Sunday, January 12, 2025

Treasure-seeking woodcutter of folklore / SUN 1-12-25 / House, slangily / Ecological portmanteau since 1905 / Oxford institution, familiarly / Blue tang fish of Pixar fame / Walker with the 2015 triple-platinum hit "Faded" / Devices worn by informants / How an animal's length may be measured / Opera character whose name might be heard in an opera singer's warm-up / Tool used in many a sci-fi film / The stuff of Persian myths? / Big letters in the pharmaceutical industry / Mythological owner of an eight-legged horse named Sleipnir

Constructor: Jeffrey Martinovic

Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium


THEME: "I Think Knot" — words for things that come in strands, or that can be "knot"ted, can be found in three sets of circled squares; each set features two "strands" that are "knot"ted together—that is, they run into one another and then bend 90 degrees (the "strands" share one letter, which represents the "knot," I guess). Then there are three different "revealers":

The "Knots" (from top to bottom):
  • STRING / THREAD
              T
              H
            STREAD
              I
              N
              G
  • YARN / CABLE
              C
             YABLE
              R
              N
  • ROPE / CORD
              C
             RORD
              P
              E
              
The Revealers:
  • HIDDEN WIRES (3D: Devices worn by informants ... and what can be found inside three pairs of answers in this puzzle)
  • ALL TIED UP (94A: Even ... or like three pairs of answers in this puzzle)
  • CROSS STITCH (15D: Bit of embroidery ... or what's depicted literally three times in this puzzle)

Word of the Day: TAIPEI 101 (111A: ___ 101, 508-meter skyscraper that was once the world's tallest) —
Taipei 101
 (Chinese台北101pinyinTáiběi 101; stylized in all caps), formerly known as the Taipei World Financial Center, is a 508.0 m (1,667 ft), 101-story skyscraper in Taipei, Taiwan. It is owned by Taipei Financial Center Corporation. The building was officially classified as the world's tallest from its opening on 31 December 2004 (in time to celebrate New Year's Eve). However, the Burj Khalifa surpassed Taipei 101 in 2010. The construction of Taipei 101 was a joint venture led by Kumagai Gumi, a Japanese construction company, in cooperation with Samsung C&T of South Korea. Upon completion, it became the world's first skyscraper to exceed a height of half a kilometer (about 0.3 miles). As of 2023, Taipei 101 is the tallest building in Taiwan and the eleventh tallest building in the world. The skyscraper celebrated its 20th anniversary in 2024. [...] In 2011, Taipei 101 was awarded a Platinum certificate rating under the LEED certification system for energy efficiency and environmental design, becoming the tallest and largest green building in the world. The structure regularly appears as an icon of Taipei in international media, and the Taipei 101 fireworks displays are a regular feature of New Year's Eve broadcasts and celebrations.
• • •
***THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU*** Today is the last day of my annual week-long pitch for financial contributions to the blog. This week is always a bit overwhelming for me, as I usually only have a very vague idea of who my audience is, where they live, etc. And then all of a sudden, in a gush, I get a bunch of messages from actual people with actual names from actual places on the map (Florida! Ireland! ... Antarctica!? Really? (really)). I'm usually very content to live my life just writing (and teaching) and not otherwise interacting with humans too much. Wife. Cats. That's about it most days. This is the one week of the year when I feel the most ... visible, and it's not necessarily the most comfortable feeling in the world for me, if I'm being honest, but you all have been So Nice—so generous, so encouraging, that any social anxiety I might've felt has (once again) been eclipsed by feelings of gratitude and good fortune. I have said every possible permutation of "Thank you" this week, and it still doesn't feel like enough. I can't tell you what your readership and support means to me. Your cards and letters began arriving this week, and I'm excited to dig into those (I'm expecting many cat cards, cat pictures, and cat stories, and I couldn't be happier about that prospect). This year's thank-you cards arrived earlier this week, and they look great. The first batch is already in the mail (look at me! on top of things! for once!)
If you were able to contribute this year, that is thrilling to me, but if you weren't able, that's also OK. Money is tight for many and you can only manage what you can manage. This blog is free to anyone who wants it or needs it, whether you are a financial backer or not. I just want you to keep solving and keep reading. Thanks for taking the time to pay attention to any of this. One last time, here are the various ways you can contribute (now, or at any time during the year). 

There's Paypal:


There's Venmo: @MichaelDavidSharp (the last four digits of my phone are 4878, in case Venmo asks you, which it apparently does sometimes)

And if you want a cat postcard, there's the actual mail (you can make checks payable to either "Michael Sharp” or “Rex Parker"): 

Rex Parker c/o Michael Sharp
54 Matthews St.
Binghamton, NY 13905 

All this contact information lives full-time in the sidebar of my website, in case you feel inclined to contribute months from now :) 

OK. That's it. To all my readers (and my hate-readers)—What a bunch of wonderful weirdos you are. As Debbie Boone once sang to God, you light up my life. A million thanks for your time and attention. Now here's your Sunday puzzle...

