Relative difficulty: Easy
![]() |
| [2D: ___-Wan Kenobi] |
THEME: SONGS IN / THE KEY OF LIFE (50A: With 52-Across, double album released on September 28, 1976, that spent 13 straight weeks at #1) — ❤️❤️❤️π΅π΅π΅❤️❤️❤️ An anniversary tribute to a classic double album by STEVIE WONDER (19A: 50/52-Across musician):
- "SIR DUKE" (21A: #1 hit from 50/52-Across ("You can feel it all over")
- "I WISH" (37A: #1 hit from 50/52-Across ("Why did those days ever have to go?")
Songs in the Key of Life is the eighteenth studio album by the American singer, songwriter and musician Stevie Wonder. A triple album, it was released on September 28, 1976, by Tamla Records, a division of Motown. The album is regarded as the culmination of Wonder's "classic period" of recording, which began in 1972 with Music of My Mind.
By 1974, Wonder was one of the most successful figures in popular music; his previous albums Music of My Mind (1972), Talking Book (1972), Innervisions (1973), and Fulfillingness' First Finale (1974) were back-to-back critical successes. However, by March 1975, Wonder seriously considered quitting the music industry and emigrating to Ghana to aid children with disabilities. Plans for a farewell concert had already begun when Wonder changed his mind and signed a new contract with Motown on August 5, 1975. This outlined a seven-year, seven-album deal, with full artistic control. This deal included $13 million up front, a potential bonus of up to $20 million, 20% of the royalties, and ownership of the publishing rights. At the time, it was the biggest recording deal in history.
Songs in the Key of Life was released as a double LP with a four-song bonus EP. It debuted at number one on the Billboard 200 chart, becoming only the third album to achieve that feat, and the first by an American artist. Both the lead single "I Wish" and follow-up single "Sir Duke" reached number one on the Billboard Hot 100. The album spent thirteen consecutive weeks at number one on the Billboard 200, becoming the album with the most weeks at number one during the year, and was the second-best-selling album of 1977 in the US. In 2005, the album was certified Diamond by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), indicating sales of 5 million units for a double album.
The album won Album of the Year at the 19th Grammy Awards and is the best-selling and most critically acclaimed album of Wonder's career. It is now widely regarded as one of the greatest albums in the history of popular music, and many musicians have remarked on its influence on their own work. It was voted number 89 in Colin Larkin's All Time Top 1000 Albums and ranked number 4 on Rolling Stone's 2020 list of the "500 Greatest Albums of All Time". In 2002, the album was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame, and in 2005 it was inducted into the National Recording Registry by the Library of Congress, which deemed it "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant". (wikipedia)
Bullets:
- 30A: Resident of Africa's fourth-largest country (LIBYAN) — oh look, another little mistake that I made. I had the -YAN part and wrote in KENYAN. Kenya is actually the 23rd-largest country in Africa. You know, in case that ever comes up.
- 53D: Ivy League school in New Haven (YALE) — once again, happy birthday to the girl, who turns 26 today. I wasn't going to tell you Yet Again that she's currently getting her MFA at the David Geffen School of Drama at YALE (Technical Design and Production), but the puzzle kind of forced my hand, sorry.
- 28D: Contents of plastic sleeves or jewel cases, informally (CDS) — I've got one of the SONGS IN / THE KEY OF LIFE CDS in the car and the other in my little Bose CD player / clock radio near my comfy coffee chair in the library. First thing I'm gonna do when I get downstairs is hit "Play."
- 61A: Whistlers in the kitchen (KETTLES) — speaking of, gotta go get my whistler in the kitchen fired up so I can have my coffee. Actually, my kettle doesn't whistle. It's one of them fancy kettles that hits whatever temperature you want and just stays there. Got a little temp read-out and everything. It is black and sleek and beautiful and my best friend in the morning. Yes, I love the cats, but they are takers and they know it. The kettle simply gives.
[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️:
✏️Upcoming Crossword Tournaments✏️:
=============================
π My other blog π:
- Pop Sensation (vintage paperbacks)






ReplyDeleteEasy but enjoyable. Liked it, but not quite as much as OFL did. At 19A I had STEV from downs and when 6D provided the I, the theme became obvious.
