Shopgirl in a Paris boutique / SUN 5-11-25 / Young salmon / Twice-distilled Turkish beverage / Reality TV star Hadid / 1999 Maeve Binchy novel / 1957 Isaac Asimov novel, with "The" / Beers from Bremen, informally / Something sown, per an idiom / Greek goddess depicted holding torches and snakes / Candy brand with a crown in its logo / Cornmeal dish at a trattoria / Embody something proudly / Spinal cord membranes / Setting for Jacques-Louis David's painting "The Death of Marat"
Sunday, May 11, 2025
Constructor: Brendan Emmett Quigley
Relative difficulty: Medium
Word of the Day: MIDINETTE (38D: Shopgirl in a Paris boutique) —
noun
plural midinettes
• • •
![]() |
[92D: Setting for Jacques-Louis David's painting "The Death of Marat"] |
I guess the central phrase, "SOMEONE IS GETTING FIRED," is supposed to be funny or evoke ... something, but it doesn't mean a lot to me. I guess I can hear someone saying it. There are a bunch of other longer answers in the grid, but a Sunday-sized grid has a way of making answers that seem long in a regular-sized grid seem not that long, and so the standout fill doesn't, ya know, stand out that much. Most of it seems solid enough, just not that thrilling. MIDINETTE has the virtue of originality. But then that's offset by the rank ugliness of PIA MATERS, plural. Something odd about that answer in the plural. Seems like it should be something else. Pias mater? Pias matres? Do people even speak of pia mater in the plural? Ever? Another question: who has ever said "Head cheese" to mean MISTER BIG? Head honcho, yes. Big cheese, sure. Head cheese? I know it's supposed to make you think of the jellied meatloaf stuff I've never actually tried, but on a purely idiomatic level, "head cheese?" Who says that?
Looks like my wife wiped out on the TARA ROAD / ARIE crossing. I doubt she'll be the only one. If TARA ROAD / ARIE is a Natick, that would be fitting, since it was a Brendan Emmett Quigley puzzle that led me to coin the term "Natick" ... 17 years ago!
OK, what else?
Additional notes:
- 43A: Beers from Bremen, informally (ST. PAULIS) — this is St. Pauli Girl, right? I haven't had one or thought of one in years. As with PIA MATERS, not sure I've ever seen it in the plural, informally or otherwise.
- 33A: Package drop-off sites: Abbr. (POS) — that's "post offices." Another plural I've never seen. I have seen "POS" before ... just ... not with this meaning.
- 50A: Fish that passes the 'Mirror test' of self-recognition (MANTA RAY) — You'd think there'd be other fish that could do this too, but cursory searching reveals that so far it's just the MANTA RAY and something called the "Bluestreak Cleaner Wrasse."
- 54A: "I've Been Everywhere" singer in the Country Music Hall of Fame (HANK SNOW) — well I know the song. The dude's name, not so well. I've definitely heard it, but needed nearly all the crosses to get it. Snow may have been everywhere, but I haven't. For instance, I've never been to the Country Music Hall of Fame.
- 95A: Joy on TV (BEHAR) — she's a crossword solver. At one point in her life, she read this blog. Just in case she's still reading: Hi, Joy.
- 2D: Home of the Italian soccer club Juventus (TORINO) — two soccer clues today, I knew neither. I guess MARTA rings a faint bell (the only kinds of bells that seem to be ringing today) (82D: One-named Brazilian soccer star who is a six-time FIFA World Player of the Year), but as with so many other names, I relied heavily on crosses.
- 14D: Greek goddess depicted holding torches and snakes (HECATE) — apparently she is associated with crossroads, which makes her a fitting grid goddess.
- 64D: Actor Pascal of "Gladiator II" (PEDRO) — Me: "Ooh, I know him!" Also me: [writes in PABLO]
- 71D: Something sown, per an idiom (WILD OAT) — no one sows just one WILD OAT. I collect old paperbacks and I distinctly remember one by MacKinlay Kantor called One WILD OAT. I remember it because I remember thinking: "that's silly, no one sows just one WILD OAT." My friend Kathy and I would periodically make fun of the book by singing "One WILD OAT" to the tune of Phil Collins's "One More Night." So now the singular phrase WILD OAT really has no hope with me. Also, I have Phil Collins in my head.
