Tuesday, May 5, 2026

Prohibited in Islam / TUE 5-5-26 / MLB stadium demolished in 2009 / Flightless bird from South America / Intermittently offered fast-food pork sandwich / 2016 Ariana Grande love song / Motorcyclist's invitation / Figure in a school pep rally / Media misinformation

Constructor: Max Schlenker

Relative difficulty: Challenging (***for a Tuesday***)


THEME: It's a snap, a cinch, etc. — phrases meaning "it's easy" that follow the [It's a ___] pattern are meant to be taken literally, so that the answer is a literal example of whatever fills in the blank in [It's a ___]:

Theme answers:
  • LADYFINGER (18A: It's a piece of cake)
  • SIMON SAYS (27A: It's child's play)
  • HEADLESS HORSEMAN (42A: It's a no-brainer)
  • TRADEWIND (52A: It's a breeze)
  • NATURE HIKE (67A: It's a walk in the park)
Word of the Day: RAMBO (53D: Title role for Sylvester Stallone) —

Rambo is an American media franchise centered on a series of action films featuring John J. Rambo. The five films are First Blood (1982), Rambo: First Blood Part II (1985), Rambo III (1988), Rambo (2008), and Rambo: Last Blood (2019). Its titular protagonist is a United States Army Special Forces veteran played by Sylvester Stallone, whose Vietnam War experience traumatized him but also gave him superior military skills, which he has used to fight corrupt police officers, enemy troops and drug cartelsFirst Blood is an adaptation of the 1972 novel First Blood by David Morrell.

Though critical reception was mixed, the film series has grossed $819 million in total, $300 million of which is from the most successful film, Rambo: First Blood Part IISylvester Stallone is the only actor to have appeared in all five films in the franchise. Stallone co-wrote the screenplays of all five films, and directed Rambo (2008), the fourth film of the series. The franchise also spawned an animated series, as well as comic books, novels and video games. (wikipedia)

• • •

I think the theme is actually fine. Tougher than the usual Tuesday theme by its very nature—the actual answers don't have anything in common and you have to think figuratively every time, finding a single element inside a very broad category each time—but clever. Would've been right at home on a Wednesday, I think, but I'm not mad about the above-average Tuesday difficulty of the theme. What I am mad about is ... well, two things, and if you can't guess what those two are, then you must be new here, welcome, hello, this is a crossword blog that I write every day. So, firstly, the fill—this may be the worst-filled puzzle I've seen this year, not because any one answer is so bad (well ... there's one, but we'll get to that), but because once the crosswordese avalanche gets going, it never ever ever stops. It just picks up steam, rolling all over the grid, from top to bottom, and seemingly getting bigger along the way. Usually if the fill is so weak that I stop to take a grid picture early, that's a bad sign. Today, I stopped not once, not twice, but three times, because I couldn't believe that every single nook and cranny of this puzzle was going to be stuffed with tired repeaters, and yet ... the puzzle kept surprising me. I could've stopped very early, in the NW corner, where ORAL ARAL TADA LLAMA were already crowding the grid with their mustiness, but I decided to let it ride. But then, after HOOHA and then, on the other side of the grid, ODESSA and SKEE, I'd had enough.


Later, after the NARC ONCD and the ASHY RHEA, I re-had enough:


And then re-re-had enough down below, where the avalanche finally buried me alive, such that I couldn't even see the theme any more. The theme didn't matter because the short fill had suffocated me.


They brought back the IKEA MCRIB for this thing!? And an EPEE? And this is before the puzzle closed out with a NEATO ETUDE at the REN fest, not to mention the EMCEE ETS. And that middle. TSO THY LOOS. Ruthless. This puzzle was ruthless with its short gunk. How is anyone supposed to enjoy the interesting theme when the (oversized!) grid has not been properly attended to and cared for? 


But the real dealbreaker today was FAKE NEWS (26D: Media misinformation). F*** that guy and his stupid f***ing catchphrases and the whole right-wing project to discredit journalists and destroy journalism as a resource in this country. F*** him and SARAH Palin and Sylvester f***ing Stallone and his RAMBO bullshit. There is no neutral way to clue FAKE NEWS. That is a phrase popularized by one dude—one singularly amoral and incompetent dude—and then amplified by the worst bunch of sycophants this country has ever seen. As for Palin: there are many many SARAHs out there, and so few of them are national embarrassments, why not use one of those? I was gonna let that clue slide, though, until I hit FAKE NEWS, which I will never let slide. And then at the end of the puzzle, to run across one of the most famous megafans of the current White House resident—and in his stupid fake-he-man RAMBO costume no less—too much. I normally wouldn't have given RAMBO a second thought, but today? After the intentional rightwing boosterism? No. All too much. Hard no. I don't solve the puzzle in a vacuum. I solve it as an American citizen alive and kicking in 2026, so yeah, smearing that guy and his lackeys all over the puzzle does in fact make a difference as to how I feel about the puzzle. Overreacting?Too sensitive?  Great. I'm fine with those accusations. Someone should be sensitive.


