Division signs, more formally / SUN 1-11-26 / Modern social media craze / Compound that ripens bananas / Bygone carrier that had a fleet of "Clippers" / Two-time capital of the Mughal Empire / Game on some kids' menus / Prank of doorbell ringing and running / Debaters who use deceptive arguments / Identifies digitally? / Mushroom often added to cream sauces / Classical Greek precinct with a noted oracle / Beast domesticated by the Incas
Sunday, January 11, 2026
Constructor: Dylan Schiff
Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium
- PING-[PONG] PADDLE / AMPHIBIA (22A: Article of sports equipment that typically has two rubber sheets of different colors / 2D: Class with frogs)
- CRISS-[CROSS] PUZZLE / DELPHI (32A: Game on some kids' menus / 20D: Classical Greek precinct with a noted oracle)
- DING-[DONG] DITCH / SAPPHIRE (38D: Prank of doorbell ringing and running / 46A: Birthstone before opal)
- TIP-[TOP] SHAPE / SOPHIA (50D: Perfect condition / 56A: Oscar-winning actress Loren)
- TIK-[TOK] DANCE / APHID (41D: Modern social media craze / 51A: Ladybug's prey)
- SING-[SONG] VOICE / SOPHISTS (43D: Melodic way of speaking / 53A: Debaters who use deceptive arguments)
- FLIP-[FLOP] SANDALS / PHILBIN (97A: Beachy footwear / 99D: Longtime TV personality Regis)
- HIP-[HOP] ARTISTS / DOLPHIN (111A: Tupac and Eminem, for two / 92D: Intelligent sea mammal)
An obelus (plural: obeluses or obeli) is a historical annotation mark in codicology that has come to have three distinct modern forms, meanings and typographical uses:
- Division sign ÷
- Dagger †
- Commercial minus sign ⁒ (limited geographical area of use)
The word "obelus" comes from ὀβελός (obelós), the Ancient Greek word for a sharpened stick, spit, or pointed pillar. This is the same root as that of the word 'obelisk'. In codicology, a (usually horizontal) obelus in the form of a dagger was used to indicate erroneous or dubious content. The third symbol is an obsolescent mark used in some European countries
In mathematics, the ÷ symbol is mainly used in Anglophone countries to represent the mathematical operation of division (but has other meanings elsewhere) and is called an obelus in older textbooks. In modern typography, the second symbol, called a dagger mark † is used as a reference mark or footnote indicator. It also has other uses in a variety of specialist contexts. (wikipedia)
The first of the thank-you cards are already in the mail (they arrived from the printer earlier this week looking perfect):
![]() |
| [illustration by Katie Kosma] |
Do you think this puzzle needed a revealer? It struck me as completely anticlimactic and unnecessary, but I guess it does go some ways toward explaining the theme concept, which might have been unclear. Or maybe people found the revealer first and the clue helped them decipher the theme concept. I don't know. All I know is I'd been writing "PHI" into squares over and over and then got to a revealer that had nothing to say to me but "PHI"! Yeah, PHI, I know, PHI, I've been writing PHI, I see the big PHI symbol depicted in the grid, stop saying "PHI!" Is it PHI Day? Oh, wait ... is PHI a secret wink to crossword tournament-goers, a subtle celebration of the fact that the American Crossword Tournament (ACPT) is moving to PHI-ladelphia in 2027? Tragically, my wife and I did not register for this year's tournament right away and registration is already closed (!?). Guess we won't get to defend our Pairs title. Oh well, we'll just have to wait for 2027, when we can be the first PHI-ladelphia champions.
Bullets:
- 16A: Bygone carrier that had a fleet of "Clippers" (PAN AM) — these were apparently flying boats (!?). Did regular passengers actually fly on these? Looks like, yes, they were some sort of luxury option (??).
