Dome-shaped Buddhist shrine / 2-7-26 / Woolen leggings, as worn by W.W. I soldiers / Reptile with a colorful name / Airbnb inclusion, usually / The Hornets, on a scoreboard / Singer with the 2016 Grammy-winning soul ballad "Cranes in the Sky" / "OMG"-evoking deed / Seldom-used PC key / Former e-book devices, until 2014 / Michael who plays Allan in "Barbie" / One of Oberon's subjects
Constructor: Mark Diehl
Relative difficulty: Medium
THEME: none
Word of the Day: STUPA (34A: Dome-shaped Buddhist shrine) —
In Buddhism, a stupa (Sanskrit: स्तूप, lit.'heap', IAST: stūpa) is a domed hemispherical structure containing several types of sacred relics, including images, statues, metals, and śarīra—the remains of Buddhist monks or nuns. It is used as a place of pilgrimage and meditation.
Walking around a stupa in a clockwise direction, known as pradakhshina, has been an important ritual and devotional practice in Buddhism since the earliest times, and stupas always have a pradakhshina path around them. The original South Asian form is a large solid dome above a tholobate, or drum, with vertical sides, which usually sits on a square base. There is no access to the inside of the structure. In large stupas, there may be walkways for circumambulation on top of the base as well as on the ground below it. Large stupas have, or had, vedikā railings outside the path around the base, often highly decorated with sculpture, especially at the torana gateways, of which there are usually four. At the top of the dome is a thin, vertical element, with one or more horizontal discs spreading from it. These were chatras, symbolic umbrellas, and have not survived, if not restored. The Great Stupa at Sanchi in Madhya Pradesh, is the most famous and best-preserved early stupa in India. (wikipedia)
• • •
OK, don't get me wrong, I appreciated the challenge. This one definitely put up a fight, something late-week puzzles don't seem to do that much these days, and I'm grateful. I just wish the grid itself were more ... pleasing, somehow. Some of the answers were, uh, questionable (a few ODDITYs, for sure), and so many of the clues just felt off or inapt—designed for misdirection, but perhaps ... overdesigned. A sharpshooter needs ... some kind of ACUITY, sure, but just ... ACUITY? I dunno. Not all (or even most?) ODDITYs are "treasures" (16A: Curio shop treasure). "GOD NO!" is a flat-out, dead-certain response to a question, not something you say when you see something fishy or unbelievable (14D: "That can't possibly be right!"). "Do you want to see the newest Marvel movie?" "GOD NO!" That's how that works. Like, "are you f***ing kidding me, absolutely not!" Whereas "That can't possibly be right!" is something you'd say if you were astonished by something that might, in fact, be true. I guess you could do a line reading wherein you make your voice more horrified, and put a little pause (audible comma) between "GOD" and "NO," but if you're alarmed like that, you'd probably start with "Oh." There's something tin-eared about this, and many other clues. And some of the answers as well. TOENAIL SCISSORS!? Do you all not use TOENAIL CLIPPERS? Imagining cutting my toenails with actual scissors is freaking me out. I don't doubt such things exist, but ... I don't doubt the ROSY BOA exists either, but what the hell is that? Do PUTTEES exist? Does an END key? I guess I believe you, but I can't really picture them. Stacking the grid with ODDITYs isn't the most entertaining way to achieve difficulty, and doesn't make for a terribly exciting experience overall.
I think the thing I resent the most today, though, is the clue on A SPOT—a horrible partial that you'd think you'd want to make relatively unambiguous so that the solver could solve it quickly and move on. No need to have the solver dwelling on the garbage. Today, however, this answer—possibly the worst thing in the grid, from a pure "how good is this single piece of fill?" standpoint—was the thing that held me up the longest, the answer I spent most time with, and all because of the deliberately ambiguous clue (8D: "Save me ___!"). Why make me spend so much time with the worst you have to offer? Of course I wrote in "Save me A SEAT!" because that is the more likely answer, so much more likely that that is exactly how "A SEAT" has been clued in the past—three times! Whereas "A SPOT" has never been clued this way. It tends to be clued in much clearer ways, like ["You missed ___!"] or [In ___ (having difficulty)]. It's been fourteen glorious years since "A SPOT" has appeared at all, but that era is now over. Sigh. It's weird how much one wrong (and very right-seeming) answer can hold up solving progress. Add "A SEAT" to "ESC" (instead of the mysterious "END"), and you've got me all gummed up in the top. Specifically, I could not parse GENUS AND SPECIES at all—and again, the answer itself is not pleasing. I know GENUS and SPECIES but GENUS AND SPECIES? GOD NO. I do not know or recognize GENUS AND SPECIES as a standalone phrase. And I was so happy to see Pauline KAEL ... really thought she was gonna blow the puzzle open for me (she got me WAFFLE MAKER!). But alas, no. I was ground down by ... "A SPOT." Bah.
The stack across the middle is solid enough. I could do without a MISSILE TEST in my grid, but GOOD SPELLER is OK. Despite the presence of the mysterious, made-up-sounding ROSY BOA (a debut, no surprise there), I think the center is the strongest part of the grid. The top is OK (GENUS AND SPECIES aside). The bottom, oof, no. Hard to think of a long answer more singularly unappealing than SONY READERS. A long bygone e-reader that I've never heard of ... in the plural ... why? And we've been over TOENAIL SCISSORS (CLIPPERS fits perfectly, by the way, if you didn't discover that fact for yourself). As a baseball fan for whom baseball season will start (mentally) as soon as the Super Bowl concludes on Sunday, I enjoyed RETIRE THE SIDE (46A: What a pitcher tries to do), though I imagine it won't be as pleasing to non-sports fans (just as I enjoyed SOLANGE (17A: Singer with the 2016 Grammy-winning soul ballad "Cranes in the Sky") but imagine many solvers will greet her appearance here with a "huh?"—this is her sixth NYTXW appearance, though, you should probably have her name committed to memory by now).
Bullets:
24A: Airbnb inclusion, usually (LINEN) — I mean, sure, but is that word actually used in the Airbnb listing? LINEN? I had the "L" but still struggled with this clue.
21A: Cause for getting stuck (MIRE) — Had the "M," wanted MIRE, held back because MUCK seemed possible.
30D: Woolen leggings, as worn by W.W. I soldiers (PUTTEES) — gonna go out on a limb and say the STUPA / PUTTEES crossing is gonna trip some solvers up. Those are both very specialized, foreign, non-everyday terms, crossing at a vowel. Seems dicey. I completely forgot that STUPA was a thing, and was so happy that some part of me dimly but confidently remembered that PUTTEES were a thing (though if you'd asked me to explain what kind of thing before I solved this puzzle, I would not have been able to help you). I associate PUTTEES with British soldiers in India. Turns out they were worn by all kinds of people and date from antiquity, but I think of British India. Why? Hang on ... Yeah, here we go: the word derives from the Hindi word for "bandage."
Worn since antiquity, the puttee was adopted as part of the service uniform of foot and mounted soldiers serving in British India during the second half of the nineteenth century. In its original form the puttee comprised long strips of cloth worn as a tribal legging in the Himalayas. The British Indian Army found this garment to be both comfortable and inexpensive, although it was considered to lack the smartness of the gaiter previously worn." (wikipedia)
37A: Instrument depicted in paintings by Hals and Caravaggio (LUTE) — picture me just sitting on "L--E" waiting for a letter to come along and make the LUTE v. LYRE decision. Because that's what happened. Thank god STUPOR came along to help me (though ... I could've used a less depressing clue on STUPOR (29D: A heavy drinker may be found in one))
39A: Use for a yew (HEDGE) — first read "use" as a verb, not a noun, which was very confusing.
27D: "Divergent" author Veronica (ROTH) — a real live-by-the-name / die-by-the-name kind of day. Never going to remember this author's name. I've tried. It just won't take. Whereas SOLANGE and Hermann HESSE and good ol' Pauline KAEL and LON Chaney and Michael CERA were real helpers today. So I guess I came out on the right side of the proper noun divide today. Mostly. But you don't tend to feel the ones you know, only the ones you don't. Only takes one mystery name to grind you to a halt.
45D: The Hornets, on a scoreboard (CHA) — not a great answer (CHA = Charlotte, btw—they're an NBA team), but I do have to thank the Hornets for helping me see quickly that TOENAIL CLIPPERS was wrong. You might say the Hornets beat the Clippers. You might. If you enjoy very mild NBA word play, you might. You don't have to. It's probably not the greatest idea. But you might, is my only point, really. You might say it.
[Couldn't find any clips of Hornets beating Clippers, so here's Clippers beating Hornets, back in January]
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook and Letterboxd] ============================= ❤️ Support this blog ❤️:
Overwrites: I use the alt key much less than the 6D END key (Ctrl-Shift-END highlights from the current cursor position to the end of the document; I use it often) Like @Rex, I saved a Seat before SPOT at 8D nO way before GOD NO at 14D @Rex TOENAIL clIppeRS before SCISSORS at 43A RETIRE batters before THE SIDE at 46A
WOEs: SOLANGE and her song at 17A ROSY BOA (20D) Veronica ROTH at 27D PUTTEES at 30D STUPA (34A)
I've never heard of TOENAIL SCISSORS, nor the phrase RETIRETHESIDE, however those were easy to fill once I had most of the downs.
I also learned today that HEDGE can be a verb (in this specific sense), which was validated by my out-of-the-ass guess for HESS (already had the -ESS).
The trivia and the proper nouns completely ruined the rest of this, which was a pretty quick romp.
All I had left at the end was the puttees/stupa cross and just tried every vowel in sequence until I made it to the U 😂
And I still know absolutely nothing about the Veronica Roth Divergent series, but after missing it on my jeopardy episode I see it EVERYWHERE and will remember it forever (at least that basic Roth = Divergent connection)
same. I thought it was a bad crossing the constructor got in a jam, and what we were left with was not fun. I really enjoy something obscure crossing something I know/guessable so I can learn new stuff, but two randos crossing is just maleskan...
I’ve been reading, in Natan Last’s book, about the ODDITYs that were standard fare in the Maleska-era puzzles, so the obscure stuff today didn’t seem quite so weird. Learning new stuff is part of the fun, even if it’s information I’m likely to forget. For instance, I had forgotten that my daughter had a friend in high school who had a pet ROSY BOA. Man, that snake was big!
(BTW, I realized belatedly that I made a comment yesterday about what SLID in a bear market but typed “bull” instead of “bear,” making my point complete nonsense. D’oh. Where’s a proofreader when you need one?)
In the days before AirBNB and VRBO, most holiday rentals came without linens. So you always had to figure out how to get all the bedding and towels for your party there. And back.
Wow. Never have I EVER had a short-term vacation rental that didn’t include bed linens and bathroom towels…and I’ve been to plenty prior to VRBO/AirBnB. Oh. MAYBE an ultra-rustic cabin in the woods where you put a sleeping bag on top of the “bed.”
Rented for years on Cape Cod and had to bring all the bedding and towels. What a pain. Luckily driving distance so could transport but two huge laundry bags took up a lot of room in the car.
I liked this one. Upon first glance the grid is daunting but a little work clears things up quickly - I worked from the middle up and down. The top tri-stack was pretty cool. The bottom stack not so much other than RETIRE THE SIDE.
The READY TO GO x ROPE INTO x GOOD SPELLER is the highlight here - top notch. Limited trivia but it is a little obscure in places. I knew PUTTEES from a PBS doc on the Blue PUTTEES of Newfoundland. My brother had a ‘68 EL CAMINO that he worked on for years. Today’s word is STUPOR.
