THEME: OSCAR BAIT (59A: Film angling for awards ... or what's depicted three times in this puzzle?) — Best Picture Oscar winners, appearing in circled-square formations shaped like hooks, drop down and snag three different fish, which are lurking in the shaded squares inside longer answers:
Theme answers:
EXIT ROUTE (17A: Part of an evacuation plan) — the TROUT is hooked by PATTON
PSALM ONE (21A: It ends "But the way of the ungodly shall perish") — the SALMON is hooked by RAIN MAN
POP CHART (50A: Hit list) — the CHAR is hooked by BEN-HUR
Word of the Day: Mechanical Turk (31A: Chess-playing Mechanical Turk of 1770, for one = HOAX) —
The Mechanical Turk (German: Schachtürke, lit.'chess Turk'), also known as the Automaton Chess Player or simply the Turk (Hungarian: A Török), was a chess-playing machine first displayed in 1770, which appeared to be able to play a strong game of chess autonomously, but whose pieces were in reality moved via levers and magnets by a chess master hidden in its lower cavity. The machine was toured and exhibited for 84 years as an automaton, and continued giving occasional exhibitions until 1854, when it was destroyed in a fire. In 1857, an article published by the owner's son provided the first full explanation of the mechanism, which had been widely suspected to be a hoax but never accurately described while the machine still existed.
This puzzle won me over with its ridiculousness. The concept here works because the puzzle really commits to the bit, elaborately literalizing a common phrase to the point of extreme silliness. A deconstructed, reconstructed metaphor, with the movie titles "fishing" not for Oscars, but for literal fish. Does it make any sense for Patton to catch a TROUT? No! But who cares. It's the arbitrariness of the fish that makes it truly loopy. So much crossword "wackiness" is lukewarm at best—subdadjoke, barely chuckleworthy. But this one? This one follows the golden wackiness rule, which is Go Big or Go Home. Also, Go Fish! Are there some problems with the theme execution? Yeah, a few. First of all, there's some visual ambiguity—the movies are supposed to be OSCAR BAIT, but they look more like hooks. Maybe they've been threaded onto their hooks so perfectly that they just *look* like hooks. Or maybe those shapes aren't hooks but worms. They look like inverted candy canes to me. But I think you could argue that the circled squares are the hooks and then you "bait" those hooks with movie titles. That's how I'm choosing to see it. I don't love the CHAR answer for a couple of reasons: one, the CHAR is a much much less familiar fish than the other two, but two, and more importantly, the CHAR does not break across the two words in its theme answer. SALMON touches both words in its answer, TROUT touches both words in its answer, but CHAR belongs only to CHART, so POP's just hanging out there doing nothing. The ideal embedded-word scenario has that word involved with every element in its host answer. It's clear Shortz doesn't care about this, given how often this weakness occurs—but I learned from the great constructor/editor Patrick Berry, so I will cling to my belief that this is how embedded words should work! But it's an admittedly minor point, esp. when there's so much entertaining visual chaos going on. I don't love PSALM ONE, written out like that, but as with POP CHART's failure to properly embed CHAR, sometimes you have to do what you have to do to make a worthily wacky theme work out.
The short stuff is kind of a drag today—a real onslaught of repeaters. So many crossword names (OGDEN IHOP RUBE AYN OATES CHER etc.) and then ENTS OSHA ICAN SYNE AETNA LODE, the always ugly SNES. It's a good thing the theme is so shiny and loud, and that the longer non-theme answers are admirably strong. EMBALMER and RAINMAKER really hold down the fort in the NW, and STAY CLOSE and BEN HOGAN do the same in the SE, those "STAY CLOSE!" is not an "admonition" I've heard on tours before (34D: Tour guide's admonition). Anyway, it's more a request or instruction. "Admonition" would be more like "Don't touch that Monet!" Because the instruction was unexpected, if not entirely unfamiliar to me, that SE corner was by far the hardest part of the puzzle for me. I got quadruple stymied heading into that corner. The quadfecta! I blanked on BEN ___, POP ___, "STAY ___," and CRAB ___. My favorite ("favorite") part was that I kept wanting 58A: Seafood dish known as the King of Salads to be CRAB ... SALAD. Should've remembered BEN HOGAN but kept getting interference from his main rival, Crossworld's own Sammy SNEAD. Knowing the theme actually helped me get into that corner (another thing in this theme's favor), as I was able to infer BEN-HUR from BEN and then got the CHART part of POP CHART from there, which got me RIALS, which was wrong (it's RIELS), but it was right enough to get me traction. Outside of that patch, the puzzle seemed quite easy.
