Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium
![]() |
| [pretty sure this is the longest Star Wars-free streak of the year] |
Theme answers:
- BEETHOVEN'S THIRD (3D: Symphony known as "Eroica")
- CORNER POCKET (5D: One of four on a pool table)
- KALEIDOSCOPE (8D: Toy meant to be looked into)
- "PEACE BE WITH YOU" (10D: Meaning of the Arabic greeting "As-salamu alaykum")
Searching is a 2018 American screenlife mystery thriller film directed by Aneesh Chaganty in his feature debut, written by Chaganty and Sev Ohanian and produced by Timur Bekmambetov. Set almost entirely on computer screens and smartphones, the film follows a father (John Cho) trying to find his missing 16-year-old daughter (Michelle La) with the help of a police detective (Debra Messing). This was the first mainstream Hollywood thriller headlined by an Asian-American actor.
A co-production between the United States and Russia, the film premiered at the Sundance Film Festival on January 21, 2018. It was released in a limited release on August 24, 2018, before opening wide on August 31, 2018 by Sony Pictures Releasing. The film was a financial and critical success, grossing over $75 million worldwide against a $880,000 budget. At the Independent Spirit Awards, Cho was nominated for Best Male Lead. The film's success launched a titular film series including a standalone installment titled Run, and a follow-up titled Missing. (wikipedia)
• • •
I'm loath to give a puzzle too much credit for post-solve animation and other whistles and bells not directly related to the solve itself, but I have to admit this one was kind of cute. The visual worked, making a nice, colorful representation of words (vegetables) I'd otherwise just have to imagine (I've been asked to imagine out-of-grid elements a number of times over the years, so it's not a problem, but the little picture of the garden at the (roof)top of the grid ... it's nice). This puzzle only really needed one revealer, but we got two, and without any apparent strain on the grid, so that was nice as well. Is there KALE in a typical VEGETABLE MEDLEY. I feel like once you add KALE, you get KALE SALAD. Or in this case, a KALE-BEET SALAD with CORN and a single PEA. But I don't think plausibility of ingredients matters much—the puzzle features a medley (or mixture) of vegetables, good enough. The theme was easy to ... dig up 😎. I ran through the NW corner until I hit the "POCKET" part of CORNER POCKET, and because the ROOFTOP GARDEN was a part of the grid from the start, it was easy to infer that the missing "CORN" from CORNER POCKET would be sticking up in the garden. Since I know what "Eroica" is, the BEET went in easily. I was flustered at first by the Arabic in the clue for "PEACE BE WITH YOU," but then realized it was the one phrase that I actually did know pretty well. Weirdly, I balked at KALEIDOSCOPE the first time I saw its clue because I thought "there's no vegetable that starts with KAL-." Sigh. Sometimes the brain just malfunctions inexplicably. Like, why does my electric toothbrush work perfectly some nights and other nights I push the button and ... nothing? I bang it, it works, I bang it, it doesn't work. I'm too lazy/cheap to get a new one. Which is how I feel about my brain as well. I'm used to it. I think I'll keep it. But it often disappoints.
Mistakes abounded, though none of them held me up for long. OMG for SMH right out of the gate, smh, that sucked (1A: "Unbelievable," in a text). Later on, the entirety of the NE corner gave me a bit of a thrashing. First, CHU for CHO (It's Jon CHU, director; John CHO, actor). Later, ACTS for OPTS (12D: Stops vacillating). M.I.A. (1A: Absent, for short), AD CREEP (15A: Intrusive marketing issue), and NOT A BIT (18A: 0%) were all elusive to me. The clue on ACTORS was not immediately clear either (9D: People who are told what to say?). So about 1/8 of the grid was the source of something like 1/2 my trouble. Had some symmetrical trouble in the SW with RELO (55D: Move quickly?) and OGLE (56D: Bad look) (LEER is more of a "look" than an "OGLE" ... an OGLE? It's a noun? I guess it's a noun). For the RELO clue, "quickly" apparently functions as an abbreviation indicator. Not at all obvious to me. I also struggled with the AFTER part of GET AFTER (39D: Nagged). So there were toughish parts, but I was never completely stuck.
Bullets:
- 24A: Scores that usually occur on fourth downs, in brief (FGS) — I guess this clue is true enough, but I couldn't process it. Me: "If you score on fourth down, you're probably close to the goal line ... so TDS?" But right. A field goal is also a "score." And those are usually attempted on fourth down.
