Emotional assessment of one's surroundings in lingo / SAT 2-11-23 / Wheat variety for a grain bowl / Unlikely trait for a beekeeper / Sustainable engineering field informally / Expanse on a Spanish explorer's map / Capital known as Keijo before the 1940s
Constructor: Sam Ezersky
Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium
THEME: none
Word of the Day: CIA WORLD FACTBOOK (39A: Reference work in the public domain that's updated weekly) —
The World Factbook, also known as the CIA World Factbook, is a reference resource produced by the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) with almanac-style information about the countries of the world. The official print version is available from the Government Publishing Office. The Factbook is available in the form of a website that is partially updated every week. It is also available for download for use off-line. It provides a two- to three-page summary of the demographics, geography, communications, government, economy, and military of 266 international entities including U.S.-recognized countries, dependencies, and other areas in the world.
The World Factbook is prepared by the CIA for the use of U.S. government officials, and its style, format, coverage, and content are primarily designed to meet their requirements. However, it is frequently used as a resource for academic research papers and news articles. As a work of the U.S. government, it is in the public domain in the United States. (wikipedia)
• • •
My wife and I were watching The Fabelmans a couple of weeks ago and afterwards she said, "That main kid ... he reminded me of somebody ..." and I had thought the same thing, but just couldn't place it. I had been thinking "I know that kid ... from somewhere." Then much later, after we got home from the theater, my wife shouts at me from the next room: "Sam Ezersky!" And I was like "oh my god that's it!" If you know Sam (today's constructor), or look at a picture of Sam alongside the young actor in question, Gabriel LaBelle, you'll probably think, "hmm ... I dunno ... not really seeing it. I mean, they're both handsome young men, but ... nah, seems like a stretch." But someday you will maybe be watching The Fabelmans, which you'd always meant to do but never did because there was book club and then "Real Housewives" was on and the laundry's not going to fold itself for god's sake ... and you'll be watching and Teenage Spielberg will come on screen and you'll notice, something in his affect, something in the way he speaks, and all of a sudden you'll be just like that Leonardo DiCaprio GIF, you know the one ... pointing at the screen is astonished recognition, and you'll say, "There it is ... oh yeah ... I SEE it ..." Anyway, The Fabelmans was a good movie and this is a good puzzle. [Nailed the landing, once again]
This one opened like a super-wide Friday for me; that is, it was very whoosh-whoosh, and there was an odd horizontality to the initial whooshing, which made me notice that the grid was horizontally oversized. This was the opening gambit:
That's a lot of traction, all over the top of the grid, very quickly. Really, no hesitation on those early answers, except when I stupidly wrote in EUROPE for E.U. FLAG (21A: It has a ring of 12 gold stars on a blue background). From the "V" in VAMPIRES, I got VIBE CHECK (talk about whoosh! couldn't believe it was right!). And then, despite finding a lot of little things kinda tough in that NW corner, I put it all together without too much trouble and then shot across the grid like a rocket with BIG TEN CONFERENCE (18A: What Minnesota and Michigan are part of, but not Missouri):
I'll confess, I completely forgot the HODGES part of Obergefell v. HODGES. I know the case as "Obergefell" and though I could not have spelled "Obergefell" without some hints, I would've at least known what the ballpark looked like. HODGES ... I had HOBBES in there at one point, maybe, I dunno. But luckily I had that answer pretty well surrounded so I didn't have time to feel too bad about my cruddy memory. No clue about the CIA WORLD FACTBOOK, though when you have the opening "CIA ..." there aren't really that many places to go. That is, no English words start that way (that I know of) so either I had an error, or it started with the initialism "CIA." The WORLD FACTBOOK part just came together from crosses. I can see how 60A: Web master, with "the" was supposed to fool me, but it didn't. It might have, but by the time I looked at the clue, I already had the "Z" in place so, like Spider-Man, "thwap," I soared across the grid some more.
Or maybe it's not "thwap"—maybe it's "FTANNG!"
The most impressive thing about this grid to me is not the grid-spanners (although they're nice). It's the prodigious NW and SE corners. I left that NW corner thinking, "Damn ... that is a nice corner." If you'd told me yesterday, "hey, tomorrow, you are going to love a corner that's got EPODE CHOO and EBB" in it, I'd've said "who are you and how do you know this?" And I probably wouldn't have believed you. But VAMPIRES / VIBECHECK is a 1A/1D crossing for the Ages, and everything inside it is tight and bright—and there's just so Much inside it. The whole thing should creak under the weight of all that white space, but it doesn't. It holds up. More than holds up.
TO BE FRANK, I am not a fan of PSALM ONE (though I am a fan of "TO BE FRANK...")—you'd write PSALM ONE as "Psalm 1" and anyway there are a 150 of them, can we just put any number after PSALM now? But then right next to it, you've got LOWER G.I., which I loved. So the icky is offset by the ironically not-icky LOWER G.I. tract. I'm not too keen on having the feds in this puzzle not once but twice (CIA andFBI). Grid could use some more counterculture to offset the cops, not to mention the corporations (specifically Big PHARMA). Cops in SOFT ARMOR (sung to the tune of "Knights in White Satin")?—no thanks. The pronoun "I" appears at least three times in the grid, but it's just one letter so who cares? ("I SEE, I SAY, therefore I AM"—Descartes's lesser-known See 'N' Say theory of being). I didn't have a negative reaction to very much in this grid. I guess I've heard / would say KILLING IT well before SLAYING IT. "SLAYING" in my limited vernacular experience often (usually?) occurs without the "it." But it seems valid, and anyway I got it easily.
Had ORAL before ANAL because well because because because because because ... wishful thinking, I guess (49D: ___ stage (concept in psychosexual development)). Had me wondering when this tradition of people RAPping on Jan. 1 had started and how I had missed it (57A: Many people do this on January 1 => NAP). There were a lot of tricky, initially mystifying clues today. Worst, for me, was 42A: K, for Kay (KARAT). "Kay" here is the damned jewelry company!!!! So in the context of jewelry, specifically gold, yes, "K" stands for KARAT, aargh. Thought the "Ah" follower might be ... well, it's four letters, so think four-letter words, and you'll have some idea what I was thinking. Had HEEL for 56A: Stiletto feature (HAFT), and I can't believe I'm alone there. The stiletto here is the knife, not the shoe. The clue on LOWER G.I. was wicked, in that I thought "Colon" was a punctuation mark, a name, a geographical location ... all of those things ... before I settled on the body part (63A: Colon's place, familiarly). Nice little scatological gag (!) there, btw: crossing LOWER G.I. with ANAL. Grateful for my relatively recent bird knowledge, which didn't give me SKYLARKS right away, but did at least let me know that I was dealing with birds. Seems entirely possible that "pipits" are not immediately recognizable as birds to many people (66A: Pipit lookalikes). The sides of a square are STS because streets make up the "sides" of some (town) squares (53D: Sides of a square, maybe). Does anything else need explaining? Oh, EGOTS are sets of all four major entertainment awards: Emmy/Grammy/Oscar/Tony. Viola Davis just completed hers last week, winning a Best Audiobook, Narration, and Storytelling Recording Grammy for her memoir Finding Me. Now, you will find me ... in the kitchen, with the cats, making coffee. Good day.
When I see Sam’s name atop a grid, I go into a humble state, knowing I’m going to spend most of the puzzle in first gear, grinding my brain, making slow hard-won progress that I feel mighty good about, and admitting all along that everything is fair. I usually exit the puzzle exultant from the workout.
I also know that the grid will be incredibly scoured. Saturday Sam (almost half his daily NYT puzzles fall on that day) holds himself to a high bar on that front. The puzzle shimmers.
All held true today. One mark of the handful of upper-echelon constructors is that you can tell who it’s by even without seeing the name on top. You can say of such a puzzle, say, “Oh yes, that’s an Ezersky.” Sam easily falls into this category.
Notes:
• OMG freshness today, with an amazing 17 NYT answer debuts, including AMAZING SPIDERMAN, TO BE FRANK, SLAYING IT, LOWER GI, and VIBE CHECK. • VIBE CHECK and SOFT ARMOR were TILs for me, but intuition-friendly, and I’m glad to learn them. • The black squares in the middle area remind me of the DNA double helix. • What a great clue for KARAT – [K for Kay]. Also, such a lovely and never-used-before misdirect for TELL ON – [Get in trouble]. Also, devilish clue for HAFT – [Stiletto feature], which had me (and I’m guessing many others) thinking another four-letter H-word (HEEL).
A most proper Saturday for which I’m most grateful. Thank you for another prime Ezersky, Sam!
I did know the CIA World Factbook because I am a geography nerd, and I used to get the print one every year (pre-internet) to randomly look things up. I was amazed that the CIA would produce something like this for public consumption and was always hoping they’d accidentally let some classified factoid in, like the dirt they had on Mobutu Sese Seko.
I really liked this one too. I’ll be checking back here later to see how many people grumble about the words they have tried to get Sam Ezersky to accept in Spelling Bee. (“Midden” was my most recent complaint.). I had no idea what he looked like so I Google imaged him and yes, handsome young man.
I SLAYED IT in the NE to get off to a whoosh-whoosh start. I immediately got all of the downs in TOBAGO except TEFLON PAN, and then I got that pretty quickly too. I graduated from Missouri so I knew right away that it isn’t in the BIG TEN while Michigan and Minnesota are. Missouri was in the Big Eight when I was there and the SEC now. I frown on all the conference jumping that results in regions like “Southeast” and numbers like “Ten” no longer meaning anything.
