Relative difficulty: Easy
![]() |
| [103A: Princess Leia or Hester Prynne (HEROINE)] |
THEME: "Next, Please!" — familiar phrases where one letter has been "raised" to the "Next" letter in the alphabet, creating wacky phrases, which are clued wackily ("?"-style); the "raised" letters are all circled and spell out "PLUS ONE"
Theme answers:
I liked this one just fine, but somehow, conceptually, it felt a little flat, or unambitious. I'm not sure the core idea quite coheres. I mean, the spelled-out phrase ("PLUS ONE") says wedding or other fancy affair, while the title ("Next, Please!") says deli counter. They both contain the ideas of progression, but in different and unrelated ways. This isn't a fault, exactly, but it does mean that the puzzle lacks ... I dunno, something. Something that makes me think, "nailed it!" I was grateful for the lack of a revealer. This one didn't need one. I was kinda mad, part way through, that the puzzle had highlighted the affected ("raised") squares. Seemed like a remedial move, an unnecessary assist. But then when I was finished, I noticed that those letters spelled out a phrase and thought, "OK, yeah, you probably do need to highlight those letters in order for people to notice the whole spelling gimmick." One good thing about the theme today is that the wackiness actually works a few times, which is to say I actually laughed. Somehow the idea of someone shouting "THAT'S SO NOT OLAY!," like they're trying to avert a lotion emergency, is funny to me. I guess the other ones aren't that funny, but they're all interestingly wacky, except maybe DISSONANT CHORES, the clue for which I don't really understand. How are loading and unloading the dishwasher "dissonant" chores, any more than loading and unloading the washing machine, or setting and clearing the table? They are opposites, in a way, but "dissonant"? I feel like I'm missing something. It would not be the first time. [People are telling me that loading and unloading the dishwasher makes a “dissonant” sound because of all the dishes clanging together—I must be a more careful loader/unloader than most of y’all because this never occurred to me]
["If anyone / Should ever write / My LIFE STORY..."]
I've taken a lot of yoga classes over the years but I can't recall ever using a YOGA BALL (?). I've definitely seen exercise balls at the gym, largish inflated things that you can do various poses on (I've done forearm planks with them, for instance—really gotta use your core to stay stable), but I don't associate those balls with yoga, so maybe there's an entirely different kind of ball that I just ... missed. And I wish DANCER POSE meant anything to me, because it sounds kind of made-up (3D: Stance that resembles a ballerina on one leg). When you have to have both a word for "dancer" ("ballerina") and a word for "pose" ("Stance") in your DANCER POSE clue just to get people to imagine it, that suggests its thingness isn't terribly strong. But again, maybe it's been in front of my face forever and I just missed it. I don't think I've ever seen and I know I've never used the phrase PIN PAD(S) before either (92D: Parts of card-swiping machines). Is that the same thing as the keypad that you enter your PIN number on? Seems so. As for LOST CAT (56D: Feline that a neighbor may find) ... I love cats. I don't so much like the idea of a lost cat, but I do like that the clue tells you that the neighbor found it, so I don't have to think about the poor cat lost out there, somewhere in fictional land, in fictional peril, all alone. Still, LOST CAT feels a little bit like GREEN PAINT (arbitrary adj./noun pairing). You could lose anything—doesn't mean it warrants its own standalone LOST- phrase. LOST SOCK? LOST KEYS? These are very real things, but I'm on the fence about their crossworthiness.
That's all. See you next time.
- CONTROLLED CHAPS (22A: Stoical British guys?)
- "THAT'S SO NOT OLAY!" (37A: "The skin cream you're using must be Neutrogena or CeraVe!"?)
- MISSED A BEAU (51A: Pined for an ex-boyfriend?)
- "GIVE ME ONE SEASON!" (64A: Exasperated television producer's plea?)
- CONTACT LEOS (80A: Reach out to people born between July 23 and August 22?)
- FIRST-CLASS NAIL (94A: Good name for a salon specializing in mani-pedis?)
- DISSONANT CHORES (111A: Loading the dishes and unloading the dishes, e.g.?)
The guanaco (/ɡwɑːˈnɑːkoʊ/ gwah-NAH-koh; Lama guanicoe) is a camelid native to South America, closely related to the domesticated llama. Guanacos are one of two wild South American camelids; the other species is the vicuña, which lives at higher elevations. // The guanaco gets its name from the Quechua word wanaku. Young guanacos are called chulengos or "guanaquitos". // Guanacos stand between 1.0 and 1.3 m (3 ft 3 in and 4 ft 3 in) at the shoulder, body length of 2.1 to 2.2 m (6 ft 11 in to 7 ft 3 in), and weigh 90 to 140 kg (200 to 310 lb). Their color varies very little (unlike the domestic llama), ranging from a light brown to dark cinnamon and shading to white underneath. Guanacos have grey faces and small, straight ears. The lifespan of a guanaco can be as long as 28 years. (wikipedia)
• • •
Not much challenge to be had today, outside of trying to piece those themers together. Wacky theme answers like these can be hard to come up with, even when the base phrases are very familiar. I needed several to many crosses in order to get all of them, but those crosses were pretty easy to come by. There are only two answers in the puzzle (I think) that were not known to me at all: the hockey guy (MCDAVID) and the alpaca relative (GUANACO). Oh, and MOLEMAN (65D: Supervillain in "Fantastic Four" comics). I know a Hans MOLEMAN, but that is the only MOLEMAN I know.
