Monday, April 25, 2022

One making a listing on Airbnb / MON 4-25-22 / Cartoon films like Spirited Away and Ninja Scroll / Mom to Jaden and Willow Smith / Military leader who lends his name to a Chinese dish

Constructor: Li Ding

Relative difficulty: Easy (apparently ...)


THEME: FOOD FIGHT (36A: Type of battle that 17-, 26-/49- and 60-Across might be engaged in?) — theme answers are FOOD-associated figured with military (i.e. "FIGHTin'") ranks in their names:

Theme answers:
  • GENERAL TSO (17A: Military leader who lends his name to a Chinese dish)
  • COLONEL / SANDERS (26A: With 49-Across, the face of Kentucky Fried Chicken)
  • CAP'N CRUNCH (60A: Cereal mascot in a naval uniform)
Word of the Day: Lucretia MOTT (7D: Abolitionist Lucretia) —

Lucretia Mott (nΓ©e Coffin; January 3, 1793 – November 11, 1880) was an American Quakerabolitionistwomen's rights activist, and social reformer. She had formed the idea of reforming the position of women in society when she was amongst the women excluded from the World Anti-Slavery Convention held in London in 1840. In 1848 she was invited by Jane Hunt to a meeting that led to the first public gathering about women's rights, the Seneca Falls Convention, during which Mott co-wrote the Declaration of Sentiments.

Her speaking abilities made her an important abolitionist, feminist, and reformer; she had been a Quaker preacher early in her adulthood. When the United States outlawed slavery in 1865, she advocated giving former slaves, both male and female, the right to vote (suffrage). She remained a central figure in reform movements until her death in 1880. The area around her long-time residence in Cheltenham Township is now known as La Mott, in her honor. (wikipedia)

• • •

I don't speed-solve any more. That is, I don't try to go as fast as I can. I don't time myself at all. I solve pretty fast because I have a lot of experience, but my days of clock-watching are pretty much over. I found it was inhibiting my enjoyment of the puzzle's, uh, let's say finer features (on days when it actually had them). But I understand the race and the rush, the obsession with personal records for each day of the week, etc. This is all to say that Paolo Pasco just posted his solving time for this puzzle, and it was 53 seconds, so chew on that for a while, won't you? 


That is the fastest time I've ever seen posted on a NYTXW. Ever. I'm not saying it's a record, because I don't know if there's any way to know, really and truly, but if it's not ... I don't know. There are only a handful of people on earth who can even break two minutes, and only a very very small handful who can even flirt with the one-minute mark. Now, under tournament conditions, you'd have to solve on paper, and breaking one would be well nigh impossible, but that's what they said about two minutes under tournament conditions, and that has now been done, so I don't know man. I just marvel at the greatness, to be honest. And the keyboard skills, my god, don't sleep on those. They have to be perfect for you to come anywhere near one minute. My fat fingers and dull brain only ever got to the low 2:20s on a NYTXW puzzle. I broke four minutes on paper under tournament conditions precisely once. And I am, ahem, a very good solver. So kudos (plural) to Paolo, and my condolences to his aspiring rivals in the speed game.


As for this puzzle: yeah, OK, this will do nicely. The theme is narrowly defined and consistent and kinda funny, insofar as the idea of CAP'N CRUNCH waging war with COLONEL / SANDERS makes me laugh (team CAP'N, for sure). The revealer is a clever way to bring the whole thing together. Not sure what else to say. I tried to think of military ranks that the theme left out and I just can't do it right now, off the top of my head. Are there privates or admirals or corporals or majors who have given their names to foods? You'll let me know. Very lucky that these military foodies happen to fit snugly and symmetrically in the grid. Nice find. 


The fill holds up well. I really thought the puzzle might play slow because of all the long Downs in the corners, but because they were clued very easily, I think those long Downs only made the puzzle play faster. You can knock out lots of territory very, very quickly by working the Downs, bam bam bam (bam) in those corners. My only hesitation came when I came up blank on my first pass at NAIVETΓ‰ (12D: Gullibility based on inexperience). I had the -ETE and with no way to know that it was an -ETΓ‰ and not an "-eet" pronunciation, I had to reach up into the short Acrosses in that NE section to get some help. I also balked slightly at SLUSHY (22D: Like winter roads during a thaw) (I think SLEETY came to mind first), and I definitely had SNIT before SNOT (a word I would not put in a puzzle for any reason ever, gross) (56D: Annoying little squirt). 

Notes:
  • 51A: Work in clay or marble (SCULPT) — that's twice in two days for this not-terribly-common word. Weird coincidence. There was a period of about 13 years where SCULPT didn't appear even once (2008-21).
  • 42A: Humble reply to "Nice job!" ("I TRY") — once again I am asking you to stop pretending that this comment is actually "humble." The normal response to "Nice job!" is "Thanks." "I TRY" is some passive-aggressive self-martyring / self-aggrandizing. Stop.
  • 41D: Nickname for Las Vegas (SIN CITY) — also the actual name for a multi-volume Frank Miller comic (and subsequent movie franchise)
  • 57A: Really bothered (A TEAT) — I just wanted to write A TEAT, because that is how my brain parses it when I see it in the grid, and if I have to see it, so do you. That's how it works!
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]

112 comments:

  1. Anonymous12:13 AM

    (1) Would have liked HUNGER GAMES better as a revealer
    (2) Needed one more leader- any pirate-named cereal around? (to balance the 2 chicken guys)
    (3) re: Pasco. He can construct really good puzzles (IMO) and can solve the puzzles of other constructors really really fast. What do they need me for?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Easy-medium. Cute and amusing with great corners, an excellent debut and POW at Xwordinfo. Liked it a bunch!