* * * * _
One overwrite, hoAx before SCAM for the 41A fraudulent offer.
One WOE, "Clemency" star ALFRE Woodard at 46A.
Sure - iconic album but the tribute puzzle just never hits for me. I still have my original vinyl. Astonishingly straightforward for Agard - during the few short minutes of the solve I realized the grid was secondary and of no real importance here.
ReplyDeleteA Few Hundred Thank Yous
Rex summarizes the fill nicely - it’s smooth and tepid for the most part. Highlight is fitting the entire SONGS title in. ILL GET IT, TUESDAYS, SILENT Z all solid. A lot of the shorts I didn’t even notice with the crosses.
Good on Rex getting to see Stevie - cute Tuesday morning solve.
The Royal SCAM
Wow, a 5* rating from @REX!!!!! Nice. Enjoyed the puzzle. I didn't know "IWISH" so that middle part took me a while too. The SW album I have memorized from my childhood is Inner Vision. One of my brothers bought it. I don't think we ever owned a copy of SONGS IN THE KEY OF LIFE, but those hits are certainly familiar from the radio etc. Thanks, Erik, for a great Tuesday : )
ReplyDeleteThe themers hit me with a big ol jolt of joy. One of my favorite albums by one of my favorite artists, and one of my favorite songs in the puzzle to boot I had a huge smile carrying me through the rest of the solve.
ReplyDeleteIsn’t she lovely!
ReplyDeleteNever heard the album. Don't like music trivia quizzes posing as crossword puzzles.
ReplyDeletedo give it a listen it won't hurt you
DeleteJoy awaits, my friend!
DeleteThis is the musical equivalent of referencing The Godfather or Casablanca. Maybe the song titles are music trivia, but the album and Mr. Wonder himself rise to the level of general knowledge worth being familiar with. Songs in the Key of Life is usually mentioned in the same breath as the Beach Boys’ Pet Sounds and Marvin Gaye’s What’s Going On as the greatest albums of all time.
DeleteAstral Weeks as well
DeleteI felt this was a smooth and easy puzzle, much like what I can recall of STEVIE’s sound. I was living abroad during much of his most important works and was taken up with other artists, so missed the songs named in this puzzle, but now I’m ready to catch up. Thanks Rex for the history lesson.
ReplyDeleteI’m generally not a fan of tribute puzzles, but anything that puts Stevie Wonder’s music in my head gets a big thumbs up from me. Pure joy.
ReplyDeletefabulous puzzle - as good as they get - bravo Erik!
ReplyDeleteI flip pancakes with a pancake-turner or flipper. I use a spatula to ice a cake. There is also the scraper, which I use to scrape bowls or peanut butter jars.
ReplyDeleteI gave up submitting tribute puzzles to the Times. The response has always been something along the lines of "we stay away from tribute puzzles, as they feel too much like trivia for solvers".
Favorite Stevie Wonder songs: Sir Duke, and Living for the City.
I knew 5D would get to you so I looked up types of spatulas. Not surprised to find that most people have different definitions than you do; quite surprised that they contradict me in a few cases. Oh, well, at least we agree on one thing - the offset spatula is a wonderful tool. You use yours to ice cakes while I, as a non-baker, use mine to flip squash blossom fritters in hot oil. And to smear straight-from-the-tube oil paint across a canvas. Not the same one, of course; some live in the kitchen, some live in the studio.
DeleteWhat? The answer STEVIE WONDER has never appeared in a Times puzzle before today? How can that be? But it is!
ReplyDeleteThank you for rectifying that, Erik.
And thank you for once again, as you always do, creating a grid so junk free, that when I look over the completed puzzle, my whole system calms down, and I feel serene and at peace. I am not exaggerating.
Thank you, also, Erik, for throwiing in a pair of world-class wordplay clues on a day when simple, direct cluing is the order of the day, to introduce newer solvers to this delicious aspect of solving crosswords. [It has M.S.G. in it] for NYC has been used before but is so good that its encore is deserved. [Bloc party?] for NATION is not only brilliant, but original.