After getting the NE easily, I went into a stall. I did put in VAMPIRES right away, but I only got the IRES downs, so not much help with the NW. After going through all the clues, I had the top filled in pretty well and practically zilch in the bottom. It became an @Lewis faith solve.
I think Viola Davis is an amazing actress and absolutely deserves that EOT. But I kinda feel like winning a Grammy from reading an audiobook is … cheating. Seems like you should have to sing for that Grammy. Oh well, if anyone can get away with it, she can. And I think she was robbed of an Oscar nom this year by the specious campaign in favor of Andrea Riseborough. Did all of those actors holding events for her think that they would be ensuring no Black woman would make it? (Either Viola for “The Woman King” or Danielle Deadwyler for “Till” probably would have gotten the slot.) Yes, in addition to being a geography nerd, I am a film SNOB. I shouldn’t really care who or what gets nominated but I can’t stop myself. I’ve seen five of the ten nominated for best picture and will try to see all of them.
What were the really bad director’s instructions to his cast? ACT NOW!
The AMAZING SPIDER-MAN is one of those grid-spanners that’s actually worth parsing together a bunch of crosses because there is actually a payoff (the clever cluing - although the fact that Web master was two words may have been a give away).
Some tough stuff like MIRY, Talofa, Keijo, HODGES, HAFT, . . . but hey it’s Saturday. Can’t complain about tough but fair, and that’s what the constructor delivered today. Nice job.
This was anything but Easy/Medium for me ... was about to google an answer or two but then got FARRO and things finally fell into place. Still took over 35 minutes.
Beautiful Saturday, tough but come-at-able, clever but not show-offy. Though if I asked you for a Snickers and you gave me a MRGOODBAR, I’m not sure I’d feel I got what I was looking for.
It usually takes me some time to ease into Sam’s cluing - today was no different. Pleasant, wide grid with mostly clean fill. The long spanners were fine - but didn’t SLAY. Agree with the big guy that the big corners were the real deal here. MR GOODBAR, SKYLARKS, FARRO etc are really top notch. No question a hand up for heel before HAFT. Liked all the conversational entries.
There were some ugly spots - doubling down on TEN, the awful GENII, MIRY, EU FLAG. Collateral damage I PRESUME. ECO TECH said no one ever. Complete back-in to the Glinka opera.
Enjoyable Saturday solve. There is a bit of crossover in Matt Sewell’s Stumper.
No happy music. Corrected a typo (I make a lot of those). Still no happy music. Then I focused on 31A. What I as a motorist used to screw up was re-folding those maps from gas stations. So I confidently put in mAP, confirmed by the last two letters. But what sort of three-letter map do motorists screw up? I considered GpS, since I know more than one motorist who gets bollixed up working the GPS. Then I thought maybe GaS mAP, short, maybe, for "gas station map"? It took a while to realize that mDC made no sense and that motorists (other than those in New Jersey) screw up a GAS CAP. Happy music.
I really liked this, and this isn’t a criticism, but I seemed awfully easy for a Saturday. I kept whooshing, as Rex would say, but also thinking no, this is too easy, it can’t be right… but it almost always was. And there was really something about seeing ANAL connect with the LOWERGI — the latter was an absolutely brilliant clue/answer pair. (For a minute or so, LOzEnGe looked plausible, but it made no sense whatsoever.)
Why didn't I put in VAMPIRES after reading the clue, it's that obvious, I said to myself when I finally got back to the NW. I think I was distracted by the "expanse on a Spanish explorer's map" and wondering whether it would be TIERRA or OCEANO. When it was the latter I stayed in the NE and went around counter clockwise and finally arrive at hey--VAMPIRES! Easy one.
I wanted the motorist to screw up folding his MAP but EGOTS to the rescue. Had the T as the last letter in the "stiletto feature" so it was HAFT or hilt. Can't remember the last time I saw a woman in stilettos around here. Probably never. Also wanted UNFLAG briefly, even though I'm very familiar with the EUFLAG .
Boo for MIRY and yay for TOPPS. Liked the cards but the sheet of "gum" always shattered.
BORG??? At least "pipit" sounds like a bird.
Really nice Saturday, SE. Simply Excellent. If you're looking for another word that should be accepted in SB (hi @Wanderlust). I'm submitting INTROIT. Thanks for all the fun.
@pabloinnh 8:28 AM - You did not put in VAMPIRES because, as others have pointed out, there were too many ?'s, and some of them were misleading. With no "?" I prolly woulda thought VAMPIRES right off. The "?" made me look too far afield, like "chiggers" or "ticks" or something a bit more wry than VAMPIRES.
My hat's off to all of you who rated this as EASY. For me it was CHALLENGING - 42 minutes! But I liked it a lot. Time well spent going back and forth from ACROSS to DOWN and back again. Letter here, another one there. January 1 clue was AIL, then NOD, then NAG, then NAP. FARRO, MENTOR etc, etc. Tough one.
There is a singer named Ciara who's had several big hits.
I don't share Rex's love for LOWER GI, which seems like it's missing a noun at the end the way it is clued (and Rex wrote "LOWER GI tract" when he talked about it).
I had BUYNOW instead of ACTNOW at first, which was my only hiccup for what was a very easy Saturday. I'm flattered that the constructor thinks I know all of NAS's discography, but it was an easy inference. All in all a smooth puz w/ delightful fill. And just a remark re: yesterday's puz - - - - YAS QUEEN feels so immediately dated that if someone were to go through the archive say ten years down the road and attempt the 2/10/23 puzzle, I think that answer would totally stump them. Otherwise, I really liked yesterday.
The number of performers who have accomplished the EGOT is now so large that it's no longer much of a distinction. As in, who are they and WTF should I care?
Otherwise, decent enough Saturday puzz. Blew through the top easily enough, entering 8A with absolutely no crosses. And 1A I suspected but waited until I had a couple crosses. The lower half was crunchier and put up a bit of a fight.
I hated this puzzle. I thought there were too many fill in the blank clues and anal is unpleasant and I kept being UNDELIGHTED as often as delighted by the fresh fill. I was very disappointed by my own vibe check of this puzzle...
Rex has been asking for a tough Saturday for a while now, and in my view (although not his) that’s what we got today. My solve had no “thwaps” or “ftanngs” in it, only “crunch” after “crunch”. Slowest Saturday in a long time. The NW was crazy hard, despite having BIGTENCONFERENCE as my very first entry.
But it was well worth it. The grid itself is AMAZING, and I learned some things (SEOUL’s former name, the term VIBECHECK). Maybe one or two too many “?” clues, but the MENTOR clue is fantastic, mostly because I didn’t think of it as a verb. Even with things like VIBECHECK, the puzzle has a formal, establishment-y VIBE (CIA, FBI, CDC, PHARMA, ISAY, I PRESUME, TOBEFRANK) which seemed to be apt.
Lost my modest streak by failing to notice the plurals (!) in the "Spirits that come in bottles" clue. Figured SeMP was an alternative spelling. So weak on my part.
HODGES was a gimme cause that's my ex husband and my kid's last names. I sent it to my son and said you finally made the NYT puzzle. You tend to notice that kind of thing and the case decider was the legality of gay marriage. Often just called Obergefell.
I never saw HAFT before , a new crosswordese for my list. I was stuck at SOFT ARMOR forever. I had ports for POSTS as PORTS are stations too, like a USB port. Had CSI too so that whole area went last. AH CHOO I worked it out just under an hour! Checks Vibe= happy about the puzzle, unhappy about all the CrapLoad of chores that await me today.
Great Saturday workout! I liked the dupe ""Ah" follower" clues. ISEE/ISAY managed not to be KEALOAs as clued. Train as a verb with workers was devilish - I plugged in an "s" at the end, which blocked that until the end.
@Wanderlust, I'm with your side-eye for an EGOT including an audiobook, and also giving Viola a pass. There has to be some kind of crossover to get all 4. Composers seem like they might have an EGOT chance without working outside their usual metier. Singing actress seems to be a large percentage of the list also.
Excellent Saturday puzzle, even if it took the wind out of my solving skills a bit. SOFT ARMOR left me drifting in the OCEANO. AND YET, it all turned out (O)K. We started out with VAMPIRES and ended with SKYLARKS. Sweet. ....BTW, is anyone else stunned that Rex does the puzzle AND writes the blog BEFORE coffee?
Hey All ! IPRESUMEd that something was amiss with my IdasSUME. As in I'D ASSUME. Hmm, says I, is Pluto a PsTar now? Why won't it fit? Erased the Idas part, said, Hey, maybe I PRESUME?, saw the MR emerge, and said, Could that be MR GOOBAR? And it was! Then saw PETDOG, and all was right with that corner. Although, MR GOODBAR is not really a straight-up Snickers alternative. But clue technically correct, as it didn't say substitution. Hey, chocolate and peanuts is chocolate and peanuts! Nougat, schmougat.
Last section was that tough SW. Dang. For NAP, wanted RECOVER FROM A HANGOVER. 😁 The ANAL/ASST/SPAWN trifecta was my hold up. Last letter in was the A of ANAL/ASST cross, said, What else could it be?, Threw it in, and Happy Music! WooHoo! First pumped the air.
So a good SatPuz brain workout. Saw the 16-wideness. At least this has a reason for it. Keep seeing POST MALONE when looking at PSALMONE.