    @bocamp - Croce’s Freestyle #702 was on the easy side for a Croce. It helped that the show that replaced “Hill Street Blues” was in my wheelhouse. Good luck!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like to tackle Mondays by looking only at the down clues, which is a real nice changeup to the week. I made it today in 24 minutes... that's right, a whopping 24 minutes. Mainly because of having PENSION for retiree's income source... seriously, how could PENSION possibly be wrong? It even fit with GENERAL TSO and ANIMES.

    Anyway, my "down only" process kinda made me miss out on the quality of the puzzle, as Rex and Jeff Chen both noted (Chen's POW!). I read only half the clues, so my loss... gain some, lose some, oh well. Can't help thinking of a Marvel comics super group (like the Avengers) with the Colonel, Capt., and General, fighting... the munchies?

    Has REBUS ever been clued as the Ian Rankin protagonist? According to xwordinfo.com, no!

    [Spelling Bee: Sun. 4 min to g; then p at 7:25; then QB much later, somehow guessing these 2 words that I've never seen before.
    My shortened week, Tues to Sun: 0, -1, 0, 0, 0, 0 (shortened because no internet out at the cabin on the long weekend). Missed this word on Wed.]

    ReplyDelete
  4. 53 seconds, WTH! How?
    I couldn’t enter gibberish across the grid that fast!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Back in my speed solving days I routinely broke the 1:00 mark on Monday thru (some) Wednesday puzzles, and on a few Mondays I even broke the 0:30 mark. This was using the NYTX app on an iPad.

    Good puzzle solving skill was crucial, of course, as was adeptness on the keypad, but my real secret was a big ol’ hit of crystal meth right before I started.

    ReplyDelete
  6. 1:34 EDT and no comments...
    My last few have been eaten by the European firewall (at least that's my son's take) - some things get through and others do not.

    @Rex my fastest Mon time as recorded by the NYT is 1:40. That's on my phone. And of course a Monday. Weirdly I think it would be faster on paper, because on paper I can read another clue as I'm filling in one I know.

    This puzz was cute! Liked it more than yd. Hello, SCULPT, my old friend from yd. Having the revealer in the middle meant the rest was obvi.

    Majo nanosecond error from *not reading the whole clue* road for LESS.

    ReplyDelete
  7. SharonAK2:05 AM

    Fun and easy.

    But 53 seconds? There must be an on-line puzzle app unlike the NYT one I get . How could anyone go that fast the way the damn thing moves the clues out of sight.

    Actually, I normally print it out and do it in pencil, but my printers on strike.
    I particularly liked naivety.
    Didn't even see win city and aladdinfilled them with crosses
    time for bed noe.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Fun puzzle. Though not a perfect fit, I would have liked to have seen General Mills, who produced tons of food items over the years.

    ReplyDelete
  9. A fun Monday puzzle which I enjoyed. I love GENERAL TSO’s chicken and I make it often. COLONEL SANDERS, meh. Never had CAPN CRUNCH cereal. The revealer FOOD FIGHT made me laugh.

    Good start to the week.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hundreds of dishes named after persons, but I could come up with just one legitimate themer: Major Grey.

    (Clued perhaps as That apocryphal British officer who "relished" his Indian curry?)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous11:05 AM

      YES!

      Delete
    2. Anonymous5:02 PM

      Yes, Major Grey Chutney, delicious, I have a jar in my fridge right now!

      Delete
  11. Thx Li; good solid early week puz! :)

    Med+

    Tues. time for me.

    Couldn't see the LOAF for the slices. lol

    Top to bottom solve, ending in SILENCE.

    Fun solve.

    Another great NYT Acrostic puz yd! :)

    @jae

    Thx; on it later today! 🀞

    @okanaganer πŸ‘ for a bunch of QB's! :)
    ___
    Got this word in the SB yd (had to look up the def). Coincidentally, shortly thereafter I was watching the last part of 'Death on the Nile' ('78), when Poirot had occasion to use it.

    yd's: pg -1 (missed this one) / Duo: 34/37 / Sedecordle: 18/21 / WordHurdle: 3 / Phrazle: 3

    Peace πŸ™ πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡¦ ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness to all πŸ•Š

    ReplyDelete
  12. OffTheGrid5:46 AM

    I enjoyed the other food items in the grid. LOAF, Rye, ACAI, BLINI, ROLO, TEA, & SLUSHY.
    And then there's FEEDME. What a great Monday!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Anonymous6:12 AM

    This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Why did the lawyer object to the 36a clue?

    Because it was a Li Ding question.

    Pretty nifty Monday puzzle. Too bad the Pow! presages doom for the rest of the week. But here:
    This will put you in a good mood.


    Phrazle 22: 2/6
    🟨πŸŸͺ⬜ 🟩🟩 ⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜🟩

    🟩🟩🟩 🟩🟩 🟩🟩🟩🟩

    ReplyDelete
    Replies

    1. Oops, my Phrazle didn't post properly. And my Preview capability is gone. Weird. Let's try again.

      Phrazle 22: 2/6
      🟨πŸŸͺ⬜ 🟩🟩 ⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜🟩

      🟩🟩🟩 🟩🟩
      🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩

      Delete
  15. Very clever and never-done-before theme; credit to Li Ding for picking it out of the ether. And while there may be a food fight going on, this grid is spotless. There were also some lovely stops along the way, with SCULPT, LAGGARD, OCEANIA, NAIVETE, and GET THIS.

    LOAF crossing FEED ME reminded me of a Bible story, and how often do you see a Monday puzzle with five REBUS squares?

    A debut that felt like the work of a veteran. Bravo on this, Li Ding. Thank you for the fun!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Wordler7:08 AM

    I still do Wordle while others seem to have moved on to more complex forms of the concept. Feels like still being on dial-up. Anyway I was starting to get bored with the Wordle but today's turned into a challenge that almost gave me a headache. Managed a 4 though, so happy outcome.

