Gaming mogul Gabe / SUN 12-14-25 / Shylock's security / Jedi-in-training / Ren faire prop akin to a halberd / Early track star Jim / Marvel superhero who can manipulate weather patterns / 1980 horror film starring William Hurt / Nickname for Mark's unsevered best friend in "Severance" / Parts of many robots in robot-sumo / Hair-care item associated with Black culture / Sci-fi sequel of 1986

Sunday, December 14, 2025

Constructor: Zachary Edward-Brown and John Kugelman

Relative difficulty: Medium


THEME: "Change Locations" — theme answers contain shaded squares that spell out the names of states, except for one circled square in each state name that is just ... wrong. Those "wrong" letters spell out "MISPLACED," and the whole theme is tied together by the revealer, ALTERED STATES (110A: 1980 horror film starring William Hurt ... or what the shaded squares contain?):

Theme answers:
  • "OOH, I'M SO SCARED" (21A: False alarm announcement?)
  • DENVER MINT (34A: Major coin producer)
  • MARS LANDER (37A: Viking I or II)
  • FLIP A HOUSE (47A: Remodel and resell some real estate)
  • DRULINES (49A: Marching band tempo setters)
  • "WHAT A HOOT!" (74A: "Hilarious!")
  • "NOT EXACTLY ..." (77A: "I mean, kind of ...")
  • "I OWE YOU ONE" (90A: "Much obliged")
  • GAINED A DAY (92A: Crossed the International Date Line from east to west, or west to east (depending on how you look at it))
Word of the Day: Gabe NEWELL (51D: Gaming mogul Gabe) —

Gabe Logan Newell (born November 3, 1962), also known by his nickname GabeN, is an American video game developer and businessman. He is the co-founder, president and majority owner of the video game company Valve Corporation.

Newell was born in Colorado and grew up in Davis, California. He attended Harvard University in the early 1980s but dropped out to join Microsoft, where he helped create the first versions of the Windows operating system. In 1996, he and Mike Harrington left Microsoft to found Valve and fund the development of their first game, Half-Life (1998). Harrington sold his stake in Valve to Newell and left in 2000. Newell led the development of Valve's digital distribution service, Steam, which launched in 2003 and controlled most of the market for downloaded PC games by 2011.

As of 2021, Newell owned at least one quarter of Valve; Forbes estimated that he owned at least half as of 2025. He is also the owner of the marine research organization Inkfish, the neuroscience company Starfish Neuroscience, and the custom yacht manufacturer Oceanco. Newell has been estimated as one of the wealthiest people in the United States and the wealthiest person in the video games industry, with an estimated net worth of $11 billion as of 2025. (wikipedia)

• • •
I guess locations are changed and states are altered, but why? For MISPLACED? But ... nothing is "misplaced." Misspelled, yes, but misplaced? Long, long way to go for an inapt spelled-out word. I enjoyed very little of this puzzle. The SW corner, the SICKBAY / POLEAXE / "I WANT IN" triad—that I liked. But otherwise the solving experience was largely unpleasant, due primarily to the extremely choppy grid. This thing is bullet-ridden with black squares, especially all through the middle. So most of the time I felt like I was hacking my way through short answer after short answer after short answer. And when you add to all those black squares all the shaded squares, and then the circled squares on top of that, the whole thing is a visual mess. It was fussy to navigate, and, stacked as it is with short stuff, there were very few highlights. 


Some of the themers were great as standalone answers ("OOH, I'M SO SCARED!" Nice), but not one, not two, but three (!!!!!?) of them are ___ A ___ phrases. It's an EAT A SANDWICH extravaganza. FLIP A HOUSE, WHAT A HOOT!, GAINED A DAY, ugh. Actually, I'll let "WHAT A HOOT!" slide, since that's a coherent phrase. But still ... there just wasn't a ton to like. RFID? Somebody named ELISHA (sorry, not up on my Bell rivals / 19c. engineers) (42D: Engineer Gray who, arguably, invented the telephone — and battled Alexander Graham Bell over it in court for years). Somebody named NEWELL (who's clearly a big deal in his field, but to me ... ???). More Star Wars baloney (PADAWAN) (23A: Jedi-in-training). It really is tiresome how frequently the crossword goes to the Star Wars universe for answers. I've mostly heard of the answers—I literally have a Star Wars (1977) poster on my living room wall—but even I'm exhausted. You can give me OREOs and EELs all day long, but please put the brakes on Star Wars ffs. If you wanted to dial back Marvel (STORM) and Game of Thrones, that would also be OK with me! I knew STORM; I did not know AIDAN. But my knowing / not knowing isn't the point. It's the unimaginative return to the same wells over and over and over ... that's the point. I like the pivot to Severance, but even there, yeesh, PETEY!?!?! (40A: Nickname for Mark's unsevered best friend in "Severance"). That's a deep cut even for people (like me) who have seen every episode of that show. If you had to list the most important characters on Severance, PETEY wouldn't even make the top ten. I remember when the puzzle would ask me to know, like, the fourth most important character on Ally McBeal and that would make me mad. I wouldn't mind a little marginal pop culture now and then, but in a puzzle that's already drenched in pop culture ... I don't love it. 

[The one and only ... makeup by Max Factor (seriously!)]

There's some wood I've never heard of (IRON WOOD??) and then GOAL NET? (43A: Football blocker?). At first I thought they meant "football" as in soccer, and the GOAL NET was just the ... net. The net in the goal. But now I think it's actually American Football that's being referred to here, and the GOAL NET is the thing that gets hoisted behind the goal posts to keep the football from, like, hitting the spectators or something? As you can see, I was desperate for anything to like today. I like ALTERED STATES! (the movie). That's something. But conceptually, I didn't think this worked well, and the grid and fill, no, they also didn't work for me.


I pretty much mentally noped out right away with this ... let's say, creative ... demonym:


I've had to suffer through UTAHN and UTAHAN and god knows how many other odd demonyms, but OAHUAN feels outerspaceian. PADAWAN looks like a more plausible demonym than OAHUAN. Is MAUIAN a thing? MAUWEGIAN? Needless to say, OAHUAN is a debut. My apologies to all the proud OAHUANs out there, but do you really call yourselves that? At least the puzzle spelled DURAG correctly today (87D: Hair-care item associated with Black culture). That's progress, of a sort. Twenty-two DORAG appearances before someone caught on that that's not how it's most commonly spelled or marketed (though the earliest dictionary defs do spell it DO-RAG). I expect DORAG will reappear some day, but for now, since 2020, it's DURAG (though this is only DURAG's second appearance, I'm surprised to find out).


