.png)
Relative difficulty: Medium-Challenging
THEME: "Downright Tricky!" — six theme answers travel down and then veer to the right; the reason is explained in the clue for EL CID (108D: Spanish hero whose 113-Down is represented enigmatically six times in this puzzle) — i.e. the theme answers form six ELs and all the ELs are three-part phrases where each part begins with "C," "I," and "D," respectively:
Theme answers:
- 8D: Lament about modern men (CHIVALRY IS D/EAD)
- 13D: Pachelbel classic, familiarly (CANON I/N D)
- 32D: Major African humanitarian concern of the 2000s (CRISIS IN DAR/FUR)
- 38D: Like the contents of many attics (COVERED IN DUST)
- 50D: 1982 holiday country hit by Alabama ("CHRISTMAS IN DIXIE")
- 71D: "Right away, boss" ("CONSIDER IT DONE")
Word of the Day: PICARO (100D: Rogue) —
n., pl., -ros (-rōz', -rōs').
- A rogue or adventurer. Also called picaroon.
- The main character in a picaresque work when that character is a man or boy.
Read more: http://www.answers.com/topic/picaro#ixzz35yjdOs9v
• • •
_01.jpg)
The fill here is mostly solid and graceful (I'm just ignoring AAAA … though it pairs nicely with BBB). There's also tons of interesting little tidbits throughout, like MS. PAC-MAN and I HAD A HUNCH and PADDED BRA and HOG CALLER and MOSH PIT and whatever SEA HOLLY (12D: European coastal plant once thought to be an aphrodisiac) and SPIKED ACES (17D: Ray-finned fishes of the Southwest U.S.) are (whoops, that's just one word: SPIKEDACES). There were all kinds of pesky little stumbling blocks in this one. Right out of the box I face-planted on 4D: Quince, e.g.. I can see a "due" misdirect coming a mile away, but got blind-sided by the Spanish word for "fifteen." Had BANTER for BICKER. Imagined Hollywood was in CA and not FLA. And on and on. Highly pleasing—one of the best NYT Sundays I've done in a while (not the highest bar, but still, dang good).
Puzzle of the Week goes to Zoe Wheeler this week for her American Values Club Puzzle, "Flexibility" (get it here for $1 / read about it here). The AVC is starting to pull away from the pack a little in terms of overall quality (though every week Fireball is right there too). Zoe's puzzle just has a perfect reveal—theme elements are a great visual representation of a well-known expression. You can't ask much more from a themed puzzle—especially from a relatively easy themed puzzle. Easy- to Medium-difficulty themed puzzles are some of the hardest to do well. Cleverness and easiness are tough to combine. Not that American Values Club puzzles are "easy"—they tend to run in the Wed.-to-Fri. level range for me. But Fireball puzzles (also great) tend to be routinely Saturday-hard, so the two puzzles contrast one another a bit, and together provide nice coverage of the themed puzzle difficulty gamut. Nearly every week I find myself solving AVC and Fireball and thinking, "this would've made a good NYT Thursday."
ReplyDeleteWhen I saw Byron Walden's byline, I HAD A HUNCH this will be a duesy and my early ESTIVATE was spot on.
Outside of VIKE, HSIA, AAAA, BBB, A NEGG and a few GEDS, ESPs and ISPs here and there, this was an absolutely enjoyable puzzle.
The theme was great, and the best part, it took some work to get to aha! I had to work my way to the very bottom when I finally figured out the EL-shaped C*I*D* down&right phrases with CONSIDER IT DONE and said: aha! See what I mean?
All the theme phrases worked perfectly, the only thing missing was the lack of symmetry for COVERED IN DUST and CANON IN D, a small price to pay for such a severely restricting design. What makes such turns a little easier to solve is that the letters in the tail end of the phrase are triple-checked, with the exception of the corner letter.
But what the heck are SPIKED ACES? Never heard of such fishes. And how is A SINK black?
When I saw "Not flat nor sharp" I was sure it was going to be NATURAL. Boy, was I wrong. It was a PADDED BRA. Byes, TATAS. Kaput, PFFT.
Do you remember the book "I'M OK, You're OK" and its sequel, "I'M OK, You're Not"?