    Wordle 310 4/6

    ⬜⬜⬜⬜🟨
    ⬜🟨🟨⬜⬜
    🟨⬜🟨🟨🟨
    🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩

    ReplyDelete
  17. I honestly can’t tell if this is an absolutely brilliant puzzle, or it’s just that yesterday’s was so bad that anything was going to look good by comparison. Probably a bit of both.

    I really, really like the theme. But I do think there was a lot of crosswordese, not just in the fill but in the cluing. Things like “berry in a smoothie bowl” and “sports replay effect”, if encountered in the real world, might not be obvious. But we’ve seen similar (identical?) clues often enough in the NYTXW that they may as well be filled in for us.

    ReplyDelete
  18. My five favorite clues from last week
    (in order of appearance):

    1. Mist a spot? (5)
    2. Name spelled with six dashes and six dots (5)
    3. It goes hand to hand (4)
    4. Joe carter? (6)(3)
    5. Guacamole go-with? (4)


    SPRAY
    MORSE
    CLAP
    COFFEE URN
    HOLY

    ReplyDelete
  19. Laura7:23 AM

    Fun puzzle. My favorite clue was wizards playing with magic. Of course this is a staple xword type of clue, but my mind went racing off to dnd? RPGs? I'm probably too old to know the latest term. Couldn't wait to see the answer until I got a boring N to give away the answer.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Fun puzzle - had an elegance not typically seen early week. I liked the long downs - LAGGARD, NAÏVETΓ‰, IMPALES are top notch. Not sure whether things like BLINI and FEED ME are there to support the theme or just unfortunate fill.

    Don’t like the SINES plural - thought JADA adjacent to FIGHT was interesting.

    This old earthquake is gonna leave me in the poor house

    Enjoyable Monday solve.

    ReplyDelete
  21. "Bacon or Hamm" made me laugh; it's nice to see a little playfulness with the clue that still leaves it perfectly workable.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I don’t time myself often, but my NYTX record is around four and my Newsday record is around three. Sub one is beyond impressive. Here’s the Tweet if you want to see responses from some noted speed solvers as well as the constructor.

    Debut you say? Also impressive. Normally the mid puzzle revealer is a bit of a downer, but the lookie loo clue had me skip past the middle section and I ended up finishing there. A genuine chuckle moment at the revealer. The fill couldn’t avoid a few moldy oldies, but is generally pretty good, fun theme, good revealer, clean fill. One cannot expect much better. I especially like that we have three solid themers, no stretching to four or five themers that are then not as solid and also tax the fill. Well done.
    πŸ‘πŸ½πŸ‘πŸ½πŸ‘πŸ½πŸ‘πŸ½πŸ‘πŸ½

    @Anoa Bob -54A’s clue made me think of you.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Anonymous7:44 AM

    53 seconds, heh heh. I could type lines of X's, and it would probably take me that time.

    This was fun. Who knew the "military" offered such tasty food? Reminds me of a M*A*S*H episode when the camp was complaining about the food... Hawkeye finally rebels, "I've had a river of liver, and an ocean of fish. We want something else! We want something else!"

    Colin

    ReplyDelete
  24. @Wordler - I do Wordle every day, the others most every day. Broke my streak by saving Wordle for bed time and then not getting to bed until after midnight (blrrrgh), and I’ve had two DNFs since then. I’ve been using the same starter for a couple of weeks, followed by “pound” if the starter gives me zilch. My last DNF I had -O-ER and went through three or maybe even four wrong words.
    Wordle 310 5/6*

    ⬛⬛🟨🟨🟨
    🟨⬛🟨🟨🟨
    ⬛🟨🟩🟩🟨
    🟩🟩🟩🟩⬛
    🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩

    ReplyDelete
  25. Anonymous7:58 AM

    ACNE and SNOT did not pass the breakfast. Good for Rex to swear off speed solving. I’ve always found it silly.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Wow, is it possible they are seeping their marbles at the Old Gray Lady over by Times Square ? After yesterday’s C**b*** insult to good taste, they decide to go with SNOT today ? No, it’s not a felony offense, but really - the optics just aren’t good.

    Other than that, pretty much all you could want on a Monday - clean, well-clued and fair.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Finished this and thought "great puzzle for getting someone interested in the NYTXW", very smooth and playful and they could learn some crosswordese without really trying, and then I went back to look for some good examples of --ese and couldn't find any. Imagine my surprise.

    Only (teeny) nit was the revealer in the middle, but it was still a nifty revealer.

    Pro tip for speed solving: Don't solve on paper, don't type. Look at the clue, say "I know that one", and move on. If you're a speedy reader this should get you a solve in under thirty seconds. Or you could try the @John X method.

    Unusual to see a REBUS on a Monday.

    A debut? Cool. Congrats to you. LD. Only Lightly Demanding but a Lovely Debut. Keep 'em coming, and thanks for all the fun.

    ReplyDelete
  28. George8:11 AM

    Wow... I loved this puzzle and was hoping Rex would. I actually chuckled at the revealer, and who doesn't love CAPNCRUNCH? (Years ago my brother-in-law was coming for a visit and I asked what he liked for breakfast and he responded CAPNCRUNCH; I had no idea that an adult would eat that.) And almost no BS little crossword-ese nonsense filler!

    ReplyDelete
  29. Perfect start for Monday. Love the word GAUDY. Was a Dorothy Sayers fan, creator of the English crime solver Peter Wimsey. One of the books is "Gaudy Night."
    Would have been a bonus to include in the puzzle the word for where this military FOOD FIGHT may have occurred: MESS.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Anonymous8:26 AM

    GENERAL TSO and COLONEL SANDERS could use a dash of SGT PEPPER.

    I am just a regular solver. My “goal” on Monday’s is to break 10 minutes, for example. But my NYT app has glitched a few times and shows my best time for Tuesday is to be 1:17, and for Wednesday to be 4:26. Those times, for me, were totally bogus.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Oh boy! Now we're going to get a slew of posts about people's "times" doing the puzzle, My question: could there possibly be a more boring, or more honestly phrased, "who gives a sh*t" question?