I’ve come to expect the skill, polish, and the feeling that all the right decisions were made, in the creation of one of your puzzles, Erik. But I never take it for granted. Thank you for another gem today!
Related factoid – In two tracks in “Songs In the Key of Life”, Stevie played all the instruments, including Synthesizers, keyboards, harmonica, and drums.
DeleteThis puzzle brought a big smile to my face as soon as Steve Wonder was revealed…and Sir Duke? I dare you not to smile as soon as that wonderful catchy tune is played!
ReplyDeleteI’ll have to get into my vinyl today and play the themer album as well as Inner Visions.
Thanks Erik Agard!
All very well, but suppose you're someone who doesn't know this album" We do exist, and we do Times puzzles. I filled in every blank, shrugged and then turned to Rex's over-the-top review. Come on. A thing of beauty? Or just a bit of fan fare?
ReplyDeleteJustice for joyless music-haters!
DeleteIt’s, as the kids say, a banger. Not a single “mid” song on the album. “Isn’t she lovely” is a particlar “bop”. But to my ears, “if it’s magic” is “tier”. (My sister may have made that last one up)
DeleteThat means extra joy for you because you now get to experience a treasure you didn’t know existed
DeleteI’m excited for you to now learn about one of the greatest albums of all time (not just my opinion, but the opinion of many music critics).
DeleteLINEAR algebra became a part of the standard college mathematics curriculum in the sixties. It involves vectors and matrices.
ReplyDeleteNice puzzle. Happy to learn about this iconic album.
I loved my linear algebra classes. Thanks for enlightening us.
DeleteMy overriding memory of Stevie Wonder is working at a boat show in Earls Court, London back in the late 1970s. Every hour or so they played "Isn't She Lovely" and 3 or 4 beautiful girls in bikinis would stroll through the exhibition hall and drape themselves over the boats.
ReplyDeleteSome great songs came out of his golden period of creativity, but I rather had my fill of the boat show song. The songs that come to my mind first are not the ones in this puzzle. Superstition, You are the Sunshine of My Life,, I Just Called to Say I Love You,
A prodigious talent who transcended his musical style.
My favorite joke from Arrested Development is when GOB buys a yacht and calls it The Seaward” and Michael gets upset and tells him “GOB, get rid of The Seaward” and Lucille is standing in the doorway and says “I’ll leave when I’m good and ready”.
DeleteMy downs only attempt was derailed by Idina, Alfre and I’m coming instead of I’ll get it. Gotta love Stevie Wonder! My favorite song of his is Living for the City. Pure artistry.
ReplyDeleteHey All !
ReplyDeleteMr. Luxury YACHT from Monty Python. "It's pronounced thrift-wobbla-man-grove."
Nice tribute puz. Unsure, as Rex notes, why it wasn't run next Monday, on the actual day of said Album release. Unsure if it warrants 5 stars, but hey, to each their own. Some like Stevie Wonder, some like Gwar, some like Rap, some like TayTay. Everyone is different.
8 Cheater Squares, the 3 Blocks in the NE and SW are all Cheaters. Not complaining, just pointing out. In case you're unfamiliar with Cheater Squares, it means if you were to take the Black Square away, adding another letter, the word count wouldn't change. Unlike, say, if you took out the Black Square before RASPY, e.g., you'd then go from three words to two words.
Anyway, quick TuesPuz, nice fill.
Hope y'all have a great Tuesday!
Five F's
RooMonster
DarrinV
I thought this was way too easy, and I’m only marginally familiar with Stevie Wonder (I know his 3 or 4 BIG hits, but that’s about it, and never heard of this album). Still, it’s nice to see Rex so happy about a puzzle.
ReplyDelete5 stars for RP = no references to Harry Potter, Elon Musk, corporate-speak, IQ tests, or ESP.....
ReplyDeleteStill, Star Wars and Star Trek in the same "orbit" ought to be at least a half "star" demerit.