• • •

Hoo boy. As I have indicated at the end of every write-up this week, my lowest-rated puzzle day of the week last year, by far, was Sunday, and today's puzzle helps ensure that that trend will continue into 2025. I guess the idea is that if you don't have one perfect revealer, you go instead with ... three imperfect ones. Throw in the title of the puzzle, and you have a lot of soft-groan punning and not a lot of excitement. Plus, a lot of imprecision. None of the "knot" formations look anything like HIDDEN WIRES. That is, none of the "strands" that interlock in this puzzle comes close to resembling a wire. Maybe "cable" comes close, but "yarn"?? And nothing in the answer HIDDEN WIRES gets at the central premise of the theme, which is that the strands cross and form "knots." Also, the very phrase HIDDEN WIRES struck me as contrived. Informants wear wires. Just ... wires. Of course they're "hidden"—would be pretty hard to get incriminating info if you were wearing the wire on the outside of your clothes. That was the worst revealer of the bunch, for sure. CROSS STITCH isn't great either. You don't stitch "rope," do you? And make up your mind about what the answers are doing. Are they merely "crossing," or are they "tied up?" Anyway, sharing a single letter hardly seems to qualify as a "knot." The whole premise felt limp, the execution awkward. Some of the longer answers involved are pretty colorful on their own: QUEEN OF CARNIVAL, SPACE TELESCOPE, GROWTH RINGS, all very nice. But overall, as a puzzle theme goes, this was definitely knot for me.


Bad taste in my mouth right from the start today. You open with MEH? And then cross it with one of the most unlikeable, repulsive, out-and-out racist dipshits on the planet (2D: Big first name in American business)?? Say what you will about Joel Fagliano's editing last year (I thought he did a good job under tough circumstances, actually), but under his leadership, ELON disappeared *completely*. Did he have anything to do with it? Was it coincidence? I don't know, man—three (3) ELON appearances in January 2024 alone and then none ... until January 2025, where it's already appeared twice? That's a hell of a coincidence. No one really wants to see ELON in their puzzle, whatever the clue (it's crosswordese—the only way most people know ELON University exists at all), and really, truly, no one wants to see That Guy in their puzzle, please stop. 


Once I got out of the NW, the fill wasn't quite as dire. I don't remember struggling too much. HIDDEN MIKES instead of HIDDEN WIRES, I remember that. HEAD-TO-TAIL before NOSE-TO-TAIL (8D: How an animal's length may be measured). I nailed the spelling on DENIECE Williams's name on the first try, but I definitely wrote those letters (esp. the "IE") in tentatively (63A: R&B singer Williams). As of this second, I have no idea who this ALAN Walker person is who had a "triple-platinum" hit with "Faded" ten years ago (122A: Walker with the 2015 triple-platinum hit "Faded"). Not even sure of the genre. Country? ALAN sounds country. [... consults The Web ...] LOL, no, not even close:
Alan Olav Walker (born 24 August 1997) is a Norwegian DJ and record producer. His songs "Faded", "Sing Me to Sleep", "Alone", "All Falls Down" (with Noah Cyrus and Digital Farm Animals) and "Darkside" (with Au/Ra and Tomine Harket) have each been multi-platinum-certified and reached number 1 on the VG-lista chart in Norway. Walker's music style is reminiscent of slightly slower-paced progressive house, 1990s trance music, or dubstep with a smoother rhythmic edge. 

But outside the awkwardness of one of the theme phrases and a few names, this one didn't present much difficulty. I realized today that I actually know nothing about ALI BABA except his name, and the fact that he's associated with forty thieves. The whole "treasure-seeking woodcutter" was a surprise to me (18A: Treasure-seeking woodcutter of folklore). Something about the way PLAYABLE was clued made it very hard for me to get (92A: Like many video game characters). The "many" is completely arbitrary, and anyway, without context, if you refer to a video game character, I'm just going to assume it's PLAYABLE. I would not call subway ADS "quick reads" any more than I'd call a stop sign a "quick read" (12A: Quick reads on the subway, perhaps). "Unintentional reads," maybe. "Visual pollution," sure. The clue is trying to be cute but it misses, imho. And is "double-JOINTED" a "medical" term (57A: Double-___ (hypermobile, medically))? "Hypermobility" *is* the clinical term, so "(hypermobile, colloquially)" would be more fitting here. Further, ASANA is a general term for *all* yoga poses. Completely bizarre to refer to it as a [Sitting meditation pose] without having an "e.g." after it. Yes, that is *an* ASANA. Down dog is another. Corpse pose another. Anyway, most people, given five letters and a [Sitting meditation pose] clue would probably be inclined to write in LOTUS, which is actually a more accurate answer. Maybe the misdirection was intended. But you can't sacrifice accuracy for misdirection. Or you shouldn't.


