Monday, October 20, 2025

Last language alphabetically on Google Translate / MON 10-20-25 / Music genre that Joan Jett "loves" / Two-part steakhouse entree / 50 years, for Bilbo Baggins in "The Hobbit"

Constructor: Adam Aaronson

Relative difficulty: Challenging (when solved Downs-only; otherwise probably "Easy," I don't know)


THEME: AD FREE (55D: Not interrupted by commercials ... or shortened like the middle words of 20-, 30-, 48- and 60-Across) — in four theme answers, the word "AND" is presented AD-FREE (i.e. free of the letters "A" and "D"):

Theme answers:
  • COOKIES 'N' CREAM (20A: Milkshake flavor made with Oreos)
  • ROCK 'N' ROLL (30A: Music genre that Joan Jett "loves")
  • SURF 'N' TURF (48A: Two-part steakhouse entree)
  • SCRATCH 'N' SNIFF (60A: Like some scented stickers)
Word of the Day: HAYAO Miyazaki (56A: Filmmaker Miyazaki) —
Hayao Miyazaki
 (宮崎 駿 or 宮﨑 駿Miyazaki Hayao[mijaꜜzaki hajao]; born January 5, 1941) is a Japanese animator, filmmaker, and manga artist. He co-founded Studio Ghibli and serves as honorary chairman. Throughout his career, Miyazaki has attained international acclaim as a masterful storyteller and creator of Japanese animated feature films, and is widely regarded as one of the most accomplished filmmakers in the history of animation. [...] Miyazaki co-founded Studio Ghibli in 1985, writing and directing films such as Laputa: Castle in the Sky (1986), My Neighbor Totoro (1988), Kiki's Delivery Service (1989), and Porco Rosso (1992), which were met with critical and commercial success in Japan. Miyazaki's Princess Mononoke (1997) was the first animated film to win the Japan Academy Film Prize for Picture of the Year and briefly became the highest-grossing film in Japan; its Western distribution increased Ghibli's worldwide popularity and influence. Spirited Away (2001) became Japan's highest-grossing film and won the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature; it is frequently ranked among the greatest films of the 21st century. Miyazaki's later films—Howl's Moving Castle (2004), Ponyo (2008), and The Wind Rises (2013)—also enjoyed critical and commercial success. He retired from feature films in 2013 but later returned to make The Boy and the Heron (2023), which won the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature. (wikipedia)
• • •


There's a jokey revealer, which is cute, but otherwise this is a fairly dull theme, in that it's just a bunch of ___ 'N' ___ phrases. AD-FREE just doesn't seem like an interesting enough phrase or a clever enough punchline to justify a puzzle whose themer set is that listless. The fill seemed listless as well, with overcommon stuff like ARLO at ATBAT and IPAD and BLAT and ICU and ELON dominating, and then the bizarrely adjectivized AFROED making things awkward. DRUM SOLO isn't bad, especially alongside BAZAAR, but that's about the only real high point in the grid. The whole puzzle seemed like a long way to go for a tepid revealer, and the road to the revealer just didn't have enough sparkle. So the revealer is clever, but the overall solving experience was unsatisfying.

[8D: Band with the aptly titled debut album "High Voltage"]

As a Downs-only solve, this ended up being brutal for me. Fatal, in fact. There was just no way I was ever going to get VERY SAME. I don't even feel that bad about the fail. If I'd been more patient, maybe I could've gotten there, but I needed to get on with things, so I looked at an Across clue or two; thus: fail. VERY SAME ... [Aforementioned] ... I suppose those are equivalents, but I was not looking for a two-word phrase, and even when the first part looked like VERY, I couldn't imagine how the phrase would conclude. I was thinking of common uses of "aforementioned," and in most cases VERY SAME would be a very unclear substitute. Here's the first (recent) real-world example of "VERY SAME" at m-w.com:
The Public happens to be the very same venue where Hamilton made its off-Broadway debut in February 2015, before moving to Broadway's Richard Rodgers Theatre that August.Erin Clack, PEOPLE, 19 Oct. 2025
Doesn't mean "aforementioned" in that case at all. These examples are better:
Yet the very same murmur can also appear when the heart is structurally normal and healthy.Joshua Hutcheson, The Conversation, 16 Oct. 2025Because Kacie herself was also asking that very same question after finding out that her ex-fiancé Patrick Suzuki was there.Sydney Bucksbaum, Entertainment Weekly, 8 Oct. 2025
VERY SAME is way more colloquial than mere "aforementioned." and requires a much clearer, more proximate referent. I could drift away from my topic and then use "aforementioned" to bring you right back, whereas if I used "VERY SAME," I'd need to have just been talking about whatever I was talking about for it to make sense. Again, [Aforementioned] is a defensible clue, just a vague and rather unclear one, to my brain (obviously).  I had V-R-S--E and no idea. All the crosses could've been other multiple things: AGE / AGO, FRAT / FRET, LIMO / LIPO. I also had no real idea about FACTOR, which seemed so oddly clued (49D: Decision-making consideration). Seems like a synonym of [Consideration] all on its own. I wrote in FACETS, and then eventually did write in FACTOR, but wasn't at all sure of it. The fact that HA--O looked like nonsense, like I must've had an error, didn't help matters. Even if I had been able to look at the clue at 56A: Filmmaker Miyazaki, I'm not entirely confident I could've remembered his first name without help from crosses. This is only HAYAO's third NYTXW appearance, and the first on a Monday. "Miyazaki" is a name I know very well, but HAYAO ... not so much; inability to see HAYAO definitely factored into my VERY SAME failure. Can't believe we've had Miyazaki's first name three times now, but still haven't had Yasujiro OZU's last name even once. "Widely regarded as one of the world's greatest and most influential filmmakers" (wikipedia), and still ... nothing. [note, as with Miyazaki, I know OZU's last name extremely well but always have to look up his first name to be sure]