DeleteI'm in the Loved It group. I played this album a lot and made tapes for in the car. Re: 28D "Contents of plastic sleeves or jewel cases, informally". I entered CDS easily but didn't get the jewel case part. I had to look it up. Had never heard the term before.
ReplyDeletedon't get the clue on 28D - shouldn't jewel be capitalized?
ReplyDeleteWhy would you think jewel should be capitalized? Isn't its use here like a jewel box?
DeleteThe plastic cases that CDs come in are called jewel cases.
DeleteA tribute to an iconic album of my youth, what can be bad? I still have the vinyl somewhere, I'm hoping I also still have the Sam Goody's receipt!
ReplyDeleteSome of this was Monday easy, some clearly appropriate for Tuesdays. It all came very quickly as 21A was a gimme for anyone who's a fan and from then it was joyful to fill in STEVIEWONDER and SONGSIN and then THEKEYOFLIFE. Whether you're a fan or not, you can't say that's not some pretty fill right there!
Loved the cluing for NYC and there was some very pleasing longish stuff: CODENAME, NATION, SCARAB, SILENTZ and the in-the-language, ILLGETIT. I also liked how YALE crossed KEY.
I had just one bit of a hold-up as I pulled a John Travolta and couldn't get Ms. Menzel's first name into my head, but the crosses were all fair. As I said, just a *bit* of a hold up.
Happy birthday to your daughter, @Rex! I'm now going to dust off some vinyl and then head right to Amazon to get that magic kettle you spoke of, that is going to be a life changer in my house! (I guess I need to get out more)
Thank you for this, Eric! All around great stuff!
Normally, the happiness of others embitters me, but it's a pleasure to see RP so joyous today. Happy 26th to kiddo. Mine turned 40 in May. Whoosh.
ReplyDeleteHere's some of my usual nonsense:
"Name that's a body part backward" ISSA clue I haven't see before for RAE.
Director of the 1963 film "The Bir." ALFRE Hitchco
When I saw how high up in the theater my $200 seats were, I TIERED up.
Vampire who makes excellent pancakes: SPATULA
Thanks for the giggles!
Delete"Normally, the happiness of others embitters me" will have people wondering all day what that woman is laughing at! I also bow down to the TIERED up pun. Thanks, @Liveprof.
DeleteThis puzzle is Monday-easy, so why not publish this on Monday, September 28? The actual 50th anniversary?
ReplyDeleteIf it’s magic!
ReplyDeleteSaw the constructor and knew Rex and the community are fans. It didn't exactly exude FANFARE out of the gate, with PAL, Star Wars' OBI and URN.
ReplyDeleteBut then we got the theme and knew that Rex was gonna love it. By my count, only the second time five stars have been awarded in the Ratings Era. The write-up exuded joy, and beyond the theme itself. Put me in a good mood for the day.
Also Kenyan before LIBYAN; guess that makes sense geographically. Had Alfie before ALFRE...what's that all about? Any doubt that the clue for RAE (33A, Ear spelled backwards) was authored by Will Shortz?
Wow, a tribute puzzle to an album and an artist from a full 50 years ago, and it holds up well. We’ve all seen so many tribute puzzles fall flat, and this one did quite the opposite.
ReplyDeleteAn ambitious effort by Erik, and it paid off. I wonder what percentage of current solvers weren’t even born when the album came out - I know I remember where and when I bought my copy. Just a fun puzzle that landed - congrats and thanks to all those who were involved.
I know there's a STEVIEWONDER album called SONGSINTHEKEYOFLIFE but I have to admit I'm unfamiliar with individual titles, so SIRDUKE and IWISH took crosses. I'm sure they're great songs, as I like pretty much everything he has done. If you don't want to get up and dance when you hear "S;uperstition" , well, I can't even.
ReplyDeleteSomeday I'll remember IDINA and/or ALFRE, but today is not that day. Otherwise found the fill more interesting than our usual Tuesday. Good stuff.
Enjoyed this one a lot, EA. Everything Always looks easy and smooth with you, and thanks for all the fun.
Back to the SB. Today's pangram is going to take some work.
Solved a Tuesday downs only. Rare feat for me.