DATUM!? Rueful LOL. Sorry, the fill, it just hurts so much. DATUM is one of those "words" that will occasionally (recently?) trip me up when I play Quordle because I forget that it is, in fact, a "word." I didn't struggle much with DATUM, but I did struggle elsewhere a bit. FAVE for GOTO (1A: Tried-and-true choice, informally). I balked at both OLYMPIAD and HARAM, the former because OLYMPIAD didn't seem particularly mathy-sciencey—aren't the regular Olympics called an OLYMPIAD?—and the latter because even though my brain wanted HARAM, I didn't trust it. "Are you just making up a word that kinda / sorta sounds like HALAL, brain?" Apparently not. HOMERUNS was a bit of a toughie as clued (23D: Undeniable successes). Took me several crosses to get the MASCOT part of TEAM MASCOT (31D: Figure in a school pep rally). KETTLES, also tricky (35A: Ones always blowing off steam?). These clues, and the oversized grid, made sure that my time was much slower than usual today (I don't actually time myself anymore, I could just tell).


Bullets:
  • 10A: Motorcyclist's invitation ("HOP ON!") — one of the few breaths of fresh air among the short fill. A nice, zippy, colloquial phrase. "HOP ON! We're going to IDAHO!" (a beautiful place—where my mother grew up and where my grandmother lived her whole life)
  • 46A: 2016 Ariana Grande love song ("INTO YOU") — another thing that slowed me down. If I've heard this song, I've forgotten it. What I know about ARIANA GRANDE is that both halves of her name appear in crosswords a lot, particularly the shortened form of her first name (ARI). 

  • 72A: "OMG, same!" ("TOTES!") — are people still saying this? Did they ever? Real "IT'S LIT" energy here. 
  • 73A: About 50.7% of all Americans (WOMEN) — reflexively started writing in ASIAN here until I looked at the clue a little closer. Subset of "Americans" + super-common five-letter answer = ASIAN. Or so says brain, anyway, when brain is on autopilot.
That's all for today. Happy Cinco de Mayo. See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook and Letterboxd]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️: 
  • Venmo (@MichaelDavidSharp)]
=============================
✏️ Upcoming Crossword Tournaments ✏️
=============================
📘 My other blog 📘:

111 comments:

  1. 8:01 for me Monday night… definitely felt easy, boom boom boom. Nice puzzle, glad it was like it’s theme, easy as pie!!! 5 consistent themers, no revealer. 16 wide grid… which put it into medium territory timewise even though it was easy. Didn’t know ODESSA, had to wait for KETTLES to fill itself in, and OLYMPIcs before OLYMPIAD was about it for problems. Like the clue/themer pairs, esp. calling the HEADLESSHORSEMEN a “no-brainer”. Perhaps a little groanworthy, but I’m always going to fall for a pun puzzle!!! : ) Thanks, Max—great puzzle, not too much junk! : ) [After reading OFL.... wow, he really didn't enjoy this one. ***.5 from me.]

    ReplyDelete

  2. Easy. Solved without reading the clues for the long answers. No overwrites or WOEs, but a few of the theme clues made me smile. And it was fun guessing at the commonality between entries like SIMON SAYS (27A), HEADLESS HORSEMAN (42A) and NATURE HIKE (67A).
    * * * _ _

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous6:03 AM

    The problem wasn’t with the answer FAKE NEWS. The problem was with how it was clued. FAKE NEWS isn’t media misinformation. It’s a phrase that the orange criminal in the White House uses to discredit any news that isn’t convenient to him. FAKE NEWS is rarely media misinformation, which is why, along with a few other answers, I felt like this puzzle was trolling the average NYT solver.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ChrisS1:44 PM

      Great analysis of a BS phrase. Olympiad in the clued context was new to me, I knew it as the 4 year period. From Wikipedia "An Olympiad is a four-year period between Olympic Games, a celebration of the modern Olympic Games, or an intense international competition (e.g., Mathematics Olympiad). Originally, it was a four-year unit of time used by ancient Greeks"

      Delete
  4. Saw the pushback on FAKE NEWS coming but the RAMBO vitriol was a surprise - gotta love it. The theme was fine - we’ve seen these before and it’s hard to get in trouble with them. Overall fill is flat - Rex summarizes it well.

    Camarillo Brillo

    I liked PACK ANIMAL, ENRICHED and HOME RUNS. The glue is overwhelming - it tries to hold that center section together. It ultimately fails. The HEADLESS HORSEMAN spanner shines - but all those shorts required are an issue.

    ODESSA

    Pleasant enough idea - but in the end a less than enjoyable Tuesday morning solve.

    Nina Simone

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. When I saw Odessa, I thought of the Bee Gees Odessa. Back in the era where they were figuring out what kind of band they wanted to be.

      Delete
    2. I had that record! It was a double album, I think, and I clearly remember its fancy red velvet cover.

      Delete
    3. Joe Pop & Yat
      I remember The Bee Gees and their first hit singles on the radio (Massachusetts the one I grew to dislike is the one I remember most unfortunately). The others I liked better. I never heard of the album named Odessa, Wikipedia says in retrospect it has a good reputation. They produced a huge amount of music and some of their best maybe got lost in the noise? Sad that only one of the brothers are still living.

      Delete
  5. My five favorite original clues from last week
    (in order of appearance):

    1. Exchanged words? (4)
    2. What am I, chopped liver? (4)
    3. Announcements before giveaways? (7)(6)
    4. Composite numbers? (7)
    5. Rounded up? (5)


    VOWS
    PATE
    SPOILER ALERTS
    MASHUPS
    DOMED

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My favorite encore clues from last week:

      [Toys for tots, perhaps] (4)
      [One wrapping up a meal before eating anything?] (3)


      TYPO
      BOA

      Delete
    2. Good to see you, Lewis, and hope you're doing well.

      Delete
    3. It’s good to see your post Lewis. I hope all is going well thus far.