A couple other answers gave me some trouble, from a Downs-only perspective. That NW corner was a disaster for me at the start, as I had PERIOD before PAROLE (2D: End of some sentences), I guessed AFROED but it felt wrong, and then I had the talk show host's "furniture piece" as a SOFA, not a DESK (4D: Furniture piece for a talk show host). I also found BRING ON hard to get, as well as CUP. I was thinking of "units" that flour actually comes in, how it's packaged. A unit of anything is a CUP if you want it to be. Anything liquid or granular, anyway. The CUP is the unit. The "flour" part seems arbitrary. I also have no idea what notes are in a G major scale, so -SHARP was a crap shoot. Just had to wait to see what the Across looked like. Not exactly fun. Oh well, better luck next Monday. Or tomorrow.


That's all. See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️: 
  • Venmo (@MichaelDavidSharp)]
=============================
✏️ Upcoming Crossword Tournaments ✏️
=============================
📘 My other blog 📘:

90 comments:

  1. Anonymous6:03 AM

    If it makes you feel any better, I had a personal Natick at VERYSAME/HAYAO to finish the puzzle, and had to blindly just put in letters until the puzzle completed.

    Axl Rose at least was a pretty prolific social media poster over on Twitter at one time, and stayed in character by shortening every “and” in every tweet to ‘n’. This puzzle reminded me of that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous9:01 AM

      I struggled with the same square.

      Delete
    2. Anonymous2:05 PM

      ‘n’is not shorter than and

      Delete
    3. Anonymous3:03 PM

      Very same here!

      Delete
  2. I left my PAD to go pick up my BRIDE to be, LOBNUNLOO, and take her to the ACDC CAFE to hear a POP SONG or two and try
    food. MERCI, her UBER friend suggested we eat some RAVIOLI or maybe have a SHORT RIB TURF. The FRAT BRO in charge had a BDAY so we ate some COOKIES. "I like CREAM with them" whispered ARLO but after one SNIFF, we had to SCRATCH that because it went bad...

    The CAFE was fun. The TURF belonged to the ZULU BRO and YOU never TIRE of watching him ROLL REFERS or drink RED ROCK ALE. Never a SLOG and the POP SONG playing on the DRUM is AD FREE; you can even SURF for a TRIVIA SONG.

    "You should come to our OASIS" shouted LOBNUNLOO. "YOU can eat EXTRA RED TURF or if cook ASKS, the ICU BLAS fish is the SURF to go with the TURF."

    A MERCI ALERT LEAPS out for the TRIVIA game. "Does AGUA go into an ICE CAP IGLOO?" My BRIDE is AT BAT and she LEAPS to answer SI SI SI. No ERRS for her so she gets COOKIES N CREAM. "We're on a FREE ROLL, so we ACT VERY UBER" they all shouted.

    The TRIVIA game is OVER and people are now at EASE. The ACDC CAFE is slowly emptying and now it's time to take LOBNUNLOO back to my PAD in the waiting LIMO. This is VERY HAYAO and now it's time to celebrate a BDAY.

    The time FLU by but we had LEAPS of EXTRA UBER FUN today. And that's the truth, don't you think

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So good to see you again!

      Delete
    2. Good to see you lady!

      Delete
    3. So wonderful to have you back here, @GILL! Especially for one of your your crazy, imaginative and slightly off-the-wall Monday sagas. Hope to be seeing you here often again!

      Delete
    4. Hola! Demasiado tiempo sin verte.

      Delete
    5. All's right with the world.

      Delete
    6. Can't tell you how much I miss these when you are away.

      Delete
    7. Best part of today’s puzzle activities? @Gill is back!!

      Delete
    8. @GILL I. 6:32 AM
      And the world is set aright again. Thanks for the fun.

      Delete
  3. Bob Mills6:46 AM

    I was OK with VERYSAME/HAYAO cross, but I Naticked with "top song" instead of POPSONG. I think my answer fits the clue better.

