Scenic stroll from the Spanish / SUN 1-8-23 / 2007 Lil Wayne song that opens Young Money! You dig? / Hindu goddess in the Ramayana / Serpentine constellation / Fragrant noodle soup made with beef / Human rights activist Xiaobo the first Chinese citizen to be awarded the Nobel Peace Prize 2010 / Influential leader of the Seminole people
Constructor: Wyna Liu
Relative difficulty: Medium (theme was easy to uncover, but fill was often thorny)
THEME: "Do You Hear That?" — My puzzle came with notes: "Note: Each italicized clue contains a blank, which should be filled with a letter of the alphabet. When completed, the letters in order will spell out a two-word phrase." Every theme clue is a phonetic rebus puzzle, where one single-letter element is missing; the letters end up spelling out "SOUNDS GOOD" (presumably an answer to the puzzle's title question) (?):
Word of the Day: OSCEOLA (57D: Influential leader of the Seminole people) —
Osceola (1804 – January 30, 1838, Asi-yahola in Creek), named Billy Powell at birth in Alabama, became an influential leader of the Seminole people in Florida. His mother was Muscogee, and his great-grandfather was a Scotsman, James McQueen. He was reared by his mother in the Creek (Muscogee) tradition. When he was a child, they migrated to Florida with other Red Stick refugees, led by a relative, Peter McQueen, after their group's defeat in 1814 in the Creek Wars. There they became part of what was known as the Seminole people.
In 1836, Osceola led a small group of warriors in the Seminole resistance during the Second Seminole War, when the United States tried to remove the tribe from their lands in Florida to Indian Territory west of the Mississippi River. He became an adviser to Micanopy, the principal chief of the Seminole from 1825 to 1849. Osceola led the Seminole resistance to removal until he was captured on October 21, 1837, by deception, under a flag of truce, when he went to a site near Fort Peyton for peace talks. The United States first imprisoned him at Fort Marion in St. Augustine, then transported him to Fort Moultrie in Charleston, South Carolina. He died there a few months later of causes reported as an internal infection or malaria. Because of his renown, Osceola attracted visitors in prison, including renowned artist George Catlin, who painted perhaps the most well-known portrait of the Seminole leader.
• • •
***HELLO, READERS AND FELLOW SOLVERS IN SYNDICATION*** (if it's mid-January 2023, that's you!) How is the new year treating you? Well, I hope. Me, uh, not great so far (COVID, you know), but I'm 95% better, and was never terribly sick to begin with, so I have every reason to believe things will turn around for me shortly, thank God (and vaccines). Anyway, it's early January, which means it's time once again for my annual week-long pitch for financial contributions to the blog. Every year I ask readers to consider what the blog is worth to them on an annual basis and give accordingly. I'm not sure what to say about this past year. This will sound weird, or melodramatic—or maybe it won't—but every time I try to write about 2022, all I can think is "well, my cat died." She (Olive) died this past October, very young, of a stupid congenital heart problem that we just couldn't fix (thank you all for your kind words of condolence, by the way). I'm looking at the photo I used for last year's fundraising pitch, and it's a picture of me sitting at my desk (this desk, the one I'm typing at right now, the one I write at every day) with Olive sitting on my shoulder, staring at me, and making me laugh. It's a joyous picture. Here, I'm just gonna post it again:
I love the photo both because you can tell how goofy she is, and how goofy she made me. Her loss hurt for the obvious reasons, but also because she was so much a part of my daily routine, my daily rhythms and rituals. She was everyday. Quotidian. Just ... on me, near me, being a weirdo, especially in the (very) early mornings when I was writing this blog. She took me out of myself. She also made me aware of how much the quotidian matters, how daily rituals break up and organize the day, mark time, ground you. They're easy to trivialize, these rituals, precisely because they *aren't* special. Feed the cats again, make the coffee again, solve the crossword again, etc. But losing Olive made me reevaluate the daily, the quotidian, the apparently trivial. In a fundamental way, those small daily things *are* life. No one day is so important, or so different from the others, but cumulatively, they add up, and through the days upon days you develop a practice—a practice of love, care, and attention given to the things that matter. If you're reading this, then crossword puzzles are undoubtedly an important ritual for you, just as writing about crosswords for you all is an important ritual for me. It gives me so much. I hope that even at my most critical, my genuine love for crosswords—for the way my brain lights up on crosswords—comes through. I also hope that the blog brings you entertainment, insight, laughter ... even (especially) if you disagree with me much (most? all?) of the time.
[man, I really wear the hell out of this red fleece...]
The blog began years ago as an experiment in treating the ephemeral—the here-today, gone-tomorrow—like it really mattered. I wanted to stop and look at this 15x15 (or 21x21 thing) and take it seriously, listen to it, see what it was trying to do, think about what I liked or didn't like about it. In short, I gave the puzzle my time and attention. And I continue to do that, every day (Every! Day!). And it is work. A lot of work. Asking for money once a year (and only once a year) is an acknowledgment of that fact. There is nothing to subscribe to here ... no Substack or Kickstarter or Patreon ... and there are no ads, ever. I prefer to keep financial matters simple and direct. I have no "hustle" in me beyond putting my ass in this chair every morning and writing.
How much should you give? Whatever you think the blog is worth to you on a yearly basis. Whatever that amount is is fantastic. Some people refuse to pay for what they can get for free. Others just don't have money to spare. All are welcome to read the blog—the site will always be open and free. But if you are able to express your appreciation monetarily, here are three options. First, a Paypal button (which you can also find in the blog sidebar):
Second, a mailing address (checks should be made out to "Rex Parker"):
Rex Parker c/o Michael Sharp
54 Matthews St
Binghamton, NY 13905
The third, increasingly popular option is Venmo; if that's your preferred way of moving money around, my handle is @MichaelDavidSharp (the last four digits of my phone are 4878, in case Venmo asks you, which I guess it does sometimes, when it's not trying to push crypto on you, what the hell?!)
All Paypal contributions will be gratefully acknowledged by email. All snail mail contributions will be gratefully acknowledged with hand-written postcards. I. Love. Snail Mail. I love seeing your gorgeous handwriting and then sending you my awful handwriting. It's all so wonderful. My daughter (Ella Egan) has designed a cat-related thank-you postcard for 2023, just as she has for the past two years, but this year, there's a bonus. Because this year ... the postcard is also a crossword puzzle! Yes, I made a little 9x9 blog-themed crossword puzzle for you all. It's light and goofy and I hope you enjoy it. It looks like this (clues blurred for your protection):
I had fun making this puzzle (thanks to Rachel Fabi and Neville Fogarty for proofing it for me!). For non-snail-mailers who want to solve the puzzle, don't worry: I'll make the puzzle available for everyone some time next month. Please note: I don't keep a "mailing list" and don't share my contributor info with anyone. And if you give by snail mail and (for some reason) don't want a thank-you card, just indicate "NO CARD." Again, as ever, I'm so grateful for your readership and support. Now on to today's puzzle...
• • •
This puzzle landed with a PHO! That is, PHO was my last word, so that is where the puzzle ... landed. I ate PHO this past week when I was feeling my COVID-worst, and I'm not going to say it cured me, because it definitely did not, but it made me feel much better. I mostly just drank the broth, with a little of the accompanying hot sauce added, and if it wasn't magic, it sure felt like it. Speaking of magic—this puzzle feels a bit like a magic trick, the way multi-layered puzzles often can. It was an interesting puzzle to solve (as I did) immediately after watching "Glass Onion" (2022), which opens with an elaborate, multi-layered puzzle—perhaps not surprising for a puzzle that has an onion as its central (titular!) metaphor. Layers! The layers in this puzzle were fun to work through, though "work" feels like a bit of misnomer, in that I just smashed through them as soon as the concept became clear (the way one of the characters in "Glass Onion" just smashes her intricate puzzle box to get what's inside rather than work through all the ... layers). Since I read the "Puzzle Notes" that came with the puzzle, I could tell after one or two themers what was going on, and so I took the ball and I ran with it, running through alllll of the remaining theme answers without even having to look at the crosses—except AUTOFILL! I knew that the "O" went in the clue's blank, but I just could not think of a word that ended "O'Fill," which I kept hearing Irishly. So I had to really work that area to make AUTOFILL show up. But as you can see, I absolutely flattened all the others:
[CANDY DANE is a typo, obvs]
You'll recall (maybe) that last week's Sunday puzzle was a lot like this, in that once I had the puzzly key to figuring out the remaining themers, I stopped solving systematically and just went at all the themers directly, bam bam bam. It gives you a bit of a rush to solve this way, to run the table the second you have the power, but it does leave you in a kind of anticlimactic position thereafter, with the theme all wrung out and just a lot of empty space to fill in. Thankfully, the grid itself is interesting and lively, beyond the theme. The clues were prickly at times, too, so I never felt too bored or too complacent. Things got a little dicey in the OSCEOLA section (partially because of my "CANDY DANE" typo, partially because I honestly don't really know who OSCEOLA is) and again in the ASIANA / PASEO region (I know both terms ... but only kinda sorta). Did not know the "Ghostbusters" car was called the ECTOMOBILE. And forgot that Lil Wayne's song was called "A MILLI"—I always hear it as "I'M ILLI"... like ... ILLI being some version of "ill" ... sigh. Luckily HASP was unimpeachable and then my dumb brain realized that "A MILLI" is (probably) short for "a million." Fun with words (15 years late)!
The "answer" phrase today—"SOUNDS GOOD"—is not what I would call spot-on, in that I don't really know how "GOOD" fits in. The way I'm interpreting it is that the puzzle is playing with the common phrase "SOUNDS GOOD" by asking me to mentally repunctuate it; the puzzle title asks me "Do You Hear That?" and I, the solver, mentally reply: "SOUNDS? GOOD!" As in "Oh, we're dealing with sounds? ... cool." Anyway, it's all good (!) enough for me. There really wasn't much that bothered me about this one. Didn't like IOU crossing AE ... IOU (14D: Ambidextrous features?) (note: "Ambidextrous" is a supervocalic, i.e. it contains one of each vowel (no "Y"s)) (note: "supervocalic" is itself a supervocalic). The puzzle probably should've kept "stick" out of the TAE KWON DO clue (107A) since STICK sticks out in the grid like a sore stick (in DIPSTICK) (59A: Insult that's also a measurement device). My favorite mistake was when I first read 61A: "The landlords of New York," e.g. (ASTORS) and tried to play ACTORS ... at the same time I was thinking "well I know there are a lot of them there, but that doesn't feel right..." Best answers of the day for me were the delightfully self-contradicting "YEAH, NO" (96D: "Nice try, but I don't think so"), the onomatopoeic "TAP TAP" (62D: [Is this thing on?]), and the unexpected but perfect negative phrase NO GENTLEMAN (68D: Hardly Mr. Nice Guy). Highest struggle-to-word-length ratio came with "WELP," the clue for which (108D: "Eh, what can you do?!") I completely misread in my head. I read it as confrontational, as if the speaker were speaking to an actual "you" and didn't think "you" were gonna be able to do squat, i.e. "Eh, what can you do, you incompetent boob!?" I was probably meant to hear something more like, "Ah, well, whaddyagonna do?" which is far more the vibe of "WELP?" But the clue is accurate enough, if not crystal clear.