- 31A: Turns (ROTS) — a brutally ambiguous clue for ROTS. So many kinds of turning... turning your car? Taking turns at a game? Today, just rotting. Appropriate for a vegetable puzzle. We've gotten a lot better at using all the produce before it "turns," but ... occasionally, you'll find some forgotten something in the back of the crisper drawer.
- 35A: Contented sighs (AAHS) — like yesterday, our puzzle has a strong visual element, and like yesterday, our puzzle has AAHS. Yesterday, just a single AAH, but the spelling ambiguity remains the same. You wanna know how you can tell if the answer is going to be AAH or AHH? You can't! Same clues are used for both. Weirdly, though, in the plural, it is always AAHS, never AHHS, which, when you look at AHHS, makes sense. Truly horrifying letter arrangement.
- 60D: Diesel in a muscle car? (VIN) — VIN Diesel is the star of the Fast & Furious franchise. Are the street-racing cars in that franchise "muscle cars"? Well, "muscle cars" are "performance-oriented street cars" with "powerful engines" (wikipedia), so maybe. Probably. Anyway, I'm pretty sure Fast & Furious is the key to understanding this clue.
That's all for today. See you next time.
[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️:
✏️Upcoming Crossword Tournaments✏️:
=============================
📘 My other blog 📘:
- Pop Sensation (vintage paperbacks)







I want to be annoyed and pedantic over SOMETHING here, but I guess I can't find anything, except that the image for PEA has many PEAS.
ReplyDeleteSometimes nits NEED to be picked!
DeleteExcellent Thursday puzzle sparkling with aha moments. You really had to use the old “bean,” as it were. My favorite clue was “info from Delta, or a letter soon after delta.” That one took some thinking to come up with.
ReplyDeleteWhen I saw the H at the top of 3D, (after filling in SMH) I figured, oh, it's Beethoven, in must be upside down.... Ninth is running upwards. I know that Eroica is not the Ninth, actually, but somehow I wasn't thinking it through. Anyway, wrestled a bit up there until I finally got (corn)ERPOCKET, and then we were off. Nice double revealer. ROOFTOPGARDENs are pretty cool. If I lived in the city I would definitely want one! So yeah, nice fun puzzle! Thanks, Jared! : )
ReplyDeleteJust realized that this grid is 15 x 16 (tall)--so it's a roof-top garden on a high-rise! : )
DeleteNice find, Rick!
Delete17 if you count the garden
DeleteTerrific! Crunchy. Innovative theme. Good sparkle.
ReplyDeleteA rebus! A word is written in the big, wide box at the top. Plus, the official solution has pictures of the vegetables, the original meaning of a rebus.
Liked the cryptic clue for 4A, CEE.
FRACAS. Yes.
Not a skier. Happy to learn SKIDOOS. It should have been 23A.
Peter Pan talked about dying? I wouldn't have wanted to read that line to my young child.
SEDATE for "Tranquil." Not the way I understand the word.
And the timing of a Vegetable Medley is perfectly appropriate with all the Thanksgiving planning and prep going on .......
ReplyDeleteI was literally just thinking about my mother in law’s vegetable medley yesterday!
DeleteHey All !
ReplyDeleteWith the VEGETABLE ROOFTOP GARDEN, the puz ends up with 17 rows! A 15x16 puz, with an outgrow of grass on top. You don't use that top GARDEN row, but it is there, making it 17 rows.
And left/right symmetry, to get yer two Revealers in, one a 13, one a 15. Handled well. None of the Themers come in contact with said Revealers, so it eases the filling of the puz a bit.
Neat clue for VIN. Plenty of muscle cars in that franchise. Mostly Chargers.
Had myself a good day yesterday. Thanks to all the places who honor veterans with complimentary stuff.
Hope y'all have a great Thursday!
Two F's
RooMonster
DarrinV
”Plenty of muscle cars in that franchise." And plenty of muscles in those cars
DeleteI had to laugh because by the time the rabbits, squirrels, chipmunks and bugs get through with my garden I usually only have one pea to show for my efforts.