    ReplyDelete
  4. By no means a Real Crossword Solver, but I thought this was rather enjoyably engaging for a Monday. More like a Tuesday in terms of difficulty. No complaints!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Tough one today - but a rare opportunity to link to Tim Minchin's off-key melody: https://youtu.be/5Ju8Wxmrk3s?si=8E5ilc0_RJB_xFuf

    ReplyDelete
  6. I was surprised when I got the happy music, as I didn’t trust VERY SAME as the answer (but couldn’t think of anything else to try) and HAYAO means nothing to me. Rex gave VERY SAME a fair shot, and it’s probably close enough for CrossWorld, so we’ll leave it there and move on.

    I don’t recall seeing NIHAO in a puzzle before, which seems a little weird because it looks pretty grid-friendly. I doubt it will ever reach the same Xword stature as ALOHA though.

    I enjoyed seeing OREOS in the clue instead of as an answer for a change (and Joan Jett - I wonder if she likes COOKIES N CREAM).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. NIHAO has definitely appeared before. I was surprised to see it in a Monday though.

      Delete
  7. Anonymous7:05 AM

    I don’t agree “aforementioned” is a legitimate clue for “very same,” even when one could be swapped for the other in a sentence. “Very same” means “identical.” It doesn’t mean “previously stated.” The gulf is just too wide.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I was moving along, thinking that this was an uninspired theme, then got to the revealer which completely saved it.

    I don't think I ever saw the clue for HAYAO, but that would have been a big WoE for me, as was NIHAO, where I wanted NIHAu or NIHAi. And with that weird clue for KNOTS I almost went with NIHAi/KNiTS.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I had the VERY SAME errors in the NW, and the VERY SAME fatal gap in the SW (as a downs-only solve).

    Apparently I've been reading this blog long enough that I'm actually channeling Rex now...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous2:20 PM

      I often use “same” to mean “aforementioned” in my time records. For example: “Reviewed court decision; telephone call with client about same”. But I agree that “very same” is not used this way.

      Delete
  10. I never even saw the revealer. That down clue just filled in with all the acrosses. So it left me very underwhelmed.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I liked the puzzle more than @Rex but it’s a bit strange when right out of the box you see 1a and you are working the puzzle on an IPAD. I’d also note that I didn’t even pause in filling in the grid (I do that weird thing of “across” solving)until I got to Joan Jett. Hey…I said I paused…I didn’t say “ I (don’t) love ROCKNROLL.”
    Interesting that VERYSAME gave me pause. I agree with Rex it is NOT colloquial BUT…as an attorney, I spent a lot of time looking at legal documents with “aforementioned” this and that.
    All in all a pleasant Monday!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I liked how uncovering the solo N in two theme answers easified getting the other two. I liked uncovering AD FREE after trying hard to guess it, and smiled at how clever it is.

    Truly, give me a tough smart riddle, and I’m happy if I get it and happy if I don’t (because the sweet effort satisfies my brain’s workout ethic).

    I liked having my five senses pinged through the theme answers alone, and echoed elsewhere in the grid. I heard a DRUM SOLO, tasted RAVIOLI, took in the aroma of COOKIES N CREAM, even flashed on an image of TRACHEA.

    I liked that AT BAT is up – Hah! I liked the four U-enders (FLU, ICU, YOU, ZULU, and wannabe IGLOO). I liked the AD in IPAD as a theme echo.

    Thus, a splendid outing. Thank you so much for making this, Adam!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hey All !
    I for one thought the Revealer was a hoot! A-D-FREE! I was wondering how to get the AND(&) in there, ended up getting NOR to see the N in SURFNTURF, then got to the Revealer, saw it as ADFREE, and chuckled at such an apropos reveal.

    Even has an F looking SHARP! Har

    Neat puz. Common "AND" things with the N.
    Guns N Roses is another. I thought the fill was OK. Clunkers (or junk, if you prefer) are in every puz. Nature of puzzledom.

    I do see a potential tough spot in the cross of VERY SAME/HAYAO. That Y was my letter in. Also, NIHAO is known-ish, but tough to remember how to spell. But, that one is fairly crossed.

    Anyway, back to my DESK to do Wordle and Connections. Have a great Monday!

    Six F's - BRO!
    RooMonster
    DarrinV

    ReplyDelete
  14. Stan Marsh7:58 AM

    I thought the puzzle was fine. The revealer was cute and placed perfectly. My only criticism is in an ad-free puzzle why would you have an ad in 1a? Which also lead to the unfortunate afroed.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Andy Freude8:02 AM

    Rex, welcome to the world of the downs-mostly solve, where I usually spend my Mondays and Tuesdays. Nothing wrong with the occasional peek at an across clue, especially when the down answer is a real head-scratcher like VERY SAME.