Explainers:
71D: Path covered with diamonds (CARPOOL LANE) — The CARPOOL LANE is often signaled by a diamond, or even called the Diamond Lane
105A: Couple of llamas? (ELLS) — There are a couple of "L"s in "llama." There are also two "A"s in "llama," so I'm not sure it's the best clue, but I guess the "L"s are more truly a couple, in that they are next to each other, and anyway, the clue doesn't say there aren't other couples
41A: Número de "Años de Soledad" in a Gabriel García Márquez novel (CIEN) — CIEN = "100," which is the number of Years of Solitude in the Marquez title
Medium. My experience was sorta the opposite of @Rex. I thought it was mostly easy except for figuring out the theme answers which I didn’t bother doing until I was almost done. However, I did get hung up in the SE corner because KILT took a long time to surface (sari and toga did not work).
I’m hoping that the presence of PRINCESSDI in this puzzle will snap Harry out of his TMI binge, STAT. Did anyone promise you a ROSEGARDEN, lad? Seems like a big, slow train wreck that we can’t get ourselves to turn away from.
Darling, you may speak Ill of my Man Cave, but just steer clear of my GOODEN.
I may not be AUCOURANT, but I don’t think it has a cur (rhymes with Warriors coach Steve Kerr) in it. More like a Coors beer.
I’m against the idea of cleaning up the vomit and feces here. Oh, are EUPHORIC?
Is it ok to have (36A) PHO right on top of more PHO in 44A? Which reminds me, if you’re ever in Tacoma there’s a great Pho King restaurant on MLK Jr. Way.
I liked the theme idea and thought it was well-executed. Fill was interesting too, so overall it was a good Sunday. Thanks, Wyna Liu.
hmmm... finished no errors but longer than usual. I figured if you strung together all the missing sounds it would amount to something but didn't have the time as I was taking down all the Christmas decorations (one of the saddest days of the year). Plus I wasn't prepared to be disappointed with another "Be sure to drink your Ovaltine” moment. Agree with Rex about WELP. what the heck was that?
@Rex, the way in which you note your dislike of IOU crossing AE. . .IOU reminds this fellow English prof of the nod to Irish writer George Russell (who wrote under the pseudonym AE) in _Ulysses_. Stephen Dedalus acknowledges an intellectual debt when he thinks at one point in the Scylla and Charybdis chapter, "AEIOU."
Welp, um I mean WELL (which was my first try for 108 down)... only a few thoughts on the puzzle, but a lot on your writeup, Rex.
Finished with two errors(!!): AMELLI crossing RORI which was a brutal Natick for me never having heard either, and OCCEOLA crossing ACTORS because I know I've seen/heard OCEOLA somewhere. Typeovers: ANGER before ANGST (both emotions!), and as I mentioned WELL before WELP, which I've never heard. CAR POOL LANE was brilliant; that clue, oh my.
As for the writeup: may be a record for length, it takes 12 hits on the Page Down key to cover it! Re your Covid... been there, somehow caught that just before Thanksgiving (mid Oct. here in Canada), despite having little contact with, well, anyone, and being 4x vaxxed (both boosters). I had to miss family get together at the cabin with incredibly warm summer like weather... people going swimming and everything. One really sick day, then just a gradual recovery. So that damned Covid cost me 2 xmases and a thanksgiving... but no one I know died.
And your cat: I am caring for my sister's boyfriend's cat for Feb and March. I went for a pre catsit visit last week, and she is the dopiest slowest moving thing (the cat, not my sister). 18 years old! It will be my first cat in the house since I lost Holly, who was a ball of fire, 14 years ago. Crazy fact: Holly got her name when my younger brother (who is long gone now) commented that the number tattooed in her ear reminded him of Holocaust victims.
I appreciate all your effort Rex.
[Spelling Bee: Sat 0, no oddball words. 4 day QB streak!]
Oops, you're absolutely right about that @daniel and I stand corrected, because I had assumed nothing but RoRI made sense as a name, so.... Not workable after all. I take back my kudos and substitute a big BOOOOOO!
I've been doing these too long, so this was a "meh" for me.
Figured out the theme early enough that I was later able to solve several other themers on that info. So for me that was a rare positive for a themer, as opposed to saying WTF and figuring it out an hour later.
HUGO was major gimme for me because of the amount of SF&F I have read over the years. But AMILLI crossing RIRI was a serious WTF, Ntaick? Possibly because I stopped listening to "pop" music back about 1987 because AM radio started to suck that year.
Rex – beautiful, poignant, insightful thoughts on Life, this blog, the quotidian, Olive. It’s a shame that some here won’t read that. I get that there are people who refuse to pay for what is free – fine – but still. . .
Thanks to your dedication, my horizons, my solving prowess, my circle of friends have grown so much. So many days I don’t have the time or energy to write anything, and I’m sure that’s the case for you, too. This difference is you dig down and deliver despite that. Thank you, thank you, thank you. (Love the picture of you and Olive. I realized that I have an Olive in my life, my son (avatar), whose goofy goofiness takes me out of myself, too.) Anyhoo . . . I’ll Venmo you a small token of my gratitude.
This theme is an absolute delight. I gobbled up sussing out the homophone-deducing exercise and delighted in filling in those extraneous letters. @Joe Dipinto – I briefly played around with this, too and all I got was “vow-taking place + ______ + spurn.” And the missing letter is K. Serendipitously I was watching a THINGY on the January 6 riot at the time. (So that whole southwest was flashing at me: MYTH, NO GENTLEMAN, NON-APOLOGY, BIG SHOTS, DON. . . YEAH, NO.)
Speaking of which – I agree that YEAH NO is terrific. The phrase can do so much semantic work, the main one (for me) being like I totally understand what you’re saying and need you to understand that I’m not misunderstanding before I tell you no.
@okanaganer and @Daniel – that RIRI/AMILLI cross. . . YEAH, NO. Natick all day, man.
So “ambidextrous” has all the vowels? Would it be facetious to say I’ve seen better?
“Steam” ENGINE before SOLAR ENGINE. Bet we’re legion today.
“Intestinal bacterium” – I found out this week that a lot of my students have no idea what the colon is when I added this beaut to my array of posters around my room:
A colon can completely change the meaning of a sentence. For example: *Jane ate her friend’s sandwich. *Jane ate her friend’s colon.
They didn’t get it. Sigh.
SOMAD keeps waving its dookness at me. Like it could be a word for a sleepwalker, amirite?
Wyna Liu – this is one I’ll remember for a long time. Well-done!
I always look for and appreciate your comments Loren. Today I appreciated you acknowledging Rex’s sweet post. Thank you for your contributions to one of those daily rituals that adds up for me.
For me the natick was the m of emer crossing amilli, I’m British so had no idea what FEMA is and the song is just a random string of letters so that letter was Ungettable. Gave up on the puzzle then and came here, and amusing to see lots of people were also naticked on that entry but by the r of riri instead!
I filled the entire puzzle without a clue as to what it was about. My biggest holdup was 3D RIRI, which I ran the vowels for. Had to come here for the theme explanation!
I picked up on the theme relatively quickly (soundalike syllables with a missing sound) but completely forgot to go back at the end and see what the missing words/letters said!!!!
I liked this. I thought it was fun and clever. The Western half fell quickly for me but the Eastern half took three times as long. Having SARI for KILT and having no idea what a SOLAR ENGINE is didn't help, but mostly I think the themers in the Eastern half just weren't clicking for me.
Not a fan of Lil Wayne, or his song A Milli, especially the part where he talks about “popping the cops”:
Sister, brother, son, daughter, father, mother-fuck a copper Got the Maserati dancing on the bridge, pussy popping Tell the coppers ha-ha-ha-ha, you can't catch 'em, you can't stop 'em I go by them goon rules, if you can't beat 'em then you pop 'em, you can't man 'em then you mop 'em, you can't stand 'em then you drop 'em You pop 'em cause we pop 'em like Orville Redenbacher Mothafucka, I'm ill
So I made it as far as the second across in the NW and decided today’s puzzle was not something with which I would like to be associated, and moved on to a different publication.
Based on the big guy’s review I GUESS I should have been EUPHORIC with this one - I was not. Perhaps it should have been a paper only solve? The layers quickly get pushed aside solving on the app and all we’re left with is fair to middling fill - and a lot of it.
Liked ROSE GARDEN and GOLDILOCKS. Theme is so constrictive that the overall fill can’t keep up - not suitable for a Sunday sized grid.
I’m sure it took time and chops to build - but squarely outside of the Sunday enjoyment category.
I really enjoyed this one, with one quibble. I've noticed that in the past year or two, the puzzle has introduced more youth oriented clues, which is fine, gotta hook the next generation and always good to learn, but when the clues cross, it becomes impossible. I'm referring to Amilli and Riri.
Another hand up for big-time Natick at AMILLI x RIRI. It was fortunate that the mystery letter had to be a vowel so I got it on the third try. Good that I had that AEIOU to refer to when coming up with candidates...
Re rituals. I recently happened across an interview with a philosopher I’d never heard of, Byung-Chul Han. His remarks on ritual made sense to me:
“Rituals are architectures of time, structuring and stabilising life, and they are on the wane. The pandemic has accelerated the disappearance of rituals. Work also has ritual aspects. We go to work at set times. Work takes place in a community. In the home office, the ritual of work is completely lost. The day loses its rhythm and structure. This somehow makes us tired and depressed.
“In The Little Prince [1943], by [Antoine de] Saint-Exupéry, the little prince asks the fox to always visit at the exact same time, so that the visit becomes a ritual. The little prince explains to the fox what a ritual is. Rituals are to time as rooms are to an apartment. They make time accessible like a house. They organise time, arrange it. In this way you make time appear meaningful.
“Time today lacks a solid structure. It is not a house, but a capricious river. The disappearance of rituals does not simply mean that we have more freedom. The total flexibilisation of life brings loss, too. Rituals may restrict freedom, but they structure and stabilise life. They anchor values and symbolic systems in the body, reinforcing community. In rituals we experience community, communal closeness, physically.
