Relative difficulty: Easy (oversized at 16x, so solving times may not be faster than avg.)
THEME: "HOLD IT!" (39A: "Stop right there!" ... or a hint to the first words of 17-, 23-, 47- and 59-Across) — first words of theme answers are things you might "hold":
Theme answers:
DOORBUSTERS (17A: Black Friday offer, e.g.)
LINE OF CREDIT (23A: Something extended to a borrower)
MAYO CLINIC (59A: Expansive medical center headquartered in Rochester, Minn.)
Word of the Day: "Forget You" (34D: CeeLo Green's "Forget You," notably => RADIO EDIT) —
"Fuck You" (stylized as "Fuck You!" or "F**k You!"), known as "Forget You" or "FU" for the clean versions, is a song by American recording artist CeeLo Green. It was written as a collaboration among Green,Bruno Mars, his production team the Smeezingtons, and Brody Brown. It was released on August 19, 2010, as the first single from Green's third solo studio album, The Lady Killer (2010). "Fuck You" received acclaim from music critics, and was an international commercial success, making the top-10 in thirteen countries, including topping charts in the United Kingdom, and number two on the Billboard Hot 100. // In an interview with NME, Green said that, in addition to being about a heartbreak, the song was also about the music industry itself. [...] Several versions of "Fuck You" have been released: the original recording, censored copies of it, and newer versions that include other performers or significant changes to the lyrics. // The original has twice beenedited to remove swearing: the first of these, which is broadcast in the music video on UK television stations and played on US radio, is called "Forget You"; the second, for UK radio use, is entitled "FU". These two are essentially identical to the original except in their treatment of profanity; "Forget You" replaces the profanity with sound effects (other than "fuck you", which is changed to "forget you" per the title), and "FU" censors words by simply silencing them except replacing "fuck you" with "eff you" - also as its title suggests.
• • •
A puzzle that would've been right at home on Monday any other week, but the Wednesday-type puzzle took the Monday slot (April Fools!), so the Monday type gets bounced to Tuesday and lord knows what we're getting tomorrow. The theme type (the "first words do X" type) is very Monday/Tuesday, and while this played like a Monday for me, it was oversized, so my time was probably more like a Tuesday. The theme itself is completely ordinary—just fine, totally familiar and normal, not showing you anything new, not horrifying you with bizarre thematic overreach or tin-eared clunkery. As many ups and downs, and none of them taking you very far off the midline. The definition of a placeholder. I didn't really process the theme until I was done, and then ... well, there's not that much to process. You do indeed hold the door (for someone), hold the line (love isn't always on time!), hold the floor (when speaking at a meeting) and hold the mayo (why? Mayo rules. Maybe you have an egg allergy). All the themers are familiar. I thought DOOR BUSTER was a relatively recent coinage, but according to the OED... 1893!
I will confess to slight hesitation when trying to think of the second word in both FLOOR ROUTINE and MAYO CLINIC; "exercise" and "center," respectively, were lodged in my brain and needed a second or two, or a cross or two, to come loose, but otherwise, the theme part of this was a cinch, the answers themselves all perfectly appropriate to the theme and solid as a rock.
Pitchfork thought "Jesus, ETC." was the 64th best song of the '00s, if that helps? If you don't know what Pitchfork is, then you definitely aren't the right demographic for this clue. Wilco was a major band and Yankee Hotel Foxtrot was a major album, but this clue still felt kind of self-indulgent to me. Not everybody knows every song in your favorite band's catalogue. "Jesus ETC." is no "God Only Knows" or "Wouldn't It Be Nice," is what I'm saying (57A: "God Only Knows," vis-à-vis "Wouldn't It Be Nice" => SIDE B). Popular songs used to be in the air. You couldn't avoid hearing them. I was never a Beach Boys *fan* and I was born after their heyday, but I know so many of their songs just because I was breathing air in the '70s and '80s and every decade thereafter, when those songs were on the radio, in movies, ads, etc. Whereas I have never heard a Wilco song in the wild. Pop culture continues to get increasingly ensiloed, so that if you're not actively into something, you can't even see it. There's no real public square, no shared space in which to encounter it. Too many outlets, too many choices, too many places to hide from each other and nurse our identities and fandoms. Algorithms have funneled everyone into valleys, so things that are massively popular in one valley aren't even discernible in another. This is why pop culture answers of all times can feel (increasingly) exclusionary. Now, it's Tuesday, no one's going to dislocate their solving bone wrestling with "Jesus, ETC." But "MR. ROBOT," maybe. I watched the first two seasons of that show and still struggled with the answer at first. Totally forgot it existed / what it was about. I only remember Rami Malek was the star. Had the "-BOT" and thought "whot?" I had a way easier time, pop culture-wise, with RADIO EDIT ... but then "F**k You" ("Forget You") was a legitimate (#2 Billboard) hit. Anyway, this puzzle did nothing wrong in terms of how it handled the pop culture answers, but it reminded me that puzzlemakers have to be Careful with proper nouns, esp. those of a pop cultural variety, if they don't want to lock out solvers from the "wrong" demographics.
