Sunday, October 18, 2026

Non, ni, 'a'ole / SUN 10-18-26 / Less than satisfactory, slangily / Novel form of summer escapism? / Tree that can be a source of water for thirsty elephants / Taib? Tbia? / Cupcake, in Ireland / ___ Allen, host of "Chopped" / "Ibis" poet / Pricing game on "The Price Is Right" / Sex symbol of the 1950s-'60s, familiarly / Reason to head for the hills / Bob ___, alter ego of Mr. Incredible

Constructor: Peter Gorman

Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium


THEME: "Tell Me About Yourself!" — The puzzle is talking to you about itself (?)— “I" phrases are clued in some kind of punny or unexpectedly literal way (???):

Theme answers:
  • "I NEED SOME SPACE" (23A: Heyhowareyou) [you 'need' to put space in between the clue words]
  • "I TELL YOU WHAT" (32A: "What") [literally, just the puzzle telling you 'What']
  • "I MISSED YOU" (49A: All--can-eat buffet) ['You' is missing from the clue phrase]
    "I DON'T SAY THIS LIGHTLY" (65A: "This") ['This' is clued in bold, i.e. not lightly]
  • "I'M OVER HERE" (86A: See 88-Across) [the clue for 88-Across ([Here]) is literally directly below this clue]
  • ON EARTH (88A: Here)
  • "I HAVE NO WORDS" (97A: Non, ni, 'a'ole) ['no' words, i.e. words that mean 'no' in other languages]
  • "I'M A BIT CONFUSED" (114A: Taib? Tbia?) ["a bit" confused, i.e. with letters mixed up]
Word of the Day: HEIDI Gardner (106A: "S.N.L." alum Gardner) —

[from the Apple TV show Shrinking]
Heidi Lynn Gardner (born July 27, 1983) is an American actress, comedian, and writer. She was a cast member on Saturday Night Live, an NBC sketch comedy series for eight seasons from season 43 in 2017 until season 50 in 2025. She was promoted to repertory status on the show in 2019. [...] Gardner departed the show in 2025, after the conclusion of the show's 50th season. In 2026, Gardner admitted that she was ultimately cut from the show ahead of season 51.
• • •

I can't talk much about this because I feel like I don't really get it. I never caught on to what the puzzle was trying to do ... or else I did, and I just didn't like it. I'm still hung up on how the "I'M OVER HERE" / ON EARTH thing is supposed to work. I get that [Here] is (literally) ON EARTH, but ... is the idea that "I'M OVER HERE" is, like, physically higher in the grid than ON EARTH? Because that answer is not really "over" [Here], i.e. ON EARTH. It's way on the other side of the grid. If it were literally over the answer for [Here], maybe it would make more sense to me. Maybe. I dunno [oh ok, just realized that 86A: See 88-Across is “over [Here]” in the clues! I never look at clue layout, so that was obviously hard to appreciate]. "I TELL YOU WHAT" is funny in its ridiculous literalness, but "I NEED SOME SPACE" doesn't really land. You just ... don't space the words? But ... "you" are speaking, so do you really "need" space(s between your words)? But I guess if “you” are the puzzle, it makes sense, “you” should have spaces. The way the "I MISSED YOU" clue is written is so awkward—the "you" in "All-you-can-eat" is just missing, so you get this double dash ("--") thing, which (for me) was really hard to read / make sense of. Whatever sense of humor is happening here, it's mostly just missing me. The fill also creaks throughout. The SMOLT / OCTAL pairing is a real lowlight, as is IN A MEMO, NO BUENO (?) and ABED, a word no one uses that also gets an "?" clue (3D: Undercover?). Never thought of ABED because I've never used the word ABED. Feels archaic. But like I said, I shouldn't go on because this felt like it simply wasn't for me. Maybe it's over my head, like some kinds of comedy that everyone seems to love and I'm like "I don't get it." It's very possible.