ReplyDeleteI misread the clue as [Diesel in a *musical* car?]. It obviously had to be VIN, but I really had no clue what kind of bizarre film this was or how I had missed it. Like, VIN Diesel going around the neighborhood in an ice cream truck? Who thought this was a good idea? Was it one of those “so bad it’s good” ideas that they just…rolled with, so to speak?
ReplyDeleteFor some reason, when I tried to remember the world KALEIDOSCOPE, my brain went first to STETHOSCOPE (obviously wrong) but second to PERISCOPE which it absolutely refused to give up on. Come to think of it, I did play with a PERISCOPE when I was a kid as well, so it’s a legit answer. But it was the KALEIDOSCOPE I was trying to think of, and just couldn’t find the word. I had to try to infer it from the little green blob that appeared post-solve, but at first I thought it was broccoli, and BROCCOLIIDOSCOPE was definitely not a thing.
You made me laugh with *musical* car, so often do I also initially misread a clue, it tickled me. I ALSO could picture a KALEIDOSCOPE, had the SCOPE but after sussing out the BEET, thank goodness KALE came to mind.
DeletePlaylist from the Broadway smash hit Diesel! The Ice Cream Truck Musical:
DeleteOverture: Vanilla's for Chumps
1 Soup up the Ice Cream Truck
2 Revving Raspberry
3 Blasting Turkey in the Straw
4 Chocolate v Strawberry: Let's Rumble
5 Guns 'n' Gummies: Mix It In
5 I Love Sprinkles ... and You
6 The Sweetest Mile
7 Penny Scoopers (That'll be $8)
8 You're My High-Test Malted
9 Sorbet??!!
The audiences have raved about the ice cream sandwiches being past out at intermission. Oreo flavored.
And apparently the off-Broadway version is more risqué with the controversial number Driver: Drizzle Caramel on My Cone
What aspersions?
DeleteYou’re the only one slinging insults like calling those who disagree with your assessment of a puzzle dogs.
I say you misjudge things. That’s not an aspersion; it’s an opinion offered without animus or insult.
You can not make the same claim.
Simplistic - but fun. The app graphic is neat but gave away the trick too soon. Liked KALEIDOSCOPE best.
ReplyDeleteVH
Overall fill was fine - Rex summarizes nicely. The 16 x 15 layout forces some oddball shorts. FRACAS - GOT AFTER - MADDER are a group. Not a lot of pushback to be found. CRADLE is the word of the day.
The Smiths
Enjoyable Thursday morning solve.
There’s Something On Your Mind
I thought this was easy for a Thursday and didn't care for the random answers just beginning off-screen (or off-page). If "hovens third" or "er pocket" made sense on their own, that would have been cool. And one of them just being "pea" was kind of a letdown. I was a big meh on this one
ReplyDeleteVery easy, but cute. I hit a bunch of the same stumbling blocks as Rex, but they were all so easy to fix (or figure out) by checking crosses. Still, I saw the gimmick right from BEEThoven’s (thanks to the grass illustration at the top), thought it was adorable, and enjoyed the quick solve from there on out.
ReplyDeleteActually, the only thing that didn’t quite work for me was that I opened the puzzle, saw the grass, and thought “ah, so we’re going to be dealing with something underground.” Got me to BEET easily, but then the rest of the veggies made less sense and ROOFTOP GARDEN really shattered my mind’s original image. Then again, the fill went in so quickly I didn’t even figure out CORN or PEA til after the drawings cropped up. But why is there a lawn of grass on the roof? Shrug.
Re "underground": I had the same reaction. That top line looks more like a hayfield than a garden. You won't get many peas - maybe just that one! - if you try to grow them in such thick sod.
DeleteLoved it, though a bit on the easy side for a Thursday. Eat your veggies, everybody!
ReplyDeleteUnusual puzzle to say the least. Loved it.🎈🎈🎊🎊
ReplyDeleteWhere the hell have you been? I got here at seven and have been waiting for an hour!!
ReplyDeleteCalm down -- I SEDATE, not seven.
Subliminal nod to Hogan's Heroes? KERNAL CLING
At their wedding, Ian Anderson's bride wore a gown of Jethro TULLE.
These puzzles are not letting me get TARA-ra-boom-dee-ay out of my head.
*********
This was a great puzzle, very well-conceived and executed, IMO.
I got tripped up by beet. Beets grow underground, so I thought all the rebuses were in-grid. Sigh.