[BEN HOGAN not pictured]
Mistakes? Not many. The RIALS/RIELS thing, and then CRUDE for CRASS (1D: Vulgar). Had one of those "malapops" where you want a word that's wrong, but then that word actually appears elsewhere later in the solve. Today, I wanted TADA for VOILA (obviously impossible given the word length, but that's what popped into my head first) (55A: "There it is!"). And then later ... TADA! There's TADA (26A: Revealing statement?). I'd never heard of the Chess-playing Mechanical Turk of 1770 and assumed that that was its (his?) full name. Kind of disappointing to discover it's just called "the Mechanical Turk" and the other bits in the clue are just descriptors. I was like "The Chess-Playing Mechanical Turk of 1770, what a badass name. If that were my name, I'd insist on being called by my full name at all times. I might have to become a pro wrestler with that name. Anyway, HOAX took some crosses, is what I'm saying.
Bullets:
19D: ___ good turn (DO A) — it's funny to me that there are non-Oscar winning movie titles trying to catch the fish as well. D.O.A. is probably the best of them—a classic 1950 film noir in which Edmond O'Brien has to solve his own murder! (dum dum dum!). But there's also the '90s legal drama The RAINMAKER out there trying to catch a fish. And then there's the Jaws ripoff ORCA! Very sad when an ORCA can't catch a fish. Can't believe ORCA lost out to PATTON today. Real upset, fishing-wise.
18A: Former carrier over Mauna Kea (ISLAND AIR) — boo to "former carriers." Luckily, the answer is very inferable with a few crosses. The clue mentions something Hawaiian, so there's your "ISLAND" part, and then ... well yeah, "carrier," there's your AIR part. VOILA! TADA! VOILDA!
5D: Holder of a large bed (OCEAN) — "Holder" is weird, but I guess defensible. I wanted this to be PAPA, as in PAPA Bear, but I think his bed was defined by firmness, not bigness. Wait, do we ever learn which bed belongs to which bear? English professor can't remember plot of Goldilocks and the Three Bears! Shameful.
11A: What am I, chopped liver? (PATÉ) — still laughing at this one. Again, like the theme, so stupid it's genius. I read the clue as if it were in quotation marks so I tried to make the four-letter answer mean something equivalent to "What am I, chopped liver?" Not easy. "I'M ME!" "UH, ME?" "IT ME!" But no, it's literally chopped liver. Better, it's the existential musing of chopped liver. "I'm chopped liver, therefore I am ... PATÉ!" Unlike PATTON, PATÉ won no Oscars because it is a film that does not exist.
13D: Gen Z slang for awesome style (DRIP) — pretty sure it was part of hip-hop vernacular before it was "Gen Z slang" but whatever.
22A: Toys for tots, perhaps (TYPO) — you'd've gotten it quickly if they'd put "toys" and "tots" in quotation marks like they should be, but where's the fun in that?
41A: What "R" might stand for on an envelope (RHODE) — as in "RHODE Island," commonly abbreviated "RI." Too deep for me. I kept wanting ROUTE and then remembering that ROUTE was already in the grid.
38A: Mocking name for failed businesses of the early 2000s (DOT BOMB) — nice to follow up yesterday's tepid (DOT) COM puzzle with this colorful (if dated) zinger.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook and Letterboxd] ============================= ❤️ Support this blog ❤️:
14:37 for me this morning, so for Thursday I think that’s medium…. Got nothing in the NW on the 1st try, so started working in the NE. Got OBEY and EMIR and YET right away…. Took me forever to see OCEAN…. I think the OCEAN is held by a big bed, more than holding the bed…. I thought of the sea “bed” as more the OCEAN floor…. Saw that the circled squares looked hook-ish, but PATTON certainly didn’t seem to spell anything hook-y. Eventually got the EXITROUTE and figured out we were indeed dealing with fish. The puzzle got a bit easier once I figured out some of the basics of the theme. DOTBOMB and BENHOGAN were both WOEs to me (though DOTBOMB was inferable, esp. once I got the final “B” from ABBA), so it took a while for BENHUR to come into view. Interesting to see “CRAB” and “OSCAR” so close…. Just need the asparagus and I’m getting hungry…. Wondering what @REX will think—the hook is not really the bait…. But I like it, it’s all rather complex and mouthwatering!!!! : ) .... On another note, 4th day with no Fs? Is Roo going to have a conniption (as my mom used to say????)... what is the longest streak with no Fs? Thanks, Lance and John, for an interesting puzzle with a complex idea and a terrific revealer!