    ReplyDelete
  32. Good Monday puzzle. Even Rex liked it! As to 53 seconds… as others have said, I don’t think I could fill in a grid with random letters in 53 seconds with the NYT app. Wow. But did he like it?

    ReplyDelete
  33. It takes me longer than 2 minutes just to read and process the clues, let alone type them in.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Thank you for your content btw. I love it.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Robin8:50 AM

    You can get gibberish whack-a-doodle times on your NYTXW solve if you're wifi acts up.

    Statistics on the NYTXW website clais that my best Saturday solve was 2 minutes 4 seconds. Yeah, sure.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Anonymous8:52 AM

    I’m thrilled when I can solve the day’s mini in under one minute!

    ReplyDelete
  37. Skeptic8:56 AM

    Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Without such, I cannot readily believe the 53 second solve time claim.

    ReplyDelete
  38. What an adorable and very smooth puzzle! And I made it even more entertaining for myself by trying to guess the themers ahead of time. Epic (but funny) fail.

    I already had GENERAL TSO, though I hadn't written in TSO yet. I had the "OOD" of FOOD FIGHT, knew immediately what the answer would be, and I tried to guess who the "battle" combatants might be. So I put the puzzle down -- out of sight -- and ran a list of military titles in my head. I got COLONEL SANDERS immediately. 14 letters. Couldn't think of any majors or lieutenants or admirals. Sergeants? Oh, yes, of course! SERGEANT PEPPER! 14 letters!!!

    I'm thinking that SERGEANT PEPPER will win the FOOD FIGHT because the GENERAL and the COLONEL won't be able to see. Their eyes will be burning something fierce. Can pepper be considered a "food". Oh well, you know that the NYT can sometimes be permissive if it's a good cause.

    I never got to captain, btw, in my list of military titles -- so I never thought of CAPN CRUNCH. It's much better, of course, and works a lot better with the other themers. But I think my answer is more fun.

    A delightful Monday with an inspired revealer. Wish I'd thought of it.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Steve "The Breev" Kaleev9:26 AM

    @bigsteve46, if you don't care you can just elect not to participate in the conversation, instead of telling other people that something they enjoy is dumb. It's not hurting anybody. My personal best for a Monday is 3:56. Hoping to go under 3:30 someday!

    ReplyDelete
  40. I heartily agree with Rex's comment about 42A: Humble reply to "Nice job!" ("I TRY"). My husband, who is now my estranged husband on the way to becoming my ex-husband, used to say "I try" every time I would say, over dinner, "You're such a good cooker!" (Yeah, I said "cooker," as per my inimitable adorableness.) And I would always think of Yoda, and wish my husband would just say, "Thank you."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Amen, @Mike in Bed-Stuy! My other most un-favorite and hideously overused “non-respinse” is the person in the workplace as some sort of a service worker (fast food and other stores are good examples) who, in response to my sincere “Thank you,” says “No problem.” And perhaps that’s just the cranky old person in me, but what ever happened to “You’re welcome?”

      Delete
    2. @CDilly52 11:27 AM - πŸ‘

      Delete
  41. Hey All !
    Nice puz. I think y'all are hung-over from YesterPuz, as this one is good (and a nice debut), but seems to be getting over-praised. My two cents, and what-not. YMMV. 😁

    It is filled quite cleanly. It was pretty easy, as most MonPuzs are, but not Under-a-Minute easy. My time came in at 7 minutes and change, as I actually don't like to fly through a puz. I like to read all the clues, even the auto-fill answers. I'm weird that way.

    Nice open corners. The consonant run of JSB in JSBACH was neat to see. Nice Boggled ROO with an extra O in center. Har.

    yd -8, should'ves 5 / Duo 35/37 (missed 1-5-6) / Phrazle 3 (πŸ‘)

    Three F's
    RooMonster
    DarrinV

    ReplyDelete
  42. Tada!!!!!

    Phrazle 22: 2/6
    ⬜🟩⬜ 🟩🟩 🟨⬜⬜🟨⬜πŸŸͺ

    🟩🟩🟩 🟩🟩 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
    #phrazle

    ReplyDelete
  43. Gee, I actually enjoyed the write-up today as much as the puzzle, maybe for the first time. That's saying something considering that the puzzle was so good. Happily, yesterday is now long forgotten.

    It's anybody's perfect right to speed solve, but frankly I don't see the point. Except that it gives you more time to solve more puzzles.

    ReplyDelete
  44. I’m with JMS…. I couldn’t type in any fill that fast. In fact I once solved a Thursday NYTX on paper, then entered it in the app. It took me 1:59. I counter that with the time I left my computer on in the middle of a Wednesday solve, came back like nine hours later and the clock was still going. That’s my longest solve time ��

    But, hey, the was a good Monday puzzle with a fun and humorous theme.

    (What’s with all the Wordl comments in a NYTX blog? Am I missing something?)

    ReplyDelete
  45. Puzzle of the Week no LESS. What a splashy way to make your debut. Congratulations to Li Ding!

    I liked the playfulness of this with using a GENERAL, a COLONEL and a CAP’N. Not much of a challenge but that’s okay, it’s Monday.

    I doubt many Boomers ever see, hear or think the words FOOD FIGHT without seeing John Belushi.
    See if you can guess what I am now. 🀣


    ReplyDelete
  46. @Skeptic - Understandable reaction. Note from my previous link that other speed solvers aren’t questioning the feat. Feyer put some examples of him speed solving on youtube awhile back:

    A nearly one minute solve
    A whole week under 20:00 (I hadn’t seen this one. There’s an earlier one on youtube as well)

    Agard and Pasco have dethroned Feyer, I believe, as the fastest solvers so the 0:53 is actually doable. Not by you and me, but I can’t run a four minute mile or speed solve a rubik’s cube either.

