Kudos to an eagle-eyed proofreader / MON 6-17-24 / 2018 Childish Gambino hit that won the Grammy for Song of the Year / Locale for beers on draft / Queer-friendly high school dance
Constructor: Kiran Pandey
Relative difficulty: Easy (solved Downs-only)
THEME: "AYE AYE, CAPTAIN" (55A: Affirmative at sea ... or a phonetic hint to what's found sequentially in 20-, 31- and 41-Across) — theme answers are familiar phrases in which two "I"s precede a famous "Captain":
Theme answers:
"THIS IS AMERICA" (20A: 2018 Childish Gambino hit that won the Grammy for Song of the Year)
FINDING NEMO (31A: Pixar film that takes place mostly underwater)
FISHING HOOK (41A: Holder of bait)
Word of the Day: NIH (35D: Medical research org.) —
As of 2013, the IRP had 1,200 principal investigators and more than 4,000 postdoctoral fellows in basic, translational, and clinical research, being the largest biomedical research institution in the world, while, as of 2003, the extramural arm provided 28% of biomedical research funding spent annually in the U.S., or about US$26.4 billion.
In 2019, the NIH was ranked number two in the world, behind Harvard University, for biomedical sciences in the Nature Index, which measured the largest contributors to papers published in a subset of leading journals from 2015 to 2018. (wikipedia)
• • •
Well the "captain" part is solid enough but the "I" part is pretty weak, and the theme clues play pretty fast and loose with the word "sequentially." You do get an "I" and then (several letters later) another "I" and then a "Captain," but the intervening letters between those "I"s kinda mucks up the "sequentially" claim, at least a little. Sometimes the "I"s appear in one word, but one time they appear in two different words. And then one time there's actually a third "I" inside one of the "Captain"s. It's a cute idea, but the execution just doesn't feel dead-on. Also, it's usually FISH HOOK, right? I recognize that FISHING HOOK is a valid and not uncommon variant, but the -ING part feels contrived to get that second "I. The wikipedia entry is for "fish hook" (or "fishhook"). There's no fatal flaw to this puzzle, just a lot of little dings and dents. The fact that the puzzle felt the need to circle the "I"s feels like an acknowledgment that the puzzle was maybe not landing perfectly. I only wish there had been some way to accommodate my favorite captain. I'm speaking of course of Captain Merrill Stubing of The Love Boat. My wife and I are currently in the middle of watching the entire run of the show. We just finished the very special Season 3 episode where Captain Stubing finally goes and claims his biological daughter Vicki from her aunt and uncle who are raising her now that Vicki's mom is dead, and who somehow conveniently live somewhere in Mexico (!?) (lord knows what happened to Vicki's stepdad). Anyway, today's "I"-"I"-"captain"s are OK, I guess, but for my money, VICKI STUBING beats 'em all. (Unless MINI UNDERPANTS are a thing, then that wins)
Perhaps unsurprisingly, in a puzzle focused on "I"s, there are too many "I"s in this puzzle. The proper noun, I mean. I CARE, I CALL, I MEAN IT. I ... think that's too many. Otherwise, the fill seemed OK. Adequate. "NICE CATCH" (33D: Kudos to an eagle-eyed proofreader) and TOMATILLO give the grid some much needed SPICE. Speaking of SPICE, I had SPIFF there for a bit (10D: Zhuzh (up)). I think of zhuzhing as adding more spiffiness than spiciness ("spiciness" kinda has sexy implications that zhuzhing alone does not). I guess I should love GAY PROM but that answer just made me sad. Can the gay kids not go to regular prom? Are there Queer-unfriendly dances? I mean, of course there are, that's a stupid question. I guess GAY PROM must be a non-school-sponsored thing for kids who don't feel welcome at their cruddy heteronormative homophobic school dances. Let's see ... [Uses internet] ... Yes, that's exactly what it is (there was one this past weekend in the Greater Cleveland area! Hello, Cleveland!), though it looks like QUEER PROM is *by far* the more common term. So hurray to the concept, but mild boo to "gay" instead of the more inclusive "queer." Still, more hurray than boo. I'll save the real "Boo!" for schools that give queer kids any shit at all about going to prom with whomever they want, in whatever fancy get-up they choose.
The Downs-only experience was pretty uneventful today. I weirdly spelled POLI-SCI as if it were a major involving *many* sciences (or the study of polysexuality) (POLY SCI!), so that was interesting (5D: College major for government studies, informally). I also had OVERT before FAMED (31D: Widely known) (a truly terrible guess) and BREW PUB before TAPROOM (9D: Locale for beers on draft) (actually a great guess, don't feel bad about it at all). Already told you about the SPIFF-for-SPICE thing, so ... yeah, that's all I got. See you next time.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
P.S. listening to my favorite DJ Evan Funk Davies (efd) filling in for Clay Pigeon on WFMU this morning and this happened ♥️
Medium. I started out with ahead before ONTOP (Monday is not a day I check crosses), did not know SON, and needed all the crosses for MAC (great clue) …hence medium.