    With that easing of the downs-only pressure, I found this a very satisfying Monday. Cute theme, good execution. My only nit: the clue for F SHARP was too keyboard-centric. Oboe players don’t think of G major in terms of black keys and white keys. On the other hand, their instrument shows up in the grid more than any other.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous9:57 AM

      Well, but the fact that it talked about black keys tipped you off that it was talking about a keyboard.

      Delete
    2. You're right. I guess you could put "accidental" instead of "black key", but I think that might take it out of Monday territory.

      Delete
    3. @Andy Freude. You're right that oboe shows up far nore often in crosswords than piano but I'd guess that far more solvers play piano than play oboe. Makes the key focus just fine with me.

      Delete
  16. Diane Joan8:07 AM

    The puzzle was indeed Monday easy if solved using both across and down clues. It was fun! However “very same” was the last one in for me even with crosses.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Anonymous8:09 AM

    Enjoyable downs-only solve here. VERY SAME came once RAVIOLI supplied the V. Had PeRiod before PAROLE and took a while to see BLAT, but having the revealer among the downs definitely helped.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I didn’t even see VERYSAME, it having been filled in with the acrosses.

    Very easy solving normally. I start across only, just typing answers as fast as I can read them, then make a pass doing the remaining down squares, then touch up the few leftovers.

    Good revealer, fun enough for a Monday.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Niallhost8:27 AM

    VERY SAME problem = Same

    ReplyDelete
  20. Anonymous8:30 AM

    I enjoyed the theme and revealer more than most it seems. Did feel like some clues were Tuesday level which is fine. Haven’t seen anyone comment on this yet but my biggest gripe (outside of VERY SAME) was the clue for ICU - every “hospital area” has IVs…the OR, the ED, the regular floor. Nothing special about IVs in an ICU. Might as well of had the clue say “hospital area”.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Anonymous8:32 AM

    Solving downs only, I had DSHARP and then wondered what on earth the NTURD answer was going to be.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Down only disaster! Had to look at across clues early on. Maybe, like Rex, I could have struggled and persevered more, but I lost patience. Not a bad puzzle, though!

    ReplyDelete
  23. Alexscott688:38 AM

    I never do downs (or acrosses) only, but the acrosses were so easy I just filled in the entire grid without having to look at the down clues, in way less than my normal Monday time. When I went back to look at the downs, I had to laugh because the clues n’ answers seemed so much harder than the acrosses. Sure enough, this is the first Monday I can recall Rex giving a “challenging” rating.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Anonymous8:41 AM

    Not challenging if not solved Downs-only, but lots of fun. Clever misdirect right away with PAROLE instead of period for "end of some sentences." All the theme answers were cute and fresh. I didn't know how to spell NIHAO but got it easily from the crosses. A perfect Monday, in my mind. Thanks, Adam!

    ReplyDelete
  25. David Grenier8:48 AM

    Got the gist of the theme after COOKIES N CREAM and ROCK N ROLL (it’s a Monday, after all). Jumped down to the revealer and couldn’t for the life of me figure out what it might be. I organically got to that part of the puzzle and had enough crosses to get it, but it took me a second to parse it properly. When I did it gave me a big grin. I enjoyed it a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  26. I quite liked the theme and didn’t see the amusing revealer coming. The theme made me think about examples that must carry the ‘N’ because 'and' would be wrong (like Guns N’ Roses), versus instances in which ‘and’ and ‘N’ are interchangeable and both are acceptable. It strikes me that the four themers here are mostly in the latter category – you often see them written with ‘N,” but they’re equally correct and comprehensible with ‘and.’ The possible exception is COOKIES ‘N’ CREAM when used as a trademark.

    I avoided the potential Asian-language naticks. I didn’t see the clue for NIHAO because I happened to be solving downs in that area and, with HAYAO, I less trouble than some in getting VERY SAME, although I thought it had at best a slippery relationship with its clue.

    Noted the mini-land-transportation theme with LIMO, UBER, PEDAL and TIRE. My husband and I are feeling positively disposed toward Michelin TIREs these days, as we had to acquire one on an emergency basis during a recent trip. We drove to Prince Edward County, a triangular peninsula that sticks into Lake Ontario from its northern shore. It’s a lovely spot with wineries, cideries, cheeseries, craft breweries, art galleries and artists’ and craftspeople’s studios, two provincial parks, and a bunch of friendly inhabitants. On the way there, we hit a level crossing that wasn't level enough, and it dealt a fatal blow to one of the back tires. We didn't discover it until the next day, when we were leaving the charmingly named Mad Dog Art Gallery (which, contrary to expectation, featured two amiable cats who followed us around looking for pats as we examined the art). When we came out and approached the car, we saw a large, scary bulge on the side of the afflicted tire. CAA came and put on the donut spare and we knew it was fine for all the sightseeing we wanted to do but, according to the specs, it was unwise to drive home on it. So, temporarily, we had to remove our tourist hats, and research the local tire shops. We found an accommodating one which was able to get the tire we needed for the next day. Yay! Some day I’ll tell you the related story of the Great Alfa Romeo Migration – stay tuned.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Made the mistake of renting a car in Ireland a few years ago. The roads are so narrow that every oncoming car seemed like it would be a direct hit. And the buses: fuhgedaboutit. So I kept veering over and tore up a tire on a curb. We were in the middle of nowhere on a Sunday and discovered we lacked a spare, but we called the help number the company gave us and a wonderful local guy came by in a van that was a rolling tire repair/replace shop. Couldn't see his wings, but he was an angel from above.