“Digitalisation strips away the physicality of the world. Then comes the pandemic. It aggravates the loss of the physical experience of community. You’re asking: can’t we do this by ourselves? Today we reject all rituals as something external, formal and therefore inauthentic. Neoliberalism produces a culture of authenticity, which places the ego at its centre. The culture of authenticity develops a suspicion of ritualised forms of interaction. Only spontaneous emotions, subjective states, are authentic. Modelled behaviour, for example courtesy, is written off as inauthentic or superficial. The narcissistic cult of authenticity is partly responsible for the increasing brutality of society.”
Rex, I am so sorry to hear about Olive. I take care of children with heart defects, and so this resonates with me.
Agree with many of the comments, including the "AU" in AUTOFILL and the PPP cross of AMILLI and RIRI. Naticked at ASTORS (I wrote ACTORS and left it at that). These were minor flaws in an otherwise enjoyable puzzle. I remember reading about Wyna - wasn't she one of the organizers or interviewees at Lollapuzzoola? - and thinking what an unusual set of hobbies she's into.
LMS and Iris, thank you for your comments. The Little Prince is one of my favorite books. And I think I align with Byung-Chul Han's insights... Something I couldn't myself place my finger on.
Some days the puzzle brings me joy. Other days, like today, the puzzle is something I slog through just for the pleasure of reading Rex (almost always a pleasure, even when we disagree) and this funny community I’ve come to look forward to hearing from every day. This daily ritual has become something I treasure. Check’s in the mail, Rex. @JoeDipinto, you crack me up.
I often push through the themes without *really* parsing them, maybe because understanding the themes isn’t often required to solve. But today was one of those days where that buffalo approach definitely worked against me. After figuring the extra letter element, it took me a long time to figure out the sound alike element. GuARD for GARDEN, Awl for ALL, PRINts for PRINCESS and others meant there were a lot of crosses that didn’t make sense. But then, once I figured it out, everything snapped into place and things got much easier. Only the head scratcher of finding AcTORS/OcCEOLA until after filling the grid was required to get the full solution. Moral of the story, don’t be so dismissive of the themes!
And thank you for the essay, and the tears, this morning Rex.
So I printed this one out and discovered that I was missing the two right-hand columns going down, or the last two squares for any Across answers that went that far. I figured if I made the page smaller everything would fit, but then all the printing would be smaller too, so I just made my own extra squares as I solved. An interesting experience. And yes, I know about the large print edition, but going back and forth between clues on one page and the grid on another is not for me. I think just a large print grid to day would have appeared on two pages.
Enough of that. I enjoyed this one but it took me too long to see how the themers worked, and I had almost all of them completely filled in before I caught on. Was seeing some familiar phrases, a la the Acrostic, and I finally started mentally pronouncing them, and aha!, or oho!, as you prefer.
I had seen RIRI in a puzzle somewhere and thought I'd see it again, and there it was.
Discovered that Capt. Kirk is from IOWA, the corny state. This may explain some things.
Nice Sunday indeed, WL. Wonderfully Layered and put up enough of a fight to make it rewarding. Thanks for all the fun.
Amy: very grateful for the blog, all the followers, and the daily ritual it provides. Observing rituals brings a sense of contentment. And so does a stellar Sunday puzzle.
Hey All ! Different. Took me a while to get the gist of what was happening. The ole brain bent into acknowledgement finally at the first Themer, after I had already filled in a bunch of stuff. Then as I was coming across the rest, had to do the mental gymnastics each time. Good brain workout.
Some tough to fill sections, the NW/SE corners, and the NCenter/SCenter spots with the stacked 10's. (WELP, I'm sure other sections were tough, too!) Nice job on the clean fill, Wyna.
Wanted nscaletrain for MODEL TRAIN, as N-Scale is pretty small. Although there is a smaller scale (half the size of N) called Z-Scale, which is tiny. You can make a layout in a briefcase. I found out recently that some sadistic person made an even smaller scale (forget the nomenclature, TT maybe?) which is half the size of Z. Which is ludicrous. (Ludicrous speed! Go!) You'd need a magnifying glass just to do a setup.
Anyway, my MODEL TRAIN screed aside, had a fun time with this puz. Helps that I got the Happy Music at the end!
GNARLY. Har. The 80's called and wants their word back.
Have at least one error. Will continue working for a solution later today. 🤔
Otherwise, an invigorating early morn exercise! :)
@Sat. Stumpers
Lucky guess at the 'Trattoria' / 'wood' cross, but alas, a careless gaff at '__ dash' did me in. :( See y'all next Sat. :) ___ Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness to all 🙏
Really beautiful appeal for support, Rex, which I will certainly honor for your dedication and hilariously entertaining writing. Your ruminations on quotidianness (quotidianity?) made me remember a project I did several years ago capturing on video a couple of seconds of my life every day for a year, stitching them together into a five minute or so vid that shows what a year of my life looked like. (This was a challenge issued on social media, which I used a lot more then.) At first I felt like I was failing because I should have been doing something video-worthy every day. But then I realized that the point wasn’t to manufacture a stunning moment every day but to show those daily routines as well as the adventures. So I had some days where my two seconds was a trip to another country, sledding in the snow or watching live music, and other days my two seconds was making dinner, walking the dog, riding a bus - or doing a crossword. That’s life - daily routines punctuated every once in a while by moments of exuberance.
One of the things I liked about today’s puzzle is that when you look at it at the end, you can’t tell which answers are themers and which aren’t. BONSAI TREE and MODEL TRAIN are the same length as (or one letter longer than) PRINCESS DI and AU COURANT but the first two are not themers and the second two are. I enjoyed figuring each one out.
I liked ROSE GARDEN growing up through the NETTLES. I wondered about the origin of the term Holy TOLEDO, so I looked it up and found about six possible origin stories, some based on Toledo, Spain, and some based on Toledo, Ohio.
The Hawkeye State is having a moment, with IOWA yesterday and IOWAN today. Speaking of which, thanks to those who made suggestions for my 50 jokes for 50 states yesterday (based on the “corny” Iowa joke in yesterday’s puzzle). I posted the last of the jokes late yesterday with New York appropriately being the final one. I was especially proud of Montana, New Jersey, Connecticut, Oklahoma and Virginia. Apologies to the mods for all the posts!
This Iowa City native and longtime Ames resident (once upon a long time ago) also noted and appreciates the two day corn state crossword run. And yesterday I saw the excellent play “Des Moines” starring Johanna Day and Michael Shannon at the Polonsky theatre to really celebrate my home state heritage from right here in Brooklyn.
@bocamp and other Sat. Stump folks--Finished but even with the very last Across filled in, and I think correctly, it sure doesn't make much sense to me.
With Joe D warning me last night that this puzzle was sloggy and that he'd dropped it early, I was predisposed to do the same before even looking at it this morning. When I did, the theme clues looked like hieroglyphics to me, the few non-theme answers I filled in were yawners, and then there was this:
A Lil Wayne song crossed with the name of the "Diamonds" singer.
Oh, no, no, no, no, I'm thinking. "I Cannot Go On".
(Wasn't there a song on the billboard chart with that title at some point? Or something very much like it?)
Never feel bad about venting your feelings over the loss of a good friend, which most cats are. I’m an old and have said goodbye to a few fur babies over the years. Whenever I feel myself hovering a bit to close to the edge of that ol’ pit of despair, I remind myself that those hairy goofballs wouldn’t want me to be too sad, about anything, especially thinking about them. Have you found yourself a new kitten friend? Or two?
I don’t like this one on principal. Unclued answers, in any guise, pervert the prime XWD directive. The fun is in puzzling out clever often cryptic clueing. When the constructor ignores this fundamental tenet . . . So I solved this one while ignoring the so-called theme.
Having dispensed with today's puzzle in a few lines, I want to pose a deep philosophical question to the blog:
Is it possible for a tone-deaf person to get an earworm?
One of the downsides of not being a tone-deaf person is that I am just about never without an earworm, I don't get rid of the last one until the next one appears.
Which is fine when the earworm is "Loch Lomand" or "Losing My Mind" or "Some Other Time". It's not so fine when the earworm is "Lydia, the Tattooed Lady".
I mean, really!
I watched the Amercan Masters PBS show, "Dick Cavett and Groucho Marx" a few days ago and "Lydia" has been in my ear, in my head and on my lips ever since. All day. Even worse, all night. There are approximately 62,985 songs I like a heck of a lot more, but right now it's all "Lydia", all the time.
Echoing Kevan Harris's comment, how does "Mr. Toad's Wild Ride" (95 down) end in hell per the clue for 83 down? Or perhaps I should ask "How the hell..."? The obvious "paleo" cross saved me from using the checker, but I had to hold my nose to punch it in. Anybody have a rational or at least literate explanation?
Amen EdFromHackensack... same. got it done but who has time to decode the “secret message”. Regarding RIRI/AMILLI - I made an educated guess. 1) that “RIRI” was Rihanna and 2) judging from the lyrics about money “AMILLI” seemed rappishly plausible. All in all a fun puzzle.
@Nancy - Yes, we the tone-deaf do get earworms. Although your description of "just about never without an earworm" is not part of the deal (at least for me). I probably get a minor earworm once a week or so, and a major one (lasting several days) once a year or so.
As I've mentioned before, I'm in awe of people who can listen to music and say that's in the key of D-major" or listen to two notes and say "those are six tones apart", while I can't tune a guitar without a device, because to do so manually you need to know which of two notes is higher than the other, so you can tighten/loosen the appropriate string.
Wondering the same thing as others, about Mr. Toad's Wild Ride ending in Hell. Guess what? It's on Wikipedia:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mr._Toad's_Wild_Ride ...After winding through the cells, guests emerged out into Shireland, passing by a shootout between the police and some weasels (using red lights to simulate gunfire). Several of the police barriers then moved aside revealing a railroad crossing, complete with a ringing bell. The gate then moved aside (presumably breaking apart), and the vehicles made a right hand turn onto the tracks. The vehicles traveled along the railroad tracks until getting hit by a train (with guests seeing the headlight of the locomotive). A door then opened, revealing the underworld scene, in which there were volcanos, flashing lights, multiple laughing demons, and a giant flat of Satan that popped up (similarly to the dandelion in Alice in Wonderland). Afterwards, guests went through a door back to the boarding area.
That is one weird re-conception of what is a delightful story.
Dnf from HELL (literally) on the MR.TOAD clue. I had Home, then HoLe, finally decided there was some variant spelling of PALaO and settled for TOAD of TOAD Hall. Just couldn't convince myself a ride at Disneyland ended in HELL, even though I've had visits to Disney World that sometimes seemed like HELL.
Very lovely blogging this morning, Rex. Thank you for that and for your contribution to my life day by day.