Used to read KAEL followed by Lester Bangs and Christgau - fantastic times. I still remember her positive review of The Warriors - a film I loved and most critics hated.
Replying versus standalone comment, as I was absolutely NOT on the same page as Rex.
Initially predicted four (or more!) stars because of the plethora of longs (ten of 10-15 letters), pretty colorful stuff, and minimal "typical" crosswordese. Isn't this more like what we (here) clamor for on a Saturday, especially?
Didn't have anywhere near the issues that Rex cited. While he was "happy to see Pauline KAEL", I was unfamiliar with the name. On and on from there.
Far less equivocal for me, Rex and I were definitely in sync with his second sentence...I appreciated the challenge.
Did this puzzle feel fresh? That is, did you feel like you ran into many answers you’ve never seen before?
Well it is. Amazingly is. This puzzle has eight answers of 11 letters or more, and every one is a NYT answer debut. That includes all six answers of the top and bottom stacks and those two long downs at 7D and 19D. Wow!
There are actually 11 debuts. Not all have zing, but, IMO, many do, such as MACARONI SALAD, ROPE INTO, WAFFLE MAKER, and GOOD SPELLERS.
New answers and their clues remove the easy gets that come from having seen them before in puzzles. They happify the brain by giving it new territory to conquer.
Mark has been making Times puzzles for 42 years, and it’s clear he’s sharp as ever, even after a six-year absence, crafting this uber-low 62-worder with plenty of GRIT and yes, pulsing with freshness.
BTW, I love those photo-album corners!
Mark, I found your puzzle satisfying and richly punctuated with pleasurable moments. Thank you, and don’t wait so long, please, before your next one!
This was my slowest Saturday in the ~4 years the crossword has become a part of my daily routine, but I really enjoyed (most of) the challenge.
Finding out that the constructor, Mark Diehl, took a six year hiatus before publishing this one made me feel a little better about myself - it just didn't have the gimmes that I'm become more familiar!
Maybe it's a sign that I should dig into the archives and struggle through some of those.
Agree with most everything the Blogmeister had to say; except genus and species is absolutely a standalone phrase. I remember this from high school Biology.
Hey All ! NW trouble spot again. Took a good amount of my solve time trying to ferret out that area. Really wanted nOway for GODNO, ONS very oddly clued, and the easy answers (MEDIAN, WANDERS) took some time appearing for some reason.
Finished, but had a one-letter DNF. Argh! Had wEDGE/wESSE. Sorry HESSE, for forgetting your name.
Used @M&A's adage of "when in doubt, go with the U" at the ST_PA/P_TTEES cross. It did seem like the most logical vowel for the cross.
Had the AseaT for A SPOT first. Betting more than not had that, too (including Rex.) And yes, TOENAIL clIppeRS.
So, a good SatPuz today. Used the ole brain just enough as to not damage it further. Har.
I loved the write up this morning, REX! Enjoying the SOLANGE tune. I think this definitely got into "Medium-Challenging" territory for me. I don't really pay that much attn to my time on a Saturday... Especially on days today when I went to bed 3/4 of the way through. My timer says 6:39. (Six hours, 39 minutes!). I measure difficulty like this on Saturdays.... I guess I do use time for easy and easy-medium. Easy is less than 15 mins. Easy-Medium is 15 to 25 minutes. And then after that, it's more like how many times I had to run the alphabet or take whole sections out and restart. If I do that just once, it's medium. If more than once, it's medium challenging. And if I can't finish at all without Mr. Google.... that's challenging! Anyway, The U in STUPA was a complete mystery (but kinda had to be a vowel, right? Though I actually ran the whole alphabet there at one point). And then the SONYREADERS. OMG, I just had no idea there was such a thing. Started out with nOokREADERS; finally saw the "doh" obvious MAIN st, and that it was a FAIRY, so I had _ONYREADERS.... ?pONY? Ran the alphabet there and .... tada... SONY. LIke OFL, was glad CHArlotte gave me the SCISSORS. GENUSANDSPECIES do go together as the complete name of an organism, so I thought that was great, and I loved seeing RETIRETHESIDE.... looks like that was a debut! Fabulous long answer (for baseball people, anyway). Same issue with ASeaT before ASPOT; Had ELdoradO before ELtorinO before finally remembering that the hybrid truck-car thing is called an ELCAMINO!!!! It's a very interesting process learning how your own brain's data filing system is organized, ya know? Anyhoo--this was a great puzzle, MARK, very puzzling for me, but I did get it in the end without cheating, so that is just want I want on Saturday. And even though I didn't agree with the clue on TOENAILSCISSORS (you don't actually shorten your toes with those), overall the challenge was welcome, and the long answers were fun! And now I feel READYTOGO, me and my DADBOD!
One of those days when it was Very Hard to get started, with my entry being DAB all the way down at 31A. But once I got going, things began to flow and overall I'd have to put this in the easy column.
I would always use LINENs in that context, rather than LINEN.
Surprisingly, CHA has never been clued by referencing the Pussycat Dolls' song.
The phrase RETIRE THE SIDE is probably said 5-10 times in every baseball game by TV or Radio announcers. “Struck him out to RETIRE THE SIDE.” Sometimes it’s said as the shortened SIDE RETIRED. Bad sign for the size of MLB viewership if the phrase is not better known.
A good write up by OFL today. I think he captured the essence of this one, as I definitely had the sense that the clue/answer combinations were intent on fooling you by being deliberately misleading. Rex pointed out the somewhat nonsensical clue for ACUITY, as a good example.
It spoils the enjoyment when you bump into a good clue and answer combination such as the one for GOOD SPELLER only to be smacked in the face with something like ROSY BOA right next door. The whole “voi
I truly love this blog. For so many reasons, not least of which is how passionate people can get about TOENAIL SCISSORS! And here’s my take: I have a pair of NAIL SCISSORS, which I sometimes use on TOEs and sometimes on fingers, depending on the demands of the moment. I also have NAIL clippers, which I use similarly. The wider the variety of tools, the more effectively they answer to need. There! I, too, have said my piece.
I liked the puzzle and went from thinking, “Oh no, I’ve got nuthin’” to finishing in half my normal Saturday time. I love when that happens. It’s such a lesson in GRIT.
I was lucky today with the answers that were WOEs for many. Being a historian helped with PUTTEES (a word which, in the singular, I’m often annoyed with the Spelling Bee for rejecting). I also knew STUPA although, oddly, when I entered it, I worried that I was mixing it up with the term for the peregrine falcon’s vertical plunge into water after prey (that’s actually just STOOP, like bad posture or your front porch). Pauline KAEL’s an old friend, SOLANGE got dredged up from previous puzzles, and Veronica ROTH from my bookseller days.
Hooray for artistic LUTEs! I have a poster of this Caravaggio in my house. And always love any reason to look at Frans Hals.
Here’s some vintage Pauline KAEL: “‘Bonnie and Clyde’ keeps the audience in a kind of eager, nervous imbalance—it holds our attention by throwing our disbelief back in our faces. To be put on is to be put on the SPOT, put on the stage, made the stooge in a comedy act. People in the audience at Bonnie and Clyde are laughing, demonstrating that they’re not stooges—that they appreciate the joke—when they catch the first bullet right in the face. The movie keeps them off balance to the end… Instead of the movie spoof, which tells the audience that it doesn’t need to feel or care, that it’s all just in fun, that ‘we were only kidding,’ ‘Bonnie and Clyde’ disrupts us with ‘And you thought we were only kidding.'” — 5001 Nights at the Movies (1982)
My reaction precisely to the SCISSORS business: we also call them NAIL SCISSORS (not TOENAIL SCISSORS -- that sounds somewhat made up for the exigencies of the puzzle). We have the clippers too.
Somehow I fat fingered into posting an incomplete comment. I was just going to say that I wished this one had gone through a few more revisions (between auto-incorrect and this blogger interface, it’s a minor miracle that I can post anything).
I was just discussing this with someone a few minutes ago …. Do you think AutoCorrect has gotten worse with the advent of AI? Sure seems like it to me.
It sure seems that way, doesn’t it. I only have a rudimentary understanding, so I may be off base - but my understanding is that the Large Language Model versions of AI are basically trained to predict the next word in a sentence (over millions of iterations) to recognize language patterns. I sometimes get the feeling that the “correction algorithm” is not so much attempting to watch out for mistakes but is actually trying to anticipate what I am about to type.
Re AI--My new laptop has a built-in gmail feature which automatically "suggests" a reply. I was unaware of this until I got a short note from my good old best friend and the suggested response not only sounded like I could have written it but ended the way I always end our emails, which as far as I know is unique to us. This is getting a little scary.
My only issue was the stupa puttees cross. I was prepared to just try every vowel till the bell rang. . But the U looked better. Maybe because stupa looks like Stuka. So got it clean.
It's a little known fact, but in the early days of golf, the hole was commonly known as the puttee. If you hang around St. Andrew's long enough, you can still run into some old-timers who refer to it as such. And to this day the IV League Rules of Golf use that term exclusively when referring to the hole.
I used to use it all the time but on my new laptop it is combined with the 1 key on the numpad, and since I can't be bothered to toggle the numpad off and on, I no longer use it. But if it were a standalone key still, it would definitely be oft-used.
I have no interest in car names or brands, so I put in Escalade and then Eldorado. I’m surprised those names even occurred to me but I guess the advertisements have seeped in somehow.
This is one of those days I pretty much thought everything @Rex said and with respect to GODNO, I’ll just add that I really tried to make my entry of nOway work for way too long. Also…besides thinking you have to have some pretty flimsy TOENAILS to successfully use SCISSORS…I think of the TOE as being the digit and NOT the nail. To me, it’s like saying that you’ll be shorter if you cut your hair. But…like many others, I really appreciated the challenge today. It seems hard to believe I’d NEVER heard of a SONYREADER until today. I don’t use an e-reader, but I’m still familiar with Kindle and Nook.
I tried "no way" and also "not so". Wow, that region was a stinker.
Nail scissors are a somewhat specialized instrument. They work great. They're small and you can use them with greater... ACUITY? [no, that's not quite the right word] than nail clippers.
I have no idea who MACARON is, but he must be young as attested by the fact that MACARONISALAD. And BTW, MACARONISALAD seems so overused as a picnic item that I think we should RETIRETHESIDE dish for good. And you certainly can't eat it as a MAIN. GODNO!
As Ms. Fosse used to say to her ape friends, MEDIAN.
Golfers generally PUTTEES into the ground before driving.
Wanna know what car has the same number of letters as ELCAMINO? ELdoradO.
ASPOT has gotten stronger over the years, my comments here have become less coherent.
I thought @Rex's review was in explanation of a 1.5 star rating. Seemed awfully negative for a 3 star. But I don't disagree with much that he said. Still enjoyed it, though. Thanks, Mark Diehl.
I've never bothered to use the WAFFLE MAKER when I'm at a hotel breakfast bar. Give me a bagel and cream cheese and I'm good - no waiting for other people to finish. I'm hungry now!
I forgot that the ELdorado car was a Cadillac model which held me up a tad in the NE. Ironically, the MIRE got me unstuck.
Thanks, Mark Diehl, for a fun Saturday with a bit of a challenge.