I have a little 😃 written next to EMOJIPEDIA because it's apt: it's an emoji, and that answer made me smile (69D: Online reference with many faces). By contrast, I have a 🙁 written next to RESORT AREA, as I don't like that phrase (74D: Touristy destination). The AREA part just feels so vague. I had RESORT TOWN written in there for a bit. This meant that my 122A: Tibetan oxen (YAKS) were, first, ANOA (if you know you know, and if you solved crosswords in the very olden days, you know), and, second, GNUS (which are neither Tibetan nor oxen). The longer Downs add some much-needed spice to today's solve. My favorite is ON THE APPS, an extremely in-the-language phrase that I can't recall seeing in the grid before (sure enough, this is its first NYTXW appearance) (4D: Using Tinder, Bumble, Hinge, etc.). "IT'S ALL OVER" (15D: "We're toast!") also has a nice colloquial energy and pairs well (in its gloominess) with GONERS (64D: They're toast) (Ha, I didn't notice until just now that their clues echo one another like that). You've also got LIP READERS, "I HATED IT," and LIFE STORY, all solid.
Bullets:
- 112D: "Mean Girls" character Janis ___ (IAN) — if you're of a certain age, then you know who this character was named after:
- 44A: Baseball legend who dated J. Lo (A-ROD) — she's had lots of high-profile partners over the years. I like how the clue used her shortened name to cue his shortened name.
- 47A: Filthy, in slang (GRODY) — I haven't heard this since ... I wanna say 1984. But the clue doesn't say "old slang," so ... did it make a comeback?
- 17A: Foot, cutesily (TOOTSY) — if you're suffering from GRODY TOOTSY, ask your doctor about ZEQLYBIA ([extremely fast voiceover voice] "notarealmedicine")
- 121A: Like the strawberry champagne in Bruno Mars's "That's What I Like" (ON ICE) — I do not know this song but I like that I can infer the answer anyway. The clue spices up an otherwise blah answer.
- 9D: One of two found on résumés? (ACCENT) — did this trick anyone? Honestly, the way it's worded, it doesn't need that "?" at all. There are in fact two ACCENTs on the word "résumés."
- 76D: Insider, in spy lingo (ASSET) — tough one for me. Somehow "Insider" just didn't get me there. I wanted MOLE but it wouldn't fit (and was already taken by MOLEMAN!), and then ... nothing. Needed help from crosses.
- 79D: So-called "Land of a Million Elephants" (LAOS) — a million? Were there ever a million, even in idealized, pre-human depredation times? No, it's just a hyperbolic way of saying there were a lot. Kind of like the "Land of 1000 Dances"—Wilson Pickett only names like half a dozen. You have to kind of feel the rest.
[The Pony, the Mashed Potato, the Alligator (wtf!?), the Watusi ... late in the song he names the Jerk. So that's five. He claims to be "Twistin' with Lucy," but that's in the context of "doin' the Watusi," so I don't think we can count the Twist as a separate dance. Judges say: five dances. 995 still unaccounted for]
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️:
Venmo (@MichaelDavidSharp)] =============================
✏️ Upcoming Crossword Tournaments ✏️
📘 My other blog 📘:
[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️:
✏️ Upcoming Crossword Tournaments ✏️
- Westwords (Berkeley, CA, Jun. 14, 2026)
📘 My other blog 📘:
- Pop Sensation (vintage paperbacks)



_Leona_Amarga.jpg)


Dissonant because of the clatter caused by plates, cups etc knocking around as you try to cram as much dishware into the racks.
ReplyDeletedissonant chores because loading/unloading a dishwasher is noisy, what with all that clanking.
ReplyDeleteGuessing I won’t be the only one who knew “guanaco” from the opening credits of Monty Python and the Holy Grail (“closely related to the llama”). A nice flashback to my youth, for sure.
ReplyDeleteBingo. Same.
Delete
ReplyDeleteEasy-Medium. I ran into some resistance in the South.
* * * _ _
Overwrites:
kIlo before GIGA as my 33A watt prefix.
For finished at 33D I had GOT over before GOT DONE.
I had YOGA BeLt(?) before BALL for the accessory at 48D.
My 74A molecule was dNA before RNA.
bASs before CAST for the musical group at 102A.
COCKY at 102D was hard to see because of the mistake at 102A, not knowing Canadian geography, not having the 111A themer and the DISc/DISK thing at 118A.
I had misER before TAKER for the selfish one at 117A.
Jet Set before SKI at 113D.
At 118A I switched between DISc and DISK several times.
WOEs:
Hockey player Connor McDavid at 41D.
GRODY for filthy at 47A. I thought the term was "grotty" as in "grotesque".
Alpaca relative GUANACO at 47D.
Star Trek's GERI Ryan at 88A.
I'm old enough to know Janis IAN the singer, but not as a Mean Girls character. (112D)
So you never saw Jeri Ryan as Seven of Nine in Star Trek: Voyager?
DeleteAnon: What do you think, as it was listed under Woes? I don't understand the rush to correct known or unknown pop-culture knowledge. Like, if they had known it, had seen Jeri Ryan as Seven of Nine in Star Trek: Voyager, do you think they would have posted that they didn't know it?
DeleteConrad: hand up for GIGA, DNA and SET B4 the correct answers. Learned something new about my own state flag, and appreciated the weather shout out to Stumptown.
DeleteLiked Bill’s comment about the rush to say how could you not know. A lot to know in this world!
DeleteI assumed the other Anon comment was simply correcting the spelling of Jeri
DeleteLewis
ReplyDeleteTheme, movie edition:
[Many monks]
[The world of audio paparazzi]
[Paul Newman character gives his buddy’s hat a try]
[Look]
HOODFELLAS
SOME MIKE IT HOT
BUTCH CASSIDY AND THE SUNDANCE LID
DO THE SIGHT THING
Controlled Chars is … what, exactly? Slowed me down slightly…
ReplyDeleteDone quickly on a train from Granada to Córdoba. Anyone in this well-travelled crowd got any recommendations that are NOT in the guide books?