Sorry, I really truly have nothing big-picture to say about this puzzle. I found it toughish in places, but somehow also finished quickly. The TONE / ABED / NO BUENO part def slowed me down, but other than that, there weren't any obviously thorny places. Occasionally the clues got (for me) very hard, like with GELATO (117A: It's cold in Italy) and BUN (115D: Cupcake, in Ireland) and even OVID, whom I've read a bunch, but "Ibis"? (36D: "Ibis" poet). No idea. Four-letter poet, though—not hard to infer. I don't know who various SNL alums are or who hosts Chopped or who the "alter ego" of Mr. Incredible is (?!?!), so I had to work through those, but that's just normal everyday solving trouble. Seemed like there were a lot of names, but none of them sank me. I think my favorite clue of the whole puzzle was 56D: Reason to head for the hills (SKI TRIP). The puzzle was pretty light on high points for me.

["I'm right over here / Why can't you see me? Oh oh oh..."]

Bullets:
  • 24D: Sex symbol of the 1950s-'60s, familiarly (MARILYN) — was expecting a nickname ("familiarly"), but first names are "familiar," and she was commonly referred to by just the one name, so that's fine.
  • 85D: "Lay it on me" ("SHOOT") — kept wanting it to be "SAY IT." Which is reminding me that ON EARTH (the "H" cross) was actually pretty hard to put together.
  • 117A: It's cold in Italy (GELATO) — does GELATO mean "cold" in Italian? No, that's FREDDO. That makes this clue weird, since GELATO (the frozen dessert) is cold no matter where you are. 
  • 7D: Novel form of summer escapism? (POOL READ) — I have definitely heard of BEACH READ. I have definitely not heard of POOL READ. I get it, I just haven't heard anyone use it as a term.
  • 48D: Series finale? (ETC.) — Does that even really need the "?" I had ESS here.
  • 82D: Something in which you might stand for a spell (BEE) — this one seems like it should have a "?"—does anyone call the act of spelling a word a "spell"?
  • 96D: Pricing game on "The Price Is Right" (PLINKO) — I guess it's a classic game from that show, but I haven't thought about that show since the '80s and am surprised we're still supposed to know things about it. It's still on the air, isn't it? Does Drew Carey host it? [checks] Yes. This is his 20th season. I forget that daytime TV still exists. Sometimes I forget that network TV still exists. I don't think I could name more than a handful of shows currently on the air, across all the major networks (ABC NBC CBS FOX). 
  • 71A: They can make a pronounced difference (UMLAUTS) — cute, but also very vague, as many diacritical marks (all of them?) do this (i.e. change pronunciation of a letter).
  • 115D: Cupcake, in Ireland (BUN) — I thought "Cupcake" was a pet name, so I really wanted "HON," but that didn't seem very Irish.

That'll have to do for today. Sorry I couldn't work up enthusiasm for this thing, even negative enthusiasm. It just missed me. See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

P.S. maybe I'm just crossworded out—I had a lovely day up in Ithaca at the Finger Lakes Crossword Competition, scoring puzzles and chatting to people and eating Oreos and what not. Turnout was as big as I've seen it, which is great, since all the proceeds go to Tompkins Learning Partners, an adult literacy org. It's fun scoring puzzles because you get to see exactly the place(s) that are most difficult for people. There was a cross in the Toughest puzzle today that wiped out maybe 1/3 of solvers: Beethoven's "MISSA Solemnis" crossing Chocolat director LASSE Hallström at the "A." The Toughest puzzle also had a tricky theme where answers were represented literally in the puzzle, like AGEBEAUTY ("Age before beauty") and DEATHLIFE ("Life after death"). One of the answers was NOONDOGDAY, for Dog Day Afternoon, which some people had apparently never heard of—I saw a couple Dog Day Afterboons and at least one Dog Day Aftersoon. Maybe they thought SOONDOGDAY was Soon Before Dog Day—sounds like something directed by LASSE Hallström (he directed My Life as a Dog, after all). Anyway, a good time for sure. But yes, I'm tired.