Pretty smooth, cute and clever, liked it.
Croce Solvers - Croce’s Freestyle #919 was easy-medium for a Croce (about 3 to 4 X recent NYT Saturdays) with the top half easier than the bottom. For me the SW corner was the toughest section. Good luck!
"AYE AYE" cried MARIO...."I need to HOOK a TON of FISH for the TOWN DELI...ON TOP of THIS, I need to TAP into some good OLIVE OILS so I can SPICE up my NACHO with a TOMATILLO and a DOT of BALMS...."
MARIO was ON TOP of it. He would CALL CAPTAIN NEMO (I KEA you not!) and ask for DE CODE to LET him TAP into a BOX of HOOKS he needed to FISH. He was FAMED for his "AS SEEN on TV" BLIP and it was NOT OK to LET him SIEVE in an OCEAN of TACIT METES!
"OY VEY" NEMO would GASP...."THIS IS AMERICA after all, and I OWE it TO you and the TOWN DELI to HOOK A TON of FISH because I CARE and I'm no YOKO so.I will give you DE CODE!"
NEMO gave MARIO DE CODE. A BET was A BET and FINDING the FISH was a TALE to be told.
MARIO RACED to the OCEAN with GAY ROSY who was LACED on ACID. She could HOOK and STAB any FISH at ALL so he didn't BLIP and eye.
TADA!...FINDING A TON OF FISH for the TOWN DELI was ACE. A BOX of BALMS filled with OLIVE OILS was used to AMP the POLI ACID of the FISH. Although MARIO and ROSY preferred a NACHO with some TOMATILLO SPICE, the TOWN folks LET them TAP INTO a ROOM full of FISH. NONE said NIH. ON TOP of it all, no ONE would STAB the SON of the Captain....
@GILL I.12:34 AM "... an OCEAN of TACIT METES!" That is the MERERest amount I've ever imagined. BTW, do you have have GAY ROSY's number. She sounds like fun.
I knew I would agree with Rex about FISH(ING) HOOK, in fact I highlighted the ING part after finishing. But surprisingly, according to Google Ngram there is not an enormous difference between the usages.
I quite enjoyed the theme, probably because the revealer is quite a vivid phrase. Also solving down clues only, all the theme answers were inferrable without their clues, which helped make it not too hard to finish without looking at any across clues.
GAY PROM was the last down answer to fall, but only because the clue made me think the answer was a dance rather than an event. GAY---- = gay waltz? gay chacha? Honestly couldn't think of a 4 letter dance name.
[Spelling Bee: Sun currently -6 (!!!) and I couldn't care less; bah.]
Duh! I missed the Captains America, Hook and Nemo. Now I like the theme more. It had seemed a bit thin.
But the puzzle was a pleasant solve, nevertheless. Didn't seem too obvious to be interesting. Just very easy. -except tomatillo took all the crosses. And I hesitated over "ashy" for dry skin.
Easy. @jae ahead before ON TOP at 1A was my only overwrite, corrected quickly when 1D had to be OMITS. Like @Sharonak, didn't like the theme until I got the Captains, a nice "Aha moment."
I thought the Venn diagram clue was pretty creative - nice to see someone attempt something new on a Monday. Saw the I’s because they circled them for me - totally missed on the Captains, but half the time I need Rex to explain the theme anyway.
Never heard of Childish Gambino, but it’s an awesome name. I thought at first it was a band, but it turns out to be a dude’s stage name.
Hhard (for a Monday). Holdups were ASHY, which I don't recognize under that meaning, GASP (dreadful clue), and Woe TOMATILLO. Also add me to the crowd with 'ahead' before ON TOP.
For a while Croce Freestyle 919 felt like it was going to be the hardest puzzle ever. Had the NW corner OK, and then a bunch of guesses with no confirming crosses. Finally took a stab at 45A which opened up the SW. And another stab with 6D with got the NE. And finally, a guess at 57A got the SE. Wound up in normal 'hard' time (5x average NYT Saturday).
Kiran’s puzzles warm my soul, as they teem with humor and wordplay. Two examples: • The theme of his May of ’23 puzzle. Here are two of the clues/answers: [Length, for example] for SEVEN LETTERS, and [Scientific definition, for short] for ELECTICAL FAULT. • In another puzzle, his clue for MALL – [Chain letter?].