[I wrote about this book here]
- 86D: Candy brand with a crown in its logo (SKOR) — SKOR is really overrepresented as a candy bar. Do people even eat these? Can't believe I have to get OREO-deep in brand lore now—the SKOR logo? I have no idea. Let's see ... oh yeah, there it is, right in the "O"—you really gotta want to see it:
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
P.S. hey, today's constructor, Brendan Emmett Quigley (a veteran, a pro, a gamesmith of renown), has a new free daily word game that runs at the Boston Globe, called Align. Here's BEQ to explain: "Elevator pitch is that it's like a clueless Mini, but presented as a jigsaw. Certain letters are locked, you use those to put it back together. It's called Align, and you can do it here: https://www.bostonglobe.com/games/align/ ." So go on, give it a try!
122 comments:
Themeless Sundays suck. I've never liked one, and I never will... especially not this one full of clunky crossings and obscure proper nouns.
I stalled out in the NW but did okay starting in the NE and going clockwise. Overall, on the Medium side of Medium-Challenging, due to all the arcana.
Overwrites:
pePS UP before AMPS at 1D
milaNO before TORINO at 2D
GOOD eye before AIM at 58D
All in ALL before AFTER ALL at 60A
fie before POX at 63D
eRIE before ARIE at 84D (also a WOE)
SMeLT before SMOLT at 86A
WOEs:
IMMIX (10D)
RAKI (22D)
The NAKED SUN (28A)
KENT STATE as clued (35D)
MIDINETTE (38D)
SWISS ROLL (43D)
HANK SNOW (54A)
GUS Fring (76A)
YOLANDA Hadid (70D)
MARTA (82D)
TARA ROAD (83A)
ARIE Crown Theater (84D)
Impressive grid today , with stimulating answers and fair clues.Not as tricky as many of BEQs. I enjoyed seeing many of the long words /phrases fill in crossing each other
Mini Irish theme today for Brendan with IRISH, COLLEEN, and TARA ROAD.
I could definitely see sowing one WILDOAT if it turned out badly or tragically and taught a lesson
Surprised to find out MANTA rays passed mirror recognition test. It would seem that the mantas, the octopi, the crows and maybe the pigs will take over the world humans go extinct!
In Lewis's absence , noted a 5 letter semi-semordnilap in SMART (semi because you get a plural TRAMS when reversed)
Fun one, BEQ
Happy Mother's Day to all!
Yep, Natick at TARA ROAD / ARIE for me :(. Had ERIE
Units of magnetic flux density are TESLAs, not GAMMAs, right?
Three different letters in TARAROAD were up for debate for me.
wOMB for TOMB
eRIE for ARIE (which I justified because of Chicago & lake proximity)
YOLeNDA for YOLANDA bc I was just trying to make the novel name work
My mother always does the nyt puzzle every day and now so do I. She still does it in ink and I only do it on line. She says hi back. And my favorite is Phil Collins so that was fun to see as well.
My logic on the TARA/ARIE nattick that I was left with once everything else was in was that maybe this novel was some kind of reimagining of Gone With the Wind (that, and "Erie" doesn't seem to be a good fit with Chicago). Sometimes a flawed process still gets you good results.
six whole minutes slower than average for me! I had wARA road because I thought wOMB worked well as "body building."
had Medusa first before crosses helped me remember my girl HECATE.
archers gift (GOOD AIM) and dime store (US MINT) made me smile.
JLD is my favorite painter, so I felt giddy to see The Death of Marat.
otherwise, just a slightly slower slog of working and repeatedly spinning through the puzzle.
I liked all the Xs on the grid.
I looked and looked for a theme. Thought there was something to "Power" (Grid) re: FIRED, RAY, GAMMA, etc. Could not make sense of this, even after completing the puzzle, and now I know why.
At first, I thought this was a great puzzle. Medium solve, very different from most Sundays. But then, ran into lots of PPP, including crosses. And, what's with HANK(SNOW) crossing HANK(ERING)? Seems very sloppy.
ARIE was a gimme, but I spent 8+ years in Chicago & its "suburbs"
I didn’t get along with this one at all - just way too much stuff that I flat out don’t recognize. I used every cross to come up with MIDINETTE, for example, which means nothing to me. Ditto for PIAMATERS and stuff like IMMIX and RAKI. Add in the novels and the other stuff that Rex mentioned, and I just felt like I was lugging an anchor around the room.
On a positive note, this one did motivate me to research and learn what a mirror test for fish (and other animals) refers to. It’s an interesting (but not fascinating) concept.
I am surprised at event else's experience thus far. This was hardest Sunday I can remember. I'm at my usual Sunday time and almost the entire east half of the puzzle is blank. I guess it's just a "not on my wavelength" issue? I feel like I haven't heard of most of the answers in this puzzle.
Under the current circumstance of mass firings I found the puzzle in bad taste and not at all funny. It took a while to get going and an overall very slow time for a Sunday. Lots of stuff I didn't know, although midinette was not unknown even if it was deeply buried.
