Relative difficulty: Medium-Challenging
THEME: "Mixed Results" — six lines of the puzzle function somewhat like equations, where the black space between two answers has an equals sign ("=") in it; on one side of the "=" sign is an answer that ends up being the clue for the answer on the other side of the "=" sign. The clue answer is made up of circled and uncircled squares that spell out completely different things, and is clued as [one thing] + [another thing]. So ... [One thing} + [another thing] gives you an (actually unclued) answer, which then functions as a clue for the answer on the other side of the equals sign.
Theme answers:
- ZEALOTS = TRUE BELIEVERS (TUBERS + RELIEVE) (27A: Potatoes, e.g. + Soothe)
- QUIT IN PROTEST (QUINTET + I.T. PROS) (33A: The Great Lakes, e.g. + Computer gurus) = WALK OUT
- SUCK-UPS = COMPLIMENTERS (COMMENT + PLIERS) (58A: Remark + Gripping tool)
- SOUND ONE'S HORN (SO DONE + UNSHORN) (66A: Totally over it + Still woolly) = SHOW OFF
- BULGING = BARREL-BELLIED (BARBELL + RELIED) (90A: Gym weight + Counted (on))
- SPA TREATMENTS (STREAMS + PATENT) (96A: Online broadcasts + Obvious) = FACIALS
A sepoy (/ˈsiːpɔɪ/) is a South Asian soldier. Originating from the Persian word sepāhī (سپاهی), the term was anglicised to "sepoy" by the British. In the army of the Mughal Empire sepāhī referred to a type of infantryman, while in colonial India it was used as a term for native troops in European service. During the early modern era European colonial authorities in India, most prominently those of the British East India Company, raised units of sepoys for service against native states or other European powers. The term is used today as the equivalent rank of private in the Indian, Pakistani and Nepalese armies. (wikipedia)
• • •
OK, where have all these "Sarah, but call me SAL" people been living literally all my life that I have never, not once, heard of such a thing? SAL!?!?!?! Where is the "L" coming from???! My mom is named Sarah, lol calling her Sal. Although ... her birth name was Sally, so maybe she's not the best example. Anyway, SAL was a shocker. Not just a shocker, a complete WTF? The "S" was the last thing I filled in. I've known dozens of Sarahs. Not a one of them has ever gone by SAL. Is this regional? What is this? Seriously, what?
I will say that PALACE COUP is a great answer with an inspired clue (103A: Attempt at a royal flush?). Hard as hell, but very good. Would've loved it on, like, a nice Saturday themeless puzzle.
Bullets:
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️:
Venmo (@MichaelDavidSharp)] =============================
✏️Upcoming Crossword Tournaments✏️:
=============================
📘 My other blog 📘:
Bullets:
- 104A: Meme throwing shade on seemingly attractive boyfriend candidates ("HE'S A TEN BUT...") — I'm sure this will thrill the meme-lovers out there. Me, despite the fact that it rings a faint bell, I couldn't parse it to save my life. The "S" in SAL is the "S" in this answer, so of course it was my last square.
![]() |
| ["He's a 7 but he cuts his hair with a chainsaw" "He's a 9 but his eyes are actually tiny muffins" "He's a 12 but I'm a manatee"—hey, this is fun] |
- 21A: "Bumping," as a party (ALIVE) — lol, this clue / answer reeks of "Hello, fellow youths, this party is really 'bumping,' isn't it? Yes yes, very ... ALIVE."
- 50A: Petty cash holder? (MISER) — "?" clues were murder today. This one was in a whole nexus of ??? stuff like MOW (46A: Take an inch from a yard, say) and MELON (46D: Bean or gourd) and MASER-not-LASER (59D: Device in a hydrogen atomic clock) and ONION (54D: Main ingredient in a German Zwiebelkuchen cake). The dreaded SESHES (plural, ugh) is also in there, but that was actually easy (53D: Get-togethers). Unfortunate, but easy.
- 69A: Pro tip? (NOD) — the murderiest of the "?" clues, for me, in that I had no idea what it meant even after I got it. I believe the idea is that if you are “pro" something (i.e. you approve of it), then you might "tip" your head, or ... NOD.
- 94A: Colonial-era Indian soldier (SEPOY) — yeeeeikes. Blast from the past. Thought I'd seen my last SEPOY, but apparently not. It's been a while—nearly 13 years, to be exact. So long that I forgot the term. "Oh, oh, it's that ... thing ... that I used to know ... because crossword fill used to be much worse." A few crosses got me there.
- 50D: Yemeni port with a namesake beverage (MOCHA) — Me: "How am I supposed to know some Yemeni bev- ... oh, right."
- 65A: Chart showing almost a third of the world's land (ASIA MAP) — here, try this: AFRICA MAP. EUROPE MAP. Do you hear it? Do you hear how it's bad? I feel like if you tried to pull off EUROPE MAP you'd get booed so hard. (this is, to no one's surprise, the first [CONTINENT]MAP answer ever to appear in the NYTXW)
- 86D: Golfing boo-boo (SLICE) — what's with the goo-goo baby talk here? I think of "boo-boos" as owies—you know, scrapes or bruises you get When You Are A Child. But "boo-boo" can also be simply a mistake or error. It's still baby talk, though.
- 99D: Field of inquiry that so far has not had any provable success (SETI)— Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence
- 82D: Wipe from visual memory, facetiously (UNSEE) — gonna go try to UNSEE this puzzle now. Hope your experience was much more enjoyable than mine.
That's all for today. See you next time.
(That was short, right?)
[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️:
✏️Upcoming Crossword Tournaments✏️:
=============================
📘 My other blog 📘:
- Pop Sensation (vintage paperbacks)








Very impressive construction. How did Simeon come up with in-the-language phrases with one word woven into another? Then, because the theme answer pairs are symmetrical each one had to be a certain number of letters.
ReplyDeleteAfter getting my first pair of theme answers I did a smile-jaw-drop. “Really?” I thought, “He’s going to come up with more of these?”
And he did.
But what I like most were the various ways to crack each theme pair. Figuring the circled letter words with a few crosses as possible. Figuring out the non-circled theme answers from crosses, then figuring out the combo words with as few crosses as possible. That’s just two ways, and there are more.
This had my brain in heaven, as did bite to conquer outside the theme. What I take from it is that this was not a SHOWOFF (68A) puzzle, but a solver’s puzzle, ingeniously devised. A most worthy Sunday.
Simeon, your puzzles are crafty and scintillating. This was a gem. Thank you so much for making it!