And here again today, humor and wordplay in his theme. This is one of those themes that can add an extra challenge – after uncovering the three theme answers, can you guess the revealer? (I, who am weak at this skill, once again failed, but had a grand time trying!)
I loved the serendipities that popped up as well: • ON TOP being exactly there. • OCEAN crossing AYE AYE CAPTAIN. • AT BAT sharing the grid with STAB, which backwards is … • Four palindromes (ERE, AAA, AHA, ALA). • The tennis answer LET echoed by nearby abutting ACE and SETS.
And my bonzo brain, which, every time I see BOX over NOTOK on the eastern edge, keeps shouting “Botox!”
So sweet when a puzzle entertains on top of providing riddles to crack. Thank you for this, Kiran, and please, keep them coming!
Once again I missed part of the theme until I came here! Got the AYE AYE part and though “huh, the I’s aren’t even next to each other, that’s a kind of weak theme” and thought nothing else of it.
Then I come here and realize the last word of each themer is a Captain (AMERICA, HOOK, NEMO). Gave me that nice post-solve smile when the revealer is something cute that I hadn’t noticed. ๐
Agree with others on: ASHY, FISHINGHOOK, and AHEAD. Also with OFL on wanting POLY as the prefix. Didn't bother to see which letters were in the circles or notice all the CAPTAINs until later, which is what happens when things are easy and you're speeding.
An OK Monday with a dearth of proper names, so yay for that, and I learned the name of a Childish Gambino song.
Nice enough Mondecito, KP. No CAPTAIN Kangaroo Person, put some good ones, and thanks for all the fun.
IN SB news, I got to G yesterday, which is where I stop, without getting either pangram. A first for me.
Thought this was a warm little puzzle with fun wordplay that became evident only on reading this blog—the three captains (see @ Sharonak) and the tennis SET (see @Lewis) and the location of ONTOP. Started with “ahead” so had to untangle myself right away, and was distracted by having to suss out TOMATILLO. The crosses all seemed fair—never could have done this downs only.
Easy, even for a Monday. I had "ahead" for 1-Across instead of ONTOP, but the crosses fixed it. Didn't notice the theme until I was finished.
I'll probably be excoriated for asking these questions, but "How does a school promote a dance that's limited to gay kids?" and, "If gay kids are welcome at a regular prom (they would be, presumably), are heterosexual kids welcome at a gay prom?"
Hey All ! Prehistoric Alaskan? INUIT CAVEMAN (Remember that cartoon?)
Decent MonPuz. Got to the LET/NET kealoa, just wrote in _ET and waited on the cross. Thankfully I know Spanish does a lot of double L's, so N wasn't a possibility. (I even know double L in Spanish is pronounced as a Y. Look at me go!)
@Lewis has got me seeing things, ala ON TOP on top of the grid.
Had dims for a bit for FADE, a rare speed bump for a MonPuz. Also, sillily had OhVEY first. OY VEY!
Haven't read @Gill's story yet, look forward to it. Some interesting things to use.
Very serviceable Monday. FISHINGHOOK was a little jarring - I wanted fIsh around the 2nd 'I' but couldn't think of a 3-letter type for one. Almost NOTOK, but not quite that bad. Also don't really think of olive as a dark shade of green, feels lighter than my starting point for that color. Agree with @SouthsideJohnny on the Venn diagram clue - the best of the day sitting there in short fill (though Captain Mac's in Delaware is worth a visit). Never heard of ASHY skin and wanted silk before LACE, so the SW puzzled briefly. But all in all, this seems like what we should want from a Monday, and offered a fun start to the morning.
Speaking of Venn diagrams, I bet the intersection of "people who fish" with "people who say fishing hook" is almost empty. It sounds like one of those things 4-year-olds say before they've learned to temper analogy with idiom.
Aside from that, yeah, Rex is right about the theme and its weakeness, but it was a nice set of captains.
With a grid that offers us a DELI, a TAPROOM, some NACHO (dip), a TOMATILLO, OLIVE OILS, and a touch of SPICE, it seems only appropriate that it also features the HDW (Hidden Diagonal Word) DIET, which begins with the D in 37A, ACID. (Perhaps we need the DIET, in fact, to deal with all that ACID.)
The current streak of grid answers with a duplicate HDW continues in today’s grid, with 59D, NAS, having a Hidden Diagonal twin to the North (beginning with the N in 33D, NICE CATCH.
Hey, NICE CATCH, TomT (if I do say so myself). Tee-hee
After each ruddy weekend of wild puzzles, gruesome Naticks, people who spell their own names wrong, and desperate cluing by lonely editors, I always feel Monday washes away the sins of the dark alleys of literary skulduggery and we return to a secret garden of lilac scented ideas. Here's a cute little Monday puzzle on exhibit. Theme works. Doesn't make you feel weird around your mother.
Right off, I proudly and unabashedly wrote in AHEAD and LUIGI only to humbly take them back out for ONTOP and MARIO. Curse you crosses.
And what the heck kind of fancy pants east coast New York City view of geography teaches a TOWN is a unit of suburbia? Out here in the west, towns are towns and the big ones might have suburban areas where they put beige boxes the new brides seem to want and they fill 'em up with babies and plastic stuff. Suburbs are units of towns.
Its OHO, not AHA. Sheesk.
I like my Mac and I love my mac, so I fit near the middle of the Venn diagram.
Zhuzh is on my favorite word list between LOLL and LITHE.
Tee-Hee: GAY PROM ... just FYI, every prom can be a gay prom if done well.
Uniclues:
1 Boy drives pickup into ditch. 2 Slogan for (boring old) PBS. 3 Jewish art instructor explains why acrylics are easier. 4 Bro-style haircut every pundit on TV wears. 5 Oh no, Beatles killer swinging. 6 Why they still haven't made it to Mars. 7 Wow-wee story from gay prom. 8 Chocolate mint delivery device ravaged by rascal, namely me.
1 SON SETS ONE TON 2 ON TV NONE RACED 3 OILS ADD OY VEY 4 POLI-SCI FADE 5 YOKO AT BAT, GASP (~) 6 NASA TAPROOM (~) 7 AHA! SPICE TALE! (~) 8 ANDES BOX NOT OK (~)
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: One about to be headless. SERF ON STRIKE.
At a fairly crucial point ........ (I)NAB(I)TOFACRUNCH
5D having the letter "I" circled twice makes it look an awful lot like a themer. And while I can't think of a Captain Fade, I think that the process of nodding off in Political Science class would be aptly described as the POLISCI FADE.
Our representatives are debating whether to ban TikTok. A compromise would be "Tik, but NOTOK".
Not having any idea who or what a CHILDISH GAMBINO HIT is (Grammy winner?) (guess I'm not cool), I solved as a themeless then saw the gimmick. A fun, typical, easy Monday for me :) Thanks, Kiran
The clue for 40A should be "What fits into the CENTER section of a Venn diagram of 'Computers' and 'Pastas'?" This is a Venn diagram drawn with two congruent overlapping circles. It has four sections. Linguini would fit into the section in the Pasta circle and outside the Computer circle. iPad would fit into the section in the Computer circle and outside the Pasta circle. Joe Biden would fit into the section outside both circles.
The most commonly seen Venn diagram has three circles which overlap so that there are eight sections (2 to the third power). There are Venn diagrams that divide the plane into 16 sections, but not made up of circles. Ellipses.
I-I-I-I-I! After an entire week of NYTXWs without silly little circles, we're back to this.
After all the discussion about Venn diagrams, why has no one commented that MAC is not a pasta? The pasta is macaroni. A question mark does not properly qualify the "for short".
BTW, Rex, a TOMATILLO is not at all spicy. It isn't what makes a salsa verde spicy.
10D Zhuzh (up) Never ever seen or heard that before and when you are working downs only and you place that right next to 11D TOMATILLO, which I never use in my salsa verde, that leaves a rather big hole. There are so many variations of salsa verde that I wouldn’t even call it a recipe. My version consists mostly of cilantro and parsley. At the end of the season I have finely diced up some unripened (green) tomatoes into it but I almost never see TOMATILLOs for sale at my local greengrocers. I’ll keep my eyes open for them in the future. They’d be good but they sure made for big problems in the NE.
Initially had NOway for NOTOK at 27D. Easily fixed.
FISHINGHOOK at 41A is NOTOK. I’ve been a dedicated fly fisherman for over 50 years and I call it a hook, occasionally, when talking to a non-angler, a fish hook, but never a FISHINGHOOK.
I agree with @Rex that “there's no fatal flaw to this puzzle, just a lot of little dings and dents” and I found it to be a fine start to Monday morning.
@bigsteve46, your question is a bit snarky, and I'm not sure I'm a "genius", but...
Personally I like solving downs only because the theme answers are usually* acrosses, and without looking at their clues you can usually* pick up their relatedness and the theme itself.
[* = usually but not always; today it worked nicely.]
Good but it would have been even better if there wasn’t any I’s other than those used in the gimmick, like the ones in OMITS, ICALL, BLIP, SPICE, OLIVE etc…
Card slang for a jack is "fishhook." The "-ing" certainly seems shoehorned in there. Along with the circles, this detracts from the theme. Two of them have -NG- between the second I and the captain; the other has just an S--and only one square between the I's. Maybe time to rethink this.
The fill was OK, but it was all too loosey-goosey. And too easy, even for Monday. Bogey.