Comforting not to be alone in stalling out at TARA ROAD. I had WOMB and ERIE and I knew the across must be wrong but I couldn’t piece it together.
Ditto.
Pretty much down with the big guy on the large grid themeless - there’s so much available space you tend to lose track of the elegant nuances that comprise a good themeless. That said I am a huge fan of BEQ’s work and the clueing voice and offbeatness here was evident.
Cash
The central spanner is neat - not exactly heartwarming in today’s federal climate but it is splashy. SWISS ROLL, MISTER BIG, COLLEEN all solid - there is a bunch of decent fill throughout. @Z and I share a love for all things Asimov - he would have plopped NAKED SUN right in. Backed into TORINO and WONG - but the crosses were fair.
SHAGGY
I would have liked this pared down to a Friday - but overall an enjoyable Sunday morning solve. Happy Mother’s Day to all the solving moms.
Oh TARA
Exactly this. Total Natick. ERIE sounds much more likely given the proximity to the great lakes.
I’ll second Rex: The best thing about this puzzle was encountering the wonderful NED BEATTY in the SE corner.
There are lots of places I’ve never been, but one I have visited is the Country Music Hall of Fame. And I do like HANK SNOW. Snow, Williams, Thompson—I like all the Hanks.
It took me awhile to realize this was themeless partly due to how long it took me to start it. After going through most of the top tier clues all I had was SIDES and ETTU. Only when the MOTHEREARTH light bulb went off did I start filling in regularly.
I finished with a WAROROAD double dnf. It didn't look anymore wrong than IMMIX and that turned out to be right. Easy mistakes to fix but no clean finish.
I'm pretty sure there was a similar clue for WOMB recently but it's not worth renewing my xwordinfo membership to find out as I only solve on the weekends these days.
COLLEEN is an SB classic.
Chicago is nowhere near Lake Erie. It's on Lake Michigan (or was that a joke?)
A gamma is a billionth of a Tesla. Or it used to be. Apparently it is out of use now. GAuss is also a unit of magnetic flux density. All three are five letters, irritatingly.
This is tiny, but is CODANN the new KEALOA? (Massachusetts Cape ____)
I figured out the TARA ROAD/ARIE cross, but thought the theater might be ARIa because I couldn’t remember how to spell Joy’s last name. One of several mistakes I had to correct to get the happy music.
This weekend has given me hope for the future of the puzzle; three days, three stiff puzzles.
No idea on either TARA ROAD or ARIE ... at least it was obviously a vowel. But that's about as Naticky as Naticks get. And I used to live in Chicago. And crossing very obscure YOLANDA, which could have been YOLoNDA. And TOMB which could have been wOMB. Basically had to choose from among twenty different plausible options for TARA. I did guess right, though.
Dithered between WHIPPED/PIA MATERS and WHuPPED/PuA MATERS, also.
Ugh I had this too! Gamma is a less common unit - 1 gamma is 1 nanotesla
I also was unenthused by the puzzle, but I’ve gotta stand up for SKOR — yes people eat them, they’re delicious — better than the more common Heath bars in fact.
I didn’t think Chicago was on lake eRIE, but tried it anyways.
Seeing as how a “wild oat” is a metaphor for sperm, a single one would definitely fall for a trip to the doctor.
I missed a pun opportunity the other day with the BUTT puzzle. Gary’s teehee rating was literally “off the charts”.
Indeed no fun with themeless Sundays. And for me personally there was quite a lot of clues that were obscure and not in my knowledge set.
Hey All !
Two outright Googs to wrestle this to the ground, and they came towards the end of the solve, as after a while, I get antsy spending too much time on a puz, and get mad at being stuck in an area (today, upper east area), so instead of staring blankly at, well, blank spaces, and rereading the clues hoping something will pop into the ole brain, I just start Googing.
Dang, how was that for a run-on sentence? 😁
Looked up the meaning of Inveigle, as I did last time it was a clue, and more than likely, next time it's a clue. Other one was for PEDRO, no idea on who that was. Having ITINERAte was messing me up there.
But, did get the rest, even with being unsure if words like IMMIX. Wha?
Knew it was a Themeless SunPuz just from looking at the grid pre-solve. Too much open space to be Themed. Hard to fathom there isn't a good Themed SunPuz that could've been run.
Welp, I DO gotta run. Bye THEN.
Four F's
RooMonster
DarrinV
The Naked Sun was the second of Asimov’s future Earth mysteries in a sci-fi setting - paired a grumpy earth detective (Elijah Bailey) with Daneel Olivaw who was a robot - Asimov looped back 40 years later inserting R Daneel Olivaw into his expansion of the Foundation series - which tied his series (Future Earth, Robot, and Foundation) together.