ReplyDeleteOne of our better Thursdays and a most memorable aha moment, as crosswords go. I was beginning to despair, thinking dang, this is another one of those tricks that’s gonna have to be explained to me when suddenly … well I’LL BE! There sprouting from the ROOFTOP, was a PEA! Then the fun part started with trying to figure out which VEGETABLE would be growing in the next row. KALE was the toughest one for me because in my mind, the only other four-letter vegetables left were okra and bean. Or maybe it was because I detest kale’s very existence on a plate with my actual food and would never purposely plant it in a GARDEN so that there would be more of it. Talk about an ICK factor. Bleh!
ReplyDeleteThe puzzle, however, was quite tasty, and I thoroughly savored every bite. A lovely grid surrounding a very clever theme idea. Nice going, Jared and thank you.
Haha on KALE. I have actually had good KALE dishes at my daughter’s home because apparently you need to “massage” kale before cooking it. Too much trouble IMO but I appreciate the effort when she prepares it because I know it’s very healthy.
DeleteAll you have to do is cut the kale into fairly thin ribbons and massage a little olive oil into it, and it's lovely in a salad, especially one with shaved Brussels sprouts, candied pecans., and a lemony dressing. Delicious.
DeleteMy Kale salad recipe
Delete1 wash kale
2 pat dry
3 slice finely
4 sprinkle with olive oil
5 toss in trash
6 order fattoush salad
Hilarious ChrisS!
Delete@Jnlzbth: Yes, I've heard of sprinkling olive oil on it too ... makes it easier to put down the garbage disposal where it belongs. LOL.
DeleteChrisS: I'm with you! And agree with Beezer. LOL!
DeleteA super Thursday! I strolled down all the side streets that Rex travelled and had a smile on my face face to start the day when the veggies appeared. I couldn’t ask for more.
ReplyDeleteAgree easy for a Thursday because I usually slog mightily with Thursdays. Not so today. The picture in digital version clicked immediately. BEET, CORN, and PEA fell into place. The green blob not so much. It took a few crosses.
ReplyDeleteIf understood RooMonster's comment correctly is one who served, so Thank you for your service! And same to any others who took up the cause.
Who solved this in 5:25?
ReplyDelete@Anonymous 8:55 AM
Delete🦖 and a few others here are speed solvers. It's important to them. Don't pit your Chevy Malibu against their top-fuel dragsters. They're going to the end of the quarter mile; you're going to the park to swing.
Anyone else have trouble printing this puzzle? it kept freezing up on me...
ReplyDeleteExcept for KALEIDOSCOPE, the theme answers were all gimmes, but I couldn't figure out what the trick was to fit them in. But the back ends of each worked normally, so I worked up, and in the case of HOVENS THIRD got all the way to the top and noticed that I was missing a BEET. And the next one started with CORN, so now I knew what was going on, except for the last one. I wanted it to start with "may" and I think there's a joke along the lines of "may peas be with you" so I got confused; finally realized it was hidden letters, rather than a pun, and there I was--until the end. I filled in the last square (or so I thought) and nothing happened, so I figured I was supposed to rebus those vegetables in with the first letter in the grid. That was a pain, and looked awful (instead of a corn rebus I had a corne one) but I did it--and then noticed that the e from etre was blank. Put that in and got an error message, so I had to take the rebuses back out. Tada!
ReplyDeleteNice touch having a KERNEL of corn at 30-D, by the way.
I frequently squeeze lemons by hand, but oranges? It can be done, but not a good way to make orange juice. I think the puzzle is thinking of a hand-powered press, basically another example of a simple machine.
"One of the six so-called "simple machines"...why is "so-called" in the clue? That's what they're called. Simple machines. "One of the six simple machines". Done. "So-called" implies they're maybe not really called that...
ReplyDeleteIt implies they are not really simple: just called simple.
DeleteThey are indeed simple and there are six classical simple machines, not "so-called".
DeleteI have to agree with @JLG's question. They are simple, and that's why they're called that. So why the qualifier? Is the clue implying that they're not really machines?
DeleteFun puzzle with neat graphics. I started out thinking the answers would have to do with something under the ground, but that was corrected when I looked at HOVEN. Still had no feel for the theme until I hit the revealers, then all became clear. As a vegetable gardener for most of my life I really appreciated this one. As a puzzle solver had a heck of a time with the NE because I started with MeN instead of MEN, ACTs instead of OPTS, and didn't know CHO.