Loved the energy in the clue for OKIE DOKIE (11D: Goofy assent that precedes "artichokie") but that's giving away way too much "okie"—but the "artichokie" bit is probably the only way you can justify that alt-spelling of "OKEY DOKEY!" (the industry standard) (11 appearances in the NYTXW, vs. just two now for OKIE DOKIE, both in the last two years ... is this gonna be like "woah" where kids have no idea how to spell but it doesn't matter and eventually the wrong spelling becomes the norm? I want to say "I hope not," but I also don't really care—although "woah" definitely looks idiotic to me 100% of the time). There are no [Choices in a sleepover game]; or, rather, there are, but those choices are Truth or Dare. "Dare" is one choice. It's not Truths or Dares. Forced cluing like this jars my ears in unpleasant ways.
[Warning: this is not the RADIO EDIT]
As for difficulty, there wasn't much, although the ORAL EXAM "?" clue held me up (as it was likely designed to) (55A: In which you might talk through your problems?), as did my lack of German—I can never remember the EINS/EINE distinction, so briefly entertained EINS / SEES before EINE / EYES (56D: A, in German / 66A: Checks out). Had SWEET before SWELL (43D: Peachy keen) and SEINE before MARNE (gotta read the whole clue!, he yelled to his earlier self) (10D: French river where two W.W. I battles took place). But otherwise this went down fast and left no real impression. See you next time.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
P.S. UIES—still terrible (30A: Highway no-nos, for short)
DRIB EHT (41D: Make a rude gesture with one's finger, literally?) (flip THE BIRD)
REVILO (48D: Former N.S.C. staffer at the center of the Iran-Contra affair, literally?) (OLIVER North)(... ugh)
Word of the Day: WERNER Herzog (45D: Film director Herzog) —
Werner Herzog (German:[ˈvɛʁnɐˈhɛʁtsoːk]; né Stipetić; born 5 September 1942) is a German filmmaker, actor, opera director, and author. Regarded as a pioneer of New German Cinema, his films often feature ambitious protagonists with impossible dreams, people with unusual talents in obscure fields, or individuals in conflict with nature. His style involves avoiding storyboards, emphasizing improvisation, and placing his cast and crew into real situations mirroring those in the film they are working on.
French filmmaker François Truffaut once called Herzog "the most important film director alive". American film critic Roger Ebert said that Herzog "has never created a single film that is compromised, shameful, made for pragmatic reasons, or uninteresting. Even his failures are spectacular". He was named one of the world's 100 most influential people by Time in 2009. (wikipedia)
• • •
I was braced for some dumb April Fools trick and well here it is. I think the theme is fine, I guess, but it's a Wednesday-level theme for sure. As a Downs-only solve, this was one of the harder Mondays I've done. You'd think making the theme answers Downs would be a help in a Downs-only solve, but it is not, and it really was not today. When you solve Downs-only, usually you are shooting the (Across) theme answers full of letters until you're able to infer them, and maybe infer the gimmick. But when the themers are Downs, well, you get no help from the Acrosses (obviously), and today, the gimmick was really gimmicky, so not having an assist from crosses really hurt. The theme seems like a reasonable concept. Fine for later in the week, not really appropriate for a Monday, but maybe appropriate for this most annoying of "holidays." The difficulty lay in the fact that every theme answer was "literally" expressing a different form of reversal, so even after I'd gotten the idea (with "BAD MOONRising"), I couldn't figure out what to do with some of the answers. That is, I couldn't figure out what the missing words were that were supposed to signify "Up." Worst of all was FAEL WEN A, which requires the solver to mentally supply a *lot* of words, not just one word like "up" or "rising," but two ("turn over"), and then the answer itself is not one or two but three words—extremely hard to parse when what you're staring at is _A(E?)(L?P?)W_NA. The other themer that gave me real trouble was REVILO, partly because "North" is a pretty weak "reversal" clue, but mostly because I completely blocked that *&$% out of my brain. Clean erased him. Sent him to the oblivion he deserves. A traitorous lying sack of &*$%. And you want to turn him into whimsy? No. Absolutely not. You need a 6-letter "North" answer? Try ATOKAD instead of inflicting that miserable *$%% on unsuspecting solvers.