ReplyDeleteDon’t even mind having the Sir Duke Earworm for today’s inner music.
ReplyDeleteUnderstand and share the love for Stevie, but this puzzle was laughably easy. A pleasant surprise from one of my least favorite constructors.
ReplyDeleteThis puzzle raises a question in my mind: Did STEVIEWONDER what KEY LIFE was IN?
ReplyDeleteA T plus ANIME gives you time.
Didn't Simon and Garfunkel have a German hit called Die Sounds of SILENTZ?
My grandpa used to say, "If you ILLGETIT don't complain if you I'll lose it."
I was smiling bigly over @Rex's fanboy giddiness today. I loved the puzzle and its attached personal memories and I really loved the writeup. Thanks, @Rex and thanks, Erik Agard. And Happy Birthday to the 26 year old Eli!
A Stevie Wonder tribute. - great, great puzzle Erik :) And a VERY pleasant surprise on a Tuesday or any day.
ReplyDeleteNothing else to say but so good to see you. Well, maybe Erik for Editor :)
And love to hear Rex gush!
Easy. I was around and still paying attention to pop music when that album came out…so easy. Kendrick Lamar, not so much.
ReplyDeleteNo erasures or WOEs but I did need to pause to carefully process the clue for RAE.
Delightful, liked it a bunch!!
Esto significa la guerra.
ReplyDeleteGreat. A tribute puzzle to an album from 1976. Just great. Add in Star Wars, Star Trek, and Atari and I'm hoping you solved this next to a lava lamp while sitting on shag carpet. I was 12 when this album came out. I haven't been 12 in a very long time. We'd need those exponents from a few days ago to calculate my current age.
Not a five star puzzle π¦.
Hopefully this opens the door for a puzzle celebrating the life of John Wilbye and his hit madrigals from the post Italian Renaissance era. He didn't need no stinkin' Rock and Roll Hall Of Fame, nor self-congratulatory Grammy, nor even Billboard magazine. He just needed a quill and a cool song title. By the way, the Wikipedia entry for madrigals uses the word "whilst" unironically in the first paragraph. That's how you know smart people are involved.
❤️ Silent Z!
Gunkometer--
Theme gunk: People 1 Products 4
Regular gunk:
People: 3
Places: 2
Products: 4
Partials: 7
Foreignisms: 2
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 18 of 72 (25%)
With the 5 theme answers: 23 of 72 (32%)
Funny Factor: 4 π
Uniclues:
1 Beetle with the boo hoos.
2 Ones with underage girls floating on them if recent news reports are reliable, or less controversially, tubs if you happen to be three men needing a rub-a-dub-dub.
3 A Carnival Cruise when norovirus broke out.
4 "Children of the Clown Prince" for the US.
5 State of mind for egg salesmen, donut makers, and rose peddlers.
6 What Monday night does.
7 Flipzper.
8 Rats out neighbors on July 4th.
1 SCARAB POUTS (~)
2 IDEAL YACHTS
3 SAT AFLOAT SCAM (~)
4 NATION CODE NAME (~)
5 DOZENS ETHIC
6 TAKE TO TUESDAYS (~)
7 SILENT Z SPATULA (~)
8 REPORTS FANFARE
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Stole your idea. RAIDED NOGGIN.
¯\_(γ)_/¯
I enjoyed reading @Rex's euphoria, which made up for the album and its SONGS meaning nothing to me (my loss, I have no doubt) and am glad for the smiles the puzzle brought to many here. I got my joy from SPATULA, TAKE TO, and I'LL GET IT. I'll also note that I'm making progress on remembering IDINA (not IrINA) and ALFRy...no, ALFRE.
ReplyDeleteLOVED!
ReplyDeleteWait what? Your kid and best friend have birthdays on 9/21? Same here!! 1968 and 2007. Strange coincidence. Agreed - great puzzle with Stevie W.
ReplyDeleteNICE start to the day, remembering SIR DUKE* from my high school band days, back when illegal arrangements weren’t policed as they are now. @Rex’s exuberant review was even more fun than the puzzle. However, I’d award those 5 stars to the opening phrase in @Liveprof’s comment.