      Delete
    4. Anonymous8:41 AM

      So great to see you @Lewis! How are you?

      Delete
    5. Welcome back Lewis. Hope you’re recovery is going well.

      Delete
  6. Anonymous6:23 AM

    I’m 33, and I believe I’m in that micro-generation that once said TOTES and IT’S LIT unironically.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. “Microgeneration” nice 😀

      Delete
    2. Anonymous7:29 AM

      Yeah, I’m 37 and I didn’t say ITSLIT but I did say TOTES and even “totes magotes” (don’t ask me what it means, because I truly have no clue, it just rhymed.)

      Delete
    3. ChrisS1:48 PM

      Anon 7:29, that's tots adorbs (learned from 36 yo daughter, about 20 years ago)

      Delete
    4. Anonymous6:34 PM

      35 and definitely said it’s lit 🤣

      Delete
  7. Anonymous6:51 AM

    Good for you, Rex

    ReplyDelete
  8. TOTES adorbs! Not the puzzle, so much, but Rex's rant. I have a family member who used to say things like that, and she's nearly 50, what I call 'the younger generation.'

    A better clue for FAKE NEWS would have been "in depth reporting, to Trump."

    OK, the theme. I ended up working my way down the left side of the puzzle, so my first two theme answers were LADY FINGERS and HEADLESS HORSEMAN. Aha, body parts! But then came TRADE WINDS. How was that a body part? Something about flatulence, maybe? But then it just fell apart, thematically speaking, so I never figured it out.

    The fill didn't bother me as much as it bothered Rex. And anyway, how can you love IDAHO but not like ODESSA? Or should it have been clued as "site of the stairway in Potemkin?"

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous7:00 AM

    Is 43D accurate? Fleas are pet pests, sure, but are lice?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. According to google, animals do not get or spread lice. They’re people pests.

      Delete
    2. @JJK - don't trust Google (in this instance). Many lice are host-specific, so while the lice that infect humans won't affect your pets or vice versa, there are dog lice that infect dogs, and cat lice that infect cats, etc.

      Delete
    3. LICE are species-specific. The ones that live on our heads don't bother pet mammals or birds, but there are species of lice that do infest pets. So it's technically fine but not ideal, especially for a Tuesday. And now I can't stop itching.

      Delete
    4. Well, good to know this more detailed lice info! And I’m feeling a little itchy now too.

      Delete
  10. I’m with you on FAKENEWS, Rex. Instant repulsion when I saw that answer.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Anonymous7:21 AM

    I liked the puzzle a lot. Perhaps I’m wrong, but I had a slight impression that Rex did not. One nit: Please ban words like totes, merch, sesh etc..🎈🎈🎊🎊

    ReplyDelete
  12. Andy Freude7:33 AM

    Singularly unpleasant puzzle, for all the reasons Rex notes. When I hit FAKE NEWS, I got the ick, and then the ick just kept coming.

    Thanks to a fat-finger typo, my NATURE HIKE became a mATURE HIKE, the kind Mrs. Freude and I take.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Anonymous7:36 AM

    I came here to see the meltdown and boy did Rex deliver!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous8:55 AM

      He never disappoints, LOL.

      Delete
  14. Played more like a Wednesday for me, although an easy Wednesday. I honestly didn't notice the fill as it was just a framework for fitting in the theme answers. Note the absence of a revealer, a route I wish yesterday's puzzle had taken.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I saw FAKE NEWS and SARAH, and I wondered if Rex would unload with one barrel or two - but he brought out the howitzer and unloaded. It does seem to be a bit in poor taste, especially FAKE NEWS. I’ll leave it at that.

    I struggled with this one a touch more than I usually do on a Tuesday, mostly because of the disjointed theme that OFL alluded to. Fortunately the tried and true crosswordese throughout the rest of the grid bailed me out to the point where I was pretty close to a normal Tuesday time.

    That clue for NOSES is borderline bizarre, at least to me. I wonder if it is regional or a colloquialism of which I am not familiar.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:22 AM

      I didn’t understand the NOSES answer at all. Is it meant as an alternative to counting heads? Is it regional or a colloquialism as you suggested? The world may never know.

      Delete
    2. I got it off the N, with a smile - recalling NOSES being counted in my grade-school classroom.

      Delete
    3. Southside Johnny & Carola
      I am with Carola. Counting noses is something I remember from childhood.
      FWIW I am in my seventies n

      Delete
  16. SARAH Palin, THY will be done. FAKENEWS!

    Ugh. Not pleasant.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I love the image of a Katamari Damacy ball of bad xword fill.

    A part of me did die when I entered FAKE NEWS (and I also got the ick). "Oh, he's definitely not going to like this," I thought.

    Faster than average time for me.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hey All !
    Tell us how you really feel. 😁

    Liked this puz. Different kind of Theme. Wasn't NEATO, but also wasn't SMEAR worthy. Good TuesPuz for the typically "worst" puz day of the week.

    16-wider today. Good flow fill, not stuck in any spots, however, did have another FWE. At 1A, of all places. Had rOTe, which got me rALL at 1D (why not?), and eLYMPIAD at 4D (thinking it wouldn't be OLYMPIAD because of the clue specifics. Thought OLYMPIAD would be sports related, so figured it was a different way to suggest a non-sports competition with the E.) Ah, me.

    Nice F puz ender. Could've actually been an S, but went with the better choice. 😁 (Although, DEAS is a stretch, but we've seen the puz stretch out plurals lately.)

    Hope y'all have a great Tuesday!

    Three F's
    RooMonster
    DarrinV

    ReplyDelete
  19. Anonymous7:50 AM

    Effrontery? Down 1? Tuesday? Wow.

    Had no idea Stallone was maga. I prefer to do crossword puzzles in a bubble. Actually, I’ve found that my blood pressure has fallen and my overall peace has risen because I avoid “news” altogether. I woke up this morning to thunder and lightning that was totally unexpected (by me) because I don’t watch the news. When T***p got elected the first time, I realized that he was right about one thing. It is all FAKENEWS. It’s a big reality TV show. And when the biggest reality TV personality got elected president I said “ok…I’m out”. And I’ve never looked back. Today was the 503rd day in a row that I solved the crossword puzzle. It has been a major improvement in my life to sit down and open the NYT app instead of any news app.

    As for discrediting journalism, I think maybe he added fuel to the fire, but they started it when they went 24/7. There isn’t any news that’s relevant 24/7. So what do you do? You make stuff up. Hey. News isn’t “what happened”. That’s just an event in time. News is “why does it matter”. And that’s the part where the real artistic license is in play. That’s where FAKENEWS lives. Making up stories about what happened that will upset or reinforce your base. All so you can keep eyes glued to the screen and maximize that sweet sweet ad revenue.

    Where is journalism?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous8:51 AM

      How nice that you get to not pay attention to the world because you're not affected. There are plenty of minorities, refugees, LGBTQ+ people, poor and unhoused people, and many others who don't get that privilege.

      Delete
    2. DAVinHOP9:59 AM

      Anon, FYI there have recently been people (Midwest area; "tornado alley") who DO watch the news but were unaware of impending, life-threatening tornadoes. The reason for that was that cuts to the National Weather Service resulted in discontinued daily use of weather balloons. The orange buffoon and his DOGE sidekick (at the time) saved a few bucks (at the NWS and elsewhere) but cut taxes for the rich. That's not FAKE NEWS; it's the criminal negligence that now defines our national government.

      Delete
    3. Anonymous10:36 AM

      Amen and well stated. Straight forward honest reporting is a remembrance of the past within mainstream media. It's all about pandering to the audience in order to maintain and increase ratings. Please wake up brothers and sisters.

      Delete
  20. Medium. Re the elephant in the room: I put in FAKE NEWS, hated it on sight, mentally SNARLED at it and thought how really awful it is they put that in, but then moved on to the next thing in concentration. A little later it did hit me how dreary and hackneyed some of those entries were, and that likely Rex was going to hate it, then moved on again until the music played.

    I think the apportionment of blame can rest equally on both the constructor and editors. Max Schlenker, why why why put that into your grid. Shame, shame. (I'm assuming that's yours and that the NYTXW team didn't redo your grid.) The overriding application of the poisonous phrase is in service to you-know-who and his ambition to destroy institutional norms and be the first US dictator. Get rid of it. Root it out. But then, that clue. As if the application is grounded in a reality that can blandly be referred to. (Ha, I see the Wordplay blurb "Max Schlenker's puzzle will help you ease into the week" -- it should say "Max Schlenker's puzzle may well piss you off -- enjoy").

    I remember Z quitting the NYT puzzle (and the commentariat) over a clue having to do with unborn babies (I no longer remember whether the clue had anything to do with ABORT specifically, but I think it was somewhere in that neighborhood). That was his deal-breaker. I don't know whether this is, at last, mine. But the NYTXW should remember that there are a whole bunch of crosswords vying for readership, and they shouldn't take theirs for granted.

    Rex wouldn't (or didn't) know, but OLYMPIADs are definitely a thing in the math and science worlds. They're mainly administered to young talented students, high school age or so. I have mixed feelings toward them. If you can do well, then you may have a bright future ahead of you, but the emphasis on being a speedy jackrabbit is not completely consonant with other qualities needed to be successful in the research world: patience, persistence, deep follow-through. The contest problems tend to be slightly contrived, and overall they are not suited for the other "slow but deep" tortoise half, who are at least as important as the coffee-fueled jackrabbits.

    Counting NOSES? Boy, I really did not get that one. Are we supposed to imagine pre-schoolers or kindergartners, whose noses are booped or BOINKed or whatever as their names are called?

    Oh, look at the time. There would be more to say about this puz, but now someone else should say them and I should be off. Have a good day, folks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous8:52 AM

      Yeah, Math and Science Olympiads were a thing when I was in school nearly 40 years ago.

      Delete
    2. @tht. I loved your comment on OLYMPIADs (which I did not know about). We need both turtles and jackrabbits. Unfortunately we only celebrate one of those groups.

      Delete
    3. Anonymous4:52 PM

      @tht, thanks so very much for your astute comment about speed vs critical thought and curiosity. My older brother was a very successful OLYMPIAD participant and a brilliant person. I loved him more than anyone on the planet. But I also grew up being “Sam’s sister,” and went clear through high school living in hope that just one teacher wouldn’t say that and attempt constantly to compare me to him. Finally happened senior year. Thank you Mr. Rice. Les S, you said it well. Let’s hear it for the turtles!

      Delete
  21. Wanderlust7:54 AM

    I made the same mistake as Rex on HAlAl vs HARAM, even though I know the difference. Oddly, one means permitted and one means forbidden. I left HAlAl in for long enough that I had the first two themers with an L subbing for some other letter in common expressions and thought that was the theme. I didn’t entirely fill in the next two because I thought I needed to put an L in somewhere it didn’t belong. And then I got to the last one, and it clearly wasn’t a revealer that explained the random Ls. Only then did I realize that I had something wrong up top and saw HARAM.