Once I gave up on "Mounds bar" and thought of Mr. Goodbar, and once I realized "I'd assume" was I presume, that NW corner fell into place and the puzzle was done. Very enjoyable and slightly easy for a Saturday. Can't imagine anyone saying they hated it when it there was verylittle to complain about.
Please tell me...would you consider me a cheater if I check my (correct) answers? It's like making your first soufflé and opening the oven to see if it's cooked. The soufflé doesn't deflate and it tastes delicious. Like @Rex, I was whooshing. It scared me; I was so sure my answers would be wrong. Saturdays do that to me....My ANAL, ANGST, AGITA meter tends to go off. Today, my happy feet were happy. I was happy, too. VAMPIRE and TOBAGO..whoosh. The whole top tier slid in like warm butter slathered on my toasted olive bread. I was afraid this would be over too soon; I didn't want the joy to end. Ah...here come the unknowns...take your time....go dance elsewhere...think outside the box (here's looking at you HAFT)... Yes...I spent way too much time with HAFT. You might've thought HEEL but I thought HEFT. Heft as in lifting you to soaring and uncomfortable heights? Nah. SOFTER something or other wasn't working. Move on....I did. I had a few holes here and there. Wimp instead of SIMP. I thought an unlikely trait for a beekeeper might be allergies. Crossing words to the rescue. Had trouble with CIA WORLD FACT BOOK...thank you easy downs. And so it went. Take you time. Get up and move around....drink your coffee...smile....make sure your answers are really right..pretend you didn't do that....crow at the end. I did. Sam and I CLICK when needed. He is much younger than I but I like what he does with words. He down't make it impossible to figure out the unknowns. After yesterday's disaster, this was wonderful....
Because I was in the ORAL stage rather than the ANAL stage, I DNFed. Now admittedly I thought of the ANAL stage too before writing in ORAL, but ORAL went so beautifully with RUE for what you do on January 1. Of course you can NAP first and then RUE. Or vice-versa.
ORAL makes it impossible to solve the SW corner. You try to find a country with the letter combo ?UM?A that says "talofa" or anything else. Only after cheating on SAMOA did I get ASST and SPAWN. LOWERGI is a DOOK.
PET DOG for Pluto is a little Green Paint-y, don't you think? He was So Much More than that.
Who knew that the CIA had a WORLD FACT BOOK? My, my.
SOFT ARMOR doesn't sound all that "lightweight" to me. I think I prefer my nylon shell windbreaker for "lightweight protection".
I had UN FLAG before EU FLAG and HEEL before HAFT -- but those were my easiest to correct writeovers.
A really, really hard themeless. I mean really, REALLY hard! Congrats, Sam, on making me "suffer" a lot today.
It took over two hours, but I finally tamed this beast without cheating. I think "easy-medium" is too passive. "Typical Saturday" would be my description.
I had PORTS instead of POSTS for "stations," so it took a long time to figure out SOFTARMOR, which I've never heard of anyway. And LOWERGI for "colon's place" is a devilish clue and a phrase used by medical professionals, not the public (thus a bit unfair).
"Train workers" for MENTOR is another clever clue, but misleading in that mentoring isn't limited to workers. You can mentor a student, for example, or your own child for that matter. "Train people" would be just as clever, and much fairer.
Easy-medium. VAMPIRES went in with no crosses. hEwn before FELL and Heel (hi @Rex) before HAFT were it for erasures and HODGES was my only WOE. Smooth, solid, and a fun solve, liked it a bunch!
Maybe it’s a regional thing, but I screw on/off a GASCAP, not “screw up”, tho I feel ok about “screw down”.🤷🏼♀️ I get the misdirection, just don’t think “screw up” is in the lingo for that particular action. Agree with many others that a MR.GOODBAR is no substitute for a Snickers- gimme my nougat & caramel!
While he may be flawed as the SB editor SE can make a decent themeless puzzle. This one was like momma bear's bed, not too hard and not too soft just nice steady Saturday level solving throughout. Speaking of LEVEL I did try to make TOBELEVEL work in that SE corner thanks to my HILT/HAFT write over. That's about as close as it came to a big problem in filling the grid. Getting 60A off of ZED cleared that up.
@Wanderlust, count me in as one of the solvers who's been waiting to see if this constructor would have the nerve to use any of the words he leaves off of his SB lists. Kudos on remembering MIDDEN. The shunned words I can think of offhand are things like TURGOR, FAIN and ATLATYL. Given these are odd words but don't most puzzle people love their odd words. It's really the randomness that gets under my skin. He largely eschews the Scrabble. Dict. words but then how do you account for the inclusion of PALAPA. The only words of SB note that I noticed today were GENII and FARRO both of which the SB has thoroughly beaten into my head.
@dgd, thanks for the shout out yesterday. I did used to be a regular here but now I've cut back to just being a weekend warrior.
I get that, like Raymond, "Everybody Loves Ezersky." But as I am more of an interloper here than a true believer, I will say that his cluing (again, much beloved by the devoted) is often obtuse, misleading, or worse. EBB does not mean "go back"; "recede," yes, but "go back" and "recede" are not the same thing. In a similar vein, AVENGE does not mean "get recompense for." To get recompense mean to be paid what you are owed. That is different than exacting vengeance. "Requite" or "Exact satisfaction," yes. And, worse of all, "induce" does not mean SPAWN. You can induce labor, but you cannot SPAWN labor. You can SPAWN progeny, but you cannot "induce" progeny. Now on to a different type of problematic clue: Motorists rarely "screw up" a GAS CAP, but they do often "screw on" a GAS CAP—but of course, that would not have resulted in a pun (or whatever you want to call it)...but the pun is worthless if its is not an apt clue for the entry. In my life I have been both a "prof." and an "ed.", and yet I found ASST hard to swallow as the entry for that clue—It's just not something that clicks, emoige (Ancient Greek for "to me at least"). And then his use of words like "famously" and "familiarly" for things that are neither famous nor familiar, vel sim. For example, 4D, PLUTO, is, yes, a pet dog, but...famously? I don't think that's how that crossword clue technique works. Similarly for 63A, LOWER GI, which is, yes, the colon's place, but again, "familiarly?" How many people do you know who go around saying, "Geez, I got such a pain in my lower GI"??? Then there is 33D, "Org. with guidelines." My first thought was AMA, my next thought was "I mean, like, don't virtually all organizations have guidelines?" And therein lies the problem with The Great Ezersky's cluing. What is "famous" about Pluto is that first it was a planet, then it wasn't, then it was again. So a good clue might have been, "Heavenly body famously demoted in 2006." You need to know how the language works. Again, I know he is a god among crossword constructors, but my reaction remains, familiarly if not famously, MEH.
"One mark of the handful of upper-echelon constructors is that you can tell who it’s by even without seeing the name on top." --@Lewis
Nope. I can't do that, Lewis. I can't even come close. I'll know that it's "one of the good ones", that it's "one of the ones I like", but that's about all. I find it quite AMAZING that you can do that.
A 73-worder themeless. But it's usin a 16x15 puzgrid, sooo … ok.
Stuff that really helped preserve the precious M&A solvequest nanoseconds: * VAMPIRES - Opened up that big old NW corner rodeo with a Ftung. * BIGTENCONFERENCE - Near gimme, especially with a coupla letters already in place. * AMAZINGSPIDERMAN - Also nailed this grid spanner PDQ. Had a chance to purchase Spiderman #1 comic, when it first came out. But I was actually kinda turned off, cuz I had been a big fan of the Amazing Stories comics that it suddenly replaced. I was therefore a teenager in mournin. But I digress. * "Ah" followers CHOO and ISEE. Definite runtpuz theme potential... * Friendly-ish ?-marker clues, especially {Razor name?} = OCCAM. * The BORG. * BOGOTA anagram minipuz fun.
Stuff that gobbled up precious nanoseconds pronto: * FARRO. Debut word of mystery. * ECOTECH. Sort inferrable, but needed most of the letters. * VIBECHECK. Induced a saywhatcheck. * CIAWORLDFACTBOOK. Don't sound real familiar. WORLD musta been replaced with ALTERNATE, durin the Trump Admin.
staff weeject pick: STS. Cute clue, for a hohum plural abbreve runt.
Thanx for the challenge, Mr. Sam-EZ dude. Lotsa great fillins! Surely that CIA thingy wasn't yer seed entry, tho ...?
Desperately sad moment when ANAL crosses LOWER GI crosses MIRY {shakes head}, but outside of that tragedy I enjoyed this. And it's really not a tragedy, but more evidence the NYTXW editorial staff is dedicated to ARSE-ifying our daily existence. As if Tumblr isn't enough. Constructors, please add "must include bottom" to your list of submission requirements.
You drop vampires and bee keepers on me right off the bat and I am all yours. AH CHOO is never not gonna be hilarious to me. So many other great phrases. Just loved 'em.
GENII is horrible and that little section is easily rewritten, so why??
Never heard of the CIA World Fact Book. It's probably something I am paying for without knowing it.
@Barbara and @Nancy I was in late last yesterday, so thank you both for the uniclue convention last night. Always so much fun. Talking tea leaves, the inner voice of a canary, and a portapotty with an attitude. What's not to love?
Uniclues:
1 Caribbean blood suckers. 2 Why Texas had that power outage according to a pro-gas-industry politician. 3 Just going to leave this buried in the middle here. 4 Fear of Polynesian pricks. 5 Quote from one witnessing a celebrity meltdown as they heave their copious awards into a marshy bog. 6 {Hahahahahaha!} 7 Teenager doing the dishes. 8 ... after all, one needs some chemical help dealing with all these losers. 9 Neons.