      Delete
  27. Anonymous9:06 AM

    Nice nod to his name from ADam the constructor! Tricky Monday but got there in the end.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Inuit luxury is an IGLOO LOO. And I'm not even gonna get into the ZULU, 'cuz it's for the birds.

    If you wanna play a T-Ball game, you better get ATBAT.

    You could tell that the anagrammer was geographically confused when he said NIHAO in HANOI.

    I love the perfectly placed NOR at 50D. If you happened to start the puzzle at 48A, you might think that the gimmick was negating "and" in familiar phrases to produce hilarious new ones like SURF NOR TURF. Could be a vegan entree.


    Clever how the puzzle starts right out with IPAD, which in ADFREE speak becomes IPN. Combined with 31D, this becomes IPN CUP, which is what I say at my monthly doping test. I liked the puzzle, although the answer to 10D was just BAZAAR. Thanks, Adam Aaronson.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Easy downs only. Can someone explain BLAT to me, though? That was a happy guess.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. onomatopoeia for a poorly played trumpet sound.

      Delete
  30. Anonymous9:28 AM

    Anytime that a majority of the comments suggest that they had the same Natick (Hayao / Verysame) means that the puzzle needed an edit. And to happen on a Monday too? Woof. Inexcusable.

    ReplyDelete
  31. This theme ain’t half b, in fact, it’s the best thing since sliced bre. I ore it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. EasyEd9:39 AM

      Good one! Your affinity for language is amazing.

      Delete
    2. @Lewis, you've sure got the he for this stuff.

      Delete
  32. EasyEd9:51 AM

    Hand up with the rest of the crowd who had trouble with VERYSAME crossing HAYAO. Completely missed the revealer, so thanks Rex and fellow bloggers. NIHAOma(?) rolls off the tongue in Mandarin as a question with a slight tonal dip in the HAO part. It’s generally a warm greeting but without the upbeat inference of an Aloha…anyway, that’s my feeling for it..

    ReplyDelete
  33. Nice, basic puztheme with a cool revealer. But, but ... All the themers are D-free, but not A-free, btw.

    AFROED? har

    staff weeject pick: AGE. Mainly because it was a piece of unknown Bilbo Baggins TRIVIA, at our house.

    fave moo-cow eazy-E MonPuz clue: {Thanks, in France} = MERCI. Always appreciate a MonPuz that ain't a no-merci solvequest.

    other faves: VERYSAME [debut]. ZULU. RAVIOLI. ALL+YOU can eat.
    no-knows: HAYAO. NIHAO. Bilbo's AGE. And maybe borderline, on that there BLAT.

    Merci for the ad-free fun, Mr. Aaronson dude.

    Masked & Anonymo6Us

    ... and now for a Friday Flick Schlockfest inspired rodeo ...

    "Colorful Spooky Flicks" - 7x7 themed runt puzzle:

    **gruntz**

    Spooky M&A

    ReplyDelete
  34. Anonymous10:04 AM

    I'd be ready 'n' willin to solve another puzzle like this one any time, it was such fun. Great theme and I don't think the puzzle maker has any obligation to make it easy for Downs-only solvers. All the answers were gettable if you approached it the usual way, filling in an answer and then taking off from its letters to solve its crosses. No leftover odds 'n' ends that way! A-plus, Adam.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Anonymous10:21 AM

    I appreciated having ARLO crossed with the restaurant catchphrase clue.

    ReplyDelete
  36. from a typical solving perspective, I enjoyed this one - lots of Monday quickness with enough tricky bits to make me feel like I was solving a puzzle. Maybe it's the lack of sleep, but I thought the revealer was cute - especially since the gimmick is clear, and I had no idea what was going to tie them together. Plus, always happy to start the week with Joan Jett.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Rex, I think you've got it backward. VERY SAME doesn't always mean aforementioned, but aforementioned always means VERY SAME. At least, that's how I always read words. As for CUP, I can see one wouldn't think of that word while shopping for flour; but once you start to cook with it, the CUP is the relevant unit of measure (at least in the USA--I guess most other place will measure in grams).

    My eldest son and his wife named their second cat NIHAO. It was a couple years later I learned that it wasn't spelled 'knee-how,' and a few more when I learned what it meant. But that long process reinforced the memory -- I'd never have got it otherwise.

    I'm in "the revealer makes it all worth it" camp.