Bullets:
  • 4D: Touchless payment tech (RFID) — so ugly. By now, it's recognizable to me, but it's still ugly as hell, as abbrevs. go. And alongside OAHUAN, hoo boy.
  • 39A: Astronaut Ochoa, the first Hispanic woman in space (ELLEN — well there's a famous golfer named LORENA Ochoa, and somehow, between her and this astronaut Ochoa, my brain has managed to convince itself that all Ochoas are ELENAs. Really really thought ELENA Ochoa was right. It just sounds so right. But it's a mash-up of two different Ochoas. Perhaps by saying all this out loud, I will be able to disentangle the Ochoa Knot.
  • 8D: Video game character with an endless appetite (PAC-MAN) — I guess he does just keep "eating" those dots or whatever, and yet I've never thought of him as being particularly hungry. Evading the damn ghosts and navigating the maze, that's what PAC-MAN does. Also, he's yellow, circular, has no legs, his girlfriend and son both have their own video games, etc. ... so many things I associate with PAC-MAN before "endless appetite." Wait, are PAC-MAN and Ms. PAC-MAN married? LOL, wikipedia just gave me the funniest sentence it's ever given me: "She was originally called Miss Pac-Man, though this was changed to avoid implying that she had her son out of wedlock."
  • 32D: Word used 10 times in Roger Ebert's review of "North" (1994) ("HATED") — that's what's known as a callback (to this puzzle, which came out on my birthday)
  • 78D: He had a Billboard Hot 100 hit with "Rubber Duckie" (ERNIE) — musically, Sesame Street was on point. Stevie Wonder's Sesame Street rendition of "Superstition" (the greatest song ever recorded) is rightly legendary. And just yesterday I was listening to a '70s playlist and I heard this Pointer Sisters tune that I swear I haven't heard since I was five. Absolute banger. 

And let's just play the Stevie while we're at it. If these videos don't brighten up your day, I can't help you, man.

  • 85D: Ren faire prop akin to a halberd (POLEAXE) — it was hilarious (to me) how fast my 1980s-D&D-playing ass plunked down POLEAXE here. Like, off the "P," and I'm not sure I even needed it. I don't know what D&D is like now, but at age 12 I can tell you I had an outsized medieval weaponry vocabulary. The fact that I know what a "halberd" is in the first place, I owe to hours and hours spent with weapons lists. 
  • 93D: Interview guest whom Ali G calls "my man Buzz Lightyear here" (ALDRIN) — I don't think I've ever actually watched a full ... episode? ... of Ali G's show. I know ALI G mainly from crosswords. I know ALDRIN primarily for uttering the immortal lines: "Careful! They're ruffled!"


Time once again for πŸŒ²πŸˆHoliday Pet PicsπŸ•πŸŒ². But first, please—I'm gonna put this in ALL CAPS today because yesterday's lowercase plea didn't seem to work: I CAN'T ACCEPT ANY MORE PET PICS THIS YEAR. I'm so happy to have so many great pics, but there just aren't enough days in the holiday season ...

Alright, let's see who we've got today. Here's Felicity, who is very sweet but no you may not have her candy cane pillow get your own.
[Thanks, Jordan!]

Maddie is a young Havanese. It doesn't snow in Havana, so naturally, for Ohio winters, she needs a little coat.
[thanks, Isaac!]

Musical interlude now—hit it, Urbie!
["O holy night, / The stars are brightly shiiiiiiiiiiining / It's is the night / When you give / Urbie treeeeeats!"]
[Thanks, Angela!]

Mel here has Resting Mean Face (RMF), but I'm assured she is a sweet and happy little cat who loves Christmas. Same, Mel. Same.
[Thanks, Jenny]

This is Malcolm. Malcolm likes carpets. Malcolm is a carpet. Malcolm has killed the traditional Christmas badger-raccoon-squirrel, so the holidays have officially begun!
[Thanks, Steve!]

And lastly ... whoa! Haven't seen one of these before. What kind of dog is this!?!?
[This is Atherton the Barn Princess, and I'm told that she's a "horse"]
[Thanks, Pat & Emma]

That's all. See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

P.S. Peter Gordon's Fireball Newsflash Crosswords is gearing up for another year. You get one puzzle every 2-3 weeks, delivered straight to your Inbox. Puzzles are true to their name—geared toward the headlines. They are a great way to keep up with names and events in the news—very topical. I'd say they are roughly Wednesday level in difficulty. Very doable, but with a lot of bite to make them interesting. Peter is an established constructor and editor, one of the best in the business. These puzzles are highly recommended. Subscribe here, now!  

[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️: 
  • Venmo (@MichaelDavidSharp)]
=============================
✏️ Upcoming Crossword Tournaments ✏️
=============================
πŸ“˜ My other blog πŸ“˜:

120 comments:

Conrad 6:14 AM  


Easy-Medium, with one trouble spot: I had REmINDS at 14D and was confident enough that I didn't notice (or care) that it didn't exactly fit the clue. And I'm not very familiar with the Star Wars saga so PADAmAN looked perfectly good at 23A (REWINDS/PADAWAN).

* _ _ _ _ (a slog for me due to all the pop culture references)

Other Overwrites:
"I WANT to" before IN at 86D
OTRo before OTRA at 104D (not a big deal; I always bear in mind that foreign words can end in o or A).

WOEs:
GoT actor AIDAN Gillen (29A)
"Severance" nickname PETEY at 40A
Engineer ELISHA Gray at 42D
Gaming guy Gabe NEWELL at 51D
Lumber type IRONWOOD (63D)
Beat poet NEAL Cassady (83A)

Jack 6:25 AM  

Been doing NYTimes puzzles for several decades. While there have been occasional Sunday puzzles that I dnf for various reasons, I have never gotten just five minutes into a Sunday puzzle and found myself so annoyed with it that I tossed it aside and had done with it.

Well, they say there is a first time for everything. Today was my first time.

Dale Gribble 6:31 AM  

I am not like super liberal or anything, but for some reason seeing "durag" anord "afro" in crosswords makes me cringe.

Lewis 6:34 AM  

BTW, constructor Zachary Edward-Brown is a 16-year-old high school junior.

Dione Drew 6:58 AM  

gravity and inertia are the same number of letters. took me a while to figure that out. πŸ˜…

liked the LISA clue - felt self-referential without actually being

I didn't notice "misplaced" but had fun with the theme. didn't know the movie ALTERED STATES so it was fun to figure out.
sundays usually take me about 30 mins but I got today in 20.

Dione Drew 6:58 AM  

impressive!