Oh no! Don't mention that name here!
I remember the Circle of Friends movie in the ‘90s with Minnie Driver and Chris O’Donnell, which was based on the Maeve Binchy novel. Rex, would have been a good opportunity to link to the Edie Brickell song of the same name (well officially just “Circle,” but the lyrics include the rest).
Got off to a very slow start today, so much so that I resorted to Check Puzzle quite early on, and found a couple of as yet uncrossed misses that probably were holding me back. After that, momentum quickly built, leading to a slightly better than average time.
For this longtime Chicagoan, ARIE was a gimme, but I sympathize with others—certainly not EL familiar.
webwinger
Me too, but I guessed right.
Had WOMB before TOMB (83d “Body building”) because it’s Mothers Day!
That trivia contest in the south west corner was a challenge.
@Rex, for the record, SKOR bars are delicious and way better than Heath bars.
Thanks for the write up!
I'm reminded of a recent YouTube video where a mother invites her kids to search the yard for Easter eggs only to declare "April Fools!" when they don't find anything. The kids were not impressed. I did the puzzle last night and looked and looked for the theme or anything that would make the title make sense. I was looking forward to coming here this morning to see what I was missing. Turns out, nothing. I'm not impressed.
Glad to have a Sunday that wasn’t just a Tuesday expanded as they’ve been more often than not. That said, I was not on the same wavelength as this puzzle and after a quick start in the NW really floundered around. Not my favorite but still, would rather lean in this direction than the training wheels Sundays the NYT serves up too often.
Horrible puzzle. Obscure proper names, dumb clues, and some complete c*** like the singular WILD OAT. No. No. No.
Just when you think you have a good vocabulary, you run into things like IMMIX and PIAMATERS and MIDINETTE. Got them from crosses but no feeling of recognition when they were filled in. Nor will I probably ever see them again. So it goes.
Filled in the NW last, I'm saying this is because our car doesn't have a GPS and the X was nowhere near what I was looking for.
This one seemed to take forever but probably didn't, but it still seemed that way. The numbers on my print out seem to get smaller and smaller, especially on Sunday, and I know there's a large print edition but that means two pieces of paper. At least there was a ST PAUL IS (hi @Roo).
Solid craftsmanship, BEQ, But Eventually Quit charming me. Thanks for a Sunday workout, at least.
Happy Mother’s Day :)
Tons of proper nouns and obscure (to me) trivia made this a brutal slog for a sunday.
Is the „someone is getting fired today“ a reference to the dupes Hank crossing Hank , and tang crossing tang?
Always disappointed when a Sunday isn't a theme
I feel like the rest of the week can be for the themeless. On Sundays I look forward to figuring out the theme and having some fun with that.
After finally getting proper Friday and Saturday-level challenges the past two days, we also get a Sunday puzzle that doesn’t feel like a Monday or Tuesday-level of difficulty. I hope this trend continues.
Broke my streak with that natick
The only "wordle" I remember having missed was GAMMA/MAGMA a long time ago, I don't recall which they wanted but I guessed GROWN oops WRONG!
Agree! Very bad taste!
Yeeeesh, this felt like a ridiculous trivia fest. IMMIX, RAKI, PIA MATERS, MIDINETTE, YOLANDA, etc. etc. Not helped by several paired clues that made it really hard to get traction in certain parts of the grid if you didn't immediately recognize some obscure proper noun clue.
I have a physics degree and did multiple semesters of electrostatics and dynamics courses and have never, ever encountered the unit "GAMMA."
Oh my, I struggled with this. I think I set a PW (personal worst) and even resorted to hitting the "mark wrong letters" button in order to solve the NW. I had nothing, NOTHING, in the NW except ALE and that was a fingers-crossed entry. IMMIX? "Back" in at 29A really held me up - Romeo wasn't going to fill in with that final letter D in place.
I should have seen PIA MATERS earlier but kept reading it as if it was one word such as dIAMeTERS.
Go DArk before REDACT, TeslA before GAMMA, Messi before MARTA, and the NW is almost all red when I look at my erasures, post-solve. I knew a BEQ wasn't going to be a walk in the park but I wasn't expecting such difficulty.
Is MOTHER EARTH the only thing related to Mother's Day? Have a great one, all who are moms!
Thanks, BEQ, you got me today!
both are great lakes…
I generally find BEQ to be tough, but fair. TARAROAD crossing ARIA crossing BEHAR was a little more than tough and a bit unfair, at least for me.
best part of the puzzle was rex's mention of _hopscotch_—such a fun film. walter matthau & glenda jones back together from _house calls_. the puzzle itself felt like automatically assembled wordlist slop.