1 TOBAGO VAMPIRES (~) 2 ECOTECH, I PRESUME 3 ANAL VIBE CHECK (~) 4 SAMOA APIPHOBIA 5 I SEE MIRY EGOTS (~) 6 EMCEE SLAYING IT 7 TEFLON PAN ARISK 8 SNOB ATE PHARMA (~) 9 HEMP SKIN TONES
There once was a crossword editor Who needed to beat his competitor He put in some ass And showed the top brass They said, "Doo it doo it you butt-end repetitor."
As the keeper of the NYT Spelling Bee, it was quite appropriate that Sam included APIPHOBIA ("Unlikely trait for a beekeeper") in his puzzle today. There was also an entry at 47-A, TOP TEN, that would have qualified as an answer in today's Bee if it was one word.
SIMP is problematic manosphere verbiage. There were quite a few near alt right entries in this one: military, religion, toxic masculinity. Only vaguely shielded by the gay marriage case.
I thought I was headed for a PB when I cleared the top half of the grid in two minutes flat, but then I made a lot of mistakes that slowed me down significantly. Started with OCEANs, not realizing the "Spanish" in the clue was looking for an O on the end. That led to me thinking 28A, "Article go-with", was NSFW. Not that kind of article, it turns out. Spent too long wondering what f__WO (29D) could possibly be. And if you have a clue that says "Stiletto feature" and it's not "heel", you're just being mean. And I automatically assumed CSI at 44A instead of FBI. What can I say? I'm a simple man. I see CBS, I see spinoff, I see three letters, I put CSI. Devious trick, that one. I still came in well below my Saturday average in the end after forcing some things I knew had to be right (SKIN TONES, SOFT ARMOR) helped me untangle my knots, but not by as much as I could have been.
I'm largely in agreement with Mike in Bed-Stuy @ 11:13. Many of these clues were tough because they were tweaked in such a way that they don't precisely mean what their answers indicate, which doesn't feel like totally fair play. Laughed a lot when I agreed with his point about 33D; the clue might as well have said "Abbr. with letters". He did start tripping over his own feet during his Pluto rant though, to where it seems like he's saying Pluto was the answer to 4D rather than PET DOG. What I think he meant was that a good clue would have been "Pluto, for one". I'm not ready to render my own verdict on Ezersky's grid-building yet, but all Mike's points are solid.
Anagrams (9A) and letters clued as wordplay (61D) need to end. If I ever construct a puzzle, I promise the only way it will have those is if editorial intervention strikes.
Agree with others that the Borg are not a species. They are a collective. But that's the kind of thing my brain elides for the sake of getting a puzzle done quick. You see Star Trek in the clue, you see B___, you throw down BORG, you move on.
GENII clued as "Spirits found in bottles" is truly execrable. I mean, I get the punny misdirect, but that's not how the -ii plural works. In my experience, GEN II represents the Johto era of Pokémon, but that would be way too niche for most NYT solvers.
You're either killing it or you're slaying. You're never SLAYING IT.
Ezersky seems like a modern enough dude to know that SIMP as clued isn't often used in that sense anymore. Not sure its meaning in modern parlance would get it into a grid, though.
Tons of great answers, and that NW corner is a thing of beauty. If Jeff Chen gave Corners of the Week (COWs?), I'd say that one got it. But there was also plenty here to earn a potent stink-eye. It worked out to pretty good in the end though.
Do more people NAP on Jan 1 than the average day? I dunno, I knew 49D was either ORAL or ANAL, and I had SPAWN in 51D, so I figured of all the N_P or R_P possibilities, NAP was the likeliest, but it still strikes me as a very weak clue. I dunno that, as an adult, I've ever napped on NYD, and I really don't think it's a thing most people do.
The idea I think is that many people stay up (sometimes very) late and/or drink too much on New Years Eve so need a nap on the 1st. At 70 I have long since stopped doing that but what I do is irrelevant. The clue works for me.
Very hard for me, so I feel good to have solved it clean. But it wasn't enjoyable. Too many clues were just on the edge of legitimacy. GASCAP. KARAT. NAP. MENTOR. PSALMONE. SPAWN. AVENGE. GENII. No joy in getting them. Just "Oh, I guess that works."
I thought this was pretty challenging and almost DNFed because I didn't know miry was a word. Know the noun, don't like the adjective. I guess it's legit, but it seems like a word that's never been said aloud. Otherwise I enjoyed it. I guess maybe I learned a new word, but not one that I like.
I think “THWIP” is the most common onomatopoeia for Spidey, coined by Ditko, popularized by Romita, and trademarked by Marvel. Other favorites include “BAMF” for Nightcrawler teleporting, “SNIKT” for Wolverine’s claws popping, and anything bass-y and rumble-y for Thor, like “KRAKA-DOOM!”
Precise usage is critical in a lexicographer’s workshop, but in Crossworld language usage’s functionality seems more appropriately in the horseshoes and hand grenades bracket. I’m recalling @LMS postings past where she in her patient teacher mode differentiates between prescribing and describing language as respective possibilities. Language changes; at times I wish it weren’t so…but often it ain’t! This SIMP is appreciative of those posters who MENTOR me, but Sam’s loosey-goosey clueing makes my Saturday filled with sunshine!
Having BIG TEN CONFERENCE led me to put stIng fear in at 2down for my first OCÉANO of error 😣 slightly SSW of the Bermuda Triangle. That made arriving back at APIPHOBIA a circuitous journey across the oversized grid.
No whooshing for me on this one! Friday's I enjoyed, this not so much. On Friday, finally getting an answer was usually "Oh, nice!" Today, it was more like "WAIT, what?" Some college sports conference (ick), VIBE CHECK (what?), MR GOODBAR (really?). Just a wheelhouse thing, I guess, except for AMAZING SPIDERMAN.
Typeover: ALLERGIES before APIPHOBIA. And of course HEEL before HAFT.
I detect some personal bias by Rex here. This was an attempted young person's puzzle (VIBECHECK??), with lots of zeitgeist and some niche knowlege. And some ugly crosswordese: GENII, MIRY. Still don't know how "STS" is sides of a square.
Gorgeous Saturday puzzle. Solved quickly, but for some reason the question mark on "Train workers?" didn't register and I could not look sideways to fathom Train as a verb. Thus MENTOR went in, but made *no* sense to me. Wish I been able to figured it out on my own before reading the posts ("cheating"), but was still a great aha moment to see an explanation. 24A "Get in trouble, perhaps" ==> TELLON was delightfully sublime.
Interesting how Great Lakes States and BIGTENCONFERENCE have the same number of letters. Fortunately, I work in pencil so my confident first entry was easily removed.
So glad to see that one of our neighborhood here whose posts I enjoy and revere, @Lewis, has the same reaction to a Sam Ezersky as I do. And as always, I had to work for it today, but I got there. After yesterday’s easy breezy Friday, I suspected that today might be trouble.
I’ve said before that I really enjoy seeing how different our solving experiences can vary so widely. For me, today’s NW was brutal. Some of it might be my very real Ezerskyphobia. I see Sam’s byline and my brain freezes for a while.
Sam is a super-constructor. Clever, intelligent puzzles that make me really work for it, test my chops and teach me something nee every time. This one did not disappoint. But it took me a good while to get started.
Sure, VAMPIRES lured me in and made me hopeful. Followed ny a huge nothing burger! Got HODGES at least but still zip in addition.
Got some whoosh whoosh going . Over in the NE with TOBAGO and had enough to get the east side put together and worked my way around counter clockwise. Loved almost all of this one, but gotta be honest, didn’t care for GENII. It felt like the last little but that the editors wanted to tweak and couldn’t come up with a better idea. No matter because it dod not dampen my enthusiasm for my otherwise totally enjoyable but tough solve. Loved seeing my favorite BIG TEN CONFERENCE.
Badly clued in so many ways. I'm a medical professional, and I can assure you that no ordinary person refers to their colon familiarly as their "lower GI"! DUH!
Also, there is no sane or acceptable explanation for "miry" as an answer - not now, not ever, not even in an alternate universe.
"Vibecheck" must be some super-cool lingo used by super-cool people. I've never heard that until today, AND I intend to forget it immediately, b/c IMO it has no value, not *even* as crossword fill.
I can't say that I've heard the expression "slaying" without "it"! It's usually been established what the speaker is talking about before saying "He/She is slaying it" - "He/She slayed it" E.g., she gave her presentation to the board and really slayed it!
How many times did we say or hear "I'm telling on you!" during childhood? Biggest threat ever!
Anonymous at 3:11 PM said "You could read the write-up." I often see this one sentence comment from an Anonymous and I'm thinking it's probably the same person. My question to you is why be so snarky? A lot of us don't mind answering other commenters' questions. As Thumper (of "Bambi" fame) wisely said, ""If you can't say something nice, don't say nothin' at all."
I hated it. Solved it. But only after many moments of rage SPAWNED by the oh-so-clever cluing and the overuse of acronyms and abbreviations designed to frustrate the solver.
A sad commentary on U of MN basketball when they can't finish in the TOPTEN of the BIGTENCONFERENCE. They used to go to the big dance. After 288 attempts (4 tournaments), the Wordle golf score would be 32 under par, counting the 3 DNFs as triple bogeys.