Anonymous 7:39 AM  

Plus 4 of the 9 shaded square theme answers do not "contain" anything, much less a misspelled state name, because the circled letter is outside the shaded squares. The theme just doesn't work.

Lewis 7:57 AM  

[One split down the middle, at times]




MAGIC( )ANSASSISTANT

Colin 8:08 AM  

First of all, congrats to Zachary on this puzzle! (and John K)

I agree with Rex that the theme is a little weak. I half-expected some twisty-thing or rebuses in the circles, but "all" this was, was substitution of letters to misspell US states. Perhaps if the letters were off in a different answer, they could be MISPLACED. Once you got the theme, many answers came pretty easily. That said, I had fun with this puzzle -- Sorta like wine, I enjoy it and am not as discerning as some!

Other observations and thoughts:
- There are lots of v's in the grid!
- 83A and 51D: PPP cross.
- 4D: Not sure why Rex is so averse to RFID. Especially surprising since OREO is OK with him, no matter how often OREO shows up?
- "More Star Wars baloney" (ala Rex): You can never have enough Star Wars baloney in a puzzle! Or Star Trek, for that matter. Which leads us to...
- 84D ("Starship's medical facility"): SICKBAY is *any* ship's medical facility, not just a starship's.

The Holiday Pet Pics are great! Thank you.

kitshef 8:22 AM  

Very hard for a Sunday. Had no idea what the theme was while solving, nor after solving. After reading Rex, I understand but the revealer seems completely wrong.

An undue number of answers where I could look at the clue and know I had no chance of knowing the answer and would rely on crosses: MIKA, AIDAN, PETEY, NEAL, ERNIE, FACEID, NEWELL. Of course, two of those cross, but it was hard to imagine a letter other than L there.

Anonymous 8:24 AM  

Agree. Sane here when I saw all the proper names needed.

RooMonster 8:34 AM  

Hey All !
Aha, there needs to be at least three things happening for a SunPuz to get accepted. My recent rejection was a tied-together-by-the-clues one thing happening. Got it.

Neat puz. Fill holds up well, with having to navigate around all the fixed letters. We even have FACED, which goes through two circled letters. And a bunch of Downs that go through two Themers, heck, even some go through three Themers. Plus, having to get MISPLACED in order means you can't even move the Themers around. And, the constructors had to find symmetric sayings/things that are real things, AND make them be a State with a letter off. Whew! (Or is that Phew?) Good job, Zachary and John.

Must've taken a bit to get all this to work. Chuckled at OOH IM SO SCARED.

Much more liked by me than OFL. LIKED, not HATED. 😁

Surprised didn't get a RexRant about ALI (54 Across) as an answer, and in a clue (93 Down). Granted, two different ALIs, but still ...

Have a great Sunday!

Five F's - OLE!
RooMonster
DarrinV

Anonymous 8:38 AM  

Two stars is extremely generous. Hated, hated,..., it.

Bob Mills 8:39 AM  

Solved it without a cheat, but only after realizing the circled letters represented bad letters in the "altered" states. I liked the puzzle better than Rex did, but also had problems with GOALNET. If he's right that a "goal net" prevents footballs from reaching spectators behind the goalposts, then who gave it that name?
I had "moonlander" at first, but the theme and circle led me to see "Maryland" and MARSLANDER.
Finally, would someone please explain how FLESH is Shylock's security?

egsforbreakfast 8:40 AM  

What King Kong and Godzilla do to break a tie? FLIPAHOUSE

Us adults can eat in cafeterias, but CANTEENS?

Marco Rubio told his staff that most of the sans serif letters are ok but he wanted a NEWELL.

I took a poll on whether to call a pig habitation a sty or a pen. The YEASTY advocates won.

I'm with @Rex on this one. Thanks, Zachary Edward-Brown and John Kugelman.

Colin 8:43 AM  

BTW, I am impressed that Zachary and John could find this many US states that, with a single letter change, could be morphed into these phrases. Not an easy task!

Anonymous 8:49 AM  

Same on the cringe. Plus, I associate dorags with Axel Rose or motorcycle gangs. Linking them to black culture?

Anonymous 8:54 AM  

I hate these puzzles with the either-or squares. If I don’t hear the happy tune at the end, I have to pore over the answers over and over to ensure no typos because I never know if the answers right answer is keyed one way or another. All acrosses right? All verticals right? Enter both as a rebus? Correct states? (It was the last one today.)

Benbini 8:56 AM  

MAUWEGIAN elicited a very non-virtual/text-speak "LOL" from this solver. Thanks for that.

Christopher XLI 8:59 AM  

So, what you’re saying is, maybe he doesn’t know about a dog named PETEY whose film debut was 96 years ago.

Twangster 9:00 AM  

FWIW I thought "misplaced," refers to the states, which are places.

Lewis 9:04 AM  

There have been state-based themes before, but I don’t ever remember seeing this clever one -- a true OR(I)G(I)NAL! Props to Zachary, who came up with it, according to the constructor notes.

I love how the process of figuring out the states – from the length of the gray squares and from crosses – helped get the full theme answer it is embedded in. There was more pleasure in this than just figuring out the theme answer from simply crosses and clue.

I also love how in some areas this puzzle fought me, checked my INERTIA. Sometimes it was from tricky cluing, other times from no-knows. I prefer a Sunday with rub, one that engages, rather than simply a time filler.

Thus, a tip-top outing, entertaining and absorbing. A lovely activity while GALES are blowing outside. Thank you both!

Lewis 9:14 AM  

PPP (post-puzzle puzzle):

The 66-down answer FACE ID has two circles, one around the C and the other around the D. Can you think of another answer or answers that can be made with both of these letters changed?

I’ve found two, which I’ll post after 3:00, so they don’t act as spoilers before then.

Danger Man 9:14 AM  

NO STARS

Anonymous 9:23 AM  

This one had me completely flummoxed. I eventually said "The Hell with it" and put it in the recycling bin.

Beezer 9:38 AM  

Shylock asked for a “pound of flesh.”

Anonymous 9:39 AM  

This was an “easy” for me, maybe because I knew most of the the popcult clues. But easy doesn’t mean fun. I too was an “ugh” at OAHUAN, and felt the choppiness (although TBH shorter answers are often easier to get). The whole thing felt like a drag, and the revealer made me go “oh, ok” rather than “aha!” let alone “wow!”