Bullets:
  • 40A: Disco fan on "The Simpsons" (STU) — there's a famous Disco STU moment ... here, let me find it ... 

The phrase "if these trends continue..." lives in my head permanently, like many Simpsons phrases. Which is why I laughed out loud listening to Casey Kasem's American Top 40 Countdown Year-End Wrap-Up show from 1978 last week (SiriusXM, 70s on 7 has a new (old) Countdown every weekend!). The Bee Gees and other Saturday Night Fever soundtrack albums were still dominating the charts in 1978, well over a year after the movie had come out, as were other disco hits that followed in the wake of that album's success. Anyway, at some point Casey, making predictions about the upcoming year of 1979, literally (or very nearly literally) said "if these trends continue..." and then predicted a lot more disco. I pointed at the car radio and shouted "Disco STU!" My wife just looked at me quizzically (not unusual). And Casey was right about 1979, by the way. But the crash was looming.
  • 68A: It's connected to the eustachian tube (EAR) — look, I don't *have* to tell you this, but I'm just gonna come clean and admit that I briefly but tragically confused the eustachian tube with the fallopian tube here and tried to write in EGG (!?), which doesn't even "connect" to the fallopian tube (optimally), but if you're thinking "three-letter word associated with fallopian tubes," EGG's just what comes up first (or OVA, I guess, but I already had the "E"!!!).
  • 79A: Oxford institution, familiarly (OLE MISS) — Oxford, Mississippi, that is. University of Mississippi is better known (esp. among sports fans) as OLE MISS.
  • 22D: House, slangily (CRIB) — do people still say this? I figured that once MTV used the term for the title of a show (about celebrity homes), the term would lose street cred.
  • 80D: Opera character whose name might be heard in an opera singer's warm-up (MIMI) — an elaborate but very clever clue. MIMI is the female lead in Puccini's La Bohème, which is the opera that Guy and Geneviève go to see at the beginning of The Umbrellas of Cherbourg, which I saw on the big screen for the first time just a couple days ago (60th Anniversary 4K restoration). That movie feels silly at first, but it turns into something moving and magical. Also, it just looks Amazing. Every frame. [whoops, my wife reminds me they saw Carmen in Umbrellas, not La Bohème, my bad]
  • 113D: Tool used in many a sci-fi film (CGI) — so tool used *in the making of* many a sci-fi film. Tricky.
This week I'm highlighting the best puzzles of 2024 by focusing on one day at a time. I kept a spreadsheet of every puzzle I solved last year, complete with ratings from 0-100 (with 50 being my idea of an "average" NYTXW) (They really did average out to around 50, with Saturday being my fav day (avg 57.7), and Sunday (obviously) being my least fav (avg 42.9). 

Here are my Top Three Sunday Puzzles of 2024. (I'm not ranking them; it's nicer that way)
  • David Kwong, "Art Heist" (Sunday, 12/15/24) — an extremely divisive puzzle that I thought was genius, both conceptually and architecturally. Paintings (represented by artists' names) disappear from the grid, replaced by single letters (from the crosses), which, taken together, form a final message: "I WAS FRAMED." So many layers, so much art. Loved it.
  • Harry Zheng, "Multi-Hyphenate" (Sunday, 12/29/24) —my first reaction to this one wasn't very positive, but that's largely because I didn't fully grasp or appreciate the technical achievement: "LINE"s replaced by a series of dashes, where each dash works perfectly as a hyphen in the (Down) crosses. This puzzle grew on me in the days followed, which puzzles rarely do (in that I usually forget them immediately).
  • Paolo Pasco, "The Big Five-O" (Sunday, 7/28/24) — the big Olympics puzzle depicting the famous Olympics insignia, the five colored rings. Every answer that forms part of a ring has, as its first word, the color of that ring, so the color itself stands in for the first part of each answer, with BLUEPRINT being represented by a (literally) blue PRINT, e.g. A technical marvel with a fun (and timely) visual gimmick. 
My Constructor of the Year for 2024 is ... well, two people: Paolo Pasco and Sarah Sinclair. They not only made two of my three favorite Thursday puzzles of the year together (MONSTER MASH, STUFFED CRUST), but separately they each made another puzzle that ranked among the three best of the year for its day (Sarah's Christmas Eve Nutcracker puzzle, Paolo's Olympics puzzle (see above). A really amazing output. Looking forward to seeing more from both of them, for many years to come.

That's all, folks. See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook]

88 comments:

  1. Andrew Z.6:16 AM

    I hate Elon too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:22 AM

      I don't necessarily hate Elon. I just don't like racism, misogyny, elitism, cronyism, egotism, antisemitism, narcissism, and people with a god complex.

      Delete
  2. Bob Mills6:17 AM

    Whenever I like a puzzle, Rex dislikes it (but I just sent him a small check, so it's OK). I thought the young man in Canada did a terrific job with this one...he tied everything together expertly (pun intended).