[Middle school cafeteria!—this photo shows the whole room but you can't really see the bulk of the crowd, who are at table in red chairs near the front of the room]

[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️: 
  • Venmo (@MichaelDavidSharp)]
=============================
📘 My other blog 📘:

86 comments:

  1. Usually when a constructor places a colorful commonly-used phrase in a grid – one that doesn’t often show up in puzzles – it gets high praise. Which is what it deserves, because so many such phrases have simply worn out their welcome, and new ones aren’t very easy to come by.

    But look at what Peter did today – seven common phrases, all with dash, all so sweetly conversational … and five of them have never shown up in the Times puzzle before. The other two – I’M OVER HERE and I MISSED YOU have appeared only once before.

    That is not only amazing; it elevates the entire puzzle, fills it with interest.

    Speaking of newness, how about the theme answers acting as the clues for their clues? How cool is that?

    Plus, it was fun trying to guess the theme answers with as few crosses as possible.

    When you add color, newness and fun to the normal pleasure of filling the grid – and you did just that, Peter – created a most gratifying and splendid outing. This was fabulous, and thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous6:35 AM

    Glad to finish this one. The SE was the last to fall after I got AMIDST. Second hardest was SW with PLINKO, which I never heard of, and ATPAINS which I filled in before I understood it. I laughed out loud at IMOVERHERE, so I must have liked it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous2:27 PM

      I think you have east and west mixed up. Plinko answer was in the SE

      Delete
  3. Anonymous6:35 AM

    I didn't really get the theme either, so I went over to the Wordplay column and I now realize what is going on. It seems that you are supposed to imagine the puzzle talking to us. Specifically, the answer to each italicized clue should be thought of as the puzzle telling us something about the clue in the first person (since the puzzle is speaking, it speaks in the first person). So the clue [Heyhowareyou] has no spaces, so the puzzle is telling us "I NEED SOME SPACE." The clue [All--can-eat buffet] is missing "you," so the puzzle tells us "I MISSED YOU." And so on. Then there is [See 88-across], which is the *clue* directly above 88-across. Since 88-across has clue [Here], the puzzle is describing the clue for 86-across when it says "I'M OVER HERE." This is a rather unusual theme that I wouldn't have picked up without the explanation, but it does seem to be consistent.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous6:36 AM

    What happened to the Star Wars counter? Hasn't it been a week?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous7:03 AM

      His counter has NEVER gone beyond 2 days. He apparently wants you to think that that's the longest they've ever gone.

      Delete
  5. I’ve said it before - if I wanted to do the cryptic I’d do the cryptic. Truly dislike this type of theme in a crossword. The big guy rightly highlights how disjoint the big picture is.

    LORELEI

    Overall fill was typical Sunday-sized grid sloggery. I do like BLOSSOMS, SMOLT and BOTANIC. The DETONATOR - SHOOT pair is ugly - I say NO BUENO to LOOKY LOO and BOOMER. You’ve never come across POOL READ because it’s not a thing. We do get SB stalwart BAOBAB.

    Tom Tom Club

    Coldest morning of the season - this solve did nothing to warm things up. @Gil turned me on to Peet’s years back - I’ll brew it a little stronger today.

    The Pogues

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous7:14 AM

    A bun in Ireland is not the same as a cupcake. We have both and they are definitely different things.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:40 AM

      what Horton heard...asked...female sheep

      Delete
    2. Anonymous 7:14 AM
      A near top google search shows cupcake as One descriptive Close enough for crosswords. (Sweet dessert not savory, with frosting).

      Delete
  7. Anonymous7:18 AM

    Yes, Plinko is a Price is Right game, but it is not a “pricing game” — just a simplified pachinko ‘drop in a chip’ effort

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, it’s a pricing game, because they all are. You earn the chips by doing the pricing.

      Delete
    2. Anonymous8:22 AM

      Yes! I thought the same thing. It caused me to briefly hesitate on filling it in.

      Delete
  8. Hey All !
    Difficult SunPuz here. Took a bit to figure out the Themers were "I" phrases. I'll take the Rexplanation of the puz talking to me. I'm fine, puz, now I know how you are.