    I agree that FAKE NEWS should be HARAM in my NYT puzzles. I hate it when people use it as a synonym for mis/disinformation because it is 100% associated with false accusations against trustworthy journalism, including that of Will’s own colleagues. I didn’t know Stallone was a Trump cheerleader but I’m not surprised.

    All that said, I thought the theme was great and I don’t notice tired fill as much as Rex when I’m solving but I agree when he points it out.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wanderlust
      Agree with your interesting point that FAKENEWS is frequently directed at Will’s colleagues
      I would add that the wannabe dictator accuses others of doing what he does as a matter of course. His MAGA propaganda machine is the one that produces the lies and half truths on a massive scale. Really, Fox should be called Fox Pravda and Trump and his lackeys the Ministry of Lies.

      Delete
  22. I’ll give the puzzle kudos for HEADLESS HORSEMAN, both the clue and the answer. That one did in fact delight me while solving.

    But yes, there is in fact no way to associate FAKE NEWS with anything but one person’s rhetoric, so quite an unpleasant insertion into the Tuesday grid. My consolation while solving was, “At least Rex will descry this.” And then when I turned to the blog, I was initially surprised not to see both that and SARAH Palin in bold in the first paragraph, and almost wondered if it was *me* who was overreacting…until I read, “What I am mad about is ... well, two things, and if you can't guess what those two are, then you must be new here, welcome, hello, this is a crossword blog that I write every day.” Cracked me up.

    Even if the NYTXW lets us down, Rex Parker never does.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Merriam-Webster4:14 PM

      Descry: 1 a: to catch sight of
      b: find out, discover
      2 (obsolete): to make known, reveal

      Delete
  23. Anonymous8:18 AM

    Great rant on FAKENEWS. Made me want to throw up.

    ReplyDelete
  24. This puzzle gave me the ick (hat tip to yesterday) in a major way. Basically everything Rex said. No one has said TOTES since 2012, and I object to the clue for reasons I can't totes articulate. Having NEATO in the next section over gave me "what decade is it" whiplash. NATURE HIKE reminded me of "nature walk" as a euphemism for leaving a gathering to do sex stuff, so that was briefly entertaining, but ugh, the rest of it can take a long walk off a short pier (we're resurrecting outdated slang today, right?).

    ReplyDelete
  25. Anonymous8:25 AM

    Why does Shortz keep insisting that ETUDES are only for piano? There are etude books for virtually all instruments.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous 8:25 AM
      Your point about etudes for other instruments does not make the answer today wrong. The clue doesn’t imply that etudes are only for piano. This type of complaint arises often with crosswords but the clue doesn’t need to list all possibilities. Piano is almost always chosen because of the Chopin Etudes.

      Delete
  26. Anonymous8:27 AM

    Thanks Rex for calling this out!

    ReplyDelete
  27. Anonymous9:01 AM

    Indeed a lot to say about this one. From a purely crossword puzzle/theme perspective, I found this a bit more crunchy than a typical Tuesday which I appreciated. I thought the theme clever and fun, and I got my spanner. Some nice, longish themers as well, so there was a lot to like.
    The much used short stuff doesn't bother me, especially when I have fun with the theme.
    But man...like @Rex and others, I really GOTTHEICK with all the fill that's already been mentioned (never thought I'd use that term so quickly). I actually do my best to solve these in the littlest bit of a bubble/vacuum to temporarily forget about what's going on around us, this one made that very difficult. @Rex's write-up was spot on there.
    So I found this to be a fine piece of construction, but my joy balloon was a bit busted by some of the subject matter.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This one was me (Hugh) not sure why it showed up as anon...

      Delete
  28. Anonymous9:10 AM

    I hate Trump and the republicans. But you are fucking unhinged dude.

    ReplyDelete
  29. My problem was trying to make a theme out of the answers and not the clues, so I missed that part entirely. Sheesh.

    Thumbs way up for OFL's rant on FAKENEWS. Such an easy dismissal of something you find unpleasant, and its usage has become far too prevalent. Just go away.

    Otherwise lots of gunk, learned, or possibly relearned, HARAM, discovered a song called INTOYOU, and found out that the longer version of OHHI IS OHHEY.

    And here is NEATO again. My campaign to eliminate NEATO, which only exists in crosswords, is so far unsuccessful

    OK Tuesday, MS. I feel Mighty Stupid for missing the clue/theme connection. Also, please think twice before deciding some things are harmless.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous11:16 AM

      Neato was a very common word at one time. It’s quaint, I know, but it’s just silly for you to demand that it be exiled from the puzzle.

      Delete
  30. It is worth remembering that one major news outlet was founded specifically to provide FAKENEWS (well, maybe two if you count The Onion). I occasionally like to place myself in the (imagined) first meeting of Fox News. I suppose it went something like this:
    Roger Ailes: White gentlemen. Thank you for agreeing to work for this important new media outlet. We will be dedicated to being unfair and unbalanced. And with that, does anybody have a suggestion for a motto?
    Lackey 1: How about Unfair and Balanced?
    Ailes: Good try, but the Unfair part, while true, needs to somehow be twisted into a lie.
    Lackey 2: How about Fair and Unbalanced?
    Ailes: I like it, but it still somehow gives too much insight into what we're really doing.
    Lackey 3: Fair and Balanced?
    Ailes: That's it! TOTES! Now let's see if we can't find a low IQ narcissist and rapist to champion for president.