The Boeing 314 Clipper was an American long-range flying boat produced by Boeing from 1938 to 1941. One of the largest aircraft of its time, it had the range to cross the Atlantic and Pacific oceans. For its wing, Boeing re-used the design from the earlier XB-15 bomber prototype. Twelve Clippers were built, nine of which served with Pan Am. It was the first aircraft to carry a sitting American president, when in 1943 Franklin D. Roosevelt flew from Miami to the Casablanca Conference in Morocco, via Trinidad, Brazil, and The Gambia. (wikipedia)
- 53A: Debaters who use deceptive arguments (SOPHISTS) — one of the things that made the grid interesting today was all the "PHI"-containing words. SOPHISTS and SAPPHIREs and DOLPHINs etc. The "I"/"O" answers are flashier, of course, but I'm surprised how solid and (relatively) colorful all the "PHI" words are.
- 70A: Two-time capital of the Mughal Empire (DELHI) — my brain short-circuited here and instead of selecting a "Mughal"-appropriate place, it just started cycling in familiar five-letter cities. My first thought was CAIRO (!?). I think I also considered DUBAI at one point. Bizarre.
- 91A: Bit of entertainment for a morning commute, maybe (PODCAST) — true enough, I suppose, but this was a little hard for me, as I don't have a much of a "morning commute," don't usually listen to PODCASTs in the mornings, and don't really think of PODCASTs as "entertainment." Of course they are, but my brain has categorized them as "informational" more than "entertaining."
- 13D: Mushroom often added to cream sauces (MOREL) — crossword mushroom protip: it's MOREL or ENOKI. If you've got a five-letter mushroom on your hands, it's a MOREL or an ENOKI. And since "cream sauces" seem more French than Japanese ... MOREL.
- 103A: "I'm fine, but thanks anyway!" ("OH, THAT'S OK!") — really stretching the "OH" limits here. Are we just adding "OH" to the beginning of any expression? OH HI, OH YES, OH SURE, OH GIVE ME A BREAK, OH YOU MUST BE KIDDING, where does it end!? I'm not actually that mad at this answer, since I can definitely hear someone (me?) saying this phrase. I just want to raise "OH" proliferation as a matter of potential public concern. I'm raising awareness here. Let's all just keep an eye on it.
[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️:
✏️ Upcoming Crossword Tournaments ✏️
- American Crossword Puzzle Tournament (Stamford, CT, Apr. 10-12, 2026) (registration closed!)
📘 My other blog 📘:
- Pop Sensation (vintage paperbacks)





















48 comments:
In the healthcare industry, "PHI" is Protected Health Information, which must not be exposed or shared, lest one risk a HIPAA violation. To say this puzzle is "full of PHI" would terrify any compliance officer!
Easy enough, but for an inexcusably long time I didn't get that [PHI] = PHI one way and I-and-O the other.
* * * _ _
Overwrites:
Not familiar with any Flo Rida titles. Tried @Rex I tRY before CRY at 77A
Also @Rex EThaNE before ETHENE at 84A until the E became inevitable.
Last time I bought china it was in A SET, not AS A SET (94D)
WOEs:
OBELI at 26A.
Didn't remember Nora DUNN of SNL (38A).
Never heard of the "Rainbow" prelude and therefore didn't know CHOPIN at 93D.
The short adventure tales CONTES at 95D.
FIE on this puzzle. Or should I say PHI on it. It actually wasn't bad, although I didn't realize until much after finishing it that a phi was shaped like an I over an O. And that explains the I/O pairs.