    ReplyDelete

  3. Easy. No overwrites and my only WOEs were DENIECE Williams at 63A and @Rex ALAN Walker at 122A.

    Me, with CA---SH at 30A: "Please don't be CATTISH ... Please don't be CATTISH ... Please don't be CATTISH ... D'oh!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Andy Freude8:01 AM

      Same here with CATTISH. I was all set to point out here that the correct word is CATlike, but a quick peek at Ngram tells me that CATTISH was more common for many decades until 1940 or so. Since then they have been neck and neck (not NOSE TO TAIL). I guess I was misled by Gilbert and Sullivan’s “With catlike tread” from “Pirates of Penzance.” I’ve enjoyed that one many times but don’t recall ever hearing “cattish.”

      Delete
  4. "Today's theme? Filamentary, my dear Watson!"

    ReplyDelete
  5. I generally enjoy most puzzles, at least to some extent, but this was decidedly meh. Way too easy (except for a little bite in the bottom right) and a very weak theme. And the inclusion of the deplorable South African person took it over the line to distasteful.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I liked that the pairs of words in each theme answer turn on a single letter. It reminded me of that moment in gift wrapping, where I start to tie a ribbon into a knot, and ask someone to press their finger onto what I’ve tied so I can finish it. That single letter uniting the two words in each theme answer evoked that feeling.

    That brought a "Huh!" and a "Hah!"

    I also got a kick out of CATTISH, a strange, funny, and likable word to me, just like yesterday’s PANTSED.

    Plus, joy came as well from a pair of original clues – [Some professions] for VOWS, and [Opera character whose name might be heard in an opera singer’s warmup] for MIMI.

    Not to mention having an area in the grid that refused to buckle, where I had to solve around it, approach it from a different direction to finally conquer it. My brain loves this kind of work.

    And, finally, this random theme about tying knots and what they may be tied with. That is so out of the box! Who thinks of that? I love running into things like that.

    So, your creation took me to a happy place, Jeffrey. Thank you for all the labor you put into this. You brightened my day!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wow, this is the earliest I’ve ever posted! So. I agree with pretty much everything Rex said today and I just KNEW he would bring up the fact that none of the CROSSSTITCH words constitute a WIRE except a cable. However, I’m easy to please so I still enjoyed the puzzle and the fact that there are people out there who are talented enough to come up with something clever (albeit imperfect) for my solving pleasure.

    My nit: Cooties were lice and are lice….not GERMS. Look up the old Cootie game (🙄) where the object is to build your Cootie before anyone else.

    ELON. I do not need to see him in puzzles, think he is a “nut” and despicable in many ways…however…pretty sure the man has provided free Starlink to many underprivileged/third world areas, so there is that.

    And Rex, YAY to the Zelle! I tend to put off doing PayPal (semi-equivalent to ELON for me) and, of course, don’t write paper checks anymore…so usually don’t have stamps. So I’m ON IT as soon as I post today!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Beezer
      But Elon Musk even threatened to cut off Ukraine from Starlink because he wanted to curry favor with Putin.
      I think it was resolved in the end without a cutoff but he is an egotistical monster at the Trump level.

      Delete
  8. I tried for a bit to make sense of the theme, but it was giving me a headache. Then I noticed that Rex basically had to write a doctoral dissertation to explain it and I literally started laughing out loud. That’s a theme ? Yeah, and I’m Albert Freaking Einstein.

    Anyway, the puzzle itself was pretty reasonable and manageable once I stopped squinting at the jumble of circled letters and just got on with solving it. There were a couple of head scratchers like PLAYABLE (more gamer-speak?) and THANOS crossing VENA is not very pretty. So, all-in-all, not a bad way to start the day - fortunately the convoluted theme didn’t strain the grid to the point where the fill turned to gibberish.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Southside Johnny
      About the theme. I decided to ignore it also. Just guessed it wasn’t worth the effort and came here after putting all letters in their correct places. A valid finish in my book. Happy I did that!

      Delete
  9. Solved as themeless - the trick is nonfunctional. That said - despite some blatantly long plurals - TELESCOPES, WIRES etc the overall fill was fine. GROWTH RING, QUEEN, NOSE TO TAIL are all solid.

    No Life SINGEd Her

    Was at CVS Friday getting my second shingles vaccine. Don’t really care if ELON or whoever shows up - they’re all in the moment and relevant. I liked CATTISH and EYE ROLL.

    Pray for me MAMA

    Enjoyable enough for a Sunday morning solve.

    Uncle Tupelo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope you’re doing well. The first shingles shot was a breeze…second one, not so much…but preferable to getting shingles!