    I often have a bone to pick with @Rex. Not today.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:57 AM

      So the inference is that you're more intelligent than the President of the USA? Who indeed is a narcissist?

      Delete
    2. Anonymous11:20 AM

      You were in the room! Too bad you couldn’t stop them.

      Delete
    3. @Anonymous 10:57. Let me be direct, rather than leave anything to inference. Every sentient being is more intelligent than Donald Trump. I don't think that this statement would lead one to classify me as a narcissist.

      Delete
    4. Hear hear, egsforbreakfast!!

      Delete
    5. Anonymous3:19 PM

      To Anon 10:57am. You meant the implication not the inference. You made the inference, and in my opinion, that’s not what Egs initially implied. Then he outright stated a his opinion about Trumps intelligence, which I happen to agree with, and then stated a fact that one statement does not a narcissist make. Hope this helps!

      Delete
    6. @egs, (in response to anon 10:57) Well said!

      Delete
  31. Anonymous9:28 AM

    Totes agree with Rex. Death of a puzzle by 3 cuts - Fake News, Sarah, Rambo. Not a pleasant way to start a day…

    ReplyDelete
  32. Anonymous9:28 AM

    On another note completely, Rex always mentions the Japanese director OZU, who has nevered appeared in a NYT crossword and whom I'd never heard of until Rex mentioned him. Tonight TCM has a documentary and is showing 3 of his movies starting at 8:00 Eastern.

    ReplyDelete
  33. EasyEd9:34 AM

    Wow, this puzzle has really stirred the pot. There I thought I was brilliant filling in one familiar word or phrase after the other, and all I was doing was following a well-trod trail. I think the theme is well done with the linkage in the clues rather than the fill. Counting NOSES was a familiar reference to me so that may be a regionalism or generationalism or both. Luckily the puzzle didn’t include “alternative facts”..that might have been an excellent “go-with” for SARAH and FAKENEWS. Love the references to yesterday’s ICK.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Anonymous9:42 AM

    Bravo, Rex! Your "rant" was spot-on, and much needed. I hated the puzzle, too, for the exact reasons you mentioned, and you said it far better than I could. Today's write up reminded me of the reason I read your blog every day.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Great write-up, Rex.
    Didn't know Stallone was MAGA - don't care but not at all surprised.
    I guess we'll all remember THIS constructor's name!
    Welcome back, Lewis - hope you're feeling good :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. jb 129
      Stallone owns a house near Mar-a-lago and is said to be a frequent visitor. Apparently he is a relatively recent convert. Trump apparently helped him on some parochial issue Stallone most definitely supported Trump in 2024.

      Delete
  36. DAVinHOP10:23 AM

    Two days in a row I've really disliked the puzzle and found simpatico with Rex. After reading the rant, I'm wondering what kept it from receiving the first ever One Star rating.

    The write-up starts tamely enough ("I think the theme is actually fine.") Talk about the calm before the storm! So presumably some technical attributes of the puzzle itself (save for the mountainous level of junk) earned it a half-star reprieve.

    In fairness to Trump (did i really just type that?), Rupert Murdoch and Roger Ailes started their sewer of a "news" operation long before, in 1996. That the corrupt buffoon still has a 30% (and not 0.3%) approval rating is undoubtedly due to the effectiveness of Fox, and its copycat clones, to convince low-energy thinkers that "down is up", "black is white", and so on. There is the real "FAKE NEWS", sadly and ironically.

    Thankfully S Palin has faded from the public eye these days; but unfortunate to have her surface (unnecessarily) in the puzzle.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Anonymous10:33 AM

    Re Fake news: there is a saying in French: “C’est celui qui dit qui l’est”, “It’s the one who says it who is (or does) it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous 10:33 am
      About Trump You put it much more succinctly than I would. Great expression!

      Delete
  38. Awful. You were being generous. Who wants any of this?!

    ReplyDelete
  39. Anonymous10:53 AM

    Yes, “neato” is something that a lot of us actually said. Before your time, I guess. I don’t blame you for wanting it out of the puzzle, but it’s a legit word. “Counting noses” is a legit colloquialism for counting people. It doesn’t have anything literally to do with noses.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not many things in the crosswords are "before my time', and another Anon has suggested that my wanting it out of crosswords is "just silly", which is exactly what I was trying to do, i. e. , be silly. I would not banish any words from these puzzles, even those as fatuous as "neato", although if that one stopped appearing I would not be heartbroken.

      "Counting noses" is something that was said in my childhood, a long time ago.

      Delete
  40. Add me to those who found this easy.

    No costly erasures but I did not know HARAM (Halal I do know) and IN TO YOU.

    Liked the theme but @Rex is right about the fill, especially FAKE NEWS.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Anonymous11:02 AM

    Right On Rex! Bet on a Blue Tsunami this Fall to make America Better Again!

    ReplyDelete
  42. I belong to the generation that said "totes" (I was too old to say "it's lit" by a few years). Totes means totally, absolutely. It's usually an intensifier. "OMG same" simply means "wow, yes, me too." How does this clue work?

    ReplyDelete
  43. Anonymous11:32 AM

    Extremely easy. Two Monday puzzles in a row. What happened to Tuesday?

    ReplyDelete
  44. Anonymous11:36 AM

    I saw the clue and counted the letters going down and thought, "no, it can't be." The I got the crosses and thought "oh my god, it is." What possessed the editors to allow this answer, with that clue?