I never patronized a NAZIERA pizzeria.
I had log roller before HOG CALLER, but learned a few new words: ABSCISSA, PICARO and ESTIVATE, this last one quite inferrable: from Lat. aestas, aestivus meaning summer, of summer, the flip side of hibernate, from Lat. hibernus for of winter, as in Hannibal hibernates in BEAR FUR. That's why Romans started to use the phrase "There is CRISIS IN DAR FUR."
This lovely little Violin Sonata, KV 31, was composed by Mozart at AGE TEN. And guess what, it is in B-FLAT MAJOR.
THANKU, Byron.
Have a safe weekend everyone, and make sure you use a CONDONE.
Black as ink
DeleteLay an egg
But I had pushupBRA and wonderBRA first
I didn't get this. At all. Well, I got that answers were going to turn right after going down, thanks to the title, but even when done I had no idea what the hell EL CID had to do with anything. This was a themeless for me.
ReplyDeleteThere was lots of other stuff I didn't grok. Didn't get how quince equaled NUMERO until Rex mentioned Spanish 15 (at which point I thought, I don't remember that in the puzzle at all). I prefer my quince poached with honey and vanilla.
Naticked twice (giving me a two DNF spots: ESTIVATE (huh?) and EVIE (who?), and ABSCISSA (huh? again) and COO (don't get how that partners with Bill - or is it bill?). Two of those answers feel positively Maleskan, and those two crosses could each feature multiple letters (I had EdIE Sands, for example).
A couple writeovers slowed me down for a while: I had aetNA instead of CIGNA, and annual PHYSICAL fits in the same number of squares as YEARLY PHYSICAL.
There were some nice bits - it was good of Byron to give the TATAs a PADDED BRA, and HOG CALLER was nice - but in the end there was too much personal obscurity in theme and fill for me to enjoy this one.
bill and coo is what doves do
DeleteBitch and complain is what I did over this puzzle! At the end DNF and did not give a flying f!
DeleteGrrrrrrr
Easy-medium once I figured out the "Down Right Tricky" part, kinda tough before that. Liked this a lot. Clever theme with a very smooth grid given the constraints. HSIA/AAAA is not pretty, but that's about it.
ReplyDeleteWOE: PICARO
Minor erasures, but I seem to frequently confuse the first names of Jannings and McGregor.
A tricky Sunday is a good thing!
I did it. 2:05. First Sunday with a perfect line score: 000. [Googles, cheats and errors.]. I'd say it took a month of Sundays, but really, it took two. 60th try was the charm.
ReplyDeleteIt came down to E_IE crossing ESTI_ATE. D, L and V were looking good. I went with V as I just liked the sound of ESTIVATE better than the others. Ok, it was a lucky win, but I'll take it.
I had serious trouble with PASSEDON/MOLD/THANKU/ILK. I probably spent 20 minutes ruling out [Relayed] PASSEDit and I HAteU (which sounded like it could be an Alanis Morrissette tune for what little I know of her). Whew.
I almost blew passed MAINER for [Down Easter] then recalibrated for the national audience and brought it home. Here in a Maine, Down East starts on the east side of Penobscot Bay, or it is a relatiive direction.
I got the EL theme in ELCID, but missed the CID part. Thank you, @Rex, for the meta reveal.
Overall easy-medium plus ESTIVATE/EVIE and PASSEDON as clued, both of which were medium challenging here.
@SteveJ. Marilyn McCoo and Billy Davis Jr. ? Atl least that was my rationalization. Same rabbit holes with aetNA and annualPHYSICAL
ReplyDelete@SteveJ: "Bill and coo" is a sweet old expression for the actions and sounds made by lovebirds when they are making out. Birds.
ReplyDelete@AliasZ - it is, I believe, "Black AS INK."
ReplyDeleteGreat puzzle! I got the theme at CONSIDERITDONE, but had to go searching for the sixth theme answer - which was the CANONIND (I also thought CANON I made sense at first.)
ReplyDeleteAnd the last to go in was ESTIVATE - never heard of that before!
And ABSCISSA came out of the depths of my memory bank!
Mark is right about Bill and Coo, but I was right there with Casco Kid. In fact, I cannot believe I can't find any reference to them as Bill and Coo.