ReplyDeleteWasn't there a VIN Diesel movie where he played a (YAM) aha piano on a medley of vegetable tunes? No wait, I'm thinging of the time Victor Borge appeared on Mr. Rogers.
ReplyDeleteI love some of those wacky SKIDOOS that Mrs. Egs and her girlfriends come up with to parade around the lodge while doing their ski-adjacent thing. Like the "Ski Jump" with its steep smooth ramp leading to a shortflat lip. Or the "Bump Run" with its long stretches of tiny moguls and troughs.
i've been out for a hip replacement surgery. It was scheduled for a relatively inconvenient time when I got a call saying I could have 11/5 (last Thursday). So I scrambled and took it. The first couple of days are an oxycodone blur where I couldn't finish a puzzle even if a finished version was my guide. But I'm feeling good today. Off to my first PT in an hour.
And by the way, thanks for the verdant and fun puzzle, Jared Cappel.
Yay! (Hip Hip Hooray) Welcome back. Always thought you were a hipster. Wishing you a speedy and easy recovery.
DeleteHappy recovery!
DeleteGlad you're back @Eggs! I hope you recover quickly!
DeleteSo glad you're back. Good luck with rehab!
Delete@egsforbreakfast 9:27 AM
DeleteThere you are. Sheesk. A mild panic was setting in. Hope you recover quickly and let me know if you have any oxy left over.
Speedy recovery! Hope you're shooting from the hip again soon.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteAhh, an oxycodone haze. Too bad you had to get surgery to get there! Best wishes for you to be back to your wily ways!
DeleteRoo
Welcome back! Very happy to hear you are well and on the road to recovery. Amazing that you are starting PT already, but apparently that's how it's done these days. I had my third rotator cuff surgery on July 8 and went to first PT on the 17th. When I had the first two surgeries in 2008 and 2014, it was 6 weeks before I started, and I wasn't even allowed to remove the sling for the first 3 weeks. I have to say that sooner is better, and I have recovered range of motion significantly faster.
DeleteWelcome back Egs! I’ve had no socket surgery, but the good news is that I “hear tell” hip recovery is quicker than knee. Hang in there!
DeleteI printed this out without looking at the image too closely (in a rush to meet someone) and wound up with what looked like a blue smudge bar across the top of the puzzle. Now what, I thought after the BLURRY photos. Started in the NW and went straight down with not much of a problem which gave me the start of the double revealers which filled in easily enough, then worked up and found the missing BEET, the jig was up, and working upwards found the other . missing veggies easily enough. Wish I'd seen the graphic, which looks pretty cool. I've solved other Thursdays with out-of-the-grid words so that helped.
ReplyDeleteEasier than most Thursdays here. SERENE before SEDATE, easy fix, thought of CHU before CHO, another easy fix. I think I've seen ADCREEP before but that took some crosses and the clue for NAACP was no help. Also I've heard of someone with a musical deficiency described as having a tin ear, but NOEAR seems a bit harsh.
Nice Thursdecito, JC. I Just Can't imagine eating a VEGETABLEMEDLEY with these examples, but thanks for all the fun.
Pats Self on Back Dept..--Finally had a QB yesterday, first in a long time. A little easier when a low number is required.
@Rex - when your electric toothbrush doesn’t work when you push the button, just put it back on the charger until it beeps then pick it up and try again - no need to bang it. At least that works for me :)
ReplyDeleteHe may use the battery charged ones. I sometimes you can change the battery and it still won’t work…unless you bang it.
DeleteHome run! Fantastic Thursday puzzle.
ReplyDeleteMorir será una aventura terriblemente grande.
ReplyDeleteAw. Cute. And funny too. I had fun growing this digital garden. Poor broccoli RABE ended up buried. Fertilizer I suppose. Vegetable cannibalism obviously.
Seven days no @egs. 😢
There's no such thing as musical talent.
I remember loving kaleidoscopes, but haven't looked through one in years. What happens in life to take them away?
My last RELO took weeks. Didn't feel "quick" to me.
PIQUE is on my favorite word list under ADROIT. I will be adding FRACAS, but I'm not sure where yet. These are important decisions.
❤️ ICK factor.