I loved it as well for just the same reasons. I'm a slow solver, so it took me almost 100min (about 40min longer than my usual for a Sunday)...but I enjoyed the struggle.
DeleteMOW and PALACE COUP both made me happy.
One of the best Sundays I can recall. Thank you! I loved the non-standard cluing and the intricate gimmick, which actually helped on a couple entries.
DeleteLove that your comment came in right on top, Lewis, so that it can serve as a sub-thread for those of us who loved it (which Rex knew were surely out there). I like Sunday puzzles with a little bit of extra puzzle-within-a-puzzle that goes into the solving experience, and this one definitely did that for me.
DeleteWhat a lovely Sunday treat it was!
DeleteI took one look at this and knew that OFL was going to hate it. And I was right about that.
DeleteBut I absolutely loved it! It is inventive, sly, involving and just plain clever. Tough enough that I had to spell out the circles versus blanks on a piece of paper to keep them straight in my head. Good job, Simeon!
PS: did anyone else get caught putting in TEA instead of JOE at 77A? That really slowed me down ...
I am surprised that Rex gave this even two stars. For me, unquestionably the worst Sunday of the year so far.
ReplyDeleteI agree with anonymous 6:44 and Rex that this puzzle was extremely unenjoyable. No🎈for me.
DeleteI second your vote!
DeleteAbsolutely hated this puzzle.
DeleteAgree. So glad Rex took the time to explain why he didn’t like this one. Too hard and no fun at all for me!!
DeleteAgree! Hate, hate, hated this puzzle all the way. Ruined my morning!
DeleteAmen. Worst in 65 years for me
DeleteDitto! 👎🏻
DeleteDitto. The worst!
DeleteAwful. Cludgy. Poor cluing. Big, heavy load. No fun.
DeleteThis was an awful slog.
DeleteOne way ticket to Slogsville.
DeleteTotally awful. Joyless and horrible theme and fill.
DeleteCouldn't stand it, and I still don't get the theme even after Rex explained it. All those three-letter clues, too. Ugh.
DeleteTotally agree with those who hated it. Been doing the puzzle 50 plus years. Worst ever. For all the reasons stated above.
DeleteHideous. Insufferable.
DeleteWow, so harsh. I didn’t mind it and btw, Sal was easy for me as I have a sister with birth name Sarah who goes by Sally and we’ve always called her Sal, so c’mon, not that bad people.😊
DeleteSHEESH!
DeleteOne more vote siding with Rex and @anon 6:44. My wife suggested SAL and I doubted her; foolish me. But the rating of two stars was appropriate.
DeleteWhat a mess. If you don’t know SETI and MASER good luck to you
DeleteFirst time in years I just gave up, came here and filled in the answers I had missing. I simply could not continue for mental health reasons.
DeleteTheme was OK. Fill was awful. Eminem song??? One of many meaningless (for me) clues. Had to look it up...I NEVER do that...
DeleteI've never NOT finished a Sunday puzzle before. Got through about a third of it, then realized I wasn't enjoying it and why was I even bothering. Tossed it aside and went right to "Split Decisions.".
DeleteThe big guy was far too kind - perhaps the least enjoyable puzzle in the WS era.
ReplyDeleteAnother Morning Stoner
A LINE, A LIST, AWOL, AA CELLS, AFC EAST? The short garbage is painful - Rex summarizes the longs including the inane meme.
I don’t typically like Sunday sized grids - the scale and magnitude tend to highlight the rough spots - but this one took it to another level. Easily in the running for WPOTY.
BARREL Chested
Sally is a common nickname for Sarah, and SAL is a shortened form of Sally. (I had no trouble with that one!)
ReplyDeleteTrue. A nickname of a nickname would have been a better clue.
DeleteNever knew that—I’ve only known Sally as a name of its own. But now that you mention it, I did have a friend named Sarah who went by Sadie.
DeleteYes - my mother's name was Sally. She was well into her nineties before mentioning to anybody that her name was actually Sarah...
DeleteSal? No
ReplyDeleteAnonymous 7:12 AM Sal yes
DeleteHoo boy, somebody woke up on the wrong side of the bed. I loved this . A little more difficult than usual...hooray .. and we get a whole set of bonus puzzles with the themes. It's a rare case where the complexity of the construction actually enhanced the solving. And I learned "sepoy"... What more could you ask for?
ReplyDeletePeople can't express appreciation and their pretentiousness at the same time
DeleteAs you can see above, two of the first three commenters agreed with Rex (and me) that the puzzle wasn’t enjoyable. The “wrong side of the bed” comment is condescending. Why, because you disagree with him? I am always stunned when you regular commentators can’t manage to express your feelings w/o denigrating others. If you loved the puzzle, just say that. It’s easy not to be a **** about it 😎
DeleteSarah/Sally/SAL seems to be pretty common in my mom's generation. Rex might just be a little young.
ReplyDeletePALACE COUP always reminds me of the Kyujo attmpted coup, when the Japanese army, in the aftermath of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, tried to overthrow the emperor in so that they could continue fighting rather than surrender.
An okay puzzle I guess, but not one that gave me much joy.
Welp, I’m up there in age and TIL that SAL and Sally are nicknames for Sarah. Kind of strange since I know Hal is a nickname for Harold. Maybe I didn’t know a Sally well enough to know their “real” name.
DeleteAbsolutely no fun.
ReplyDeleteA computer wrote this and it shows
ReplyDeleteA computer helped find words that can shuffle with other words to form longer words. There are many thousands of those. A human spent long hours choosing the only 8 or 9 in that vast list with two common parts, both amenable to concise clueing, which combine to make a compound word which itself points to a serviceable 7-letter antonym (found by a human). And a human conceived of that challenge, thought it might make for a fun brain teaser for some solvers, and then spent 10s of hours trying their best to make it so. And a human broke their brain inventing clues that even AI can’t (yet) solve, knowing that lots of human solvers are interested in that specifically. Not all, and that’s par for the course. It’s 100% fair game to say you didn't enjoy these discoveries, or that you found the puzzle boring or annoying or insufferable, and it’s great that so many solvers are invested enough to share their opinions here. But you’re mistaken about the human effort involved in the attempt to challenge and entertain a very diverse world of strangers.
DeleteAnonymous at 8:32 am's reply is oddly specific...
DeleteEven with Rex's explanation, I couldn't do the puzzle. When it's THIS hard, FOR ME, its no fun at all. It was just a waste of a Sunday 🙄
ReplyDeleteSame. DNF, do not care.
DeleteDNF. Disgusted with BarrelBellied and had CAR instead of CAB so just walked away from the last four rows. Don't know why I stuck around even that long.