My actual last name is ROTH and I had trouble with that clue even with only the “R” missing. As a person who works with very large spreadsheets on the daily, I use the END key frequently. I knew PUTTEES, probably from some British -Colonial- adjacent fiction I read a long time ago
Even being a GOOD SPELLER this was hard for me - ROSY BOA, STUPA, PUTTEES, SOLANGE, CHA & of course, never remembering whether it's CERA or CENA. Thanks for the challenge, Mark (I think) :)
- ST_PA x P_TTEES took me 5 guesses because AEIOU. - TOENAILSCISSORS absolutely exist. If you really want to feel squeamish, I had mine trimmed by a man with a loupe and scalpel blade once. There, you feel better about the scissors now. - Loved the Hornets beating the Clippers!! Now that James Harden is no longer a Clipper and the Hornets are on a roll, it may be coming soon. - with no letters in place, my conundrum was HARP/LUTE/LYRE. - I think the vagueness in the clues are fair, and what you want on a Saturday. Answers that are perfectly legit, but not the first thing you’d think of - looking at you, Save me ___ a seat? Nope. I also thought we’d be resetting the Star Wars meter with OBWAN:) Lots of blank space after the first pass that you gradually chip away at until you look at the grid afterward and wonder what could have been so challenging.
This one took me a tad longer than usual because it’s loaded with ODD vocabulary and names I don’t know and some tricky clues. Died like many on the cross of STUPA and PUTTEES. Had one in five chance of getting it right but whiffed. And ACUITY, wow, the crosses made it fit, but not the first thing that comes to mind for a shooter. In the end though have it admit this puzzle was fun to puzzle out. Will credit myself with GRIT for this one.
The end key is on Windows keyboards near the home key, page up key, and page down key. If you use a Mac, you’d generally need Command +right arrow to achieve the same thing.
Happy Birthday to Crossworld's own John DEERE, born on this date in Rutland, Vermont in 1804. His design of a plow with blades that cleaned themselves as they worked was a very big deal. He and wife Demarius had nine kids, and one of their granddaughters married Warren Giles, who was the President of the National League for 18 years and is in the Baseball Hall of Fame as an executive. Hope you remembered to send a card. Not in today's puzzle, but it's only a matter of time.
Finally just before I get to put in my 2 cents, egs mentions the obvious. TOENAILNSCISSORS, or clippeRS, do not make the toes smaller. They just make the toenails smaller. Uness there's a good literary reference to Cinderella's evil stepsisters using TOENAILSCISSORS to make the glass slipper fit.
So, PUTTEES is a word from the British colonization of India, and actually derives from Hindi, but we’re cluing it to a later military narrative that’s slightly more palatable. Just making sure I’m clear on this.
What a terrific Saturday. I expected no less from this constructor. He's made some of the most fiendishly difficult puzzles I've ever solved. Today's offering came in a little over average time. I was still impressed because the triple stacks culminating with grid spanners are feats of construction that typically sacrifice difficulty. Finding out that all six of them are debuts and that he could still work five more into the grid was an "we are not worthy" moment.
Wish I could say I finished this one cleanly. My "last" entry was the T of STE. I saved it for last only because I couldn't remember what STE stood for. When I got the "so close" notification I knew I had to look elsewhere for the mistake. It wasn't hard to find. Turns out GENUSANT isn't a word. I just thought that ENT was short for enter. For a split second I thought GENUSAND was a word then the light bulb went off. Shoot me now!
Dear SB, PUTEE is absolutely a word. I've known it since I was a child. It has its own illustration in Webster's. You include PARATHA and PALAPA but not PUTEE? WTF, SMH.
Some good write overs today. I had GRIDLECAKES then WAFFLECAKES and finally WAFFLEMAKER. I also had to deal with ASEAT/ASPOT. In the south HESSE single handedly knocked out CLIPPERS. YESSIR put SCISSORS in.
Read the first clue, wrote in WAFFLEIRON and off to the races. Couple of longer answers like GOODSPELLER and READYTOGO went in right away and my only writeovers were SCISSORS, SPOT, and CERA (which I never get straight). STUPA is classic crosswordese, and by classic I mean ancient. and I even knew PUTTEES , They appear in a classic Bob and Ray spot as a bargain deal when their clothing store is going out of business, if memory serves. Oh, and had RETIREBATTERS before RETIRETHESIDE, but that was fixed by knowing HESSE.
In short, this one made me feel like the smart feller who felt smart. Thanks for that MD, You made My Day.
So happy to see Ms. Kael. And, living in SE Asia Stupa and Puttees were both gimmes. On the other hand = Genus? I got And Species but had problems with God No. For a long time I thought No Way - but that didn't work. And I had to juggle El Camino and El Dorado for a bit. All in all, fun.
Did I miss a comment, or am I really the first to mention STUPA crossing STUPOR (likely the first time two words starting with "STUP" have intersected in a grid [off the top of my head, the only other STUP- words I can think of are STUPENDOUS and STUPID])? STUPA was a new one for me, but I knew PUTTEES, so I didn't have the hangup in that section most people did.
I agree with WS that the ebook device clue was poorly written (I knew what the clue was getting at, but the word "Former" should not be there)! Also agree with Anonymous 8:02—a LINEN CLOSET is a thing, but to say LINEN is included with a rental instead of LINENS is ridiculous! And even though I'm chronologically 58 years old, similar to RodeoToad, when I had FA_T filled in from the crosses, and read the clue for 4D, the first thought that jumped into my head was 'how does farting help prep for surgery'? I got to FAST eventually, but my inner immaturity made it take a few seconds!
Biology nomenclature nerd here. Homo sapiens is only the species name. Yes, homo is the genus, but the specific epithet (sapiens) requires the genus name to be a unique identifier. This makes more sense thinking of trees. Quercus rubrum is red oak, acer rubrum is red maple. Rubrum alone can’t be the species name.
I agree. A species name must always be two-part, i.e., "binomial", in order to be a unique identifier. "Homo" is the genus name. "Homo sapiens" is the species name.
I also agree with Rex that many of the answers in this puzzle were "questionable" and this is a prime example.
Well, I’m terribly impressed, not sure whether it’s with the puzzle or myself but I got ‘er done all on my own today. That’s rare for me on a Saturday. I always print a copy and solve with a pencil but last night I had a major case of feline paralysis when publishing time rolled around. Since I couldn’t disturb the fur baby, I decided to start on my iPad and before I knew it, I was finished. Maybe I should do that more often. In any case, it was a it was a good workout and extremely satisfying. Appreciate the effort and thanks for a very nice Saturday puzzle, Mr. Diehl.
It was really tough to get started. I was looking for something to eat at the breakfast bar, and when neither cole slaw or potato SALAD would fit into my picnic basket I was stuck. I finally decided to try the downs, and got lucky--rAmbleS at 1-D, giving me humanoid SPECIES. -- so I turned to the crosses and ran head on into MEDIAN which just had to be right. Eventually I sorted out that corner. Like Rex, GENUS AND SPECIES seemed odd; if I pointed at an American Robin and asked you what species it was you'd reply "turdus migratorius" not simply migratorius. But people do say it in many contexts, so OK.
MISSILE TEST got me into the middle, GRIT seemed likely, and the colorful reptile starting with R had to be a Red something, which made it hard to see FOOL. SPORTS BETS was obvious, though, and gave me STUPOR, PUTTEES, and STUPA. I'm pretty sure the books of P.G. Wodehouse and Agatha Christie are full of retired colonels who spent their careers in India and like to walk around wearing PUTTEES. I've never been too sure what they were, but knew the word well. I knew STUPA from reading about Buddhism, though I've never seen one in the flesh. I realize that's just my particular wheelhouse, though, and can see why others found them tough.
Now came my real difficulty. I misread 39-D as 38-D and put HESSE in the wrong place., leading eventually to Oberon's subject being hAIRY. I figured that must apply to Bottom after he was turned to an ass.
Fortunately I notice the error and put HESSE in the right place, which saved me from clIppeRS. My family did use NAIL SCISSORS when I was young, though eventually we switched over to clippers--I thouht maybe they'd just been invented, but I looked them up, and they've been on the market since 1875, at least. Sue Grafton's detective, Kinsey Millhone, uses a nail scissors to cut her hair. I think my father did have a scissors specifically for toenails -- it had long handles, and the cutting partwas angled to the left, soo you could use it even if you had trouble bending over.
I enjoyed the difficulty, and would give it at least a half-star more than Rex did.
Oh my gosh, that northeast corner. Save me A SEAT, yup. Cause for getting stuck, RUTS. Then the true disaster, EL DORADO . . . it's a car yeah? It's old? Man that took a while to unravel. Fun!
Had to run the vowels at STUPA/PUTTEES, but otherwise it was a pleasant solve. Plenty of gimmes and the longs sorted themselves out straightaway. I had many of the same sticking points as @🦖 but didn't seem to be bothered by most. Quick solve for me. Solidly constructed and joyful.
I liked image searching STUPAS and PUTTEES after the solve.
I wrote in LUTE right off, because LYRES are lame, and I was rewarded. I checked both paintings and knew them both and neither shows the lutenist using typical form. So maybe bad painters or bad players or maybe (probably) I'm being a ridiculous lutenophile. I've ordered from Sweden an 11-string guitar for messing up Baroque lute music and it should arrive sometime this month. I know you'll want to be posted, so stay "tuned." And by the way, a missed cluing cross-reference, it's a FOOL in the Hals painting.
Let's not fight about this today please. WAFFLES are way better than pancakes. And MACARONI SALAD will forever be an also-ran to potato salad or baked beans.
I am under the impression there are many things included in an AirB&B, like the floor, a door, maybe a roof. Good to know LINEN was top of mind on the clue writer's mind.
They make clippers and scissors @🦖. Maybe time to get onboard with the pedicurist revolution. We're old men now and won't be long before we need a foot guy.
I use "That can't possibly be right," all the time. I learned it from a psychotic boss I had in the 90s and it stuck. It turns out most of the time it is right to everyone's disappointment.
Y'ALL is a pronoun everywhere. If you're not using it yet, get going. It'll save you all a lot of time. It's mo'bettah, amirite?
As a student, my goal was to meet girls. The fact they give you a degree after four years of chasing them seems incidental to the process.
This whole puzzle was worth doing just for the GOOD SPELLERS clue.
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Inspired by @okanaganer there were epic loops telling two groovy stories. PREDICTABLE CRIME NOVELIST CHANCE ENCOUNTER and ON A REGULAR BASIS DINNER THEATER CAUSES A RIOT.
@Gary, as usual you posts brighten my day! My college experience was similar. Maybe it's telling that after four years I was able to scrape up the degree but NOT the girl :o) I tried MUCH harder for the latter...
Like others, I enjoyed the challenge that this one offered. No chance of a start up top, so I headed to the bottom where the DAB, Y'ALL, YES SIR, HESSE, and LESBOS cluster gave me what I needed. On the way back up, I enjoyed STUPOR, ROPE INTO, and learning ROSY BOA. Last in: WAFFLEMAKER x WANDERS.
Do-over: rarITY before ODDITY. Luck of the memory junk drawer: STUPA x PUTTEES. Help from previous puzzles: CERA. No idea: SOLANGE.
Just curious ... do people really have two sets of clippers; one for fingernails and one for toenails? I just have clippers, and use them on all my toes and on my thumbs, and occasionally on the non-thumb fingers.
I'm curious to know the number of people that are in the overlapping part of the Venn diagram of "people who know what PUTTEEs are" and "people who know what STUPAs are". Also, saying that I "take issue" with the clue for TOENAILSCISSORS just doesn't cut it (pun intended). Clipping/cutting toenails makes your digits smaller??? Sure, ok.