ReplyDeleteI loved the theme. For some reason it is far more gratifying to grok long answers, and this theme created more than most puzzles. And you have to love that an El Cid themer would include CHIVALRYISDEAD, FILMINDUSTRIES and PICARO.
As a rogue, El Cid fought for the Christians, then the Moors, and finally set up the pluralistic state of Valencia.
Did this one at the beach yesterday. No problem with the grid, except at 109 A had WYNN DIXIE before WINN ...
ReplyDeleteSaw, but didn't count, the Ls, which I expecxted the minute I saw the title, but utterly failed to see the C-I-D, and never got past CANON I.
But it was a very nice beach day.
First you are going to make me run the alphabet and then go past plausible guesses like ELIE or EDIE or even ERIE to get to ESTIVATE. What a way to finish.
ReplyDeleteOtherwise a tough but doable Sunday. I went looking for the Els, but didn't count, so missed CANON IN DBID. Odd little name, but what do I know about the peculiarities of Pachelbel lovers?
Got nailed with the V in estivate. I went with an N to match hibernate. Never heard of spikedaces so the S was a guess and I thought it continued into a right hand turn. Bah!
ReplyDelete@Casco - Well Done!
Congratulations @Casco Kid. I thought he puzzle and the theme were great but hand up for recognizing the right turns from the title and CHRISTMAS IN DIXIE and CHIVALRY IS DEAD early gimmes but did not get the C-I-D part until I read @rex this morning. Had a good night's sleep not knowing how amazingly clever the puzzle really was. Thank you Mr. Walden.
ReplyDeleteHand up for getting the Down Right but had no idea what El Cid had to do with it. Too many things I did not know so a lot of googling.
ReplyDeleteHave never, ever had a hot pocket!!!
@Casco Kid Congratulations!
ReplyDeleteLike others, I saw the L shapes but found only four of them. And I'm embarrassed to say, like @Steve J, @Bob, @chefbea, and @RAD2626, I totally missed the phonological play on EL CID. Man, oh man. And I love that kind of trick. I just thought in the end there was something about EL CID that I was unaware of, some kind of literature thing. Now that I'm able to C It, Damn, I am impressed!
ReplyDeleteThe two I couldn't find - CANON IN D (I, too, thought CANONI was acceptable) and COVERED IN DUST. I can't believe I missed that. I HAD A HUNCH can turn right, too, so I kept considering that one.
I really liked the five bending themers that redirected the last part (CONDONE/..IT DONE, FUR/DARFUR, etc). DIXIE was the only one that didn’t.
@Steve J, @Casco, @Hartley70 – Yeah – ESTIVATE/EVIE is a really tough cross. I guessed right but considered "estidate/edie."
@Bob – me, too, for "Wynn" first.
Rex - nice catch on the AAAA and BBB pair. Think the average solver CCCC PADDED BRA crossing DD? (Hey, go big or go home, right?)
So is CHIVALRY DEAD among PICAROs?
I initially had "mancala" for MAN CAVE since I've never played.
And "image" for USAGE. Shame on me for that one. I do try to keep up with the language edicts handed down by the Style Powers that Be. Hopefully, I'll get it next time. ;-)
ESTIVATE – where has this word been all my life? I guess I'm a world-class estivatress; when that hot weather sets in, I just want to stay inside, do absolutely nothing, be grumpy, and count the days until that first chill shows up in the air again. Textbook case of Seasonal Affective Disorder – it's just the opposite of most sufferers. I even love it when it gets dark at 5pm. Probably was a mole in my former life.
Byron – this is one I'll remember for a long time, YES INDEED. I love your puzzles.
Best Sunday puzzle in a long time! ESTIVATE was a gimme for me, but it took a while to catch on to the down + right idea, even though ESTIVATE went through two of the L's. Never noticed the C.I.D. pattern until Rex pointed it out to me. Too bad the bottom L's are not all pronounced differently (i.e. DONE and CONDONE), but it's cool that three of them are.
ReplyDeleteI got the Down + right from the title, but wasn't expecting 13D to be one -- so I put in CANON D, figuring maybe the lazy music lovers left out the 'in' -- but BLIND BID finally fixed that, and the rest was tough but fun.