    ReplyDelete
  45. I'm going to need some guidance on where to place the commercial. ADHERE

    Where a baby wolverine sleeps: MCRIB. (Go Blue!)

    When it was discovered the team's shortstop had LICE he was scratched from the lineup. He was ticked off and thought the manager made a RASH decision.

    John Derek felt awful after losing control of the steering wheel. The last thing he wanted to do was RAMBO's car.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're on fire today, Liveprof. Thanks. I needed the laughter.

      Delete
  46. My friends and I often use FAKENEWS ironically, usually to describe something obviously true that we are pretending to deny for self-interested reasons, or something clearly not true or false. "You know Monday's only a holiday for federal workers?" "Fake news!" "Cowboy Carter is Beyoncés best album." "Fake news!" Part of the humour is referring to something said conversationally as "news". So the phrase doesn't bother me in the abstract. But agree, as clued it's simply not what it means, and in a way that suggests a political slant. Ick.

    ReplyDelete
  47. har. Well, pretty much official ...
    The Seashells & a vast majority of the comment gallery say: 86 26-D.

    Pretty good puztheme, at least. Coulda also used that {It's a no-brainer} clue for SARAH Palin, btw.
    This TuesPuz didn't play all that hard, at our house. Maybe a sneaky clue here and there, plus that there HARAM-scare-em area, of course. And it did have that extra-large puzgrid size, too boot.

    staff weeject pick: Only 10 to choose from. Will go with PHI, based on its slightly feisty [all Greek to M&A] clue.

    some fave stuff: PACKANIMAL & TEAMMASCOT. ABORT + TOTES stacked, 86-like, sentiments. SNARLED [a la @RP today]. ORAL/ARAL & RUDE/ETUDE poetry.

    Thanx for the easy-themed puz, Mr. Schlenker dude. And congratz on a nice, kinda mighty controversial, debut.

    Masked & Anonymo3Us

    p.s.
    Runt puzzle:
    **gruntz**

    M&A

    ReplyDelete
  48. First, thank you to @Rex for pointing out that all of the theme clues are ways of saying "It's easy" - which I'd somehow managed to overlook. I think it's a great idea for a theme, and nicely carried out, with the array of idiomatic phrases and then the wit of the literal answers, especially HEADLESS HORSEMAN. And speaking of overlooking, I really didn't notice the ARAL-SKEE-LOOS-etc. pile up, in favor of OLYMPIAD, PACKANIMAL, HOME RUNS.... I did wince at FAKE NEWS and wondered if there is really one single TRADE WIND.

    ReplyDelete
  49. @M&A - much confusion about the runt puzzle you linked on 4/28 (dot compost). Any chance of an explanation?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @kitshef: Thanx for yer runtpuz interest & question.
      This is what I told the test solvers of "dot-compost #2", when they all wondered if M&A had lost his day-um marbles:

      "A dot-compost is a 3-letter answer that connects to the lone black square [dot] in the puzgrid. Generally, dot-composts are totally weird sets of 3 letters, clued desperately."

      M&A Help Desk

      Delete
  50. 73A clue is definitely wrong. 50.7% of the U.S. population is FEMALE, according to the census.

    But many of them are under 18. And I think we all agree we call those people girls, not women.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Elizabeth1:40 PM

    You go Rex!

    ReplyDelete
  52. I also thought the theme was fine; I had to think a bit to get that all the phrases meant "easy". I agree this seemed like a perfect Wednesday puzzle. The fill didn't bother me nearly as much as it did Rex, although I really groaned at SKEE, RHEA, and ASHY.

    I did get HARAM as a gimme; it's a common Spelling Bee word along with its counterpart HALAL.

    ReplyDelete
  53. Hear! Hear! Totally agree on the MAGA stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  54. SharonAK1:51 PM

    I loved Headless Horseman for the no brainer clue. In fact I thought all the clue answers were clever and fun.
    As for Rex's complaint about the fill. BMost of the word he lists seem to me like perfectly fine words,, not goofy abbreviations etc.
    And remember, many people, when beginning to do crossword, need words to repeat. In fact, decades ago a more experienced solver told me that would happened, which encouraged me to continue.
    Rex and other bad mouthers: THIS WAS A TUESDAY puzzle.

    Enjoyed Egs' tale of the Fox meeting and Live Prof's play with words from the puzzle

    ReplyDelete
  55. Anonymous1:53 PM

    This old timer thinks fake news is a very outdated slur going back to the first Trump administration. These days it is mainly applied to anything coming out of the current White House. And until recently to what the left called Faux News and its cable channels.

    I say until recently because the natives are growing restless at Fox these days. I guess even they have limits.

    As for the puzzle OFL got it right in terms of difficulty but I thought the themers were clever.

    ReplyDelete
  56. Whew! Before I get too the egregious part of this puzzle, let me say that I made my own list of tired and awful dreck and it was different from @Rex’s, and shorter. I guess that’s because I did this downs-only and a fair amount of the junk was in the acrosses.

    But there was good stuff, too. I think the grid was ENRICHED by the inclusion of OLYMPIAD (as clued; never heard of it in this context), PACK ANIMAL, TEAM MASCOT, and HOME RUNS. Loved seeing SKEE because it reminded me of one of my favourite movies, Dogma, where God is incapacitated while playing SKEE-ball. Great movie.