Count me in for the overlapping part of the Venn diagram. I saw many stupas while hiking in Nepal and my Brit husband calls his hiking gaiters puttees. Being a biologist, I was very familiar with genus and species as a standalone and also rosy boas. Altogether a relatively easy Saturday for me.
I hated this puzzle for many reasons, almost all of which have been eloquently expounded upon by Our Fearless Leader.
However, I still loathe and completely fail to understand one answer, which left me so stunned I paused for ten to fifteen minutes repeating it over and over again, sure to my marrow that either Will Shortz, Mark Diehl (or even I, myself!) had been struck with a sudden seizure of aphasia. So before I go ask a search engine, I will share with you my incredulous (and as-yet-unanswered) query:
When an out is recorded, the batter is said to be retired. When three outs are achieved, the offensive side is retired, and the pitcher who has been trying to retire the side as successful. I'm thinking you're not a big fan of baseball.
I also found that entry confounding. But I did look it up later. "THE SIDE" refers to the team that was just at bat. The expression apparently comes from cricket, originally.
By my Saturday standards, I flew through this, circling the U in the STUPA/PUTTEES crossing, before remembering the leggings from the wonderful Flashman novels. Tripped up by the AND in the Homo Sapiens entry. Oh, well . . . Good fun.
I think this is a great example of being on the right wavelength or not. I started st the top but it took me until the southeast that I started getting a toe hold (just as I was starting to feel despondent), and then made my way back around. 16:38 flew by! Knew both Puttee (having taught a WWI course) and Stupa (travel in SE Asia). Didn't know Kael or Solange (Knowles).
Spent way too much time thinking “pitchers” was some kind of marketing misdirect, those who pitch new products. I don’t watch baseball enough to be familiar with the phrase RETIRE THE SIDE, but as soon as it appeared and pushed my brain into the realm of sports, it all made sense. A much better answer than I had been anticipating for sure!
Wanted "Save me JESUS" but figured that wouldn't be kosher. Shoulda gone for it since GOD NO was apparently not too blasphemous. (I had NO WAY, which seems like a way better answer "That can't possibly be right" and took out a lot of stuff because of that over-confidence--worked with AINT, for "Not, colloquially" and which was also wrong but felt so good I took out WANDERS.
GOD NO, this was not my favorite puzzle.
STUPAxPUTTEES was just rude and lazy. Make a funner puzzle, please!
Next to the last letter entered: S in SONY READERS (since 30D suggested a plural and SONY had its day as the tech entertainment Alpha dog). Last letter entered: U in PUTTEES, a pick-a-vowel-on-faith entry that happened to be correct.
I first wanted my friend to save me Abite, then ASeaT, and finally (thanks to SPECIES) A SPOT
Like many, I wanted NO WAY, not gOdno.
For a seventy-something birthday gift my son gave me a tee shirt announcing, "It's not a DADBOD, it's a father figure."
Hornets beat Clippers word play--loved it! Delightful Rex-ian conclusion to another greater blog post!
Good challenging Saturday, just a nice level of difficulty at 23 minutes.
I was stumped by the "Seldom used PC key"... TAB, ALT, ESC, END? I use END all the time... I just used it now to get to the "Post a comment" button at the bottom of the page. Is this another case of the clue writer assuming everyone else shares his opinion, or is it based on some obscure study?
Hands up for ELDORADO before EL CAMINO, and for "Save me --" A SEAT. And for the breakfast item at 1 across I had only the AKE- part at the end and assumed it must be [something]PANCAKES.
Holy crap, I found this tough. Rex pretty much nailed everything about it except for the business about TOENAIL SCISSORS, where I suspect he has a wrong picture in mind. If you haven't seen them, they're not like kitchen shears. They're small and the cutting edge is slightly curved and they can be wielded with great accuracy (ACUITY wouldn't quite be the right word, for roughly the same reasons given by Rex) to get the shape you want. I would go so far to say they work better than nail clippers, where there is always a danger of flying keratin shrapnel, as in a Sopranos scene where Ralph laughs at Janice when a piece of his toenail hits her in the face as he's, um, shortening his toes.
The SE fell easily and was by far the easiest section. That's how I knew it was SCISSORS and not "clippers". But I did not know RETIRE THE SIDE (and don't even know what it means, precisely, but I can look that up) and I did not know SONY READER (sigh... Products, esp. bygone products, are the worst of the PPP).
WAFFLE cAKEs are a thing and that's what I had first. The NW region messed with me bad. 14 Across (GENUS AND SPECIES, pfft on the first two words) and 14 Down (GOD NO) were just nasty. The natural thing to put in for 14 Down is "no way", and what Rex said about the entry is correct. ACUITY felt a bit off in the cluing (as also noted by Rex); I had ACUmen before that. Oh, and like many I wanted A SeaT and not A SPOT. Oh, and like @Rick Sacra, I went through "dorado" and "torino" before landing on CAMINO. I mean, GOD, this was a real Murphy's Law puzzle.
NARY is colloquial? Really? I just looked that up now, and it's not wrong, but to me it sounds slightly old-fashioned (it's actually an alteration of "ne'er a", and it's centuries old), and maybe more POSH than most colloquialisms I know of.
FASTS I found quite tricky, but I appreciated the deviousness.
I've done quite a bit of reading on Buddhism and Tibetan Buddhism in particular, but STUPA was strangely long in coming.
ROSY BOA was a complete unknown. I admit I cheated to get ROTH. I very much dislike resorting to that, but I was feeling a bit desperate at that point.
Mark Diehl, I shall remember your name. There was GOOD stuff in there, but as solving experience goes, I was in a STUPOR through most of it.
Lol @tht…maybe Rex and I have “similar” toenails but I have an abundance of keratin on fingers/toes. TMI fer shur, but for my “tonios” I use a clipper that is configured more like scissors but NOT scissors. Even when I was young! Keratin will out for some of us! Even so…I figure you flimsy nailed peeps use what I call “cuticle scissors” so the scissor thing didn’t rock my world. :)
Such a satisfying solve for me, I really loved this one. I thought this was proper Saturday difficulty, I really had to work here but what a joy. At first pass all I had was YALL. But all it took was the "F" in Fray on my second pass to make WAFFLE fall and then Pauline made WAFFLEMAKER a gimme - what a lovely entry. I have to admit I get the spelling of her last name wrong almost every time I'm forced to write it and today was no exception. Kale, Kail, etc... I'm not sure what blocks me here. Second day in a row that I'm proclaiming that I absolutely loved all the longs. The last to fall was GENUSANDSPECIES - I had no clue even with every letter in except the G - I did not read three words until I came here so that put up a big fight. First thing I walked away with was, "There is an end key???!!!" Even doing this on an *actual* key board didn't help me. Now looking - yup, there it is, right in the upper right. As the clue indicates, I've never, ever used it. Unlike @Rex, I enjoyed all the mis-directs in the cluing. I also did not mind ASPOT, came fairly quickly for me. Leaned some new things - STUPA and PUTTEES. I thought these little ODDITies were a lot of fun. I also loved ODDITY as an answer to Curio shop treasure. For me, one of the best Saturdays in a long time. Thank you Mark! I hope we see more soon.
Gotta disagree with you on GENUS AND SPECIES -- it is definitely a thing, as most species when referred to in a scientific context get both parts of the Latin Binomial. If the answer had been LATIN BINOMIAL, well that would have been something, wouldn't it.
Certainly, our different responses are related to familiarity -- this was the first answer I landed and was grateful to it for illuminating the top half of the grid.
Not surprised that a lot of you didn't know PUTTEES. Apparently not many branches of the American military used them after the First World War. I knew of them because, when I was about 12 or 13 years old, my older brother decided (or was forced to by my father, a great fan of "discipline") to join the militia. This being the Canadian Army Militia, they were still teaching kids how to clean and re-assemble defunct rifles and properly wrap PUTTEES, something mon frere seemed incapable of doing.
So, on Parade Days he would dress up in all his regalia and then beg me for help. "I've got some really good weed in the top drawer. You can help yourself." And I would wrap these woolen bands around his lower legs and off he'd go to pretend to be a soldier.
I hated this. I was anti-war, anti-fascist, anti-military industrial complex, anti everything at the time. And here I was, batman to a pretend soldier. But he was my brother. And he owes me. Big time.
Oh, the puzzle ... I thought it was pretty good. Totally agree with @Gary about waffles over pancakes and potato salad over MACARONI SALAD, though it's pretty tasty, too. Our waffle iron is about 70 years old. Yeah, seriously. And it comes out for family holiday breakfasts and does a great job. I like mine with butter and maple syrup. The kids prefer whipped cream and fresh fruit or blackberry compote.
I seldom watch baseball these days but RETIRE THE SIDE was a gimme. And I use clippers while my wife prefers scissors. Vive le difference.
Seeing all the white space was a bit daunting, but it didn’t turn out as tough as it looked. I think I actually enjoyed the weird cluing more because I had prepared myself for a struggle.
Hand up for writing in A SeaT before A SPOT, but my initial reaction was Save me A bite. (Hi, @Tom T!)
Another hand up for being STUPefied by STUPA/PUTTEES. I liked the look of PUTTEES but not STUPA, so I put down my pen and paper and went to the online puzzle for a vowelTEST.
I’m probably among the very few to have been disappointed seeing GOOD SPELLERS, though it has grown on me. I had the G and really wanted GRANDMOTHER as “One of many at a (quilting) bee.”
A few years ago I took note of some of the bloggers who mentioned their birthdays. Happy Belated to @GILL, I if you’re reading, and Happy Birthday today to @Barbara S! Think @chefwen is coming up too, yes?
Here’s a Swedish birthday composer selection, Midvinter, by Wilhelm Stenhammar. It starts out a bit dark but not for long. @Barbara, as a birthday bonus the “video” is a painting by Gustaf Rydberg, "Vinterlandskap med hästfora.”
I'm even later than usual, gettin to here. Got tied up watchin the "Olympic Curling" events, M&A's fave. Also, our grand-nephew is currently a diehard Pokemon card collector, so M&A had to make him a customized Pokemon card for his upcoming 12th b-day.
the puz ... a 62-worder with fresher than snot [and fresher than ASPOT] fillins -- with more than sufficient SatPuz feist to yield some extra nanosecond carnage, at our house. Only two ?-marker clues that I see .. but seemed like a lot more; hidden clue feist abounded.
staff weeject pick [of a mere 6 choices]: CHA.
some fave stuff: GENUSANDSPECIES & its clue. RAINING clue. The album-mount puzgrid corners. YALL. STUPA/STUPOR [apt description of the resultin STUPA/PUTTEES cross's effect -- but, when in doubt ... (yo, @Roo)]. READYTOGO.
Thanx for the challenge, Mr. Diehl dude. Good to see yah again.
I wonder if AL GORE has been asked to give his Nobel Peace Prize to a certain someone?
3D "Preps for surgery, perhaps" had me thinking about what a surgeon does prior to an operation. Oh, it's what the one being cut on does, not the one doing the cutting. You switch your regular DIET to a FAST.
Neither FAST nor DIET are up to the task of filling their slots. POC (plural of co0nvenience) to the rescue. Both get a letter count boost by sharing a final S. See also WANDER/ON, LAG/SPORTS BET, and DAD BOD/SONY READER. Those four Ss are the equivalents of cheater squares. Each could be changed to a black square and nothing of interest or value would be lost. The grid now would have a virtual black square count of 38, quite a bit higher than the average of 31.0 for Saturday puzzles (per xwordinfo.com).