EasyEd 9:57 AM  

Oh my, a tough trivia test or fest, depending on your point of view. The eclectic variety of subjects in this puzzle are maybe explained by one author’s age. I had (and still have) a much younger brother who liked to memorize tons of facts from whatever books he could find that reviewed the events of the past year (or years). In retrospect, puzzle was quite a feat of construction, but went entirely over my old head in the solving. Once I figured out OAHUAN, I knew I was in for trouble…

Anonymous 10:01 AM  

Rex summed this one up very well in his write-up. The theme was pretty obvious to me and the non gunk stuff was sufficient to keep my interest throughout most of the solve.

I don’t enjoy cobbling together the gunk on a Tuesday when the grid is smaller and the crosses are a big help. That’s not the case on a Sunday with the larger grid and stuff like PADAWAN, ELISHA. RFID, Marvel, GoT, PETEY, FLESH, and NEWELL crossing a beat poet (whatever that is) named NEAL. What a mess. Somebody must love this stuff though. It reminds be of those foods that some people consider a delicacy but would probably make a lot of us lose our lunch.

I’m surprised that Will S. signed off on that clue for GOAL NET. That seems pretty weak to me.

Anonymous 10:03 AM  

Thank you times a million for the Sesame Street Superstition. The absolute best.

thfenn 10:09 AM  

Bit of a slog. Always impressed by puzzle constructors, and construction, but didnt have a lot of fun, or arouse much curiosity, today. Maine, Maryland, and Vermont all feature prominently in my life, so that was nice, and using the shaded squares to write in states helped with some of the answers. But mainly just plodded thru. My puff piece was a VAnE but I still couldnt figure out what cross in FIRETRAn was a problem, so maybe I wasn't firing on all cylinders. But no happy bubbly today. Just work.

Anonymous 10:12 AM  

OK. That was fund as always, but today I do have a nit to pick. Which is, come on, guys, to call NEAL Cassady a "beat poet" is so outlandishly exaggerated as to be just plain wrong. Cassady was more a saint than a poet, if you ask anyone. He mostly did stuff, and talked, and left the scribe work to folks like Jack Kerouac and Robert Hunter. Still, nice to see him in the puzzle!

Beezer 10:13 AM  

Baby it’s COLD outside in my neck of the woods this morning! We usually don’t get this type of action until after Christmas but it IS conducive to getting cozy and working crosswords.
I didn’t love the puzzle today but seems to me it’s a VERY good offering by a 16 year old. I didn’t catch if it is a debut. At any rate, it isn’t heavy on current pop culture, and seems to have something for everyone, so I consider that a plus.
My brain works in strange ways. Why do I know about RFID? Only because at some point I heard about RFID-blocking wallets/billfolds years ago. I didn’t look up what RFID meant, just knew it could prevent high tech criminals from remotely stealing my credit card when I was out and about. Still seems like magic to me.
How do I know ALIG? When (I think it was) Borat came out my daughter told me that Sacha Baron Cohen (who I didn’t know at that point) had been Ali G. To which I said “Thank you, very helpful”, not. well…I finally figured it out.
Finally, I know enough about Starwars to be dangerous, so when PAD first revealed itself, I thought…wait…isn’t there a Padme…but that’s to short! So yes…I was thinking of PadmΓ© Amidala, which btw…makes me think of the amygdala.

Anonymous 10:14 AM  

Shakespere's Shylock in Merchant of Venice demands a pound of flesh as collateral

Anonymous 10:19 AM  

I used to live on Oahu and before last night pretty sure the word “Oahuan” had ever been put before me.

Anonymous 10:19 AM  

I still don’t get the theme! Something is misplaced, obviously, but huh?!

Anonymous 10:23 AM  

A slow, steady, somewhat tedious solve that started in the NE, then dripped down south, and then oozed its way west. The mild "aha" came with NOT EXA(C)TLY and was confirmed by MAR(S) LANDER. I think Rex summarized the puzzle very well. The grid was indeed choppy, and there was indeed an Eat A Sandwich vibe which seemed especially pronounced with FLIP A HOUSE. (The way these types of answers hit me now, they sound almost imperative. "Make me flip a house. Just try and see what happens.") Medium is also about right IMO; my own time was maybe a few minutes more than an average Sunday time.

Also agree wholeheartedly with his Star Wars sentiment. The problem of course is finding sources of common knowledge (so as to avoid having a glut of niche answers), and it has been determined that "everyone" knows Star Wars and action movies based on Marvel Comics, so they're going to stick with that. Which counts me out. Anyhow, it does get really tiresome.

I don't want to rag too much, because (1) one of the constructors is young, and (2) architecturally, it looks like it was a challenge to construct, all for the effort of spelling out "misplaced" with the circled letters, and having coherent theme answers to boot. That's a lot. I just didn't find it much fun on the solver end.

They threw a bone to the math-y types in the crowd, that enabled me to change from "math CLUB" to GLEE CLUB with the cross NEGATOR. However, I don't recall seeing that specific word in this context. I would say either "negation" or "negation operator". (Likewise, I have never seen "conjunctor" nor "disjunctor", which would seem to be linguistically parallel to "negator" in the matter of Boolean algebra terms.) I don't claim there is no such term, but I'm in the biz and I've not seen it. Maybe some computer science types use it?

Great write-up, Rex. I would just say one thing. Yes, Superstition is fantastic. But just about anything by Stevie Wonder from those years is golden, and I personally have a pretty hard time deciding on a FAVE. Throw a dart at Musiquarium (a compilation album) and tell me what you hit isn't banger. Songs in the Key of Life, from which a number of hits on Musiquarium were drawn, is another great album. He and Aretha Franklin were very big with my mom, so naturally they formed part of the musical background of my childhood.

Snowy here in Connecticut. Stay warm, all.

Azzurro 10:31 AM  

Wait, that was the Pointer Sisters?! I remember that song clearly from my childhood but never knew that was them singing. Today years old, as they say…

pabloinnh 10:33 AM  

Was trying to think of why I really didn't enjoy solving this one and then OFL came up with "fussy to navigate". Bingo. I saw that the STATES had problems after MARYLAND and MAINE and wrote in ALTEREDSTATES as the revealer without reading the clue, but by then I had had enough and didn't go back to try to see what he circled letters might spell.

I agree with many here that among the propers I never want to see again are AIDAN, PADAWAN, NEWELL, and ELISHA. I did know NEAL from On the Road and of course ERNIE. Thanks to OFL for the "Superstition" video. Anyone who can hear that and not start moving some body part needs help.

I am familiar with IRONWOOD, which around here is also known as "hornbeam" or "hop hornbeam" or sometimes "leverwood", for obvious reasons. Tough stuff.

Appreciate your efforts, ZEB and JK. Not exactly in my Zone, Expect Bigger fun on a Sunday, but his one Just Kinda fell flat. Thanks for some interesting answers at least.