My only holdup was the Arie/Tara crossing, and with a bit of experimenting I was able to work it out. Everything else I didn't know I was able to work out with the crosses. As for Skor bars: I love them. The crown in the "O" is from the Swedish logo (the more astute might recognize that the Swedish national hockey teams have three of these on their jerseys; in Swedish, "Tres Kronor"). The bar is originally from Sweden, where it is named "Dajm" which would be pronounced "dime" in English. I don't know if the Swedes renamed it for English consumers, but the word "Skor" in Swedish translates to "shoes" in English-so perhaps a tongue-in-cheek poke at the English speaking world.
So I went back to look at the finished puzzle, (I was shocked to hear the music so fast, thinking "couldn't be") to see how I did it. Not normally a fan of BEQ, I am now. At least as far as this themeless Sunday goes. No disputing that MIDINETTE, IMMIX, RAKI, GUS were Woes, I guess I gravitate to themeless Sundays. Only problem is now I'm hearing "I've been everywhere" over & over in my head. Many thanks to you BEQ :)
Slightly easier than medium for me. The grid looked pretty intimidating but that turned out not to be the case. The WOEs were either fairly crossed or inferable, plus I knew TARA ROAD.
I’m with @Rex on WILD OAT, it just seems wrong.
Solid, liked it.
A lot of very obscure words here, didn't love it.
Oof, tough. 2x average time on Sat & Sun. Jim Horne notes (from xwordinfo.com): "This crossword has only 54 black squares — a new record for a 21x21 grid." No woosh, but I enjoyed the challenge. Thank you sir, may I have another?
"YOLANDA! I thought you said you were gonna be cool."
Am I the only person who has read TARA ROAD? 😅 That might have been the easiest clue for me in the entire grid. It’s a classic book from years ago (at least in Canada), and definitely the inspiration for the movie The Holiday. Am also IRISH and an MD so double-plus good for today’s puzzle: COLLEEN, CORTEX, PIA MATERS, LARYNX.
I also complete the puzzle with one of my best friends each Sunday via Zoom. We were thoroughly disappointed that an opportunity was list with this week's puzzle being theme-less. Today is Mother's Day. There was a clue about Mother Earth .. Could have expounded on this and had a lovely puzzle about mind, women's history, etc... Wishing for better next year.
Learned something about MANTARAYS, that’s a plus. Another hand up for WOMB. Having TOMB for “body building” is too funny! Had to start in the SE today. Stuff like IMMIX to tough. The PPP in general made this hard but thought getting the central phrase “SOMEONES…FIRED” was worth the effort of an occasional DuckDuck Google.
Agree on both counts!
Almost 50 years working in and teaching quantum physics and I had never heard of a GAMMA unit for magnetic fields. #obscure
I think somehow “someone’s getting fired” is the theme= power grid
Dear Mr. Shortz,
Please be so kind as to indicate definitively when a puzzle is a themeless, so I will know not to waste my time. Thank you.
Anyone have an idea what the title “Power Grid” could mean?
Today I learned that St. Pauli Girl is brewed in Bremen. I've been to Bremen with my son who lives in Hamburg. And speaking of Hamburg, I would probably have guessed that St. Pauli Girl would be brewed in the St. Pauli quarter of Hamburg (which has a fabulous "naughty" Christmas market, btw). I also got a chuckle that the St. Pauli Girl label featured in the blog today locates the brewery not in St. Pauli, but in St. Louis, where the Americanized version is produced. Which reminds me of John Cleese's definition of American beer: "Like making love in a canoe--(eff-ing close to water)."
I was terrified that 54 across was JOHN CASH because if it was I would’ve had to throw my iPad across the room.
A Sunday themeless is like wine without alcohol.
P.S When the editor should have checked his info better (43A): it so happens that St. Pauli is a neighborhood of Hamburg..
Hardest for me, too. And after I did so well with yesterday’s.
Certainly a well-made wide-open-spaces SunPuz, but ... day-um ... the SatPuz even had more of a theme.
staff weeject pick: OWE. As in "IOU a SunPuztheme".
MOTHEREARTH was by far the fave, at our house -- Happy Mother's Day!
Thanx, BEQ. Interestin center Across answer/clue, btw.
Masked & Anonymo6Us
... need a little puztheme fix? ...
"Tug of War" - 7x7 themed runt puzzle:
**gruntz**
M&A
I was going to point that out too. I think this is the third time I’ve seen it recently and guessed wrong the first two times; like Natick, it is in Massachusetts.