ReplyDeleteMedium. Decent Saturday themeless. Liked it.
* * * * _
Overwrites:
I use the alt key much less than the 6D END key (Ctrl-Shift-END highlights from the current cursor position to the end of the document; I use it often)
Like @Rex, I saved a Seat before SPOT at 8D
nO way before GOD NO at 14D
@Rex TOENAIL clIppeRS before SCISSORS at 43A
RETIRE batters before THE SIDE at 46A
WOEs:
SOLANGE and her song at 17A
ROSY BOA (20D)
Veronica ROTH at 27D
PUTTEES at 30D
STUPA (34A)
Really easy for a Saturday -- except.
ReplyDeleteExcept SOLANGE crossing KAEL. Mmkay.
Then CERA crossing STUPA. Blech.
*** coupled with ***
STUPA crossing PUTTEES.
Barf.
I've never heard of TOENAIL SCISSORS, nor the phrase RETIRETHESIDE, however those were easy to fill once I had most of the downs.
I also learned today that HEDGE can be a verb (in this specific sense), which was validated by my out-of-the-ass guess for HESS (already had the -ESS).
The trivia and the proper nouns completely ruined the rest of this, which was a pretty quick romp.
All I had left at the end was the puttees/stupa cross and just tried every vowel in sequence until I made it to the U 😂
ReplyDeleteAnd I still know absolutely nothing about the Veronica Roth Divergent series, but after missing it on my jeopardy episode I see it EVERYWHERE and will remember it forever (at least that basic Roth = Divergent connection)
same. I thought it was a bad crossing the constructor got in a jam, and what we were left with was not fun. I really enjoy something obscure crossing something I know/guessable so I can learn new stuff, but two randos crossing is just maleskan...
DeleteHer books are big in the teen/young adult section
DeleteI’ve been reading, in Natan Last’s book, about the ODDITYs that were standard fare in the Maleska-era puzzles, so the obscure stuff today didn’t seem quite so weird. Learning new stuff is part of the fun, even if it’s information I’m likely to forget. For instance, I had forgotten that my daughter had a friend in high school who had a pet ROSY BOA. Man, that snake was big!
ReplyDelete(BTW, I realized belatedly that I made a comment yesterday about what SLID in a bear market but typed “bull” instead of “bear,” making my point complete nonsense. D’oh. Where’s a proofreader when you need one?)
A Freude-ian slip?
DeleteGood one, Twangster
DeleteForm the Redundant Redundancy Department Division Office...
ReplyDeleteIf Sony readers were former ebook devices, until 2014, what were they after 2014? Previously former ebook devices?
Landfill
Delete: )
DeleteIn the days before AirBNB and VRBO, most holiday rentals came without linens. So you always had to figure out how to get all the bedding and towels for your party there. And back.
ReplyDeleteRight, but it’s LINENs, never singular.
DeleteWow. Never have I EVER had a short-term vacation rental that didn’t include bed linens and bathroom towels…and I’ve been to plenty prior to VRBO/AirBnB. Oh. MAYBE an ultra-rustic cabin in the woods where you put a sleeping bag on top of the “bed.”
DeleteRented for years on Cape Cod and had to bring all the bedding and towels. What a pain. Luckily driving distance so could transport but two huge laundry bags took up a lot of room in the car.
DeleteI liked this one. Upon first glance the grid is daunting but a little work clears things up quickly - I worked from the middle up and down. The top tri-stack was pretty cool. The bottom stack not so much other than RETIRE THE SIDE.
ReplyDeleteMeat Puppets
The READY TO GO x ROPE INTO x GOOD SPELLER is the highlight here - top notch. Limited trivia but it is a little obscure in places. I knew PUTTEES from a PBS doc on the Blue PUTTEES of Newfoundland. My brother had a ‘68 EL CAMINO that he worked on for years. Today’s word is STUPOR.
Friggin’ In The Riggin’
Used to read KAEL followed by Lester Bangs and Christgau - fantastic times. I still remember her positive review of The Warriors - a film I loved and most critics hated.
Magazine
Enjoyable Saturday morning solve. Matt Sewell’s Stumper today presents fairly tricky crossing spanners - makes for a nice puzzle day.
Today Your Love, Tomorrow The World
I was totally on the same page as Rex today. What he said.
ReplyDeleteditto
DeleteReplying versus standalone comment, as I was absolutely NOT on the same page as Rex.
DeleteInitially predicted four (or more!) stars because of the plethora of longs (ten of 10-15 letters), pretty colorful stuff, and minimal "typical" crosswordese. Isn't this more like what we (here) clamor for on a Saturday, especially?
Didn't have anywhere near the issues that Rex cited. While he was "happy to see Pauline KAEL", I was unfamiliar with the name. On and on from there.
Far less equivocal for me, Rex and I were definitely in sync with his second sentence...I appreciated the challenge.
Did this puzzle feel fresh? That is, did you feel like you ran into many answers you’ve never seen before?
ReplyDeleteWell it is. Amazingly is. This puzzle has eight answers of 11 letters or more, and every one is a NYT answer debut. That includes all six answers of the top and bottom stacks and those two long downs at 7D and 19D. Wow!
There are actually 11 debuts. Not all have zing, but, IMO, many do, such as MACARONI SALAD, ROPE INTO, WAFFLE MAKER, and GOOD SPELLERS.
New answers and their clues remove the easy gets that come from having seen them before in puzzles. They happify the brain by giving it new territory to conquer.
Mark has been making Times puzzles for 42 years, and it’s clear he’s sharp as ever, even after a six-year absence, crafting this uber-low 62-worder with plenty of GRIT and yes, pulsing with freshness.
BTW, I love those photo-album corners!
Mark, I found your puzzle satisfying and richly punctuated with pleasurable moments. Thank you, and don’t wait so long, please, before your next one!
This was my slowest Saturday in the ~4 years the crossword has become a part of my daily routine, but I really enjoyed (most of) the challenge.
ReplyDeleteFinding out that the constructor, Mark Diehl, took a six year hiatus before publishing this one made me feel a little better about myself - it just didn't have the gimmes that I'm become more familiar!
Maybe it's a sign that I should dig into the archives and struggle through some of those.
Fun Saturday overall!
Agree with most everything the Blogmeister had to say; except genus and species is absolutely a standalone phrase. I remember this from high school Biology.
ReplyDeleteHey All !
ReplyDeleteNW trouble spot again. Took a good amount of my solve time trying to ferret out that area. Really wanted nOway for GODNO, ONS very oddly clued, and the easy answers (MEDIAN, WANDERS) took some time appearing for some reason.
Finished, but had a one-letter DNF. Argh! Had wEDGE/wESSE. Sorry HESSE, for forgetting your name.
Used @M&A's adage of "when in doubt, go with the U" at the ST_PA/P_TTEES cross. It did seem like the most logical vowel for the cross.
Had the AseaT for A SPOT first. Betting more than not had that, too (including Rex.) And yes, TOENAIL clIppeRS.
So, a good SatPuz today. Used the ole brain just enough as to not damage it further. Har.
Hope Y'ALL have a great Saturday!
Four F's
RooMonster
DarrinV
I loved the write up this morning, REX! Enjoying the SOLANGE tune. I think this definitely got into "Medium-Challenging" territory for me. I don't really pay that much attn to my time on a Saturday... Especially on days today when I went to bed 3/4 of the way through. My timer says 6:39. (Six hours, 39 minutes!). I measure difficulty like this on Saturdays.... I guess I do use time for easy and easy-medium. Easy is less than 15 mins. Easy-Medium is 15 to 25 minutes. And then after that, it's more like how many times I had to run the alphabet or take whole sections out and restart. If I do that just once, it's medium. If more than once, it's medium challenging. And if I can't finish at all without Mr. Google.... that's challenging! Anyway, The U in STUPA was a complete mystery (but kinda had to be a vowel, right? Though I actually ran the whole alphabet there at one point). And then the SONYREADERS. OMG, I just had no idea there was such a thing. Started out with nOokREADERS; finally saw the "doh" obvious MAIN st, and that it was a FAIRY, so I had _ONYREADERS.... ?pONY? Ran the alphabet there and .... tada... SONY. LIke OFL, was glad CHArlotte gave me the SCISSORS. GENUSANDSPECIES do go together as the complete name of an organism, so I thought that was great, and I loved seeing RETIRETHESIDE.... looks like that was a debut! Fabulous long answer (for baseball people, anyway). Same issue with ASeaT before ASPOT; Had ELdoradO before ELtorinO before finally remembering that the hybrid truck-car thing is called an ELCAMINO!!!! It's a very interesting process learning how your own brain's data filing system is organized, ya know? Anyhoo--this was a great puzzle, MARK, very puzzling for me, but I did get it in the end without cheating, so that is just want I want on Saturday. And even though I didn't agree with the clue on TOENAILSCISSORS (you don't actually shorten your toes with those), overall the challenge was welcome, and the long answers were fun! And now I feel READYTOGO, me and my DADBOD!
ReplyDeleteI went through the exact same sequence of cars!
DeleteOne of those days when it was Very Hard to get started, with my entry being DAB all the way down at 31A. But once I got going, things began to flow and overall I'd have to put this in the easy column.
ReplyDeleteI would always use LINENs in that context, rather than LINEN.
Surprisingly, CHA has never been clued by referencing the Pussycat Dolls' song.
The phrase RETIRE THE SIDE is probably said 5-10 times in every baseball game by TV or Radio announcers. “Struck him out to RETIRE THE SIDE.” Sometimes it’s said as the shortened SIDE RETIRED. Bad sign for the size of MLB viewership if the phrase is not better known.
ReplyDeleteEven with EN- I couldn't bring myself to add the D, because anyone who does a lot of typing or coding uses the HOME and END keys almost constantly!
ReplyDeleteA good write up by OFL today. I think he captured the essence of this one, as I definitely had the sense that the clue/answer combinations were intent on fooling you by being deliberately misleading. Rex pointed out the somewhat nonsensical clue for ACUITY, as a good example.
ReplyDeleteIt spoils the enjoyment when you bump into a good clue and answer combination such as the one for GOOD SPELLER only to be smacked in the face with something like ROSY BOA right next door. The whole “voi
I truly love this blog. For so many reasons, not least of which is how passionate people can get about TOENAIL SCISSORS! And here’s my take: I have a pair of NAIL SCISSORS, which I sometimes use on TOEs and sometimes on fingers, depending on the demands of the moment. I also have NAIL clippers, which I use similarly. The wider the variety of tools, the more effectively they answer to need. There! I, too, have said my piece.
ReplyDeleteI liked the puzzle and went from thinking, “Oh no, I’ve got nuthin’” to finishing in half my normal Saturday time. I love when that happens. It’s such a lesson in GRIT.
I was lucky today with the answers that were WOEs for many. Being a historian helped with PUTTEES (a word which, in the singular, I’m often annoyed with the Spelling Bee for rejecting). I also knew STUPA although, oddly, when I entered it, I worried that I was mixing it up with the term for the peregrine falcon’s vertical plunge into water after prey (that’s actually just STOOP, like bad posture or your front porch). Pauline KAEL’s an old friend, SOLANGE got dredged up from previous puzzles, and Veronica ROTH from my bookseller days.
Hooray for artistic LUTEs! I have a poster of this Caravaggio in my house. And always love any reason to look at Frans Hals.