Anonymous 10:42 AM  

This is the weirdest response to normal Black stuff.

tht 10:44 AM  

Oh, that was me. Thought I "signed in".

tht 10:45 AM  

Images of "Nancy's wall". Lots of flung newspapers this morning.

tht 10:54 AM  

Weird image popped into my head: a friend of Antonio starts a GoFundMe, where if they could get enough people to scrape off enough excess skin from their heels after taking a bath, they might be able to make that payment. "Here you go, Shylock -- you asked for it." Thunk.

Teedmn 11:08 AM  

You people with your heart-warming memories of Sesame Street! I grew up in a TV-viewing desert, with no PBS channel within aerial distance, so Sesame Street, bah, I never saw it and I've lived lo these many years without it. Just kidding - I was jealous when we got the Sunday St. Paul paper and the TV listings had all of these interesting-sounding shows I would never see. So sad...

RFID - I found one of those thingies in a book as an anti-theft device and thought it looked cool so for some reason I put it in my wallet. Next thing you know, leaving Target, I start setting off the alarm. I finally found the culprit and removed it and steered clear of them after that.

I can't say I enjoyed this. It took me longer than I liked, I wasn't able to use my usual solving platform for some reason, and the title threw me off - I was expecting a change of letters between the across and down, forgetting to read the whole of the grayed-out squares. Plus I totally missed the MISPLACED bit.

Nice work for what it is, thanks Zachary and John.

Steve Washburne 11:15 AM  

Didn't hate it, but no love either. Didn't suss out the theme and still don't see the connection of those specific letters.
Most all the names were getable from crosses and a time halfway between my average and best seems about right. Stumbled on PADAWAN.
Congrats to constructor Zachary !

tht 11:23 AM  

SBC had a lot of fun mispronouncing names on Ali G. One interview began, "I'm here with Norman Chomsky..." (Chomsky played gamely along, but was not long in figuring out it was a joke interview.)

jb129 11:23 AM  

Love the pet pics. Didn't love the puzzle. So many "WOES" - PADAWAN, RFID just to name a few - actually the whole "gimmick". Solved but almost gave up & had to cheat - A LOT
:(

walrus 11:27 AM  

best puzzle-related aspect was reading max factor's wikipedia article. thank you for the link, rex.

Niallhost 11:31 AM  

There's a great 30 Rock episode where Liz Lemon worries it's offensive to use the term "Puerto Rican" - as if it were a slur.

Lisa 11:32 AM  

I've seen Severance 5 times. I'm obsessed with the show. I was stumped on this clue.

They were best friends only when Petey was Severed, that is when they were both in innie form inside the office. I kept thinking of a best friend who was Unsevered--to me that meant some friend he had outside of work. In the half unsevered state, Mark did not even know who the hell Petey was, let alone be his best friend. I was thinking , the brother in law?

MetroGnome 11:33 AM  

Hey! Let's see how many names, brand names, and pop culture trivia references we can cram into a single puzzle! Won't that be fun?

SouthsideJohnny 11:33 AM  

The comment above was mine. I keep forgetting that we get logged off occasionally. I was also going to mention that I like Little Richard’s version better than ERNIE’s.

Rubber Duckie

Niallhost 11:35 AM  

I kept wondering why this puzzle felt easy and yet I was having trouble finishing it. I wanted to make sense of the substituted letters in the state names. Seems very anti-climactic that there was nothing, even with learning that the letters spelled something somewhat relevant after the fact. Never good to feel relief but no satisfaction when done. 36:38

Anonymous 11:43 AM  

I had the exact same problem with “rewind.” Couldn’t find my mistake until coming here.

Ken Freeland 11:52 AM  

There were way too many proper names in today's puzzle for it to be enjoyable, but I dutifully slogged through it anyway, navigating as best I could through Hollywood obscurity. But it was my undoing: For SNARLSAT I had SNoRtSAT. This is an innocent mistake bacuae the only crosschecks on my guess were two proper names for an actor and a Latina astronaut. Really? I have to know such obscure crap in order to correctly solve a NYT Sunday puzzle? I would pay $20 fo Will Shortz to give s fib
ve mi ute explanation why he believes that solvers should be required to know every Tom, Dick and Harriet in the entertainment industry to solve a crossWORD puzzle. I can't find it in the fine print....

Anita 12:00 PM  

Same - that's how I read it.

Anonymous 12:13 PM  

Yeah, but the pet pix made it all worthwhile in the end.

Sinfonian 12:15 PM  

Huh. I didn't hate it. Fairly easy solve fore as Sundays go (~5 minutes faster than average) and I solved the tricky proper names (like NEAL, for me) with crosses. Even more impressive when you know the constructor is 16 years old. Maybe I'm getting *less* cranky in my dotage? (I doubt that!)

Anonymous 12:21 PM  

I also hated this puzzle almost as much as Roger Ebert hated North. Was surprised we didn’t get a classic Rex rant about having RFID and FACEID (not to mention MEME and MIME).
Also, the kid dancing on the fire escape in the Superstitious video has lived in my brain for over 40 years. If that were me I’d still be dining out on that story.

Bernie 12:25 PM  

34A answer is DENVER MINT, with the "I" replacing the "O" in the state name VERMONT. That's the ALTERED STATE.

Alex 12:26 PM  

While the theme wasn’t my favorite (for the reasons that Rex highlighted) I should mention that my gf printed all the NYT puzzles that landed on birthday for the last 30 years and we are shocked at how difficult some of the early week puzzles here and how many Naticks we are encountering. Makes us less cranky when we not every puzzle nowadays is a slam dunk (I liked some things about this puzzle inc the constructor’s young age (wow!) and some of the references like the Simpsons, Severance, Jim Thorpe))! It would fun to see Rex blog about some puzzles across the decades - maybe his birthday puzzles - or some such thematic ones we could do together.

puzzlehoarder 12:43 PM  

This was an easy solve. I ignored the theme and just slogged through all the odd fill. I don't do early week puzzles so I get my theme induced fill quota for the week by doing Sundays. This one didn't disappoint. The closest I got to a Natick came when I was finishing in the NE. I'd already put in PANSY but when I saw the Star Wars nonsense that it crossed with I recalled that there was also a flower called a tansy. PADAWAN/ TADAWAN made no difference to me so I just stuck with PANSY for the congrats. That was as exciting as it got today.

PADAWAN looks like it's trying to be a member of today's "eat a sandwich " trio.