DeleteAt least it was hard. Pretty fun.
ReplyDeleteDNF for me. I just gave up. I could not parse this at all. Not at all enjoyable.
ReplyDeleteWith you on that. I got the first few cross-overs, found it such a slog, I didn’t want to waste time solving it and preferred to start reading Emily St. John’s new book, “Exit Party”.
DeleteMurderiest! Ha!
ReplyDeleteProsecutor's summation: Ladies and gentlemen of the jury. We ask that you bring in guilty verdicts for all three of the defendants in this homicide case. While Defendant #1 was the murderiest, all three participated in the act. . .
We went from DOGGONEIT on Friday to DOGIT today. The middle is GONE! Wait -- there it is at 2D!
WADSUP, Doc?
BULGING (88A) LEES (93A): My fat cousin Lenny in jeans.
Sup with ERATO?
ERATO BEMUSE.
I ain't gonna work on Maggie's lawn. No MOW.
******
I always respect RP's assessment, but I'm with @Lewis today. Impressive wordplay IMO. Looks like I'm in the minority (so far).
Maggie’s Lawn hit me right in the funny bone. Thanks for a huge laugh!
DeleteEverything Rex said. I’m a bit disappointed in myself for sticking with it to the bitter end (in my case, fixing MASER and the execrable SOUNDONESHORN). I used to have the ability to walk away from a puzzle this unpleasant.
ReplyDeleteYou have reminded me to look up MASER.
DeleteDifficult puzzle for me as well. Yes, impressive construction, but I have to agree with Rex that some of the answers were a bit goofy. Also, I expected the first item of the clues to be the circled answers or vice-versa, but there seemed inconsistent... I guess the first item in the clues was the first item in the answer(s)? CAB/CAR, Pro tip?= NOD, SAL as a nickname for Sarah (never, ever heard this), HESATENBUT, etc. -- Yes, all problems for me here too. Also, 89D ("Not pass") could be either GETANF (As in, you do not pass) or GOTANF (As in, you did not pass); so between LEES and LOES, I went with LOES, which sounded more plausible. The lower third of the puzzle took me the longest time.
ReplyDeleteEven my wife was surprised at how long this puzzle took me.
[I wrote this before I saw your comment, but I also was puzzled by the circle inconsistency.]
DeleteDefinitely a tough one for me. Solve time was 43% longer than average.
After I finished I got hung up on an inconsistency I'm still trying to understand (entering the pedantic realm of my favorite crossword critic, perhaps): In the first two themers, the first part of the clue "sum" is circled (the A of the A + B = C format). In the final four, though, it's the second sub-clue, the B part, that's circled. Why?
I get that the first sub-clue always gets the first square in the answer, so the ordering (which is the A and which is the B) makes sense. But which part you circle is another degree of freedom, and that one seems arbitrary. I thought maybe the shortest (or the longest) answer gets the circle treatment, but that's not it. I must be missing something.
Otherwise, it was a struggle, but I still enjoyed it. Yes, there were some clunkers, but I'm pretty forgiving.
David Eisner
DeleteMaybe you were thinking of loess which is a kind of soil. Lees is a fairly common bit of crosswordese It will show up again.
You know it's a problem when the puzzle is a loser for Rex and even the EAT A SANDWICH entry of the day doesn't GET AN F on its own.
ReplyDeleteEven though I’m among those who liked this puzzle, I was going to mention the strong EAT A SANDWICH vibes on GET AN F if no one else did. :)
DeleteWell, mid way through the solve, I joined my spouse for Spelling Bee and told her I hated the puzzle. So annoying. It took me a long time to suss out the theme. Even longer to come up with SUCKUPS.
ReplyDeleteI am terminally online and had never heard of that meme and it took me most of the crosses to get there. SAL was infuriating but CAB was a close second for me, followed by AA CELLS. Happy to hear that Rex and everyone else disliked this as much as I did! I will give begrudging flowers to the clue for END, which was the last square I got but in retrospect was a very clever clue.
ReplyDeleteAgreed - elevator CAR. Also remote power source - AACELLS/ALIVE last thing I filled. Absolutely never heard of “bumping” at a party, unless you count “Where’s Me Jumper” by the Sultans of Ping. No trouble with SAL, common in my family preWWII. Liked INSIDE DOPE, COLOR CODED, SEPOY, PALACE COUP.
DeleteWe’re fast approaching 90 years since anything pre-WWII. At what point do we retire such phrases? Or should we just go all in and include words and phrases from the Reconstruction or even Colonial eras?
Delete1) Shocked this got 2 whole stars. Thought it'd be in 1 star territory. I'm more forgiving than Rex when it comes to most of these themes and tricks, but this was a SLOG. And the FILL?
ReplyDelete2) I literally have an aunt whose name is Sara (no H) whom I have always called Aunt Sal, and I STILL couldn't figure out what they expected.
I think this may be the hardest Sunday puzzle I’ve done in the last 30 or 40 years. But I’m not sure how I feel about it. Amazing construction, sure, but the solve wasn’t especially fun, except maybe for the first few minutes after I figured out the gimmick. The gimmick itself is superb, but… Lots of head scratchers in here. I pretty much much agree with Rex.
ReplyDeleteNot seeing the circles until 3/4 filled made this a hot confusing mess for me. Did not enjoy.
ReplyDeleteHey All !
ReplyDeleteHas Simeon SOUND ONES HORN by being a SHOWOFF with this puz? I'd have to say Yes.
Just an X short of a Pangram. Not as SGOWOFFy as I thought! 😁
Tough to find Themers (unless some computer assistance was involved.) He had to find 6 two-words that can combine into one word to mean a third word. Not easy. I'm sure someone could describe that better!
Liked it overall. Have seen these combo-thingie puzs before. Makes the ole brain work a bit.
Uniclue:
Dewrinkles
USES IM HOT IRON~
Hope y'all have a great Sunday!
Five F's
RooMonster
DarrinV
I enjoyed the construction’s complexity. It required some concentration, but was really not that difficult because of multiple avenues for problem-solving. It is good-natured and (to me) funny, to-wit: GETANF for not pass and SUCKUPS for COMPLIMENTERS. Good job.
ReplyDeleteAgreed!
DeleteGETANF for "Not pass" is funny? In what way???
DeleteHard to understand why anyone would want to create a crossword this enjoyable? Once I finished it I had to ask myself why I just hadn’t stopped at some point; boring.
ReplyDeleteI confess I tried Palace Poop for attempt at a Royal Flush
ReplyDelete🤣🤣🤣
DeleteROFL!!