BEQ has a Mother's Day theme in today's Boston Globe
@Conrad. Had the same list of woes., plus
Behar and motorplex. I've never heard o a motorplex. I kept trying for something like main street, alley, parking lot.
Didn't realize as I was doing it, that the puzzle was themeless.
Enjoyed the clue for tomb, but agree it also works for "womb".
POS = Point Of Service, new lingo used in packing and shipping servicing these days. Not your parents' P.O.S., that's for sure.
I think the "power grid" is a reference to the shapes formed by the sparsely-spaced black squares. I took off my glasses and held the phone a little farther away from my face, and it sort of resembled a kind of vague electricky wire layout... sorta? Not 100% sure though.
That TARA ROAD section was brutal. I had no idea what kind of road it could be so ended up (and I'm sure I'm not the only one) with wErA ROAD because a wOMB is where you build a body (I know a womb isn't a building, and I guess a tomb is, but still - screw that clue/answer), and eRIE makes sense because it's in Chicago. WTF is IMMIX? RAKI? I didn't know either but at least was able to figure them out because of the crosses.
I prefer a themed Sunday, but know when there are lots of long answers that it was probably going to be a themeless. Enjoyed the challenge on most of it, but a bummer to get that far and then end on a sour note. DNF for me.
Arrgh, finished with two wrong squares. Like many I had ERIE, and like many others I had WOMB because I mis-parsed the clue as "Body builder". Just a terrible mashup of Unknown Names down there: TARA ROAD, ARIE, BEHAR, YOLANDA. Awful.
And there's another ugly cluster in the upper right: HECATE RAKI EROS NAKEDSUN.
Hands up for: I have a physics degree and have never heard of GAMMA being magnetic flux. What an awful clue, because gamma has a *lot* of meanings in physics and math (and probably other sciences too) besides being a Greek letter. No need for such a nasty clue.
Today's annoying "school sports team" clue led to KENT- - - -, so I thought: KENTUCKY U!
Oh well, I did like SOMEONE IS GETTING FIRED except I wanted SOMEONE'S which was a letter too short. And nice to learn MIDINETTE which is a pretty word.
Wow! I was flabbergasted by all that open white space when I opened this one. No wonder. The grid has only 54 black squares! That is the record per xwordinfo.com for the fewest ever in a Sunday NYTXW. The average is 74.
I judge Sunday puzzles by how far I get before I quit. Today I dove in and continued steadily until the very end. And enjoyed it. I like interesting words and phrases crossing one another and this one has a ton of them. I rarely see a theme that can hold my attention long enough to finish a Sunday sized grid. More themeless Sundays I say.
Yeah, PIA MATERS is an iffy plural of convenience (POC) but it's (not 12D ITS) counterbalanced by the singular of convenience (SOC) WILD OAT.
I thought 54A "'I've Been Everywhere' singer in the Country Music Hall of Fame" was Johnny Cash. Ah, that was a cover of the original song. I see that even the Canadian born HANK SNOW version was a cover. It was originally written by Australian Geoff Mack and of course the places were all Australian. Here's Johnny's version.
A MISDEMEANOR of a puzzle!
Started off with ATARI TAPE, with a TAC on my dash. But couldn't get outta there, so dropped to the bottom, where ORLANDO worked with the crosses I was able to provide.
I got bit by a STING RAY, then WINEd and DINEd in the WONG place.
Not so SWEET.
Hard for me, and I enjoyed having a more challenging Sunday. I thought the cluing was tough, and, again, I appreciated having the resistance. Was happy to finish! A tidbit I did know was the ARIE Crown Theater, Chicago being my nearest Big City.
Do-overs: a desperate MAckerAl before MANTA RAY, InMIX. No idea: YOLANDA, TARA ROAD.
What a slog. Hated it. I did know ARIE Crown, though, but then I'm from Chicago and have actually been there.
After listening to myself play the Sunday Puzzle with Will Shortz on my local NPR station, (for the second time!!!) I settled in with this themeless and liked it okay. The TaraRoad/Arie cross was a Natick for me also.
Must be a thrill to see your mom‘s name in a Sunday NYT puzzle! Especially on Mother’s Day😀
Not a fan of this puzzle. Played like a Saturday, but just much bigger (and more painful). I wish the NYT wouldn't mess around with the silly titles on themeless Sundays. They should let the solver know it's themeless at the outset.
My natick was the soccer star —arta…bash, dash, gash, hash, mash … all seemed plausible.
I will third Rex and second Andy on Ned Beatty. Don’t forget him as Bolander on Homicide.
I got a pretty average time for a Sunday, but the puzzle played noticeably harder than recent Sundays. It was only slightly easier than yesterday’s, using (# of white squares)/(solve time) as a metric.
