Not too many names today. I think we just had ELLA the Elephant somewhere, unless it was in a New Yorker or a Croce or a Stumper. Can be confusing. I knew Fr. SERRA immediately from my Spanish teaching days but I wonder if he's familiar to very many of us.
All in all a good theme which mostly landed and a nice aha! revealer, which is all I ask for on a Thursday, Nice job, RR. Your Risk Reward factor worked out nicely, and thanks for all the fun.
@andrew: It sucks to get old and slow and become an easy target even when you don't play hockey. Or any sport at all.
Puzzle was Easy-Medium, although I solved it as a themeless ignoring or not reading the themer clues, which were pretty much useless anyway. Didn't get the theme until I got here.
No overwrites, although I had to toss a coin at 8D to decide if my first try would be EdgES IN or EASES. Luckily it came up tails. And I did entertain ScAT before SKAT at 68A.
Didn't know ELLA the Elephant (35D) or Junipero SERRA (67A), and maybe RIDGY (42A) might count as an honorary WOE, as in "Please don't be RIDGY, please don't be RIDGY, please ..."
I don’t know about Buddhism, but VIA MEDIA is a description of Anglicanism—between Roman Catholic and Protestant.
IMPOSTOR, not impostER. I objected at having to spell the word this way to complete the puzzle. I looked it up and found that it seems to be accepted as a variant..But I’m with Rex — it’s still a BOO from me.
I hated Ridgy. It's what I thought immediately, but refused to put it, because it felt like such a dumb word.
@kitshef 7:26 AM
Ack! Missed it. Great call.
Hopped up pop on Twitch.
MTN DEW VIA MEDIA (~)
Polecar is not a recognized word, not even in slang
Polecar is not a recognized word
Finally realized that the RIPPEDABS were supposed to be ripped from the clue. I had assumed that "AB" was to be subtracted from the answer. Once I got that right, the puzzle was fairly routine.
I agree with MazzPuzz and Rex Parker that IMPOSTER is a horrible misspelling. I also question EDEN as the place Columbus thought he had landed. Columbus thought he had reached India, which is why he (falsely) named the Caribbean islands he had reached as Indies (later called West Indies). It slowed me down, because I thought EDEN was India and that it was a rebus puzzle.
Interesting puzzle, but worried editing.
Never heard of the term “pole car“. Also, “racetrack leader“ would assume that the race has already started. The car in pole position is only in front before the start of the race.
Ridgy? Ugh! Myope? Hmm.
I remember the Yankees versus Indians playoff game in 2007 when Joba Chamberlain was attacked by MIDGES coming off of Lake Erie!
I found the puzzle difficult, not because of the theme which was excellent in my opinion, but just generally outside my wheelhouse. The one little quibble I have is with the “flower shop” clues. I find “bulbs” and “pots” in nearby plant nurseries or online. Flower shops are for house plants, bouquets, posies, cut flowers, centerpieces; basically more finished or arranged plant products. Otherwise I found the puzzle to be a good example of a Thursday crossword. Thanks to the creator for the fun!
Hey All !
Argh! NE corner! What kind of way to clue AVIAN is that? I wanted Aloft, inair, awaft (!), something. And MIDGE? Holy Moly, crossed by VIAMEDIA and NESTS as clued. Total brain meltdown up there. Had rest of puz done in about 14 minutes, finally ran to Goog for VIAMEDIA at the 22 minute mark. Dang. Do you AGREE about that corner?
Figured out the concept after getting PONZI SCHEMES. Was trying to insert ABS somewhere in EXPONENTS after getting that, but nothing was working. Saw the "ab" string in both clues, RIPPED them out, and got the Aha moment.
Good puz, beside the [$@#%!] NE corner. Can never remember if it's IE or EI in NIECE. Good RexRant on RIDGY. Gor a chuckle.
Happy Thursday.
One F
RooMonster
DarrinV
Always hope for a ridgy puzzle, but this was just sloggy.
[Michael Caine voice] MYOPE is next Fursday is bettuh.