    ReplyDelete
  47. The theme was fine; I missed Captain Morgan, the spiced rum guy, but I think they were trying not to duplicate ranks. Sailor Moon, maybe?

    But two things really bothered me:

    1) ANIMES. I admit this isn't my thing, but that strikes me as maybe the worst POC ever.

    2) SOFIA/JADA. No idea about either. I guess Will Smith is they guy who slapped someone else during the Oscar ceremony, but his mother? SOFIA or SOFIe? I finally decided that the mother of Jaden was more likely to be JADA than JeDA. Whew, that was a close one!

    ReplyDelete
  48. Another paper-saving Monday puzz, filled in my head.

    ReplyDelete
  49. Anonymous9:58 AM

    This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  50. @Rex No no no no no. I ate Cap'n Crunch last night (with stupid almond milk because my cat turns into a feral terror if cow's milk is anywhere in the house), and it was heavenly, but nowhere near the bliss of a bucket of fried chicken. I have given up eating most meat for health reasons (and a persistent nagging sense it's factory-facilitated murder), but fried chicken is my Siren's song. I blame society.

    Also, great puzzle. OBSCENE and SINCITY crossing ENYA seems like a trifecta of evil in the southwest. :-)

    Yay: GETTHIS
    Boo: JADA

    ReplyDelete
  51. Anonymous10:02 AM

    See, now, the revealer told ME that the link was in the 'first' word of the answers, so FIRE is what went in. Military space and all. What with Ukraine going on, and all. Of course, "Animal House" is today's earworm. Or the near-end of "Blazing Saddles" (TCM, last night). I can't help it; the bean scene still cracks me up.

    ReplyDelete
  52. 53 seconds? Paolo cheated, somehow. He must have.
    I like that Rex no longer times himself. When I rush through the puzzle I enjoy it alot less. I always equate it to eating a good meal. Does it taste any better if you eat it fast?

    ReplyDelete
  53. The Cleaver10:06 AM

    @okanaganer:
    seriously, how could PENSION possibly be wrong?

    Given that they don't exist anymore here in the USofA ("you're on your own, hoi polloi!")??? Make America Poor Again. Scopes was a criminal!!!

    ReplyDelete
  54. I do recommend putting CAP'N CRUNCH in your ice cream sundaes. Mint chocolate chip ice cream, hot fudge, Cap'n Crunch and a cherry.

    ReplyDelete
  55. Anonymous10:08 AM

    @JOHN X.:
    my real secret was a big ol’ hit of crystal meth right before I started.

    goes well with strawberry puree.

    ReplyDelete
  56. Anonymous10:19 AM

    New record time for me at 2:20. I had seen last night's Tweet and came in with an expectation of how easy the puzzle might be, but frankly, I've had easier, more free-flowing solves that actually took longer. Left more than a handful of acrosses blank on the first pass, and had to grind a little bit to fill in some of the bigger gaps. Some good guesses along the way, but Scat for SHOO and image for PHOTO were snags.

    0:53 just seems otherworldly.

    ReplyDelete
  57. This was a nifty little Monday and I liked the idea of the theme infinitely more than I like any of the food mentioned. Yuck! Now, @Nancy’s Sgt. Pepper is much healthier option.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Nice Monday, but of course anything would be a relief after Sunday. But once again the dreaded Monday POW is hovering.

    Speed solving...I usually fill at least two or three words across when they should be down, and vice versa, so I will never be entering that contest. Last week I filled a 51 across in the last line of the puzzle and after 5 minutes of making no headway, I discovered there was a 53 across clue hiding from sight.

    ReplyDelete
  59. What fun! This one had everything I look for in a Monday (and quite honestly cheered me after yesterday’s slogfest), and it even had some Monday (Cap’n) crunch. One of the construction elements that caught my attention was the care our constructor took to choose clues that purposefully skewed Monday.

    I confess I get a touch irritated when a Monday flows along nicely and then comes to a big ol’ pothole caused by a constructor’s inability to stick to the Monday-ness of a puzzle, and I find myself scratching my head As I finish a Monday, I usually think of it in terms of those solvers for whom the day marks their first ever “no Dcheat solve,” and I give them all a little mental cheer. I predict this one will have some well deserved self-congratulatory cheers.

    Thank you, Li Ding. Just a delight!

    ReplyDelete
  60. I loved it - a theme so simple yet so inspired and funny + a stellar cast of supporting entries. Thanks to those who pointed out all of the other FOOD references in the grid, along with Bacon and Hamm in the clues. Still laughing.

    Do-over: writing out CAPtain and running out of room. DNF: deleted the -ain from the preceding, leaving me with the incorrect CAPt CRUNCH and hence, "Where's the SNOT everybody's talking about?"

    @amyyanni 8:15 - Another Sayers fan here who thought of "Gaudy Night" :)
    @Nancy 9:02- Thank you for adding to the fun with your Sgt. Pepper scenario.

    @Li Ding - What a terrific debut. Very much looking forward to your next one.

    ReplyDelete
  61. My FOOD FOR THOUGHT:
    A metaphoric phrase that soothes the digestion question of "Who puts ketchup on their hot dogs?"
    You give me a sweet little Monday with a bunch of edibles and I smile. Isn't MOTT some applesauce?
    Can you BROIL or BISECT a little LOAF of BLINI and enjoy it?.... or is that too OBSCENE? Will I feel LAGGARD after all is said and done? Should the ACAI STEMS be IMPALED with some GAUDY looking SNOT? Sometimes SILENCE is ROSIER.

    Oooh...I just peeked at @Nancy's post: YES....YES! Peppers come in all kinds of edibles morsels. You have green, red, yellow, purple, hot....SERGEANT PEPPER should get you a POW!

    ReplyDelete
  62. Wow, 53 seconds. How is it possible? With digital (finger and computer ) tricks?