I've noticed that Nancy is no longer commenting and Im concerned about why.

jae 12:55 PM  

This was easy for me, capping off an easy weekend. Knowing the reveal was helpful. I ignored the circles and shaded squares and figured out the theme post-solve. The only area that briefly hung me up was the RVLOT, ALTO, NEGATOR section where NEGATOR was a WOE and the Amy clue took some staring.

Like it more than @Rex did.

okanaganer 12:55 PM  

Across Lite let me down today; it had the circles but not the shaded squares. No wonder I couldn't figure out what the "states" in the theme were. (I did get the M I S P L A C E D bit.) Add in way too many Unknown Names -- what else is new -- and it wasn't much fun.

Jim THORPE made me remember staying in the Pennsylvania town named Jim Thorpe; quite a pretty little old town in the mountains. When I checked in at the B & B, I asked the girl why it was named after him... she didn't have a clue. And now, Wikipedia tells me there is no connection. I suspect they did it because the existing name was Old Mach Chunk, which is colorful but not very pretty.

Buzz ALDRIN is a colorful guy who seems to love the spotlight; the total opposite of Neil Armstrong who was very modest. I've read a couple of biographies of Armstrong and he was a genuine hero to me.

And ands up for loving Stevie Wonder's Superstition... one of the greatest songs ever.

Les S. More 1:15 PM  

That wasn’t even fun. Not a bit. But maybe I’m missing something wonderful. I’ll check in with Rex in the morning.

******************

Woke up this morning to no internet, so couldn’t read Rex. Three hours later everything is back up. It wasn’t a problem with my system; it was one of those area -wide things. We had a windstorm overnight and all power went out for a few hours. So I’ve read Rex’s explanation of the theme and, sadly, discovered that that it was just what I thought it was.

Oh, well.

jae 1:21 PM  

I get Nancy’s comments via email and today’s puzzle went SPLAT!

Anonymous 1:32 PM  

I print it out so that I'm done when I'm happy, I finish my coffee, ifs not empty already, give the puzzle a quick look and come here.

Anonymous 1:37 PM  

The US Navy's first six boats (frigates) had ironwood keels. Almost broke the budget buying saw blades.

MegtroGnome 1:51 PM  

RFID?! UBERX??!! Crosswords have now officially become crossgobbldygooks?

corakat 1:52 PM  

That's interesting! I had an easier time with this than I expect for a Sunday. I wonder if I'm more attuned to younger references than classic ones. Not that 53 minutes is "sailing though" haha.

I liked that so many of the clues had to do with (often space) travel, which relates a bit to the theme. I needed to catch onto the theme and fill VERM[]NT to solve that corner. Actually I always enjoy when the theme helps me solve. Feels like sneaking around the tricky clues haha. πŸ™‚

JazzmanChgo 2:03 PM  

Cassady wrote poetry occasionally (he co-wrote the poem that served as inspiration for "Pull My Daisy," the title of the Robert Frank Alfred Leslie film about everyday Beat life that has since become a cult classic), but he was mostly a "poetry-in-motion" force of nature, talking endlessly, weaving surreal, Zen-like loops of words, images, and ideas, charging with obsessive alacrity through the world, spreading enlightenment and chaos with equal (and apparently uncontrollable) abandon. He could be called "Beat icon," a "Beat inspiration," or a "Beat avatar," but "Beat poet," I think, is a stretch.

SharonAK 2:14 PM  

Agree with those who said too many names. And several were OBSCURE .
But then half the ball player names and most o the rock performers name are OBSCURE to me.
I enjoyed the themers and when I caught on they were altered state names it helped with the solve
Didn't hate Superstition (listened to part of it here) BUT, " Best song ever written"????
@Egs chuckled at "flip a house" and "canteen" riffs.
And reminded me I wanted to argue with Rex at his dissing of the former as a phrase.

Beezer 2:17 PM  

First, agree on Stevie Wonder…I have about all his albums (vinyl) and while Superstition isn’t my favorite, it’s up toward the top.
Second. I would truly like to know WHY people use Across Lite. Is it because they are solving on a laptop? I do NOT want to advocate any type of “computer.” I DO know I solve using the NYT app on an iPad. I find it VERY easy to navigate. By the same token, when “forced” to solve on my iPhone…the set-up is abysmal. Hey. I forget WHY I initially went Apple but my family is equally Android/Apple. Anyway, I’ve been desperate in past and worked puzzle on worked puz on a laptop using Across Lite (since a lot of peeps recommended). It was a “fail” for me. In closing…people out there (I know Okanaganer wouldn’t) please do not accuse me of being “bougie” or whatnot because I have an iPad. I really am trying to sort this stuff out. And, I resisted Apple products (expensive!) for years.

okanaganer 2:18 PM  

@puzzlehoarder, I used to skip Monday and Tuesday, but then I tried the down-clues-only method which made all the difference. Now Monday is one of my favorite days, mainly because it's something different.

Beezer 2:25 PM  

@puzzlehoarder…there was, let’s say, a “flap.” Nancy is doing well, but has left the blog.

Anonymous 2:27 PM  

Spent the whole puzzle unable to complete the NW because of the overlap in spelling, syntax, and meaning of SUSSED and SCOPED.

Les S. More 2:29 PM  

Nicely said. Good post. Thank you for that.

Beezer 2:31 PM  

Same here. I may be in my dotage also but I think “less cranky” always good! Like, for God’s sake…I KNOW I can’t construct a puzzle! I am SO happy that ANYONE puts themself out there at peril of criticism. And, I am sure the young constructor will learn a bit if he reads Rex, but skips the laypeeps criticism.

Beezer 2:38 PM  

@Lisa. I love Severence too! I confess…I got hung up on that. Petey had initially been “severed.” In this alternative world (so far) MANY people are not “severed.” So…I was like…well, what is “unsevered”…or should it be “de-severed”? Haha…anyone who hasn’t watched would think this is gobbledygook.

Beezer 2:47 PM  

Yep tht…on the same wave length with Mr. Wonder. Depending on whether you want him “hard” or “softer” or both…too many choices! But Inner Vissions and Songs in the Key of Life my favorite compilations.

kitshef 2:47 PM  

Follow-up. No shaded squares for me, so I assumed the "shaded squares" referred to the circles. Now the theme makes more sense.

Beezer 2:49 PM  

Don’t ya just hate that “signed off” biz? I really TRY to see if my “bee” avatar is there, but dammit…I’m not perfect!

Seth 3:01 PM  

I'm fairly certain MISPLACED is a pun about how the states, aka "PLACEs," are MISspelled.

Beezer 3:02 PM  

After seeing ALIG in puzzle, I decided I’m going to see if I can stream it. Maybe YouTube? I’ll figure it out. SBC is brilliant, but I have to be in the right “mood” since his “stuff” is so “cringey.”