DeleteMe, too! 🤣
DeleteWelcome difficulty for a Sunday, but a real monkey’s paw in that the difficulty was from some of the worst fill one could imagine. Agree on ASIAMAP amongst others. C’mon. Rex is on point here, especially re computer construction. What should be aids are becoming the means. A little artistry and personality are what a solver wants, not architectural feats and new for the sake of new.
ReplyDeleteThis is found all over the world of crosswords with great editors and constructors making fun puzzles, and given the freedom to do s. The NYT is limited by its parochialism and conservatism so new feeling puzzles have such a small turf to play in that we end up with ones like today’s. Shortz has done so much for the crossword world but dare I say it has passed him by and it is time for some fresh blood (and ideas)
I grudgingly accept US MAP whenever it shows up, but ASIA MAP is absurd.
DeleteOh God I totally forgot about ASIAMAP. Terrible.
DeleteThe only time I use that term is when I want to draw up the map of Asia. ASIA MAP
Deletetotal slog - played like a themeless - and the clues just weren't for me (nor were some of the answers - A LINE and A LIST? GET AN F
ReplyDeleteI agree this was on the challenging side for a Sunday just due to its complexity. The SUCKUPS section was where I ended, cuz I couldn't believe that would be the answer, and cuz blow or toot seemed more likely there.... Also cuz HUNDO is a word I've never seen before.... That final O was my last entry (@REX agree that clue for NOD was oblique.). Enjoyed the challenge! Thanks, Simeon
ReplyDelete1. I love hard puzzles.
ReplyDelete2. I love themed puzzles.
3. Themed puzzles should be fun to solve and should be worth the solving.
It’s when should-be-fun themed puzzles are too resistant to giving the payoff that I get mean about puzzles. This is a good example. It’s clearly a neat idea, but it wasn’t worth the solve, IMO.
It does make me feel better when I spend the entire time solving cursing about the weird theme, and then I come here and you didn’t like it either.
ReplyDeleteHa ha, so true! :-D
DeleteI always come here first because of the size of the grid on Sundays. I'm prone to typos & hate having to search for them.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed your write-up, Rex, thank you.
I think I'll pass & go back to sleep.
Where was the joy in this?? Absolutely no fun.
ReplyDeleteI admit it was a struggle, however I did enjoy the solve. Shaky start and thought I'd never get it done, but eventually succeeded with only one cheat. Eminem song. I know a Sarah, Sally, Sal so that went right in. Thanks, Simeon for a rewarding hour.
ReplyDeleteMy thoughts exactly. Flubbed the CAR/CAB thing, which led to not seeing GET AN F. (Didn't know what a trapeze dress was.) But overall a fun, challenging puzzle. I loved the clever answers to the ? clues.
DeleteI stuck with this until I had it all filled in, very sloggy that, and I had all the themers, some of which made sense but how the trick worked was still a mystery. Having read the explanation I am still somewhat mystified but don't want to spend the mental energy trying to understand something that basically wasn't much fun.
ReplyDeleteSo Sorry, SS. Hope you had more fun constructing this than I did solving it.
You're a book person. 'Blueberries For Sal' is a childrens classic
ReplyDeleteAnd her real name was Sally not Sarah (no idea what her real name was but I did read this one to my kids)
DeleteWikipedia says "Sal and Sal's mother are modelled after McCloskey's daughter, Sally, and wife Peggy."
DeleteAnd the wikipedia article on McCloskey lists his children as Sarah and Jane! So: Sarah = Sally = Sal
Deleteit was hard, but I finished. when that happens I kinda "like " it. At first I had SUCKasS and said... no way can that be right lol. ASIAMAP? didnt sound right and I know alot of Sarahs, none of them are called Sal.
ReplyDeleteMy experience exactly. A rewarding struggle! I have a book of 500 old Sunday puzzles many of which are harder than this one.
DeleteOooof. I probably spent twice as long on the bottom half as I did on the top. Felt like a slog. Just not on my wavelength.
ReplyDeleteI've always heard 'car' for elevators, but the Wikipedia elevator page is 'cab, cab, cab' and only lists car as an alternate form, so I'll concede that one. At least I caught that RULGING didn't work, and quickly got it changed to BULGING. Not so lucky on the right side: I typed in WALKOFF instead of WALKOUT and never checked crosses until no happy music, so that took a while to find/fix.
Right after I revealed the S of Sal (could not make 104A make sense without that S and could not see that the S was needed) I stared at this Sunday oeuvre and wondered just how much Rex would dislike it. Me, I admired the crazy theme answers but had problems with every area Rex mentioned. CAr, NOD, huh? SAL, there are any number of alternative ways to clue SAL. Nickname of Sarah? Not a thing, as far as I know. Why would a nice, short name like Sarah need a nickname anyway?
ReplyDeleteSorry, Simeon, I can't say this was my favorite Sunday puzzle, as interesting as it was.
It is a thing. And surprisingly enough, Peggy and Peg are nicknames for Margaret. I wonder if women are more familiar with these than men?
DeleteBlecccchhh. So I get clever construction, up to a point. Not my thing but okay. No, my problem was that in order to achieve that he has to use SO much fill of the "No human ever says that" variety. Starting with Sal--one of those "are you really going to go there????" things where you see what the answer has to be but you just don't want to fill that last square because it is So. WRONG. I mean, if that's what you want why not clue it "Salvatore," or some fictional character or whatever. One of these duds you could maybe get away with if it was only one but the thing was packed with this forced, strained crap. I get "sesh" is kind of a thing outside xwordese, but the plural??? No. No one says that. Here's why: "sesh" drops a syllable so it's the kind of elision people do in spoken language but how is "seshes" quicker than "sessions"? You'd just say "sessions." So awkward. And HUNDO??? Who the heck ever said that? "C-NOTE" sure. "Benjamin," absolutely. And "thou," "grand," "large" (my favorite) for thousands. HUNDO? No. What's so annoying about all these duds is what they communicate to the solver. "Hey, my word list threw it up so it's fair even if it's ugly AF so Imma use it," or to put it another way "I gotta make this dang thing work cuz that's all I care about. Admire me for the cleverness of my construction!" I see some upthread are filled with exactly that admiration. "Hey, the fill admittedly sucked but you gotta do that to achieve this marvel of computer-assisted complexity!" Whereas for me the annoyance is going to outweigh the admiration pretty rapidly. If you've gotta lean into your wordlist this hard and break the compact that the answers have to actually be a thing, that feels like a constructor fail, not an achievement.