Didn't quite work for me. Yeah, I guess EXPONENTS are next to carets when no superscript is used, but that seems a stretch. "By talk" -- sorry, no. Not sure anyone really says POLECAR -- paceCAR and POLEsitter, sure, but POLECAR? And the less said about VIAMEDIA...well, you know.
Growing up about 20 miles from San Juan Capistrano, I was taught that Father SERRA was a great man. The missions he and others built are magnificent, but his legacy is way more complicated than what was presented to me as a kid.
IMPOSTER has enduring use in my family. 30+ years ago, when my best college friend came to stay with my family over the Christmas holidays, at one point he profusely thanked us and expressed hope that he was not an imposition. My sister replied, "Oh no, you're absolutely not an IMPOSTER!" They've been married since 1992, and we still call him that.
Best part about @Rex's write-up is the P.S. I can hear him screaming "RIDGY" in the Gene Wilder "SEDAGIVE?!?" voice.
Liked it. Easy seems right. Knew right away, well, at PONZI SCHEMES, that it would be something in the clues, since the answer was the exact opposite of the clue. No problem with IMPOSTER or the radius clue, since I had the E____ and recently broke that bone! (Hiking)
Put in RIDGY as last answer in complete disgust!
Clues for Hidden Diagonal Words in the grid today:
1. Blueprint
2. Arrive at LGA, perhaps
3. Ifs, ____ ...
Thought this was a clever Thursday puzzle, and I suspect that others shared my solving experience (I haven't read the comments yet): really hard until I hit the revealer, very easy afterwards.
Had to fix a "No-Happy-Music glitch at the end, because I had confidently entered PacE CAR instead of POLE CAR, and didn't notice the obviously incorrect crosses (ELBaW & cTS).
Answers: If you start with the P in 48A, MAPS, and move to the NW, you will find this string of letters: PLANDS, which contains consecutively the answer to the three HDW clues:
1. PLAN
2. LAND
3. ANDS
(Add the S to LAND and get the only 5-letter HDW I noticed today. Moving the other direction on that letter thread produces DNA and ALP)
Lots of other HDWs today, including EMU, PEER, Six, HOSE, and "Unlikely expression at a Cardinals day game this month"--BRR
Medium for me, leaning to the easy side, but with enough effort required that I felt good about finishing. Still, the final mystery of the theme conceit wasn’t jumping out at me. I could see I needed to RIP out some ABS but studying the answers got me nowhere. Finally a lightbulb appeared over my head, and I remembered at @Nancy‘s brilliant advice the other day that if you can’t figure it out from the answer, go back to the clue. Specifically in this case, go back and read the clue for the revealer. “Eureka! The thrill of victory!” Followed swiftly by the agony of “Duh. How did I miss that?”
So thank you @Nancy, for your sideline coaching and thank you Rajeswari, for a gold medal debut. Not the easiest day to pull that off and you got me good, but it was a good get. I fully expect to see your name again, hopefully soon and often.
Liked it very much. When I saw "gymgoer's" and "goal" in 61A, I figured ABS must part of the gimmick. BELOWTHEBELT confirmed it and I crossed "ab" out of all the starred clues.
Junipero SERRA High School is a Catholic school in neighboring San Mateo. Barry Bonds went there.
Nice gimmick, smart cluing, no junk. Good job.
Easy. This was a post-finish “oh, so that’s what’s going on” moment (hi @Rex). The * clue/answers were not making sense but they were pretty obvious so the solve was mostly whooshy. No erasures and I did not know VIA MEDIA and ELLA…so easy.
Smooth, clever and cute, liked it.
Now, what gymgoer in the world wants MISSING ABS?
I knew almost immediately what the trick was, but not what the phrase would turn out to be.
And didn't I tell you all only just yesterday that "when there's a mismatch between the clue and the answer, the trick is in the CLUE."
Yesterday I was wrong, but today I was right!! Yay, me!!