    This one was just cute, fast, and fun.
    (Mondays often feel fast and SO dull.)

    And as for fast - used to do puzzles on paper with no thought to speed, but this darn NYT app kinda forces me to rush to beat previous speed, as πŸ¦– said. In doing so, letters often end up in the wrong places and the time it takes to fix often ends up the same as on paper - and less fun. So maybe I’ll turn it off or just not care.πŸ€—πŸ‘πŸ½πŸ€—

    Cheers for a good Monday!
    πŸ€—πŸ¦–πŸ¦–πŸ¦–πŸ¦–πŸ¦–πŸ€—

    ReplyDelete
  63. Joseph Michael11:09 AM

    A delicious treat from Li Ding. Congrats on the debut.

    Experienced a moment of PTSD as I filled in S-C-U-L-P-T and suddenly began to relive the horrors of yesterday’s puzzle. Fortunately none of the words today end in -CKET so there were no other triggers to prolong the trauma. I was finally able to move on with my life and enjoy the puzzle.

    Favorite answers : LAGGARD, SLUSHY, and FOOD FIGHT.

    Favorite clue: “Bacon or Hamm,” which is not only clever but also echoes the FOOD theme. Too bad there wasn’t room for Halle Berry or Jack Lemmon.

    ReplyDelete
  64. The NBA is where Wizards play with Magic (5D), but it’s also a place for a backward RECAP (50D).

    Does CDC (53A), which I think is an initialism, also count as a palindrome? Better than tons o SNOT! Sorry, I know that’s OBSCENE.

    Is the regular broadcast, at normal speed, done in MO? NorMO?

    Nice debut, Li Ding. It provided me considerably more than 53 seconds of enjoyment.



    ReplyDelete
  65. @bigsteve (8:28) Discussions on solving times put me to sleep too. I sort of get it but to me it would take all the enjoyment out of the experience. I like to sit down with my coffee and take my sweet time.

    @Mike (9:27) “My husband, who is now my estranged husband on the way to becoming my ex-husband.” Been there, done that. Painful but necessary. Hoping all turns out for the best.

    @Joe and @Nancy (Phrazle) Wow!! Impressive.

    ReplyDelete
  66. What a delight! This one had everything I look for in a Monday (a delightful antidote to yesterday’s slogfest), and even had a touch of (Cap’n) crunch. As a long time NYTXW solver, I confess part of its continuing allure is the predictable weekly escalation of difficulty and the traditional daily expectation for themes, trucks and challenges.

    I truly appreciate our constructor’s care with clues today. The fill is more creative than many Mondays, and the clues were carefully chosen to keep to the puzzle’s Monday-ness, yet the puzzle didn’t feel like just another easy Monday; artistry afoot, for sure.

    When contemplating a Monday NYTXW, one of my first thoughts on completion
    Is always, “are there likely happy first time no-cheat solvers today?” I’d bet yes today. The care Li Ding took to keep the fill and the clues more vibrant than many Mondays with a consistent, humorous Monday theme impressed me, and I gave a mental shoutout to this for whom this puzzle marks that special solve.

    Kudos to Li Ding; I imagine that constructing a vibrant Monday puzzle such as this is in its own ways every bit as challenging as creating a tough Saturday. This one made me smile. I look forward to more.

    ReplyDelete
  67. @Joe / @Nancy (I knew you'd do it!) πŸ‘ for Phrazle 2's

    @Zed (9:46 AM)

    Thx for the Feyer vids. Amazing! :)

    Good points! What people are capable of should never be underestimated! Case in point: the world record (in competition) for Rubik's Cube (3x3) is now 3.47s (51 secs into vid).
    ___
    td pg: 4:58 (0 in ?) / W: 5*

    Peace πŸ™ πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡¦ ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness to all πŸ•Š

    ReplyDelete
  68. M&A wnodered hw mucj of his commment herehe could writ eoutin 53 secs. On the othe h anad I suspecthat Paolo dude"s slovquestin nanoseconds aer lomger then officill M&A nnaoseconsd. .

    satff we eject pick :

    **** end of 53 seconds worth of M&A blog postin ****

    ta da! Not bad, for hunt-n-peck data entry. Behold, mere mortals!

    staff weeject pick was gonna be: CRO. Looks the most like somethin that coulda turned up in M&A's 53-sec comment text. M&A blames that there "we eject" typo on an Otto Correct re-interpretation, tho.

    I think Capn Crunch could take em. Carries a machete, or somesunch.

    fave moo-cow eazy-E MonPuz clue: {Desert watering hole} = OASIS.

    Thanx for the slightly crunchy fun, Li Ding dude. And congratz on yer kick-ass debut.

    Masked & Anonymo6Us


    **gruntz**

    ReplyDelete
  69. Addendum to earlier comment: as for time solving, my only goal is to finish. Period. The only time I ever really pay attention is on the days I have no wavelength connection to the constructor and the solve takes the whole dang day.

    ReplyDelete
  70. @anon 8:26 -- and a dash of Colonel Mustard
    @egs -- Good PACER catch!

    ReplyDelete
  71. Thanks to @Carola, @GILL, @Hartley, @bocamp and @Whatsername for their various shoutouts about various posts of mine today -- all of them appreciated.

    ReplyDelete
  72. I'm still waiting for Will Smith to show up in the comments to tell Li Ding to "Keep my wife's name out of your f*cking puzzle!"

    yd -0

    ReplyDelete
  73. Skeptic12:19 PM

    @Zed. I watched the Feyer video. Not convincing. It appeared to be the opposite of SLO MO.

    ReplyDelete
  74. Anonymous12:19 PM

    @bocamp:
    the world record (in competition) for Rubik's Cube (3x3) is now 3.47s (51 secs into vid).