Where are you getting “Chars?”
DeleteChaos (O before P)
DeleteIt's "controlled chaos"
DeleteThat one took me a bit to see—the pronunciation difference threw me. I think that made it ultimately my favorite.
DeleteHa of course- it’s the heat…
DeleteThe Mosque-Cathedral in Corona is fascinating
DeleteI've been on that train, but I didn't stop in Cordoba. I continued on to Valencia where I wanted to soak up the atmosphere that once surrounded Cathedral organist Juan Bautista Cabanilles. The Chapel of the holy Grail in the Cathedral is definitely worth visiting. The alabaster chalice, which supposedly Christy used at the Last Supper, got dropped by a priest, probably because Cabanilles got carried away and played too long of an elevation piece at the consecration and his arms gave out; The priest died the next day. the chalice got glued back together again, it looks fine.
DeleteKinda like “50 Ways To Leave Your Lover.” Paul Simon names like five.
ReplyDeleteAt least there he says “There must be 50 ways” etc, implying here are a few but surely there are more.
DeleteFirst Sunday I've finished in a while. Had "tiamo" instead of TEAMO, which kept the music quiet at first. Mostly easy with a simple theme.
ReplyDeleteBob Mills
DeleteFWIW. Ti AMO is Italian
It's "CONTROLLEDCHAPS" and the previous letter is "O" for CONTROLLEDCHAOS".
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed this one a lot! 30 minutes last night…. Seemed easy until I didn’t get the happy music. Had to run the puzzle… found I had EMOtIPEDIA instead of EMOJIPEDIA (JERI vs tERI was no help). So that added about 4 minutes. Really enjoyed this multilayered theme! Had to grok it to get traction in the puzzle. First sensed what was going on with MISSEDABEAU, and GIVEMEONESEASON and finally FIRSTCLASSNAIL…. Went back and forth on all three of those until I figured out the base phrase had the circled letter minus one. Aha, got it! For the downs, I enjoyed LIPREADERS and IHATEDIT. GUANACO was a total WoE for me. I guess my favorite themers were THATSSONOTOLAY, and FIRSTCLASSNAIL. Thanks, David, for a terrific Sunday puzzle!!! : )
ReplyDeleteExact problem I had. Mixed up emoticons (typed faces) with emojis. Took forever to find.
DeleteAnother hand up, Rick, for having to hunt down that T in EMOtIPEDIA. I figured it was a portmanteau of emoticon and encyclopedia. And JERI, not tERI? OK, whatever.
DeleteYep. A quarter of my solve time was tracking down that same error.
Delete@Rick Sacra, hands up for EMOTIPEDIA crossing TERI, both of which never heard of. Impossible to correct without cheating.
DeleteSame here. Emotipedia/Teri.
DeleteEmoti vs. Emoji as well. Also, I can't remember ever saying, "Oh, we had the most delightful time in that RESORT AREA."
DeleteHey, me too for EMOTI. Since I'm not familiar with either one or JERI, sorry, it looked OK to me and solving on paper means I didn't know anything was wrong. That would be the end of a streak if I cared about such things.
DeleteTAB2TAB
DeleteRex also didn’t like it Not me.
I have mostly read the term “resort area “ but it is a thing Maybe something like Cape Canaveral is famous for being the “launch pad” of the US space program but it also is a resort area. Unnecessary,? Redundant? Doesn’t matter. That’s language
Oh, sweet to see David back after more than a year. Some marquee constructors specialize in themeless puzzles, and others in themed, but David does it all –he’s done 60 themeless puzzles and 51 themed in the Times, marked by wit and skill.
ReplyDeleteI loved the trip [White bed, perhaps] took me through, where first I flipped through a mental montage of beds with white frames and covers, then confidently slapped SNOW in, but then it didn’t work; eventually, with a lovely aha, RICE became clear, and I inwardly high-fived David -- got my money's worth right there.
It was fun to guess at the theme answers with as few fill-ins as possible, and it was impressive that he found theme answers that not only were of the specific letter lengths to fit symmetry, but the trick letters also spelled PLUS ONE – in order. Wow!
I always feel like I’m in good hands when doing David’s puzzles, and afterward, that I coursed through high quality. Thank you for what you do, David, and for what you did today!
DANCERPOSE is a *yoga* pose—an asana, if you will. I’m surprised that wasn’t indicated in the clue. Though, it couldn’t’ve been “yoga pose,” because YOGABALL is in the grid. No ball needed for DANCERPOSE, though.
ReplyDeleteI will indeed! Good comment to explain the awkwardness.
DeletePretty much solved as a themeless - but we are in David’s good hands so the theme has to work and has to have some type of elegant nuance - Rex summarizes it well. The lack of a revealer is welcome.
ReplyDeleteGIVE ME ONE REASON
THAT’S SO NOT OLAY takes the prize for wackiness. I would claim that any DISSONANCE loading the dishwasher is based primarily on the user. The circles are getting out of hand.
I Will DARE
Overall fill is fantastic - easy for a Sunday but smooth and fun. RESORT AREA, EMOJIPEDIA, LIP READERS all solid. My wife tells me she uses a YOGA BALL in Pilates.
Summer Day Reflection Song
GRODY is a direct throwback to the valley girl days - neat to remember. OTTAWA, SAND ART and the great MCDAVID are welcome additions. ON THE APPS should be ESCHEWed. ISIS and EROS works.
IT’S ALL OVER
A pleasant Sunday morning solve. The holiday weekend weather is rainy and cold - feels more like February than late May - I’ve already decided to break Rex’s one cocktail limit later.
Club Tropicana
Definitely finished this one with Tracy Chapman playing in my head. Thanks for the link, Son!
DeleteJust loved Controlled Chaps.. had no idea about grody.. ? Very enjoyable solve on a rainy Sunday.
DeleteAll I could think of was George Harrison’s “dead grotty” line from Hard Day’s Night.
DeleteGrody took me a little longer.
111A: It's DISSONANT because some people think it is and others do not.
ReplyDeleteNatick on tERI/EMOtIPEDIA. Had to come here to find the error.
ReplyDeleteTook my dog, Lou, to the boarding kennel, left the puzzle undone, it occurred that my whacko dog is a Lou-natick, just finished with no naticks, the changes in pronunciation (chaps/chaos and chores/chords) fouled me up as did jet set/SKI.
DeleteHey All !
ReplyDeleteGood ole David Steinberg, back after quite an absence (for him, he used to be almost a once a week constructor.) He must be pushing 30 by now, no? Getting old! (Me, not him. 😁)
Impressive construction. Notice how he needed to have a 7 letter word to go twixt 3 Themers! [center Down] And one required to be a circled letter! Plus, needing to have the Themers set in place, to get the PLUS ONE to read from top to bottom. Normally, you can move your Themers around to beget better fill, but these had to be where they had to be. And symmetrical! How many REDOs of the Blockers did he go through?
Liked the concept. Funny phrases resulting from the letter-after-the-letter-needed replacement. Was going to complain about ON THE APPS as being a made up phrase, but Rex said it's current. Again, I must be just getting too old to be currently hip. Har
Never knew there is an EMOJIPEDIA. I suppose they need to all be in one place somewhere (as opposed to the 963 of them on your phone.)
Nice one DS. What else have you been up to? LIFE STORY time
😁
Hope y'all have a great Sunday!
Two F's
RooMonster
DarrinV
Hey, @Roo, thanks for pointing out how G(circled U)ANACO connects three (of seven) long theme answers. GUANACO went from WTF (during solve) to TIL (as WOTD) to "OOH, nice" (after your observation).
DeleteThe wackiness of the theme answers certainly elevated this one; although quite a bit of Monday-level cluing and ultra-short fill (28 three-letter answers, plus seven four-letter plurals). Lots of the themes were fun; lots of the short stuff was not. Noticing the theme (and the rationale for the individual circled letters) was impressive, though the "PLUS ONE" reveal of sorts was a solving afterthought.
A few corrections along the way: SAND loT before ART; tERI (working vainly toward EMOTI...) before JERI; dNA (working vainly toward DESERT...) before RNA; yUp before DUH; YOGA mats before BALL.
Rex, ever the optimist, asserts that the neighbors found the LOST CAT, although the clue says they "may". These days, we can all use a bit of optimism, so in his oft-used phrase, "I'll allow it".
I’ve tried unloading the dishwasher before Mrs. Freude is up in the morning, and she tells me it’s quite a DISSONANT CHORE.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Rex, for the Gladys Knight song. My imaginary LIFE STORY describes my dream job as one of the PIPs.
I liked this a lot, and I didn't actually even see PLUSONE! To find phrases where shifting the letter by one works, that's fun.
ReplyDeleteI think DISSONANTCHORES refers to the fact that *simultaneously* loading and unloading is dissonant; you're working against yourself.
Almost wrote in AHAB for "Sailor's opener" (54D), as in "Call me Ahab"... except I remembered quickly it's "Call me Ishmael", of course. Now that I think of it, Chips Ahoy! was one of my favorite cookies when I was growing up.
I felt the circles were the revealer. They seemed unnecessary to the solve but did draw attention to the neat pattern behind the letter substitution. I guess if you load the dishwasher like basketball players shooting threes there is some dissonance, but otherwise in my household it’s a pretty quiet event. Unloading large dinner plates early in the morning can be trickier tho if your wife is a light sleeper. Liked this puzzle for its low-key humor and deft cluing and words like ESCHEWED.
ReplyDeleteI don't know. I was totally unamused and bored by this puzzle. Generally very easy crosswordese fill with a few unknowns. Uninteresting at best or tortured punny theme answers.
ReplyDeleteI have to agree. Sunday grids with lots of 3- and 4-letter fill are just the worst.
DeleteAlso had EMOTIPEDIA and couldn't find the mistake without looking at the answer key.
ReplyDeleteTell Rex it's THAT'S SO NOT OLAY, not THAT'S NOT OLAY.
Re dishwasher loading/unloading ... isn't it the dissonance it causes between partners, who both have very specific ideas of how it should be done?
ReplyDeleteNever heard a dispute about HOW to unload, just more of who should.
DeleteOnce I got the theme, a terrific puzzle to solve. I needed to recover from yesterday’s.🎈🎈🎊🎊
ReplyDeleteI made plenty of progress but really struggled to get the theme answers. I believe I got one of them via pretty much all of the crosses before the light bulb finally illuminated.
ReplyDeleteI had two problem areas. - Ti AMO, before TE AMO (Hi Bob), with the cross being a fictional character, so no help there. Similarly, I had tERI before JERI (again with the cross being the name of something I had never heard of).
I agree with Rex that the “wacky theme answers like these can be hard to come up with” as it took me nearly the entire grid before I grasped even one - fortunately there was a bit of a domino effect after I had my “aha” moment. The grid must have been on the easy side since I made so much progress without grasping the theme, but it was enjoyable nonetheless.
I try not to do Sunday puzzles, but the constructor's name lured me in, and I wasn't sorry; this was a fun solve.
ReplyDelete@Rex, take another look at 37-A -- It's actually "That's SO not okay"--a much better answer, IMO.
Like Ric Sacra, I finished not sure about that J in EMOJIPEDIA/JERI. I got lucky this time.