@Kevan Harris, padraig - Mr. Toad's wild ride is great for kids. Towards the end, you enter a tunnel and collide with a train, which kills everyone, and you end up in the netherworld. Not literally, of course.
I'm surprised that Rex did not frown upon the great number of junk clues that ask the solver to replace supposedly quotable phrases or sounds with supposedly quotable phrases or sounds:
7A "Uh sure"; 35A [I'm frustrated!]; 44A "Ugh!"; 119A "Anything for you!"; 62D [Is this thing on?]; 91D "Hmmm, gotcha"; 96D "Nice try, but I don't think so"; 106D [Grrrr!]; 108D "Eh, what can you do?!"
I understand having one or two clues/answers of this kind, but eight? "Ugh!" indeed. [I'm frustrated!] IMO, that's just poor cluing and fill, making this a very irritating puzzle to solve. And this by a puzzle editor for the NYT. "Nice try, but I don't think so."
The term originated from a Southern Italian dialect and became part of the Italian -American mashup of terms for Italian foods. I have always heard the 2 syllable version, usually without broccoli "I'll have a pint of rabe " spoken at the deli. But the one syllable version is certainly around. That comes from the fact that Southern Italian dialects reduce unaccented last syllables to a schwa and sometimes drop them entirely. So both versions live on in the US. FWIW my four grandparents immigrated to the US from Southern Italy.
Naticked at the SAL BONSAI crossing. I always see salt as SEL (which is of course French, but..) so couldn't get to SAL and "bonsei" looked like it could be right.
As one who lost two beloved cats recently, I was very moved by Rex’s insightful paean to Olive and the quotidian. I just finished Hua Hsu’s great memoir, Stay True, which also deals masterfully with grief and the daily. It is one of the supreme memoirs I’ve read in my lifetime. (It’s justifiably on many top ten lists of the best books of 2022.) As for the puzzle, I had mixed feelings, not crazy about the theme but found many of the clues and answers inventive, though a good number were overcooked, maybe?
SOUNDS GOOD/feels bad. I should probably like this puzzle more than I do because it gave me a good tussle to come up with a clean grid. RIRI and WELP were out on the very edge of the radar.
The meta aspect of the theme was the biggest let down. I pretty much ignored the blanks in the theme clues while solving as the puns alone were painful enough. With the grid filled in I went back over the clues and saw that of course they spelled something out. This was interesting until it turned out to be just SOUNDS GOOD. That's what all this smoke and mirrors was for? YEAH NO sums up my reaction perfectly.
I've always enjoyed Wyna's puzzles ever since her NYT debut, not quite 4 years ago. This Sunday is no exception. I had fun sounding out the theme answers. I will agree that SOUNDS GOOD isn't a real stunner although it is a nice bonus effort from the constructor.
WELP - I say this a lot but it doesn't end in a P sound, more like a nasally aspiration swallowing the L, far from the full swelling of WELL. I don't know if that's how everyone's version of WELP sounds or if it's a regionalism (or just me, though I doubt that).
I threw in lIPSTICK once I had enough filled in to see that potential answer. I read the clue again, said "huh?" and looked at the cross. Oh, DIPSTICK. I have used that as both an aspersion and a measuring device, har.
Rex, thanks for your daily efforts. I'm sending my annual contribution by mail so I can get the postcard!
@Wanderlust, from yesterday, thanks for all the great state jokes, kudos!
Three areas gave me trouble today. 1. The NW natick. 2. The HELL where Disney delivers kiddos instead of hall, hole, hill. 3. ASIANA x PASEO which should have been obvious…
I did see the phonetic feature which was helpful - cryptickish. I liked it. Yay! For BONSAITREE, MODELTRAIN and DIPSTICK
Thanks Rex and @Iris for sharing your thoughts about ritual. I sometimes feel guilty about time spent on this ephemeral activity. I read somewhere that most of us suffer from a pleasure deficit. Working the puzzle and reading this blog and the comments help remedy that a bit each day. Thanks to all of you.
(Private message to Rex. I was going to use your email address, but I know how much I hate slogging through mine...)
The photo of you and Olive struck me today, since I had been pushing a playful kitten off of my desk chair all morning. She is one of my foster cats who wants my lap and attention, but I have a rule that cats can't bother me at my desk. I don't have the patience that you have! If/when you are ready to adopt another feline friend, I would be willing to drive half the distance between us to gift you a healthy, spayed, vaccinated girl born April 16 at my house (Medina, Ohio). Her mom is feral, but Kathy is the opposite of her mother. She also fetches like a dog, dropping her toy at your feet for another round! (We spayed and vaccinated her mother and returned her to her neighborhood.)
Since we spend so much money rescuing cats, I can't afford to fund your blog work, but I can gift you a companion who acts very much like your Olive. If interested, feel free to call or text 330-635-1230. Best wishes, Donna Miller
Joe D's theme-driven appraisal of the puzzle at 12:42 a.m. is very funny and very clever.
He gave me the solution off-blog. I'm not sure I'd have figured it out for myself -- but that's partly because I didn't bother with figuring out the theme of today's puzzle in the first place.
Joe -- You should put up the solution at the end of today's blog for anyone who didn't figure it out.
For the most part I found this one sloppy and un-fun. Agreed that AMILLI/RIRI is a fairly brutal Natick. STY and STYE should never occupy the same grid. The theme and revealer were too much work for not nearly enough payoff.
No one has mentioned what I found the ugliest clue/answer pair: 72A, "Cherubic archer"/AMOR. In what world is a 4-letter answer to that clue not EROS? AMOR is not any person or figure I'm aware of—merely the Romantic-languages word for love. Someone got their love language wires crossed, methinks.
I did, however, enjoy seeing two hobby pursuits overlaid one atop the other with BONSAI TREE and MODEL TRAIN, and the clue on CARPOOL LANE ("Path covered with diamonds") was cute. But most of the fill I just found choppy.
One answer I will diverge from prevailing opinion on is WELP. It went in smooth for me, and I would argue that lacking familiarity with it suggests a deficiency in good-faith engagement with the way Actual People talk.
WELP, OHOK, IGUESS. DAM. Did on paper as usual for Sunday, no hints in the constructor's bio in the NYT mag, so was pretty proud to figure out SOUNDS GOOD all by my lonesome. Got the trick at 44A because all the crosses were in, sadly not the case in the NW with the noted Natick cross.
For some reason the whole thing left me ... underwhelmed?
GNARLY and not in a good way. Definitely the worst puzzle of the year, if not several years. Or ever. I’m not going to waste any time explaining why. Those who solved this mess understand already. How could the NYT accept this at the expense of other better puzzles which were rejected. Obviously, being associate editor helped. That is not a good enough reason in my opinion…
A mutt is a cur but AUCOURANT is not pronounced with the cur sound. It’s more like the sound in Coor as in Coors Lite. The mispronounciation by someone with an English accent does not make it okay.
Welp, glad to see I’m not the only one with questions about Toad HELL. RIRI and A MILLI were in my wheelhouse, tho I can see them easily being Naticks if they weren’t.
Great post today, Rex, and my condolences on the magnificent Olive. With my good boy being solidly in his golden years, I try to remember to treasure each quotidian moment, even when he wakes me up for food and a walk at 6 am in single digit temps. Anyway, I will put something in the pot next pay day. Grateful for this little corner of the internet!
In the late 90's/Early aughts one could see a replica ECTOMOBILE driving and parked around Roseville, MN. IIRC, it was built on a GM A-Body Wagon platform. I never saw the movie, but that thong always made me smile.
I did not see any of that comment about the missing letter spelling out a word so I was left with a big HUH? Also though that SE corner was tough as someone else mentioned.
@Smith… You and others seem to say that there is no note in the print magazine version of the puzzle. I always print the puzzle, and the only version available to print today was the "Newspaper Version"—even from the Standard Layout link. I noticed that the Inksaver option was not working and sent a note to the Times; a rep confirmed what was happening.
Apparently the Times web producers can't figure out how to italicize anything in text exported from print to web, as the italicized answers would seem to be the only reason a regular Standard Layout, with Inksaver, wasn't deemed possible. I told the Times that I (a web producer for The Nation, who used to produce both print and web versions of a crossword in that mag) find this laughable.
But now you tell me that there was no note about working the puzzle in the upper left corner under the headline in your copy of the magazine. Since I'm looking at that box in my printout of the Newspaper Version, this seems a massive screw-up.
In the magazine print version, there IS a note but it does not include the instruction that Rex mentions he had in his version (he says it included, “Note: Each italicized clue contains a blank, which should be filled with a letter of the alphabet. When completed, the letters in order will spell out a two-word phrase.")
The online version said this: "Each italicized clue contains a blank, which should be filled with a letter of the alphabet. When completed, the letters in order will spell out a two-word phrase."
But not every answer from the italicized clues were two word phrases. 44a is italicized. The answer is "Euphoria."
Everything you need to know about "Krapp's Last Tape":
For the life of me I couldn't remember Krapp. All I could think of, of course, was Godot. I think I blocked "Krapp's Last Tape" out of my mind for, like, forever, because I found it so completely unwatchable back in the day. I saw it in my early 20s down in the Village. It was on a double bill with "The Zoo Story" -- which fortunately was performed first. Otherwise I would have been long gone. I LOVED "The Zoo Story" -- definitely my favorite Albee play of all time. And then came this beyond-depressing (and totally plotless) depiction of a decrepit old man eating a banana and listening to a tape recorder -- I thought at the time: This is the worst play I have ever seen!!!! And nothing has happened in 50-60 years to change my mind.
@JC66 – I did not, but feel free to substitute + eponym for the town in a Dan Levy sitcom as the last part of the clue.
I did the puzzle in the magazine itself, and it was easy enough to figure out that the missing components represented letters that spelled out something, without needing an editor's note to explain. They do versions of this gimmick all the time.
Meanwhile, I liked this, from WS's constructor notes: The thing she loves most about her job is "talking puzzles with other people who love them!" Okay. But then it adds: (That would be the rest of us on the Games team.) Who else would we think she meant?
There was, I reiterate after several others mentioned it, NO NOTE IN THE PRINT EDITION. All we had to go on was the title, DO YOU HEAR THAT? I finished the whole puzzle without figuring out what the unclued bits were supposed to be. Annoying.
wow for once the print version didn’t give away the theme and had no such note and … I figured it out anyway ! I just … figured it out! By solving. No hints. Yay.
Seeing Rex gush over this one was painful. I found no pleasure in the solve experience; just slow tedious torture. Phonetically breaking down the fill and clueing the result should entail much more cleverness in the exercise.
U-Fore-Ick doesn't cut it. There's no solving joy in that (or at least little more than the typical wordsearch serves up.