Medium. I had trouble in the SE. I didn't enjoy the wackiness as much as @Rex did. * * * _ _
Overwrites: scAm before HOAX for the Mechanical Turk at 31D. When you shortchange someone (42D) you DEceIVE them before you DEPRIVE them. My 47D station was a train station and announcement was an Arr[ival] before it was a police station and an APB. bahtS before RIALS for the currency at 53D. ClAm(?) LOUIE before CRAB at 58A.
WOEs: I'm not very good at Gen Z slang. DRIP (13D) was lost on me. Didn't know ISLAND AIR (18A), but I had it filled in before I saw the clue. I knew BEN HOGAN, but not well enough to infer him from the 39D clue. Rotten Tomatoes' SPLAT at 45D. The OGDEN Canyon Waterfall at 61A.
Sometimes during a solve I’ll think “Oh, Rex is gonna hate this” and then I check the site to see nothing but effusive praise. Gahh. One of these days my Rexometer will be calibrated!!
I had two problems with the theme. First, the hook for PATTON is squat and turned the other way from others, so that if you read it left to right you get NOT TAP. A sequel to "Strictly Ballroom," maybe? I never figured it out.
Second, the three fish included are all salmonids, i.e., closely related to each other, so I kept looking for a similarly close connection in the revealer. Chalk that one up to coincidence, I guess; if I had not been trying to guess the revealer, I would not have cared.
I had Hawaii AIR before ISLAND AIR, and CRAB LOUIS before CRAB LOUIE. And I just spent 10 minutes which I will never get back trying to figure out why AETNA is not spelled like Etna; apparently the former is its name in Latin.
As for AETNA's symmetric partner, SHREK, it's weird to have him be in here as a non-theme answer. I realize that Best Animated Feature is not Best Picture, but still, why clutter up your theme? (OTOH I didn't notice the problem Rex points out with CHAR.)
Finally, I still can't decide whether the plural clue for the singular DOT BOMB is OK. I guess it is -- the actual clue is 'mocking name' -- but the "failed businesses" part kept me from putting in the answer.
I really like this one too - the goofy theme hits - it’s well revealed and the overall fill is fantastic. BEN HUR through POP CHART and CRAB LOUIE is classic.
The trivia was in my wheelhouse but I could see some struggling with it. BEN HOGAN, STAY CLOSE, RAINMAKER are all top notch. EMBALMER is dark in the AM - keep DOT BOMB out next time and didn’t love the full letter string of PSALM ONE. Initially had OGDaN x RIaLS.
Hey All ! Neat puz. Gets in yer Circles and Shaded Squares! With only 35 Blockers. And good fill considering the constraints. I mean, look at the NE corner. Needed to get things to work with almost the whole corner being the Theme. Tough!
However, the F drought continues. This is why I started my championing of the F. For a "regular" letter, i.e. not an oft non-used letter, like J, Q, X, Z, it's sparse in these crosswords. As a matter of fact, the missing letters in today's are J, Q Z, and F. Dang.
Nice puz, gents, but where's FLOUNDER? 😁 That'll get yer F.
Lots of unfamiliar stuff for me today. Everything I know about golf I learned from doing the NYTXW and then promptly forgot. I was fully conscious in the early 2000s and never heard DOTBOMB. I do remember Bart Simpson being surprised that “bubbles can burst!”
OGDEN(?) crossing BENHOGAN(?) and RIELS(?) was the death blow for me.
A riddle-fest from start to finish; a capital-P puzzle.
Yes, the obvious riddles to crack. What is the theme? What are the grayed and circled letters for? But then there were also tough areas to fill in, tough clues to crack.
Each riddle solved brought pings of pleasure. “Oh, the grayed letters are fish!” “Oh, the circled letters are hooks!” “Oh, the first word of [Exchanged words] is an adjective!”