I knew what the central entry was going to be from FIRED, but I wanted a more informal variant with ‘S. So I went with SOMEONE’S GETTING FIRED (doesn’t fit) and later SOMEBODY’S GETTING FIRED.
@Rex I got Naticked by BEQ… in his Monday themeless (https://crosswordfiend.com/2025/05/04/monday-may-5-2025/#bq). Uninferrable cross at 24A/25D, which is something I would normally handle by running the alphabet. But then there’s 45A (the clue is [Clarifies, perhaps]) where another, much more natural answer fits, and differs from the actual answer in exactly the squares that cross proper names I didn’t know. Sometimes the stars (i. e. crossings) line up in juuuuust the right way to mess with solvers.
Being able to make love in a canoe is the actual definition of being Canadian.
I think every clue should stand on its own and be able to be solved, even if its the most obscure trivia. I know Maeve Binchy but know none of her books, but I do understand how some solvers could easily plug in the letters to solve that clue. When you have clues "partner of 74 across" and "partner of 67 across" they are unsolvable on their own. You need crosses to suss it out. Hate it.
Oh, wow! Drag racing events I've attended take place at a drag strip (my daughter-in-law's father is a race marshal at a local one and often parks his Plymouth Barracuda funny car in our driveway to do repairs) or they may just take place on a little-used straight stretch of out-of-town highway. No MOTORPLEX, whatever that is, involved.
This sucked. Bad cluing, weird proper nouns…Hank Snow? (Its a famous Johnny Cash song..in a Sunday puzzle that is asking for a lot of Country Music trivia)i Midinette? Are Swiss Rolls known for anything? Like is that common icing knowledge? SMOLT? Ned Beatty is a fairly well known character actor but certainly not the first name from ‘Network’ that you think of. If this was a sloggy Saturday sure, but Sundays shouldn’t be this dense with trivia.
Chicago has streets named after each Great Lake.
Uh oh. Fat fingers! I was beginning to say that 46D TANGERINE is in no way an equivalent of pumpkin in my world and I have been a practising artist (painter) for mare than 50 years. IMMIX at 10D was a WOE, as was 28A NAKEDSUN. I'm not a sci-fi fan. But the worst (as noted by many commenters, was the crossing at 83A and 84D of TARAROAD and ARIE. Ouch! I know *of* Maeve Binchy, but I don't know the titles of her books And A Chicago theatre with an obscure name????
But it was nice learning MIDINETTE, I guess.
Agreed. I thought this puzzle was harder than the Friday or Saturday puzzles this week. Ugh.
That was my last cross. I, too, think of fire as in starting up a power plant for the first time. Fire up (the power grid), quite a stretch?
The first version of I've Been Everywhere I ever heard was by Rolf Harris, and was the Australian version. I thought Johnny Cash was really clever to update it to the US, but now know otherwise.
Isn’t it “shinnied” up a rope? “Shinned”is something I’ve never heard of.
Just for the record, the arie Crown Theatre was named after Lithuanian immigrant arie crown. He was the American industrialist and philanthropist
Gotta love BEQ no matter how tough!
Nobody ever ever EVER says PIA MATERS. And the LARYNX isn’t an organ, it’s an anatomic structure.
At least he got CORTEX right (sigh).
Doc John
Just this week I read this in “A Tree Grows in Brooklyn”:
She rushed down to Gorling’s, the department store at the Polish end of Grand Street, where she worked from four to seven, serving coffee and sandwiches to the salesgirls who were not allowed to take the time to go out for supper on account of the Christmas rush. Her family desperately needed that seventy-five cents that she earned each day.
I guess she was feeding the midinettes.
I agree! There also May as an option
Colin
Shortz has no rule against dupes
A lot of solvers do but they aren’t editors. He routinely allows the same word to be duplicated, like yesterday’s puzzle, never mind the same 4 letters, one a name the other an unrelated syllable as we have here.
FWIW It isn’t sloppy editing but intentional!
To be honest, dupes bother me not at all
I dropped this puzzle a third of the way through this morning and went out into the beautiful sunshine without it. Didn't want to spoil a gorgeous day with a puzzle that felt long and tedious -- with some really arcane vocab and too many cross-references.
Finished it this evening -- except for the NW corner that I couldn't do this morning. While I somehow wended my way through IMMIX and MIDINETTE, et al, having put in PROMISE TO instead of PROMISE ME meant that MEMORIES and EXERTED were both ungettable. (I thought that the speaker was doing the pinky swearing, not asking someone else to do it. I never thought to correct it.)
A tough and pretty dreary Sunday. A clever theme definitely would have helped.