    I've always wondered -- are such records based on a specified starting distribution, or just some random shuffling, presumably by sequestered control? and thus 'records' really aren't comparable. unless it's been demonstrated that X number of shuffles (from the solved distribution) yields a distribution (of tile distributions) which is equally difficult vis-a-vis all others of at least X shuffles.

    ReplyDelete
  75. Admiral Bill Johnson, Naval Academy Superintendent12:47 PM

    CAP'N CRUNCH is actually a Commander

    ReplyDelete
  76. My fastest Monday time is 3:53 done on a laptop with the NYT app. It was a puzzle I'd done on paper first, and I was curious how fast I could redo a puzzle. I can't even imagine doing one in under a minute! The fastest I've done a Monday sight unseen is 4:36. I've been doing old puzzles and it was a March 1998 Monday.

    I thought this was a very cute puzzle with a tight theme. Never noticed the cute NBA clue!

    ReplyDelete
  77. I've been wondering for years who's army would win: General Tso vs Colonel Sanders. Never thought to turn it into a puzzle; good on you, Li Ding!

    I was solving on paper for a while there, then typing in the answers to keep streaks going. I think of myself as a fairly fast typist, but my best was 1:07 not even needing to look at the questions. I think the maneuvering around (tab, space, arrow keys) requires some practice to really get your speed down. WOE with the :53?

    Could Professor Plum be a military leader?

    ReplyDelete
  78. Anonymous1:42 PM

    REBUS- one McEntire

    ReplyDelete
  79. I think that 34 black squares is the sweet spot for a themed puzzle. This allows enough room to balance the theme material with quality fill, as happens today. The theme doesn't overwhelm the grid space plus we get triple stacked sevens in all four corners and all those were top quality entries that you might expect to see in a themeless. Yeah, I did notice the two for one POC at the end of 13D 35A IMPALE and SINE but in the service of such interesting surrounding fill it is more than justified and beyond reproach, even to an inveterate POC hunter like me.

    From time to time I see fellow commenters either praising or criticizing the puzzle constructor for how clues are written. Let me remind yous again that without direct knowledge there's no way to know for sure whether a clue is the constructor's or the editor's. In my experience, clues are where editors are most likely to make changes, so the default responsibility for clues should be the editors'. Or as I've mentioned before, we could follow crossword luminary Tyler Hinman's dictum, If you like a clue, give me credit and if you don't, blame the editor.

    Yep Zed @7:35, I definitely sat up and took notice of 54A REBUS. It has made a grid appearance 24 times during the Shortz era and has always been clued as a "Puzzle type with pictures" or some close variation of that. Early on it got a couple of clues relating to the old TV game show "Concentration" which required contestants to decipher picture clues to suss out the correct sentence or phrase.

    And never, not once, has REBUS been clued as a puzzle type with multiple letters in single grid squares.

    I believe that one day, probably far into the future, during more enlightened times this practice of misusing REBUS for puzzles with letters or words in individual squares will be referred to as the Rebusgate era.

    ReplyDelete
  80. Feyer doing a Rex puzzle (August 17, 2010 if you want to try it first).
    More Feyer here, but spending an afternoon watching speedsolving is fairly nerdy.
    @Skeptic - Is your first name Thomas? There’s an actual timer visible at the top of the screen.

    @puzzlehoarder - πŸ˜‚πŸ€£πŸ˜‚ - I had a similar thought flit though my mind as I solved.
    @12:19 - I’ve always wondered the same.
    @1:42 - πŸ€£πŸ˜‚πŸ€£ - Rebopodes - a Reba family.

    ReplyDelete
  81. Anonymous2:14 PM

    I can’t finish a puzzle in under a minute and I can’t drink 64 beers on a cross country fight. Apparently there are people who can do those things. God Bless ‘em.

    ReplyDelete
  82. Anonymous2:28 PM

    LOL.
    Thomas (from ta'am) means twin. Neither Feyer nor Pasco is Messianic, so the doubting comment is, well, inapt at best.
    As for the time, so what? There's little question he entered the letters that fast, but who's to say he didn't have them written down so in fact all he was testing was his typing skills.

    ReplyDelete
  83. For his 1.08 time, Dan seemed to stumble a few times; I have no prob w/ Paolo's 53.

    @Nancy (11:47 AM) :)

    @puzzlehoarder πŸ‘ for -0 yd! :)

    @Anonymous (12:19 PM)

    Good points!

    This is why, in the top tournaments (including world championships) the following is the norm:

    Scrambles - what are they?

    "The time it requires to solve a cube depends on the scrambled state of the cube. Some are easier and some are harder than others. To make it all fair, five random states are generated, as well as the moves that should be applied to a solved cube to get to that state. All competitors submit their own cube and the scrambles are applied to their cube. This way, everyone gets the same five scrambles and everyone has the possibility to exploit the easy situations that others have too." (Xomnia)

    Here's a record performance over an avg of five solves. (5.207)
    ___
    Peace πŸ™ πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡¦ ~ Compassion ~ Tolerance ~ Kindness to all πŸ•Š

    ReplyDelete
  84. Roscoe2:57 PM

    If you're ever in New Haven, be sure to try a hamburger at LOOIE'S LUNCH.

    (OK, that one doesn't work.)

    ReplyDelete
  85. Frazzled by Phrazle3:29 PM

    Joe DiPinto, as you introduced me to Phrazle, I’ll cry on your shoulder. As soon as I enter a phrase, all of the entered letters disappear from the keyboard. (I use an iPad). This is very frustrating. I contacted support and was asked to send a screen shot but haven’t heard back. Any suggestions? TIA.

    ReplyDelete
  86. Here I was enormously pleased with my 3:33.. 53 seconds?! Phew.

    ReplyDelete
  87. Anonymous3:43 PM

    Roscoe,
    New Haven has always been home to lunatics and lesser institutions. But Louis lunch takes the cake. Their no ketchup policy isn't just absurd it's a deal breaker for a lot of folks.
    Want lux et veritas? Head to Ted's in Merdian. Waaay better than the crud Yaleville.