ReplyDeleteAdding to the fun: the symmetry of OBI and OPI, the ABRUPT shift from Star Wars to Star TREK, and those longISH semordnilap SOLIS and TUBER. (Hi, @Lewis!) But wait, the 7-letter entry REPORTS reverses to STROPER, which is not just a character in Final Fantasy and the name of an herbicide but an actual word!
stroper m (plural stropers, diminutive stropertje n)
1. poacher, marauder
TIL another word for emordinlap: “an anadrome is a word or phrase whose letters can be reversed to spell a different word or phrase.”
Congrats to @Roo on the 5 F’s - I noticed them piling up during the solve.
*This is not my band but you can get the idea.
My high school band also performed a SONGSINTHEKEYOFLIFE show back in 1999, and it was such a delight! The music really translates well to a marching show.
DeleteOnly complaint… Wanted even more Stevie Wonder crammed into this puzzle. God bless that genius
ReplyDeleteA real struggle today. My musical knowledge went out with Frank Sinatra ... and spent way too long trying to figure out what NYC has to do with monosodium glutamate. And it's only Tuesday!
ReplyDeleteI knew STEVIE WONDER, of course--I listened to him a lot when he was 12 years old and went around with a "Little" in front of his name. But by 1976 I was in my classical-and-jazz-only period, which lasted until my then-three-year-old son entered his teens and demanded rock on the radio while being driven to school. So I'd never heard of this album or any of the songs on it. But I still enjoyed the puzzle because it was easy to work out the unknown answers, and the grid had some neat easy answers like SCARAB, SILENT Z, and KRISPY (even though I live in Dunkin' -only Boston, it was fun to see it).
ReplyDeleteOK, it's almost noon, I'd better get to work!
Well, I reckon @RP liked this one.
ReplyDeleteM&A consulted his 45 singles stash this mornin, and yep ... got some Stevie Wonder tunes. Fave is "Fingertips, Part1/Part2" by a 12-year-old Stevie. It's a hoot.
staff weeject picks: OBI & OPI. Both dwellin in the primo weeject stacks, NW & SE, btw.
some fave stuff: SILENTZ. ILLGETIT. LINEAR [algebra]. [Star] TREK [II]. TUESDAYS clue. NATION clue.
Thanx for the Wonderous TuesPuz, Mr. Agard dude. Nice tributin.
Masked & Anonymo5Us
p.s.
Runt puzzle:
**gruntz**
M&A
We collect and play vinyl in our house. Songs in the Key of Life is still, 50 years on, a rare, perfect album.
ReplyDeleteI prefer my puzzles without trivia. I like wordplay. Still easy, in spite of myself.
ReplyDeleteReally surprised you liked this one this much, Rex! Every single other tribute puzzle like this you've ever done you haven't liked, because it's just a list of facts. You always wonder why there wasn't more to it, some wordplay, something beyond just a list. I wonder (ha), if you didn't know who the constructor was going in, would you have liked it this much?
ReplyDeleteFive stars? Unprecedented, surely! I didn't looooove it quite as much as Rex because:
ReplyDelete1. While I definitely like Stevie and all the songs, I didn't know their names or the name of the album.
2. I foolishly tried to solve this down clues only, which left me no hope of seeing the theme until I finally gave up and read some across clues. This is totally my fault, but still...
Anyway, as a bonus now I know the names, especially SIR DUKE which is a great tune. Not sure I will remember I WISH as it's a kinda forgettable title.
Two totally Unknown Names, which is not horrible: IDINA and ALFRE.
Oh, and I've never used whistling KETTLES. All my life we've had the plug-in ones, not the stovetop type. I think maybe they don't have to whistle because they shut themselves off? And I seem to recall they didn't used to be nearly as common in the U.S... am I remembering correctly?
I was in grad school in '76 and barely remember the album. STEVIE WONDER, yes, but I mistakenly put in SONGS IN THE KEY OF LOVE for the album title.
ReplyDeleteShouldn't the plural of ROOF be ROOVES? Speaking of plurals, the fill relies on them quite a bit when POUT, TUESDAY, ARENA, BEND, YACHT, REPORT, NDA, SILO, CD, KETTLE and DOZEN all come up short of their slots. POC to the rescue.
Puzzle was easy and fine, only complaint is that onus is an obligation that one dislikes, not all obligations are onuses. Stevie Wonder is a wonderful musician and "Songs..." is great. It was the 2nd best seller of 1977, losing out to Rumours (no justice in the world). My freshman (in 1978) college roommate was a blues fan, I was clueless. He put on a great blues album and told me I should recognize the band as they had the #1 album last year. I was confused until he showed me the cover of Fleetwood Mac's "Then Play On" and then I was more confused. How could the same band make such completely different music (mostly different band members is how). According to Wikipedia they made Rumours with the intention of making a commercially successful album.
ReplyDeleteThe symmetry of obi and opi is a beautiful little touch
ReplyDeleteI almost always enjoy an Eric Agard puzzle but this one didn’t really do it for me. Tribute puzzles are always problematic. If you’re not a fan of the subject, they can flop. I am sort of a fan of Stevie Wonder, just not a superfan. If I’m driving down the road listening to the oldies station and they decide to play Superstition, I’m pleased. Good stuff from a fine performer but I don’t know the whole SW canon. I recognized most of the tunes superfan @Rex posted but I didn’t know the titles. And, as D-O solver on Tuesdays, I was extra irritated. My fault, I know, I could have solved normally but, still …
ReplyDeleteMy mother gave me Songs In The Key Of Life for Christmas 1976 when I was a kid. I still have that vinyl copy (except for the lost 7" bonus record). It always will be one of my favorites.
ReplyDeleteLove Stevie wonder . what is bloc party - /nation ?
ReplyDeleteAlso lived in nyc for many years never referred to Madison square garden as msg .
To those who were surprised by the five star rating, Rex has always said his reviews are HIS very personal, often immediate, reaction to a puzzle. So it makes perfect sense. As he noted, he had previously said, how excited he was to go to the concert. Plus the connection with his best friend. And it is a good puzzle after all.
ReplyDeleteOddly, I have always been fascinated by the album title. The title is brilliant. But I now realize I never knew anything about the album. SIR DUKE. Never remember hearing the song title but upon listening ( thanks for the link Rex) oh I heard that song many times. But not among my favorite songs of his.
Songs w
But as someone else said, reading the review made me happy!
Songs learned abd loved at a young age have a powerful impact on you for the rest of your life.
Erik Agard scored TWO marquee puzzles today. Here, NYT, AND The New Yorker. And the latter (much more Friday NYT) has a wonderful Rex-ian whoosh whoosh. Maybe not 5* but close. I'm afraid next to Not fair, Above it all over Transgress, etc.
ReplyDeleteI think in the history of Rex star-ratings, the only two five-star puzzles were on a Monday and a Tuesday. Just pointing that out, as someone who actually enjoys themes and has to take long-time-solvers’ word for it that themeless is beautiful when you know what you’re doing, that sometimes a good theme can give the puzzle that extra bit of mwah.
ReplyDeleteThe SHUI/SCARAB crossing wouldn’t be Monday-appropriate, but I totally agree that it should have been run on the actual anniversary anyway regardless.
Knew Stevie Wonder but never listened to him. In 1976 I was totally into the Ramones.
ReplyDeleteThis puzzle makes me so happy I do the puzzles at night. I can sit back with an adult beverage and listen to Stevie. Lovely.
ReplyDeleteJFC, every time. GRAIN does NOT go into a silo. SILAGE goes in a silo. Grain goes in a GRANARY
ReplyDeleteAnother great solve from Erik — the STEVIE WONDER / SONGS IN THE KEY OF LIFE reveal had me smiling all the way down. Rex's write-up finally sold me on giving that album a proper front-to-back listen, so I'm putting it on this afternoon. After the crossword I picked up my morning Wordle hints over at thewordlehint.com (https://thewordlehint.com/) — one good puzzle deserves another!
ReplyDelete