There was a minor kerfuffle over the gunkometer yesterday. A couple of positive thoughts {thank you}, and aspersions cast by my usual Haterade sipping Chihuahuas (arf). Today, I present the results of the count exactly the same way as I have for years, and if you prefer, don't look at them. I want you to be happy.
Gunkometer--
People: 8
Places: 0 {not even EGYPT}
Products: 4
Partials: 10 {gah}
Foreignisms: 2
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 24 of 78 (31%)
Funny Factor: 5 😄
🔥 Ooh-la-la! 🔥 Skintight activewear. Simple machine.
Uniclues:
1 One scouring dance magazines not for the articles.
2 Turns on NPR.
3 Attended the costume party wearing pro-27th presidential attire.
4 Troll cast aspersions on relo guru.
5 His neck.
1 LEOTARD AD CREEP
2 STEREO SOBERS
3 CAME AS GO TAFT-ER
4 MAN SOILED AGENT
5 ACTOR'S HEADREST
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: One way to get a smoking hot look. SRIRACHA EYE MASK.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Egs is back as of 9:27am. :-)
DeleteYour musical car is either Greased Lightning or Chitty Chitty Bang Bang.
ReplyDeleteWas I the only one who got to the end and wondered, What's a BROCCOLIDOSCOPE?
ReplyDeleteHaha! Quite possibly…but everyone’s journey through a puzzle is different in one way or another!
DeleteA nice moment of puzzlement at HOV??? before catching on to the missing BEET in the ROOFTOP GARDEN above. A very cute and tidy puzzle. I especially liked KALE trying to disguise itself in KALEIDOSCOPE. I also smiled at the single PEA - it reminded me of the menu at a neighborhood restaurant where all the ingredients listed are in the singular, e.g., a salad with chickpea, salmon with local mushroom, and duck with brussels sprout. I think this is supposed to indicate "upscale," along with everything being in lower case. SMH.
ReplyDeleteReally enjoyed this, although it is once again a theme puzzle that can be solved without needing to understand what's going on. As in, I could have filled in all of the across clues on top and never figured out what vegetables are going to appear after the happy music.
ReplyDeleteThat would of course mean that 4 of the down answers don't make any sense, but I have often finished puzzles successfully where I don't understand the theme. And so I entered BEET etc as rebuses with a slash for the across letter (BEET/H) to no success. Only when I erased the vegetable did the happy music play.
I get why the vegetable isn't in the box (it's above) so my logic is off - and yet it seemed odd to not have to identify the actual vegetable to solve the puzzle. Small nitpick. Still a fun Thursday. 18:36
Odd is right. I put in the complete rebuses and then spent longer than I care to admit banging my head against the wall. I'm not a fan of Thursday puzzles.
Delete@hankster65 the reason I got it was it’s not really possible to use a rebus answer, because the rebus answers would be “beeth”, “corne”, etc., and as Niallhost points out, using the slash would be incorrect because the slash indicates either/or, not both. So with a full missing word, and a bright row of grass up top, it seemed clear the answer would be hidden in that grass somewhere, not on the board.
DeleteWow
ReplyDeleteJust wow.
This was a hoot! A tad easy for a Thursday but a lot of fun. I'm not sure where or when it all clicked for me, but click it did and then it was pretty much off to the races.
ReplyDeleteI generally don't love visual gimmicks but this one didn't take anything away from the *word* part of crossword. I found it more endearing than distracting.
Somehow the ETA/JETTA paring kept catching my eye, I'm probably the only one who thought that was kinda neat. Now realizing you also get ETA hidden in VEGETABELMEDLEY. I'll go on pretending that there is something important in that find. I'll keep everyone posted.
I like some crypticish cluing every once in a while in a regular puzzle and the CEE at 3A scratched that itch. That was cool.
So what's not to like? You get two fun revealers, one being a spanner, a neat visual trick and a pretty clean grid. This was good time!
Thanks Jared! What a great Thursday!
Easy. It was clear that some answers were not making sense but I just keep filling in stuff and figured I’d go back and fix things when I hit a wall. The wall thing never happened. Instead I got the happy music and vegetables on top of the puzzle that made sense of the nonsense answers.
ReplyDeleteCostly erasures - SErenE before SEDATE and NOThing before NOT A BIT.
Fun breezy solve with a clever graphic, liked it.