Did this last night, 36 minutes but I was watching football (Go Bears, great game!). I guess I think it was medium. Nice that the app accepted EITHER Rebus-- "IO" or "PHI". I thought having both SOPHIA and SOPHISTS in the grid was a bit dupey, since they both come from the same root. But yes, I agree with Rex, the commitment to the theme was impressive, and there really was not much junky fill. CONTES was a complete WOE--thought I must must have had some mistake there, but it was the only option to fit the crosses so I left it and -- tada -- got the happy music. Since OBELI was a word I had no idea of knowing, and AMPHIBIA wanted to be either ANATOMY or APBIO or something at first, I actually finished back up in that NW corner. I think I finally really got the gimmick on the DOLPHIN/HIPHOPARTISTS cross, so it took me a while to really get it. And it was confusing to have the REBUS magic working both ways--sometimes the PHI was across, sometimes up/down. Didn't realize til I got here how that was organized--the across PHIs all lining up across the center of the grid like that. Enjoyed having to find the Rebus squares as always-much better than circling them or making them exactly symmetric. Thanks for a great puzzle, Dylan!!!
Well I guess that’s what being a constructor does for you…the solve was the usual Sunday slog, fortunately know my Greek letters so not hard to get the key (like phi beta kappa?)… but completely missed the giant PHI staring at me from the middle of the grid. Impressive.
I, for one, needed the revealer. I could see all the elements but I would have needed to come here for the explanation (mostly cause I didn’t know what phi looked like) and I liked that I got to it right at the end. It was a little pain rebusing in all the phis to finish but I enjoyed the puzzle more than Rex.
I like that the puzzle started even before filling in the first letter – wondering what picture those black squares were making.
I’m uber-impressed that those theme answers in which the phi represents I/O, are symmetrical.
I’m also impressed with how the two islands in the middle (the phi halves) are filled and clued, showcasing the art of puzzle-making. If it’s too hard you’re stuck forever; if too easy, it’s boring mindless fill-in. I think they nailed it.
Finally, I’m impressed with the tightness of the I/O phrases (such as FLIP FLOP and SING SONG). There are not too many in our language aside from those in the box today.
The solve incorporated the fun of finding the Φ’s with the delight of seeing the two answers each engendered. All on top of the normal riddle-cracking pleasure of filling in the boxes.
I came into the box neutral and left it feeling the buzz of a rich experience. Bravo and thank you, Dylan!
When I see INIGO (115A), all I can see is a statement made when opening a door.
I really enjoyed this puzzle, but... I missed SOPHISTS! I have SOISTS crossing with SINGVOICE, thinking that the obnoxious debaters would say "SO? SO?? SO???" to whatever you threw at them. LOL.
(I also knew ladybugs do not eat ants but had ANT in there for a while, which flummoxed me.)
The NE corner was the last outpost for me. When I think of kids and CRISSCROSS, "criss-cross apple sauce" kept coming to mind and just stuck there, a sort of "puzzler's block." Ragdolls PURR? And I stared at PERSE forever, once this area was completed, wondering if this is a new term for "personal" as in, "if it's inherent, maybe it's personal." Didn't think of PER SE for the longest time, SHEESH.
I think the big guy summarizes it pretty thoroughly. The chops here are evident - building this multi-layered rebus is an accomplishment. The trick is sophisticated and clear enough - there’s just too much of it - the magnitude overwhelms it. I don’t mind the revealer although it is kind of second nature by the time you get to it.
SAPPHIRE Bullets of Pure Love
Got the full trick early with the AMPHIBIA x PING PONG PADDLE pair. Overall fill was obviously highly restricted by the graphics. The short stuff inside the center suffered the most. Some decent non-theme longs - HADRIAN, ALIENATE, ESTRANGE etc are all neat. What - no call for ERNESTO to be kept out? - @Gill would like a word.
Meat Puppets
There is good fill here - nothing really taxing but just splashy enough to keep your interest. RIP OFF, FINERY, TEASON, LLAMA - good stuff. Nothing unknown anywhere in the grid.
Silicone on SAPPHIRE
Enjoyable enough Sunday morning solve. It was a lot to deal with and did grind to a slog eventually but the build quality is impressive.
Siouxsie
Ethene is a shortcut for ETHYLENE, H2C=CH2, a known plant growth regulator which hastens ripening.