ReplyDeleteOnly it was only after the grid was full and I went back to mark all the theme answers that I saw the C.I.D. thing -- up until then I that rogue at 100D as a PICARON.
The best part of the puzzle, though, was the proximity of PADDED BRA and BEAR FUR. Now that would be a garment.
@Casco Kid, congratulations! As for Down East, I think it's relative -- when I head to Stonington to ESTIVATE, my affectation is to say I'm driving down to Maine. I've heard the term comes from the prevailing wind direction, back when most coastal transport was by sailing ships.
Very fun. Caught the right turns pretty quickly and that helped. Did in Across Lite (normally do Sundays on paper) so liked seeing Rex's lovely L's in the write-up.
ReplyDeleteBravo, Byron! This is such a clever, tightly done theme ... and taken to a higher level than most with the inclusion of CID in of all the "L" shapes -- downright tricky, indeed! I mean you can love it just for "L's" without even seeing the CIDS!
ReplyDeleteFantastic clues for MANCAVE, AWFUL and especially the total update for IKE alluding to a very modern Facebook like button.
PADDEDBRA brought a smile.
I learned ABSCISSA and also looked up PICARO where I also learned that a female rogue is a PICARA! You know who you are!
Anybody else have SPAREbEd before SPAREKEY?
I really loved this one!
Loved this puzzle- also had spare bed before spare key. But PFFT? Really?
ReplyDeleteI imagine a HOT POCKET to be a flaky outer layer of Monsanto with a gooey Monsanto interior.
ReplyDeleteUnlike this delectable Sunday confection by Mr. Walden. The way Sunday crosswords ought to be.
MS. PACMAN wants a BBB PADDED BRA for her TATAS? (sorry 'bout that folks.)
ReplyDeleteVery enjoyable puzzle. THANK U, Mr. Walden.
Well that was fun, and tough - although not as tough as the Walden byline had us fearing.
ReplyDeleteFinished the puzzle, but only found the L five times (figured old Pachelbel might have cooked on the side and improved on the Canoli). Like others, we never even noticed the CID trick.
SPIKEDACES? had to fill almost every letter - have visiting Texan who never heard of the blasted thing - where do they swim?
Big shout out to @CascoKid. Heartiest congrats - may all your Sundays be as joyous.
Challenging. DNF. Must remember 3 rules:
ReplyDelete1. Run the entire alphabet, even if you already have a plausible answer ( EdIE x ESTIdATE).
2. Read all the clues, even if the word is already filled in from crosses (EL CID).
3. If the theme leaves you with "Is that all there is?", look again, especially if the constructor is Byron Walden (EL C-I-D).
Wow, this took me a long time, but I really enjoyed the rasslin'. I struggled with new words - SEA HOLLY, SPIKEDACES, tricky clues (MAN CAVE), wrong ideas (beaDED BoA), tough crosses (CIGNA x NOMAR), and the theme - finally saw the right turn in CRISIS IN DARFUR (explaining BEAR FUR instead of BEARskin).
Even though I went through and found all of the right-turn answers, I never saw the C-I-D pattern. Fantastic, Byron! (Waaaaa! Wish I'd seen it!)
Thanks, @Rex, for explaining and @commenters, for the many smiles.
When I got CONSIDER IT DONE and the EL CID revealer, I thought there was going to be phonetic "sid"s on the theme answers.
ReplyDelete@joho, I thought SPAREbEd but never wrote it in. KEY made itself known from ANGRY which gave me Black AS INK.
ReplyDeleteSPIKEDACES, ABCISSA and ESTIVATE all involved lucky guesses for me, what they call in Los Angeles WAGS.
Good on ya, @Casco. You see, persistance pays!
One day, I was listening to my favorite classical music radio station and there was this lovely lilting melody meandering away. As it was about to resolve for the first time, there was the sound of an explosion where the final note should have been. The anouncer said, "You have just heard Pachelbel's Cannon." I pulled that trick on a producer who asked for that piece of music over part of one episode. He didn't get the joke but the other people in the room did.
WINN DIXIE, I used to shop there in Alabama so no Y in it for me. In New Orleans, they have a huge liquor section, not just wine and beer, but then ONE can buy hurricanes in drive thrus in NOLA. I had a hard time walking down Bourbon St after drinking one of those, I can't imagine trying to drive.
I got the "downright" part of the theme early onn and did see the CIDs in the answers but never considered the Ls until I read Rex. Very clever, very tight, very good!
Rex, spikedace is really a contraction of Spiked Dace (being an avid fly fisher I knew that one right away).
ReplyDeletePADDED what? Sorry, does not compute, I'm unclear on the concept...
ReplyDeleteI do remember being at a FRAT party years ago where one young lovely was holding forth on the condition of advanced curvitude, very likely since, for a college girl, she had quite a handsome endowment herself. I wouldn't have retained this memory but for the fact that she wrapped up her dissertation with a sigh and the observation, "It's SUCH a responsibility!".
Like to think I've been fairly responsible, myself.
So I see we got the LEG PAD and the BRA PAD, but PASSED ON the Thai PAD. Too bad, as that's one of my favorites. Would also have liked Tom to have been our LEHRER.
Had Lord Byron stuck with the BRITCOM C.I.D., I might have had a hope. As it was, looking around the corner was the last thing on my mind; it'sall I can do just to ESTIVATE.
THANKU for another chance to marvel.
Medium w/one error. EdIE. Error was my fault. I've seen ESTIVAL in puzzles before and I know I've seen EVIE Sands before. Nice to see a solo effort from Walden; feels like it has been aeons. Hopefully, he has some Saturdays in the pipeline. I found 5 of the L's; no clue on Pachelbel; never heard of him. Also, did not pick up on CID theme. Second time I've seen SORB, so committing to memory. Tough clues for MANCAVE, QUINCE and FLA. Liked it.
ReplyDeleteYep, liked it a lot. Historically appropriate, as followers of El Cid frequently would comment on his propensity, while on the march, to make Hard Rights without any notice.
ReplyDeleteFor real. It was
C
I
T
E
D
I
N
D
I
S
P
A
T
CHES.
M&A
Am alarmed that @BobK has no puz to work today. Permit me to offer him up this, my first in a new set of daring runtpuz experiments...
www.xwordinfo.com/Solve?id=4581&id2=371
It's alive! It's alive! [maniacal laughter ensues]
Poor old Hannibal sure is pulling double duty these days, is he not?
ReplyDeleteQUINCE was my favourite clue-pair, since I love number puns, esp in different languages. That made another reason to like the play on CONDONES, since that advo-cates 'safe sechs'.
Have a glorious weekend, all y'all.
@M&A
ReplyDeleteSpanish, not French, I'm thinkin'
Either I'm getting much better, or this was easier than most. THANKU< I needed a boost!
@M and A
ReplyDeleteTI {Sometimes M and A ends up with it backwards.}
Attached is a @Leapfinger-edited, more better version, of today's runtpuz...
ReplyDeletewww.xwordinfo.com/Solve?id=4583&id2=819
Wrong again, M&A breath. (A -phobia of mine)
As ever,
no refunds.
M&A
@Casco, your my hero. Well done!
ReplyDeleteAs usual I agree with @SteveJ, didn't enjoy. I did know bill and COO, but the ESTIVATE, HSIA, EVIE area was brutal. Had vILE before BILE , which gave me vouchBID?. That section took forever due to that misstep.
Liked the long answers everywhere. Some of the L's ending on black squares and some just ending in the middle of other answers seemed arbitrary and less than ideal to me. Probably couldn't be helped though.
In the end, challenging and barely in the did not like column.
@M and A
ReplyDeleteHow is
www.xwordinfo.com/Solve?id=4583&id2=819
different from
www.xwordinfo.com/Solve?id=4581&id2=371
@Mark: Thanks. Never heard that expression before. Add another to my list of things that were foreign to me (which is not the puzzle's fault) with this one.
ReplyDelete@Questinia: Would you like some Cargill sauce with your Monsanto pie?
@Casco: Nicely done. Especially on a puzzle that most everyone is describing on the challenging side.
@Mohair Sam: Apparently SPIKEDACEs are primarily in Arizona and New Mexico. Never heard of them either, but I was eventually able to get it with crosses. Needed pretty much every cross to do it.
Very PICAResque puzzle, was in need of some of dat dar furbearance.
ReplyDelete@r.alph: Well, first up, all them weird little numbers in the file names are pretty different...
ReplyDeleteAlso, M&A had to correct a word in the 12-Across clue. In first published version, he had mis-spelt "foreign" as "French". [uncomfortable "har, right"]
M&A
"Doin IT Backwards Since 2014"
Way to go @Casco! Congratulations!
ReplyDeleteSurprised others found this harder than medium. Maybe enough was in my wheelhouse that it just seemed easier than it really was to me. So far it looks like my time will be the fastest I have ever had relative to the published NYT times.
ReplyDeleteTried CHIVALRY IS (dead) as a rebus first. Left the D to be resolved later when the rebus made no sense, ditto CANON I. Soon figured out what the "downright" from the title meant.
Lots of good fill and a masterful theme. Theme: I did not notice the CID feature of the theme and was pleasantly surprised to see this wrinkle when I read this blog. Made 108D something of a puzzler - even looked up EL CID's real name to see if that helped. No.
Hand up for loG roLLER. And for liking Quince => NÚMERO. And for learning SPIKEDACES.
Thanks, Mr. Walden. Good one.
It bothered me that some of the L-shaped answers like CONSIDERITDONE and CHRISTMASINDIXIE ended at a black square but others didn't, like CANONIND, which I read as CANONINDBID and thought I was wrong for a while. My biggest error was having WONDERBRA for 100-A at first. Also thought 4-D had to be a fruit.
ReplyDeleteI am an estivating school teacher, so that was easy, and don't know who Alabama is/was, so Christmas in Dixie was tough, loved remembering Bram Stoker, and my yearly physical is about four decades overdue. Very nice Sunday puzzle; pleased that I remembered what a mosh pit is. I promised a friend that I would confess that I made a mistake on Friday, ruining a long winning streak. I had "BEGS" instead of "BUMS," which made sense, but I never double checked the "pea brain," or I'd have seen that "Gendel" wasn't right. MENDEL! Hang my science teacher head in shame...
ReplyDeleteMedium for me. Like so many, I never saw the C I D until I came here! No googles (there wasn't much need as most answers were phrases or pretty common). Didn't particularly like it or dislike it. It was just sort if there.
ReplyDeleteI am really bad at proof reading! "of"
ReplyDeletegot lost at WINNDIXIE, i'm no southerner. Instead of COXING, I had rOwING. I didn't know DARA, so it was a natick for me. Finally got it by googling "Alabama." Hadn't heard the term BRITCOM, I like it. Never figured out the ELCIDs til I looked at this blog. I didn't know MANCAVE was a game. Was slightly miffed that some of the "Downright"s didn't end at the last square. Still not sure about HOECALLER, Hoe-downs?
ReplyDeleteWhat a great gimmick, the six els containing C-I-D phrases. But I think that it should have been telegraphed more clearly than it was. It seems that very few of our savvy group saw it.
ReplyDeleteWhat does IHADAHUNCH have to do with Spider-Man?
I am in a*w*e, Mr. Walden. Thanks, @Rex for wiping the mist from the mirror. 1:23, a bit longer than avg.
ReplyDeleteC4H10O, on my screen,but I guessed ESTER anyway. Thanks a lot, ton. . .but not MIL until very late.
Me, too, for beaDED BoA, annual before YEARLY, mantissa before ABSCISSA (knew it was math term, & it fit). Before I saw the right turn thing, wanted the African tragedy to end in wAR, but that gave me NO wOGS at the pool, & that don't work.
Hard,but not too, & that elegant design!
@M&A - Just got back from the beach (where I actually did about ten of the miscellaneous old Xwords that I routinely print out from G Barany, A Kravis, E Agard, B Tausig, P Broda, S Newman, WSJ et al.), haven't gotten up to date on all comments, but when you supplied a runtpuz just for me (?), had to do it. 3:04, lightning speed for me, slowed a bit because I AHed at the puppies before I AWed at them.
ReplyDeleteThanks for thinking of me.