For an extraordinarily talented constructor, I can see where this exercise might have been filled with opportunities to play. Maybe my mind dulled over too quickly to appreciate some latent word play here. I came away weary from a slog fest.
Given that cheerleader-supreme @Lewis hasn't chimed in today, I suspect he may have commandeered a portion of Rex's blog today.
(Apologies to those who savored the challenge today, and regrets to the constructor: in all other respects it was a very admirable effort.
Re @Rex, I feel his feline loss all too much. My wife and I have owned two cats through the duration of our 38 year relationship. The average age at which our cats have succumbed is 16, meaning that we're on our third set now. Cats so subtly integrate and enmesh themselves into your life that upon their loss it's easy to sense that you've lost a limb.
And, on the topic of Covid, we returned from a lovely cruise out of Puerto Rico on the 30th. Covid was on our minds and we took moderate protections. Nonetheless, on Jan 4 I suffered the onset of "cold" symptoms and modest fever. There's much to suggest that this infection may be the work of one of the latest variants.
The toll on my body is modest by comparison with my prior two infections: I was double vaxxed from the start; I refer to my first infection as the "immaculate infection" -- I was practically a hermit at the time. The second, a year later despite rigorous defenses while travelling, likely resulted when at the tail end of a cross country flight, I removed my mask for dinner and was drawn into conversation with my seat mate, never putting the mask on until touch down. (up to that point, I spend at least 14 hours of each day that trip masked.)
I simply fear some developing chest congestion in my current infection. I'm a two time loser to bacterial pneumonia (35 years and 15 years ago), I have doubts about my hardiness if tested by reinfection at this time in my life ...
I solved the puzzle with no knowledge of any note and am glad of it, enjoying the challenge of figuring out what the blanks stood for. And at the end, I liked spelling out the "hidden" phrase. Enjoyed the whole thing.
Apologies - I posted this to the wrong day initially. Lots on my mind!
Rex, my sincere condolences about your cat. And I'm sorry to hear you are dealing with Covid. Nothing but admiration for you to continue to do what you do, every day, on this blog; despite other obligations and worries. FWIW, for me this is absolutely one of those rituals that offers solace during frustrating or scary times. (Today I'm dealing with TWO failed external hard drives, and feeling a little lost RN :( Many. many thanks, and I will show my appreciation as best I can with a donation.
Today's puzzle was tough for me. I find that there are some constructors that are easier and some that are harder to get in synch with, and today's is the latter. The first themer I got was "euphoric", one word; and I wasn't looking for two-word solutions on the others, so that got me stuck for longer than it should have. I solve on paper and there was no explanation but I thought it was pretty evident what we were looking for and that the blank spaces would spell a phrase, so that helped. The sound element to me was hard. When I hear a word I see it, spelled correctly, in my mind - and to disconnect from that and just listen to the sound was mind-twisting, but in a fun way. Okay, back to trying to recover my data!
Medium. My experience was sorta the opposite of @Rex. I thought it was mostly easy except for figuring out the theme answers which I didn’t bother doing until I was almost done. However, I did get hung up in the SE corner because KILT took a long time to surface (sari and toga did not work).
ReplyDeleteClever word play with some fun clues, liked it.
Being a Scotsman, KILT was fairly easy for me! However, my pedantic side wonders when EUPHORIC became a two-word phrase. Am I missing something?
DeleteI had the exact same experience today!
DeleteIsn’t a Scottish inlet “loch”?
Delete“Two-word phrase refers to “Sounds good.”
Deletesomeone please tell me, where do I find the “Puzzle Notes” you refer to?
DeleteNobel Prize category won by Obama + have debts + title character in a Beckett play (no not that one)
ReplyDeleteWell maybe not quite that bad, but pretty unfun.
ReplyDeleteI’m hoping that the presence of PRINCESSDI in this puzzle will snap Harry out of his TMI binge, STAT. Did anyone promise you a ROSEGARDEN, lad? Seems like a big, slow train wreck that we can’t get ourselves to turn away from.
Darling, you may speak Ill of my Man Cave, but just steer clear of my GOODEN.
I may not be AUCOURANT, but I don’t think it has a cur (rhymes with Warriors coach Steve Kerr) in it. More like a Coors beer.
I’m against the idea of cleaning up the vomit and feces here.
Oh, are EUPHORIC?
Is it ok to have (36A) PHO right on top of more PHO in 44A? Which reminds me, if you’re ever in Tacoma there’s a great Pho King restaurant on MLK Jr. Way.
I liked the theme idea and thought it was well-executed. Fill was interesting too, so overall it was a good Sunday. Thanks, Wyna Liu.
I will definitely try the pho restaurant that you mentioned. I often read your comments but had no idea that you are a neighbor.
Deletehmmm... finished no errors but longer than usual. I figured if you strung together all the missing sounds it would amount to something but didn't have the time as I was taking down all the Christmas decorations (one of the saddest days of the year). Plus I wasn't prepared to be disappointed with another "Be sure to drink your Ovaltine” moment. Agree with Rex about WELP. what the heck was that?
ReplyDelete@Rex, the way in which you note your dislike of IOU crossing AE. . .IOU reminds this fellow English prof of the nod to Irish writer George Russell (who wrote under the pseudonym AE) in _Ulysses_. Stephen Dedalus acknowledges an intellectual debt when he thinks at one point in the Scylla and Charybdis chapter, "AEIOU."
ReplyDeleteWhat about sty and stye?
ReplyDeleteI thought the same thing! In the same puzzle?
DeleteWelp, um I mean WELL (which was my first try for 108 down)... only a few thoughts on the puzzle, but a lot on your writeup, Rex.
ReplyDeleteFinished with two errors(!!): AMELLI crossing RORI which was a brutal Natick for me never having heard either, and OCCEOLA crossing ACTORS because I know I've seen/heard OCEOLA somewhere. Typeovers: ANGER before ANGST (both emotions!), and as I mentioned WELL before WELP, which I've never heard. CAR POOL LANE was brilliant; that clue, oh my.
As for the writeup: may be a record for length, it takes 12 hits on the Page Down key to cover it! Re your Covid... been there, somehow caught that just before Thanksgiving (mid Oct. here in Canada), despite having little contact with, well, anyone, and being 4x vaxxed (both boosters). I had to miss family get together at the cabin with incredibly warm summer like weather... people going swimming and everything. One really sick day, then just a gradual recovery. So that damned Covid cost me 2 xmases and a thanksgiving... but no one I know died.
And your cat: I am caring for my sister's boyfriend's cat for Feb and March. I went for a pre catsit visit last week, and she is the dopiest slowest moving thing (the cat, not my sister). 18 years old! It will be my first cat in the house since I lost Holly, who was a ball of fire, 14 years ago. Crazy fact: Holly got her name when my younger brother (who is long gone now) commented that the number tattooed in her ear reminded him of Holocaust victims.
I appreciate all your effort Rex.
[Spelling Bee: Sat 0, no oddball words. 4 day QB streak!]
Workable, but nothing else to add. Thanks to constructor and editor. Nothing stellar, but no complaints.
ReplyDeleteRIRI and AMILLI - Sorry, but that's a Natick to me.
ReplyDeleteOops, you're absolutely right about that @daniel and I stand corrected, because I had assumed nothing but RoRI made sense as a name, so.... Not workable after all. I take back my kudos and substitute a big BOOOOOO!
DeleteI'm only halfway through, so I haven't looked at Rex or at other comments. I find this neither great nor terrible.
ReplyDeleteBut its title really ought to be "Bad Homonyms."
Villager
I've been doing these too long, so this was a "meh" for me.
ReplyDeleteFigured out the theme early enough that I was later able to solve several other themers on that info. So for me that was a rare positive for a themer, as opposed to saying WTF and figuring it out an hour later.
HUGO was major gimme for me because of the amount of SF&F I have read over the years. But AMILLI crossing RIRI was a serious WTF, Ntaick? Possibly because I stopped listening to "pop" music back about 1987 because AM radio started to suck that year.
Homophone Hell!
ReplyDeleteRex – beautiful, poignant, insightful thoughts on Life, this blog, the quotidian, Olive. It’s a shame that some here won’t read that. I get that there are people who refuse to pay for what is free – fine – but still. . .
ReplyDeleteThanks to your dedication, my horizons, my solving prowess, my circle of friends have grown so much. So many days I don’t have the time or energy to write anything, and I’m sure that’s the case for you, too. This difference is you dig down and deliver despite that. Thank you, thank you, thank you. (Love the picture of you and Olive. I realized that I have an Olive in my life, my son (avatar), whose goofy goofiness takes me out of myself, too.) Anyhoo . . . I’ll Venmo you a small token of my gratitude.
This theme is an absolute delight. I gobbled up sussing out the homophone-deducing exercise and delighted in filling in those extraneous letters. @Joe Dipinto – I briefly played around with this, too and all I got was “vow-taking place + ______ + spurn.” And the missing letter is K. Serendipitously I was watching a THINGY on the January 6 riot at the time. (So that whole southwest was flashing at me: MYTH, NO GENTLEMAN, NON-APOLOGY, BIG SHOTS, DON. . . YEAH, NO.)
Speaking of which – I agree that YEAH NO is terrific. The phrase can do so much semantic work, the main one (for me) being like I totally understand what you’re saying and need you to understand that I’m not misunderstanding before I tell you no.
@okanaganer and @Daniel – that RIRI/AMILLI cross. . . YEAH, NO. Natick all day, man.
So “ambidextrous” has all the vowels? Would it be facetious to say I’ve seen better?
“Steam” ENGINE before SOLAR ENGINE. Bet we’re legion today.
“Intestinal bacterium” – I found out this week that a lot of my students have no idea what the colon is when I added this beaut to my array of posters around my room:
A colon can completely change the meaning of a sentence. For example:
*Jane ate her friend’s sandwich.
*Jane ate her friend’s colon.
They didn’t get it. Sigh.
SOMAD keeps waving its dookness at me. Like it could be a word for a sleepwalker, amirite?
Wyna Liu – this is one I’ll remember for a long time. Well-done!
I always look for and appreciate your comments Loren. Today I appreciated you acknowledging Rex’s sweet post. Thank you for your contributions to one of those daily rituals that adds up for me.
DeleteFacetiously has 'em in order!
DeleteAlso abstemiously
DeleteFor me the natick was the m of emer crossing amilli, I’m British so had no idea what FEMA is and the song is just a random string of letters so that letter was Ungettable. Gave up on the puzzle then and came here, and amusing to see lots of people were also naticked on that entry but by the r of riri instead!