      Delete
  10. Anonymous8:16 AM

    The NYT is a fascist publication, so it's really no surprise that they want to stick our new oligarch co-president in the puzzle.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous 8:16 AM
      About The NY Times
      You are entitled to your opinion.
      But if you are right, then the world is overwhelmingly fascist. And things are utterly hopeless.
      A bit of history.
      Statin ordered the German Communists to fight with every other party and negotiate with no one else. Hitler used the Communist party as a perfect foil to help him get into power.
      Every physical confrontation meant more votes for Hitler
      Stalin’s theory was to put the worst in power then take over later. See how much good that did his country!
      You have to choose your enemies carefully. The Stalinist all against all is the worst option

      Delete
  11. Easy puzzle. As usual I ignored the presence of circled squares. Paid no attention to “revealers.” Even reading Rex afterward, my reaction to the knots was “huh?” or maybe “meh.” I feel as though I remember a time when the Sunday puzzles were clever, delightful. The conceits were a joy to unravel. Now there’s all this tormented, non-witty, meaningless stuff. Is it bc of AI? I’m gong to blame AI.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The crossed theme words vaguely remind me of the knots in barbed wire, the way the ends stick out apart from the horizontal wires. Could those be the hidden wires?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous2:35 PM

      Nice catch! I believe that's correct.

      Delete
  13. The best and nearly the only moment of joy for me in this one was getting CROSSSTITCH off the C. I share pretty much all of OFL's objections to the things in the themers bearing no resemblance to WIRES and that none of them can be stitched. Jeez.

    Met DENIECE (I'm sure someone will come up with the whole joke about DENEPHEW) and learned about TAIPEI 101. Also found out about TOTO's birth name, which was cool, as I'm a big Wiz fan.

    Totally agree with @Conrad re CATTISH, which I doubt is even a word, and if it is, should not be. Feh.

    Some impressive construction, JM, but Just Made me glad to have it over with. To quote our benevolent overlord, "knot for me". Thanks for the effort and a modicum of fun.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thanks for reminding me of the Umbrellas of Cherbourg. I had it recommended and couldn’t believe what I was seeing! Amazing. Cher was watching La Boheme in Moonstruck - maybe that’s what you were thinking of.

    NPC is a “Non Playable Character”, so yes it is worth specifying in the clue. The movie “Free Guy” features Ryan Reynolds as a sentient non-playable character.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Free Guy was a surprisingly (to me) entertaining movie!

      Delete
  15. just bleh. too many short answers we’ve seen a thousand times. the woosh factor started too soon to be fun. and now the nyt is pandering to the douchebag who should remain nameless. the only positive thing about this puzzle is that it didn’t have a beginning or ending letter hint (“dee” “ess”). after connections, this has been a dud sunday.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Minori dreams9:01 AM

    I, too, liked the puzzle. Perhaps, after all these many years of at least sporadically solving the NYT crossword puzzle, I am still at Sunday, Monday, Tuesday skill level, but I liked it. Loved the clue for Mimi - brought back years of theatre warm up. I do hate the word ‘meh’ and I react to Elon, clued as it was today (a friend’s son is at Elon U), with equal distain. Thankfully the rest of the puzzle wasn’t so tainted!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Anonymous9:05 AM

    Hi, Michael. I’m happy to send a check today because this blog is worth so much to me and, I’m sure many solvers. It’s equal parts informative, entertaining, educational and cathartic. No matter where the daily NYTxword falls on the spectrum, this blog consistently shines. My thanks to and your team for providing this welcome constant companion.
    Happy, safe and healthy 2025!
    -Ted

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What a nice comment from an "Anonymous" for a change & one in which I totally agree :)

      Delete
  18. Diane Joan9:06 AM

    I liked the cross-stitch theme and the revealers. I do have to agree with Rex. As soon as Elon went into the puzzle I had a bad attitude.
    Elon and CVS? Yikes. Also at first I had "LOTUS" instead of "Asana" because asana is a general term for poses. Otherwise it was a pretty quick puzzle and in my wheelhouse, so thanks to the constructor for that!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Diane Joan
      As to CVS
      I just started a treatment program and one of the drugs had to be issued by “CVS Specialty Pharmacy “ No choice. CVS is now a Frankenstein monster participating on both sides of many medical pricing negotiations. Its “specialty pharmacy” is a bureaucratic mess. BTW I live in its home state. And it started life as a local discount store. (Consumer Value Store).

      Delete
  19. Hey All !
    CATTISH. Is that a word? Is that how CatWoman is described? EYE ROLL. Har.

    Strange puz. Agree about HIDDEN WIRES . It seems the circled answers don't qualify as WIRES. I'm sure it's lawyerable, though.

    Puz has E/W symmetry, seems a few SunPuzs lately have taken that route.

    Fun clue on NINELIVES. terrific clue for STEVIE!

    Didn't dislike puz (nice way to say that?), but a tad in the MEH side. I hate to say that, as I know making and filling puzs is no easy task. Fill held up pretty well today.