Way too tricky for me. So the towel was hurled in early. Am too new to these kinds of puzzles to become anything but irritated. But I do ultimately admire the construction and the ability off the solvers who contribute to this blog. Congrats to all.
ReplyDeleteThank you for including the Jim Gaffigan bit on Hot Pockets in your post. As soon as I filled in that clue, I sang, "HOTPOCKETS" and giggled.
ReplyDeleteDid this one in fits and starts. Down time for World Cup. Cruel finishes both.
ReplyDeleteIn most cases, when I get stuck and put the puzzle down for a few hours, it falls quickly. Not this one. Took three grind-it-out sessions to wrestle it to the ground.
Even then I naticked at the EVIE/ESTIVATE crossing. Do I (dimly) remember correctly a singer named Tommy Sands from the, what?, fifties? sixties? Didn't fit anyway, so there's that. EVIE I'll just forget; ESTIVATE I'll add to the lexicon. If I solved on a computer, the absence of Mr. Happy Pencil would have prompted me to try again (and again, and again) until I got it. As a paper solver, however, I just had to turn it in and hope for the best, which, in this case, wasn't so good.
Stupidly had Expo as a Minnesota player. Isn't Montreal the capital of Minnesota (or maybe the other way round)? I do know it's cold up there from August to June.
Writeovers: the aforementioned expo/VIKE; annual/YEARLY; lot/MIL; satS/GEDS; ALIa/ALII.
The Downright (L) gimmick was clever; incorporating the CID element makes it brilliant. Good one Mr. Walden.
This week's relative difficulty ratings. See my 8/1/2009 post for an explanation and my 10/15/2012 post for an explanation of a tweak I've made to my method. In a nutshell, the higher the ratio, the higher this week's median solve time is relative to the average for the corresponding day of the week.
ReplyDeleteAll solvers (this week's median solve time, average for day of week, ratio, percentile, rating)
Mon 5:17, 6:04, 0.87, 4%, Easy (9th lowest ratio of 233 Mondays)
Tue 8:33, 8:33, 1.00, 50%, Medium
Wed 9:40, 9:40, 1.00, 51%, Medium
Thu 15:15, 17:32, 0.87, 24%, Easy-Medium
Fri no data
Sat no data
Sun 36:02, 28:08, 1.28, 91%, Challenging
Top 100 solvers
Mon 3:33, 3:55, 0.91, 9%, Easy
Tue 5:30, 5:21, 1.01, 54%, Medium
Wed 6:29, 6:08, 1.06, 66%, Medium-Challenging
Thu 9:39, 10:40, 0.90, 28%, Easy-Medium
Fri no data
Sat no data
Sun 27:01, 20:13, 1.34, 87%, Challenging
Do I understand that Rex completed this in 14 minutes? Are you kidding me?
ReplyDeleteI will never be good at this. I was so proud of myself for finishing this in 40 minutes. Plus I didn't event get the CID piece until I read about it.
Christ.
gpo
I got this entirely right without ever figuring out either the els or the cid. I did see the turns...
ReplyDeleteI'm surprised that only a few people have complained about some of the els being followed by random letters. Since crossword answers *always* end at a black square or an edge, I assumed that I must have something wrong with, CANON IN DBID, etc. For that reason, I would give the theme an F. I think this is much more egregious than, say, the "Crossed out" puzzle of a few weeks ago. In that case people might think it was ugly, but at least no one thought it was *their* problem. To quote from Emma, "Very badly done."
ReplyDelete@Mathguy: Spider Man has a "Spidey sense", which is a kind of physical intuition, usually leading to ducking just in time.
What a treat. Thank you Byron. Can't remember the last time a Sunday puzzle was so much fun and a little tough. DNF because of CANON. And, not only did I miss the CID thing, but did not put together downright with the L shapes. So what was an enjoyable romp became doubly so once I read Rex and then the comments here.
ReplyDeleteThis was an unusually tough one for me. I took a wrong turn, not being a Harry Potter fan, and figured that perhaps he had a STAR birthmark indicative of his magical legacy, rather than a SCAR. That gave me PITARO on the vertical, which I couldn't figure out how to correct, not having ever encountered the word PICARO.