I went to print out this puzzle (as I do for Thursday through Saturday) and it looked very narrow in the preview. I quick went to the NYTimes online version to confirm that the print version I was looking at contained the full puzzle. There, I saw the green ROOF TOP and was thus expecting something to "grow" above the grid.
ReplyDeleteBut throwing in REpAirS at 17A gave me a starting answer at 3D of HOpE. BEETHOVEN would have to wait a bit before I got to him. Instead, I finally saw [CORN]ER POCKET and that was my aha. PEAs, KALE and BEETs followed shortly and I really enjoyed that.
My big mystery answer was 4D, CAMEAS. CAMEoS? CAMo_S? Ah, someone CAME AS, aka "dressed like". Whew.
Jared Cappel, great job for a Thursday surprise, thanks!
This puzzle was lots of fun and deserved all those stars. My biggest mistake was putting in TUiLE (the wafer) instead of TULLE (the fabric), which gave me _UIY for 27D (As is fitting). But Iafter awhile I figured it out. This reflects Rex's best line of the day: "Sometimes the brain just malfunctions inexplicably." Boy is that the truth, especially after one reaches a certain age!
ReplyDeleteIn the paper version of the NYT which is my old-fashioned medium, the “rooftop” was simply a gray bar. I had to wait for the revealer to grok the veggies!
ReplyDeleteI glad I’m not the only person who fills in the puzzle in the printed NYT. This blog is so online (and sports) oriented.
DeleteSuperbly crafted ThursPuz. Luved everything about it, altho leery of the AMOEBA in that there VEGETABLEMEDLEY. Might need to spray, or somesuch.
ReplyDeletestaff weeject picks: SMH [Shut My Hatch?], CEE [great clue], MIA, and CHO. The four veggie root words.
I reckon the puz was a dash easy-ish for a ThursPuz, but liked the top floral decoration strip, the E/W puzgrid symmetry, and the salad of fun fillins. sooo ... still really diggin it.
some fave stuffins: PIQUES. SKIDOOS. NOTABIT. GOTAFTER. THAR. Extra RABE & KERNEL veggie-mites.
And ... a fun KALEIDOSCOPE spellin challenge, too boot.
Thanx for the crop of fun, Mr. Cappel dude. Primo 4-star stuff. Woulda even rated a 99% Rotten Tomatoes at our house, if you had had a POTATO splatzed down under that there puztop floral strip. [101%, if you'da also chipped in a Star Wars reference.]
Masked & Anonymo3Us
p.s.
Runt Puzzle:
**gruntz**
p.p.s.s.
@RP: M&A can identify with that brain misfire discussion. Yesterday we met up with a gal, while enterin the local grocery store. She inquired about my wife's sister, so my wife assumed she was some friend of her sis. But I insisted that the mystery gal looked extra-familiar, for some reason. About 2-3 hours later, M&A brain has an ahar moment -- that was Felicia .. the sweet gal who cuts my hair [and my sis-in-law's hair] every month or two!
p.p.p.s.s.s.
Hats off to Mississippi's taste in Senators-elect.
M&A
No comment on NO EAR? Worst fill in the grid for me.
ReplyDeleteThe theme was easy because of (BEET)HOVEN'S THIRD giving the game away (the vegetables are all different, but still). The idea is great, but the "problem" with this sort of theme is that it only affects the very top of the grid, so once you're done there, there's no more Thursday trickery left to uncover.
I would've liked the clues to have more bite, and the "?"s are pretty much all disappointing, ranging from weak (ACTORS) to transparent (MATH, VIN) to trying too hard (CRADLE). Going from "bed that rocks" to "bed rock" is a huge stretch.
I was not fond of NO EAR (see above).
DeleteWait, we're the pictures of the vegetables always there? I literally never noticed until I got to the comments. 🤣
ReplyDeleteWhen I opened the Across Lite file I noticed the little warning note symbol (I've really learned to watch for those lately), so I had a look at the grid on the NYT website. Oh!... there's a flower garden up there? Then mostly forgot about it. But "Eroica" had me expecting BEETHOVEN in 3 down, so when I saw HOVEN------ I knew there was some invisible letter thing going on. Much later I realized: BEET, CORN, [something]-IDOS (?), and then I recognized the Arabic for "[PEA]CE BE WITH YOU". No problem!
ReplyDeleteOf course in AL there was no animation, so I never saw the little pictures. Oh, well. Pretty good Thursday theme! I took some time trying BEETHOVENS NINTH, then FIFTH, because I knew Eroica was one of them...