    Stuck in spots, NW last spot to fill. Had revEAL for UNSEAL, which was the catalyst causing my consternation up there. clIP for SNIP adding to the confusion.

    Had BAmBoo for SB fav BAOBAB. How no "Chuck" clue for NORRIS? 😁

    Overall good puz, different, interesting.

    Hope y'all have a great Sunday!

    Four F's
    RooMonster
    DarrinV

    ReplyDelete
  9. I got the theme at the missing "you ". I enjoyed the multiple "ahas".
    I particularly liked "I'm over here " above "on earth ". C'mon, pretty clever.
    What language is 'ni' no in? Or is it the text for no idea.
    Dog Day Afternoon is one of the greats, an amazing bunch of performances. Al Pacino and John Castle have never been better. The look on Pacino's face is worth the price of admission alone when he tells his psychotic sidekick Casale that the police are going to fly them to whatever country they want to go to and Casale says "Wyoming. I've never been to Wyoming" . Based on a remarkable true story in which the married Pacino holds up a bank to get money for his boyfriend's sex change operation. Lumet's directing is stellar, as always.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous12:07 PM

      I could not find ni=no. There are close ones, but wasn’t able to get an exact match. Ukrainian uses a different character for the ‘n’ and in some languages ni negates, but still doesnt mean no.

      Delete
    2. I think Ni is either Chinese or The Knights who say it (not that word!)

      Roo

      Delete
  10. Anonymous8:24 AM

    I thought having a word from the clue in the answer was a big no no. But here we get both here and there in the answers. And no one says boo?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous 8:24 AM
      Exceptions are allowed for themes.

      Delete
  11. Andy Freude8:29 AM

    As I was finishing this puzzle, I asked myself why I was wasting 25 minutes of my life on it. Came here hoping to find the answer, but no. Son Volt nails it with my word of the day: sloggery.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I was pretty sure Rex wouldn’t give this more than two stars, tops.

    I had a very hard time figuring out what a SKIT RIP was and why it would make anyone head for the hills.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Got off on the wrong foot early with INAMEMO, and that offness continued throughout with thinks like POOLREAD (it's beach read), NO BEUNO, AT PAINS, I HAVE NO WORDS (should be there are no words). Other than INAMEMO, nothing egregious, but just a bit off to my ear.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Puzzlehoarder8:44 AM

    Did this on my phone last night. The clue with the "no" words was the only one I didn't understand. I thought it was a sentence in some other language which is half right. It made no difference for the solve as the puzzle was rarely challenging. The SW corner was the only section that seemed intimidating but once started it went in as smoothly as the rest.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Anonymous8:57 AM

    I totally agree with you. I hope the NYT gives us more puzzles like this one.🎈🎈🎊🎊

    ReplyDelete
  16. Anonymous9:01 AM

    Dumb.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I feel seen on SAYIT and FREDDO

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous2:11 PM

      Well, GELATO means “ice cream” but also something along the lines of “frozen over” so the clue kiiiiinda works with both different interpretations. As a side note, the Italian word for cold FREDDO comes from Latin frigidus which also gave us refrigerator.

      Delete
    2. No problem with either answer, just had the exact same misdirects

      Delete









  18. It just felt very forced. I didn't like clue words being in the answers nor did I enjoy the YOU dupe. I think this puzzle needed a RESET.

    ReplyDelete

  19. I went with Pepsodent before SENSODYNE.

    Some combos in the grid today: ION and INO; DETONATOR and BOOMER; ESSO BEE; OSWALD and SHOOT (Yikes!); AMY and ROE (Amy's vote as a member of the Supremes was crucial in overturning ROE.)

    The placement of AMY Coney Barrett right above ALLPRO reminded me of the famous incident between footballer John Riggins and Sandra Day O'Connor back in '85. Riggins was with the Washington team at the time and he and O'Connor were at the same table at a banquet in DC. Riggins got drunk, knocked over two bottles of wine, and fell asleep under the table. But before his nap, he put his arm around O'Connor's husband and said to her: "C'mon, Sandy baby, loosen up. You're too tight." He later apologized and sent her a dozen roses. I guess she took his advice about loosening up, because she viewed the incident very fondly. She reciprocated and sent him roses when he made his acting debut and they had a good relationship until she passed away. Riggins joked that they would always be associated with each other, which he said was good for him and no so good for her.