All this, and yet, maybe, the highlight was [What am I, chopped liver?] for PATE, where my jaw actually OMG-dropped in elation.
And it was an impressive build. The hooks alone greatly restricted what answers could surround them. Not to mention, those hooks had to catch fish, and film titles had to go in as well. Are you kidding me?
And even with all that, there was answer loveliness – COME ON MAN, CRAB LOUIE, OSCAR BAIT, WHAT NERVE, RAINMAKER. There was pop as well, with eight NYT debut answers, all worthy.
I came to the box, Lance and John, curious and hopeful for a stellar Thursday, something clever and something I had to earn, and you two came through handsomely. I relished this. Thank you!
No shaded squares and only some of the key letters had circles in my version. For example, in PATTON only the P, A, second T and N were circled. This made things a bit harder, and I had to solve as a themeless.
FWIW, I'm OK with former carrier clues. Island Air, TWA, PanAm are part of my happy memories file.
Enjoyed the puzzle a lot, except the SE corner. It was mostly just gibberish proper nouns to me. I couldn't care less about golfers, never heard of the "king of salads", knew that Angkor Wat was in Cambodia but I have no clue what the currency is there...the whole area was pretty much impossible for me to figure out with all of this esoteric nonsense.
The rest of the puzzle was pretty fun though. I liked the theme a lot!
I found this hard, although I got the theme pretty early. But there were many WOEs, including DRIP, OGDEN, and DAMN. I also could not parse PSALMONE. I had the SALMON part but kept wanting something to do with the Song of Solomon. My knowledge of olden golfers begins and ends with Ernie Els, and I have never heard of BENHOGAN.
I also noticed the PATTON hook was going the wrong way, and am surprised Rex didn’t say anything about that. And, I’m not much of a fisherwoman, but I don’t think SALMON and TROUT are used for BAIT. Shouldn’t the fish here be bait fish? Or maybe any fish can be used for bait.
I enjoyed Rex’s write-up today more than the actual solving experience. Fortunately, I discerned the theme in the PATTON / TROUT section.
My nits would be the usual ones about answers or sections that start to look like trivia tests (OGDEN crossing RIELS, for example). I did get CHER crossing HABLA - which is a wheelhouse effect crossing a foreign word that’s actually common usage for a change (I wish that common usage “requirement” were something that Shortz actually enforced, instead of merely paying lip service to).
The clip of Dick Cavett with the pianist was very interesting - I don’t know anything about music, but I could tell from context that those were some next-level concepts he was explaining - a wonderful find by OFL.
Medium, with a somewhat annoying length of time sorting out the SE corner, not having heard of OGDEN Waterfalls Canyon or CRAB LOUIE (the King of Salads? must keep an eye out for that one), and I also got snared on the spelling of the Cambodian money (RIELS). Not *very* annoying, though, since I have to hand it to them, there was some pretty good misdirection with AUDIT ("Fear for a launderer"), so there was some good-natured "aw, you got me" in the mix.
Like Rex, I don't think "admonition" is optimally accurate for STAY CLOSE. I'd call that a direction. When I hear "admonition", I generally see (picture) some finger-wagging going on.
At first the playing field felt a little crowded, with all those grayed and circled squares colliding into each other. It was like "don't distract me! I just want to lay in some answers before I try figuring out the theme". I think it was the revealer that pleased me the most about the theme. For a moment I tried OSCAR fish -- what's that, you might ask? I didn't know either. But that got sorted out quickly and I found OSCAR BAIT not bad, not bad at all.
Not as much of a fan of PATE as Rex, mainly because it brings to mind the practice of gavage (hey there, Sam Ezersky the other day). Aside from that, though, it was interesting misdirection, as you have to go from the idiomatic to the literal ("What am I, chopped liver?"), a move I generally like.
So anyway, not a bad way to spend some time on a grayish Thursday morning. Thanks, Lance and John.
Wavelength issues for me today with lots of ? clues, at least for me. Had the NW mostly filled in, wound up in the SW somehow where I had most of OSCARBAIT, saw SALMON crossing RAINMAN, aha!, and that was helpful in completing the other themers..