Here’s some vintage Pauline KAEL:
“‘Bonnie and Clyde’ keeps the audience in a kind of eager, nervous imbalance—it holds our attention by throwing our disbelief back in our faces. To be put on is to be put on the SPOT, put on the stage, made the stooge in a comedy act. People in the audience at Bonnie and Clyde are laughing, demonstrating that they’re not stooges—that they appreciate the joke—when they catch the first bullet right in the face. The movie keeps them off balance to the end… Instead of the movie spoof, which tells the audience that it doesn’t need to feel or care, that it’s all just in fun, that ‘we were only kidding,’ ‘Bonnie and Clyde’ disrupts us with ‘And you thought we were only kidding.'” — 5001 Nights at the Movies (1982)
That Kael excerpt is brilliant. I never really thought about the movie that way, but it’s SPOT on. Another film that has a similar effect is Fargo.
DeleteMy reaction precisely to the SCISSORS business: we also call them NAIL SCISSORS (not TOENAIL SCISSORS -- that sounds somewhat made up for the exigencies of the puzzle). We have the clippers too.
Delete@Barbara S. 8:12 AM
DeleteLove your posts.
Somehow I fat fingered into posting an incomplete comment. I was just going to say that I wished this one had gone through a few more revisions (between auto-incorrect and this blogger interface, it’s a minor miracle that I can post anything).
ReplyDeleteI was just discussing this with someone a few minutes ago …. Do you think AutoCorrect has gotten worse with the advent of AI? Sure seems like it to me.
DeleteIt sure seems that way, doesn’t it. I only have a rudimentary understanding, so I may be off base - but my understanding is that the Large Language Model versions of AI are basically trained to predict the next word in a sentence (over millions of iterations) to recognize language patterns. I sometimes get the feeling that the “correction algorithm” is not so much attempting to watch out for mistakes but is actually trying to anticipate what I am about to type.
DeleteI don't know whether AutoCorrect has gotten worse recently, because I disabled mine some time back -- and I'm a happier man ever since.
DeleteRe AI--My new laptop has a built-in gmail feature which automatically "suggests" a reply. I was unaware of this until I got a short note from my good old best friend and the suggested response not only sounded like I could have written it but ended the way I always end our emails, which as far as I know is unique to us. This is getting a little scary.
Delete@tht 12:15 PM
DeleteRight there with ya. I turn off everything I can in all software that's "auto" anything. I want to own every mistake I make.
My only issue was the stupa puttees cross. I was prepared to just try every vowel till the bell rang. . But the U looked better. Maybe because stupa looks like Stuka. So got it clean.
ReplyDeleteIt's a little known fact, but in the early days of golf, the hole was commonly known as the puttee. If you hang around St. Andrew's long enough, you can still run into some old-timers who refer to it as such. And to this day the IV League Rules of Golf use that term exclusively when referring to the hole.
ReplyDeleteYeah…no.
DeleteWell, that's just silly. :-)
DeleteBetween the names and all the inapt cluing masquerading as tricky cluing, I found this one deeply unpleasant.
ReplyDeleteReally hated the clue on "end" because I use the end key all the time. Not every keyboard has it but it's pretty useful.
I used to use it all the time but on my new laptop it is combined with the 1 key on the numpad, and since I can't be bothered to toggle the numpad off and on, I no longer use it. But if it were a standalone key still, it would definitely be oft-used.
DeleteThought I was in for a wavelength match when I confidently put in save me JESUS!
ReplyDeleteSadly it was more boring than that.
Sign seen in Berkeley CA many years ago: Jesus, save me from your followers.
DeleteI have no interest in car names or brands, so I put in Escalade and then Eldorado. I’m surprised those names even occurred to me but I guess the advertisements have seeped in somehow.
ReplyDeleteEscalades and El Dorados are not Chevys
DeleteSTUPA/PUTTEES is a big fat Natick.
ReplyDeleteThis is one of those days I pretty much thought everything @Rex said and with respect to GODNO, I’ll just add that I really tried to make my entry of nOway work for way too long. Also…besides thinking you have to have some pretty flimsy TOENAILS to successfully use SCISSORS…I think of the TOE as being the digit and NOT the nail. To me, it’s like saying that you’ll be shorter if you cut your hair.
ReplyDeleteBut…like many others, I really appreciated the challenge today. It seems hard to believe I’d NEVER heard of a SONYREADER until today. I don’t use an e-reader, but I’m still familiar with Kindle and Nook.
I tried "no way" and also "not so". Wow, that region was a stinker.
DeleteNail scissors are a somewhat specialized instrument. They work great. They're small and you can use them with greater... ACUITY? [no, that's not quite the right word] than nail clippers.
I have no idea who MACARON is, but he must be young as attested by the fact that MACARONISALAD. And BTW, MACARONISALAD seems so overused as a picnic item that I think we should RETIRETHESIDE dish for good. And you certainly can't eat it as a MAIN. GODNO!
ReplyDeleteAs Ms. Fosse used to say to her ape friends, MEDIAN.
Golfers generally PUTTEES into the ground before driving.
Wanna know what car has the same number of letters as ELCAMINO? ELdoradO.
ASPOT has gotten stronger over the years, my comments here have become less coherent.
I thought @Rex's review was in explanation of a 1.5 star rating. Seemed awfully negative for a 3 star. But I don't disagree with much that he said. Still enjoyed it, though. Thanks, Mark Diehl.
I actually entered ELdorado first, then realized I had the wrong SPECIES.
DeleteMEDIAN. 🤭😆😂
Deletecorvette also fits. and it's a Chevy
DeleteChevelle, also a Chevrolet product.
DeleteGenusand Species. Sounds legit. Couldn’t parse it as three words.
ReplyDeleteActually homo sapiens is the genus. The species is hominid.
DeleteAnon 12:45, sorry to say this is completely wrong. See Anon 10:37AM below for the correct explanation.
DeleteTrip some solvers up?..
ReplyDeleteSTiPA (PiTs for WWI!)
STePA (STeePles for shrines!)
SToPA (Wordplay on PoTTiES!)
STaPA (Wordplay on PaTTies!)
STUPA (Nailed it!)
Loved the challenge but too many proper names.
ReplyDeleteI've never bothered to use the WAFFLE MAKER when I'm at a hotel breakfast bar. Give me a bagel and cream cheese and I'm good - no waiting for other people to finish. I'm hungry now!
ReplyDeleteI forgot that the ELdorado car was a Cadillac model which held me up a tad in the NE. Ironically, the MIRE got me unstuck.
Thanks, Mark Diehl, for a fun Saturday with a bit of a challenge.
Me too on hotel breakfast bars!
DeleteThe way this one played out for me had me trying to convince myself that a surgeon makes sure to FART before going into the operating room.
ReplyDeleteI thought of FArTS, too. It helped me see FASTS
DeleteMy actual last name is ROTH and I had trouble with that clue even with only the “R” missing.
ReplyDeleteAs a person who works with very large spreadsheets on the daily, I use the END key frequently.
I knew PUTTEES, probably from some British -Colonial- adjacent fiction I read a long time ago
Even being a GOOD SPELLER this was hard for me - ROSY BOA, STUPA, PUTTEES, SOLANGE, CHA & of course, never remembering whether it's CERA or CENA. Thanks for the challenge, Mark (I think) :)
ReplyDelete- ST_PA x P_TTEES took me 5 guesses because AEIOU.
ReplyDelete- TOENAILSCISSORS absolutely exist. If you really want to feel squeamish, I had mine trimmed by a man with a loupe and scalpel blade once. There, you feel better about the scissors now.
- Loved the Hornets beating the Clippers!! Now that James Harden is no longer a Clipper and the Hornets are on a roll, it may be coming soon.
- with no letters in place, my conundrum was HARP/LUTE/LYRE.
- I think the vagueness in the clues are fair, and what you want on a Saturday. Answers that are perfectly legit, but not the first thing you’d think of - looking at you, Save me ___ a seat? Nope. I also thought we’d be resetting the Star Wars meter with OBWAN:)
Lots of blank space after the first pass that you gradually chip away at until you look at the grid afterward and wonder what could have been so challenging.
This one took me a tad longer than usual because it’s loaded with ODD vocabulary and names I don’t know and some tricky clues. Died like many on the cross of STUPA and PUTTEES. Had one in five chance of getting it right but whiffed. And ACUITY, wow, the crosses made it fit, but not the first thing that comes to mind for a shooter. In the end though have it admit this puzzle was fun to puzzle out. Will credit myself with GRIT for this one.
ReplyDeleteThe end key is on Windows keyboards near the home key, page up key, and page down key. If you use a Mac, you’d generally need Command +right arrow to achieve the same thing.
ReplyDeleteHappy Birthday to Crossworld's own John DEERE, born on this date in Rutland, Vermont in 1804. His design of a plow with blades that cleaned themselves as they worked was a very big deal. He and wife Demarius had nine kids, and one of their granddaughters married Warren Giles, who was the President of the National League for 18 years and is in the Baseball Hall of Fame as an executive. Hope you remembered to send a card. Not in today's puzzle, but it's only a matter of time.
ReplyDeleteFinally just before I get to put in my 2 cents, egs mentions the obvious. TOENAILNSCISSORS, or clippeRS, do not make the toes smaller. They just make the toenails smaller. Uness there's a good literary reference to Cinderella's evil stepsisters using TOENAILSCISSORS to make the glass slipper fit.
ReplyDeleteThey used axes - quite grisly actuallym
DeleteSo, PUTTEES is a word from the British colonization of India, and actually derives from Hindi, but we’re cluing it to a later military narrative that’s slightly more palatable. Just making sure I’m clear on this.
ReplyDeleteLuke Skywalker wears puttees. Days without a SW reference? 0.
ReplyDeleteWhat a terrific Saturday. I expected no less from this constructor. He's made some of the most fiendishly difficult puzzles I've ever solved. Today's offering came in a little over average time. I was still impressed because the triple stacks culminating with grid spanners are feats of construction that typically sacrifice difficulty. Finding out that all six of them are debuts and that he could still work five more into the grid was an "we are not worthy" moment.
ReplyDeleteWish I could say I finished this one cleanly. My "last" entry was the T of STE. I saved it for last only because I couldn't remember what STE stood for. When I got the "so close" notification I knew I had to look elsewhere for the mistake. It wasn't hard to find. Turns out GENUSANT isn't a word. I just thought that ENT was short for enter. For a split second I thought GENUSAND was a word then the light bulb went off. Shoot me now!
Dear SB, PUTEE is absolutely a word. I've known it since I was a child. It has its own illustration in Webster's. You include PARATHA and PALAPA but not PUTEE? WTF, SMH.
Some good write overs today. I had GRIDLECAKES then WAFFLECAKES and finally WAFFLEMAKER. I also had to deal with ASEAT/ASPOT. In the south HESSE single handedly knocked out CLIPPERS. YESSIR put SCISSORS in.
Read the first clue, wrote in WAFFLEIRON and off to the races. Couple of longer answers like GOODSPELLER and READYTOGO went in right away and my only writeovers were SCISSORS, SPOT, and CERA (which I never get straight). STUPA is classic crosswordese, and by classic I mean ancient. and I even knew PUTTEES , They appear in a classic Bob and Ray spot as a bargain deal when their clothing store is going out of business, if memory serves. Oh, and had RETIREBATTERS before RETIRETHESIDE, but that was fixed by knowing HESSE.
ReplyDeleteIn short, this one made me feel like the smart feller who felt smart. Thanks for that MD, You made My Day.
So much for being smart. I wrote in WAFFLEMAKER, of course. Sheesh.