    ReplyDelete
  88. All I could think of was Private Stock Beer (malt liquor).

    ReplyDelete
  89. [Spelling Bee: td pg in 2:40... 1/10th the time the xword took me. (Beat you bocamp!)
    I wonder if Paolo does the SB; he could probably get pg in 53 seconds as well.
    Got to QB in about 15 minutes; no goofy words today for a nice change.]

    ReplyDelete
  90. 22 seconds!! I mean I solved in less than 10 minutes at 9:22. Than’s holding my breath and bugging out for breaks, too fast for fun.

    ReplyDelete
  91. @Frazzled – I have no idea why that would happen. I do it on my android and I think the letters on the keyboard turn whatever color they are in the current guess, but I haven't really paid attention. They certainly don't disappear. When it's completed the keyboard letters that are in the solution are all green and the ones not in the solution are all white. Hopefully support will figure out the problem and fix it for you.

    My online weirdness for today is that I'm not getting the usual message box to post in on this blog. I get a solid blue line, with a Publish button underneath, but the Preview button is gone. This is when I'm in Mobile mode. Web mode looks the same as it always did. Has this happened to anyone else?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @Joe Dipinto Yes, the comment box is sorta broken on my Android Chrome browser.

      Delete
  92. Anonymous8:41 PM

    @3:43

    not just Louis.

    search with "burger with no ketchup policy"

    and you'll get a raft of joints. personally, I only put ketchup on scrambled eggs. YMMV.

    ReplyDelete
  93. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  94. LateSolver9:54 PM

    I agree with Rex in that I, too, have stopped paying attention to my solve time. I do not read fast, I do not type fast, and reading the comments here were causing me anxiety. So I stopped reading your solve times and just went at my pace and the fun came back (except for the cryptic / smarter than you clues of the young constructors who just use software to build their puzzles and ignore the commonality of the answer and/or clues)

    ReplyDelete
  95. Very enjoyable Monday. Took me longer than my usual Monday. I only try rushing when it starts to fill in quickly. Otherwise just plod along and enjoy. and sip Joe. Never was much of a typer anyway. I was amazed when I saw a 2 thumb typer hit 72 words per minute on the old phone keyboard.

    Pepper (spray) vs. Mustard. I think pepper wins. But if it's mustard gas we have different winner.

    Had a hard to see tap-in for a 3.
    Wordle 310 3/6*

    🟦⬛🟦⬛🟦
    🟧🟧⬛🟧⬛
    🟧🟧🟧🟧🟧

    ReplyDelete
  96. Anonymous4:44 PM

    I thought ate it for really bothered

    ReplyDelete
  97. Rex is mellowing out. He found this one to be okay. And he doesn’t time his solves anymore because it cut into the enjoyment and appreciation of the puzzle. Something we’ve been telling him for ages. Speed solving is fine. But it’s the difference between a nice leisurely walk on a beautiful day and a 100-yard dash at the track.

    ReplyDelete
  98. Having never timed my NYTXW solutions (hey, I'm retired. I remember rushing--not that fondly), I am pleased to see OFF finally giving it up, though with a few back-pats thrown in. Do I believe Pasco? Well, I have no experience save on paper with pen, so it's hard to imagine what can be done on high-speed devices. I guess I do; why else would he mention it? I just now read an article about "quantum internet." Frightening. Soon the prime number list will approach a googol, plex to follow.

    But yeah, today's did seem to go rather quickly. I was first struck with more openness than I usually see this early in the week. Fat corners. The theme didn't TRY to do too much; just three examples (one split into elegantly equal parts) plus a central fun revealer. Who can forget

    "See if you can guess what I am NOW!" *SPLURT!!* "A zit!!"

    The puzzle is further enhanced by co-DOD's crossing each other: SOFIA Vergara and JADA Pinkett-Snith. ENYA, stuffed away in the corner, can only muster an honorable mention.

    She is part of a gaggle of Xwordese to infest this otherwise beautiful grid. ATE/EAT AT was a poor awkward partial the first time; there have been FAR too many reprises of that one. SLOMO is catching up, unfortunately. These, however, merely rob our debuter of eagle possibilities. Birdie.

    I stumbled to a bogey today:

    YBBBB
    YYBYB
    GBGBY
    GGGBB
    GGGGG

    P.S. Tried Phrazle once and decided it was too hard for me.

    ReplyDelete
  99. Diana, LIW12:10 PM

    @Foggy - well put! I'll take that fine walk through the neighborhood vs. a run at the track any day of the week. (Unless it's raining/snowing/hailing, etc.)

    I and my morning cup of coffee, with Lambo's assistance, finished off this puzzle in a leisurely manner. @Spacey - I find ATE/EATAT in puzzles going back a long, long way. (I have filled in many, many anthologies in an attempt to catch up with all of you 40+ year solvers!

    Diana, Lady-in-Waiting for Crosswords

    ReplyDelete
  100. Burma Shave12:11 PM

    ITRY TO GETTHIS . . .

    SOFIA dresses GAUDY, RITE?
    With GENERAL NAIVETE TO FIGHT;
    OBSCENE AT lunch
    with CAP'NCRUNCH,
    "IT's OLD COLONEL SANDERS every NITE!"

    --- JADA BACH

    ReplyDelete
  101. rondo1:54 PM

    Nice to see OFL getting off of speed. It kills.
    Was no trouble to GETTHIS puz.
    What LIES in the corners!?!

    Birdie in wordle
    BYYYB
    BBYYG
    GGGGG
    After 26 tries: 2 deuces, 11 threes, 10 fours, 3 fives

    ReplyDelete
  102. Son Volt: I agree! "Keep my wife's name out your ------- puzzle!"

    ReplyDelete
  103. Anonymous5:24 AM

    This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete