Literally, "our thing" / FRI 6-21-24 / Shape of the Crab Nebula / Peddled good / Roughly half of mice / Island that's home to Popeye Village, a film-set-turned-theme-park / Nickname for a 3.2 million-year-old Australopithecus skeleton discovered in 1974 / Repeat an interviewer's question, perhaps / Burks, N.B.A. shooting guard since 2011
Constructor: Billy Bratton
Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium
THEME: none
Word of the Day: LUCY (33A: Nickname for a 3.2 million-year-old Australopithecus skeleton discovered in 1974) —
Lucy is an early australopithecine and is dated to about 3.2 million years ago. The skeleton presents a small skull akin to that of non-hominin apes, plus evidence of a walking-gait that was bipedal and upright, akin to that of humans (and other hominins); this combination supports the view of human evolution that bipedalism preceded increase in brain size. A 2016 study proposes that Australopithecus afarensis was also, to a large extent, tree-dwelling, though the extent of this is debated.
Lucy was named by Pamela Alderman after the 1967 song "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds" by the Beatles, which was played loudly and repeatedly in the expedition camp all evening after the excavation team's first day of work on the recovery site. After public announcement of the discovery, Lucy captured much international interest, becoming a household name at the time.
Lucy became famous worldwide, and the story of her discovery and reconstruction was published in a book by Johanson and Edey. Beginning in 2007, the fossil assembly and associated artefacts were exhibited publicly in an extended six-year tour of the United States; the exhibition was called Lucy's Legacy: The Hidden Treasures of Ethiopia. There was discussion of the risks of damage to the unique fossils, and other museums preferred to display casts of the fossil assembly. The original fossils were returned to Ethiopia in 2013, and subsequent exhibitions have used casts. (wikipedia) [my emph., what the hell!? Were the archaeologists being punished? This sounds like torture]
• • •
Usual trouble up front and then usual Friday whoosh. Not particularly remarkable in terms of how it played, or how exciting it was. Solid. Fine. There's this meme (is it a meme?) going around on Twitter (which apparently we're just calling "X" now) where people are asked to post their most "boomer" opinion ("boomer" being a relentless and stupid byword for "old" and "out of touch" used by social media lemmings terrified of aging and death). Well, I have not as yet participated in this mass confession of "old man yells at cloud" opinions, but if I did, my own most "boomer" opinion—crossword edition—would be "Get Your Damn Emojis Out of My Crossword Puzzle!" I don't mind emojis, in their place. I use them. A bunch. Where they belong—in texts and social media posts. Every time I see the puzzle trying to be "modern" by using emojis for clues, I just feel very, very ... tired. Disappointed. Will Shortz absolutely changed crossword puzzles in the '90s by making them more contemporary, including more everyday phrases and names, steering puzzles away from arcane trivia and leaning more heavily into wordplay. His approach was a substantial innovation. If you're going to innovate, innovate. Adding emojis ... is not innovation. It's just bad redecoration. This is all to say that "THIS IS NOT A DRILL!" is a great answer (best in the puzzle, appropriately placed in a marquee position) and does not deserve to have its clue cheaply bedazzled by siren emojis, or any emojis (8D: 🚨"Serious situation developing!"🚨). It's degrading. I am exaggerating the extent to which I actually care, but I do think there's something Vegas-ugly about taking an elegantly designed thing like the crossword and slapping emojis, animation, etc. on top of it. It's not making the puzzles better. It's just making them tackier.
Beyond that one marquee central answer, the answers that really grabbed my attention weren't any of the long ones. Those are OK, for the most part, but they aren't showing me anything new. Even stuff that's trying to be fresh, like BOOTY CALLS and MANSPLAINS, feels already a little dated. Not bad answers at all, but not as funky fresh as I think they think they are. "Mansplaining" is already 16 years old, as a term (I mean, it's likely ancient, as a concept, but as a term—just 16!). I only just learned that the term was coined in response to a 2008 essay by Rebecca Solnit ("Men Explain Things To Me"). Here's the origin story, in her words:
The word mansplaining was coined by an anonymous person in response to my 2008 essay Men Explain Things to Me and has had a lively time of it ever since. It was aNew York Times word of the year in 2010, and entered the Oxford English Dictionary in 2018; versions of it exist in many other languages from French to Icelandic, and the essay itself has appeared in many languages including Korean and Swedish. People often recount the opening incident in that almost 15-year-old essay, in which a man explained a book to me, too busy holding forth to notice that I was its author, as my friend was trying to tell him. (The Guardian, Feb. 9, 2023)
It's a fine answer, MANSPLAINS, it's just not giving wow at this point. I was more taken with the lively colloquial phrases today, "I WOULDN'T..." and "WE GET IT." There's something about hearing the voices of people saying these things in my head that is wonderfully entertaining. I like hearing the mock-urgency in "THIS IS NOT A DRILL!," the diplomatic reserve of "I WOULDN'T," the eye-rolling impatience of "WE GET IT!" What I like less is the awkward plural HOLES-IN-ONE (valid, but dumb-looking and -sounding). SLIME TRAIL gets a thumbs-up for daring to be gross, and for giving the puzzle that lovely SLIME/GRIME juxtaposition. Most of the rest of the answers in the grid just take up space. I don't mind them. There they are. Existing. Doing what they do...
Clues on ELK (18A: Colorado's ___ Mountains) and ALEC (49D: ___ Burks, N.B.A. shooting guard since 2011) were totally meaningless to me. Sports names are always going to be problematic for a certain sizable subset of solvers, so as a rule those names should belong to players for some distinction. Now, you have to be a very good basketball player to have the kind of longevity that ALEC Burks has had (13 years in the league now), but ... no All-Star appearances, no championships, no "most this" or "highest that" or "league-leading something or other" or really anything beyond just being a solid player (sometimes starting, but mostly off the bench). He's got a name-like name and the crosses are easy, so no harm no foul (!), but there should probably be Some kind of bar that athletes have to clear before being considered crossworthy. I know you desperately want to deliver a new and better ALEC for the crossword solvers of the world, but ... come on.
Had some great mistakes / wrong thoughts today, starting with trying to make NOTRE DAME work at 1A: Literally, "our thing despite knowing very well that that is not what NOTRE DAME means. I'd like to thank ASS for giving me the "A" that helped me remember COSA NOSTRA, which jump-started the NW and sent me no my way, with no real hesitations or slow-downs thereafter, though there were a few "huh?" moments. I was very unsure about what was going on with half of all mice (27A: Roughly half of mice). Wanted SHES (!?)—the crossword puzzle has insisted over the years that HES is a plural known for "males," so why not SHES? Once I got it down to -OES ... I'm just happy I (sorta) knew they were DOES (like the deer, the female deer), and also knew the term DOPE SHEET, because I'm imagining a world where someone thinks a bookmaker publishes the betting odds on a HOPE SHEET (because bettors "hope" they win??), and then the mice would end up as HOES, which would be ... confusing, probably. I thought the decor at a lake house was an OIL ("couldn't those hang in any house?") (30A: Piece of wall décor at a lake house, perhaps), I thought SANK was FELL (3D: Didn't go down well?), and when the [Shape of the Crab Nebula] wasn't CRAB, I was fresh out of ideas there. Found the clue on WAS extremely awkward ("that WAS that"??? I've heard "that's that!" but ick this past tense version feels contrived) (11A: What might come between "that" and "that"). But I loved the clue on STALL (15D: Repeat an interviewer's question, perhaps)—again, imagining the context is part of the fun—and the clue on WARE is particularly great, with its fake bad grammar (36A: Peddled good) ("it's peddled well!" I can hear someone prematurely shouting)
Notes:
35A: Island that's home to Popeye Village, a film-set-turned-theme-park (MALTA) — was puzzled / intrigued by this seemingly bizarre bit of trivia until I remember that MALTA is where Altman filmed his 1980 movie Popeye, and yeah, that outdoor set is elaborate, stunning. The kind of place a kid (like me, at the time of the movie's release) would in fact want to run around in. (Note: it's ... not really a kids' movie, despite being about a kids' cartoon character and starring that guy who played every 1980 kid's favorite sitcom character, Mork from Ork)
56A: "Hang on!" ("HOLD IT A SEC!") — got the "HOLD IT," which seemed a complete answer in itself. My brain wanted only "HOLD IT RIGHT THERE!"
52D: Translation material (RNA) — "Translation is the process by which a protein is synthesized from the information contained in a molecule of messenger RNA (mRNA)" (nature.com)
55A: Shares on X (RTS) — “X,” formerly known as Twitter. RTS = “retweets” (because RXS already has a meaning?)
On the easy side - and not a lot of depth. Agree with Rex on the stuff that tried to be fresh and the graphics use - detracted from the fun. The HOLES plural is inexcusable.
SLIME TRAIL, GRIME, ABJECT, the completely irrelevant WORLD COURT - downers. Did like MALTA and SOB STORY.
Patience paid off after way way way too long. I probably stared at the NAPPIES (?!) area for 15 minutes because I was sure [much adult programming] was ONLINE and [Scottish folds] was BRAIDS. I finally worked it out, but oof. Nothing will make you love crosswording more than knowing you need more diaper and pacifier knowledge to be successful at filling the grid.
Thirteen solid long and lively phrases. Good puzzle. So random to add emergency light emojis on one clue for no reason. I counted that as a funnyism, but I think it's a weirdism.
Tee-Hee: I'm pretty sure I got the hook previously this week for showcasing two baudy words, and now this puzzle arrives. In the neighborhood of 20 ehem-ish moments. Pretty sure our beloved lonely slush pile editor has been busy not-editing other aspects of the puzzle lately, and today opted to make a cameo appearance by slumming with the plebs and helped select this non-stop juvenalia parade. Maybe a new slushie is in training.
Uniclues:
1 What one old white guy (at least) does in Chicago, Ill. 2 Makes baby hook-and-loops. 3 The lesser known and altogether dismal Old Sorta Faithful. 4 The government's grubby paws all over your business in Chicago, Ill. 5 Mayonnaise on your chin. 6 Where Bad Barbies come from near Fairbanks, Alaska.
Whooshiest Friday in memory, COSANOSTRA and MASNSPLAINS instantly and AVALANCES wasn't far behind. See also IWOULDN'T, HOLDITASEC, HOLESINONE and various other first guesses. Didn't know the Popeye reference but an island ending in -LTA was easy enough. Wanted TIPSHEET but that didn't fit but DOPESHEET was my first alternative. That kind of a morning.
Didn't know ALEC but did remember LUCY so names today not a problem. Finally.
Smooth as a smelt Friday, here BB. Basically Busted my Friday record, (maybe, don't keep track) and thanks for all the fun.
Graham Parker's "Soultime" has several emphatic "that was that"s.
We never tried to change the world It didn't need changing We were the in crowd yeah And that was that Graduating from a Lambretta to a Triumph Herald car Was the only future in sight Oh and that was that
If you hate the convergence of crosswords and emojis, don't even take a peek at the Apple News+ puzzles. Frequently, emojis are either in the clues or ARE the clues. It's horrible, and (I do them on my Mac) they're so small it's extremely hard to even determine what they are. Just stupid, really.
Not sure that I understand the criticism for “holes in one”. There’s literally no other way to say it. Properly anyway. What’s next, carping about attorneys generals?
Some outstanding clues (AVALANCHE, for example) with a fair grid spanner (just ignore the emojis), a nice homage to BOOTY CALL and best off all, no B-list actors or soap opera “stars”. Unfortunately, we did go with one B-list athlete - but of course, this is the NYT so that was pretty much mandatory.
I really, really wish they would aspire to deliver puzzles like this as a rule rather than the exception (low on PPP, light on foreign stuff, very little arcana or trivia, virtually no gunk or quasi made-up words).
We have some experienced constructors who post here regularly - tell us your thoughts: is it really that much more difficult to construct a puzzle with the constraints I described above ? Maybe it is, in which case this constructor deserves a real tip of the hat (and consideration for the best “crafted” grid of the year). I’m guessing that this is also some indication of what is possible if you eliminate the requirement that the grids have a theme five days a week.
Oh, well. So much for my wishful thinking - I will enjoy this one while it lasts though.
I’m with you on finding ALEC a pretty ridiculous answer as clued, and I’m a big NBA fan. But in addressing your questions more broadly, are you perhaps making a faulty assumption that people at large want the version of the puzzle that’s often advocated for in these comments? I for one like the arcana and trivia, even if it costs me a solve on rare occasions. I think the issue may lie in the fact that constructors, and the Times, are not trying to construct to the taste of this commentariat and failing, but rather that they are aiming for a balance to appeal to a wider community of solvers.
Lovely breezy Friday! I love it when this happens: first time through the acrosses, things look grim, very few letters filled in, then through the downs for a bunch more words coming clear, then whoosh, whoosh! I liked SLIMETRAIL, SOBSTORY, and everything in the NW.
re "RTS", thankfully Elon's attempts to get people to say things like "I just X'ed this on X" have failed so far. I was genuinely afraid that that answer would turn out to be "RXS" (though that would have violated the rule of no direct hints in the clue).
I’m still reeling from the fact that I filled in the NW corner in a matter of seconds—nothing like that ever happened to me before. That must be what it’s like to be a really good crossword puzzler. May never happen to me again! The southwest was much harder but once I guessed that female mice could be DOES that part filled in with back and forth among the crosses. In the SW got hung up starting HOLESINONE as sOLE something, so struggled there. Otherwise, was pretty much on the author’s wavelength. Remembering the fuss over LUCY was fun.
Didn’t know “does” or or “door” or “opt” or “rts”… Whole southwest a complete flop… Dope sheet? Booty calls? Ugh… PS . Emojis dont appear on print version either.
Well that was a fun Friday. Not whooshy for me, but most of the long answers slipped in with relatively (for me) few crosses, which I still find gratifying on a Friday. Couple holdups: I refused to go with BREEDS because I was sure not capitalizing fold and blue was a misdirect, LOL, which I guess it was. OSCARnoD, John or James, ONLinE, SadSTORY, but all happily and easily resolved.
Being a DOGOODER I kind of resent being type cast as HOLIERTHANTHOU. IWOULDNT say most DOGOODERS are, but WEGETIT. LOL, and only some of the calls to my lover are BOOTYCALLS, but OK there too. Much as I enjoyed most of the longs, my favorite clue/answer was for BLOWN.
COSA NOSTRA = "Our thing". Somehow, I've always known that about the Mafia, even though I don't know anything else. Though I was an editor at the Literary Guild during the heyday of Mafia-themed books by the likes of Puzo, Talese and Pileggi, I somehow managed to miss them all. Missed all the Mafia flicks, too. No, I have never even seen Godfather 1.
Because their "thing" is not my thing. I don't find them colorful; I don't find them remotely interesting. I don't care about their weddings and I don't care about their funerals. I don't care if they're good fathers or lousy fathers. "If you'll just leave me alone," I say to the Mafia, "then I'll leave you alone. Go swim with the fishes, for all I care."
So 1A went in promptly. Making the puzzle seem quite easy for a Friday.
I'm going to add SLIME TRAIL to the Mafia in my list of things I don't ever want to think about. I'm not sure what a SLIME TRAIL is, exactly, but I know it doesn't pass my "Breakfast Test". It may be as un-breakfast-y an answer as I have ever seen in the NYTXW.
But the puzzle today certainly didn't lack for colorful fill. MANSPLAINS; SOB STORY (very nicely clued); BOOTY CALLS; ALIEN RACE; THIS IS NOT A DRILL. Why, a good storyteller could weave this into quite an effective potboiler of a novel -- and if he didn't throw COSA NOSTRA into the mix, I'd read it. A fun puzzle.
Hey All ! Solved like walking through mud. Stuck all over, thinking how am I to get anywhere?, but amazingly enough, got through the mire rather quickly for what seemed like I wouldn't be able to solve this. Finished to the Happy Music in 25 and 1/2 minutes! Dang. Good, but odd.
NW toughest spot. The NAPPIES clue was a Huh?, ONLATE a good misdirect, was looking for smutty or some sort of synonym for that.
Who put in MTETNA at first for GEYSER? *Raises hand*
EELS are scary enough in the water, now we have to worry about them on land? Terrific. 😁
Made it to Friday, now only if the weekend was longer (and I wasn't so tired at the end of the day!)
I actually thought this was a pretty good example of the stuck.... stuck... WOOOSH model of puzzle solving experience. At first I was worried when the NW started right off with that big fat gimme (COSANOSTRA) and the whole quadrant fell with a Tuesday-easy flump! But after that the other quadrants gave ma a pretty good tussle before letting go, and some fun fill to make it feel worth the trouble. Other than the stupid emoji (why bother? it didn't register as a clue to anything--I couldn't even figure out what it was) this one wound up "easy" but with just enough sticking points along the way to make it fun. That said, my time was more Wednesday than Friday. Guess the marketing Dept is still pushing for easy easy but I'm not cancelling my subscription just yet.....
Finally got it after changing "sex story" to SOBSTORY. It was hard to get SLIMETRAIL because IMED made no sense as a cross. What does IMED mean?
I agree with thfenn that "holier-than-thou type" is an overly harsh description of a DOGOODER. It might describe someone who brags about doing good things. But my church is filled with people who do good things without bragging about it.
Mr. Mills: When you send a text you are sending an Instant Message, or 'IM'. People use that as a verb: "Why don't you IM me?" And so IMED is the past tense of that verb: "But I IMed you last Tuesday!"
People are complaining about the false equivalence that this puzzle sets up between DO-GOODERS and people who act HOLIER-THAN-THOU. I sympathize, but there is a real and recognized difference between "People who do good deeds" and "DO-GOODERS". There's something more overt about "DO-GOODERS" than "People who do good deeds" - - something very slightly ostentatious? Remember the parable of the widow's mite.
JFK: “We choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other things (e.g., Friday crosswords) not because they are easy, but because they are hard. Because that goal will serve to organize and measure the best of our energies and skills, because that challenge is one that we're willing to accept.”
Today’s was just not very challenging. (Didn’t even need any Rexplaining to fully grok it).
Hey, since I adopted Diva, the ultimate VELCRO dog, am I a DOG GOODER?
Bonanza of 4 letter Hidden Diagonal Words (HDW) today. Here are clues for 4 of them:
1. Runs out of juice
2. Very in Rouen
3. Hardy titular character
4. White vestments with rope cinctures
(Answers below)
Friday (and Saturday) puzzles fall in three categories for me: a) those that look hopeless for the first few minutes, then get a couple of toeholds and turn out to be "Easy" for me--25-30 minutes; b) those that look hopeless at first and lead to a long slow grind, ending in a hard fought victory or a "close but no cigar" dnf--roughly an hour; and c) those that look hopeless at first and ... are hopeless, those rare "never gonna happen" solves.
Today was an "a)" puzzle. Took a few minutes to establish a toehold in the extreme SE corner (TAOS, SINE, JAMESI, SHH), then moving across to the SW; then up to the NE; and finally getting the NW with NAPPIES as a breakthrough guess.
Answers to HDW clues: 1) DIES (Begins with the D in 25D, DOLL, moves to NE) 2) TRES (T in 22A, I WOULDNT--that LDNT looked so weird and wrong at first) 3) TESS (T in 1A, COSA NOSTRA, moves to SE) 4) ALBS (A in 39A, ABJECT, moves to NW)
@Tom T 10:27 AM So happy you're back. I do not know why I love your HDWs so much, but I do. And you and I have similar solving options for Fridays and Saturdays. On the ones that are "never gonna happen," my best friend Uncle G helps.
Thanks, Gary. I have this stubborn streak about looking up answers that I'm sure I should get over. I'll just hit reveal if I'm at the point of giving up. But if I used Uncle Google, I could learn and maybe even remember more for the next time. Keep those uni-clues coming!
With @Pabloinnh today. His “ Whooshiest Friday in memory, COSANOSTRA and MASNSPLAINS instantly and AVALANCES wasn't far behind.” was 100 percent 💯 emoji mine. (Bet that emoji doesn’t work, but gotta try just to MANSPLAIN for 🦖 (dinosaur emoji).
As a Godfather film freak, one across provided a rare toehold……literally half the usual slog of late week solves. SLIMETRAIL and BOOTYCALLS clues were outstanding. Impossible to find a HOLE IN (this) ONE!
Easy, with one slow-down where I was thinking DReam before DRILL. I liked ABJECT, the clue for BLOWN, GRIME on SLIME, and coming upon DOPE SHEET in my memory junk drawer.
The first Stuart king was formally James, but JAMESI to his buds.
I asks Mrs. Egs to grab me something from my shop to put two HOLESINONE of her cupboards for cup hooks. She brings me a hammer, so I MANSPLAINS that THISISNOTADRILL.
Of course this won’t age well, but a defense of ALEC Burks in the puzzle: 1 - NYT is a NY paper and he plays for the Knicks 2 - He just had a moment in the playoffs where he Did Not Play for 14 games, then once half the Knicks roster went down to injury against the Pacers in the 2nd round, he came in like gangbusters, averaging almost 20 ppg. Memes went around with him and Michael Jordan juxtaposed with “Save Us Alec Burks” jokes. 3 - All the crosses were fair;)
I loved the clue for SLIMETRAIL and BOOTYCALL surprised me even if not certified fresh.
A lot of stuff fell easily with no crosses, including SLIME TRAIL. One look at the clue and there was no better option. Love that. Remembered DOES from, I think, Watership Down. Really glad I learned DOPE SHEET from some other (recent?) Friday or Saturday puzzle. Had “hole in ones” before HOLES IN ONE but the latter is clearly correct in retrospect. Fun puzzle. I liked it!
I had my share of troubles but every time I thought I’d met ABJECT failure, I’d get one little breakthrough and be back in the RACE again. The NE slowed me down where I had HEDGE for stall and ALIEN LIFE for race. Plus I couldn’t seem to get my mind out of the gutter trying to make a blue yarn? something to do with SMUT or PORN. Brilliant cluing, my favorites being BOOTY CALLS, AVALANCHES, and SLIME TRAILS. Then there was that little NOT A DRILL jewel down the middle, with quotation marks on my printout and emojis on my app.
Smoothest solve and best Friday in a very long time. Thank you, BB! Even though I’ve done your puzzles before, I don’t recall them being this much fun, but I sure look forward to seeing your name again.
In light of yesterday's remarks about YALE and ELI being over-used in the NYT crossword, I think we should normalize CARL clues and answers. Carleton College-based constructors--Mr. Bratton, Sophia Maymudes, David Liben-Nowell--are very well-represented.
I started in the NW and continued clockwise at the fastest I’ve ever done on a Friday. …until I hit the SW, where everything ground to a halt. Still finished but that last section killed me.
An okay Friday for me & surprised I finished it so fast. I didn't know LUCY, ALEC. Once I got it, I liked SHH for Sound in the Stacks.. And I'm embarrassed to say I really liked BOOTY CALL. So all in all, a nice Friday, Billy - thanks :)
Yeah, @kitshef, it's hard to imagine -- were you able to walk around unassisted, or did you need somebody to carry your train? Wish I'd seen it!
I'm getting tired of people using "boomer" to mean "old." Boomers are called that because they were born during the baby boom, when the men who'd fought the war came back and got busy at home, so to speak. I'm old but, having been born in 1943, I am definitely not a boomer. (My father worked in an important war industry, Seagram's Distillery, so he was exempt.)
As reported already, they did not print those emojis in the paper, although they have in the past--but not in color. So I'm glad you illustrated what you meant, Rex.
A little self-deprecation: I thought there might be 17 rOOms in Clue, but when I needed that D I went with DOOmS, figuring maybe when you combine different ways to die in that game there might be 17 (far too small a number, in fact). Aside from its being wrong I kind of like that answer -- but never noticed that I had BREm as a title where BRER would work.
I've learned about DOES among mice from crosswords of the past, more than once, I think. Rabbits, too, as @Sam points out.
When "nuestra cosa" was one letter too long for 1A "Literally, 'our thing'" I remembered COSA NOSTRA and I was off to the races. I did notice, however, that AVALANCHE and MANSPLAIN needed some ASSistance to do their jobs. And appropriately enough, so did BOOTY CALL and HOLE IN ONE. My inner nine year old will stop there lest I start leaving a SLIME TRAIL.
I'm still not sure how 41A OSCAR BID is the answer to "Consideration for the Academy". "Votes" and "nominations" are mentioned at oscars.org but no "BID". There are some sites, including wiki, that speak of "OSCAR Bait", movies that seem to have been made just to get some OSCAR nominations. And then some sites that estimate how much you would have to BID to buy an OSCAR statuette at an auction.
Liked it. Learned a female mouse is a doe, male mouse a buck, baby is a kitten or pinkie. You’d think they could’ve come up with terms for an animal in the rodent family that was a far cry from the deer family.
It's so nice when 1 across is a gimme. However there weren't all that many others for me, although WORLD COURT went right in because of the suspicious "suits" in the clue.
A couple of typeovers, SAD STORY and THIS IS NOT SO GOOD which I was glad to change because... it was not so good.
@kitshef, your slug costume sounds hilarious and dangerous. I get a LOT of kids at Halloween, and my front gate is kind of narrow which can cause issues. One kid was dressed as a carton of milk and he got firmly stuck, poor guy.
Easy + Medium SW. COSANOSTRA went right in. (How does extra virgin olive oil taste these days?) LUCY helped speed up the right side. I knew the origin of the name, but I never questioned why they listened to only one song. At least it was LUCY instead of Wild Honey Pie.
Original clue for 49D: Name found in "Yale College". Joel said HOLDITASEC and changed the clue at the last moment, due to all the complaints about Yale. (Fun fact I just made up.)
I had Popeye on VHS growing up. Some serious nostalgia watching that clip, decades later. Robin Williams, miss that guy.
Thanks for the puz, Billy Bratton. See you again soon, I'm sure.
@2:17 Legendary comment. In the mansplain coinage origin story, it all really depends on your outlook: you could be really proud that someone is so excited about your book not knowing you are the author; or you could have just had 4 other mansplaining annoyances right beforehand and have no patience left.
"I'm old but, having been born in 1943, I am definitely not a boomer," says @jberg.
Oh, @jberg (12:31)-- we're more or less the same vintage and I most definitely AM a boomer! All my classmates from both high school and college have always considered themselves to be boomers. I'm not going to let those clueless contemporary revisionists, those Johnny-come-latelys, take my generation away from me. We were considered boomers for decades -- until suddenly we were told we weren't. But if not boomers, then what are we exactly? We're hardly the Silent Generation. What a ridiculous thought THAT would be! At the tail end of the "silent" 1950s, I was 17 and you were 16. We were both in college in the tumultuous '60s. We both had our first jobs in the tumultuous '60s. The 1960s, which is the quintessential boomer era, is the era that formed us.
And now people born as late as 1964 are considered boomers? Fuhgeddaboutit! They weren't even born until after the Kennedy assassination. They were 3-years-old when Woodstock occurred. They wouldn't have entered college until the mid 1980s. They inhabited an entirely different world from the baby boom generation. I don't know who re-defined these categories, exactly when they re-defined them, or who granted them permission to do so, but I cry foul.
Don't take it lying down, @jberg. You may be an early boomer, but you're still a boomer.
Sorry. OPT as clued was not right. You OPT OUT or I guess you can opt IN, but I found that clue unfair. Maybe "one of a pair of words". But not like that.
Not a lot to add here. Like most commenters, I liked the puzzle. Also, like most commenters, I thought the emojis were stupid. They just looked like red and white blobs to me. Started in the NW where I stumbled over COSANOSTRA, which I know but apparently don't know, and proceeded clockwise at my usual ambling pace around to the central west coast where I just bogged right down. Small stuff like BREEDS, DOES, DOOR and OPT just wouldn't happen. Saved by BOOTYCALL and DOPESHEET (though my first thought was the too short tipSHEET).
MALTA was a gimme because I'm a big Robert Altman fan and Robin Williams and Shelley Duvall were great in Popeye.
@Nancy, I see your point -- certainly I'm part of the same cultural group as boomers, so maybe I should just accept the term. I think of us more as the Vietnam/Civil Rights generation, but I guess it's too late to change it.
@anon (1:47) I did google OSCAR BID. Google changed it to OSCAR Bait. I stayed the course and finally got a page on OSCAR BID. I didn't see any confirmation. Guess I didn't look far enough. Thanks for the correction.
A fun and snappy Friday (despite the terrible emojis, which looked awkward on the Games website). My fastest Friday in a whole, but still seems challenging. Getting 1A right off the bat on a Friday or Saturday is always empowering.
Have to respectfully disagree with Rex on WAS. I loved that answer once I got it, because it's less often seen. Reminded me of one of the scenes in No Country for Old Men Tommy Lee Jones and Barry Corbin. Some of the nest scenes in an amazing movie. Corbin ends one of his stories that way. "Uncle Mac knew the score, even if Aunt Ella didn't. Shot through the left lung. And that was that - as they say." Goodfellas does have a "And that's that" when Tommy gets killed.
Absolutely with Rex on ALEC Burks, and I'm a Knicks fan. He's not good enough for common knowledge. In my younger days, 90s, I got in my head that I would try to submit a puzzle. It was terrible, but I did it. I got a very nice encouraging email from Will Shortz. He said some of my names were too obscure and were forced. He was right, but my response back was that ESAI Morales is not an A-List actor, but he has three vowels in a four letter name. I stand by that. Thanks for the great write-up. Happy Friday!
I always appreciate your comments and was only offering additional information for you, not trying to correct you.
I find Google searches to be a puzzle in and of themselves. There's a rubric involved that includes understanding the most succinct way to get the responses you're looking for, but also seeing the initial set of results and understanding how better to finesse the search on subsequent attempts.
In this case, for my third attempt to get results specific to OSCAR BID (rather than the tangential connections Google was absolutely sure I must have wanted), I put double quotes around the search term (i.e., "OSCAR BID") which tells Google to try hard to stick to exactly what was entered.
I hope this helps, and thanks again for your consistently interesting/amusing comments on this blog.
This was one of those puzzles where I completed about half; felt stuck; took a three hour break and came back and completed it in 10 minutes. I love when that happens. Seems to prove that our brains do a lot of work when we’re not consciously thinking.
Got thrown off in spelling today, and thought there was a minor Chicago theme with Trib, Ohare, and Els, turns out I don’t know how to spell cosenostra. I also had hopesheet and hoes, but did figure that out eventually,
Hard. Good Friday-level hard fun. To the blogmaster: Can we have a button to click on to enter comment so we don’t have to scroll down to the bottom of the page please?
OFNP misunderstands the "Peddled good" clue. It's not bad grammar. GOODS:WARES::GOOD:WARE.
I like this puzzle, though it's a BIT easy for Friday. In the 8-down clue, there was no emoji in my paper, just quote marks. I wouldn't have recognized the emoji anyway. Still laid it down with only a few crosses.
Also laid down: COSANOSTRA. Helped a lot kicking off the NW. The most resistance I got was sub-NW, around BIT, BRER, DOES and DOOR. Birdie.
A LATE BOOTYCALL? NOT A reason to STALL, A RACE to LACE SHEETs, DO NOT forget IT. IT IS A thrill, and THISISNOTADRILL, IWOULDN’T wait, THISIS how WEGETIT!
Puzzle was velcroish in many spots for me, but definitely easier than yesterpuz. I doh slapped myself when I finally wrote in cosa nostra, and said to myself: you know that you moron! I think I'll call my Depends mannappies from now on.
Solved in a flash…these ARE getting easier. Not complaining but do like more of a struggle on Friday and please keep your BOOTY CALLS to yourself, thanks! 😉
What emojis?
ReplyDeleteNo emoji on the printed version here.
DeleteNot in Switzerland either. Easy Friday. I like that!
DeleteOn the easy side - and not a lot of depth. Agree with Rex on the stuff that tried to be fresh and the graphics use - detracted from the fun. The HOLES plural is inexcusable.
ReplyDeleteSLIME TRAIL, GRIME, ABJECT, the completely irrelevant WORLD COURT - downers. Did like MALTA and SOB STORY.
I’m going to the beach.
Just get up and close the DOOR
Shares on X ??
ReplyDeleteX = formerly Twitter. RTS = “retweets”
DeleteThe emojis meant nothing to this boomer. Squint, shrug, solve anyway.
DeleteFun fact: the ELK mountains are very prone to AVALANCHES.
ReplyDeletePatience paid off after way way way too long. I probably stared at the NAPPIES (?!) area for 15 minutes because I was sure [much adult programming] was ONLINE and [Scottish folds] was BRAIDS. I finally worked it out, but oof. Nothing will make you love crosswording more than knowing you need more diaper and pacifier knowledge to be successful at filling the grid.
ReplyDeleteThirteen solid long and lively phrases. Good puzzle. So random to add emergency light emojis on one clue for no reason. I counted that as a funnyism, but I think it's a weirdism.
Propers: 6
Places: 4
Products: 3
Partials: 4
Foreignisms: 2
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 19 (27%)
Funnyisms: 9 🤣
Tee-Hee: I'm pretty sure I got the hook previously this week for showcasing two baudy words, and now this puzzle arrives. In the neighborhood of 20 ehem-ish moments. Pretty sure our beloved lonely slush pile editor has been busy not-editing other aspects of the puzzle lately, and today opted to make a cameo appearance by slumming with the plebs and helped select this non-stop juvenalia parade. Maybe a new slushie is in training.
Uniclues:
1 What one old white guy (at least) does in Chicago, Ill.
2 Makes baby hook-and-loops.
3 The lesser known and altogether dismal Old Sorta Faithful.
4 The government's grubby paws all over your business in Chicago, Ill.
5 Mayonnaise on your chin.
6 Where Bad Barbies come from near Fairbanks, Alaska.
1 MANSPLAINS TRIB
2 BREEDS VELCRO
3 ABJECT GEYSER (~)
4 OHARE TSA GRIME
5 DELI SLIME TRAIL
6 SCAR DOLL IGLOO
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Teaches brine shrimp to sit, stay, roll over, speak and shake hands. TAMES SEA MONKEY.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Whooshiest Friday in memory, COSANOSTRA and MASNSPLAINS instantly and AVALANCES wasn't far behind. See also IWOULDN'T, HOLDITASEC, HOLESINONE and various other first guesses. Didn't know the Popeye reference but an island ending in -LTA was easy enough. Wanted TIPSHEET but that didn't fit but DOPESHEET was my first alternative. That kind of a morning.
ReplyDeleteDidn't know ALEC but did remember LUCY so names today not a problem. Finally.
Smooth as a smelt Friday, here BB. Basically Busted my Friday record, (maybe, don't keep track) and thanks for all the fun.
Graham Parker's "Soultime" has several emphatic "that was that"s.
ReplyDeleteWe never tried to change the world It didn't need changing
We were the in crowd yeah And that was that
Graduating from a Lambretta to a Triumph Herald car
Was the only future in sight Oh and that was that
If you hate the convergence of crosswords and emojis, don't even take a peek at the Apple News+ puzzles. Frequently, emojis are either in the clues or ARE the clues. It's horrible, and (I do them on my Mac) they're so small it's extremely hard to even determine what they are. Just stupid, really.
ReplyDeleteRS
ReplyDeleteLovely Friday, at the appropriate difficulty level for the day of the week. I'm expecting (dreading?) a Saturday tomorrow.
Overwrites:
8D: THIS IS a red alert before NOT A DRILL
21A: Old crosswordese orT before BIT
24A: stEEDS before BREEDS
40D: John iI before JAMES I
WOEs:
ALEC Burks at 49D
Twitter/X abbrev. RTS at 55A
Emojis, you say? These boomer eyes couldn’t make out what those red smudges were supposed to be.
ReplyDeleteIf people are still retweeting (and, I infer, tweeting in the first place), then doesn’t that make “X” about the stupidest rebranding ever?
Came here to understand the answer DOES to clue ‘Half of mice’ - and now I can relax. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteSo … those weren’t jello mold emoji?
ReplyDeleteI’m guessing ALEC Burke was considered OK for the Times puzzle because he played for the Knicks last year, but … no.
Thanks Rex for explaining the clue for RTS.
HOLD on A SEC sounds natural. HOLD IT A SEC sounds made up to fit your crossword.
Beginning of DOG OODER definitely dooked me.
Not sure that I understand the criticism for “holes in one”. There’s literally no other way to say it. Properly anyway. What’s next, carping about attorneys generals?
ReplyDeleteYes
DeleteThat double plural hurt my brain
DeleteIt’s “attorneys general”, but I agree that there’s absolutely nothing wrong with “holes in one”.
DeleteSome outstanding clues (AVALANCHE, for example) with a fair grid spanner (just ignore the emojis), a nice homage to BOOTY CALL and best off all, no B-list actors or soap opera “stars”. Unfortunately, we did go with one B-list athlete - but of course, this is the NYT so that was pretty much mandatory.
ReplyDeleteI really, really wish they would aspire to deliver puzzles like this as a rule rather than the exception (low on PPP, light on foreign stuff, very little arcana or trivia, virtually no gunk or quasi made-up words).
We have some experienced constructors who post here regularly - tell us your thoughts: is it really that much more difficult to construct a puzzle with the constraints I described above ? Maybe it is, in which case this constructor deserves a real tip of the hat (and consideration for the best “crafted” grid of the year). I’m guessing that this is also some indication of what is possible if you eliminate the requirement that the grids have a theme five days a week.
Oh, well. So much for my wishful thinking - I will enjoy this one while it lasts though.
I’m with you on finding ALEC a pretty ridiculous answer as clued, and I’m a big NBA fan. But in addressing your questions more broadly, are you perhaps making a faulty assumption that people at large want the version of the puzzle that’s often advocated for in these comments? I for one like the arcana and trivia, even if it costs me a solve on rare occasions. I think the issue may lie in the fact that constructors, and the Times, are not trying to construct to the taste of this commentariat and failing, but rather that they are aiming for a balance to appeal to a wider community of solvers.
DeleteLovely breezy Friday! I love it when this happens: first time through the acrosses, things look grim, very few letters filled in, then through the downs for a bunch more words coming clear, then whoosh, whoosh! I liked SLIMETRAIL, SOBSTORY, and everything in the NW.
ReplyDeletere "RTS", thankfully Elon's attempts to get people to say things like "I just X'ed this on X" have failed so far. I was genuinely afraid that that answer would turn out to be "RXS" (though that would have violated the rule of no direct hints in the clue).
ReplyDeleteEasy puzzle without being stupid.
ReplyDeleteI agree emojis have no place in a puzzle that is, by definition, about words, not about tiny indecipherable picture-code things.
I’m still reeling from the fact that I filled in the NW corner in a matter of seconds—nothing like that ever happened to me before. That must be what it’s like to be a really good crossword puzzler. May never happen to me again! The southwest was much harder but once I guessed that female mice could be DOES that part filled in with back and forth among the crosses. In the SW got hung up starting HOLESINONE as sOLE something, so struggled there. Otherwise, was pretty much on the author’s wavelength. Remembering the fuss over LUCY was fun.
ReplyDeleteNo emojis in AcrossLite, just [?][?] on each side, which was easy to ignore. Sometimes obsolete (or abandoned) technology is a blessing.
ReplyDeleteHOLES IN ONE are wonderful things no matter what Rex says.
Unfortunate typo in THIS IS NOT A gRILL which took me a while to catch and which is kinda funny.
Didn’t know “does” or or “door” or “opt” or “rts”…
ReplyDeleteWhole southwest a complete flop…
Dope sheet?
Booty calls?
Ugh…
PS . Emojis dont appear on print version either.
FH
ReplyDeleteAnother very easy Friday....
Hardly put a foot wrong and finished in 12 minutes which is fast for me - - less than half my Friday average.
The trouble with mansplaining is how often I wind up with a mess when I don't.
ReplyDeleteSo Jammon
DeleteYou thought it was okay for the man to explain the book to its author?
Well that was a fun Friday. Not whooshy for me, but most of the long answers slipped in with relatively (for me) few crosses, which I still find gratifying on a Friday. Couple holdups: I refused to go with BREEDS because I was sure not capitalizing fold and blue was a misdirect, LOL, which I guess it was. OSCARnoD, John or James, ONLinE, SadSTORY, but all happily and easily resolved.
ReplyDeleteBeing a DOGOODER I kind of resent being type cast as HOLIERTHANTHOU. IWOULDNT say most DOGOODERS are, but WEGETIT. LOL, and only some of the calls to my lover are BOOTYCALLS, but OK there too. Much as I enjoyed most of the longs, my favorite clue/answer was for BLOWN.
COSA NOSTRA = "Our thing". Somehow, I've always known that about the Mafia, even though I don't know anything else. Though I was an editor at the Literary Guild during the heyday of Mafia-themed books by the likes of Puzo, Talese and Pileggi, I somehow managed to miss them all. Missed all the Mafia flicks, too. No, I have never even seen Godfather 1.
ReplyDeleteBecause their "thing" is not my thing. I don't find them colorful; I don't find them remotely interesting. I don't care about their weddings and I don't care about their funerals. I don't care if they're good fathers or lousy fathers. "If you'll just leave me alone," I say to the Mafia, "then I'll leave you alone. Go swim with the fishes, for all I care."
So 1A went in promptly. Making the puzzle seem quite easy for a Friday.
I'm going to add SLIME TRAIL to the Mafia in my list of things I don't ever want to think about. I'm not sure what a SLIME TRAIL is, exactly, but I know it doesn't pass my "Breakfast Test". It may be as un-breakfast-y an answer as I have ever seen in the NYTXW.
But the puzzle today certainly didn't lack for colorful fill. MANSPLAINS; SOB STORY (very nicely clued); BOOTY CALLS; ALIEN RACE; THIS IS NOT A DRILL. Why, a good storyteller could weave this into quite an effective potboiler of a novel -- and if he didn't throw COSA NOSTRA into the mix, I'd read it. A fun puzzle.
It seems to me that Twitter *lengthened* its name, in effect, because we usually see it as “X (formerly Twitter)”, or something like that.
ReplyDeleteHow 'bout TwiXter and that's that!
Deleteemojis? what emojis?
ReplyDeleteenjoyed this puzzle very much. close to a personal best time.
X? Who uses that???
ReplyDeleteRTS? WTH?
Hey All !
ReplyDeleteSolved like walking through mud. Stuck all over, thinking how am I to get anywhere?, but amazingly enough, got through the mire rather quickly for what seemed like I wouldn't be able to solve this. Finished to the Happy Music in 25 and 1/2 minutes! Dang. Good, but odd.
NW toughest spot. The NAPPIES clue was a Huh?, ONLATE a good misdirect, was looking for smutty or some sort of synonym for that.
Who put in MTETNA at first for GEYSER? *Raises hand*
EELS are scary enough in the water, now we have to worry about them on land? Terrific. 😁
Made it to Friday, now only if the weekend was longer (and I wasn't so tired at the end of the day!)
No F's - Again! - I ABJECT!
RooMonster
DarrinV
I actually thought this was a pretty good example of the stuck.... stuck... WOOOSH model of puzzle solving experience. At first I was worried when the NW started right off with that big fat gimme (COSANOSTRA) and the whole quadrant fell with a Tuesday-easy flump! But after that the other quadrants gave ma a pretty good tussle before letting go, and some fun fill to make it feel worth the trouble. Other than the stupid emoji (why bother? it didn't register as a clue to anything--I couldn't even figure out what it was) this one wound up "easy" but with just enough sticking points along the way to make it fun. That said, my time was more Wednesday than Friday. Guess the marketing Dept is still pushing for easy easy but I'm not cancelling my subscription just yet.....
ReplyDeleteFinally got it after changing "sex story" to SOBSTORY. It was hard to get SLIMETRAIL because IMED made no sense as a cross. What does IMED mean?
ReplyDeleteI agree with thfenn that "holier-than-thou type" is an overly harsh description of a DOGOODER. It might describe someone who brags about doing good things. But my church is filled with people who do good things without bragging about it.
Mr. Mills: When you send a text you are sending an Instant Message, or 'IM'. People use that as a verb: "Why don't you IM me?"
ReplyDeleteAnd so IMED is the past tense of that verb: "But I IMed you last Tuesday!"
People are complaining about the false equivalence that this puzzle sets up between DO-GOODERS and people who act HOLIER-THAN-THOU. I sympathize, but there is a real and recognized difference between "People who do good deeds" and "DO-GOODERS". There's something more overt about "DO-GOODERS" than "People who do good deeds" - - something very slightly ostentatious? Remember the parable of the widow's mite.
ReplyDelete@Bob Mills 9:14 - IMED - "instant messaged", which may or may not help depending on your experience of instant messaging.
ReplyDeleteI once dressed up as a slug for Hallowe'en. Trailing out the back was forty feet of plastic wrap to give the appearance of a SLIME TRAIL.
JFK: “We choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other things (e.g., Friday crosswords) not because they are easy, but because they are hard. Because that goal will serve to organize and measure the best of our energies and skills, because that challenge is one that we're willing to accept.”
ReplyDeleteToday’s was just not very challenging. (Didn’t even need any Rexplaining to fully grok it).
Hey, since I adopted Diva, the ultimate VELCRO dog, am I a DOG GOODER?
DNF
ReplyDeleteFARE for Peddled goods
Fegetit for ‘Yeah,Yeah, Yeah’
Had -TRA at the end of 1 Across and thought it could be KAMA SUTRA for a (hot) second before realizing it was one letter too short.
ReplyDelete"That Was That" is a common way of summing up a story. "We went to the restaurant, paid for the meal, and that was that."
Bonanza of 4 letter Hidden Diagonal Words (HDW) today. Here are clues for 4 of them:
ReplyDelete1. Runs out of juice
2. Very in Rouen
3. Hardy titular character
4. White vestments with rope cinctures
(Answers below)
Friday (and Saturday) puzzles fall in three categories for me: a) those that look hopeless for the first few minutes, then get a couple of toeholds and turn out to be "Easy" for me--25-30 minutes; b) those that look hopeless at first and lead to a long slow grind, ending in a hard fought victory or a "close but no cigar" dnf--roughly an hour; and c) those that look hopeless at first and ... are hopeless, those rare "never gonna happen" solves.
Today was an "a)" puzzle. Took a few minutes to establish a toehold in the extreme SE corner (TAOS, SINE, JAMESI, SHH), then moving across to the SW; then up to the NE; and finally getting the NW with NAPPIES as a breakthrough guess.
Answers to HDW clues:
1) DIES (Begins with the D in 25D, DOLL, moves to NE)
2) TRES (T in 22A, I WOULDNT--that LDNT looked so weird and wrong at first)
3) TESS (T in 1A, COSA NOSTRA, moves to SE)
4) ALBS (A in 39A, ABJECT, moves to NW)
@Tom T 10:27 AM
DeleteSo happy you're back. I do not know why I love your HDWs so much, but I do. And you and I have similar solving options for Fridays and Saturdays. On the ones that are "never gonna happen," my best friend Uncle G helps.
Thanks, Gary. I have this stubborn streak about looking up answers that I'm sure I should get over. I'll just hit reveal if I'm at the point of giving up. But if I used Uncle Google, I could learn and maybe even remember more for the next time.
DeleteKeep those uni-clues coming!
With @Pabloinnh today. His “ Whooshiest Friday in memory, COSANOSTRA and MASNSPLAINS instantly and AVALANCES wasn't far behind.” was 100 percent 💯 emoji mine. (Bet that emoji doesn’t work, but gotta try just to MANSPLAIN for 🦖 (dinosaur emoji).
ReplyDeleteAs a Godfather film freak, one across provided a rare toehold……literally half the usual slog of late week solves. SLIMETRAIL and BOOTYCALLS clues were outstanding. Impossible to find a HOLE IN (this) ONE!
Easy, with one slow-down where I was thinking DReam before DRILL. I liked ABJECT, the clue for BLOWN, GRIME on SLIME, and coming upon DOPE SHEET in my memory junk drawer.
ReplyDeleteThe first Stuart king was formally James, but JAMESI to his buds.
ReplyDeleteI asks Mrs. Egs to grab me something from my shop to put two HOLESINONE of her cupboards for cup hooks. She brings me a hammer, so I MANSPLAINS that THISISNOTADRILL.
OHARE there really 8 runways at OHARE?
Fun and fast. Thanks, Billy Bratton.
Of course this won’t age well, but a defense of ALEC Burks in the puzzle:
ReplyDelete1 - NYT is a NY paper and he plays for the Knicks
2 - He just had a moment in the playoffs where he Did Not Play for 14 games, then once half the Knicks roster went down to injury against the Pacers in the 2nd round, he came in like gangbusters, averaging almost 20 ppg. Memes went around with him and Michael Jordan juxtaposed with “Save Us Alec Burks” jokes.
3 - All the crosses were fair;)
I loved the clue for SLIMETRAIL and BOOTYCALL surprised me even if not certified fresh.
Very easy and easier than Wednesday’s for me. COSA NOSTRA went in with no crosses and it was nothing but whoosh from there.
ReplyDeletetoRE before WARE was it for erasures and MALTA and ALEC were WOEs as clued.
I did need to stare at the DOPE/OPT cross because my first thought was the wrong kind of bookmaker.
Very smooth with a bit of sparkle, liked it.
A lot of stuff fell easily with no crosses, including SLIME TRAIL. One look at the clue and there was no better option. Love that. Remembered DOES from, I think, Watership Down. Really glad I learned DOPE SHEET from some other (recent?) Friday or Saturday puzzle. Had “hole in ones” before HOLES IN ONE but the latter is clearly correct in retrospect. Fun puzzle. I liked it!
ReplyDeleteI had my share of troubles but every time I thought I’d met ABJECT failure, I’d get one little breakthrough and be back in the RACE again. The NE slowed me down where I had HEDGE for stall and ALIEN LIFE for race. Plus I couldn’t seem to get my mind out of the gutter trying to make a blue yarn? something to do with SMUT or PORN. Brilliant cluing, my favorites being BOOTY CALLS, AVALANCHES, and SLIME TRAILS. Then there was that little NOT A DRILL jewel down the middle, with quotation marks on my printout and emojis on my app.
ReplyDeleteSmoothest solve and best Friday in a very long time. Thank you, BB! Even though I’ve done your puzzles before, I don’t recall them being this much fun, but I sure look forward to seeing your name again.
In light of yesterday's remarks about YALE and ELI being over-used in the NYT crossword, I think we should normalize CARL clues and answers. Carleton College-based constructors--Mr. Bratton, Sophia Maymudes, David Liben-Nowell--are very well-represented.
ReplyDeleteSLIME TRAIL, AVALANCHES, THIS IS NOT A DRILL. Nice.
ReplyDelete@kitshef - Love your costume!
I thought they were firework emoji. 🤷♀️
I started in the NW and continued clockwise at the fastest I’ve ever done on a Friday. …until I hit the SW, where everything ground to a halt. Still finished but that last section killed me.
ReplyDeleteAn okay Friday for me & surprised I finished it so fast. I didn't know LUCY, ALEC. Once I got it, I liked SHH for Sound in the Stacks.. And I'm embarrassed to say I really liked BOOTY CALL.
ReplyDeleteSo all in all, a nice Friday, Billy - thanks :)
Yeah, @kitshef, it's hard to imagine -- were you able to walk around unassisted, or did you need somebody to carry your train? Wish I'd seen it!
ReplyDeleteI'm getting tired of people using "boomer" to mean "old." Boomers are called that because they were born during the baby boom, when the men who'd fought the war came back and got busy at home, so to speak. I'm old but, having been born in 1943, I am definitely not a boomer. (My father worked in an important war industry, Seagram's Distillery, so he was exempt.)
As reported already, they did not print those emojis in the paper, although they have in the past--but not in color. So I'm glad you illustrated what you meant, Rex.
A little self-deprecation: I thought there might be 17 rOOms in Clue, but when I needed that D I went with DOOmS, figuring maybe when you combine different ways to die in that game there might be 17 (far too small a number, in fact). Aside from its being wrong I kind of like that answer -- but never noticed that I had BREm as a title where BRER would work.
I've learned about DOES among mice from crosswords of the past, more than once, I think. Rabbits, too, as @Sam points out.
OK gotta run.
When "nuestra cosa" was one letter too long for 1A "Literally, 'our thing'" I remembered COSA NOSTRA and I was off to the races. I did notice, however, that AVALANCHE and MANSPLAIN needed some ASSistance to do their jobs. And appropriately enough, so did BOOTY CALL and HOLE IN ONE. My inner nine year old will stop there lest I start leaving a SLIME TRAIL.
ReplyDeleteI'm still not sure how 41A OSCAR BID is the answer to "Consideration for the Academy". "Votes" and "nominations" are mentioned at oscars.org but no "BID". There are some sites, including wiki, that speak of "OSCAR Bait", movies that seem to have been made just to get some OSCAR nominations. And then some sites that estimate how much you would have to BID to buy an OSCAR statuette at an auction.
I didn't really have a problem with the was clue, but Rex said it was no good and he's the final word. So that was that.
ReplyDeleteLiked it. Learned a female mouse is a doe, male mouse a buck, baby is a kitten or pinkie. You’d think they could’ve come up with terms for an animal in the rodent family that was a far cry from the deer family.
ReplyDelete@Anoa Bob
ReplyDeleteSeveral results pop right up. It's common usage. Google link below:
Lots of OSCAR BIDs going on out there!
It's so nice when 1 across is a gimme. However there weren't all that many others for me, although WORLD COURT went right in because of the suspicious "suits" in the clue.
ReplyDeleteA couple of typeovers, SAD STORY and THIS IS NOT SO GOOD which I was glad to change because... it was not so good.
@kitshef, your slug costume sounds hilarious and dangerous. I get a LOT of kids at Halloween, and my front gate is kind of narrow which can cause issues. One kid was dressed as a carton of milk and he got firmly stuck, poor guy.
Easy + Medium SW. COSANOSTRA went right in. (How does extra virgin olive oil taste these days?) LUCY helped speed up the right side. I knew the origin of the name, but I never questioned why they listened to only one song. At least it was LUCY instead of Wild Honey Pie.
ReplyDeleteOriginal clue for 49D: Name found in "Yale College". Joel said HOLDITASEC and changed the clue at the last moment, due to all the complaints about Yale. (Fun fact I just made up.)
I had Popeye on VHS growing up. Some serious nostalgia watching that clip, decades later. Robin Williams, miss that guy.
Thanks for the puz, Billy Bratton. See you again soon, I'm sure.
In case anybody didn't know, "mansplains" is a portmanteau of the words "man" and "explain."
ReplyDeletePretty good themeless, overall. Had The Jaws, to make it an official contender.
ReplyDeletestaff weeject pick: RTS. With an X clue of mystery. Probably Re-TrumpS, or somesuch.
some faves: HOLDITASEC. IWOULDNT. ALIENRACE. DOGOODER.
some non-faves: JAMESI. NAPPIES. BOOTYCALLS. SLIMETRAIL. RTS.
Thanx, Mr. Bratton dude.
Masked & Anonymo2Us
**gruntz**
@2:17 Legendary comment.
ReplyDeleteIn the mansplain coinage origin story, it all really depends on your outlook: you could be really proud that someone is so excited about your book not knowing you are the author; or you could have just had 4 other mansplaining annoyances right beforehand and have no patience left.
"I'm old but, having been born in 1943, I am definitely not a boomer," says @jberg.
ReplyDeleteOh, @jberg (12:31)-- we're more or less the same vintage and I most definitely AM a boomer! All my classmates from both high school and college have always considered themselves to be boomers. I'm not going to let those clueless contemporary revisionists, those Johnny-come-latelys, take my generation away from me. We were considered boomers for decades -- until suddenly we were told we weren't. But if not boomers, then what are we exactly? We're hardly the Silent Generation. What a ridiculous thought THAT would be! At the tail end of the "silent" 1950s, I was 17 and you were 16. We were both in college in the tumultuous '60s. We both had our first jobs in the tumultuous '60s. The 1960s, which is the quintessential boomer era, is the era that formed us.
And now people born as late as 1964 are considered boomers? Fuhgeddaboutit! They weren't even born until after the Kennedy assassination. They were 3-years-old when Woodstock occurred. They wouldn't have entered college until the mid 1980s. They inhabited an entirely different world from the baby boom generation. I don't know who re-defined these categories, exactly when they re-defined them, or who granted them permission to do so, but I cry foul.
Don't take it lying down, @jberg. You may be an early boomer, but you're still a boomer.
That was one of the Top 20 things I’ve ever read. Thank you.
DeleteSorry. OPT as clued was not right. You OPT OUT or I guess you can opt IN, but I found that clue unfair. Maybe "one of a pair of words". But not like that.
ReplyDeleteNot a lot to add here. Like most commenters, I liked the puzzle. Also, like most commenters, I thought the emojis were stupid. They just looked like red and white blobs to me. Started in the NW where I stumbled over COSANOSTRA, which I know but apparently don't know, and proceeded clockwise at my usual ambling pace around to the central west coast where I just bogged right down. Small stuff like BREEDS, DOES, DOOR and OPT just wouldn't happen. Saved by BOOTYCALL and DOPESHEET (though my first thought was the too short tipSHEET).
ReplyDeleteMALTA was a gimme because I'm a big Robert Altman fan and Robin Williams and Shelley Duvall were great in Popeye.
All in all, a fine Friday morning.
Thanks to Anonymous and kitshef for setting me straight. Now I've been IMED, I guess.
ReplyDeleteLiked it a lot, even the siren emojis! I thought they made a good clue even more fun.
ReplyDeleteAgree with Anonymous that OPT was badly clued. Loved AVALANCHES and BOOTYCALLS, got a kick out of the clue for BLOWN. Fun puzzle :)
@Nancy, I see your point -- certainly I'm part of the same cultural group as boomers, so maybe I should just accept the term. I think of us more as the Vietnam/Civil Rights generation, but I guess it's too late to change it.
ReplyDelete@jberB OK Boomer(says another Boomer).
ReplyDelete@anon (1:47) I did google OSCAR BID. Google changed it to OSCAR Bait. I stayed the course and finally got a page on OSCAR BID. I didn't see any confirmation. Guess I didn't look far enough. Thanks for the correction.
ReplyDeleteA fun and snappy Friday (despite the terrible emojis, which looked awkward on the Games website). My fastest Friday in a whole, but still seems challenging. Getting 1A right off the bat on a Friday or Saturday is always empowering.
ReplyDeleteHave to respectfully disagree with Rex on WAS. I loved that answer once I got it, because it's less often seen. Reminded me of one of the scenes in No Country for Old Men Tommy Lee Jones and Barry Corbin. Some of the nest scenes in an amazing movie. Corbin ends one of his stories that way. "Uncle Mac knew the score, even if Aunt Ella didn't. Shot through the left lung. And that was that - as they say." Goodfellas does have a "And that's that" when Tommy gets killed.
Absolutely with Rex on ALEC Burks, and I'm a Knicks fan. He's not good enough for common knowledge. In my younger days, 90s, I got in my head that I would try to submit a puzzle. It was terrible, but I did it. I got a very nice encouraging email from Will Shortz. He said some of my names were too obscure and were forced. He was right, but my response back was that ESAI Morales is not an A-List actor, but he has three vowels in a four letter name. I stand by that. Thanks for the great write-up. Happy Friday!
@Anoa Bob (5:45)
ReplyDeleteI always appreciate your comments and was only offering additional information for you, not trying to correct you.
I find Google searches to be a puzzle in and of themselves. There's a rubric involved that includes understanding the most succinct way to get the responses you're looking for, but also seeing the initial set of results and understanding how better to finesse the search on subsequent attempts.
In this case, for my third attempt to get results specific to OSCAR BID (rather than the tangential connections Google was absolutely sure I must have wanted), I put double quotes around the search term (i.e., "OSCAR BID") which tells Google to try hard to stick to exactly what was entered.
I hope this helps, and thanks again for your consistently interesting/amusing comments on this blog.
This was one of those puzzles where I completed about half; felt stuck; took a three hour break and came back and completed it in 10 minutes. I love when that happens. Seems to prove that our brains do a lot of work when we’re not consciously thinking.
ReplyDeleteGot thrown off in spelling today, and thought there was a minor Chicago theme with Trib, Ohare, and Els, turns out I don’t know how to spell cosenostra. I also had hopesheet and hoes, but did figure that out eventually,
ReplyDeleteHard. Good Friday-level hard fun.
ReplyDeleteTo the blogmaster: Can we have a button to click on to enter comment so we don’t have to scroll down to the bottom of the page please?
OFNP misunderstands the "Peddled good" clue. It's not bad grammar. GOODS:WARES::GOOD:WARE.
ReplyDeleteI like this puzzle, though it's a BIT easy for Friday. In the 8-down clue, there was no emoji in my paper, just quote marks. I wouldn't have recognized the emoji anyway. Still laid it down with only a few crosses.
Also laid down: COSANOSTRA. Helped a lot kicking off the NW. The most resistance I got was sub-NW, around BIT, BRER, DOES and DOOR. Birdie.
Wordle par.
INONE SEC
ReplyDeleteA LATE BOOTYCALL? NOT A reason to STALL,
A RACE to LACE SHEETs, DO NOT forget IT.
IT IS A thrill, and THISISNOTADRILL,
IWOULDN’T wait, THISIS how WEGETIT!
--- BARB O’HARE
ReplyDeletePuzzle was velcroish in many spots for me, but definitely easier than yesterpuz. I doh slapped myself when I finally wrote in cosa nostra, and said to myself: you know that you moron! I think I'll call my Depends mannappies from now on.
Personally, I have 7 holes-in-one:
ReplyDelete2 eye sockets
2 ear canals
2 nostrils
1 mouth
And that's just off of the top of my head!
In my experience, men are not the only "MANSPLAINERS"
ReplyDeleteSometimes guys get a bad rap. Tho I do like the name "mannappies"
good Friday all
Lady Di
Solved in a flash…these ARE getting easier. Not complaining but do like more of a struggle on Friday and please keep your BOOTY CALLS to yourself, thanks! 😉
ReplyDelete