I think if the phrase as “pish posh” so I automatically put a PHI at 83D without realizing it wouldn’t work in the other direction.
Once upon a time, your grandmother's china as-a-set was a real asset. Now you can't even give them away.
Figured out part of the gimmick early but didn't fully understand until the revealer which was a nice moment of discovery... only at the end realizing it had been stari me in the face the whole time in the grid layout.
28 minutes on a cell phone which is very good for a Sunday for me.
This must have been an absolute bear to construct, so a tip of the hat to Dylan Schiff. It’s nice that the clues were reasonable enough to allow us to deal with the trouble spots (e.g. AMPHIBIA, OBERLI, HADRIAN . . .) and get a toehold as well.
It did get a little monotonous after a while, but that just may be me having a short attention span.
It’s interesting how much things have changed just in my lifetime. I’ve never been on Tik Tok, and I couldn’t name a Tupac or Eminem song if my life depended on it. I don’t expect either of those to change anytime soon, but it is nice to at least be kept aware of what is going on in the world and be entertained at the same time via crosswords. It makes reading the news or listening to a PODCAST to be less of a chore/necessity.
Hey All !
Was wondering why the grid Blockers were pattern-like before starting the puz, now I see it's to represent the PHI symbol. 83 Blockers, not bad to be able to get a huge PHI in, with 78 being normal max.
Put the PHI Rebus into each square, puz turned them into the actual symbol upon completion. Neat.
What is a ragdoll PURR? Hopefully it's not something I know, and the ole brain refusing to help me with!
Had TOASTER down to _O_STER, and naturally wanted to put in ROOSTER! They do pop up (and cock-a-doodle-doo) from time to time (about once every 8 seconds!)
Nice fill, had to Goog to get HADRIAN. Ah, me. Having P(IO)NGhAnDLE in wasn't helping. Also, OBELa for OBELI, getting my 23D Imagine to be whatever a HACTURE is.
Puz had me ABUZZ. Nice different type Rebus, ID SAY.
Have a great Sunday!
Six F's - Five being up top, Four in the NW!
RooMonster
DarrinV
Solved it in the magazine for a change, so I didn't know I'd missed on the CONTES/CRANE cross (had COTTES/CRATE). Got everything else. Saw the ""PHI" rebus trick quickly, but only got the "I-O" part from TIPTOPSHAPE near the end. My compliments to Mr. Schiff for a neat construction effort.
Pan Am flew CLIPPERS, not just the actual Boeing 314 CLIPPER flying boats, but they called later aircraft CLIPPERS also. Sort of a trademark, like how Eastern Airlines called its aircraft 'Whisperjets' (or Whisperliner in case of the L1011) even though they were loud AF, and American Airlines called its planes 'Astrojets'.
Saw the giant phi right off the bat. I never got the I/O bit. Finished the puzzle and wondered why one direction just used the i (from phi) and why the answers seemed a bit truncated. PING PADDLE, HIP ARTIST, etc. Oh well, got the music.
I wish I could share Rex’s enthusiasm for this one. First of all, rebuses on a Sunday—ugh. Second, this had the typical problem of grid art: the huge PHI created those two central hard-to-access chunks and lots of short fill. The result was a choppy solving experience. And the point of it all, I’m guessing, was lost on those of us who know that PHI is a Greek letter but don’t know what it looks like.
I found myself slogging through this one and thinking, “I’ve got to get through this so I can read what Rex has to say today.” Then I realized that I didn’t have to finish it, I could just go straight to the blog and enjoy his insights and those of my fellow commenters. So I bailed, with no regrets. Some puzzles I can skip, but Rex (and all of y’all)? Never.
Ha. Very true
Loved the i/o phrases; apparently there are so many in that order (tick tock, not tock tick) because of “ablaut reduplication.” Thank you to the excellent Merriam Webster social media team for teaching that a while back. Impressively constructed puzzle.
Not very hard, as Rex said. I did see that giant Φ in the grid, waving its arms wildly at me (metaphorically, obviously; I don't actually see arms), around the time I figured out what was going on thematically and what I had to do. I dislike rebuses generally and find them fussy to deal with, and they slow things down, so I'm going to factor that in when I'D SAY this is a Medium, based on my time.
Today I learned OBELI and CONTES (as clued).
One weirdness, in my opinion, was PISH, when the expression that I recognize is PISH posh, which would seem to necessitate another Φ, which I duly tried, but the corresponding across was nonsensical. So, OK, have it your way. PISH it shall be. And at this point, I'm gonna try to head off at the pass an opportunity that may TEMPT a certain commenter, whereby he counsels us to look this up in the dictionary, and with an accompanying tedious explanation. (I do frequently consult dictionaries, thanks, and may even do so now!)
Love the Raindrop prelude. I've occasionally tried to PICTURE what it might be like being a student of CHOPIN, and the thought is a little scary, imagining him setting forth yet another daunting Etude of his to work on. "Scary" is perhaps a funny word to apply to someone that I imagine as being so delicate and refined in sensibility, and sickly in a Romantic artist sort of way, suffering from consumption or some such. (Perhaps that's largely in the popular imagination, but that's the way he's portrayed in the movie Impromptu -- good title! -- and he did in fact suffer from tuberculosis and and other health problems, thus contributing to this almost stereotypical image.) Still, "scary" is the word that comes to my mind.
Anyhow, I mostly liked this puzzle. Hope all of you reading this have a good day.
One thing for sure about LLAMAs, they don't need MORELs.
I've heard that inhaling ETHENE can give you ABUZZ.
Barack: SOMALIA, IDSAY SKIP the FACES. We just asked you to give your hair AWASH.
Malia: What if ICRY?
Michelle: We'll just get STRICTER.
PANAM used to be so ubiquitous that it was even used as a verb. You could, for instance, PANAM to Europe. Or PANAM a canal.
I forgot that Cameron's last name was DIAZ. At first I HADRIAN.
Nice ANGLE on this theme. Thanks, Dylan Schiff.
I always come here on Sundays first. Taking a look at today's puzzle, encompassing a REBUS 😳 theme, don't know when (or IF) I'll be back.
But I did want to say that I really enjoyed your review & personal comment today, Rex. Thank you for sharing. We're all grateful that you continue with your daily routine here at 3:45 am to do your review, share your thoughts, enlighten all of us, & that you brush your teeth :)
Ethene? Even the spell check didn’t know the word. Ethylene gas is used to ripen fruit.
Rex, so you and your wife won the annual tournament, and you didn't get an automatic invite to the next year's tournament?
When I see IGLOO I see a lavatory for an Inspector General.
HIΦPHOORAY for a most lovely theme!
Really admire the hard work and creativity behind this puzzle—the Greek theme, the choice of clues and answers that are very light on crosswordese and the physical design. Start was tough for me not knowing OBELI and completely missing AMPHIBIA. And at the end, the cross of ROW and NEW was frustrating because I never use the NEW heading to sort my email—I have my mail sorted by date
I give the concept and construction an A+ but the cluing gets a C. A bit too much straight cluing. Would have preferred a few more clever head fakes.
Ragdolls are a type of cat.
Flew through this with nary a bump until the very end, and even that bump didn't last too long. Knew something was going on with the I/O thing quickly (originally thought those two letters were the rebus), and the puzzle name gave away the Greek thing, but had no idea what a "PHI" looks like.
Also knew that some names didn't fit, like SOPHIA and PHILBIN but it took me a minute to get the connection. After that it was smooth sailing, except no happy music when done. Had never heard of CONTES, so thought something was off there. Eventually discovered that I had CHOPoN (I thought it was spelled INoGO). Quick fix and voila. Really clever puzzle, if too easy. 24:56
I liked the revealer because, for those of us that do the puzzles on our phones, there can often be trouble with multiple-rebus puzzles in arriving at which rebus entry will be accepted. PHI? IO? I/O?