More good news: for a nice change, not really too many names here! Still a lot of short ones: TARA, CHO, VIN, ALDA, ELMO, NEIL, YSL. And CHO was the only real Unknown, yay!
No “post-solve animation” for die-hard paper solvers like me.
ReplyDeleteMEET and VEGETABLE(s)
ReplyDeleteHEIR, AIR
EYE, OGLE
NOEAR of corn for you until you finish the grid.
Too bad there's no EWE to go with 23A.
The blog pic of VIN Diesel tickled my funny bone. Look at those muscles!! Yet as a 15 year old kid with skinny under-developed arms I drove, and soon as a scrawny withered old person of 98 I'll shift into overdrive and stomp on the accelerator. Just watch me! Or take away the key fob.
ReplyDeleteGive VIN an ice cream truck. Five gallon Ice cream buckets are heavy and frozen ice cream can be hard to scoop. He can handle it.
random - is this a garden holiday or something ? If not it’s just random
ReplyDeletefun fact: Beethoven's family name literally means 'beet garden' that truly adds to the brilliance of this puzzle - its a classic in my book!
ReplyDeleteOh, that's a wonderful additional bit of info!
DeleteAgreed! Brilliant…thanks!
DeleteI solve on paper, saw the grass on top and knew immediately I was looking for starts of words up there - I didn’t get any post solve fun of course. Cute theme but like Son Volt I felt the picture at the top gave too much away. Enjoyed the puzzle anyway, and I love KALE, stir fried with ginger. TIL SMH but I’ll probably forget it
ReplyDeleteAnnoyed that when I put in all the necessary letters in as four rebuses (rebi?), e.g. KALEI, the app told me I was wrong. Still fun, but…
ReplyDeleteWow! When I saw the vegetation bar across the top of the grid, I said to myself "That looks like a ROOFTOP GARDEN". My confidence in that began to fade as I was unable to figure out what was going on with several longer Downs up there even though I knew "Eroica" was BEETHOVEN'S THIRD. Doh!
ReplyDeleteI kept plugging away until I got to 55A "Site of some urban greenery..." Wow again. My initial impulse fit! And then immediately underneath VEGETABLE MEDLEY comes along. A third wow. That's some high caliber constructioneering (™M&A) there. Most impressive.
A couple of commenters have described this as a rebus (Latin: by way of or with things) puzzle. It does use pictures of things but the Latin for "things" is res. The "by way of" part of rebus is to use the sound of the thing portrayed rather than the literal meaning. This was the case with the development of the first abstract alphabets. It is also the way contemporary picture puzzles like the TV game show "Concentration" use it. More on this at The Rebus Principle.
By the way, I think that ROOFTOP GARDEN needs a little weeding.
Thank you! I have to say that when, many moons ago, I started reading the blog, I got confused at the reference to “rebus” puzzle. I decided to reconcile myself to what seemed to me an “outside of the box” concept of what a rebus is. Oddly, most rebuses are “inside the box” in Crossworld!
DeleteDid anyone else notice that BEETCORNKALEPEA fits perfectly in the top row?
ReplyDeleteReally fun puzzle. No bells and whistles for me, and nothing across the top of the grid.
ReplyDeleteTook me to the bitter end to figure out the theme, which was very much needed to cross the finish line.
Thank you Rex for the 'muscle car' explanation. I've heard of VIN Diesel, but know nothing of the movie franchise.
I was ready to be grumpy if 24A was tds because those are rarely attempted on fourth down, yet it somehow seemed like an easy “not quite right” mistake to be made, and the NYTXW isn’t usually that detailed on football (not like they are with golf, anyway). So I was pleasantly surprised that the correct FGS was the answer. Not all fourth down plays are FGS, but all FGS are on fourth down. And tds are uncommonly attempted on fourth down, even when close to the goal line (too risky in most cases, though some stats say when it’s better to go for it).
ReplyDeleteI'll join many of my solving colleagues and write that this was a really fun way to spend some time on Thursday. Delightful and congrats to the creators.
ReplyDeleteThat As-salamu alaykum clue had me stuck for a good while — I only got it once I started filling in the crossings and working out what words the letters could make. Always satisfying when a tough one finally clicks. Great solve!
ReplyDelete