But I can't say I hated the basic concept here. Again, without that OLIVER guy, and later in the week, and with a few terrible bits of fill eliminated from the grid (OWERS???), this puzzle would've made a fine Wednesday. The most intolerable answer, from the perspective of someone who teaches Dante every semester (that is, me), is DANTEAN (19D: Reminiscent of work by the 14th-century author of "Inferno"). I grimaced so hard my face nearly froze. Well, first, I just had DANT- and no idea how I was supposed to fit DANTESQUE (the correct adjective) into just seven squares. Sincerely, I had DANT- and no idea where that was supposed to go. If I have seen DANTEAN ... I don't know when. I googled it and it seems someone somewhere uses it, but DANTESQUE is more than three times as popular as a search term. DANTEAN is defensible, but it was a huge clank in my ears, for sure. On the other hand, I loved CHANDLER, but only because, solving Downs-only, I supplied my own hardboiled detective fiction context. Then I come to find out that it was clued via "Friends." Sigh. I did enjoy that show, and RIP Matthew Perry (who was very good), but I cannot imagine a circumstance in which I would choose that CHANDLER over Raymond CHANDLER. Luckily, for the entirety of the solve, today's CHANDLER *was* Raymond CHANDLER, since the clue existed only in my mind—yet another perk of Downs-only solving.
I was also happy to see the great WERNER Herzog. Kind of startling that WERNER hasn't appeared in the NYTXW in 12 years (!?!?). All those ultra-common letters in a shortish answer and ... nothing? For that long? Bizarre. Looking the grid over now, it actually seems pretty lively for a Monday grid, theme aside. MINIDONUT is nice, and UNCERTAIN and BELITTLE are at least solid. STOUT MOMMY. TREBEK VISION. ARNOLD NAUSEA. None of this is gonna knock anyone's socks off, but it more than holds up, esp. for a Monday puzzle. I guess I come out more on the pro- than the anti- side today, despite my antipathy for everything April Fools-related. The "trick" was actually very gettable, and mostly enjoyable to work out on a theme answer-by-theme answer basis. Cruddy fill was kept to a minimum. Yes. Approved. Good day.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
P.S. Ew, sorry, totally forgot about TADAS (because it was an Across and I didn't really see it). I said there was very little cruddy fill in this grid, and that remains true, but TADAS is 100% garbage. Plural!? LOL, no, never.
P.P.S. Why is "14th century" even in the DANTEAN clue??? [Reminiscent of work by the author of "Inferno"] makes total sense. What other "author of 'Inferno'" is there? It's Dante's Inferno, not Roald Dahl's Inferno or Dr. Seuss's Inferno or Danielle Steel's Inferno. Take out "14th century" and you get a tighter, less awkward clue while losing nothing in clarity.
A long time ago, I was solving this puzzle and got stuck at an unguessable (to me) crossing: N. C. WYETH crossing NATICK at the "N"—I knew WYETH but forgot his initials, and NATICK ... is a suburb of Boston that I had no hope of knowing. It was clued as someplace the Boston Marathon runs through (???). Anyway, NATICK— the more obscure name in that crossing—became shorthand for an unguessable cross, esp. where the cross involves two proper nouns, neither of which is exceedingly well known. NATICK took hold as crossword slang, and the term can now be both noun ("I had a NATICK in the SW corner...") or verb ("I got NATICKED by 50A / 34D!")