ReplyDeleteI filled the entire puzzle without a clue as to what it was about. My biggest holdup was 3D RIRI, which I ran the vowels for. Had to come here for the theme explanation!
ReplyDeleteI picked up on the theme relatively quickly (soundalike syllables with a missing sound) but completely forgot to go back at the end and see what the missing words/letters said!!!!
ReplyDeleteI liked this. I thought it was fun and clever. The Western half fell quickly for me but the Eastern half took three times as long. Having SARI for KILT and having no idea what a SOLAR ENGINE is didn't help, but mostly I think the themers in the Eastern half just weren't clicking for me.
Not a fan of Lil Wayne, or his song A Milli, especially the part where he talks about “popping the cops”:
ReplyDeleteSister, brother, son, daughter, father, mother-fuck a copper
Got the Maserati dancing on the bridge, pussy popping
Tell the coppers ha-ha-ha-ha, you can't catch 'em, you can't stop 'em
I go by them goon rules, if you can't beat 'em then you pop 'em, you can't man 'em then you mop 'em, you can't stand 'em then you drop 'em
You pop 'em cause we pop 'em like Orville Redenbacher
Mothafucka, I'm ill
So I made it as far as the second across in the NW and decided today’s puzzle was not something with which I would like to be associated, and moved on to a different publication.
Say you’re a racist with saying you’re a racist.
DeleteOh, please. Come on!
DeleteBased on the big guy’s review I GUESS I should have been EUPHORIC with this one - I was not. Perhaps it should have been a paper only solve? The layers quickly get pushed aside solving on the app and all we’re left with is fair to middling fill - and a lot of it.
ReplyDeleteLiked ROSE GARDEN and GOLDILOCKS. Theme is so constrictive that the overall fill can’t keep up - not suitable for a Sunday sized grid.
I’m sure it took time and chops to build - but squarely outside of the Sunday enjoyment category.
Tom T.
No explanatory notes at all in the print version. FYI.
ReplyDeleteExactly! WTF??? Eventually, sorta figured it out. Thought it was stupid. Had no idea there was another layer involved.
DeleteDitto. Why didn’t we get the note in the printed edition???
DeleteI really enjoyed this one, with one quibble. I've noticed that in the past year or two, the puzzle has introduced more youth oriented clues, which is fine, gotta hook the next generation and always good to learn, but when the clues cross, it becomes impossible. I'm referring to Amilli and Riri.
ReplyDeleteAnother hand up for big-time Natick at AMILLI x RIRI. It was fortunate that the mystery letter had to be a vowel so I got it on the third try. Good that I had that AEIOU to refer to when coming up with candidates...
ReplyDelete@LMS, I laughed out loud at your sandwich joke.
Re rituals. I recently happened across an interview with a philosopher I’d never heard of, Byung-Chul Han. His remarks on ritual made sense to me:
ReplyDelete“Rituals are architectures of time, structuring and stabilising life, and they are on the wane. The pandemic has accelerated the disappearance of rituals. Work also has ritual aspects. We go to work at set times. Work takes place in a community. In the home office, the ritual of work is completely lost. The day loses its rhythm and structure. This somehow makes us tired and depressed.
“In The Little Prince [1943], by [Antoine de] Saint-Exupéry, the little prince asks the fox to always visit at the exact same time, so that the visit becomes a ritual. The little prince explains to the fox what a ritual is. Rituals are to time as rooms are to an apartment. They make time accessible like a house. They organise time, arrange it. In this way you make time appear meaningful.
“Time today lacks a solid structure. It is not a house, but a capricious river. The disappearance of rituals does not simply mean that we have more freedom. The total flexibilisation of life brings loss, too. Rituals may restrict freedom, but they structure and stabilise life. They anchor values and symbolic systems in the body, reinforcing community. In rituals we experience community, communal closeness, physically.
“Digitalisation strips away the physicality of the world. Then comes the pandemic. It aggravates the loss of the physical experience of community. You’re asking: can’t we do this by ourselves? Today we reject all rituals as something external, formal and therefore inauthentic. Neoliberalism produces a culture of authenticity, which places the ego at its centre. The culture of authenticity develops a suspicion of ritualised forms of interaction. Only spontaneous emotions, subjective states, are authentic. Modelled behaviour, for example courtesy, is written off as inauthentic or superficial. The narcissistic cult of authenticity is partly responsible for the increasing brutality of society.”
Rex, I think you need a new cat. My daughter is fostering the adorable Romeo in NYC but can’t keep him. Any interest??
ReplyDeleteRex, I am so sorry to hear about Olive. I take care of children with heart defects, and so this resonates with me.
ReplyDeleteAgree with many of the comments, including the "AU" in AUTOFILL and the PPP cross of AMILLI and RIRI. Naticked at ASTORS (I wrote ACTORS and left it at that). These were minor flaws in an otherwise enjoyable puzzle. I remember reading about Wyna - wasn't she one of the organizers or interviewees at Lollapuzzoola? - and thinking what an unusual set of hobbies she's into.
LMS and Iris, thank you for your comments. The Little Prince is one of my favorite books. And I think I align with Byung-Chul Han's insights... Something I couldn't myself place my finger on.
Some days the puzzle brings me joy. Other days, like today, the puzzle is something I slog through just for the pleasure of reading Rex (almost always a pleasure, even when we disagree) and this funny community I’ve come to look forward to hearing from every day. This daily ritual has become something I treasure. Check’s in the mail, Rex.
ReplyDelete@JoeDipinto, you crack me up.
Why would they not put the “puzzle notes” in the Times Magazine?
ReplyDeleteGreat question! It seems the two of us are the only ones who still do the puzzle with a pen (or pencil)!
DeleteCount me in.
DeletePaper & pencil all the way!
Delete“Grrr!” seems like a good summary of my solving experience today.
ReplyDeleteI GUESS, ARGH, OH OK, YEAH NO, SO MAD, WELP. That’s twice as many of those as I’m willing to put up with for a theme that is not my cuppa.
A technical note.
ReplyDeleteMost Scottish inlets are firths.
Most (not all) Scottish lochs are fresh water lakes.
Needless to say, firth didn't work in the answer.
Villager
I often push through the themes without *really* parsing them, maybe because understanding the themes isn’t often required to solve. But today was one of those days where that buffalo approach definitely worked against me. After figuring the extra letter element, it took me a long time to figure out the sound alike element. GuARD for GARDEN, Awl for ALL, PRINts for PRINCESS and others meant there were a lot of crosses that didn’t make sense. But then, once I figured it out, everything snapped into place and things got much easier. Only the head scratcher of finding AcTORS/OcCEOLA until after filling the grid was required to get the full solution. Moral of the story, don’t be so dismissive of the themes!
ReplyDeleteAnd thank you for the essay, and the tears, this morning Rex.
Mr. Toad`s ride lands in hell? Is there really a hell in Disneyland?
ReplyDeleteSo I printed this one out and discovered that I was missing the two right-hand columns going down, or the last two squares for any Across answers that went that far. I figured if I made the page smaller everything would fit, but then all the printing would be smaller too, so I just made my own extra squares as I solved. An interesting experience. And yes, I know about the large print edition, but going back and forth between clues on one page and the grid on another is not for me. I think just a large print grid to day would have appeared on two pages.
ReplyDeleteEnough of that. I enjoyed this one but it took me too long to see how the themers worked, and I had almost all of them completely filled in before I caught on. Was seeing some familiar phrases, a la the Acrostic, and I finally started mentally pronouncing them, and aha!, or oho!, as you prefer.
I had seen RIRI in a puzzle somewhere and thought I'd see it again, and there it was.
Discovered that Capt. Kirk is from IOWA, the corny state. This may explain some things.
Nice Sunday indeed, WL. Wonderfully Layered and put up enough of a fight to make it rewarding. Thanks for all the fun.
What is welp? Jim
ReplyDeleteAmy: very grateful for the blog, all the followers, and the daily ritual it provides. Observing rituals brings a sense of contentment. And so does a stellar Sunday puzzle.
ReplyDeleteHey All !
ReplyDeleteDifferent. Took me a while to get the gist of what was happening. The ole brain bent into acknowledgement finally at the first Themer, after I had already filled in a bunch of stuff. Then as I was coming across the rest, had to do the mental gymnastics each time. Good brain workout.
Some tough to fill sections, the NW/SE corners, and the NCenter/SCenter spots with the stacked 10's. (WELP, I'm sure other sections were tough, too!) Nice job on the clean fill, Wyna.
Wanted nscaletrain for MODEL TRAIN, as N-Scale is pretty small. Although there is a smaller scale (half the size of N) called Z-Scale, which is tiny. You can make a layout in a briefcase. I found out recently that some sadistic person made an even smaller scale (forget the nomenclature, TT maybe?) which is half the size of Z. Which is ludicrous. (Ludicrous speed! Go!) You'd need a magnifying glass just to do a setup.
Anyway, my MODEL TRAIN screed aside, had a fun time with this puz. Helps that I got the Happy Music at the end!
GNARLY. Har. The 80's called and wants their word back.
One F (Not LARGE enough!)
RooMonster
DarrinV
Thx, Wyna, for your creative offering! :)
ReplyDeleteVery hard (2x Sun. avg at this juncture).
Have at least one error. Will continue working for a solution later today. 🤔
Otherwise, an invigorating early morn exercise! :)
@Sat. Stumpers
Lucky guess at the 'Trattoria' / 'wood' cross, but alas, a careless gaff at '__ dash' did me in. :( See y'all next Sat. :)
___
Peace 🕊 🇺🇦 ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness to all 🙏
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteReally beautiful appeal for support, Rex, which I will certainly honor for your dedication and hilariously entertaining writing. Your ruminations on quotidianness (quotidianity?) made me remember a project I did several years ago capturing on video a couple of seconds of my life every day for a year, stitching them together into a five minute or so vid that shows what a year of my life looked like. (This was a challenge issued on social media, which I used a lot more then.) At first I felt like I was failing because I should have been doing something video-worthy every day. But then I realized that the point wasn’t to manufacture a stunning moment every day but to show those daily routines as well as the adventures. So I had some days where my two seconds was a trip to another country, sledding in the snow or watching live music, and other days my two seconds was making dinner, walking the dog, riding a bus - or doing a crossword. That’s life - daily routines punctuated every once in a while by moments of exuberance.
ReplyDeleteOne of the things I liked about today’s puzzle is that when you look at it at the end, you can’t tell which answers are themers and which aren’t. BONSAI TREE and MODEL TRAIN are the same length as (or one letter longer than) PRINCESS DI and AU COURANT but the first two are not themers and the second two are. I enjoyed figuring each one out.
I liked ROSE GARDEN growing up through the NETTLES. I wondered about the origin of the term Holy TOLEDO, so I looked it up and found about six possible origin stories, some based on Toledo, Spain, and some based on Toledo, Ohio.