DeleteSo happy to see Ms. Kael. And, living in SE Asia Stupa and Puttees were both gimmes. On the other hand = Genus? I got And Species but had problems with God No. For a long time I thought No Way - but that didn't work. And I had to juggle El Camino and El Dorado for a bit. All in all, fun.
ReplyDeleteDid I miss a comment, or am I really the first to mention STUPA crossing STUPOR (likely the first time two words starting with "STUP" have intersected in a grid [off the top of my head, the only other STUP- words I can think of are STUPENDOUS and STUPID])? STUPA was a new one for me, but I knew PUTTEES, so I didn't have the hangup in that section most people did.
ReplyDeleteI agree with WS that the ebook device clue was poorly written (I knew what the clue was getting at, but the word "Former" should not be there)! Also agree with Anonymous 8:02—a LINEN CLOSET is a thing, but to say LINEN is included with a rental instead of LINENS is ridiculous! And even though I'm chronologically 58 years old, similar to RodeoToad, when I had FA_T filled in from the crosses, and read the clue for 4D, the first thought that jumped into my head was 'how does farting help prep for surgery'? I got to FAST eventually, but my inner immaturity made it take a few seconds!
Biology nomenclature nerd here. Homo sapiens is only the species name. Yes, homo is the genus, but the specific epithet (sapiens) requires the genus name to be a unique identifier. This makes more sense thinking of trees. Quercus rubrum is red oak, acer rubrum is red maple. Rubrum alone can’t be the species name.
ReplyDeleteMy brain hurts. I read this to my wife and she told me not to do that again.
DeleteI agree. A species name must always be two-part, i.e., "binomial", in order to be a unique identifier. "Homo" is the genus name. "Homo sapiens" is the species name.
DeleteI also agree with Rex that many of the answers in this puzzle were "questionable" and this is a prime example.
Well, I’m terribly impressed, not sure whether it’s with the puzzle or myself but I got ‘er done all on my own today. That’s rare for me on a Saturday. I always print a copy and solve with a pencil but last night I had a major case of feline paralysis when publishing time rolled around. Since I couldn’t disturb the fur baby, I decided to start on my iPad and before I knew it, I was finished. Maybe I should do that more often. In any case, it was a it was a good workout and extremely satisfying. Appreciate the effort and thanks for a very nice Saturday puzzle, Mr. Diehl.
ReplyDeleteIt was really tough to get started. I was looking for something to eat at the breakfast bar, and when neither cole slaw or potato SALAD would fit into my picnic basket I was stuck. I finally decided to try the downs, and got lucky--rAmbleS at 1-D, giving me humanoid SPECIES. -- so I turned to the crosses and ran head on into MEDIAN which just had to be right. Eventually I sorted out that corner. Like Rex, GENUS AND SPECIES seemed odd; if I pointed at an American Robin and asked you what species it was you'd reply "turdus migratorius" not simply migratorius. But people do say it in many contexts, so OK.
ReplyDeleteMISSILE TEST got me into the middle, GRIT seemed likely, and the colorful reptile starting with R had to be a Red something, which made it hard to see FOOL. SPORTS BETS was obvious, though, and gave me STUPOR, PUTTEES, and STUPA. I'm pretty sure the books of P.G. Wodehouse and Agatha Christie are full of retired colonels who spent their careers in India and like to walk around wearing PUTTEES. I've never been too sure what they were, but knew the word well. I knew STUPA from reading about Buddhism, though I've never seen one in the flesh. I realize that's just my particular wheelhouse, though, and can see why others found them tough.
Now came my real difficulty. I misread 39-D as 38-D and put HESSE in the wrong place., leading eventually to Oberon's subject being hAIRY. I figured that must apply to Bottom after he was turned to an ass.
Fortunately I notice the error and put HESSE in the right place, which saved me from clIppeRS. My family did use NAIL SCISSORS when I was young, though eventually we switched over to clippers--I thouht maybe they'd just been invented, but I looked them up, and they've been on the market since 1875, at least. Sue Grafton's detective, Kinsey Millhone, uses a nail scissors to cut her hair. I think my father did have a scissors specifically for toenails -- it had long handles, and the cutting partwas angled to the left, soo you could use it even if you had trouble bending over.
I enjoyed the difficulty, and would give it at least a half-star more than Rex did.
Oh my gosh, that northeast corner. Save me A SEAT, yup. Cause for getting stuck, RUTS. Then the true disaster, EL DORADO . . . it's a car yeah? It's old? Man that took a while to unravel. Fun!
ReplyDeleteI thought crossing “stupor” with “stupa” was cute but lame.
ReplyDeleteGuárdame un asiento.
ReplyDeleteHad to run the vowels at STUPA/PUTTEES, but otherwise it was a pleasant solve. Plenty of gimmes and the longs sorted themselves out straightaway. I had many of the same sticking points as @🦖 but didn't seem to be bothered by most. Quick solve for me. Solidly constructed and joyful.
I liked image searching STUPAS and PUTTEES after the solve.
I wrote in LUTE right off, because LYRES are lame, and I was rewarded. I checked both paintings and knew them both and neither shows the lutenist using typical form. So maybe bad painters or bad players or maybe (probably) I'm being a ridiculous lutenophile. I've ordered from Sweden an 11-string guitar for messing up Baroque lute music and it should arrive sometime this month. I know you'll want to be posted, so stay "tuned." And by the way, a missed cluing cross-reference, it's a FOOL in the Hals painting.
Let's not fight about this today please. WAFFLES are way better than pancakes. And MACARONI SALAD will forever be an also-ran to potato salad or baked beans.
I am under the impression there are many things included in an AirB&B, like the floor, a door, maybe a roof. Good to know LINEN was top of mind on the clue writer's mind.
They make clippers and scissors @🦖. Maybe time to get onboard with the pedicurist revolution. We're old men now and won't be long before we need a foot guy.
I use "That can't possibly be right," all the time. I learned it from a psychotic boss I had in the 90s and it stuck. It turns out most of the time it is right to everyone's disappointment.
Y'ALL is a pronoun everywhere. If you're not using it yet, get going. It'll save you all a lot of time. It's mo'bettah, amirite?
As a student, my goal was to meet girls. The fact they give you a degree after four years of chasing them seems incidental to the process.
This whole puzzle was worth doing just for the GOOD SPELLERS clue.
❤️ NARY.
People: 8
Places: 2
Products: 3
Partials: 2
Foreignisms: 0
--
Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 15 of 62 (24%)
Funny Factor: 4 🙂
Tee-Hee: LESBOS.
Uniclues:
1 What I say as a compliment to Asians regarding their shrine.
2 Another "Right Yer Own, Y'all" Uniclue Opportunity. ©️®️™️
3 Why I'm sleeping next to a stoplight.
4 Cause consternation in Tinkerbell by steamrolling her.
5 Uber request and gracious reply in low-rider land.
6 Weather forecast at the Bear Bar.
1 POSH STUPA Y'ALL (~)
2 OPTIMAL LESBOS
3 MEDIAN STUPOR
4 FRAY FLAT FAIRY
5 EL CAMINO? YES SIR.
6 RAINING DADBODS
My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Inspired by @okanaganer there were epic loops telling two groovy stories. PREDICTABLE CRIME NOVELIST CHANCE ENCOUNTER and ON A REGULAR BASIS DINNER THEATER CAUSES A RIOT.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Nice uniclues today. Audible chortle on #1.
Delete@Gary, as usual you posts brighten my day! My college experience was similar. Maybe it's telling that after four years I was able to scrape up the degree but NOT the girl :o) I tried MUCH harder for the latter...
Delete@Gary J... oh yeah, I remember ON A REGULAR BASIS DINNER THEATER CAUSES A RIOT! That was the best.
DeleteGary…not having previously assigned “lameness” I had L__ES to start. I will NOW remember that “lyres” are lame! ;)
Delete24D "Isn't keeping up" kea loa'd Sags v Lags
ReplyDeleteImagining a very drunk Arnold Schwarzenegger rubbing his temples saying “it’s not a stupa”
ReplyDeleteLike others, I enjoyed the challenge that this one offered. No chance of a start up top, so I headed to the bottom where the DAB, Y'ALL, YES SIR, HESSE, and LESBOS cluster gave me what I needed. On the way back up, I enjoyed STUPOR, ROPE INTO, and learning ROSY BOA. Last in: WAFFLEMAKER x WANDERS.
ReplyDeleteDo-over: rarITY before ODDITY. Luck of the memory junk drawer: STUPA x PUTTEES. Help from previous puzzles: CERA. No idea: SOLANGE.
Yews for a yew is a hedge.
ReplyDeleteHonestly pretty shocked and disappointed Rex didn’t use the “SAVE ME _____” clue as a perfect opportunity to embed the “SAVE ME JEBUS” Simpsons clip.
ReplyDeleteSOLANGE is great, and that song is worth checking out for anyone who didn’t know it. PUTTEES/STUPA was a Natick.
ReplyDeleteJust curious ... do people really have two sets of clippers; one for fingernails and one for toenails? I just have clippers, and use them on all my toes and on my thumbs, and occasionally on the non-thumb fingers.
ReplyDeleteYou are a lucky person Kitshef. 🤣
DeleteDefinitely tricky ….had “a seat” before “a spot”….”Genus and species” is definitely a Familiar phrase… And I got a kick out of the stupa/stupor cross.
ReplyDeleteUp vote on the END key. Super useful.
ReplyDeleteI'm curious to know the number of people that are in the overlapping part of the Venn diagram of "people who know what PUTTEEs are" and "people who know what STUPAs are". Also, saying that I "take issue" with the clue for TOENAILSCISSORS just doesn't cut it (pun intended). Clipping/cutting toenails makes your digits smaller??? Sure, ok.
ReplyDeleteCount me in for the overlapping part of the Venn diagram. I saw many stupas while hiking in Nepal and my Brit husband calls his hiking gaiters puttees. Being a biologist, I was very familiar with genus and species as a standalone and also rosy boas. Altogether a relatively easy Saturday for me.
DeleteI hated this puzzle for many reasons, almost all of which have been eloquently expounded upon by Our Fearless Leader.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I still loathe and completely fail to understand one answer, which left me so stunned I paused for ten to fifteen minutes repeating it over and over again, sure to my marrow that either Will Shortz, Mark Diehl (or even I, myself!) had been struck with a sudden seizure of aphasia. So before I go ask a search engine, I will share with you my incredulous (and as-yet-unanswered) query:
What the bloody flip-flop is RETIRE THE SIDE?!?
When an out is recorded, the batter is said to be retired. When three outs are achieved, the offensive side is retired, and the pitcher who has been trying to retire the side as successful. I'm thinking you're not a big fan of baseball.
DeleteI also found that entry confounding. But I did look it up later. "THE SIDE" refers to the team that was just at bat. The expression apparently comes from cricket, originally.
DeleteBy my Saturday standards, I flew through this, circling the U in the STUPA/PUTTEES crossing, before remembering the leggings from the wonderful Flashman novels. Tripped up by the AND in the Homo Sapiens entry. Oh, well . . . Good fun.
ReplyDeleteI think this is a great example of being on the right wavelength or not. I started st the top but it took me until the southeast that I started getting a toe hold (just as I was starting to feel despondent), and then made my way back around. 16:38 flew by!
ReplyDeleteKnew both Puttee (having taught a WWI course) and Stupa (travel in SE Asia). Didn't know Kael or Solange (Knowles).
I hit the curb with my car and ended up with two flats. I had to RETIRE THE SIDE.