ReplyDeleteThe MAN CAVE clue, I'm assuming on account of the question mark, refers not to some game that employs an XY coordinate system, but rather to the male XY sex chromosome.
I, too, missed the C-I-D aspect of the theme, and having figured the answer to the Pachelbel clue was CANON I, couldn't for the life of me find the sixth theme answer.
TUFF!!!!DNF. Missed Estivate,Thanku, and Seaholly. Never saw abscissa in a puzzle before. Has anyone else? It is not used as much these days in math /science classes bit I liked it as well as the entire puzzle.
ReplyDeleteThank you BW.
I had to come to you on a Monday morn after solving the puzzle correctly to find out how the 6 El Cids fit. Doh! Now I see! Had to ask my husband about abscissa, Nomar, and leg pad. Nearly put Piggly Wiggly for Winn Dixie and Maya for Inca. Afro was good, Nazi Era, and Padded Bra. Good puzzle.
ReplyDeleteThey aren't SPIKEDACES, they're SPIKE DACES, small fish living in the Gila River system of New Mexico and Arizona.
ReplyDeleteNo googling required, no pop culture, no trivia that can't bet solved by context. Perfect. Some gimmes, but enough lateral-thinking cluing to make it challenging. Lots of traps to fall into (like "natural", as others fell into), clues that hid their direction well. I didn't think much of the overused theme, but with such great cluing and no googling required, how can anyone complain? Well done!
ReplyDeleteI think my favorite Sunday ever. Completely in my wheelhouse, no googling, and seeing the CID component of the Els helped me when I needed it. Thank U Mr. Walden! Viva El Cid!
ReplyDeleteA most unfortunate DNF for me, because of 13d/40a. Not knowing the official Pachebel title, I tried what I thought was reasonable for an offer to buy unspecified stocks: BLaNkBID. This left me with CANONA, which looked OK, and LEGPAK: I figured, every modern "pack" is now "PAK" so I left it in.
ReplyDeleteCounting my phrases, though, I could only come up with five. And shame on me, though I got the "Right turn, Clyde!" thing before even starting--from the title "Downright Tricky!" (duh)--I completely missed the fact that all the phrases acronymmed to CID. Had I done so, I might have spied that CANONIND.
All the rest of it went swimmingly; it actually rates easy-medium to me save that one glitch. Blank bid, blind bid. Rats. I should get on top of my financial terms.
For a moment, I mused that the sixth themer might be PFFTATAS: PADDEDBRA, anyone? OK, I'll shut up now.
151=7, no card.
What a great puzzle, quite easy in parts, and slow-going in others. Got the "go down and turn right" thing from the title, and was happy to find four of them pretty easily.
ReplyDeleteThe NE was distinctly more difficult than the rest. I had to leave that part and complete the SE, where the clue for ELCID was a big help in getting CANONIND (actually got BLINDBID first) and CRISISINDARFUR.. That strange fish came completely from crosses,
I'm always in awe of the creative themes that constructors come up with, and this ONE was AMAZIN'.
2621=11 take away a 2.
I caught on to the gimmick pretty quickly with 50D/109A, but didn't snap to the CID trick until I was done with the puzzle and tried to figure out what Byron meant.
ReplyDeleteI had five of the six downrights discovered, but not a sixth. Finallllly, I figured out that CANONI wasn't an answer and took it around the corner ND. Voila!
Really clever fun puz Mr. Walden.
Liked the shoutout to @Diri with 99D.
Learned PICARO and ESTIVATE, words not previously in my vacab. Wasn't sure until I googled that I had it correct.
Can anyone explain how "Absolutely Fabulous," e.g. leads one to the answer BRITCOM?
And what kind of FILMINDUSTRIES BEARFUR?
@DMG, I caught the final set yesterday and thought of you. What a match. Both guys are great role models.
Capcha: 1028 = 2
Finally finished the puzzle today - ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS (The link is for @SiS).
ReplyDelete3420 > 9 if the game is still open.
Thanks, @Diri, I think I get it now.
ReplyDeleteIts a mental exercise, it takes time if your vocabulory is not strong, you must know synonyms to solve it instantly
ReplyDeleteIndependent hyderabad escorts