I must live in the only place on earth where it is called a fishing hook. Of course when you're fishing you just say give me a hook. In my head a fish hook would be on the fish itself.
(I)T(I)SNTFANTASTIC nor FL(I)PP(I)NGOBVIOUS nor particularly engaging. But this is where we are these days. The marquee constructors have gone elsewhere and this passes for good. Disappointing. Wordle birdie.
Medium. I started out with ahead before ONTOP (Monday is not a day I check crosses), did not know SON, and needed all the crosses for MAC (great clue) …hence medium.
ReplyDeletePretty smooth, cute and clever, liked it.
Croce Solvers - Croce’s Freestyle #919 was easy-medium for a Croce (about 3 to 4 X recent NYT Saturdays) with the top half easier than the bottom. For me the SW corner was the toughest section. Good luck!
"AYE AYE" cried MARIO...."I need to HOOK a TON of FISH for the TOWN DELI...ON TOP of THIS, I need to TAP into some good OLIVE OILS so I can SPICE up my NACHO with a TOMATILLO and a DOT of BALMS...."
ReplyDeleteMARIO was ON TOP of it. He would CALL CAPTAIN NEMO (I KEA you not!) and ask for DE CODE to LET him TAP into a BOX of HOOKS he needed to FISH. He was FAMED for his "AS SEEN on TV" BLIP and it was NOT OK to LET him SIEVE in an OCEAN of TACIT METES!
"OY VEY" NEMO would GASP...."THIS IS AMERICA after all, and I OWE it TO you and the TOWN DELI to HOOK A TON of FISH because I CARE and I'm no YOKO so.I will give you DE CODE!"
NEMO gave MARIO DE CODE. A BET was A BET and FINDING the FISH was a TALE to be told.
MARIO RACED to the OCEAN with GAY ROSY who was LACED on ACID. She could HOOK and STAB any FISH at ALL so he didn't BLIP and eye.
TADA!...FINDING A TON OF FISH for the TOWN DELI was ACE. A BOX of BALMS filled with OLIVE OILS was used to AMP the POLI ACID of the FISH. Although MARIO and ROSY preferred a NACHO with some TOMATILLO SPICE, the TOWN folks LET them TAP INTO a ROOM full of FISH. NONE said NIH. ON TOP of it all, no ONE would STAB the SON of the Captain....
And that's the truth....Hi @JC!
@GILL I.12:34 AM
Delete"... an OCEAN of TACIT METES!" That is the MERERest amount I've ever imagined. BTW, do you have have GAY ROSY's number. She sounds like fun.
Love this one! I guess you were fishing for compliments ๐
DeleteI knew I would agree with Rex about FISH(ING) HOOK, in fact I highlighted the ING part after finishing. But surprisingly, according to Google Ngram there is not an enormous difference between the usages.
ReplyDeleteI quite enjoyed the theme, probably because the revealer is quite a vivid phrase. Also solving down clues only, all the theme answers were inferrable without their clues, which helped make it not too hard to finish without looking at any across clues.
GAY PROM was the last down answer to fall, but only because the clue made me think the answer was a dance rather than an event. GAY---- = gay waltz? gay chacha? Honestly couldn't think of a 4 letter dance name.
[Spelling Bee: Sun currently -6 (!!!) and I couldn't care less; bah.]
Duh! I missed the Captains America, Hook and Nemo.
ReplyDeleteNow I like the theme more. It had seemed a bit thin.
But the puzzle was a pleasant solve, nevertheless. Didn't seem too obvious to be interesting. Just very easy. -except tomatillo took all the crosses. And I hesitated over "ashy" for dry skin.
My five favorite original clues from last week
ReplyDelete(in order of appearance):
1. Pop art? (7)
2. Padded piece of paper, perhaps? (6)
3. Not in English, say (6)
4. "Ew, ew, EW!" (3)
5. Small cube (3)
DADAISM
RESUME
ABSENT
TMI
ONE
ReplyDeleteEasy. @jae ahead before ON TOP at 1A was my only overwrite, corrected quickly when 1D had to be OMITS. Like @Sharonak, didn't like the theme until I got the Captains, a nice "Aha moment."
I thought the Venn diagram clue was pretty creative - nice to see someone attempt something new on a Monday. Saw the I’s because they circled them for me - totally missed on the Captains, but half the time I need Rex to explain the theme anyway.
ReplyDeleteNever heard of Childish Gambino, but it’s an awesome name. I thought at first it was a band, but it turns out to be a dude’s stage name.
I was super excited to see Childish Gambino as a clue!
ReplyDelete[Cooking organ meat] BROILING BEEFHEART
ReplyDeleteHhard (for a Monday). Holdups were ASHY, which I don't recognize under that meaning, GASP (dreadful clue), and Woe TOMATILLO. Also add me to the crowd with 'ahead' before ON TOP.
ReplyDeleteFor a while Croce Freestyle 919 felt like it was going to be the hardest puzzle ever. Had the NW corner OK, and then a bunch of guesses with no confirming crosses. Finally took a stab at 45A which opened up the SW. And another stab with 6D with got the NE. And finally, a guess at 57A got the SE. Wound up in normal 'hard' time (5x average NYT Saturday).
Ditto ASHY
DeleteKiran’s puzzles warm my soul, as they teem with humor and wordplay. Two examples:
ReplyDelete• The theme of his May of ’23 puzzle. Here are two of the clues/answers: [Length, for example] for SEVEN LETTERS, and [Scientific definition, for short] for ELECTICAL FAULT.
• In another puzzle, his clue for MALL – [Chain letter?].
And here again today, humor and wordplay in his theme. This is one of those themes that can add an extra challenge – after uncovering the three theme answers, can you guess the revealer? (I, who am weak at this skill, once again failed, but had a grand time trying!)
I loved the serendipities that popped up as well:
• ON TOP being exactly there.
• OCEAN crossing AYE AYE CAPTAIN.
• AT BAT sharing the grid with STAB, which backwards is …
• Four palindromes (ERE, AAA, AHA, ALA).
• The tennis answer LET echoed by nearby abutting ACE and SETS.
And my bonzo brain, which, every time I see BOX over NOTOK on the eastern edge, keeps shouting “Botox!”
So sweet when a puzzle entertains on top of providing riddles to crack. Thank you for this, Kiran, and please, keep them coming!
Once again I missed part of the theme until I came here! Got the AYE AYE part and though “huh, the I’s aren’t even next to each other, that’s a kind of weak theme” and thought nothing else of it.
ReplyDeleteThen I come here and realize the last word of each themer is a Captain (AMERICA, HOOK, NEMO). Gave me that nice post-solve smile when the revealer is something cute that I hadn’t noticed. ๐
Agree with others on: ASHY, FISHINGHOOK, and AHEAD. Also with OFL on wanting POLY as the prefix. Didn't bother to see which letters were in the circles or notice all the CAPTAINs until later, which is what happens when things are easy and you're speeding.
ReplyDeleteAn OK Monday with a dearth of proper names, so yay for that, and I learned the name of a Childish Gambino song.
Nice enough Mondecito, KP. No CAPTAIN Kangaroo Person, put some good ones, and thanks for all the fun.
IN SB news, I got to G yesterday, which is where I stop, without getting either pangram. A first for me.
Thought this was a warm little puzzle with fun wordplay that became evident only on reading this blog—the three captains (see @
ReplyDeleteSharonak) and the tennis SET (see @Lewis) and the location of ONTOP. Started with “ahead” so had to untangle myself right away, and was distracted by having to suss out TOMATILLO. The crosses all seemed fair—never could have done this downs only.
Struggled a bit Downs-only despite getting the revealer and the circled i’s. But I didn’t realize the themers were all captains. Duh!!
ReplyDeleteThere are no words to express how mindless and boring I found this puzzle.
ReplyDeleteSo glad to see This Is America mentioned - phenomenal song by a wonderful artist
ReplyDeleteEasy, even for a Monday. I had "ahead" for 1-Across instead of ONTOP, but the crosses fixed it. Didn't notice the theme until I was finished.
ReplyDeleteI'll probably be excoriated for asking these questions, but "How does a school promote a dance that's limited to gay kids?" and, "If gay kids are welcome at a regular prom (they would be, presumably), are heterosexual kids welcome at a gay prom?"
Hey All !
ReplyDeletePrehistoric Alaskan?
INUIT CAVEMAN
(Remember that cartoon?)
Decent MonPuz. Got to the LET/NET kealoa, just wrote in _ET and waited on the cross. Thankfully I know Spanish does a lot of double L's, so N wasn't a possibility. (I even know double L in Spanish is pronounced as a Y. Look at me go!)
@Lewis has got me seeing things, ala ON TOP on top of the grid.
Had dims for a bit for FADE, a rare speed bump for a MonPuz. Also, sillily had OhVEY first. OY VEY!
Haven't read @Gill's story yet, look forward to it. Some interesting things to use.
Monday again. GASP!
Two F's
RooMonster
DarrinV
Very serviceable Monday. FISHINGHOOK was a little jarring - I wanted fIsh around the 2nd 'I' but couldn't think of a 3-letter type for one. Almost NOTOK, but not quite that bad. Also don't really think of olive as a dark shade of green, feels lighter than my starting point for that color. Agree with @SouthsideJohnny on the Venn diagram clue - the best of the day sitting there in short fill (though Captain Mac's in Delaware is worth a visit). Never heard of ASHY skin and wanted silk before LACE, so the SW puzzled briefly. But all in all, this seems like what we should want from a Monday, and offered a fun start to the morning.