    Put in Aeon for AGES like I do Every. Time. Always wondering why the crossers don't work. Surprised Rex didn't go off on the UP dupe. "One is in the Revealer! How can you have another UP somewhere else?" which is what I had in my mind Rex was going to say. Rex SLIPped UP on that one! 😁

    MUST READS - My Book! Well, I don't know if I'd go that far! But, it's a fun romp, quick read at 125 pages. Search Darrin Vail at barnesandnoble.com or Amazon. If you think it's terrible, let me know! I've gotten good and "constructive" feedback. Har.

    Have a Great Sunday!

    Three F's
    RooMonster
    DarrinV

    ReplyDelete
  20. Anonymous9:20 AM

    Easy, and theme-wise, just fine. Nothing too special, not EYEROLL-worthy, simply MEH.

    About PLAYABLE - a very common term in gaming lingo is NPC (Non-Playable Character) which could be anything from a minor character, to a sidekick, or a main villain. And there are occasions where gamers get excited to see an NPC become PLAYABLE in a sequel to a game.

    Rex's top Sunday pick, the Art Heist puzzle, was very clever in concept IMO. However, I didn't like it as much as Rex because of some unknown (to me) squares that were only checked by the I WAS FRAMED secret message, and the stolen squares weren't easy to keep track of for online solvers, as many have pointed out. I didn't hate it like many others because it still had the fun factor of hunting down rebus squares.

    ReplyDelete
  21. My grand-nephew is a freshman at Elon U. Loves it. Just sayin'.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Anonymous9:42 AM

    If you can complete a puzzle without ever having to consider the theme then you might as well go themeless and concentrate on better fill and cluing.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Anonymous9:43 AM

    LOVE TO SURE CAN AND ALSO ugh

    ReplyDelete
  24. Anonymous10:22 AM

    THANK YOU Rex for your Elon remarks.

    ReplyDelete
  25. TICTACS crossing TAX is ticky-taxi in my book.

    Mr.Koppel and I love to go to those self-serve type businesses. Like the laundromat, the automat and the photomat. In fact tomorrow I'm going to JOINTED at the YOGAMAT for some auto-ASANAS.

    I may not know a lot about La Bohème, but I know that that CATTISH MIMÌ never became an OLEMISS.

    I used to work at a company where the C-Suite suits sported neckwear to denote their position. Chief Executive Officers had CEO ties, Chief Financial Officers had CFO ties and Chief Operating Officers had COOTIES. It was a fitness products company that promoted different ways to utilize your stomach muscles, relying on the general public to provide a stream of new product ideas. You may remember their short-lived campaign featuring the slogan "Tell us about your ABUSES."

    @Lewis. Is FLIRTY crossing ALLTIEDUP an S & M PuzzPair?

    I liked this more than@Rex did (but not more than I like @Rex. In fact I just WIREd him some clams because I love his blog). If you can't stretch a bit to acknowledge that even yarn is, in some ways, a WIRE, then why're we here?
    In fact, M-W's third definition is "something (such as a thin plant stem) that is wirelike". Can you imagine the reaction here if "plant stem" had been one of the components. I think knot.

    Anyway, I'm much more positive than most on this, so thanks, Jeffrey Martinovic.

    ReplyDelete
  26. There are two kinds of solvers. Those who will willingly make a huge effort to re-trace, re-track and cross-reference all the superfluous grid design elements whose letters they just filled in with no sweat at all -- sort of as if they were mining for gold after the fact. And those who won't. I'm squarely in the second camp.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Anonymous11:19 AM

    I would respect the NY Times more if they clued 2D as "47th President of the US?".

    ReplyDelete
  28. Easy. DENIECE, ALAN, and ALPEN were my only WOEs and Apnea before ANGST was it for erasures.

    I liked it, but I had the same take as @Rex about the revealers…they really didn’t work very well.

    @CDilly - Nice to have you back!

    ReplyDelete
  29. Isn’t it ironic how the president elect who once ranted and raved about Obama’s birth certificate is now the servant of a foreign-born tech bro - ELON Musk?

    ReplyDelete
  30. Anonymous11:38 AM

    Is this puzzle edited by Will Shortz? If so, when did he come back? And damn him to hell for trolling us with his ELON clue.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous3:51 PM

      He came back Dec 30

      Delete
  31. Omg…I just saw JAE shout out to CDilly52 and checked yesterday’s blog. Good to have you back after your rough year CDilly!

    ReplyDelete
  32. I know you’re not supposed to comment on a puzzle from prior days, but my therapist Jim Beam said it’s good to get it out with people who understand. Saturday’s puzzle was the hardest I have ever done in about 10 years of solving. Only got about 10%.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My therapist is Jim’s cousin, Jack Daniels. Small world!

      Delete
    2. And I agree 100% on Saturday’s puzzle!

      Delete
    3. Anonymous2:33 PM

      Yep, Makers Mark suggested I agree on yesterday's puzzle. I couldn't finish more than 3/4 of it. Super hard!

      Delete
    4. Anonymous9:36 PM

      At least we're drinking well 😅

      Delete
  33. Anonymous12:09 PM

    KNOT !