ReplyDeleteI’m wondering if nicknames for particular denominations of currency is a generational thing. I’m in my 40s and I have never heard all of the terms that the crossword is teaching me (C-note, Benjamin, etc.), and I just accept that maybe people used to when we were using cash more. Anyway, all that to say, I was glad to read your comment and have it affirmed that HUNDO is indeed a bridge too far. I stared at it in utter disbelief.
DeleteSeshes should be banned.
ReplyDeleteI struggled, I prevailed, it was not much fun.
ReplyDeleteSolved, but a hard no on the next puzzle by this guy. Effin' "SAL", come on.
ReplyDeleteI concur with Rex's two star grade but for opposite reasons. I thought the theme was frightfully clever and extremely well executed. I would love to have given this puzzle high marks, but alas, it ends on a natick: SETI/ITALO. Now Rex lists "SETI" as a bullet point, but doesn't comment, so let me fill the vacuum: I get around the internet pretty well, and in my younger years was a sci-fi addict. Never once have I encountered this acronym! And why bother creating one in the first place? How often does this phrase occur? Geesh. I consider naticks generally as editorial oversights. We all have blind spots, but it is the editor's job to identify those of the constructor and keep puzzles workable. I think this one is frequently sleeping at the switch.
ReplyDelete@Ken Freeland, SETI is a pretty common term in science fiction and astronomy. Google AI says it originated in print in 1976 (in the New York Times!), so if you haven't been into SF much since then you might not have heard of it.
DeleteHi Ken! First, I cheated to finish because this puz wasn’t my cuppa. But, gotta say, I’m surprised that your DNF was at SETI considering (for me) the myriad other possibilities. So I guess my comment is just that I didn’t see the edit failure at SETI/ITALO (ITALO Calvino has been in numerous past puzzles)
DeleteCassini, Mercator, Peters…nope! ASIA map. What are we doing here?
ReplyDeleteHmm. I liked it.
ReplyDeleteI'm eighty-one, so I have to print Sunday puzzles as large type, i.e. grid on one full page, clues on another. But whenever some type of weird graphic element exists, the only way it prints is very small on one page, making it virtually impossible to read and solve. Sorry for the rant.
ReplyDeleteYes yes yes!!! I finished but that makes it very hard. NYT should find a fix for that!!
DeleteI've known at least two women named Sally who went by Sally
ReplyDeleteRex, FWIW:
ReplyDeletefrom Google AI:
Yes, Sal (or more commonly Sally) is a traditional nickname for Sarah.
Historically, this nickname evolved through a common English phonetic shift where the "r" sound in a name was softened or substituted with an "l" sound (similarly turning Mary into Molly or Harry into Hal). Over time, Sally became the most common traditional diminutive for Sarah, and Sal functions as a shorter variation of that name
Thanks for the etymology on that one! I guess when you roll your “r,” your tongue is near the “l” position, so that shift makes sense (I had always wondered why Prince Hal was thus called). I appreciate learning this much more than I did learning SEPOY!
DeleteI admire our host. He is committed to solving and analyzing, pretty much every day. Thank you @Rex. I, OTOH, have the luxury of walking away, which I did today. Early on.
ReplyDeleteYeah, this was one-star for me, and I almost always like puzzles more than Rex. Several times during the solve I said, “ugh” because the fill was so dreadful. Though I half-understood the theme, I didn’t even take the time to figure out both words in each themer, because I just wanted to be done. I love hard puzzles, but this one didn’t have any answers that brought joy.
ReplyDeleteI had a DNF because I entered “SERIes” instead of SERIAL and could not find my error. “DES PLeINES” seemed plausible, but I couldn’t figure out JAIsABLE.” I was so convinced of “SERIes” that l kept running the alphabet to see what other word could end with “AIsABLE” and what other word might stand in for “JOE” as coffee. Anyone else?
ReplyDeleteYes, that was the one area that really tripped me up, since I also started with SERIes, which made me doubt JOE. I got it eventually.
DeleteMe too. See my comment below.
DeleteI rarely just want a puzzle to be over, but that was my wish today. Jailable.
ReplyDeleteI'm with those who liked it. After the first two equations were filled in, I went back over them to figure out what was going on. After that, I enjoyed guessing the components (circles + blanks), having the best luck with PLIERS and UNSHORN, having to wait for PATENT. For me it's a bonus when a crossword requires extra "puzzling."
ReplyDeleteI think the ‘pro tip” NOD was a tipping of the head in approval, if you are ‘pro’ something. Not that that makes it much better.
ReplyDeleteThis is what I said, isn’t it?
DeleteIt’s what I was trying to say. Sorry if unclear. I never know in situations like this if I was unclear or if people just didn’t read.
DeleteWhy not both?
DeleteIt’s ok Rex. I know I’ve misunderstood you a few times because I’m going over your points too quickly. Today I totally got what you were saying because it was also my thought process on “pro tips.”
DeleteOoop, apologies, Rex—rereading it, that is exactly what you said. I’m not sure why it struck me as meaning something else when I read it the first time! Sorry!
DeleteWow, this puzzle really stirred some strong feelings. The construction was complex and some clues/answers were dicey and I felt the same as many who thought a computer was likely used to develop some of the fill. However, even tho the construction was complex the gimmick was quickly discoverable and gave the solver a leg up. I am usually very slow on these puzzles so didn’t mind having to work my way through the intermingled answers and looking up. Doris the proper names. I’ve known only one SAL in my life but his name was Salvatore, so that one sailed right past me.
ReplyDeleteFor the first time in memory, I quit solving this puzzle about halfway through and I regret that I waited so long to do that. An impressively constructed total slog.
ReplyDeleteThink of Blueberries For Sal. Lovely story
ReplyDeleteYou're the second one to suggest this, but I don't know how it helps. I haven't read the book in years (and agree it's a lovely story), but does it ever say Sal is a nickname for Sarah??
DeleteThe Wikipedia page for the book describes "the adventures of a young girl named Sal" and says that she is "modelled after McCloskey's daughter, Sally." Absolutely no mention of Sarah anywhere that I can see...
His daughter’s given name was indeed Sarah.
Delete@Anonymous 6:41 Okay...but to get the point I raised, is that fact ever mentioned in the book "Blueberries for Sal"? If not, referring someone to the book to explain that Sal = Sarah is useless. Refer someone to the Wikipedia page for McCloskey as an example, but not to the book.
DeleteAm I late? I cannot tell a lie, somebody should get an F for this fill. Now if you'll excuse me I'm going to go eat a sandwich.
ReplyDeleteThis was a brilliant puzzle! A highly innovative theme carried out with panache, that anyone who appreciates crossword puzzles would appreciate.