ReplyDeleteSpeaking of Venn diagrams, I bet the intersection of "people who fish" with "people who say fishing hook" is almost empty. It sounds like one of those things 4-year-olds say before they've learned to temper analogy with idiom.
ReplyDeleteAside from that, yeah, Rex is right about the theme and its weakeness, but it was a nice set of captains.
With a grid that offers us a DELI, a TAPROOM, some NACHO (dip), a TOMATILLO, OLIVE OILS, and a touch of SPICE, it seems only appropriate that it also features the HDW (Hidden Diagonal Word) DIET, which begins with the D in 37A, ACID. (Perhaps we need the DIET, in fact, to deal with all that ACID.)
ReplyDeleteThe current streak of grid answers with a duplicate HDW continues in today’s grid, with 59D, NAS, having a Hidden Diagonal twin to the North (beginning with the N in 33D, NICE CATCH.
Hey, NICE CATCH, TomT (if I do say so myself). Tee-hee
After each ruddy weekend of wild puzzles, gruesome Naticks, people who spell their own names wrong, and desperate cluing by lonely editors, I always feel Monday washes away the sins of the dark alleys of literary skulduggery and we return to a secret garden of lilac scented ideas. Here's a cute little Monday puzzle on exhibit. Theme works. Doesn't make you feel weird around your mother.
ReplyDeleteRight off, I proudly and unabashedly wrote in AHEAD and LUIGI only to humbly take them back out for ONTOP and MARIO. Curse you crosses.
And what the heck kind of fancy pants east coast New York City view of geography teaches a TOWN is a unit of suburbia? Out here in the west, towns are towns and the big ones might have suburban areas where they put beige boxes the new brides seem to want and they fill 'em up with babies and plastic stuff. Suburbs are units of towns.
Its OHO, not AHA. Sheesk.
I like my Mac and I love my mac, so I fit near the middle of the Venn diagram.
Zhuzh is on my favorite word list between LOLL and LITHE.
Propers: 5
Places: 1
Products: 4
Partials: 4
Foreignisms: 2
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 16 (21%) wow!
Funnyisms: 1 ๐คจ
Tee-Hee: GAY PROM ... just FYI, every prom can be a gay prom if done well.
Uniclues:
1 Boy drives pickup into ditch.
2 Slogan for (boring old) PBS.
3 Jewish art instructor explains why acrylics are easier.
4 Bro-style haircut every pundit on TV wears.
5 Oh no, Beatles killer swinging.
6 Why they still haven't made it to Mars.
7 Wow-wee story from gay prom.
8 Chocolate mint delivery device ravaged by rascal, namely me.
1 SON SETS ONE TON
2 ON TV NONE RACED
3 OILS ADD OY VEY
4 POLI-SCI FADE
5 YOKO AT BAT, GASP (~)
6 NASA TAPROOM (~)
7 AHA! SPICE TALE! (~)
8 ANDES BOX NOT OK (~)
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: One about to be headless. SERF ON STRIKE.
¯\_(ใ)_/¯
Nice, smoooth MonPuz with an ahar moment. Like.
ReplyDeletestaff weeject pick: AHA. Seems to fit the puztheme shenanigans.
fave moo-cow eazy-E MonPuz clue: {Subway vehicle} = TRAIN. TRA(I)N (I)S OBVIOUS, Captain.
other fave stuff: NICECATCH. TAPROOM. IMEANIT. SPICE clue.
Thanx for the dandy fun, Mr. Pandey dude. But, what? No U's? Aye yi yi, Kidd. :(
Masked & Anonym0Us
**gruntz**
At a fairly crucial point ........ (I)NAB(I)TOFACRUNCH
ReplyDelete5D having the letter "I" circled twice makes it look an awful lot like a themer. And while I can't think of a Captain Fade, I think that the process of nodding off in Political Science class would be aptly described as the POLISCI FADE.
Our representatives are debating whether to ban TikTok. A compromise would be "Tik, but NOTOK".
Pretty nice theme concept. Thanks, Kiran Pandey.
Not having any idea who or what a CHILDISH GAMBINO HIT is (Grammy winner?) (guess I'm not cool), I solved as a themeless then saw the gimmick. A fun, typical, easy Monday for me :)
ReplyDeleteThanks, Kiran
Star Trek: Discovery
ReplyDeleteBook (Michael’s boyfriend) comes aboard the ship and responds to something she says: “Aye aye, sir.”
“Just one ‘aye’ — we’re not pirates!”