    ReplyDelete
  34. Anonymous12:11 PM

    living in socal for several decades it is obvious that here stop signs are also seen as visual pollution.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Niallhost12:16 PM

    I don't care about a theme that doesn't require that I understand any part of it. Like today. I'm sure I could have gone back over everything and figured out what the CROSS STITCH and HIDDEN WIRE business was all about but I didn't care. Easy Sunday. My only mistake was in the SW where I had put "URGE to" instead of URGE ON but a quick once over fixed that. 33:01

    ReplyDelete
  36. Anonymous12:37 PM

    by far my fastest sunday. one third my normal time.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Thought it was going to be a personal milestone as the first Sunday that I finished without looking anything up (it was short on proper nouns, and I was able to get the ones I didn’t know with crosses). But when I didn’t get happy music and was at a loss, I came here to find my error. Turns out that it was an abbreviation that messed me up. I didn’t know BTU so I had to rely entirely on crosses, and I had entered WAR ORDERS as a plausible (but much darker, as it turns out) answer for [Shots, for example]. Oh well. Committing BTU to memory now.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous5:42 PM

      Emily, thank you for explaining. Until now, I had bar or dens for "shots, for example". I had no idea what it meant. I FIW but on paper I did not realize. War orders seems to fit.

      Delete
  38. I liked this :). I still don't know what MODELUN is
    (anyone??), was stuck on VOWS for the longest time for some reason, I liked 13D DIYERS & if I never see (ugh!) ELON again it will be too soon. Thanks, Jeffrey :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Diane Joan2:07 PM

      MODELUN stands for Model United Nations, a high school club in which students take the roles of United Nations members.

      Delete
    2. Anonymous2:19 PM

      model (u)nited (n)ations does that help? i've also heard it refered to as mock un. its a simulation of the u.n. where students learn how the u.n. works (or is supposed to work)

      Delete
  39. My comment on this theme: 1 across. Nothing sticks out from my solve last night, except I highlighted the answer 49 across SLIPS UP for "Goofs". Why? Well it's a weird kind of kealoa in that if you take the clue as a plural noun instead of a verb, it can be SLIPUPS.

    Re Rex's annual financial pitch: I always dread it, not because I don't want to contribute (absolutely do!) but because PayPal is such a drag. Yesterday I had to click about 50 images of bicycles before it would let me contribute. I would click an image, it would disappear and another one would pop up!

    I wish Rex were here in Canada because then I could just do Etransfer, which is how I pay for absolutely everything that is not on my list of payees at my bank's web site. It sounds the same as Zelle (which does not work from Canada) in that all you need is an email address, and you can send them money from your bank's web page. No app to install; no extra steps. But... pretty much only works in Canada. Too bad!

    ReplyDelete
  40. Anonymous1:47 PM

    The puzzle had some interesting answers, I wonder if Rex would have liked it better as a themeless. Maybe that would have made the long theme answers less "bad"?

    ReplyDelete
  41. To jb129: MODELUN is model U.N. as in a pretend or mock United Nations.

    ReplyDelete
  42. SharonAK2:13 PM

    I loved Lewis' explanation of the theme. (Not given as an explanation, but his comment made it so clear.) I had rather enjoyed the theme without quite getting how it worked. I pulsed that the first letters needed to change places, but did not quite get how it worked. STUpid. So obvious once it was pointed out.
    Agree with Rex and other commenters that there is no wire in the theme answers. But it didn't bother me.
    Some great answers here and there in the puzzle. Got a smile out of 25 A as I put in eyeroll.
    Sunday has always been one o my favorite puzzle days.

    ReplyDelete
  43. @jb129 It's Model United Nations. Common high school activity.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Anonymous2:21 PM

    i can do without elon in my puzzles and in my real life.
    as for todays puzzle, i enjoyed it on a lazy sunday morning and think it was a good puzzle for new solvers.

    ReplyDelete
  45. M and A2:36 PM

    @RP: My least fave puz days in these parts: Fri or Sat, assumin they are themeless. I like SunPuzs fine, if the puztheme is either real humorous or real clever-enigmatic.
    Today's SunPuz is pretty weak on both, even tho a nicely filled puzgrid with the beluved [at our house] E/W symmetry.
    Seemed a bit easier than most SunPuzs, too boot.

    staff weeject pick [of a mere 34 choices]: hard to single out just one, but will go with TAT, on account of its cool clue.

    Thanx, Mr. Martinovic dude. Well-tangled fiberstuff, I'd grant.

    Masked & Anonymo9Us

    ... runty drivin rule ...

    "Stay in Your Lane!" - 7x7 themed runt puzzle:

    **gruntz**

    M&A

    ReplyDelete
  46. Anyone have a problem with 101,508 meters X 3.3 feet per meter = ~335,000 feet even with 15 foot ceilings that’s 22,000 floors ? What am I missing

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous4:41 PM

      The name of the building is Taipei 101. It is 508 meters high. That pesky comma.