As for DISSONANT, I'm with Rex. All you folks who bang your dishes together, do you break a lot of them? I'm always trying to not bang them. So I think of those two chores as more dialectical than dissonant. But I'm glad to know there's another interpretation.
The clue for 91-A is a little odd--is milk worth crying over if it has not been spilt? Maybe if it's gone sour? (OK, it's a clue, not a definition, but it just got me thinking.)
I have come to like online solving, but there is one problem--once the grid is filled in, it's hard to see where the circles are. Because of that, I never checked to see if they spelled anything. My loss.
Today’s Sunday puzzle arrives clutching its little gimmick like a toddler who learned a card trick and has mistaken polite encouragement for international acclaim.
ReplyDeleteThe idea: take a familiar phrase, advance one letter in the alphabet, and voilà—innovation. The circled replacements spell PLUSONE, because of course they do. Why imply when you can announce? Why whisper when you can rent a blimp?
The theme answers themselves have all the subtlety of community theater. THATSSONOTOLAY (“The skin cream you’re using must be Neutrogena or CeraVe!”?) lands with the heavy-footed certainty of a joke that desperately wants you to notice it is a joke. Yes, “Olay” became “not Olay.” Thank you, crossword, for guiding me through this intellectual ravine with industrial floodlights. MISSEDABEAU somehow manages to be both overexplained and underfunny at once, which is honestly a kind of achievement. And CONTACTLEOS—“Reach out to people born between July 23 and August 22?”—has the very specific energy of a clue generated by a startup trying to disrupt astrology.
Then there’s GIVEMEONESEASON, an answer so oddly plaintive and sitcom-executive-coded that I briefly wondered if the constructor had unresolved trauma from pilot season. “Exasperated television producer’s plea?” Fine. Mild smile. But on a Sunday? We are now approximately halfway across Nebraska and the scenery remains conceptual wordplay.
And DISSONANTCHORES—“Loading the dishes and unloading the dishes, e.g.?”—is the sort of phrase that feels reverse-engineered in a laboratory. No one has ever said “ugh, these dissonant chores” in human history. This is crossword language in its purest form: vaguely grammatical, technically decipherable, spiritually synthetic.
The fill keeps doing Sunday Fill Things™. Tiny connective words carpeting entire regions of the grid like shag in a basement rec room. You lurch from ORSO to MOI to ALA to IDO while pretending this constitutes a sentence spoken by Earth residents. TEAMO sitting next to JERI Ryan and SPILT milk has the chaotic neutrality of someone emptying a Scrabble bag onto the floor and calling it narrative. And EELS clued as “They twist beneath the surface” somehow feels both technically correct and vaguely accusatory.
Yet the truly maddening thing—and this is where the puzzle earns its smugness—is that the machinery works. The theme is internally consistent. The alphabet gimmick commits to the bit. The grid moves. You solve it quickly, occasionally rolling your eyes so hard you nearly detach a retina, and then suddenly you are done, staring into the middle distance wondering whether you enjoyed yourself or merely complied.
Overall: a gigantic, perfectly serviceable machine built to deliver a joke approximately one-third as clever as it thinks it is. Mildly pleasant. Mechanically competent. So eager to be adored it practically clues itself as ADORE.
You know who’s approximately one-third as clever as he thinks…?
DeleteI completely agree with your take on today's puzzle. I was so bored.
DeleteIs this a regular poster who got signed out accidentally?
DeleteUnwritten rule for Anonymous posters is one sentence or two at most, 80% snark-20% elucidation from unexpected source.
Hands up for EMOtIPEDIA...
Am I correct in remembering that David had retired from puzzle making? I hope this means he's back; otherwise, this must be an old submission that fell into the space between someone's desk and the wall and was just found while rearranging the furniture. Hopefully the former:)
You're trying much harder than the puzzle to be clever.
Delete@burtonkd: Not sure. My initial impression is that this poster is the same Anon that posted at 7:50AM yesterday, to widespread acclaim (cf. first paragraph of today's post).
Delete“wondering whether you enjoyed yourself or complied.” I can’t tell you how accurately that describes my experience of the crossword on too many days.
Deletewhat's up john x !!
Deletetht
DeleteI immediately assumed it was the same Anonymous poster from yesterday you mentioned. He/she at first seemed to follow the same pattern, piling up criticism and then compliments. But this time more negative. His posts intrigue me though.
Scientist: Please mix me up some RNA nucleotides.
ReplyDeleteAssistant: How much of each do want in Gram Molecular Weights?
Scientist: GUACAMOLE, MAN.
It's distressing, as I get older, to find that I've often forgotten my PINATA PINPAD.
If you try to read MAPS in a mirror, all you'll see is spam.
GRODY was one of my go-to adjectives in grade school.f. I hope it's making a comeback, as it is a good and versatile descriptor.
I started out not loving the theme idea, but you had me at THATSSONOTOLAY. Thanks, David Steinberg.
PIÑATA PINPAD! Nice!
DeleteEMOtIPEDIA sounded just as good to me as EMOJIPEDIA, and tERI sounded a heck of a lot better than jERI, so a one-letter DNF. There really does not appear to be significant gird pressure in that area, so I put this down as an editing failure.
ReplyDeleteDANCER POSE is very much a thing in yoga. Yoga ball ... not so much. I've heard it called a stability ball and a fitness ball much, much more often, and never seen it used in a yoga class though I'm sure it happens.
Surprise of the day ... people don't know about adorable GUANACOs.
The cover of Who's Next is incorrect. It is not a police box but rather a big piece of concrete. Where did your image come from?
ReplyDeleteYeah, that was really weird.
DeletePresume that's a joke referencing the TARDIS from Doctor Who.... (LoL!)