I made this puzzle hugely enjoyable for myself once I figured out from getting PONZI SCHEMES and EXPONENTS that the ABs in the clues would go missing. I then filled in EMAILS and ORALLY with no crosses -- and in dark ink, mind you. I held off on the nasty not habits-but-hits clue because there are all kinds of nasty hits. But once I had just the W, I immediately filled in BELOW THE BELT -- once again in dark ink.
Aha -- RIPPED ABS! (Shouldn't they really be RIPPED OUT ABS?) No matter -- I had a wonderful time with this puzzle, which, btw, made me feel really, really smart. That's two very clever and very entertaining puzzle in a row. I'm a happy camper.
Barry Bonds and Tom Brady and Lynn Swann, to name just a few Serra athletes.
RP: “MTNDEW looks like you slammed your face on the keyboard.” Good one.
@Peamut (9:06) As a longtime racing fan, POLE CAR sounded wrong to me too. In fact, PACE CAR was my first thought. The terms pole position, pole winner, pole sitter, or just simply the pole, all seem more familiar.
@Sir Hillary (9:45) “Rex screaming RIDGY in his sedagive voice.” I’d buy a ticket to see that. 🤣
I'll give myself one point for suspecting that the trick was in the clues and subtract two for failing to see the common ABS. I needed the reveal to finish: the DAB-RIDGEY-HENRY-ORALLY AREA really flummoxed me. At least "By talk," as dreadful as it is, allowed me to get ORALLY and then the rest. Last in was the D in DAB x RIDGY, both of which I resisted until the bitter end. Otherwise, pleasingly challenging for me, enjoyed working on it.
Do-overs: HTtp; SieRA, POst car. No idea: HENRY.
@Sir Hillary, I love your IMPOSTER story!
I'm shocked that no one has pointed out the racist implications of MTNDEW. For those who don't read the news, JD Vance, the former Trump despiser who is currently (and I believe temporarily) weighing down the fast-sinking ship of Trump's campaign, was recently quoted as saying "I had a Diet Mountain Dew yesterday, and one today. I'm sure they're going to call that racist too.". So please, constructors, let's drop MTNDEW from your word lists.
I'm somehow charmed at the thought of communicating "by talk". It's like the next step after a few weeks of on-line chat on a dating app.
Why did the body builder fail in his quest for RIPPEDABS? There was just no WHEY.
Nice fun debut puzzle. Congrats, Rajeswari Rajamani.
MYOPE is new to me. I like it. It rhymes with dope. Speaking of dope, are flowers shops selling POT now?
RIDGY is also new. I guess you could say RIDGY is edgy.
This is my favorite puzzle of the week so far. Like OFL, I refused to look at the revealer until the end. At first I didn’t notice it said “the starred clues” must have the ABS RIPPED, not the entries. SLOPPY reading, dumb A. Got it eventually.
Wish I’d remembered @Nancy’s comment from the other day that when the answers don’t match the clues, the trick is in the clues. Think I’ll put that on a post-it note on my desk.
Anyway, I still enjoyed it because I enjoy a mystery, even if I can’t solve it. I also liked some of the clues, like “Like a kite” and “Endpoint of a radius.” Oh, and ICE RINK. Such a great image @Rex drew with his “hugging the edge of the rink” riff. Spot on.
Crafty work, Ms. Rajamani. Maybe I’ll be ready for your next one.
Yep, pole position, pacecar & just a tangent to the " ripped" theme. Has anyone seen these Facebook reels of Anatoly pranking weight lifters in the gym?
My God, another candidate for WOAT, and so soon. Riddled with mistakes and a *terrible* and incompetently executed gimmick.
Solved this as a theme less - never got the gimmick until coming here and reading the explanation. I continue to just not jive with Thursdays. Fine as a theme less though.
Lol I too finished my solve thinking, “Rex is going to have RIDGY brows today…”
Easy????? NOSIREEBOB. I said a few ay dios mios, cheated a lot, went to the reveal, still didn't get it until......Light Bulb Moment.!!!! I had one....at the end. Should've paid closer attention to @Nancy's advice.