DNF
TeRA/eRIE.
I think I had heard of the novel at some point because I did think about TARA as a likely name. But eRIE just killed that idea. Well there is a street named Erie in Chicago they say.
At least I knew PIA. But the plural was a long time coming.
BTW
MATER is mother in Latin of course.
So another indirect reference to Mother’s Day.
Found it hard. I do like figuring out the unknown stuff BuT that is what I put down for hedge/ BET. It made no sense with the cross but I forgot to double check
So double dnf.
Tough puzzle.
Is no one from Chicago? Of course it's Arie Crown. The Crown family are generous philanthropists in the area.
ARIE was a gimme for me also, as a lifelong resident of Chicago and its suburbs. However, the theater is not located in "Downtown" Chicago. Even the McCormick Place website, where the theater is located, states that the location is minutes from downtown. Also, I don't believe that many Chicagoans would consider the theater as a "landmark".
are none of you IRISH? if you were, you'd know TARA ROAD. some how I pulled out HANK SNOW out of the corner of my brain. dont like themeless Sundays but I finished no problem, Medium for me
Ditto on the TARA/ARIE natick... this is so glaring.... can someone tell me what the puzzle editor's job is if stuff like this is permitted?
85D: A better clue for RASH would have been “Like acting without thinking.” RASH is an adjective, but the given clue, “Acting without thinking,” calls for a verb in some form, such as BLUNDERING.
I realize “He was acting without thinking” and “He was rash” have the same meaning, but somehow this clue offended my sense of crossword fairness. Does anyone else feel the same way?
Terrible puzzle. Too many Naticks. And why call it a power grid? No theme I could discern . Ah well - wait for another Sunday
Alguien está siendo despedido.
As expected from a BEQ, definitely a tough Sunday for me. I wish it had a theme. So many tough unknowns helped me learn a lot I will forget by week's end, but worth the fun today. Stuck the same places everyone else mentioned. Only 128 answers on a Sunday is remarkable.
😫 CORTEX, SMOLT, GAMMA, IMMIX, PIAMATERS, SHINNED, two soccer clues, tangerine is totally not akin to pumpkin except in a world where blondes are akin to komodo dragons.
❤️ I am a super fan of "SMILE AT," but those receiving mine tend to be fans of "SNEER BACK AT."
People: 13
Places: 3
Products: 8
Partials: 2
Foreignisms: 5
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 31 of 128 (24%)
Funnyisms: 3 😕
Uniclues:
1 Pong with a brogue.
2 A planet covered in parking lots.
3 When the hot one gives you the moon.
4 Shut up a comedienne.
5 Fruity drink for barroom bruiser.
6 How petit become grand larcenywise.
7 Pastry "to go" grows mold in a coffin.
8 Why the photo is blurry after lunch.
9 To treat others as you'd like to be treated.
10 Wandering lover's ploy.
1 SWEET IRISH ATARI GAME (~)
2 MOTHER EARTH MOTORPLEX (~)
3 NAKED SUN ORBIT SIDES (~)
4 REDACT WONG LARYNX (~)
5 MISTER BIG ORANGE VODKA (~)
6 MISDEMEANOR AMOUNTING
7 TOMB SWISS ROLL AMPS UP (~)
8 SOUP'S ON ENLARGER IRIS (~)
9 IT'S ELEGANTLY "REAL MAN"
10 ITINERANT EROS GAMBIT (~)
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Feline fêtipodes. MEOWED MEETUPS.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Naticked in the NW. Had "peps up" instead of AMPSUP and couldn't come up with ATARIGAME. Got everything else, so I awarded myself a consolation prize.
I’ve lived in Chicago for 23 years and have no idea what the Arie Crown Theater is, I failed with Erie 🤷🏼♂️
A cleaner wrasse I’ve never seen.
Brenden is a beast and this puzzle was no different.
Totally agree. Clumsy and contrived.
“Nowhere near” is relative when you live in Central America and have only a vague notion of northeastern-ish US geography. That said, the Spanish clues are always a gimme so it’s a tradeoff :)
I don't consider it a Natick, because, at least for me, A is the only vowel that made sense there. Tara is the name of the plantation in Gone With the Wind, plus it adds to the Irishness of the puzzle.
It might have helped me a smidge that I have been to said theater, but I still had to dredge it up from old memories.
FIRED UP
OFLATE, YOLANDA wants A REALMAN,
A HANKERING for SOMEOE to dig,
A PRIORITY ROMEO WHO can
come AMOUNTING as MISTERBIG.
--- COLLEEN BEATTY
Not sure about all possible contexts, but, I would say an ORBIT is a path within a Sphere of influence.
Post a Comment