A medium Saturday for me. Wasn't liking ECOTECH: a prefix + a suffix. Also had trouble with my Bible ignorance; had Proverbs which fit nicely. Much ink blotting there, including hand up for Heel before HAFT. What is SOFTARMOR if not an oxymoron? Got it all sorted out though, eventually. Nice, roomy grid. Birdie.
It is such a turn off to see a "?" clue, which was totally unnecessary anyway, as the lead off clue on Saturday. BAN THE ?!
ReplyDeleteNice writeup but I’m surprised that there was no mention of the duplicate use of TEN.
ReplyDeleteAgree on all points with OFL. First time ever.
ReplyDeleteWhen I see Sam’s name atop a grid, I go into a humble state, knowing I’m going to spend most of the puzzle in first gear, grinding my brain, making slow hard-won progress that I feel mighty good about, and admitting all along that everything is fair. I usually exit the puzzle exultant from the workout.
ReplyDeleteI also know that the grid will be incredibly scoured. Saturday Sam (almost half his daily NYT puzzles fall on that day) holds himself to a high bar on that front. The puzzle shimmers.
All held true today. One mark of the handful of upper-echelon constructors is that you can tell who it’s by even without seeing the name on top. You can say of such a puzzle, say, “Oh yes, that’s an Ezersky.” Sam easily falls into this category.
Notes:
• OMG freshness today, with an amazing 17 NYT answer debuts, including AMAZING SPIDERMAN, TO BE FRANK, SLAYING IT, LOWER GI, and VIBE CHECK.
• VIBE CHECK and SOFT ARMOR were TILs for me, but intuition-friendly, and I’m glad to learn them.
• The black squares in the middle area remind me of the DNA double helix.
• What a great clue for KARAT – [K for Kay]. Also, such a lovely and never-used-before misdirect for TELL ON – [Get in trouble]. Also, devilish clue for HAFT – [Stiletto feature], which had me (and I’m guessing many others) thinking another four-letter H-word (HEEL).
A most proper Saturday for which I’m most grateful. Thank you for another prime Ezersky, Sam!
Thx, Sam; well done! :)
ReplyDeleteMed. (smack dab avg Sat. time).
I'd SAY this ONE was mostly in my wheelhouse.
Dropped in VAMPIRES / EMCEE, and with some trial and error, polished off the NW.
BIG TEN CONFERENCE / BORG facilitated the remaining top 1/3.
OCEANs was easily repaired with NOUN.
Needed lots of crosses to nail the other two grid-spanners.
Loved "ah" follower for CHOO!
Fun solve; liked it a lot! :)
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness to all 🙏
Delightful puzzle
ReplyDeleteJust came here to brag about getting APIPHOBIA off just the A in VAMPIRES.
ReplyDeleteThis was a really good puzzle. But it was easier than yesterday’s so some extra difficulty in the clues would have been appreciated.
ReplyDeleteAlternative clue: Fish in gym class? PSALMONE
Is ORAL/ANAL an official kealoa? I think so.
ReplyDeleteCiabatta!
ReplyDelete(English language word starting with cia.)
I did know the CIA World Factbook because I am a geography nerd, and I used to get the print one every year (pre-internet) to randomly look things up. I was amazed that the CIA would produce something like this for public consumption and was always hoping they’d accidentally let some classified factoid in, like the dirt they had on Mobutu Sese Seko.
I really liked this one too. I’ll be checking back here later to see how many people grumble about the words they have tried to get Sam Ezersky to accept in Spelling Bee. (“Midden” was my most recent complaint.). I had no idea what he looked like so I Google imaged him and yes, handsome young man.
I SLAYED IT in the NE to get off to a whoosh-whoosh start. I immediately got all of the downs in TOBAGO except TEFLON PAN, and then I got that pretty quickly too. I graduated from Missouri so I knew right away that it isn’t in the BIG TEN while Michigan and Minnesota are. Missouri was in the Big Eight when I was there and the SEC now. I frown on all the conference jumping that results in regions like “Southeast” and numbers like “Ten” no longer meaning anything.
After getting the NE easily, I went into a stall. I did put in VAMPIRES right away, but I only got the IRES downs, so not much help with the NW. After going through all the clues, I had the top filled in pretty well and practically zilch in the bottom. It became an @Lewis faith solve.
I think Viola Davis is an amazing actress and absolutely deserves that EOT. But I kinda feel like winning a Grammy from reading an audiobook is … cheating. Seems like you should have to sing for that Grammy. Oh well, if anyone can get away with it, she can. And I think she was robbed of an Oscar nom this year by the specious campaign in favor of Andrea Riseborough. Did all of those actors holding events for her think that they would be ensuring no Black woman would make it? (Either Viola for “The Woman King” or Danielle Deadwyler for “Till” probably would have gotten the slot.) Yes, in addition to being a geography nerd, I am a film SNOB. I shouldn’t really care who or what gets nominated but I can’t stop myself. I’ve seen five of the ten nominated for best picture and will try to see all of them.
What were the really bad director’s instructions to his cast? ACT NOW!
The AMAZING SPIDER-MAN is one of those grid-spanners that’s actually worth parsing together a bunch of crosses because there is actually a payoff (the clever cluing - although the fact that Web master was two words may have been a give away).
ReplyDeleteSome tough stuff like MIRY, Talofa, Keijo, HODGES, HAFT, . . . but hey it’s Saturday. Can’t complain about tough but fair, and that’s what the constructor delivered today. Nice job.
Nitpicking I know, but shouldn’t the word “the” in the Spider-Man clue be capitalized?
DeleteThis was anything but Easy/Medium for me ... was about to google an answer or two but then got FARRO and things finally fell into place. Still took over 35 minutes.
ReplyDeleteBeautiful Saturday, tough but come-at-able, clever but not show-offy. Though if I asked you for a Snickers and you gave me a MRGOODBAR, I’m not sure I’d feel I got what I was looking for.
ReplyDeleteIt usually takes me some time to ease into Sam’s cluing - today was no different. Pleasant, wide grid with mostly clean fill. The long spanners were fine - but didn’t SLAY. Agree with the big guy that the big corners were the real deal here. MR GOODBAR, SKYLARKS, FARRO etc are really top notch. No question a hand up for heel before HAFT. Liked all the conversational entries.
ReplyDeleteI’m at peace in the web of your arms
There were some ugly spots - doubling down on TEN, the awful GENII, MIRY, EU FLAG. Collateral damage I PRESUME. ECO TECH said no one ever. Complete back-in to the Glinka opera.
Enjoyable Saturday solve. There is a bit of crossover in Matt Sewell’s Stumper.
The Box Tops
I liked this one, had a good time solving. No cringing for me at all.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteNo happy music. Corrected a typo (I make a lot of those). Still no happy music. Then I focused on 31A. What I as a motorist used to screw up was re-folding those maps from gas stations. So I confidently put in mAP, confirmed by the last two letters. But what sort of three-letter map do motorists screw up? I considered GpS, since I know more than one motorist who gets bollixed up working the GPS. Then I thought maybe GaS mAP, short, maybe, for "gas station map"? It took a while to realize that mDC made no sense and that motorists (other than those in New Jersey) screw up a GAS CAP. Happy music.
Are the Borg a species, technically?
ReplyDeleteI really liked this, and this isn’t a criticism, but I seemed awfully easy for a Saturday. I kept whooshing, as Rex would say, but also thinking no, this is too easy, it can’t be right… but it almost always was. And there was really something about seeing ANAL connect with the LOWERGI — the latter was an absolutely brilliant clue/answer pair. (For a minute or so, LOzEnGe looked plausible, but it made no sense whatsoever.)
ReplyDeleteWhy didn't I put in VAMPIRES after reading the clue, it's that obvious, I said to myself when I finally got back to the NW. I think I was distracted by the "expanse on a Spanish explorer's map" and wondering whether it would be TIERRA or OCEANO. When it was the latter I stayed in the NE and went around counter clockwise and finally arrive at hey--VAMPIRES! Easy one.
ReplyDeleteI wanted the motorist to screw up folding his MAP but EGOTS to the rescue. Had the T as the last letter in the "stiletto feature" so it was HAFT or hilt. Can't remember the last time I saw a woman in stilettos around here. Probably never. Also wanted UNFLAG briefly, even though I'm very familiar with the EUFLAG .
Boo for MIRY and yay for TOPPS. Liked the cards but the sheet of "gum" always shattered.
BORG??? At least "pipit" sounds like a bird.
Really nice Saturday, SE. Simply Excellent. If you're looking for another word that should be accepted in SB (hi @Wanderlust). I'm submitting INTROIT. Thanks for all the fun.
@pabloinnh 8:28 AM - You did not put in VAMPIRES because, as others have pointed out, there were too many ?'s, and some of them were misleading. With no "?" I prolly woulda thought VAMPIRES right off. The "?" made me look too far afield, like "chiggers" or "ticks" or something a bit more wry than VAMPIRES.
DeleteMy hat's off to all of you who rated this as EASY. For me it was CHALLENGING - 42 minutes! But I liked it a lot. Time well spent going back and forth from ACROSS to DOWN and back again. Letter here, another one there. January 1 clue was AIL, then NOD, then NAG, then NAP. FARRO, MENTOR etc, etc. Tough one.
ReplyDeleteThere is a singer named Ciara who's had several big hits.
ReplyDeleteI don't share Rex's love for LOWER GI, which seems like it's missing a noun at the end the way it is clued (and Rex wrote "LOWER GI tract" when he talked about it).
The clue did say familiar y.
DeleteI had BUYNOW instead of ACTNOW at first, which was my only hiccup for what was a very easy Saturday.