So my first starred clue: EXPONENTS. Meant nothing and NADA. Zilch. Got frustrated and moved on. AVIAN is like a kite? ELBOW? Why are you clued that way? ICE RINK is where I might find myself on edge? What, pray tell, are NDAS and I've never seen a MTNDEW. See what I mean?
RIPPED ABS. I even looked at you twice because I kept seeing RIP PEDABS and thinking this was another made up word. Yikes on me. OK, so I stared. I went back up to BELOW THE BELT and saw that [HIT] was missing. Hmmm. Look at the clue. Oh....Like some nasty HITS! I erased the AB and lookie here....there's your answer. Finished.
Yes, I stuck to the puzzle although I wasn't enamored with it. I really want to dance a fandango tango on a Thursday. Today I did the Funky Chicken.
Overall I agree that this was easy/medium for a Thursday. I liked NDA and PDA. Also disliked RIDGY and came here to complain about it. Can someone explain NESTS to me?
The revealer clue does specify that it is something "the starred clues ... must have," but that's putting it pretty subtly. But like everyone else here (except @Nancy!) I first tried to take the ABS out of the answers. But another look at the clue straightened that out.
However, I got all the theme answers from crosses that left no other choices (I guess that's what some of you do with all the acrosses on Mondays). I did think, with PONZI SCHEMES, that the trick might be to add NON at the start of the clue, but that didn't work anywhere else. And I did think that for a nun to wear her habit BELOW THE BELT would be inappropriate, making it a 'nasty habit.' So I didn't know what was going on -- and then saw it with the revealer. Pretty neat in retrospect.
I had PacE car before POLE CAR. I really don't know from auto racing -- but aren't there some races where a race official leads the pack around for one lap, then drives off --- thereby letting all the cars start from the same speed. Now that I think, I've only seen that with trotting horses, where the pickup can suddenly accelerate ahead.
Yeah, if we're going to talk Latin, it should be terra MEDIA, which wouldn't fit.
Here's a little of that Good Ol' MTN DEW for you.
Enjoyed it a lot. Thought the conceit was quite clever… and that Rex was overly nit-picky.
Worked my way down systematically. Confused by the first two starred clues but 38 Across enabled me to figure out the need to remove AB from clues and it checked out for the earlier answers. I didn’t figure out the revealer until I got to it.
Also, I’m still sad about Poochie dying on the way back to him home planet.
To put it nicely ... this was not for me :(
For those confused by the clue for AVIAN (9A), a kite is a type od bird.
AWLS well that ends.
I would swear that the first time I heard the term "ripping" in relation to copying the audio from a CD, about 30 years ago, it was explained to me that RIP stood for Raster Image Processing. But I can't find any citation to back that up.
For "Neighbor of Ursa Major", for the life of me I couldn't think of a 3 letter constellation. LEO, what's wrong with my brain?
OGRE's are not real, ergo the man-eating menace must be an Orca. Not until I got POLE CAR did I change 40D.
I agree with Rex on disliking "Middle ground" for 10D. I didn't think VIA meant ground (it doesn't) so the second half of the Latin phrase must be "terra"? The M of MOET kept me from putting that in the grid, but the clue sure didn't lead to MEDIA; I needed all the crosses.
Once again we're stuck with a pet SPA. I had SUN in there - SUNDAY, SUNDOG. Fie on SPA. I had a few mental BLEEPs when that showed up.
But the SE was what really got me. LEE a no-know, MTN DEW not a thing for me, and was Postmates acquired by eBay, perhaps? Finally the T of BELT got me to MTN DEW and the rest filled in. So where did Columbus land, that he thought he was in EDEN? Ah, Google says it was Venezuela.
All of the above to let you know that I found this puzzle quite challenging!
Thanks, Rajeswari Rajamani!
@Sam 11:46
From Wikipedia "Ploceidae is a family of small passerine birds, many of which are called weavers, weaverbirds, weaver finches, or bishops. These names come from the NESTS of intricately woven vegetation created by birds in this family."
Edge is an essential skating and skiing concept. If you lean, you put weight on the edge of the ski or skate and you turn in that direction because of the shape of the ski or blade
had ribby before ridgy. 'dab' as an answer seemed to muddle the theme.
There’s been a rash of these of late, puzzles easily finished (with the understanding something’s going on here) and then an anticlimactic understanding of what theme must have been, or not even caring. We need a term such as “Naticked” for this.
I did not enjoy solving this puzzle. Even after solving the “revealer” I didn’t understand it. Until I read this blog I didn’t realize that the “abs” were ripped from the clues not the answers. Corduroy is ridged or rugose, not ridgy. This puzzle would be better as a themeless with better clues.
egsforbreakfast: "There was just no WHEY!" Solid gold!!!
i before e except after c
Totally played myself trying to think I had to add “AB” to the answers to get them to match the clues and just could’t make it work!!!
Fun solve, frustrating theme, with a “holy cow I’m an idiot” a-ha moment when I came here and finally understood.
What the f****** hell. Cocktail in a copper mug. Etc. Give me a f***ing break. Not clever, just extremely annoying.
I think most of the posters are too good at this nyt crossword stuff to appreciate the revealer. For me, I was completelely stuck with a puzzle that looked like Swiss cheese until I concentrated on the revealer. Once I figured that out, it was smooth sailing. Ripped the abs out and sprinted across the goal.
Ripped abs means they are developed. Ripped out? Ow!
@egsfor 11:04...WHO can undo hearing his MTN DEW????? I wonder what Meemaw Glenn Close is thinking now? "There was just now WHEY."....
Never got the revealer. Had no idea til I finished and read this what was going on.
I’ll take an explainer — which tells you how to actually solve the themers — over a revealer — which tells you some dumb obvious but maybe cute thing about why the themers you already solved are related — anytime!
not even NASCAR heathens say POLE CAR. its POLE sitter; your sitting on the POLE position (also widely used). but, of course, NASCAR fans are total POLE CAtS
Ridgy? Mtndew? What is a “pole car”? A “dab” of what, hair gel?
For POLE-CAR, Merriam-Webster has only “a railroad car sometimes used in pole switching”—nothing to do with racing. It doesn't seem to be British English (Collins) either. It's not even in Chambers.
Lol. Can I please get a definition of gunk? Facinating that it is a trackable metric. Much obliged
Waled before RIDGY.
With just a tweak to DAB, the constructER 😂 could have changed to POLECAT, replaced the vile RIDGY, and cleaned things up considerably (though commentary here would have been cut in half).
Hey Peamut, as a Red Sox fan, the Joba Chamberlain attack by midges is a lasting memory. Of course, I was rooting for the Indians.
…and the midges (sorry)
Nope. Never POLE CAR. Always pole sitter. Regardless of the racing series.
Bravo on your debut RR but seriously, the substitute editor cannot allow clues such as 40A. If there is no workaround then scrap the idea entirely. I miss Will Shortz!
Sorry, but when I see an extra long clue, especially at the head of a column as it was today, my EYES just gravitate. So, something about bodybuilding. In puzzles, this usually turns out to be ABS, a handy "weeject." The first starred clue did have an -AB-word, so I quickly checked the next: yep, "viABle." So I tried subtracting, and there it was. Somewhat tame for a Thursday, but okay.
Hardest no-know: NDAS. Sure, non-disclosure, but I don't bandy the acronym about on a daily--or yearly--basis. I'm all for full disclosure, baby. NDA = what are you hiding?.
Re: ELLA the elephant: Ms. F. takes offense. AGREE that EFILE/EMAILS = at least one too many E-things. Par.
Wordle phew; I guess I need to widen my vocabulary.
DIVIDED PAIR (LOSER LIST)
ELLA MAE suffered ENNUI,
‘LIVE and LETLIVE’ IS A LIE, she felt.
On one SCHEME we DEW AGREE,
IN THE AREA BELOWTHEBELT.
--- SIR HENRY LEE PLUMB
Hey @WAXY - you made it in at 2d!
I did not look ahead, so got the aha moment after completion. ANTS in the corners.
Wordle birdie, and har har to @spacey.
Post a Comment