    I’m not an American and I probably shouldn’t be disparaging your politicians, but this guy is a menace and has the power to affect so many other countries with his blatant stupidity that I can’t stop myself. When I see him in his aircraft telling a reporter, “You’re fake news”, or “You’re a terrible reporter”, or “You’re a low IQ person”, I just want to scream. Have you noticed that these remarks seem to be aimed mostly at female reporters? @jberg’s take on this (A better clue for FAKE NEWS would have been "in depth reporting, to Trump.”) might have been acceptable. But yours, Max Schlenker or Will Shortz, or whoever okayed it, was not.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous5:14 PM

      Les S, thanks for reminding me of “Dogma.” Haven’t thought of it in a long while. Worth a read-watch.

      Delete
  57. Anonymous2:18 PM

    I knew Rex would hate this puzzle, and as usual I agree with him for the same reasons. Shameful.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Este es mi primer día en el trabajo.

    I guess this is an -LY EASY puzzle come to life, and then it rushed to snog with cult members. Part of the reason for doing a puzzle is to escape, but when they're dropping contemporary politics into the grids, it takes away from the journey. I say it probably once a week, but why can't they just try to be humorous? We do these silly things for lots of reasons, but I doubt any of us would list "keeping up on the broken political landscape" as one of our reasons.

    A REN Faire is about as "historical" as comic books are literature.

    ❤️ HOP ON. HEADLESS HORSEMAN. Effrontery. RUDE.

    😫 FAKE NEWS.

    People: 4
    Places: 4
    Products: 4
    Partials: 3
    Foreignisms: 5
    --
    Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 20 of 79 (25%)

    Funny Factor: 2 😕

    Tee-Hee: HOOHA.

    Uniclues:

    1 Manicurists.
    2 Soso potter.
    3 Dubious McDonald's based remedy for eczema.
    4 How weight lifters often get punched in the face.
    5 Effrontery at being offered a bon bon in Pompeii.
    6 Backfires related to Wile-E-Coyote.
    7 Your ass smells funny.

    1 LADY FINGER TECHS
    2 MEAN ARTISAN (~)
    3 RASH? SMEAR MCRIB!
    4 TOTES DEAF WOMEN (~)
    5 ASHY TREAT GALL
    6 ACME HIT-NESS (~)
    7 PACK ANIMAL RIPE

    My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Surgery sites for unharvesting your organs. TIME MACHINE ORS.

    ¯\_(ツ)_/

    ReplyDelete
  59. I’m having trouble finding my copy of Eric Hoffer’s “The True Believer” so I can’t quote you any passages out of it (lucky you) but I would recommend reading it. It was written after WWII, early 50s, and explores the impetus behind mass movements including, of course fascism. There’s more than a few MAGA cross-overs.

    Hoffer was a conservative, a working class philosopher, if you will. He worked on the docks, in the fields. He wrote between assignments. It’s good suff.

    ReplyDelete
  60. Totally agreed with Rex about FAKE NEWS. However, He seemed to welcome ANTIFA into the grid a whole back, I put that into the same category.

    ReplyDelete
  61. Wow. Did not anticipate the HOOHA this one stirred up.

    I thought the theme was clever and amusing and that the short stuff was fairly typical for a grid with five themers. I even thought the opening section with the likes of GALL, LLAMA, OLYMPIAD, HOOHA and CHERI was quite nice.

    There were some longer non-theme entries that I thought were first rate, HOME RUNS even. I think FAKE NEWS has a much longer and broader history than being solely a product of what's his name. I wonder if anyone uses a PACK ANIMAL as a TEAM MASCOT.

    I would have changed the clue for 33A MEAN "One of three statistical averages" to "One of three statistical central tendencies. The MEAN is the statistical average while the other two are the mode (most frequent value) and the median (the middle value).

    The clue for 14D NOSES "They may be counted...." reminded me of an old dad joke. "Hey kids, do you know how to tell how many cows are out in that field? You count their legs and divide by four!"

    ReplyDelete
  62. fake news And palin not worth capitalizing ad mcrib I lost my appetite

    ReplyDelete
  63. After the FAKENEWS, SARAH and RAMBO of it all I got to 50.7% of Americans with only the W revealed of the 5 letter word. I thought, N way. They are not asking for WHITE. No. No. No. Thank goodness for WOMEN

    ReplyDelete
  64. Not bothered by the fill mostly, as Carola noted, it’s a Tuesday. Rambo never saw any of the movies but it is common trivia.As is Sarah (Palin) The name Rambo is derived from Rambeau Not sure why but maybe someone in Hollywood knew that after he quit poetry he went off to the French African colonies to make money but also got involved in a lot of violence. Not a good ending.
    FAKENEWS It is possible many liberals use the term to attack Fox but Trump still uses it routinely. Still too much part of the MAGA propaganda machine language. Should be avoided.

    ReplyDelete
  65. Anonymous5:11 PM

    What @Rex said. Congratulations to you, Max Schlenker, on your debut puzzle, but shame, shame, shame on the editors for failing to help you clean up the grid. Both to rid it of so much junk fill, but again, just what OFL said. Inclusion of something so vile is unacceptable by its mere presence. That expression is not something that by its very definition does not exist.

    I assume that the clever theme entries are what tipped the scale, but this is just is not nearly the quality I expect from this puzzle that I have enjoyed for almost every single day for over 60 years. Again, the crossword editors are not doing their jobs. Period.

    At least HEADLESS HORSEMAN made me chuckle.

    ReplyDelete
  66. Anonymous6:51 PM

    Bogus, completely bogus. Trite and then some.

    ReplyDelete