The Hawkeye State is having a moment, with IOWA yesterday and IOWAN today. Speaking of which, thanks to those who made suggestions for my 50 jokes for 50 states yesterday (based on the “corny” Iowa joke in yesterday’s puzzle). I posted the last of the jokes late yesterday with New York appropriately being the final one. I was especially proud of Montana, New Jersey, Connecticut, Oklahoma and Virginia. Apologies to the mods for all the posts!
This Iowa City native and longtime Ames resident (once upon a long time ago) also noted and appreciates the two day corn state crossword run. And yesterday I saw the excellent play “Des Moines” starring Johanna Day and Michael Shannon at the Polonsky theatre to really celebrate my home state heritage from right here in Brooklyn.
DeleteYay.
@bocamp and other Sat. Stump folks--Finished but even with the very last Across filled in, and I think correctly, it sure doesn't make much sense to me.
ReplyDelete@Kevan Harris - Disneyland is hell.
ReplyDeleteAn aggravating collection of total garbage.
ReplyDeleteWith Joe D warning me last night that this puzzle was sloggy and that he'd dropped it early, I was predisposed to do the same before even looking at it this morning. When I did, the theme clues looked like hieroglyphics to me, the few non-theme answers I filled in were yawners, and then there was this:
ReplyDeleteA Lil Wayne song crossed with the name of the "Diamonds" singer.
Oh, no, no, no, no, I'm thinking. "I Cannot Go On".
(Wasn't there a song on the billboard chart with that title at some point? Or something very much like it?)
Never feel bad about venting your feelings over the loss of a good friend, which most cats are. I’m an old and have said goodbye to a few fur babies over the years. Whenever I feel myself hovering a bit to close to the edge of that ol’ pit of despair, I remind myself that those hairy goofballs wouldn’t want me to be too sad, about anything, especially thinking about them. Have you found yourself a new kitten friend? Or two?
ReplyDeleteyou deserve more than I donated, but it's what I can do.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Rex.
ReplyDeleteI don’t like this one on principal. Unclued answers, in any guise, pervert the prime XWD directive. The fun is in puzzling out clever often cryptic clueing. When the constructor ignores this fundamental tenet . . . So I solved this one while ignoring the so-called theme.
Having dispensed with today's puzzle in a few lines, I want to pose a deep philosophical question to the blog:
ReplyDeleteIs it possible for a tone-deaf person to get an earworm?
One of the downsides of not being a tone-deaf person is that I am just about never without an earworm, I don't get rid of the last one until the next one appears.
Which is fine when the earworm is "Loch Lomand" or "Losing My Mind" or "Some Other Time". It's not so fine when the earworm is "Lydia, the Tattooed Lady".
I mean, really!
I watched the Amercan Masters PBS show, "Dick Cavett and Groucho Marx" a few days ago and "Lydia" has been in my ear, in my head and on my lips ever since. All day. Even worse, all night. There are approximately 62,985 songs I like a heck of a lot more, but right now it's all "Lydia", all the time.
Tone-deaf people never have such problems, right?
Echoing Kevan Harris's comment, how does "Mr. Toad's Wild Ride" (95 down) end in hell per the clue for 83 down? Or perhaps I should ask "How the hell..."? The obvious "paleo" cross saved me from using the checker, but I had to hold my nose to punch it in. Anybody have a rational or at least literate explanation?
ReplyDeleteAmen EdFromHackensack... same. got it done but who has time to decode the “secret message”. Regarding RIRI/AMILLI - I made an educated guess. 1) that “RIRI” was Rihanna and 2) judging from the lyrics about money “AMILLI” seemed rappishly plausible. All in all a fun puzzle.
ReplyDelete@Nancy - Yes, we the tone-deaf do get earworms. Although your description of "just about never without an earworm" is not part of the deal (at least for me). I probably get a minor earworm once a week or so, and a major one (lasting several days) once a year or so.
ReplyDeleteAs I've mentioned before, I'm in awe of people who can listen to music and say that's in the key of D-major" or listen to two notes and say "those are six tones apart", while I can't tune a guitar without a device, because to do so manually you need to know which of two notes is higher than the other, so you can tighten/loosen the appropriate string.
Wondering the same thing as others, about Mr. Toad's Wild Ride ending in Hell.
ReplyDeleteGuess what? It's on Wikipedia:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mr._Toad's_Wild_Ride
...After winding through the cells, guests emerged out into Shireland, passing by a shootout between the police and some weasels (using red lights to simulate gunfire). Several of the police barriers then moved aside revealing a railroad crossing, complete with a ringing bell. The gate then moved aside (presumably breaking apart), and the vehicles made a right hand turn onto the tracks. The vehicles traveled along the railroad tracks until getting hit by a train (with guests seeing the headlight of the locomotive). A door then opened, revealing the underworld scene, in which there were volcanos, flashing lights, multiple laughing demons, and a giant flat of Satan that popped up (similarly to the dandelion in Alice in Wonderland). Afterwards, guests went through a door back to the boarding area.
That is one weird re-conception of what is a delightful story.
Whodathunk?
Dnf from HELL (literally) on the MR.TOAD clue. I had Home, then HoLe, finally decided there was some variant spelling of PALaO and settled for TOAD of TOAD Hall. Just couldn't convince myself a ride at Disneyland ended in HELL, even though I've had visits to Disney World that sometimes seemed like HELL.
ReplyDeleteVery lovely blogging this morning, Rex. Thank you for that and for your contribution to my life day by day.
@Kevan Harris, padraig - Mr. Toad's wild ride is great for kids. Towards the end, you enter a tunnel and collide with a train, which kills everyone, and you end up in the netherworld. Not literally, of course.
ReplyDeleteI'm surprised that Rex did not frown upon the great number of junk clues that ask the solver to replace supposedly quotable phrases or sounds with supposedly quotable phrases or sounds:
ReplyDelete7A "Uh sure"; 35A [I'm frustrated!]; 44A "Ugh!"; 119A "Anything for you!"; 62D [Is this thing on?]; 91D "Hmmm, gotcha"; 96D "Nice try, but I don't think so"; 106D [Grrrr!]; 108D "Eh, what can you do?!"
I understand having one or two clues/answers of this kind, but eight? "Ugh!" indeed. [I'm frustrated!] IMO, that's just poor cluing and fill, making this a very irritating puzzle to solve. And this by a puzzle editor for the NYT. "Nice try, but I don't think so."
Broccoli rabe (29-Down)? Never heard of it. Broccoli raab? Yes, I use that phrase all the time.
ReplyDeleteThe term originated from a Southern Italian dialect and became part of the Italian -American mashup of terms for Italian foods. I have always heard the 2 syllable version, usually without broccoli "I'll have a pint of rabe " spoken at the deli. But the one syllable version is certainly around. That comes from the fact that Southern Italian dialects reduce unaccented last syllables to a schwa and sometimes drop them entirely. So both versions live on in the US.
DeleteFWIW my four grandparents immigrated to the US from Southern Italy.
Naticked at the SAL BONSAI crossing. I always see salt as SEL (which is of course French, but..) so couldn't get to SAL and "bonsei" looked like it could be right.
ReplyDelete@Photomatte
ReplyDeleteFWIW, Broccoli rabe gets 4.2 million Google hits, Broccoli raab gets .5 million.
As one who lost two beloved cats recently, I was very moved by Rex’s insightful paean to Olive and the quotidian.
ReplyDeleteI just finished Hua Hsu’s great memoir, Stay True, which also deals masterfully with grief and the daily. It is one of the supreme memoirs I’ve read in my lifetime. (It’s justifiably on many top ten lists of the best books of 2022.)
As for the puzzle, I had mixed feelings, not crazy about the theme but found many of the clues and answers inventive, though a good number were overcooked, maybe?
SOUNDS GOOD/feels bad. I should probably like this puzzle more than I do because it gave me a good tussle to come up with a clean grid. RIRI and WELP were out on the very edge of the radar.
ReplyDeleteThe meta aspect of the theme was the biggest let down. I pretty much ignored the blanks in the theme clues while solving as the puns alone were painful enough. With the grid filled in I went back over the clues and saw that of course they spelled something out. This was interesting until it turned out to be just SOUNDS GOOD. That's what all this smoke and mirrors was for? YEAH NO sums up my reaction perfectly.
YD -0
I've always enjoyed Wyna's puzzles ever since her NYT debut, not quite 4 years ago. This Sunday is no exception. I had fun sounding out the theme answers. I will agree that SOUNDS GOOD isn't a real stunner although it is a nice bonus effort from the constructor.
ReplyDeleteWELP - I say this a lot but it doesn't end in a P sound, more like a nasally aspiration swallowing the L, far from the full swelling of WELL. I don't know if that's how everyone's version of WELP sounds or if it's a regionalism (or just me, though I doubt that).
I threw in lIPSTICK once I had enough filled in to see that potential answer. I read the clue again, said "huh?" and looked at the cross. Oh, DIPSTICK. I have used that as both an aspersion and a measuring device, har.
Rex, thanks for your daily efforts. I'm sending my annual contribution by mail so I can get the postcard!
@Wanderlust, from yesterday, thanks for all the great state jokes, kudos!
Three areas gave me trouble today. 1. The NW natick. 2. The HELL where Disney delivers kiddos instead of hall, hole, hill. 3. ASIANA x PASEO which should have been obvious…
ReplyDeleteI did see the phonetic feature which was helpful - cryptickish. I liked it.
Yay! For BONSAITREE, MODELTRAIN and DIPSTICK
Thanks Rex and @Iris for sharing your thoughts about ritual. I sometimes feel guilty about time spent on this ephemeral activity. I read somewhere that most of us suffer from a pleasure deficit. Working the puzzle and reading this blog and the comments help remedy that a bit each day. Thanks to all of you.
@Nancy — Lydia? My sympathies!
(Private message to Rex. I was going to use your email address, but I know how much I hate slogging through mine...)
ReplyDeleteThe photo of you and Olive struck me today, since I had been pushing a playful kitten off of my desk chair all morning. She is one of my foster cats who wants my lap and attention, but I have a rule that cats can't bother me at my desk. I don't have the patience that you have! If/when you are ready to adopt another feline friend, I would be willing to drive half the distance between us to gift you a healthy, spayed, vaccinated girl born April 16 at my house (Medina, Ohio). Her mom is feral, but Kathy is the opposite of her mother. She also fetches like a dog, dropping her toy at your feet for another round! (We spayed and vaccinated her mother and returned her to her neighborhood.)