    ReplyDelete
  38. I've been thinking of giving Downs-only a try, but I'm glad I didn't start today. I found this slightly harder than a normal Monday, even with the acrosses in hand. If Rex found Downs-only challenging, I'm not sure what hope I would have had.

    It's just my twitchy nature that the shortening of "and" to 'N annoys me somehow. Part of it may be that the shortening gives a whiff of an advertiser's contrivance, to make the product name seem jazzily colloquial, and this to me has a ring of fakeness to it. (In other words, not AD-FREE! Since advertiser-speak is embedded in the phrases.) Anyway, such phrases did not endear me to this puzzle. But clearly this is a me-thing. If the 'N thing gladdens your heart, then I'll be happy for you.

    All that said, I thought the intended meaning of AD-FREE was very clever. Certainly this theme has potential.

    Like Rex, I fell into the trap of putting in PeRiod before PAROLE, and like Rex I thought AFROED looked weird. Very weird.

    I'm not sure I feel as strongly as he does about VERY SAME. To me, "aforementioned" is pretty close to "same as above", and VERY SAME would function as an emphatic variant. One version of Joaquin's Dictum that works for me is that the answer should be capable of subbing in for the clue, where "capable of" implies "under some circumstances", and not necessarily "under all circumstances". The better examples that Rex gave in his write-up show that this principle of cluing is being adhered to here.

    I just looked to check whether ARLO Guthrie is still alive. He is, but not performing so much these days. Not quite a ROCK 'N ROLL guy; that would be more for the professionals like AC/DC. His only real POP SONG (one that hit the top 40) was City of New Orleans, which I love. Not so much the song Alice's Restaurant; I'd much rather read the lyrics, which I can do at my EASE and at my own speed, rather than submit to the 18' 34'' of Guthrie's discursive telling of a shaggy dog story. (As I said, I can be a little twitchy.)

    Time to get to work. Hope you have a pleasant day.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @tht -- I think that your seeing the use of "n" instead of "and" as an advertiser's contrivance and a prime example of ad-speak is just about the most perspicacious comment on the blog today. I never thought of it in those terms -- and boy does it add some unintended irony to the AD FREE revealer. (But I enjoyed the revealer a lot anyway.)

      Delete
    2. @tht and @Nancy…great comment on ad speak AND reply! Haha…sometimes it takes me a while to have comments “soak in,” even when I read them!

      Delete
    3. And Nancy…YOU GET kudos for the use of perspicacious!

      Delete
    4. @tht. Thanks for reminding me of Alice's restaurant. Back in the late sixties/early seventies when I was trying to avoid my somewhat oppressive family situation by living in a sympathetic neighbour's basement, I would do my high school homework while listening to an "alternative" FM station (though I don't remember the term being used then, but it was certainly not standard top-40 stuff). Sometime about midnight or 1 am I might call in to chat with the DJ. (You could do that back then and the late night guy, John Tanner, was easy enough have a relaxed conversation with). One night he interrupted our conversation to say, "Look, Les, I've got to get out for a smoke. Gotta request?" Well, if you'd play Alice's Restaurant you could fit in two smokes at least." "Great idea."

      Next time it was "Got any two smoke requests?" "Um, In-a-gadda-da-vida?" "Good call." And so on.

      Oh yeah, Alice's Restaurant is way more than a shaggy dog story.

      Delete
    5. @Nancy -- thank you for saying so! (And I share @Beezer's liking of the word "perspicacious".)

      @Les -- that's a nice story! I don't relate to the smoking much, but the vibe is still a good one. How times have changed.

      Delete
    6. Well. Thanks to you both for reminding me that the movie “Alice’s Restaurant” was rated R when it came out (1969) and I somehow managed to get in (with at least one other person) at age 14. Man…today, so NOT an R rated movie. Also that year I was in study hall (across a table) from a sophomore who introduced me to Ina Godda da Vida (sic) accompanied by his pencil drum beats. Obviously the study hall wasn’t monitored well.

      Delete
    7. @Les - what a great story!

      Delete
  39. Very nice downs-only Monday except for one big outlier. 56A HAYAO. Working D-O, I had no idea that I was looking for a Japanese name and even if I did, I would have no idea who Mr. Miyazaki is or what his first name is. I just had to trust the crosses and pray. Not a Monday answer, I think.
    But that was only part of what made the SW the toughest section for me. I had trouble connecting “Aforementioned” with VERY SAME but when I finally did I thought it was great. Another FACTOR of my difficult time down there was … you guessed it … FACTOR, which was just so straightforwardly obvious that I couldn’t see it. Aargh! FLU also tripped me up. “It goes around every year” sent me in search of something orbiting, not infecting.

    The rest of the puzzle was pretty easy and fun but, of course, I still have some nits to pick. IGLOO at 21D kind of bugged me because the clue says “Inuit’s home” which implies a long-term residency. Igloos are temporary shelters usually constructed while out hunting. Once again, check out North of North to see how modern day Inuit live, and have a bit of a laugh. It’s on Netflix.