    ReplyDelete
  20. My friend Red is big on animals. I like his cow, his goat and his pig. But most of all I love REDSOX.

    To some, [Large volume] may have been hard to get, but TOME TOME was a gimme.

    In addition to being father and son, Kingsley and Martin AMIS were [Buddies in Bayonne].

    "I won't ABET your crime because I'll be ABED" said Abel.

    Put the Bluegrass State between two potties and you've got a LOOKYLOO.

    For some reason this one took me forever to solve, possibly because I was watching the most boring football game in history (Ducks v. Huskers), but once I got that the puzzle was yakkin' at me, I really kinda liked it. Thanks, Peter Gorman.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I'm stuck between wondering if it's harder to try to see tiny numbers on a print out or struggle with scrolling all over trying to find the clue I want. Either one makes Sundays less fun than the rest of the week. I suppose ai could print out the Large Print edition but then I'm back and forth between two pages, not ideal. First world problems indeed.

    I caught on to the "I" -ness of the themers pretty quickly but like others got not great enjoyment from finishing just because it's what I do. I almost stopped at NOBUENO, which is a major annoyance, and I'm not easily annoyed. Add to that a bunch of names that would have been helpful to know--NORRIS, PARR, OSWALD, and HEIDI. Agree with others that POOLREAD is not a thing.

    Partial redemption by seeing ATHOS again, who has been missing, and the nod to classic crosswordese with SMOLT. Otherwise not a bunch of fun.

    Off to do some actual busking with my partner at a mall. This will be a first for me in all my years of singing, chirping away with an actual open guitar case in front of us. Hope the shoppers have lots of loose cash because we don't take plastic.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @Pablo. You don't know who Lee Harvey OSWALD is?

      Delete
    2. Anonymous8:46 PM

      I’m not Pablo, but one can easily know who Oswald is without knowing/recognizing the date of the Kennedy assassination or that Stephen King wrote a time travel novel about him.

      Delete
    3. Anonymous12:28 AM

      Sometimes Sunday puzzles won’t accommodate the large print option and are really disagreeably small. Like this one.

      Delete
  22. I get what Rex was saying, but I still thought this was fun. Plus I am tired of Rex bashing Sundays when I still so look forward to them as my Sunday indulgence. Love them.

    BTW, “gelato” as a word (not a dessert) means “frozen” in Italian. Past participle of gelare. The “congelatore” is a freezer.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ChrisS2:44 PM

      I dont understand the content complaints. It's his blog, if you don't like it don't read it. Even though I did the puzzle and really really didn't like it.

      Delete
  23. Anonymous10:16 AM

    Nope. Not for me. Oh well.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Anonymous10:24 AM

    'Gelato' does mean 'frozen' or 'icy' in Italian, that is, besides the famous dessert. So not exactly cold, but you could use it in a sentence to say something like "it's freezing". Perhaps it would have been better clued as 'it's freezing in Italy'.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous8:42 PM

      I’m confused by Rex’s confusion with this one, seems like a standard clue format to me. It’s not literally saying it MEANS the word “cold” in Italian. It’s saying it’s a cold thing in Italy. Sure, gelato is cold elsewhere, but when you think of cold things in Italy, isn’t gelato likely to be the first thing that comes to mind? The standard crossword out-of-the-box phrasing interpretation made perfect sense to me.

      Delete
  25. As soon as I saw Amy Coney Barrett, I quit. Forget you if you put a fascist in here when anything else is available as a clue for that name. 500 thumbs down to this puzzle

    ReplyDelete
  26. Anonymous10:45 AM

    My boss communicated his new policy IN A MEMe.