Since we spend so much money rescuing cats, I can't afford to fund your blog work, but I can gift you a companion who acts very much like your Olive. If interested, feel free to call or text 330-635-1230. Best wishes, Donna Miller
Joe D's theme-driven appraisal of the puzzle at 12:42 a.m. is very funny and very clever.
ReplyDeleteHe gave me the solution off-blog. I'm not sure I'd have figured it out for myself -- but that's partly because I didn't bother with figuring out the theme of today's puzzle in the first place.
Joe -- You should put up the solution at the end of today's blog for anyone who didn't figure it out.
For the most part I found this one sloppy and un-fun. Agreed that AMILLI/RIRI is a fairly brutal Natick. STY and STYE should never occupy the same grid. The theme and revealer were too much work for not nearly enough payoff.
ReplyDeleteNo one has mentioned what I found the ugliest clue/answer pair: 72A, "Cherubic archer"/AMOR. In what world is a 4-letter answer to that clue not EROS? AMOR is not any person or figure I'm aware of—merely the Romantic-languages word for love. Someone got their love language wires crossed, methinks.
I did, however, enjoy seeing two hobby pursuits overlaid one atop the other with BONSAI TREE and MODEL TRAIN, and the clue on CARPOOL LANE ("Path covered with diamonds") was cute. But most of the fill I just found choppy.
One answer I will diverge from prevailing opinion on is WELP. It went in smooth for me, and I would argue that lacking familiarity with it suggests a deficiency in good-faith engagement with the way Actual People talk.
WELP, OHOK, IGUESS. DAM. Did on paper as usual for Sunday, no hints in the constructor's bio in the NYT mag, so was pretty proud to figure out SOUNDS GOOD all by my lonesome. Got the trick at 44A because all the crosses were in, sadly not the case in the NW with the noted Natick cross.
ReplyDeleteFor some reason the whole thing left me ... underwhelmed?
@Rex, I'll venmo you this week.
@me 12:42am – "solution":
ReplyDeleteNobel Prize category won by Obama + have debts + title character in a Beckett play (no not that one)
Peace + owe + Krapp*
*"Krapp's Last Tape" is the play
Thanks Joe. I was wondering who the Beckett character was, but was too lazy to look it up.
ReplyDeleteVillager
GNARLY and not in a good way. Definitely the worst puzzle of the year, if not several years. Or ever. I’m not going to waste any time explaining why. Those who solved this mess understand already. How could the NYT accept this at the expense of other better puzzles which were rejected. Obviously, being associate editor helped. That is not a good enough reason in my opinion…
ReplyDeleteA mutt is a cur but AUCOURANT is not pronounced with the cur sound. It’s more like the sound in Coor as in Coors Lite. The mispronounciation by someone with an English accent does not make it okay.
ReplyDeleteWelp, glad to see I’m not the only one with questions about Toad HELL. RIRI and A MILLI were in my wheelhouse, tho I can see them easily being Naticks if they weren’t.
ReplyDeleteGreat post today, Rex, and my condolences on the magnificent Olive. With my good boy being solidly in his golden years, I try to remember to treasure each quotidian moment, even when he wakes me up for food and a walk at 6 am in single digit temps. Anyway, I will put something in the pot next pay day. Grateful for this little corner of the internet!
@Joe D
ReplyDeleteDidn't know Krapp. Did you consider using the Dan Levy sitcom?
In the late 90's/Early aughts one could see a replica ECTOMOBILE driving and parked around Roseville, MN. IIRC, it was built on a GM A-Body Wagon platform. I never saw the movie, but that thong always made me smile.
ReplyDeleteI did not see any of that comment about the missing letter spelling out a word so I was left with a big HUH? Also though that SE corner was tough as someone else mentioned.
ReplyDelete@Smith… You and others seem to say that there is no note in the print magazine version of the puzzle. I always print the puzzle, and the only version available to print today was the "Newspaper Version"—even from the Standard Layout link. I noticed that the Inksaver option was not working and sent a note to the Times; a rep confirmed what was happening.
ReplyDeleteApparently the Times web producers can't figure out how to italicize anything in text exported from print to web, as the italicized answers would seem to be the only reason a regular Standard Layout, with Inksaver, wasn't deemed possible. I told the Times that I (a web producer for The Nation, who used to produce both print and web versions of a crossword in that mag) find this laughable.
But now you tell me that there was no note about working the puzzle in the upper left corner under the headline in your copy of the magazine. Since I'm looking at that box in my printout of the Newspaper Version, this seems a massive screw-up.
In the magazine print version, there IS a note but it does not include the instruction that Rex mentions he had in his version (he says it included, “Note: Each italicized clue contains a blank, which should be filled with a letter of the alphabet. When completed, the letters in order will spell out a two-word phrase.")
DeleteThe online version said this:
ReplyDelete"Each italicized clue contains a blank, which should be filled with a letter of the alphabet. When completed, the letters in order will spell out a two-word phrase."
But not every answer from the italicized clues were two word phrases. 44a is italicized. The answer is "Euphoria."
Can someone enlighten me?
@Anita 7:54 – it means the letters missing from all the clues, when strung together, spell out a two word phrase: S-O-U-N-D-S G-O-O-D.
DeleteEverything you need to know about "Krapp's Last Tape":
ReplyDeleteFor the life of me I couldn't remember Krapp. All I could think of, of course, was Godot. I think I blocked "Krapp's Last Tape" out of my mind for, like, forever, because I found it so completely unwatchable back in the day. I saw it in my early 20s down in the Village. It was on a double bill with "The Zoo Story" -- which fortunately was performed first. Otherwise I would have been long gone. I LOVED "The Zoo Story" -- definitely my favorite Albee play of all time. And then came this beyond-depressing (and totally plotless) depiction of a decrepit old man eating a banana and listening to a tape recorder -- I thought at the time: This is the worst play I have ever seen!!!! And nothing has happened in 50-60 years to change my mind.
@JC66 – I did not, but feel free to substitute + eponym for the town in a Dan Levy sitcom as the last part of the clue.
ReplyDeleteI did the puzzle in the magazine itself, and it was easy enough to figure out that the missing components represented letters that spelled out something, without needing an editor's note to explain. They do versions of this gimmick all the time.
Meanwhile, I liked this, from WS's constructor notes:
The thing she loves most about her job is "talking puzzles with other people who love them!"
Okay. But then it adds:
(That would be the rest of us on the Games team.)
Who else would we think she meant?
There was, I reiterate after several others mentioned it, NO NOTE IN THE PRINT EDITION. All we had to go on was the title, DO YOU HEAR THAT? I finished the whole puzzle without figuring out what the unclued bits were supposed to be. Annoying.
ReplyDeleteAlways (and I mean Always!) read but rarely comment. Doing so today to say thanks Rex for the community you’ve created. Venmo in progress.
ReplyDeletewow for once the print version didn’t give away the theme and had no such note and … I figured it out anyway ! I just … figured it out! By solving. No hints. Yay.
ReplyDeleteSeeing Rex gush over this one was painful. I found no pleasure in the solve experience; just slow tedious torture. Phonetically breaking down the fill and clueing the result should entail much more cleverness in the exercise.
ReplyDeleteU-Fore-Ick doesn't cut it. There's no solving joy in that (or at least little more than the typical wordsearch serves up.
For an extraordinarily talented constructor, I can see where this exercise might have been filled with opportunities to play. Maybe my mind dulled over too quickly to appreciate some latent word play here. I came away weary from a slog fest.
Given that cheerleader-supreme @Lewis hasn't chimed in today, I suspect he may have commandeered a portion of Rex's blog today.
(Apologies to those who savored the challenge today, and regrets to the constructor: in all other respects it was a very admirable effort.
Re @Rex, I feel his feline loss all too much. My wife and I have owned two cats through the duration of our 38 year relationship. The average age at which our cats have succumbed is 16, meaning that we're on our third set now. Cats so subtly integrate and enmesh themselves into your life that upon their loss it's easy to sense that you've lost a limb.
And, on the topic of Covid, we returned from a lovely cruise out of Puerto Rico on the 30th. Covid was on our minds and we took moderate protections. Nonetheless, on Jan 4 I suffered the onset of "cold" symptoms and modest fever. There's much to suggest that this infection may be the work of one of the latest variants.
The toll on my body is modest by comparison with my prior two infections: I was double vaxxed from the start; I refer to my first infection as the "immaculate infection" -- I was practically a hermit at the time. The second, a year later despite rigorous defenses while travelling, likely resulted when at the tail end of a cross country flight, I removed my mask for dinner and was drawn into conversation with my seat mate, never putting the mask on until touch down. (up to that point, I spend at least 14 hours of each day that trip masked.)
I simply fear some developing chest congestion in my current infection. I'm a two time loser to bacterial pneumonia (35 years and 15 years ago), I have doubts about my hardiness if tested by reinfection at this time in my life ...
Enjoyed the puzzle and love your cat photo, the UMN stormy kromer really adds to the goofy vibe. I'm glad you had such a wonderful cat. Hugs.
ReplyDeleteI solved the puzzle with no knowledge of any note and am glad of it, enjoying the challenge of figuring out what the blanks stood for. And at the end, I liked spelling out the "hidden" phrase. Enjoyed the whole thing.
ReplyDeleteApologies - I posted this to the wrong day initially. Lots on my mind!
ReplyDeleteRex, my sincere condolences about your cat. And I'm sorry to hear you are dealing with Covid. Nothing but admiration for you to continue to do what you do, every day, on this blog; despite other obligations and worries. FWIW, for me this is absolutely one of those rituals that offers solace during frustrating or scary times. (Today I'm dealing with TWO failed external hard drives, and feeling a little lost RN :( Many. many thanks, and I will show my appreciation as best I can with a donation.
Today's puzzle was tough for me. I find that there are some constructors that are easier and some that are harder to get in synch with, and today's is the latter. The first themer I got was "euphoric", one word; and I wasn't looking for two-word solutions on the others, so that got me stuck for longer than it should have. I solve on paper and there was no explanation but I thought it was pretty evident what we were looking for and that the blank spaces would spell a phrase, so that helped. The sound element to me was hard. When I hear a word I see it, spelled correctly, in my mind - and to disconnect from that and just listen to the sound was mind-twisting, but in a fun way. Okay, back to trying to recover my data!
As @Lori (above) said - "there are some constructors that are easier and some that are harder to get in synch with, and today's is the latter." Ditto.
ReplyDeleteLots of words/people/phrases I'm not familiar with. OROH, after a bit I did find that the "theme" helped with my solve. Is that a NONAPOLOGY? IGUESS
Not my favorite Sunday ever.
Diana, Lady-in-Waiting for Crosswords
Oh - one more thing. Hand up for "no notes" in my paper.
ReplyDeleteLady Di