Today's problems were DOTBOMB, RAINMAKER (as clued) DRIP (ditto) SNES, and OGCEN, who should be "Poet Nash". Wanted STAYINLINE which didn't fit and was dearly hoping the tag line wouldn't be YOUROUT, I see your/you're misuse enough and was sure the NYT wouldn't allow it, and they didn't.
In the age-has-benefits department I knew both BENHOGAN and CRABLOUIE, so there's that.
Very clever stuff, LE and JK. Loved Everything! Nah, Just Kidding, but a damn nice Thursday. Thanks for all the fun.
@Les S. More and @DAVinHOP from yesterday--I'm in total agreement with you about national anthems being unnecessary before sporting events and would be happy to drink to that. Too many singers make the song about themselves, which just adds to the annoyance.
My one exception is Marvin Gaye's rendition of The Star Spangled Banner before the 1983 NBA all-star game which was an instant classic and a historical event. Available on Youtube, highest recommendation.
Fairly easy for me. I must be on the constructor’s wavelength today. I even surprised myself when I threw in BENHOGAN on just the B without a second thought. I solved it as a themeless but I really enjoyed the theme as I admired the puzzle afterwards. Very, very silly. I agree with Rex: the unabashed wackiness gave the puzzle its special charm.
A long time ago, I was solving this puzzle and got stuck at an unguessable (to me) crossing: N. C. WYETH crossing NATICK at the "N"—I knew WYETH but forgot his initials, and NATICK ... is a suburb of Boston that I had no hope of knowing. It was clued as someplace the Boston Marathon runs through (???). Anyway, NATICK— the more obscure name in that crossing—became shorthand for an unguessable cross, esp. where the cross involves two proper nouns, neither of which is exceedingly well known. NATICK took hold as crossword slang, and the term can now be both noun ("I had a NATICK in the SW corner...") or verb ("I got NATICKED by 50A / 34D!")
19 comments:
14:37 for me this morning, so for Thursday I think that’s medium…. Got nothing in the NW on the 1st try, so started working in the NE. Got OBEY and EMIR and YET right away…. Took me forever to see OCEAN…. I think the OCEAN is held by a big bed, more than holding the bed…. I thought of the sea “bed” as more the OCEAN floor…. Saw that the circled squares looked hook-ish, but PATTON certainly didn’t seem to spell anything hook-y. Eventually got the EXITROUTE and figured out we were indeed dealing with fish. The puzzle got a bit easier once I figured out some of the basics of the theme. DOTBOMB and BENHOGAN were both WOEs to me (though DOTBOMB was inferable, esp. once I got the final “B” from ABBA), so it took a while for BENHUR to come into view. Interesting to see “CRAB” and “OSCAR” so close…. Just need the asparagus and I’m getting hungry…. Wondering what @REX will think—the hook is not really the bait…. But I like it, it’s all rather complex and mouthwatering!!!! : ) .... On another note, 4th day with no Fs? Is Roo going to have a conniption (as my mom used to say????)... what is the longest streak with no Fs?
Thanks, Lance and John, for an interesting puzzle with a complex idea and a terrific revealer!
Medium. I had trouble in the SE. I didn't enjoy the wackiness as much as @Rex did.
* * * _ _
Overwrites:
scAm before HOAX for the Mechanical Turk at 31D.
When you shortchange someone (42D) you DEceIVE them before you DEPRIVE them.
My 47D station was a train station and announcement was an Arr[ival] before it was a police station and an APB.
bahtS before RIALS for the currency at 53D.
ClAm(?) LOUIE before CRAB at 58A.
WOEs:
I'm not very good at Gen Z slang. DRIP (13D) was lost on me.
Didn't know ISLAND AIR (18A), but I had it filled in before I saw the clue.
I knew BEN HOGAN, but not well enough to infer him from the 39D clue.
Rotten Tomatoes' SPLAT at 45D.
The OGDEN Canyon Waterfall at 61A.
Sometimes during a solve I’ll think “Oh, Rex is gonna hate this” and then I check the site to see nothing but effusive praise. Gahh. One of these days my Rexometer will be calibrated!!
I had two problems with the theme. First, the hook for PATTON is squat and turned the other way from others, so that if you read it left to right you get NOT TAP. A sequel to "Strictly Ballroom," maybe? I never figured it out.