    ReplyDelete
  27. This puzzle was NO BUENO for me. I reacted the same way Rex did, kind of a big a big "Huh?" The I'M OVER HERE/ON EARTH entries really had me confused until Rex figured out that it was the clues that were being referenced. I've never heard POOL READ, and I've never heard pedestrians (Walkers) referred to as PEDS. I did think AT PAINS was an interesting answer, and thank goodness I got it, because I've certainly never heard of PLINKO and would have been sure it was wrong. Oh well, I can't expect to love every puzzle. Next time!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ted Striker12:36 PM

      I'm guessing you've seen a lot of "PED XING" signs; PEDS is just the plural of PED. I agree with you on POOL READ!

      Delete
  28. Anonymous10:49 AM

    Dont mind some punny answers…too many here.
    And PLEASE, Stop using so darn many names. Boring !

    ReplyDelete
  29. This one was a bit of a slog for me. Doing the occasional cryptic helped, especially with "confused" indicating jumbled.

    Like @Liveprof I had pEpSODeNe before SENSODYNE.

    If you were home sick from school in the 1980s, you were almost guaranteed to have seen your fair share of the Price is Right. ("have your pets spayed or neutered."), so that one was easy. PLINKO and pachinko are similar in the falling ball (disk?) with pegs aspect -- I wonder if that was intentional.

    Troy and ____ in the Morning! That's how you clue ABED.

    https://youtu.be/177bweUmfnw?is=C8PGutK07bsYEEa7

    ReplyDelete
  30. I enjoyed the brain-twisting (for me, anyway) TIE between the clues and answer phrases. It took me until the midpoint to understand that the clues were talking about themselves;; after that I had a couple of solver's highs, getting I'M OVER HERE and I HAVE NO WORDS without crosses, and ended with apt CONFUSION over Taib? Tbia?- was there a broken "tibia" involved? That one was hard! Thank you to the constructor - I appreciated the originality and wit.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Anonymous11:12 AM

    Rex, you sell yourself short. You know the names of at least two handfuls of network shows, CSI [blank] and NCIS [blank].

    ReplyDelete
  32. This was a tough one for me. Kudos to the folks who breezed through it. Wish it had more humor and less trivia and proper names. Felt that many of the clues had answers that were apt in retrospect but so vague that they were extremely hard to guess without multiple crosses. As one blogger mentioned earlier, maybe more like a cryptic than a traditional puzzle.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Anonymous11:36 AM

    Not my favorite Sunday puzzle. I found it odd that a word in the clue was also a word in the answer.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Rex pointed out that the clue/answer combo for 117 Across doesn’t seem to make sense. For starters, obviously GELATO is cold everywhere, so let’s just say goodbye to that potential line of reasoning.

    What else have we got to work with ? Uncle Google is indicating that CONGELATO actually means “frozen” in the Italian language, so it’s possible that some dialects may get us from CONGELATO to something that sounds like GELATO in English, but even that is a dead end (the clues says COLD , not FROZEN).

    There is a subtlety that may show some promise - GELATO is generally served a little warmer than traditional frozen ice cream (Marcella Hazan for example, emphasized serving gelato at a warmer temperature than standard American ice cream). So if you enjoy your GELATO on the more creamy side, it could be something that we crazy Americans freeze, but it would normally be served COLD in Italy. That’s a bit of a stretch though - so, at the end of the day, the clue / answer combo is confusing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous2:15 PM

      The clue is simply trying to get cute/aim for misdirection(?) by saying “it’s cold and Italian” in a fancy way. CONGELATO meaning “frozen” is actually related to the verb _congeal_.

      Delete
  35. I'M A BIT CONFUSED described how I felt doing this puzzle and I DON'T SAY THIS LIGHTLY - a slog from start to finish. Thanks to Sam & SB UMLAUTS came easily to me. Otherwise, I don't even care to go back & find my typo :(

    ReplyDelete
  36. Replies
    1. BANYAN was my first guess, but when it didn't fit, BAOBOB was pretty much all that was left.

      Delete
  37. Two thumbs down, indeed. I have never said "what is happening?" more times in one solve.

    The pic of the tournament captures, I believe, the moment that I (far right toward the top of the people, in a checkered/plaid shirt) borrowed a sharper pencil from the kind fellow in the glasses facing the camera. What a mensch!

    ReplyDelete
  38. Anonymous12:16 PM

    I found it fun! But I knew Rex would not like INAMEMO because it’s like his pet peeve EATASANDWICH. I thought NOBUENO was hilarious.

    ReplyDelete
  39. This puzzle did not fall easily for me - I was solving randomly and it took forever to get enough crosses in the theme answers to figure out WHAT was going on. Various missteps also contributed - by eMail instead of IN A MEMO, flAx before BRAN, UNvEiL before UNSEAL.

    But I enjoy punny puzzles more than @Rex so the end result here was enjoyable for me.

    I never get answers like FIR (40D) on the first try, as clued. My family, after about the time I was five years old, always had an artificial tree so there was no piney scent for Christmas. I really had no clue until FAVOR and REDSOX arrived. Nog, maybe?

    I was confused by 114A. I looked at "Taib, tbia" and thought it was going to be TiBIA related. Hah, way off.

    Peter Gorman, this was a fun Sunday puzzle, thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. While I can't condemn any puzzle I am able to successfully complete, I fully concur with Rex....unlike him, I never did grasp the theme. After a good bit of sloggery (great word, well coined!) and a couple of naticks which I educationally guessed my way through (PARR/POOLREAD, SMOLT/MCAT) I was happy to be done with this PPP extravaganza.

      Delete
  40. Points for cleverness, I guess, but it was less than fun to solve. Sunday … yeah, OK. I might have liked it more if it had run on a different day in a smaller format. Then it would have been over sooner.

    I vaguely remember a few small moments of delight last night when I was solving, but I didn’t make any notes and I’m not going to scour through that bloated grid this morning to find them. Some things are just not worth it.

    ReplyDelete
  41. I didn't get the theme and I didn't care. I totally crashed and burned in the upper left; I put UNICORN at 1 across and I was so sure of it. That made 6 down REVEAL, and 23 across HEY GIVE ME SPACE! I finally got tired of looking at that mess and just clicked Reveal Complete Solution. I haven't done that in a while. And never heard of POOL READ.

    Plus, once again, so many names. Unknowns: TED NORRIS PARR LORELEI ROSS CHU NELL HEIDI VEDA PLINKO. And what a bizarre clue for ESSO... we have lots of them here in Canada, but I have never ever heard of Happy the Oil Drop.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Okanaganer
      FWIW
      NELL is not a trivia answer. The clue ask for a common nickname for Ellen & Helen.
      But there did seem to be a lot of names.

      Delete
    2. @dgd, I didn't say NELL was trivia (but isn't it?); I said it was an Unknown Name. I have known a few Ellens and Helens but never heard anyone I know called "Nell". But say Elizabeth = Betsy, Beth, Liz, etc,... those I've heard.

      Delete
  42. Medium for me with the bottom tougher than the top.

    Exactly what @Rex said.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Anonymous2:43 PM

    Can’t say that I’ve enjoyed a Sunday recently as much as this one. Nice to have a bit of a challenge, and didn’t hate the theme.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Anonymous3:11 PM

    At least the puzzle has one good message. which I'm surprised that no one has picked up on, so far.
    87D: Ousted, democratically -- VOTED OUT. Let's do it, rbefore it's TOO LATE!

    ReplyDelete
  45. Anonymous3:13 PM

    When I thought 114-across might start with “imagine”, I had to grapple with the idea that “Irish cupcake” might mean a gun. Taking my mind to what kind of dark humor must have pervaded the gritty streets of 1970s Belfast for a few seconds too long.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Anonymous3:14 PM

    Excellent comments, unlike the quality of the crossword, sadly. I agree that it felt forced. And a cupcake is really not a bun in Ireland; also that ‘no bueno’ is terribly inelegant.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Anonymous3:17 PM

    ABED is absolutamente NOBUENO. And I don’t say this lightly.