Beezer 3:05 PM  

Ok. Now I’m stuck on anon 8:49 response that associates Axyl Rose bandana with a durag…I’ll live.

ChrisS 3:19 PM  

I have an ironwood cutting board from Argentina & an ironwood chiltepin grinder from Mexico. Both are from different tree species and neither is Hornbeam or Hop Hornbeam. I'll take Rex's word that durag is correct, I've never seen it written before but I assumed it was do-rag, from hairDO rag.

Liveprof 3:20 PM  

I couldn't tell if I was dealing with real DAN or AIDAN.

********
Buzz ALDRIN is the oldest living astronaut: He'll be 96 next month. He married a beautiful and brilliant chemical engineer (Anca Faur), about 30 years his junior, on his 93rd birthday! Sadly, she passed away at age 66 last year. He said they were "as excited as teens eloping" when they married. Jersey boy too: Glen Ridge.

Anonymous 3:26 PM  

Impressive

Anonymous 3:49 PM  

Very quick Sunday for me, but ended with my one wrong answer: hANkY for PANSY, because what do I know about violets or jedis (and I can easily imagine a flower that looks kinda like a hanky), and the other wrong square could have been anything except a Y

Greater Fall River Committee for Peace & Justice 3:55 PM  

Rubber Ducky, huh. I accompanied it once on stage. It was supposed to be a children's concert, but the music wasn't mostly all that child -friendly. An opera singer decided that instead of the aria they were expecting him to sing, he would go Sesame Street on them. It was a huge hit. He had been in the auditions for the Met as a young lad, but his dad came home from Korea with no legs, so he had to give up trying for a career to take care of him. He sold shoes for a living in a downtown department store, and in his spare time mostly sang his beloved operatic staples wherever anybody would let him, whether they wanted them or not. But he had gotten old by the date in question and thought he'd try something different. And that's how I remember him.

Whatsername 4:11 PM  

Nancy still comments most every day but she does so via a group email list. If you’d like to be added to it, you can email me and I’ll forward it to her. FYI, today’s puzzle hit her wall with a big SPLAT.

Lewis 4:15 PM  

FADE IN
FAKE IT

(both have been NYT answers)

thefogman 4:17 PM  

The MISPLACED letters of the various states when flipped back to their proper original letters spell out OOYDAUSAV. What a letdown. It would have been great if the flipped letters spelled out something interesting. Is that too much to ask Mr. Shortz?

Paul 4:31 PM  

Easy but unpleasant

gregmark 4:35 PM  

Believe it or not, finding these words cringy... is cringy. These words are only offensive in the context of an offensive statement.

Beezer 4:44 PM  

Interesting facts Liveprof! Plus…very sad.

Beezer 4:46 PM  

Good idea!

Anoa Bob 4:55 PM  

NOT EXACTLY my FAVE type of theme. When the circled letters are change to correctly spell the STATES in the remaining shaded squares, we are left with gobbledygook. 21A OOH IM SO SCARED, for example, becomes OOH IO SO SCARED and 5D MEME becomes MEOE. And so on for all the other themers and crosses.

And the "... or what the shaded squares contain?" part of the reveal had me doing a arched brow, side-eye squint. The shaded squares are OHI, VERMNT, MARLAND, et al., both before and after the circled letters (which are not shaded) are ALTERED, right?

I think the theme was trying to do too many things and it all didn't coalesce to stick the landing for me.

I did see ALTERED STATES when it first came out but would not describe it as a "horror film", as clued. I thought it was more of a fantasy psychedelic film.

gregmark 4:57 PM  

I had some trouble in the SW, but overall I found this... easy medium maybe. Hit my GenX popular culture wheelhouse in a very idiosyncratic way.

You had X-Men, Star Wars, The Merchant of Venice, The Ali G Show, Petyr "Littlefinger" Baelish, Altered States (scared the crap out of me as a little feller), The Simpsons, Elvis, Fiddler on the Roof, Judd Apatow movies. Just things I knew, plus a bunch of other things I knew *of*, like I didn't know "Gaspard de la Nuit" because zzzzz... boring! But I knew there was a composer RAVEL.

And OOHIMSOSCARED? First thing that brought to my mind was a line by Wesley Snipes in Demolition Man, the 1993 film that first clued me in to Sandra Bullock:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qOgT9Ifw6Io

Anybody? Just me? Maybe it's just me. Anyway, I can see how NOT knowing these would make this particular layout unpleasant. I just lucked out.

okanaganer 5:00 PM  

@Beezer; I prefer solving on my computer, with its full old-style keyboard and two large monitors. The web page version of the puzzle is awful; it only fills about one quarter of one of the monitors so I have to constantly scroll like mad.

I can download puzzles in the Across Lite format (.puz) from almost any site: New Yorker, Wall St Journal, LA Times, etc. For the NYT puzzle, on every day except Sunday I don't have to scroll, ever. I can re-arrange, shrink, or grow the grid and clue areas at will. On Sunday I can zoom out the grid so it fits perfectly my screen and only have to scroll to see the last few clues. There may indeed be a better app that works on Windows; I'm open to suggestions!

Anonymous 5:05 PM  

Joyless slog — like pushing the out-of-alignment grocery cart that keeps hitting the cans off the shelf.

Anonymous 5:17 PM  

With respect, Nancy left and I don’t understand this need to report what she thinks. She was awful to Rex and yet you all still fawn over her. Let her stay gone.

CDilly52 5:19 PM  

HooBOY! Much of this on was so far outside my wheelhouse, I was sure I’d bust my one-year-plus streak, but I persevered despite my frustration.

The pace of the solve (as @Rex aptly describes) created by the grid itself was the cause of most of my frustrstion. It forced me into my least favorite Sunday solve pace: the stutter-step. It was impossible to get a flow going because of the little black squares popping up everywhere. Instead if acting like stepping stones to a whooshy rhythm, they acted like speed bumps in a neighborhood street - spaced just far enough apart to allow the driver to get a foot back on the gas only to hit the brakes at the next one and feel the shocks wearing out.

Besides the speed bumps, much of the internet, comic book/animation and gaming fill might as well have been in Swahili. And I shamefully admit here that I have never seen a full episode of The Simpsons. It’s just not for me, but I keep learning lots about the show through crosswords.

Couldn’t even get a solid start in the NW because both SussED and SCOPED fit - and naturally, I thought SussED was the better answer. I should have read the clue more than once. I admit (now, in my post-solve thorough review) that according to the clue, SCOPED is the better answer.