Second, the three fish included are all salmonids, i.e., closely related to each other, so I kept looking for a similarly close connection in the revealer. Chalk that one up to coincidence, I guess; if I had not been trying to guess the revealer, I would not have cared.
I had Hawaii AIR before ISLAND AIR, and CRAB LOUIS before CRAB LOUIE. And I just spent 10 minutes which I will never get back trying to figure out why AETNA is not spelled like Etna; apparently the former is its name in Latin.
As for AETNA's symmetric partner, SHREK, it's weird to have him be in here as a non-theme answer. I realize that Best Animated Feature is not Best Picture, but still, why clutter up your theme? (OTOH I didn't notice the problem Rex points out with CHAR.)
Finally, I still can't decide whether the plural clue for the singular DOT BOMB is OK. I guess it is -- the actual clue is 'mocking name' -- but the "failed businesses" part kept me from putting in the answer.
I really like this one too - the goofy theme hits - it’s well revealed and the overall fill is fantastic. BEN HUR through POP CHART and CRAB LOUIE is classic.
OCEAN Avenue
The trivia was in my wheelhouse but I could see some struggling with it. BEN HOGAN, STAY CLOSE, RAINMAKER are all top notch. EMBALMER is dark in the AM - keep DOT BOMB out next time and didn’t love the full letter string of PSALM ONE. Initially had OGDaN x RIaLS.
ISLAND Style
Highly enjoyable Thursday morning solve.
APB
Hey All !
Neat puz. Gets in yer Circles and Shaded Squares! With only 35 Blockers. And good fill considering the constraints. I mean, look at the NE corner. Needed to get things to work with almost the whole corner being the Theme. Tough!
However, the F drought continues. This is why I started my championing of the F. For a "regular" letter, i.e. not an oft non-used letter, like J, Q, X, Z, it's sparse in these crosswords. As a matter of fact, the missing letters in today's are J, Q Z, and F. Dang.
Nice puz, gents, but where's FLOUNDER? 😁 That'll get yer F.
Hope y'all have a great Thursday!
No F's
RooMonster
DarrinV
Lots of unfamiliar stuff for me today. Everything I know about golf I learned from doing the NYTXW and then promptly forgot. I was fully conscious in the early 2000s and never heard DOTBOMB. I do remember Bart Simpson being surprised that “bubbles can burst!”
OGDEN(?) crossing BENHOGAN(?) and RIELS(?) was the death blow for me.
NATICK Alert for BEN HOGAN dropping through CRAB LOUIE and OGDEN, with RIELS mixing it up too. That corner is deadly with proper nouns.
A riddle-fest from start to finish; a capital-P puzzle.
Yes, the obvious riddles to crack. What is the theme? What are the grayed and circled letters for? But then there were also tough areas to fill in, tough clues to crack.
Each riddle solved brought pings of pleasure. “Oh, the grayed letters are fish!” “Oh, the circled letters are hooks!” “Oh, the first word of [Exchanged words] is an adjective!”
All this, and yet, maybe, the highlight was [What am I, chopped liver?] for PATE, where my jaw actually OMG-dropped in elation.
And it was an impressive build. The hooks alone greatly restricted what answers could surround them. Not to mention, those hooks had to catch fish, and film titles had to go in as well. Are you kidding me?
And even with all that, there was answer loveliness – COME ON MAN, CRAB LOUIE, OSCAR BAIT, WHAT NERVE, RAINMAKER. There was pop as well, with eight NYT debut answers, all worthy.
I came to the box, Lance and John, curious and hopeful for a stellar Thursday, something clever and something I had to earn, and you two came through handsomely. I relished this. Thank you!
No shaded squares and only some of the key letters had circles in my version. For example, in PATTON only the P, A, second T and N were circled. This made things a bit harder, and I had to solve as a themeless.
FWIW, I'm OK with former carrier clues. Island Air, TWA, PanAm are part of my happy memories file.
The clue "Hall's former partner" makes me sad.
Enjoyed the puzzle a lot, except the SE corner. It was mostly just gibberish proper nouns to me. I couldn't care less about golfers, never heard of the "king of salads", knew that Angkor Wat was in Cambodia but I have no clue what the currency is there...the whole area was pretty much impossible for me to figure out with all of this esoteric nonsense.
The rest of the puzzle was pretty fun though. I liked the theme a lot!