    Is 2D PAROLE the end of a sentence or just a continuation of a sentence under altered terms? And who okayed AFROED (3D)?

    With the exception of the aforementioned HAYAO and possibly NIHAO, all the acrosses seemed, upon review, to be pretty easy and the themers were a lot of fun. Nice way to start the week. Too bad we couldn’t fit a serving of Mac’n’Cheese in there.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Try as I might, I couldn't come up with a revealer that explained the theme. Anyone? I think it's a really good revealer. And while the theme makes the puzzle quite easy, the Mandarin and the Japanese name make it considerably harder in places than most Mondays.

    I guess if something is aforementioned, it has to be the VERY SAME, right? But I challenge anyone to find a sentence in which you would substitute either one for the other one and have the sentence make much sense. Awful clue, I'd say -- I wouldn't even like it on a Saturday.

    High point of the morning is @GILL's very welcome post.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @Nancy, you may have seen my post but unfortunately (I think many attorneys would agree) it is used in “legalese” once something is identified. Like one might say “the blue 1966 Schwinn bicycle with a banana seat” and later say “the aforementioned bicycle.” I know…Sheesh.

      Delete
    2. Oh. Of course I’m an OLDSTER, nowadays “aforementioned” has been replaced by parens and quote marks after description like (“the bicycle”) which essentially designates “hereinafter referred to”. TMI

      Delete
    3. I'll give it a crack: "Tom decided to take a long walk in the city neighborhood, to help shake off his jet lag. Not knowing where he was going really, and still in a state of lassitude, he acted on some obscure impulse and entered a clothing store, some old tweedy place called Maxwell's. He was never one for shopping, but with his recent arrival, he thought he might try out a new look for himself. Starting with this rakish-looking hat he found on display, one that reminded him of hats his father used to wear.

      "Somewhat to his surprise, over the next couple of days he received many compliments on his new hat, and his self-confidence began to soar. Later that week, he returned to the aforementioned store, and to his delight found there a pair of shoes that were perfect for the look he was imagining for himself."

      Okay, that was perhaps a little over-elaborated, but I wanted to set it up. To my ear, you could substitute "very same" for "aforementioned" ("very" acting merely as an amplifier) and it would ring true. Or you could substitute in the opposite direction and use the slightly old-fashioned "aforementioned", with its somewhat tweedy overtones.

      Delete
  41. I didn't think the puzzle needed a revealer - the theme answers were all the same type and I was happy with that. Reading Rex and finding out there was a revealer, I went looking and thought it very charming.

    I had Rex's PeRiod before PAROLE but otherwise this puzzle was easy except for the VERY SAME area.

    Thanks, Adam Aaronson!

    ReplyDelete
  42. I'm in the ??? crowd for HAYAO and NIHAO today. HAYAO was going to be impossible, as was VERYSAME but only because I misread the clue for RAVIOLI, which should have been obvious, and somehow came up with CANNOLI. This does not work.

    Fun fact: ARLO Guthrie's grandson has followed the family tradition and become a good folksinger. He lives in VT and I had a chance to talk to him last summer after he performed "This Land Is Your Land" for his finale from the same spot where I had sung it a couple of months earlier during an anti-Trump rally. Nice moment.

    I remember seeing someone's rant against the use of "N" for and expressed as an undertaker's business called "Caskets N Things".

    Seems like I've been seeing the missing letters trick in other puzzles lately, but I like it.

    Nice Monday, AA. Anything ADFREE is aces with me, and thanks for all the fun.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Thanks for the welcome backs. I'm going through some rough patches but Monday foolery is something even I look forward to. I should be back in full regalia before the holidays....cross fingers. I really miss the blog and all of you.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Medium i. HAYAO was it for WOEs and no costly erasures, just fat fingers.

    I got the N thing early on but the revealer was a surprise and hoot which made AFROED forgivable, liked it quite a bit more than @Rex did.



    Croce Solvers - Croce’s Freestyle #1054 was an easy Croce for me. Less than 1.5X a medium NYT Saturday. No real problems anywhere, good luck!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Croce 1054 was a new record for speed for me - seven seconds faster than 1034.

      Delete
  45. Hats off to the constructor for seeing the theme potential in AD-FREE and for illustrating it with four iconic phrases. Favorite non-theme moment: figuring out VERYSAME.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Rafael Musa has a New Yorker puzzle published today. It’s labeled as challenging but would probably run on a Weds or Thurs in the Times. I won’t flirt with any spoilers, but I think some of the solvers here would consider it an interesting diversion.