ReplyDeleteI'm flattered that the constructor thinks I know all of NAS's discography, but it was an easy inference.
All in all a smooth puz w/ delightful fill.
And just a remark re: yesterday's puz - - - - YAS QUEEN feels so immediately dated that if someone were to go through the archive say ten years down the road and attempt the 2/10/23 puzzle, I think that answer would totally stump them. Otherwise, I really liked yesterday.
The number of performers who have accomplished the EGOT is now so large that it's no longer much of a distinction. As in, who are they and WTF should I care?
ReplyDeleteOtherwise, decent enough Saturday puzz. Blew through the top easily enough, entering 8A with absolutely no crosses. And 1A I suspected but waited until I had a couple crosses. The lower half was crunchier and put up a bit of a fight.
Chewy, fair, fun!
ReplyDeleteI hated this puzzle. I thought there were too many fill in the blank clues and anal is unpleasant and I kept being UNDELIGHTED as often as delighted by the fresh fill. I was very disappointed by my own vibe check of this puzzle...
ReplyDeleteRex has been asking for a tough Saturday for a while now, and in my view (although not his) that’s what we got today. My solve had no “thwaps” or “ftanngs” in it, only “crunch” after “crunch”. Slowest Saturday in a long time. The NW was crazy hard, despite having BIGTENCONFERENCE as my very first entry.
ReplyDeleteBut it was well worth it. The grid itself is AMAZING, and I learned some things (SEOUL’s former name, the term VIBECHECK). Maybe one or two too many “?” clues, but the MENTOR clue is fantastic, mostly because I didn’t think of it as a verb. Even with things like VIBECHECK, the puzzle has a formal, establishment-y VIBE (CIA, FBI, CDC, PHARMA, ISAY, I PRESUME, TOBEFRANK) which seemed to be apt.
Alternative clue: Star of Mayberry, UFO*
ReplyDeleteAnswer below
Lost my modest streak by failing to notice the plurals (!) in the "Spirits that come in bottles" clue. Figured SeMP was an alternative spelling. So weak on my part.
Answer:
ANDY ET
Only real trouble I ran into was the last word in CIA WORLD FACT BOOK, which finally opened up those longer downs in the southeast.
ReplyDeleteHave to say - I reject SLAYING IT. That’s not in the language. No one says the “IT.”
Can someone please explain the plural of genie as GENII for me?
Sam Ross @9:40. I think comedians often tell people that they were SLAYING IT last night.
DeleteHODGES was a gimme cause that's my ex husband and my kid's last names. I sent it to my son and said you finally made the NYT puzzle. You tend to notice that kind of thing and the case decider was the legality of gay marriage. Often just called Obergefell.
ReplyDeleteI never saw HAFT before , a new crosswordese for my list. I was stuck at SOFT ARMOR forever. I had ports for POSTS as PORTS are stations too, like a USB port. Had CSI too so that whole area went last. AH CHOO I worked it out just under an hour!
Checks Vibe= happy about the puzzle, unhappy about all the CrapLoad of chores that await me today.
Great Saturday workout! I liked the dupe ""Ah" follower" clues. ISEE/ISAY managed not to be KEALOAs as clued. Train as a verb with workers was devilish - I plugged in an "s" at the end, which blocked that until the end.
ReplyDelete@Wanderlust, I'm with your side-eye for an EGOT including an audiobook, and also giving Viola a pass. There has to be some kind of crossover to get all 4. Composers seem like they might have an EGOT chance without working outside their usual metier. Singing actress seems to be a large percentage of the list also.
Anybody else get thrown by putting in GORN - a true Star Trek species - rather than Borg (not really a species)?
ReplyDeleteExcellent Saturday puzzle, even if it took the wind out of my solving skills a bit. SOFT ARMOR left me drifting in the OCEANO. AND YET, it all turned out (O)K. We started out with VAMPIRES and ended with SKYLARKS. Sweet.
ReplyDelete....BTW, is anyone else stunned that Rex does the puzzle AND writes the blog BEFORE coffee?
Hey All !
ReplyDeleteIPRESUMEd that something was amiss with my IdasSUME. As in I'D ASSUME. Hmm, says I, is Pluto a PsTar now? Why won't it fit? Erased the Idas part, said, Hey, maybe I PRESUME?, saw the MR emerge, and said, Could that be MR GOOBAR? And it was! Then saw PETDOG, and all was right with that corner. Although, MR GOODBAR is not really a straight-up Snickers alternative. But clue technically correct, as it didn't say substitution. Hey, chocolate and peanuts is chocolate and peanuts! Nougat, schmougat.
In SE, had PlAsMA/liFT in for a while. Thinking, How does PlAsMA fit the clue? People trading their blood for drugs? (Desperate times for some...) Saw SOFTiRMOR, said, That can't be right, unless it's a corporate name thingie, like ©Leggs. Erased the A I had in 60A, making the Web master clue end in IDEA MAN (har!), saw PHARMA, changed the I to an A to get SOFT ARMOR, and hoped that HAFT was correct.
Last section was that tough SW. Dang. For NAP, wanted RECOVER FROM A HANGOVER. 😁 The ANAL/ASST/SPAWN trifecta was my hold up. Last letter in was the A of ANAL/ASST cross, said, What else could it be?, Threw it in, and Happy Music! WooHoo! First pumped the air.
So a good SatPuz brain workout. Saw the 16-wideness. At least this has a reason for it. Keep seeing POST MALONE when looking at PSALMONE.
Time to get my MIRY HAFT outta here.
Six F's (SLAYING IT)
RooMonster
DarrinV
Once I gave up on "Mounds bar" and thought of Mr. Goodbar, and once I realized "I'd assume" was I presume, that NW corner fell into place and the puzzle was done. Very enjoyable and slightly easy for a Saturday. Can't imagine anyone saying they hated it when it there was verylittle to complain about.
ReplyDeletePlease tell me...would you consider me a cheater if I check my (correct) answers? It's like making your first soufflé and opening the oven to see if it's cooked. The soufflé doesn't deflate and it tastes delicious. Like @Rex, I was whooshing. It scared me; I was so sure my answers would be wrong. Saturdays do that to me....My ANAL, ANGST, AGITA meter tends to go off. Today, my happy feet were happy. I was happy, too.
ReplyDeleteVAMPIRE and TOBAGO..whoosh. The whole top tier slid in like warm butter slathered on my toasted olive bread. I was afraid this would be over too soon; I didn't want the joy to end. Ah...here come the unknowns...take your time....go dance elsewhere...think outside the box (here's looking at you HAFT)...
Yes...I spent way too much time with HAFT. You might've thought HEEL but I thought HEFT. Heft as in lifting you to soaring and uncomfortable heights? Nah. SOFTER something or other wasn't working.
Move on....I did. I had a few holes here and there. Wimp instead of SIMP. I thought an unlikely trait for a beekeeper might be allergies. Crossing words to the rescue. Had trouble with CIA WORLD FACT BOOK...thank you easy downs. And so it went.
Take you time. Get up and move around....drink your coffee...smile....make sure your answers are really right..pretend you didn't do that....crow at the end. I did.
Sam and I CLICK when needed. He is much younger than I but I like what he does with words. He down't make it impossible to figure out the unknowns. After yesterday's disaster, this was wonderful....
Because I was in the ORAL stage rather than the ANAL stage, I DNFed. Now admittedly I thought of the ANAL stage too before writing in ORAL, but ORAL went so beautifully with RUE for what you do on January 1. Of course you can NAP first and then RUE. Or vice-versa.
ReplyDeleteORAL makes it impossible to solve the SW corner. You try to find a country with the letter combo ?UM?A that says "talofa" or anything else. Only after cheating on SAMOA did I get ASST and SPAWN. LOWERGI is a DOOK.
PET DOG for Pluto is a little Green Paint-y, don't you think? He was So Much More than that.
Who knew that the CIA had a WORLD FACT BOOK? My, my.
SOFT ARMOR doesn't sound all that "lightweight" to me. I think I prefer my nylon shell windbreaker for "lightweight protection".
I had UN FLAG before EU FLAG and HEEL before HAFT -- but those were my easiest to correct writeovers.
A really, really hard themeless. I mean really, REALLY hard! Congrats, Sam, on making me "suffer" a lot today.
It took over two hours, but I finally tamed this beast without cheating. I think "easy-medium" is too passive. "Typical Saturday" would be my description.
ReplyDeleteI had PORTS instead of POSTS for "stations," so it took a long time to figure out SOFTARMOR, which I've never heard of anyway. And LOWERGI for "colon's place" is a devilish clue and a phrase used by medical professionals, not the public (thus a bit unfair).
"Train workers" for MENTOR is another clever clue, but misleading in that mentoring isn't limited to workers. You can mentor a student, for example, or your own child for that matter. "Train people" would be just as clever, and much fairer.
Rex,
ReplyDeleteCould you occasionally post a cat photo on Mastodon so that we know they are still alive? (How is Alfie, BTW?)
Some of us are never going to go back to the Muskrat's bird site.
Thanks you.
Easy-medium. VAMPIRES went in with no crosses. hEwn before FELL and Heel (hi @Rex) before HAFT were it for erasures and HODGES was my only WOE. Smooth, solid, and a fun solve, liked it a bunch!
ReplyDeleteMaybe it’s a regional thing, but I screw on/off a GASCAP, not “screw up”, tho I feel ok about “screw down”.🤷🏼♀️ I get the misdirection, just don’t think “screw up” is in the lingo for that particular action. Agree with many others that a MR.GOODBAR is no substitute for a Snickers- gimme my nougat & caramel!