ReplyDeletePffffffft. I very much appreciate crossword puzzles, but to my mind and many others' this was no shining example.
DeleteThis was not Medium-Challenging. It was Tedium-Challenging. This was a fussy mess of a puzzle.
ReplyDeleteMost of this was pretty easy but I got severely bogged down in the SW partly because I had SERies before SERIAL. Also, BEFALL and HESATENBUT did not come easily. Fixing that section took many nanoseconds…so medium overall for me.
ReplyDeleteA clever feat of construction that helped with my solve, but as @Rex pointed out the theme is SUS in spots. Mixed feelings is apt, although I agree with much of @Rex’s take on this one.
Had to give up and go to bed last night with blanks in at least three different areas of this slog-gish nightmare. But I arose this morning and managed to complete it successfully (in 1 hour, twenty-one minutes, and thirty-eight seconds--not counting the seven hours of rest).
ReplyDeleteMy husband and I do the NYT daily alone but often do the Sunday puzzle together. We work and read in vastly different fields so when one of us is totally stumped the other usually knows the answer, or can offer an alternative way to interpret a clue. We both enjoyed this very complex but sometimes awkward puzzle. IMHO WS should have rated it very challenging, then those who dislike spending an hour solving harder puzzles (it's a game people. You don't have to play!) can just skip a day and go for a walk instead. Loved "Try for a Royal Flush" ❤️
ReplyDeleteMany of us on here really like hard puzzles. But we like them sparkly, clever, and apt. To me and, I think, others, this one just seemed ugly.
DeletePor si no me has oído, he dicho...
ReplyDeleteThree days without @egsforbreakfast. I am concerned.
Early on I assumed I would fail on this one because nothing was flowing, and with so much thematic material blocking every route, I was stuck with a epic hunt-n-peck. Finally I managed to cobble together the row with PLIERS in it and could see how the bubbles were working and then everything gave up and went home for supper.
I'm guessing lots of commenters will have disliked the fiddliness of piecing this together, but I enjoyed it. There's an attempt at humor here, so I commend the effort. It took my typical time and my full brain power (such as it is) and I felt proud of finishing this one. I am also guessing 🦖 will grumble about the theme rows as they're wildly awkward and inconsistent, but I find them each charming in their own little way. Yeah, it's a computer-barf word-string I-know-Python tragedy, but I kept engaged and wondering what the next train wreck would look like, so it's all good to me.
I've been to some bumping parties and I wanted to "not be ALIVE," so I guess the clue is partially right.
My mother used the word PUNY often. I don't think I've heard anyone else ever use it, so that was a nice memory spark. There used to be a guy who wore a BARREL to every Bronco game no matter what the weather was like. He was known as the BARREL MAN and I think his barrel ended up in the Colorado history museum. Another memory from my youth.
Of all of the ways in all of the world to describe HOSE, I think they found the worst possible one today. It's a JAILABLE offense. We've been HOSED. They chose to HOSE us those un-L'eggs-ed HOSING HOSERS. Of all the tubular clothing available, one of them actually has "tube" in the name, and while I am a big fan of those who elect to wear such things, I'd probably prefer talking about watering the garden, or clue it as rubber item used to discipline those who put Latin endings on English words ... looking at you EMERITI lovers. QED.
No-knows: MOCHA, MASER, Fabulate, Astromancer, ASSAM, SEPOY, HE'S A TEN, BUT...
❤️ GET AN F. Impaler of note. DOG IT. Royal flush = PALACE COUP {Best clue in a long time ... epic!}
Okay enough. Let's count. (Counting Sundays is less fun than I wish it was.)
Gunkometer--
People: 13
Places: 9
Products: 7
Partials: 15
Foreignisms: 3
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 47of 140 (34%)
Funny Factor: 8 🙂
🔥 Ooh-la-la! 🔥 INSIDE DOPE. SPAWN. LUBE.
Uniclues:
1 Jokes about the boss are green. Unverified suspicions about the boss's wife are pink. Mean poems about Carol in accounting are yellow. The office pool for how many time Daryl will be late this month is filed under purple. Complaints about the pay scale are green, duh. And of course coworkers you hope get hit by a bus are ranked in order and filed under black.
2 Zoom with the number one most famous and most humorous internet tree about the "stately" moniker in the NYTXW.
3 Trumpeter performing an obnoxious solo.
4 Part of an electric vegetable.
1 INSIDE DOPE COLOR CODED
2 E-MEET A-LIST LOLS OAK
3 SOUND ONE'S HORN SHOW OFF
4 AA CELLS ONION SLICE
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: To be fondled by amateurs on the side of the road. SPARE TIRE'S ONUS.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Your opening "por si" reminded me of one of my favorite Spanish phrases "por si acaso" which translates as "just in case" but is literally "for if maybe". I have a good friend who learned his Spanish in the Peace Corps mainly by listening and left me a note once when I was housesitting for him that started "por si hay casa" which translates literally as " for if there's house". Just thinking about that always makes me smile.
DeleteI’m with you on the puzzle as an entertaining and challenging train-wreck. Some of the mixed clue-answers weren’t quite in the language, but they worked for defining the unclued answers. Once I saw what was happening the theme helped with the overall solve. I needed some help there because of the truly creative clues, like palace coup, pro-tip, take an inch etc. and the unfamiliar meme and some iffy fill. It took a bit of fiddling and it gets a thumbs up.
DeleteI usually agree with Rex for the most part, even when the crowd disagrees. It looks like today I’m solidly in the minority. Yes, it was on the hard side, about 1.5x my normal time, but I quite liked it. 4.5 stars from me.
ReplyDeleteToo obtuse for my taste.
ReplyDeleteDid not know that a party was ALIVE / “bumping” (22a) and didn’t care. Did not know about the meme (104a) but loved Rex’s expose and am now glad I’ve discovered HESATENBUT.
ReplyDeleteOtherwise liked a lot of the clues/ answers (MOW for take an inch from a yard, 46) but found way too many to be tortured or completely unknown (MASER at 59d obscure, GOGIT at 23d ??). Circles are difficult to see on my iPhone app - in fact can’t see them at all when word/ phrase is selected - so I just figured they meant something that I could eventually figure but decided to just come here instead (it was 1 am!)
Does it help that 23D was DOG IT
DeleteOops. Sorry. (But no doesn’t help.)
DeleteIt takes a distinctly unfun crossword for me to give up my general respect for setters - they are all better than me.