    ReplyDelete
  47. My five favorite original clues from last week
    (in order of appearance):

    1. Noted chairman? (5)
    2. Whom you might meet with open arms, for short? (3)
    3. What a comment might be made in (4)
    4. Spirals out of control? (9)
    5. Fights back tears? (5}


    EAMES
    TSA
    JEST
    TORNADOES
    DARNS

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My favorite encore clues from last week:

      [Easily removed locks] (3)
      [Canniest, for instance] (7)


      WIG
      ANAGRAM

      Delete
  48. Also solving down clues only, also couldn't quite get there so I looked up one of the across clues (LIMO, I think?) for 39 down, for which I had V-R-S--E which looked like it might be VORESIDE (?). Yes this was challenging to solve that way. Fortunately the theme became obvious which helped so much.

    I love HAYAO's films very much, so I'll forgive him for making it so tough.

    ReplyDelete
  49. I’m usually an “across only” guy on Mondays, but since I’m just getting back on the grid, I solved it easily using both acrosses and downs.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Thanks, Lewis, for reminding me of "Canniest, for instance." One of the all-time great clues.

    ReplyDelete
  51. I had TOP SONG at the end thinking that you could have a CUT of flour. (Shrug)

    ReplyDelete
  52. The actual puzzle, as opposed to the extra layer of difficulty with downs only. Is quite easy. Rex complained about the beginning but ACROSS the first row is all gimmes. The puzzle is designed to solve in the normal fashion.so what Rex comments were irrelevant to my solve.
    I liked the puzzle

    ReplyDelete
  53. Easy, breezy Monday - I liked it. While solving I thought this would be the perfect puzzle for a beginner. Difficulty is just right, and the theme, themers and revealer, while basic, are cute and clever enough to hold interest and trigger a nice "AHA" moment.
    I did not know HAYAO but the downs were fair (I've not yet developed the chops for Downs only...) and that was my only hold up.
    Thanks Adam for nice, smooth ride.

    ReplyDelete
  54. Todo lo que puedas comer.

    Exciting Monday morning with so many 'N'-words. SCRATCH N SNIFF in Zulu is nwaya futhi uhogele. In the same song mentioned by Joan Jett, she also loves a 17-year-old boy, so maybe she's not the best arbiter of taste.

    I thought the fodder for Jeopardy was boredom?

    ❤️ BLAT. VERY SAME.

    😩 AFROED. TERSER.

    People: 5
    Places: 1
    Products: 4
    Partials: 3
    Foreignisms: 3
    --
    Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 16 of 78 (21%)

    Funny Factor: 2 😕

    Tee-Hee: ANAL KNOB KNOTS.

    Uniclues:

    1 What you step on to hit number 11.
    2 Toss a sister's bed pan.
    3 Anthem where you're almost certain to hear guacamole rhymes.
    4 More murder.
    5 Dashboard light that'll lead to your pedometer melting down.
    6 What the NYTXW app is for.

    1 ROCK N ROLL PEDAL (~)
    2 LOB NUN LOO
    3 RAVIOLI POP SONG
    4 EXTRA SURF N TURF
    5 LIMO TIRE ALERT (~)
    6 YOU SLOG AD FREE

    My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Doing the nono in SoHo with Bohos. ALL IN MANHATTAN HOOKUP.

    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    ReplyDelete
  55. Excellent Monday. I will encourage my LawSon to tackle it. He’s having some difficulty understanding themed puzzles and why one would even want to do one. The more “extreme” the cuteness is, the less he enjoys it and yet, he is anything but a staid person-he teaches theatre for heaven’s sake! I think it’s more the adult bugaboo of trying something new and being frustrated at not being an “expert” immediately.

    I ended up with undoubtedly my longest Monday solve time possibly ever (that’s over 60 years of very consistent if not daily solving of the NYTXW) because of a typo that “made sense.” Like some others today, I thought top SONG was good instead of POP SONG. Throughout the whole solve, I was going very rapidly never stalling to think about an answer and not needing to read many clues.

    Such was the case at the CUP/POP SONG cross which I had as CUt/tOP SONG. I never read the clue “unit of flour.” I put in my last letter at 73A (EASE) and thought I finished in just a tad over 4 minutes but alas, no happy music! So, I scanned every answer looking for an obvious typo and found none. Ugh. At least it was Monday, not Sunday and reading my answers didn’t take long.

    I began the slog through each answer again, and ignored the CUt - again!!! So I took a break and came back, but forgot to close out the app and the clock had been running the whole time.

    The second full pass through, I ignored it again and just about gave up and chested, but I decided to go through every single clue and answer. If this had been a similar mistake in a big Sunday grid, I would have given up and checked the puzzle and broke my streak.

    I solve for fun - for me - and until lately never paid attention to my streak. About a week ago though, my granddaughter was watching me solve and when I finished and the app congratulated me and added a day to my streak, Grace was impressed. I told her I don’t care about it, I just solve for fun and to learn things. She made such a big deal of it that I said I would see how long I could go without having to cheat to finish. So now Every day she asks if I finished without cheating. So far so good. Of I can keep from being my own worst enemy . . .

    ReplyDelete