ReplyDeleteWhile he may be flawed as the SB editor SE can make a decent themeless puzzle. This one was like momma bear's bed, not too hard and not too soft just nice steady Saturday level solving throughout. Speaking of LEVEL I did try to make TOBELEVEL work in that SE corner thanks to my HILT/HAFT write over. That's about as close as it came to a big problem in filling the grid. Getting 60A off of ZED cleared that up.
ReplyDelete@Wanderlust, count me in as one of the solvers who's been waiting to see if this constructor would have the nerve to use any of the words he leaves off of his SB lists. Kudos on remembering MIDDEN. The shunned words I can think of offhand are things like TURGOR, FAIN and ATLATYL. Given these are odd words but don't most puzzle people love their odd words. It's really the randomness that gets under my skin. He largely eschews the Scrabble. Dict. words but then how do you account for the inclusion of PALAPA. The only words of SB note that I noticed today were GENII and FARRO both of which the SB has thoroughly beaten into my head.
@dgd, thanks for the shout out yesterday. I did used to be a regular here but now I've cut back to just being a weekend warrior.
Speaking of SB...
Sun -0, Mon pg-1,Tu + Wed -0, Fri pg-1, Sat -0
I get that, like Raymond, "Everybody Loves Ezersky." But as I am more of an interloper here than a true believer, I will say that his cluing (again, much beloved by the devoted) is often obtuse, misleading, or worse. EBB does not mean "go back"; "recede," yes, but "go back" and "recede" are not the same thing. In a similar vein, AVENGE does not mean "get recompense for." To get recompense mean to be paid what you are owed. That is different than exacting vengeance. "Requite" or "Exact satisfaction," yes. And, worse of all, "induce" does not mean SPAWN. You can induce labor, but you cannot SPAWN labor. You can SPAWN progeny, but you cannot "induce" progeny. Now on to a different type of problematic clue: Motorists rarely "screw up" a GAS CAP, but they do often "screw on" a GAS CAP—but of course, that would not have resulted in a pun (or whatever you want to call it)...but the pun is worthless if its is not an apt clue for the entry. In my life I have been both a "prof." and an "ed.", and yet I found ASST hard to swallow as the entry for that clue—It's just not something that clicks, emoige (Ancient Greek for "to me at least"). And then his use of words like "famously" and "familiarly" for things that are neither famous nor familiar, vel sim. For example, 4D, PLUTO, is, yes, a pet dog, but...famously? I don't think that's how that crossword clue technique works. Similarly for 63A, LOWER GI, which is, yes, the colon's place, but again, "familiarly?" How many people do you know who go around saying, "Geez, I got such a pain in my lower GI"??? Then there is 33D, "Org. with guidelines." My first thought was AMA, my next thought was "I mean, like, don't virtually all organizations have guidelines?" And therein lies the problem with The Great Ezersky's cluing. What is "famous" about Pluto is that first it was a planet, then it wasn't, then it was again. So a good clue might have been, "Heavenly body famously demoted in 2006." You need to know how the language works. Again, I know he is a god among crossword constructors, but my reaction remains, familiarly if not famously, MEH.
ReplyDelete"One mark of the handful of upper-echelon constructors is that you can tell who it’s by even without seeing the name on top." --@Lewis
ReplyDeleteNope. I can't do that, Lewis. I can't even come close. I'll know that it's "one of the good ones", that it's "one of the ones I like", but that's about all. I find it quite AMAZING that you can do that.
A 73-worder themeless. But it's usin a 16x15 puzgrid, sooo … ok.
ReplyDeleteStuff that really helped preserve the precious M&A solvequest nanoseconds:
* VAMPIRES - Opened up that big old NW corner rodeo with a Ftung.
* BIGTENCONFERENCE - Near gimme, especially with a coupla letters already in place.
* AMAZINGSPIDERMAN - Also nailed this grid spanner PDQ. Had a chance to purchase Spiderman #1 comic, when it first came out. But I was actually kinda turned off, cuz I had been a big fan of the Amazing Stories comics that it suddenly replaced. I was therefore a teenager in mournin. But I digress.
* "Ah" followers CHOO and ISEE. Definite runtpuz theme potential...
* Friendly-ish ?-marker clues, especially {Razor name?} = OCCAM.
* The BORG.
* BOGOTA anagram minipuz fun.
Stuff that gobbled up precious nanoseconds pronto:
* FARRO. Debut word of mystery.
* ECOTECH. Sort inferrable, but needed most of the letters.
* VIBECHECK. Induced a saywhatcheck.
* CIAWORLDFACTBOOK. Don't sound real familiar. WORLD musta been replaced with ALTERNATE, durin the Trump Admin.
staff weeject pick: STS. Cute clue, for a hohum plural abbreve runt.
Thanx for the challenge, Mr. Sam-EZ dude. Lotsa great fillins! Surely that CIA thingy wasn't yer seed entry, tho ...?
Masked & Anonymo3Us
slight bite alert:
**gruntz**
Hard but hey it’s Saturday also skewed young I’m 70 do challenged
ReplyDeleteDesperately sad moment when ANAL crosses LOWER GI crosses MIRY {shakes head}, but outside of that tragedy I enjoyed this. And it's really not a tragedy, but more evidence the NYTXW editorial staff is dedicated to ARSE-ifying our daily existence. As if Tumblr isn't enough. Constructors, please add "must include bottom" to your list of submission requirements.
ReplyDeleteYou drop vampires and bee keepers on me right off the bat and I am all yours. AH CHOO is never not gonna be hilarious to me. So many other great phrases. Just loved 'em.
GENII is horrible and that little section is easily rewritten, so why??
Never heard of the CIA World Fact Book. It's probably something I am paying for without knowing it.
@Barbara and @Nancy
I was in late last yesterday, so thank you both for the uniclue convention last night. Always so much fun. Talking tea leaves, the inner voice of a canary, and a portapotty with an attitude. What's not to love?
Uniclues:
1 Caribbean blood suckers.
2 Why Texas had that power outage according to a pro-gas-industry politician.
3 Just going to leave this buried in the middle here.
4 Fear of Polynesian pricks.
5 Quote from one witnessing a celebrity meltdown as they heave their copious awards into a marshy bog.
6 {Hahahahahaha!}
7 Teenager doing the dishes.
8 ... after all, one needs some chemical help dealing with all these losers.
9 Neons.
1 TOBAGO VAMPIRES (~)
2 ECOTECH, I PRESUME
3 ANAL VIBE CHECK (~)
4 SAMOA APIPHOBIA
5 I SEE MIRY EGOTS (~)
6 EMCEE SLAYING IT
7 TEFLON PAN ARISK
8 SNOB ATE PHARMA (~)
9 HEMP SKIN TONES
Uniclues:
ReplyDelete1) Words from the Bible that you feel deep in your gut
2) The washed-out, sickly look
3) Admitting you're very, very rigid
4) Thick lampshades?
5) I know it's real heavy, but choose cast iron, OK?
1) LOWER GI PSALM ONE
2) HEMP SKINTONES
3) VIBECHECK ANAL
4) GENII SOFT ARMOR
5) TEFLON PAN A RISK
FYI…It’s NIGHTS IN WHITE SATIN (not KNIGHTS). It refers to sleeping at night in satin sheets.
ReplyDeleteThere once was a crossword editor
ReplyDeleteWho needed to beat his competitor
He put in some ass
And showed the top brass
They said, "Doo it doo it you butt-end repetitor."
As the keeper of the NYT Spelling Bee, it was quite appropriate that Sam included APIPHOBIA ("Unlikely trait for a beekeeper") in his puzzle today. There was also an entry at 47-A, TOP TEN, that would have qualified as an answer in today's Bee if it was one word.
ReplyDeleteKinda MEH actually. A few gems, a few lumps of coal, and ordinary fill.
ReplyDelete@Mike in Bed-Stuy 11:13. "MEH" was my thought as well. Thank you for taking the time to describe the faults in this puzzle.
ReplyDeleteSIMP is problematic manosphere verbiage. There were quite a few near alt right entries in this one: military, religion, toxic masculinity. Only vaguely shielded by the gay marriage case.
ReplyDeleteIf you didn’t like 29D, your reaction perhaps was UPTWO no good.
ReplyDeleteThe full name is now BIGTENandlittlefourCONFERENCE. Or perhaps they’ve taken to using base 14 as their counting system.
I’m sure that someone will do a nice uniclue today on VIBECHECK ANAL.
Nice puzzle. Easy for a Saturday. Thanks, Sam.
@Mike in Bed-Stuy (10:s47)- You know, I think you're on to something there.
ReplyDeleteI thought I was headed for a PB when I cleared the top half of the grid in two minutes flat, but then I made a lot of mistakes that slowed me down significantly. Started with OCEANs, not realizing the "Spanish" in the clue was looking for an O on the end. That led to me thinking 28A, "Article go-with", was NSFW. Not that kind of article, it turns out. Spent too long wondering what f__WO (29D) could possibly be. And if you have a clue that says "Stiletto feature" and it's not "heel", you're just being mean. And I automatically assumed CSI at 44A instead of FBI. What can I say? I'm a simple man. I see CBS, I see spinoff, I see three letters, I put CSI. Devious trick, that one. I still came in well below my Saturday average in the end after forcing some things I knew had to be right (SKIN TONES, SOFT ARMOR) helped me untangle my knots, but not by as much as I could have been.