ReplyDeleteThis one does that. Loved the theme. Hated every. other. thing. I’m a little miffed at Mr. Shortz for letting some of those clues get by. I just kept saying ‘nope’ as I solved it. It could have been so much better with stronger clues.
As someone else wrote, this puzzle stirred up some quite strong feelings!
ReplyDeleteI probably solved half of it as a themeless, relieved that the equals signs didn’t affect the downs. Eventually I realized that the circled letters corresponded to one of the words in the clue, which helped. I confess I never (until I came here) saw that the uncircled letters were also words. So quite a bit of the brilliance of the puzzle was lost on me. I, too, was ignorant of CAB, and stared at RULGING uncomprehendingly for a bit.
It makes sense to me that those who fully grokked the theme would enjoy the puzzle. Since I didn’t get it, the experience was meh. I solved it more as a work-like task. I knew I could finish it whether I got the theme or not, because I can always finish. And, not for the first time, I appreciated that the puzzle is a CROSSword: we get two chances at every square!
I'm a longtime Rex reader, and annual financial contributor, and neither of those things will change. But I strongly disagree with today's puzzle review. The construction was brilliant, and the solve was both fun and challenging - the perfect combination. I'd have give this 4 or 4.5 stars. But Rex's opinion is no less valid than mine!
ReplyDeleteThis was awful.
ReplyDeleteI just completed this crossword with my brother, and we found the puzzle to be far better than most Sundays. Rex's criticisms hold water (BARRELBELLIED? SAL?), but we were able to look past the questionable answers, at least enough to fill them in, and enjoyed figuring out the puzzle's challenging structure. Once we figured it out, the remaining theme answers were not so hard because each theme answer has multiple clues, multiple ways to be solved. There was less junk fill than usual (which is saying a lot; hello again EMO, BAE, UMA, SPF, UNO ...) and some clues are quite cleverly written. Since I'm usually posting about puzzles I think are stinkers, I'm happy to post a positive review for a change.
ReplyDeleteThis is a perfect example of computer aided construction run amok. We get convoluted themers with no real basis in the language. BARRELBELLIED was the poster child but pretty much all of them grated on my nerves. BARREL chested is a common phrase and I would think everyone has heard of a potBELLIED pig but when your software spits out BARRELBELLIED and you choose to use it you have to wonder how bad were the rejects? Things that aren't really in the language amp up the difficulty level , which I appreciate, but the attempts at cluing them as if they were are just cringe inducing.
ReplyDeleteMost of the fill today was boilerplate and that helped to smoke out the weird theme but ASIAMAP was in a category all by itself. It's in the running for worst debut of the year. The oof factor for me is that it has ASIA in it and it comes across sounding like "Chinglish."
Speaking of debuts the clue for CAB was a completely new one. I had a CAR/CAB write over because I've never heard them referred to as CABs always CARs. After solving I checked the entire Shortz era clue list for CAB and sure enough this is a debut. For all the recent history of the NYTXW it's been either a taxi, a wine or the front end of a semi. Maybe the editor just wanted to add some insult to today's injury.
On a positive note I was forced to learn that SAL is a nickname for Sarah. Every dark cloud has a silver lining... only not.
I got the congrats after slogging through this thing on my phone last night and it really wasn't worth the eye strain.
I'm solidly in the Dislike camp with Rex. It was a painful slog, which is a shame because the themers are actually ingenious. When I had most of them figured out, I admired them, but that was the only positive thought I had in this 38 minute slog. And I think we've seen this type of broken-up-phrase theme several times recently.
ReplyDeleteAnd I'm always unhappy to see:
- Lots of circles all over the place
- Clues that read "See XX-across"
- Black squares with special symbols that aren't really necessary (although Across Lite doesn't show them, which is actually a good thing).
3 strikes!
Oh... at least I learned a new meme: HE'S A TEN, BUT.
BTW, I had enough to fill in SETI for 99D and knew what SETI is... but since SETI is an abbreviation, why is there no abbreviation in the clue ("Field of inquiry that so far has not had any provable success")? Doesn't this violate crossword construction principles? Am I missing something?
ReplyDeleteAm I the only person who put in JAILBIRD instead of Jailable?
ReplyDeleteMy Catholic mother wanted a Saint’s name for my sister Sally!
ReplyDeletePretty much the same experience as Rex, including the final CAr -> CAB error. Such a drag to solve I nearly left it unfinished (breaking a long streak) as my own QUIT IN PROTEST.
ReplyDeleteI thought the meme might begin with HESgay_ _ UT. I figured the anticipated answer couldn't possibly be right, even in the post-breakfast era.
ReplyDeleteWhat's with the Anonymous chain of "hated it" at the top of the blog?
Worst puzzle ever, in my 50 plus years of doing it. For all the reasons others have stated.
ReplyDeleteJust awful, for all the reasons set forth by OFL. Awful.
ReplyDeleteI hated and despised this puzzle. Where's the fun? The entertainment? The 'have a nice weekend' charisma? This wasted my time AND pissed me off.
ReplyDeleteWell, I have to say that I thought "Take an inch from a yard, say" was a clever and amusing clue for MOW (except that "say" was totally unnecessary).
ReplyDeleteOther than that, I agree with Rex at every point. And to Rex's critique I'll add that I found it annoying and inelegant that there was no consistency as to which part of the theme clues referred to the circled part of the answer.
I'm just not a fan of these elaborate constructions that say "Look what I did!" but are a slog to solve.
Tough one!!!! I had to give up after a long slog. Loved some of these comments, “Tedium-Challenging “. Brilliant!
ReplyDeleteHad palace poop for royal flush
ReplyDeleteWell, puztheme was definitely different, which is a plus. But alas, not enough humor for yer SunPuz solvequest. I reckon that will keep folks from bein real thrilled with it. [Includin M&A.]
ReplyDeleteSome noteworthy items:
* Just an X short of yer pangrammer.
* HESATENBUT is just a T short of a now-common Trump weird comment splurge.
* That UAE clue may be mistaken! My sources tell m&e that the UAE withdrew from OPEC in May, 2026. Right?
* Cool ACHOO/IMHOT clue twerkers, for a refreshin dash of humor.
* Fabulouso U-count!
staff weeject pick: SAL. The name of a very beloved lady in M&A's life.
Thanx, Mr. Seigel dude. Heckuva puztheme to develop, so thanx for yer efforts. But puztheme = WedPuz, IM&AO.
Masked & Anonymo12Us
p.s.
Runt puzzle:
**gruntz**
M&A
I think everyone who has commented did this online. The hard copy version has a different clue for 88 & 90 across. It’s Gym weight + Counted on. I did get ‘bulging’ and ‘barrel bellied’. But not because of the cluing.