DeleteYeah, okay, there were some nice answers and fresh phrases, but the whole thing felt Way Too Easy.
ReplyDeleteDancer Pose is the name of a yoga pose that resembles a ballerina
ReplyDeleteNot at all hard, but lots and lots of short fill in a bumpy grid made me think of needle and thread, going across, down, across, down, over and over. So not much whoosh going on until I fully understood the thematic brief. I thought the theme answers were excellent, though. I wonder how long this took to construct. The reverse-engineered transformation CHAPS --> CHAoS was especially nice IMO, since there just aren't many words with the letter string "aos", LAOS being a notable second example. And THAT'S SO NOT OLAY and GIVE ME A SEASON just ring out their wackiness loud and clear, with a very pleasing sound to them. Not DISSONANT at all. I cannot say the same however for DISSONANT CHORES since you have to change the CH sound used in CHORdS. Oh, FIRST CLASS NAIL is also very fine. O NICE, I say!
ReplyDeleteEMOJIPEDIA: see, now this is a very useful piece of information for me. I am constantly, constantly flummoxed and bewildered by emoji and I'm always pestering people to explain them to me. "What's that octopus supposed to signify?" I asked my colleague the other day. I kind of hate emoji (I HATED IT!) for being, for me, unintuitive and too cutesy by half. Me, I'm old school, I use emoticons myself. Simple, functional, with universally understood definitions, and just about indispensable for navigating the minefields of communication over the internet. I'll take a winky emoticon (ah, I see you're kidding!) over an upside-down face emoji (is that mockery? I can't tell) any day of the week. Anyhow, EMOJIPEDIA is probably the thing I never knew I needed until this day.
GUANACO. Well, isn't that a CURIO of a word?
ON THE APPS. That one however is a clunker.
Awaiting the fun sure to be seen from some of y'all (hi @egs, hi @Gary). Have a good day!
Didn't get the "one letter up" thing. Thought it was a Rebus at first, wanting different letters for the Acrosses and Downs, but then realized the clue described the actual answer not the phrase it was patterned after. Pretty breezy solve, if not particularly memorable.
ReplyDeletemeGA before GIGA
lIly before RICE
DISc before DISK
aReS before EROS (all being fair of course)
DoH before DUH
dIt before PIP
30:02
Yawn… Found this one easy and very not fun… Didn’t bother to put the circled letters together so I missed that revealer… as it were…
ReplyDeleteI also got stuck on "emoJi vs emoTi" and had to come here to find the answer and get my music. That's a tough cross.
ReplyDeleteIf only all NYT (recent submissions, anyway) were like this! Especially on a Sunday (larger grid).
ReplyDeleteNot to sound corny - this was a joy to solve - it FLOWED.. I heard someone yelling "SLOW DOWN!" and it was me.
LOVED 1D RICE (in spite of not knowing 47A GRODY - learned something new - and didn't know 41D MCDAVID).
Speaking of DAVID - where have you been?? You've been missed. Thank you for a great Sunday :)
My buddy who's half Scottish and half Jewish wears a Star of MCDAVID around his neck.
ReplyDeleteMOLEMAN: What we call my dermatologist.
Rule #1 at the ashram: NOIRE
'Sfree? No, 'SPAY
Many years ago, I was speaking with a friend at some event and noticed he was wearing a beautiful tie. It had colorful little children floating around on a dark-blue background. I complimented him on it, and he said it was his SAVE THE CHILDREN tie: For a $300 donation, he received it as a thank-you gift. "Well, that's very generous of you and it's a beautiful tie," I told him.
Just a few days later, we took a family trip down to DC. As we strolled along the streets near the Smithsonian, I noticed one souvenir table piled high with ties. One caught my eye: it was quite similar to my friend's tie, only the figures of the children were larger. A sign on the table said: Ties: $5 each. I pointed to the tie and said, "So, this tie costs $5?" He said, Yes, and I bought it. I call it my "Save the Money" tie.
I completely agree with OFL about the three unknown answers. Learn something every day. The 44A answer triggered a cute memory. I was at a lovely event at a fancy hotel and as I turned around from the buffet table J Lo walked right into me with A Rod right behind her. I looked down at her and smiled and said hello. She responded in kind then we all went on our way. My quick brush with fame, literally!
ReplyDeleteI guess it helps to have done yoga (where we do indeed use things called yoga tune-up balls) and be a hockey fan in Canada. When I haven't sleep well and it's another cold rainy day in late May, fer gawd's sake, a fun, not-too-challenging Sunday puzzle is just the thing.
ReplyDeleteI wasn't on David's wavelength at all today. I didn't notice that the circled letters all advanced one in the alphabet to form the new phrase. And it wouldn't have worked for me even if I had because in my mind, the original phrase at 111A was DISSONANT CHORuS. What would DISSONANT CHORvS mean?
ReplyDeleteThe east side gave me fits. DECO, sure, but adeN or OMAN? I tried to make a case for EditIPEDIA, that all the people who might edit a wiki entry constituted the faces in the clue. Yeah, no. And mis-reading the clue for 83A as someone repeating "Oh, please" didn't add up to COME. I get it, someone saying "COME, COME" in a somewhat disparaging manner = "Oh, please".
And, I didn't see PLUS ONE although I did try to make a phrase with the displaced letters. OK TRNMv, sure.
David Steinberg, this had some cute theme answers, especially THAT'S SO NOT OLAY. Thanks!
@Teedmn from yesterday, re: PANDA CARS - yes, it was Elizabeth George for me.
DeleteDancer pose is a yoga pose. And in my world tootsies are toes, not feet.
ReplyDeleteAll this time I thought the lyric was "strawberries, champagne on ice"
ReplyDeleteEasy, but…so much fun! I thoroughly enjoyed putting these theme answers together with as few letters as possible. Good time!
ReplyDeleteI loved the stroll down Hans Moleman lane but am disappointed it didn’t include “Are you really allowed to execute people in a local jail?”
ReplyDeleteI love "GRODY". Just saying it aloud makes me want to use mouthwash. I hung onto Jet Set way too long, my only real stumble. I thought I was being pretty clever when I entered REweD for "Knot again". Anyone else? COME, COME. I know you did.
ReplyDeleteI'd say, "Note to self: see if circles in Sunday puzzles spell something out," except that I've already done that a bunch of times and always forget. Rats. I enjoyed working out the theme answers, especially the changes from CHAoS to CHAPS and BEAt to BEAU, I think this was my first GUANACO sighting in maybe 40-some years, since reading to my kids about them and admiring their extraordinary eyelashes.
ReplyDeletePuztheme had some slight humor to it. Pretty basic sub-a-letter theme mcguffin -- easy solvin, once you catch on to the mcguffin. Especially with them Circles, flaggin the subbed letters.
ReplyDeleteThe letter subbin did at least have a next-in-alphabet rule to it, so that was kinda impressive, as a constructioneerin feat. Woulda been extra impressive, if the Downs also obeyed what the Circled letters were up to.
staff weeject pick: EAU. Formerly known as EAT.
Thanx, Mr. Steinberg dude. Nice ouzzle.
Masked & Anonymo4Us
p.s.
Runt puzzle -- another "Next" theme, but quit a bit ornerier:
**gruntz**
M&A
Easy. The only place I got hung up was parsing THATS SO NOT OLAY, the rest was pretty whooshy.
ReplyDeleteCute/clever idea, mildly amusing “whacky” answers, pretty smooth grid, liked it.
Just a short comment this morning as we have a group of children scheduled to visit our little farm in order to harass the chickens and pet the goats. I have to make everything safe for them and that means isolating the one really mean goat, with pointy 18 inch horns, in a separate paddock. He doesn't like to co-operate so I will face him with my matador's cape (a piece of scrap cardboard about 2 or 3 feet square) and my sword (an old broom handle) and guide him into a small enclosure right outside my studio. I might even reward him with some fresh cut willow branches. Oscar's not really a bad goat, he's just misunderstood.
ReplyDeleteLoved the puzzle (and I'm not a big fan of Sundays) and it's good to see Mr. Steinberg's byline again.
And for those of you wondering who Connor McDavid is … north of the 49th we call him McJesus.
Before he died, my husband drew up a playlist for his "celebration of life." Number 3 of 10 was "Land of 1,000 Dances." Pickett scored twice on his list; he also included "In the Midnight Hour." Miss him, my husband and Pickett.
ReplyDeleteMary Jane, I am so sorry that you lost your husband.
DeleteMary Jane. Wow, raucous soul music at a memorial. I think I would have liked your husband. I just went up to the house and pulled out my Best of WP album to read the list of cuts. I might add "Knock on Wood". Sorry for your loss. Keep the music playing.
DeleteHe certainly had excellent taste in music, Mary Jane. Now I’m inspired to work on my own playlist. Thanks for sharing this memory!
DeleteEasy puzzle, mostly.
ReplyDeleteI had EMOTIPEDIA and TERI. Worked for me.
I would have clued Hotel California’s pink champagne ON ICE. But I’m old.
I finished it cleanly but never really enjoyed the solve. Compared to yesterday's puzzle it felt like going from the penthouse to the outhouse. CAMERAROLL? Is that supposed to be film roll?
ReplyDeleteEMOJIPEDIA, MCDAVID and MOLEMAN were all woes. There were a couple of annoying write overs KILO/GIGA and PIKER/TAKER.
I judge Sunday puzzles by how far I get through the grid before I quit. That's usually about half way through. Today I completed the whole puzzle, ergo I liked it.
ReplyDeleteDISSONANT CHORDS worked for me but not the CHORES version. In the former there might be two musical chords that sound fine when each is played alone. It's only when they are played together that the sound becomes DISSONANT. That doesn't track well for loading and unloading a dishwasher. That might make grating or harsh sounds but I don't think that's the same as being DISSONANT (or CONSONANT).
For the record, the ANOA is not now nor has it ever been an ox. An ox is a large domesticated bovine used as a draft animal to pull plows, wagons and the like. The ANOA is too small too be a draft animal and is too wild to be domesticated.
Just because they are the smallest of all the buffaloes doesn't mean they are not aggressive. Here's a 2:26 YouTube video of an ANOA vigorously attacking a cardboard box that has invaded her territory. Note how she comes over at the end to get her reward for defending the home turf.
With the title serving as the revealer, and the circled squares, it was pretty straightforward to get the theme. However solving last night I never thought to string the letters together.. oh, PLUS ONE! Nice touch.
ReplyDeleteAs I said in a separate reply, like many of you I finished with EMOTIPEDIA crossing TERI but could not find the error without clicking Reveal Incorrect Letters. I mean c'mon David, that is brutal!
There seems to be a lot of 4 letter names lately: IRAN EROS AROD DEPP GERE TRIB OMAN JERI LAOS. And Today I Learned ON THE APPS (and EMOJIPEDIA). And interesting fact about Oregon's flag!
And @tht from yesterday, to prolong the discussion of MATE IN ONE, here is an example of what I thought it referred to: https://www.chesspuzzles.com/mate-in-one.
Okay, thanks. So clicking on the link, this *is* a very beginner level puzzle. It makes sense that there would be a site that would cater to players at that level, but I still stand by what I said, that this type of puzzle is would be far too easy even for players at an 800 ELO level; it's solvable by cursory inspection (Qh3++ for the one I looked at). Most players would solve it virtually instantly -- within a few seconds.
DeleteSo once again, the NYTXW is not technically wrong, but I would have to consider this pretty borderline, in terms of what people who know about chess would consider the norm for chess compositions.
So…. The Times was right.
DeleteOn the easier side, as I finished in about 65 percent of my average time.
ReplyDeleteI guess I admit the theme isn't amazing or anything, but I still liked it. I'm amused by my initial inability to make sense of CHAOS; I was so channeled by CHAPS that I mentally pronounced CHAOS as "chows" ("Is controlled chows a thing?"). I think I was first clued into it by GIVE ME ONE SEASON (REASON), though CONTACT LEOS (LENS) might also have been there.
In addition to Star Wars, there's also a Star Trek bit, with JERI Ryan.
Does gold count as an ORE? It's pretty non-reactive and usually found as pure grains, isn't it?
Mistakes: YES for DUH, causing me initially to doubt ADEPT, but then ERA and PIP set me back right again. Other than that, although there were answers like GUANACO and MOLEMAN that I needed crosses for, nothing else that I actually got wrong.
Brian Tung
DeleteI got the first themer fairly early. As I got the others I noticed the substitution pattern but I had the exact same problem as you The Chaos? That doesn’t work. Much later, I figured it out!
this theme is faultless I don't understand the disappointment - fill is mostly right on the money as well 4 1/2 stars
ReplyDeleteGreat to see David Steinberg again. Not his most cleverest puzzle of all time, but still an enjoyable Sunday. I guessed the theme from the title, which was the revealer in a previous NYT. Thanks David, hope to see more during your "semiretirement" from constructing. :)
ReplyDelete***Theme SPOILERS - 7/19/2018***
DUD -> EVE
ETSY -> FUTZ
SNEER -> TOFFS
TANKS -> UBOLT
OHMS -> PINT
HAL -> IBM
Revealer: NEXT PLEASE
it one of those Sunday rare gems that grows on you after you solve it and reflect on how New York funny it is - like you're at the Deli and the letter in question is the next customer its a brilliant puzzle 5 stars
ReplyDeleteWell CONTROLLEDCHAPS didn't make much sense but THATSSONOTOLAY made me check the title of this one and that was the reveal and made for a good time getting the other themers. Some time lost on the bottom as I had ____SONANTCHORES and made it RESONANT without checking the spelling, easy fix later. I agree that DISSONANCE is intentional in music and not the random banging you get with loading and unloading things.
ReplyDeleteIs that the same Janis Ian that sang "At 17"? I guess I could look it up.
Misheard song lyrics made me think of Paul McCartney telling Colbert that someone had heard "Living is easy with eyes closed" from Strawberry Fields Forever as "Living is easy with nice clothes". I like mondegreens but hadn't heard that one.
Oops-wasn't quite done. I wanted to point out that if you start with DNA and have an S after a blank, DISNEYLAND fits very nicely. If you then find LEOS which gives you DES, you can change that to DESERTISLE. After way too long, you will arrive at RESORTAREA (ugh) and say NOMORE, which should be, let;s face it, NOMAS. I mean, really. Oh, and if you don't know who Connor MCDAVID is, a lot of people think he's the best hockey player in the world.
ReplyDeleteLate today as our choir director asked me to sing Danny Boy for Memorial Day, which works as a remembrance of a boy going off to war and the parent left behind. You could stop me from doing almost anything and ask me to sing Danny Boy and nothing would make me happier.
I enjoyed your Sunday offering very much, DS. Just original and goofy enough and Delightfully Silly is how I roll. Thanks for all the fun.
DANCER POSE is legit. It’s Natarajasana.
ReplyDeleteReading the comments I noticed some complained about CHORES & CHORdS not having the same beginning sound. 7 themers 4 sound the same except for the circled square and 3 do not. (Chaos, Leos, Chores). I don’t see anything to complain about
ReplyDeleteIn Chile, "guanaco" is the nickname used for the armored police vehicles that spray noxious water from cannons to disperse protesters (so named b/c of the animal's penchant for spitting).
ReplyDeleteNYT has an obituary for Manny Nosowsky - a crossword puzzle constructor and contributor to NYT
ReplyDeleteI'm a big fan of Haircut 100 and the album Pelican West but I'd never seen that video before, thanks!
ReplyDeleteI likewise am a bit wrapped around the axle about the use of dissonant in this context. Simultaneously loading and unloading the dishes would be dissonant. But ordinarily, those two chores are not performed at the same time.
ReplyDeleteVamos, vamos. Relájate, cálmate, respira.
ReplyDeleteWriting in a day after finishing this and I probably wouldn't bother because I found this very clunky, but somehow I feel if I miss any days I will suddenly decide to miss every day and then miss every thing and I'll be left only with ironic contempt.
Not much of a theme here. More switch a letter, make a pun, write a goofy clue. It's fine. Maybe I'm just grumpy. I guess it's cute.
My mother used to use the word GRODY and I love it so I'm adding it to my favorite word list between DOOM and SKOSH. That's pretty high up.
There's no reason an adult can't or shouldn't take a swing at a piñata.
❤️ [Pow!]
😫 ON THE APPS.
People: 12
Places: 6
Products: 9
Partials: 11
Foreignisms: 4
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 42 of 140 (30%)
Funny Factor: 4 😕
Tee-Hee: COCKY.
Uniclues:
1 Bots.
2 Love composing bad music.
3 Grizzly bears in Swanktown.
1 CONTROLLED CHAP'S INSPO
2 ADORE DISSONANT CHORES
3 IT'S ALL OVER RESORT AREA
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: so much college / so much knowledge / yet still I'm bent / to pay the rent ENTRY-LEVEL EPODE.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