I did enjoy seeing the great Jim THORPE, member of the Oklahoma Sac and Fox Nation appear prominently in the puzzle. He gave me something to go on. I almost fell for the misdirect trying to con me into a rebus as I tried to cram Hawaiian into what became OAHUAN of immediate necessity.

When the grey squares accented what clearly wanted to be OHIo, I suspected something funny with state names. The DENVER MINT, quickly confirmed, and it revealed the theme. To speed up my solve, I hunted for the remaining theme entries, filked them in but still couldn’t get my whoosh on because of the grid. Ugh.

Not too hard, not too easy, but pretty far from just right. However, as NYT debuts go, Mr. Edward-Brown picked a generous and highly skilled partner for his collaboration. The grid, not so much the fill brought down the puzzle. Sure, quite a bit of weak fill appears throughout, but I excuse much of that on a Sunday because of both the size of Sunday grids and the constraints occasioned thereby. Hearty congratulations, Zachary. I look forward to your next one. I suspected a youthful constructor based solely on the fill that challenged me. I’m clearly going to have to up my gaming and animation/comics knowledge. That’s on me. I think 2 stars was a bit chintzy. Clearly, our young PADAWAN had quite a good idea well in hand, reached out for guidance from a super star (I’m a John Kugelman fangirl) and had settled on a problematic grid.

Anonymous 5:52 PM  

I’m youngerish, so I guess this was just in my wheelhouse? I am shocked that everyone thought it was a slog; I thought this was the easiest and least tedious Sunday in a long while. Solved in 25 m, close to my fastest Sunday time!

Anonymous 6:16 PM  

100% agree with all the above. Saw all the trivia requirement, and threw it away.

Kevin O'Connor 6:57 PM  

Agree. I DNF’d on making rebuses after not making rebuses.

okanaganer 7:09 PM  

Oh I forgot to add about Across Lite; usually if it's not able to show some special features (like the shaded squares here), I will get a warning to that effect and I take a look at the web page version to check them out. Today there was no warning, dunno why.

Gary Jugert 7:34 PM  

Oh estoy tan asustada.

Urban safety hazard ... URBAN safety hazard. URBAN. Why isn't a FIRE TRAP a safety hazard everywhere? You're in a cardboard box on fire next to the freeway. FIRE TRAP. In a garage in suburbia filled with cans of paint and a gas can on fire. FIRE TRAP. In a corn field with your pants on fire from the lies you tell. FIRE TRAP. Surrounded by tumbleweeds aflame in the badlands. FIRE TRAP. In one of those little shrines in some seacoast village in Greece with a zillion candles on a rack. FIRE TRAP, probably.

I used to live a few blocks from the DENVER MINT, but I never got any free pennies. When we were kids you could tour the facility, but once you've gone as a 7 year old, you feel like you know all that is knowable about pennies and you never go back. The minute I moved away, they stopped making pennies. Apparently I was the magic.

I confidently wrote in FIX AND FLIP because that's the right answer.

DRUM MAJORS set the tempo, the DRUM LINE follows it.

Good god, I may have to abandon the gunkometer on Sundays. They're trying to break me.

People: 23 {no no definitely not}
Places: 2
Products: 11
Partials: 16
Foreignisms: 3
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 55 of 138 (40%) {πŸ”” Honk the horn on the gunkmobile as this beast was rolling through the red lights.}

Funny Factor: 5 😐

Tee-Hee: ANAL.

Uniclues:

1 Trainee shaking in a dress.
2 This puzzle.
3 When you're naked and have bubbles inside and out.
4 "They should still be teaching this in elementary school," and "No really people still need to know how to do this."
5 Chess coach wants fewer pawns.
6 Popcorn connoisseur says youngster isn't so cool.

1 OOH -I'M-SO-SCARED PADAWAN
2 WHAT A HOOT ... NOT EXACTLY
3 BATHING ALTERED STATES
4 CURSIVE AGENT AXIOMS (~)
5 SNARLS AT SHY OPENS
6 PACMAN OUTS TEEN'S ACT

My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Crowd uproars when lilliputian torredors wave their fragrant capes. DRYER SHEET OLÉS.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

okanaganer 9:10 PM  

@Gary: People 23! I thought there were a lot.

Gary Jugert 9:38 PM  

@okanaganer9:10 PM
Yeah! 23. And 40% overall gunk on a big grid is never going to be well received. Add in 27 partials and products and you can imagine a whole lot of pushback no matter how great the theme is.

Jnlzbth 9:49 PM  

I do appreciate that this constructor is young and obviously talented, but this puzzle was so choppy, so tortured...just not ready for prime time. So many obscure names...and it had no flow, no lift, nothing light or delightful, just slog slog slog with very little payoff. Wish they had held it for more development.

brad 11:03 PM  

Thank you for posting the Stevie Wonder clip. It pulled me out of a very deep funk after finishing this puzzle. It made me think that even NYT crossword editors make mistakes. In this case, they forgot to schedule a Sunday puzzle, and pulled one out of the slush pile on Saturday. I sent a quick email to corrections@nytimes.com.

Sailor 11:04 PM  

I love DRUM LINES, but I was shocked at this answer - it's absolutely the Drum Major that sets the tempo!

The young co-constructor shows a lot of promise, and I'm sorry he didn't get all the help he deserved from the editors. It was a cute theme, but the grid was too easy, too choppy, and had waaay too many names.

dgd 11:04 PM  

I thought the theme made the puzzle much easier. All those state names helped (minus one letter of course) me a lot. NEAL and THORPE are certainly easy for Boomers. I thought the ppp was varied enough. The segmentation created by the theme is what made the puzzle harde but for me the theme balanced that off. Medium is about right.
Also altered states means to me that with the crosses each circle has a typo or misplaced letter So I have no idea why Rex thinks misplaced is bad!

Anonymous 12:56 PM  

Awful. 40000 proper nouns and crosswordeses

Danno 2:39 PM  

Hmm, not to mince words, but no. Just seemed all over the place for the sake of being all over the place.

Chatsworth Osborne Jr. 4:57 PM  

Wow, a lot of unlove for this one. Had I not seen ALTERED STATES upon release or had it not remained with me as it has, I'd be less pleased today. I basically agree with OFL across the board, and I tip my hat for his posting the one and only (and the real) Petey.

Anonymous 5:07 PM  

Thank you.

William 12:27 PM  

I enjoyed it, got it, and think it is clever. Rex Parker never has a positive spin on the Sunday puzzle. Most of the time, his take is santimonious.

Anonymous 10:39 PM  

Is Malcolm a Lagoda Romanella?

Back to TOP