ReplyDeleteI did the hard copy. BULGING = (uncircled)BARBELL and (circled) RELIED. Right?
DeleteRather on the harder side today, at 105 percent of my average. That's two of the last three!
ReplyDeleteI definitely like the idea of the theme today, but it's hard to argue with Rex that the execution is a bit on the haphazard side (ASIA MAP ugh). Nonetheless, I seem to have enjoyed the wordplay more than he did. And of course, it is rather impressive.
It was just talking to someone about the great prevalence of OREO in crosswords. I wonder if it's just a NYTimes thing, since that's all I play. And EDEN, and AGRA, and...
I should've trusted myself on ERATO. I did learn something new about MOCHA.
Errors: SOP for SOT. MUST for LEES. SOS for SPF lol. CUT for MOW. CAR for CAB, as with Rex. BOGEY for SLICE. SERIES for SERIAL, which I was a bit annoyed at. Not too bad. Oh yes, ZEALOUS briefly for ZEALOTS.
So many complaints about (adjective) easy puzzles and look what happens when one has to struggle; “I couldn’t finish it so it was bad!” It was challenging and not every answer fit nicely into everyone’s reality (do they ever) but like most things worth doing it require an effort.
ReplyDeletewhat a dreary slog... boggles the mind anyone thought this was a good time - happy Sunday!
ReplyDeleteWhat a garbage puzzle. I guess it's cool we might still have something democracy-ish but this puzzle nonetheless ruined my week ;)
ReplyDeleteMy alternate clue for 105D: Mineo or Bando
ReplyDelete50D: based on crossers, I initially had MACHA, but almost immediately thought to myself...'Wait, doesn't that have a T, and isn't it Asian [I guess I could look up areas where the leaves are produced on an ASIA MAP!]?'...and a few seconds later my brain popped out MOCHA.
Good review, Rex. The puzzle's title says it well. Now I'll UNSEE it.
ReplyDeleteMarmee
ReplyDeleteI am not enamored of these convoluted constructed puzzles. Always have just put it down to being a dinosaur. I do crosswords for fun/enjoyment. This wasn't for me.
I'm a family genealogist and knew Sally was a common nickname for Sarah - in the past. Haven't heard it in contemporary times, and I know a number of Sara(h)s. History and England are also interests, so knew SEPOY.
As a cranky old lady, I also dislike the prevailing slang practice of shortening words - SUS, HUNDO, etc - when did we get so lazy it's too much trouble to fully pronounce a word?
ASIAMAP was terrible, entered TEA before JOE ( cuppa misdirect ), I have to confess I wrote JAILBAIT before JAILABLE.
I finished because I cheated then felt why did I bother. Hope all had a stupendous Sunday!
It’s very late to comment and probably nobody will read, but just wanted to pop in and say that one particular clue was quite easy for me today! I’m 86 and named after my grandmother, so yeah, comments about (most) solvers being too young to know that nickname are spot on.
ReplyDeleteReally awful. ASIA MAP is an absolute no. BARREL-BELLIED, no. etc.
ReplyDeleteAlso most of the time the first clue referred to the uncircled answers, but one time only (23a) the first clue referred to the circled answers. I understand that was the only time the answer started with circled answers but all a little sloppy imo.
Wow
ReplyDeleteI liked the puzzle. Thought Rex wouldn’t. but surprised by the general anger. A majority seemed to find it hard (even Rex). Maybe that caused some of the commotion?
I found it on the “easy “ side, except the bottom. My. time would be an eternity for most commenters btw. I was helped by the fact I have heard of MASER and ITALO. Wheelhouse and all that.
SAL was a gimme for me. It is an old name BUT there is a little ditty about the Erie Canal which mentions SAL a, female name -it is not ancient history.
Variations on standard phrases, like SOUND for tOot do not bother me.
Glad to hear so many negative reviews. I’m a relative newcomer to this blog. Maybe been following it for two years. This was very un enjoyable and I was glad to see that so many other people had a tough time with it.
ReplyDeleteI don’t usually comment but had to today because I absolutely adored this puzzle. Finally, a Sunday with some teeth! It’s rare anymore that I pick up a puzzle and then have to put it down because I’m at a standstill and then I pick it up again after things have marinated. I enjoyed the unique clueing, and I especially enjoyed finding out the “trick“ at which point everything else fell into place. A very satisfying solve!
ReplyDeleteWow, it's 8 PM EST and there are 160 comments! I'll add my own response and then read everyone's. I agree with everything Rex said: impressive construction, some very tough cluing, but a slog to solve.
ReplyDeleteHad CAr instead of CAB, then tried CAB + BULking...just couldn't come up with BULGING. Oh well. Happy to have gotten 99% of it.
Idk, I liked it. Challenging and fun. Impressive construction. Thanks for the workout Simeon.
ReplyDeleteSEPOY made me feel like Eugene T. Maleska had risen from the dead.
ReplyDeleteIs today a special day in Indian history? There’s Agra, Assam, and sepoy here, and today’s midi was the India Gate.
ReplyDeleteCompared to most Sundays, this took twice as much time while being half as much fun.
ReplyDeleteThe effort was not worth the reward.
ReplyDeleteJust so glad other folks had trouble w this one. Been doing NYT for decades IN INK, but this one was inexplicable. Constructor wants to be too cute by half? That equals annoying.
ReplyDeleteWow. I guess I did a different puzzle than 95% of the people here. I absolutely loved this one! And did not find it terribly difficult, even though week after week I discover on this blog that pretty much everyone here is smarter than me. It took me a while to figure out the theme. But once I got it, I couldn’t wait to tackle each of the other theme entries. Great stuff! Sorry most of you couldn’t find any fun here.
ReplyDeleteZero days without a Bible reference.
ReplyDeleteOk: how is the answer to BEAN OR GOURD a MELON? I found the puzzle challenging, but finished it and liked that it didn’t hand you any hints to figuring out the theme.
ReplyDeleteThis was an AWFUL puzzle. Not because it was hard (I got it all) but because many of the clues are poor. For me, a poor clue is one in which — after you get the correct answer — your first reaction is…really? “Stump” is “bemuse”? “Pro tip” is “nod”? Really??? Interesting construction that took me awhile to crack, so kudos for that. But otherwise…really?
ReplyDeleteHere it is Thursday and I’ve only completed 5% of the puzzle. Total frustration (and indignation) that the creator thinks this is a clever puzzle.
ReplyDeleteToughest Sunday in a long while and a very satisfying solve.
ReplyDelete