The clue for 40A should be "What fits into the CENTER section of a Venn diagram of 'Computers' and 'Pastas'?" This is a Venn diagram drawn with two congruent overlapping circles. It has four sections. Linguini would fit into the section in the Pasta circle and outside the Computer circle. iPad would fit into the section in the Computer circle and outside the Pasta circle. Joe Biden would fit into the section outside both circles.
ReplyDeleteThe most commonly seen Venn diagram has three circles which overlap so that there are eight sections (2 to the third power). There are Venn diagrams that divide the plane into 16 sections, but not made up of circles. Ellipses.
Jberg
ReplyDeleteYou’re quite right about no fisherman ever having said fishing hook.
The problem is no fisherman says fish hook either. It’s always just a hook.
Tom F
ReplyDeleteDefinitely better if the I’d are not circled.
ReplyDeleteI-I-I-I-I! After an entire week of NYTXWs without silly little circles, we're back to this.
ReplyDeleteAfter all the discussion about Venn diagrams, why has no one commented that MAC is not a pasta? The pasta is macaroni. A question mark does not properly qualify the "for short".
BTW, Rex, a TOMATILLO is not at all spicy. It isn't what makes a salsa verde spicy.
Updated my profile pic to reflect Rex’s rant du jour, Sajak Style!
ReplyDeleteAnd "QUEER" used to be a pejorative.
ReplyDelete10D Zhuzh (up) Never ever seen or heard that before and when you are working downs only and you place that right next to 11D TOMATILLO, which I never use in my salsa verde, that leaves a rather big hole. There are so many variations of salsa verde that I wouldn’t even call it a recipe. My version consists mostly of cilantro and parsley. At the end of the season I have finely diced up some unripened (green) tomatoes into it but I almost never see TOMATILLOs for sale at my local greengrocers. I’ll keep my eyes open for them in the future. They’d be good but they sure made for big problems in the NE.
ReplyDeleteInitially had NOway for NOTOK at 27D. Easily fixed.
FISHINGHOOK at 41A is NOTOK. I’ve been a dedicated fly fisherman for over 50 years and I call it a hook, occasionally, when talking to a non-angler, a fish hook, but never a FISHINGHOOK.
I agree with @Rex that “there's no fatal flaw to this puzzle, just a lot of little dings and dents” and I found it to be a fine start to Monday morning.
Also agree to his take on the GAYPROM thing.
Have to add that jberg’s take on the FISHINGHOOK thing at 9:14 was spot on.
ReplyDeleteWhy don't some of you geniuses solve the puzzle "across only"? Just asking ..
ReplyDelete@bigsteve46, your question is a bit snarky, and I'm not sure I'm a "genius", but...
ReplyDeletePersonally I like solving downs only because the theme answers are usually* acrosses, and without looking at their clues you can usually* pick up their relatedness and the theme itself.
[* = usually but not always; today it worked nicely.]
I thought the CAPTAINs were really well disguised in plain sight - and so found the reveal a treat. NICE one!
ReplyDeleteI really liked this one!
ReplyDeleteHi Rex - from what I can remember from this am, I liked this puzzle. Apple did its job - here I am. See you tomorrow, I hope :)
ReplyDeleteSo why do you assume a traditional prom to be cruddy and homophobic? That sounds pretty closed minded to me.
DeleteA good, beginner-friendly Monday puzzle. Exactly what this is supposed to be.
ReplyDeleteGood but it would have been even better if there wasn’t any I’s other than those used in the gimmick, like the ones in OMITS, ICALL, BLIP, SPICE, OLIVE etc…
ReplyDeleteCard slang for a jack is "fishhook." The "-ing" certainly seems shoehorned in there. Along with the circles, this detracts from the theme. Two of them have -NG- between the second I and the captain; the other has just an S--and only one square between the I's. Maybe time to rethink this.
ReplyDeleteThe fill was OK, but it was all too loosey-goosey. And too easy, even for Monday. Bogey.
Wordle par.
ICALL THIS A FISHING TALE
ReplyDeleteEDIE’s A FAMED ONE, IMEANIT, what A SET.
I’m FINDING I get NONE, NOT A bit ON ABET.
--- CAPTAIN MARIO POLO
I must live in the only place on earth where it is called a fishing hook. Of course when you're fishing you just say give me a hook. In my head a fish hook would be on the fish itself.
ReplyDelete(I)T(I)SNTFANTASTIC nor FL(I)PP(I)NGOBVIOUS nor particularly engaging. But this is where we are these days. The marquee constructors have gone elsewhere and this passes for good. Disappointing.
ReplyDeleteWordle birdie.
Ai yi yi, right? The eyes have it.
ReplyDeleteLady Di