I found this hard, although I got the theme pretty early. But there were many WOEs, including DRIP, OGDEN, and DAMN. I also could not parse PSALMONE. I had the SALMON part but kept wanting something to do with the Song of Solomon. My knowledge of olden golfers begins and ends with Ernie Els, and I have never heard of BENHOGAN.
I also noticed the PATTON hook was going the wrong way, and am surprised Rex didn’t say anything about that. And, I’m not much of a fisherwoman, but I don’t think SALMON and TROUT are used for BAIT. Shouldn’t the fish here be bait fish? Or maybe any fish can be used for bait.
I enjoyed Rex’s write-up today more than the actual solving experience. Fortunately, I discerned the theme in the PATTON / TROUT section.
My nits would be the usual ones about answers or sections that start to look like trivia tests (OGDEN crossing RIELS, for example). I did get CHER crossing HABLA - which is a wheelhouse effect crossing a foreign word that’s actually common usage for a change (I wish that common usage “requirement” were something that Shortz actually enforced, instead of merely paying lip service to).
The clip of Dick Cavett with the pianist was very interesting - I don’t know anything about music, but I could tell from context that those were some next-level concepts he was explaining - a wonderful find by OFL.
Medium, with a somewhat annoying length of time sorting out the SE corner, not having heard of OGDEN Waterfalls Canyon or CRAB LOUIE (the King of Salads? must keep an eye out for that one), and I also got snared on the spelling of the Cambodian money (RIELS). Not *very* annoying, though, since I have to hand it to them, there was some pretty good misdirection with AUDIT ("Fear for a launderer"), so there was some good-natured "aw, you got me" in the mix.
Like Rex, I don't think "admonition" is optimally accurate for STAY CLOSE. I'd call that a direction. When I hear "admonition", I generally see (picture) some finger-wagging going on.
At first the playing field felt a little crowded, with all those grayed and circled squares colliding into each other. It was like "don't distract me! I just want to lay in some answers before I try figuring out the theme". I think it was the revealer that pleased me the most about the theme. For a moment I tried OSCAR fish -- what's that, you might ask? I didn't know either. But that got sorted out quickly and I found OSCAR BAIT not bad, not bad at all.
Not as much of a fan of PATE as Rex, mainly because it brings to mind the practice of gavage (hey there, Sam Ezersky the other day). Aside from that, though, it was interesting misdirection, as you have to go from the idiomatic to the literal ("What am I, chopped liver?"), a move I generally like.
So anyway, not a bad way to spend some time on a grayish Thursday morning. Thanks, Lance and John.
Wavelength issues for me today with lots of ? clues, at least for me. Had the NW mostly filled in, wound up in the SW somehow where I had most of OSCARBAIT, saw SALMON crossing RAINMAN, aha!, and that was helpful in completing the other themers..
Today's problems were DOTBOMB, RAINMAKER (as clued) DRIP (ditto) SNES, and OGCEN, who should be "Poet Nash". Wanted STAYINLINE which didn't fit and was dearly hoping the tag line wouldn't be YOUROUT, I see your/you're misuse enough and was sure the NYT wouldn't allow it, and they didn't.
In the age-has-benefits department I knew both BENHOGAN and CRABLOUIE, so there's that.
Very clever stuff, LE and JK. Loved Everything! Nah, Just Kidding, but a damn nice Thursday. Thanks for all the fun.
@Les S. More and @DAVinHOP from yesterday--I'm in total agreement with you about national anthems being unnecessary before sporting events and would be happy to drink to that. Too many singers make the song about themselves, which just adds to the annoyance.
My one exception is Marvin Gaye's rendition of The Star Spangled Banner before the 1983 NBA all-star game which was an instant classic and a historical event. Available on Youtube, highest recommendation.
This puzzle caught me, reeled me in and kept me hooked until I finished it. Excellent puzzle.🎈🎈🎊🎊
Geez. Yeah. My comment is just above yours but I forgot about CRABLOUIE! Wtf is CRABLOUIE?
Fairly easy for me. I must be on the constructor’s wavelength today. I even surprised myself when I threw in BENHOGAN on just the B without a second thought.
I solved it as a themeless but I really enjoyed the theme as I admired the puzzle afterwards. Very, very silly. I agree with Rex: the unabashed wackiness gave the puzzle its special charm.
Post a Comment