ReplyDeleteI'm largely in agreement with Mike in Bed-Stuy @ 11:13. Many of these clues were tough because they were tweaked in such a way that they don't precisely mean what their answers indicate, which doesn't feel like totally fair play. Laughed a lot when I agreed with his point about 33D; the clue might as well have said "Abbr. with letters". He did start tripping over his own feet during his Pluto rant though, to where it seems like he's saying Pluto was the answer to 4D rather than PET DOG. What I think he meant was that a good clue would have been "Pluto, for one". I'm not ready to render my own verdict on Ezersky's grid-building yet, but all Mike's points are solid.
Anagrams (9A) and letters clued as wordplay (61D) need to end. If I ever construct a puzzle, I promise the only way it will have those is if editorial intervention strikes.
Agree with others that the Borg are not a species. They are a collective. But that's the kind of thing my brain elides for the sake of getting a puzzle done quick. You see Star Trek in the clue, you see B___, you throw down BORG, you move on.
GENII clued as "Spirits found in bottles" is truly execrable. I mean, I get the punny misdirect, but that's not how the -ii plural works. In my experience, GEN II represents the Johto era of Pokémon, but that would be way too niche for most NYT solvers.
You're either killing it or you're slaying. You're never SLAYING IT.
Ezersky seems like a modern enough dude to know that SIMP as clued isn't often used in that sense anymore. Not sure its meaning in modern parlance would get it into a grid, though.
Tons of great answers, and that NW corner is a thing of beauty. If Jeff Chen gave Corners of the Week (COWs?), I'd say that one got it. But there was also plenty here to earn a potent stink-eye. It worked out to pretty good in the end though.
Do more people NAP on Jan 1 than the average day? I dunno, I knew 49D was either ORAL or ANAL, and I had SPAWN in 51D, so I figured of all the N_P or R_P possibilities, NAP was the likeliest, but it still strikes me as a very weak clue. I dunno that, as an adult, I've ever napped on NYD, and I really don't think it's a thing most people do.
ReplyDeleteThe idea I think is that many people stay up (sometimes very) late and/or drink too much on New Years Eve so need a nap on the 1st. At 70 I have long since stopped doing that but what I do is irrelevant. The clue works for me.
DeleteVery hard for me, so I feel good to have solved it clean. But it wasn't enjoyable. Too many clues were just on the edge of legitimacy. GASCAP. KARAT. NAP. MENTOR. PSALMONE. SPAWN. AVENGE. GENII. No joy in getting them. Just "Oh, I guess that works."
ReplyDeleteI thought this was pretty challenging and almost DNFed because I didn't know miry was a word. Know the noun, don't like the adjective. I guess it's legit, but it seems like a word that's never been said aloud. Otherwise I enjoyed it. I guess maybe I learned a new word, but not one that I like.
ReplyDeleteI think “THWIP” is the most common onomatopoeia for Spidey, coined by Ditko, popularized by Romita, and trademarked by Marvel. Other favorites include “BAMF” for Nightcrawler teleporting, “SNIKT” for Wolverine’s claws popping, and anything bass-y and rumble-y for Thor, like “KRAKA-DOOM!”
ReplyDeletePrecise usage is critical in a lexicographer’s workshop, but in Crossworld language usage’s functionality seems more appropriately in the horseshoes and hand grenades bracket. I’m recalling @LMS postings past where she in her patient teacher mode differentiates between prescribing and describing language as respective possibilities. Language changes; at times I wish it weren’t so…but often it ain’t! This SIMP is appreciative of those posters who MENTOR me, but Sam’s loosey-goosey clueing makes my Saturday filled with sunshine!
ReplyDeleteHaving BIG TEN CONFERENCE led me to put stIng fear in at 2down for my first OCÉANO of error 😣 slightly SSW of the Bermuda Triangle. That made arriving back at APIPHOBIA a circuitous journey across the oversized grid.
No whooshing for me on this one! Friday's I enjoyed, this not so much. On Friday, finally getting an answer was usually "Oh, nice!" Today, it was more like "WAIT, what?" Some college sports conference (ick), VIBE CHECK (what?), MR GOODBAR (really?). Just a wheelhouse thing, I guess, except for AMAZING SPIDERMAN.
ReplyDeleteTypeover: ALLERGIES before APIPHOBIA. And of course HEEL before HAFT.
[Spelling Bee: Fri 0, last word this silly 4er.]
I detect some personal bias by Rex here. This was an attempted young person's puzzle (VIBECHECK??), with lots of zeitgeist and some niche knowlege. And some ugly crosswordese: GENII, MIRY. Still don't know how "STS" is sides of a square.
ReplyDeleteYou could read the write-up
DeleteRazor name? OCCAM.
ReplyDeleteCan someone explain?
Google Occam's Razor
DeleteGorgeous Saturday puzzle. Solved quickly, but for some reason the question mark on "Train workers?" didn't register and I could not look sideways to fathom Train as a verb. Thus MENTOR went in, but made *no* sense to me. Wish I been able to figured it out on my own before reading the posts ("cheating"), but was still a great aha moment to see an explanation. 24A "Get in trouble, perhaps" ==> TELLON was delightfully sublime.
ReplyDeleteInteresting how Great Lakes States and BIGTENCONFERENCE have the same number of letters. Fortunately, I work in pencil so my confident first entry was easily removed.
ReplyDelete@Anonymous 1:21 — STS as in "streets" which can be sides of a (town) square
ReplyDelete@CZ @ 1:40 — Occam's Razor is a maxim that states that the best solution to a problem tends to be the simplest.
@chip hilton@2:33- I think they would more commonly be known as GREAT LAKE STATES
ReplyDeleteSo glad to see that one of our neighborhood here whose posts I enjoy and revere, @Lewis, has the same reaction to a Sam Ezersky as I do. And as always, I had to work for it today, but I got there. After yesterday’s easy breezy Friday, I suspected that today might be trouble.
ReplyDeleteI’ve said before that I really enjoy seeing how different our solving experiences can vary so widely. For me, today’s NW was brutal. Some of it might be my very real Ezerskyphobia. I see Sam’s byline and my brain freezes for a while.
Sam is a super-constructor. Clever, intelligent puzzles that make me really work for it, test my chops and teach me something nee every time. This one did not disappoint. But it took me a good while to get started.
Sure, VAMPIRES lured me in and made me hopeful. Followed ny a huge nothing burger! Got HODGES at least but still zip in addition.
Got some whoosh whoosh going . Over in the NE with TOBAGO and had enough to get the east side put together and worked my way around counter clockwise. Loved almost all of this one, but gotta be honest, didn’t care for GENII. It felt like the last little but that the editors wanted to tweak and couldn’t come up with a better idea. No matter because it dod not dampen my enthusiasm for my otherwise totally enjoyable but tough solve. Loved seeing my favorite BIG TEN CONFERENCE.
Badly clued in so many ways. I'm a medical professional, and I can assure you that no ordinary person refers to their colon familiarly as their "lower GI"! DUH!
ReplyDeleteAlso, there is no sane or acceptable explanation for "miry" as an answer - not now, not ever, not even in an alternate universe.
"Vibecheck" must be some super-cool lingo used by super-cool people. I've never heard that until today, AND I intend to forget it immediately, b/c IMO it has no value, not *even* as crossword fill.
A couple of responses:
ReplyDeleteI can't say that I've heard the expression "slaying" without "it"! It's usually been established what the speaker is talking about before saying "He/She is slaying it" - "He/She slayed it" E.g., she gave her presentation to the board and really slayed it!
How many times did we say or hear "I'm telling on you!" during childhood? Biggest threat ever!
Anonymous at 3:11 PM said "You could read the write-up." I often see this one sentence comment from an Anonymous and I'm thinking it's probably the same person. My question to you is why be so snarky? A lot of us don't mind answering other commenters' questions. As Thumper (of "Bambi" fame) wisely said, ""If you can't say something nice, don't say nothin' at all."
I hated it. Solved it. But only after many moments of rage SPAWNED by the oh-so-clever cluing and the overuse of acronyms and abbreviations designed to frustrate the solver.
ReplyDeleteISEE, ISAY
ReplyDeleteThat BIG CIAWORLDFACTBOOK
is AMAZING if you CHECK how
the TOPTEN E.U. members look,
AND how we PRESUME they ACTNOW.
--- MR. FRANK HODGES, FBI
Not exactly a perfect solve for me.
ReplyDeleteBUT...I was pretty proud of a few of the answers that I DID get. AMAZINGSPIDERMAN and VIBECHECK among them.
Diana, Lady-in-Waiting for Crosswords
remember - don't forget your GASCAP
A sad commentary on U of MN basketball when they can't finish in the TOPTEN of the BIGTENCONFERENCE. They used to go to the big dance.
ReplyDeleteAfter 288 attempts (4 tournaments), the Wordle golf score would be 32 under par, counting the 3 DNFs as triple bogeys.
A medium Saturday for me. Wasn't liking ECOTECH: a prefix + a suffix. Also had trouble with my Bible ignorance; had Proverbs which fit nicely. Much ink blotting there, including hand up for Heel before HAFT. What is SOFTARMOR if not an oxymoron? Got it all sorted out though, eventually. Nice, roomy grid. Birdie.
ReplyDeleteWordle par.
Miry clay is a term from the psalms.
ReplyDeleteI've sat on the shores of Lake Michigan and watched the water GO BACK. I believe they call it an ebb tide