    ReplyDelete
  48. who you talking to? would have been a more fitting title for the puzzle and methinks led to a better understanding of the theme. the phrases indeed do all add up and are pretty funny to boot!

    ReplyDelete
  49. Anonymous4:04 PM

    I really wanted "bait and switch" for 114A: Taib? Tbia?

    ReplyDelete
  50. BELT before BEAN at 80D, which took me a while to untangle.

    Also starting to hate when they clue ETSY will anything that looks like it could be EBAY. Each of them could have "Star Seller" programs for all I know.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Anonymous4:33 PM

    Took me WAY too long to finally finish. Bleh.

    ReplyDelete
  52. MetroGnome4:37 PM

    Still clueless on "gawker" / LOOKYLOO. What the hell is that about? Meanwhile, FAR too many damn names . . .

    ReplyDelete
  53. Back over my ten-minute milestone by finishing at 107 percent of my average. Alas!

    Aggressively ok about the theme, whatever the heck I mean by that. Did not know that about Lorelei! ("Mythical figure whose name means 'murmuring rock.' ")

    Annoyed at myself that I couldn't call up ECCE for " 'Behold,' in Latin"; it's in the title of a poem familiar to me, James Joyce's "Ecce Puer," and also in the Latin edition of Winnie-the-Pooh (Alexander Lenard, translator, I think). And I could not parse IMOVER____ as "I'm over"; I had the phrase "move heaven *and* earth" in my head and could not break OVER from the rest. AT PAINS was also a hard one for me to break up properly.

    I really want Martin AMIS to be the basis of that clue. Does the NY Times want near-Boomers to start stressing over the coming septuagenarianism? Septuagenarity?

    Errors: ITO(A) for INO. Tried to fit PEPSODENT or something like that in SENSODYNE's spot. NADA for ELAN (after putting NIL in correctly). BANYAN briefly for BAOBAB. REVEAL for a split second for UNSEAL. Not too bad.

    ReplyDelete
  54. Anonymous8:43 PM

    This puzzle was no bueno. Hated everything about it and came here for enlightenment

    ReplyDelete
  55. whether you like it or not every single theme answer adds up if taken in the perspective - as any reader or writer knows as the puzzle being the 1st person objective 'as it' it were talking to you the Solver. Rex doesn't post all comments - only the ones he likes

    ReplyDelete
  56. everybody wants the full breadth of a puzzles deeper meaing right away - the best things take Time to look back on and go oh yeah that was amazing - spot judgements at any point hinder clear evaluation of the real meaning of the puzzle. This was a hilariously funny puzzle where the puzzle become the ego/id and we are talking to it. get it?

    ReplyDelete
  57. Anonymous12:16 AM

    Rex, you need to see The Incredibles ASAP. You won't be disappointed.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Anonymous12:38 AM

    Ditto to all. Theme didn’t work , clues were vague or wrong e.g “ gelato” even for a crossword. Sorry to the constructor - I know these things must be hard to create but editor should have worked with you and done a better job of making the puzzle live up to the theme and creating better clues

    ReplyDelete
  59. this blog is bereft without Morrissey and the Smiths playing the puzzle with us. honestly the ny times should pay Rex as an adjunct crossword professor. that is all

    ReplyDelete
  60. A
    acjones
    nyc · Pending Approval
    the puzzles start in NYC that's eastern standard time - people are solving from different time zones - does the ny times have any clue in the puzzle department that these time zones exist and many of us are flying through the time zones as we do the puzzles. The world does not revolve around NYC. there's an idea for a puzzle Will Shortz - I would love to she a Shortz PUZZLE next SUNDAY from the WIZARD HIMSELF. all caps are only because I have only upper or lower case choices https://linktr.ee/glassjonespiano

    ReplyDelete
  61. zofrex4:39 AM

    When I consulted Google for "cold" in Italian, as well as "freddo", which I initially picked but eliminated early on, it also gave me "gelido", which was an unfortunate overlap with the intended answer and took longer to figure out!

    ReplyDelete