      Delete
    2. Anonymous5:21 PM

      What are you talking about?

      Delete
    3. If you're serious, then you're missing that the building is named TAIPEI 101? But I have to admit that the 101,508 raised my left eyebrow for a nanosecond as well.

      Delete
  47. Anonymous2:39 PM

    Solved as a themeless. I have little interest in the silly games that the NYT tries to sell us these days.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Anonymous4:28 PM

    Agree that Sundays are my least favorite (only do Thursday-Sun) but as Sundays go, this was more fun than most. Don’t quibble with the lack of literal knots, and enjoyed the marquee answers,

    ReplyDelete
  49. I do an occasional workshop for our local sailing club on ropework---I call it Why Knot*---so when I saw the puzzle title, "I Think Knot", I was primed and ready to uncover some bowlines, rolling hitches, sheet bends, double constrictors and such. Then 3D HIDDEN WIRES crashed the party. As Rex points out, knots are tied with the likes of twine, thread, rope, line, etc., but with WIRES, no. Bummer. Yeah, and not with CABLE either.

    I did complete the entire puzzle to see if I had missed some angle that would explain these anomalies but that never materialized.

    *There's an Aussie that has a YouTube channel called "Why Knot" that is one of the better knot tying tutorials out there. Highly recommended.

    ReplyDelete
  50. I, too, am very glad to see you back, @CDilly, after what sounds like a perfectly wretched year. Please stay well!

    ReplyDelete
  51. La reina del carnaval llevaba un alambre oculto.

    This felt like secretarial work.

    ❤️ COOTIES. [Persian myths].

    Propers: 18
    Places: 5
    Products: 11
    Partials: 14
    Foreignisms: 5
    --
    Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 53 of 138 (38%)

    Funnyisms: 3 😕

    Uniclues:

    1 What might cause alone time in the lunchroom.
    2 Ursa major peeper.
    3 Feathered one's nest.

    1 COOTIES SURE CAN
    2 BEAR SPACE TELESCOPE
    3 QUEEN OF CARNIVAL CRIB

    My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Comic sans ... before I learned it's not okay. MY FAULT FONT.

    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    ReplyDelete
  52. Anonymous5:22 PM

    Anybody else puzzled by the apparently mangled clue at 88D: “Rock and roll Paul of fame”? I mean, that should be “Paul of rock and roll fame,” right?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous5:04 AM

      I believe it's a punny takeoff on the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame.

      Delete
  53. Hi. I just donated because I agree with you about Elon and loved your comment. And I rely on your blog to explain these puzzles when I don’t get them. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  54. Anonymous9:21 PM

    Given how many ways ALAN could be clued, picking an artist who has exactly one single hit the charts in the US, which peaked at #80, and zero albums on the US charts, is not the best choice.

    ReplyDelete
  55. LMTR.... not because of his dour view of the theme, I agree it was a bihikey, but so what? There were a few obscure propers but they were all fairly crossed, leading to a free, natick-free finish. Any puzzle that achieves that gets my vote!

    ReplyDelete
  56. OK, it’s actually Monday for some and it’s even starting to feel late here in NorCal (oh, in addition to everything else, earlier this year I relocated from Norman OK to Santa Rosa CA to be near my kids and granddaughter) but my first comment doesn’t appear and I really wanted to comment.

    Generally, this was super easy (especially after yesterday!) but the theme was lackluster for me. I just solved the whole thing without ever even wondering a teensy bit about the circles until I was completely finished. Even with ALL TIED UP staring at me, I still just didn’t really wonder enough to look back to see what it meant. So as I occasionally do in similar circumstances, I came here to see what @Rex and y’all have to say.

    When I was finished reading here, I concluded that my opinion hadn’t changed. The theme today was more of a constructor’s work of perseverance than an entertaining or even annoyingly (to many) goofy Sunday theme. And this from a long time solver who really enjoys the types of silly Sunday themes that tend to annoy so many. So go figure. I’ll look forward to seeing what everyone thinks about tomorrow.

    ReplyDelete
  57. Anonymous3:03 AM

    Poor Elon University. Really a great school.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Anonymous5:53 PM

    I dislike Elon Musk as much as everyone in this puzzle’s comments. I also think that 2 down should have read. Small first name in big American business.

    ReplyDelete
  59. Anonymous6:27 PM

    Elon musk’s name should never ever appear in any puzzle or publication. What a sicko. He has so far fathered 12 children since he is apparently trying to procreate the race. . His father is even worse. Errol has fathered 2 children with his stepdaughter that he helped raise since she was 4 years old. Even Steve Bannon doesn’t like him, that’s saying something. Isn’t it?

    ReplyDelete
  60. Anonymous1:35 PM

    Since when are Oreos a dessert? As in 99 down.

    ReplyDelete