So to me the revealer seemed to be saying “I/O will work.”
(Although as it turned out, PHI worked as well.)
Better than usual Sunday!
Ragdolls are a cat breed. =^..^=
Far from being "melodic," I find SING SONG speaking to be utterly annoying, much like "uptalk" in which the speaker says everything as if it ends in a question.
I didn’t like “flip flop sandals” - I’ve never heard these (or called these) anything other than just “flip flops”.
Hi, @Roo. A ragdoll is a breed of cat. If you saw the movie Meet The Parents, the first one, then you've seen a ragdoll; this one was named Jinxy, if my memory is correct.
You may have never heard of the Raindrop Prelude, but there's a good chance you've heard it. It's beautiful.
"Ragdoll" is a breed of cat, which likes to be carried, and which goes mostly limp while being carried. My neighbor's 5-year-old daughter has a ragdoll, which is perpetually slung over her shoulder, and purrs loudly the whole time.
That was a hell of a game, wasn't it? "Da Bears."
A ragdoll is a certain breed of cat.
Ragdoll is a breed of cat, which I only know because sometimes I read the classifieds in a print edition of a local newspaper, curious about who actually pays to run a classified ad these days. Just yesterday, I saw one from a (probably unscrupulous) breeder selling ragdoll cats.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ragdoll
A breath of fresh air after a so-so Saturday. Cleverly conceived and constructed and, given the constraints imposed by the architecture, comparatively little crosswordese. I also appreciated being reminded of CONTES, which had migrated through disuse to the dustiest corners of my brain. 4.5 stars from me.
I bet you'll recall, from this point on, at least one Eminem song, STAN, since you've already seen that as an answer in the NYTXW around a thousand times (but without realizing it was the song title, perhaps).
ASASET? Looks like EATASANDWICH to me.
I suppose the only way I needed the revealer (which I did) was to make the I/O pairs make sense. I saw the giant PHI, and started figuring out the PHI rebuses, so it took me a little to pick up the I/O in the other direction. When I did, I wondered “okay but why???” until I saw the revealer. Never thought of the PHI that way. So the revealer did in fact reveal and gave me an aha moment.
One interesting thing about this puzzle is that you can win without uncovering all of the PHI/IOs. So only after the fact do I realize that it is not in fact a CROSS PUZZLE (I hit that one early before I had discovered the rebus, so I was thinking that maybe people abbreviated “cross word” accordingly), and apparently Ancient Greece also had an oracle at a place named DELO. So while I did in fact finish, my puzzle leaves evidence that I didn’t get all of them, and I kinda like that.
This one didn’t do too much for me. Got the theme early at the crossing of 2D and 22A. Had to be AMPHIBIA. Had to be PING PONG PADDLE. Then I just had to work out why PING PONG? Oh, yeah, because the capital version of the rebused PHI is visually a combined I and O (just in case you didn’t get that from the “grid art”). The lower case version is a bit different, but we work in all caps here in Crossword, so why not Greek caps? Anyway, once you’ve got one, you’ve got ‘em all and you just have to figure out where they go. Fortunately, the placement seems to be symmetrical.
Probably a bear to construct but that’s not my problem; I’m the solver. I wasn’t too excited by most of the fill, but it wasn’t terrible. OH, THAT’S OK. Just OK.
Oh, by the way, No Shave November (79A STACHE) was a new one on me. We have a movement here in Canada (begun in Australia in about 2007) called Movember where we get folks to fund our moustache growing efforts in aid of men’s health initiatives. For a number of years I was a group leader, squeezing somewhere between $1500 and $2000 out of my friends annually. At some point I got buried in other responsibilities and had to pass the reins to one of those friends. He hasn’t emailed me for a contribution for a few years now so I might just have to start up a new group next fall. It’s a good cause and it’s fun.
Post a Comment