ReplyDeleteI waffled between waffle maker and coffee mates for a bit.
ReplyDeleteHaha! I kept trying to make it “waffle cakes.” We shan’t go there as to why…
DeleteSpent way too much time thinking “pitchers” was some kind of marketing misdirect, those who pitch new products. I don’t watch baseball enough to be familiar with the phrase RETIRE THE SIDE, but as soon as it appeared and pushed my brain into the realm of sports, it all made sense. A much better answer than I had been anticipating for sure!
ReplyDeleteMe too!
DeleteWanted "Save me JESUS" but figured that wouldn't be kosher. Shoulda gone for it since GOD NO was apparently not too blasphemous. (I had NO WAY, which seems like a way better answer "That can't possibly be right" and took out a lot of stuff because of that over-confidence--worked with AINT, for "Not, colloquially" and which was also wrong but felt so good I took out WANDERS.
ReplyDeleteGOD NO, this was not my favorite puzzle.
STUPAxPUTTEES was just rude and lazy. Make a funner puzzle, please!
Medium seems right.The bottom third was pretty whooshy but the top third put up some resistance.
ReplyDeleteMe too for the U in the STUPA/PUTTEES cross being a lucky guess.
I had no idea there’s an END key on my PC.
If you are a “Breaking Bad” fan and haven’t seen the follow-on movie “EL CAMINO” you are in for a treat. It’s on Netflix.
@Conrad - “Decent Saturday themeless. Liked it.” works for me.
Next to the last letter entered: S in SONY READERS (since 30D suggested a plural and SONY had its day as the tech entertainment Alpha dog). Last letter entered: U in PUTTEES, a pick-a-vowel-on-faith entry that happened to be correct.
ReplyDeleteI first wanted my friend to save me Abite, then ASeaT, and finally (thanks to SPECIES) A SPOT
Like many, I wanted NO WAY, not gOdno.
For a seventy-something birthday gift my son gave me a tee shirt announcing, "It's not a DADBOD, it's a father figure."
Hornets beat Clippers word play--loved it! Delightful Rex-ian conclusion to another greater blog post!
Good challenging Saturday, just a nice level of difficulty at 23 minutes.
ReplyDeleteI was stumped by the "Seldom used PC key"... TAB, ALT, ESC, END? I use END all the time... I just used it now to get to the "Post a comment" button at the bottom of the page. Is this another case of the clue writer assuming everyone else shares his opinion, or is it based on some obscure study?
Hands up for ELDORADO before EL CAMINO, and for "Save me --" A SEAT. And for the breakfast item at 1 across I had only the AKE- part at the end and assumed it must be [something]PANCAKES.
And yes Rex, that clue for ACUITY is just nuts.
Wow OK (etc) You almost make me want to read blog on a PC cuz my pop-up keyboard doesn’t have an “end” key. I’m serious…yet too lazy… :D
DeleteIn case it hasn’t yet been said, it’s likely a Buddhist drunk monk would be in a stupa 🤪
ReplyDeleteHoly crap, I found this tough. Rex pretty much nailed everything about it except for the business about TOENAIL SCISSORS, where I suspect he has a wrong picture in mind. If you haven't seen them, they're not like kitchen shears. They're small and the cutting edge is slightly curved and they can be wielded with great accuracy (ACUITY wouldn't quite be the right word, for roughly the same reasons given by Rex) to get the shape you want. I would go so far to say they work better than nail clippers, where there is always a danger of flying keratin shrapnel, as in a Sopranos scene where Ralph laughs at Janice when a piece of his toenail hits her in the face as he's, um, shortening his toes.
ReplyDeleteThe SE fell easily and was by far the easiest section. That's how I knew it was SCISSORS and not "clippers". But I did not know RETIRE THE SIDE (and don't even know what it means, precisely, but I can look that up) and I did not know SONY READER (sigh... Products, esp. bygone products, are the worst of the PPP).
WAFFLE cAKEs are a thing and that's what I had first. The NW region messed with me bad. 14 Across (GENUS AND SPECIES, pfft on the first two words) and 14 Down (GOD NO) were just nasty. The natural thing to put in for 14 Down is "no way", and what Rex said about the entry is correct. ACUITY felt a bit off in the cluing (as also noted by Rex); I had ACUmen before that. Oh, and like many I wanted A SeaT and not A SPOT. Oh, and like @Rick Sacra, I went through "dorado" and "torino" before landing on CAMINO. I mean, GOD, this was a real Murphy's Law puzzle.
NARY is colloquial? Really? I just looked that up now, and it's not wrong, but to me it sounds slightly old-fashioned (it's actually an alteration of "ne'er a", and it's centuries old), and maybe more POSH than most colloquialisms I know of.
FASTS I found quite tricky, but I appreciated the deviousness.
I've done quite a bit of reading on Buddhism and Tibetan Buddhism in particular, but STUPA was strangely long in coming.
ROSY BOA was a complete unknown. I admit I cheated to get ROTH. I very much dislike resorting to that, but I was feeling a bit desperate at that point.
Mark Diehl, I shall remember your name. There was GOOD stuff in there, but as solving experience goes, I was in a STUPOR through most of it.
Lol @tht…maybe Rex and I have “similar” toenails but I have an abundance of keratin on fingers/toes. TMI fer shur, but for my “tonios” I use a clipper that is configured more like scissors but NOT scissors. Even when I was young! Keratin will out for some of us! Even so…I figure you flimsy nailed peeps use what I call “cuticle scissors” so the scissor thing didn’t rock my world. :)
DeleteSuch a satisfying solve for me, I really loved this one. I thought this was proper Saturday difficulty, I really had to work here but what a joy.
ReplyDeleteAt first pass all I had was YALL. But all it took was the "F" in Fray on my second pass to make WAFFLE fall and then Pauline made WAFFLEMAKER a gimme - what a lovely entry. I have to admit I get the spelling of her last name wrong almost every time I'm forced to write it and today was no exception. Kale, Kail, etc... I'm not sure what blocks me here.
Second day in a row that I'm proclaiming that I absolutely loved all the longs. The last to fall was GENUSANDSPECIES - I had no clue even with every letter in except the G - I did not read three words until I came here so that put up a big fight.
First thing I walked away with was, "There is an end key???!!!" Even doing this on an *actual* key board didn't help me. Now looking - yup, there it is, right in the upper right. As the clue indicates, I've never, ever used it.
Unlike @Rex, I enjoyed all the mis-directs in the cluing.
I also did not mind ASPOT, came fairly quickly for me.
Leaned some new things - STUPA and PUTTEES. I thought these little ODDITies were a lot of fun. I also loved ODDITY as an answer to Curio shop treasure.
For me, one of the best Saturdays in a long time. Thank you Mark! I hope we see more soon.
Great post Hugh!
DeleteGotta disagree with you on GENUS AND SPECIES -- it is definitely a thing, as most species when referred to in a scientific context get both parts of the Latin Binomial. If the answer had been LATIN BINOMIAL, well that would have been something, wouldn't it.
ReplyDeleteCertainly, our different responses are related to familiarity -- this was the first answer I landed and was grateful to it for illuminating the top half of the grid.
Where is this mysterious End key? My MacBook doesn't have one.
ReplyDeleteMe too. There must be a multiple key equivalent but I have found no need to track it down.
DeleteNot surprised that a lot of you didn't know PUTTEES. Apparently not many branches of the American military used them after the First World War. I knew of them because, when I was about 12 or 13 years old, my older brother decided (or was forced to by my father, a great fan of "discipline") to join the militia. This being the Canadian Army Militia, they were still teaching kids how to clean and re-assemble defunct rifles and properly wrap PUTTEES, something mon frere seemed incapable of doing.
ReplyDeleteSo, on Parade Days he would dress up in all his regalia and then beg me for help. "I've got some really good weed in the top drawer. You can help yourself." And I would wrap these woolen bands around his lower legs and off he'd go to pretend to be a soldier.
I hated this. I was anti-war, anti-fascist, anti-military industrial complex, anti everything at the time. And here I was, batman to a pretend soldier. But he was my brother. And he owes me. Big time.
Oh, the puzzle ... I thought it was pretty good. Totally agree with @Gary about waffles over pancakes and potato salad over MACARONI SALAD, though it's pretty tasty, too. Our waffle iron is about 70 years old. Yeah, seriously. And it comes out for family holiday breakfasts and does a great job. I like mine with butter and maple syrup. The kids prefer whipped cream and fresh fruit or blackberry compote.
I seldom watch baseball these days but RETIRE THE SIDE was a gimme. And I use clippers while my wife prefers scissors. Vive le difference.
I enjoyed this one - thanks, Mark D!
ReplyDeleteSeeing all the white space was a bit daunting, but it didn’t turn out as tough as it looked. I think I actually enjoyed the weird cluing more because I had prepared myself for a struggle.
Hand up for writing in A SeaT before A SPOT, but my initial reaction was Save me A bite. (Hi, @Tom T!)
Another hand up for being STUPefied by STUPA/PUTTEES. I liked the look of PUTTEES but not STUPA, so I put down my pen and paper and went to the online puzzle for a vowelTEST.
I’m probably among the very few to have been disappointed seeing GOOD SPELLERS, though it has grown on me. I had the G and really wanted GRANDMOTHER as “One of many at a (quilting) bee.”
A few years ago I took note of some of the bloggers who mentioned their birthdays. Happy Belated to @GILL, I if you’re reading, and Happy Birthday today to @Barbara S! Think @chefwen is coming up too, yes?
Here’s a Swedish birthday composer selection, Midvinter, by Wilhelm Stenhammar. It starts out a bit dark but not for long. @Barbara, as a birthday bonus the “video” is a painting by Gustaf Rydberg, "Vinterlandskap med hästfora.”
Yes…thank you Mark. I forgot to say that…
ReplyDeleteI'm even later than usual, gettin to here. Got tied up watchin the "Olympic Curling" events, M&A's fave.
ReplyDeleteAlso, our grand-nephew is currently a diehard Pokemon card collector, so M&A had to make him a customized Pokemon card for his upcoming 12th b-day.
the puz ... a 62-worder with fresher than snot [and fresher than ASPOT] fillins -- with more than sufficient SatPuz feist to yield some extra nanosecond carnage, at our house.
Only two ?-marker clues that I see .. but seemed like a lot more; hidden clue feist abounded.
staff weeject pick [of a mere 6 choices]: CHA.
some fave stuff: GENUSANDSPECIES & its clue. RAINING clue. The album-mount puzgrid corners. YALL. STUPA/STUPOR [apt description of the resultin STUPA/PUTTEES cross's effect -- but, when in doubt ... (yo, @Roo)]. READYTOGO.
Thanx for the challenge, Mr. Diehl dude. Good to see yah again.
Masked & Anonymo3Us
Hey, at least no Star Wars!
ReplyDeleteI was surprised to see STUPA right next to STUPOR. (Isn't STUPA just STUPOR with a Brooklyn accent?)
ReplyDeleteI very much wanted ROSY BOA to be RAIN BOA. A little disappointed.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if AL GORE has been asked to give his Nobel Peace Prize to a certain someone?
ReplyDelete3D "Preps for surgery, perhaps" had me thinking about what a surgeon does prior to an operation. Oh, it's what the one being cut on does, not the one doing the cutting. You switch your regular DIET to a FAST.
Neither FAST nor DIET are up to the task of filling their slots. POC (plural of co0nvenience) to the rescue. Both get a letter count boost by sharing a final S. See also WANDER/ON, LAG/SPORTS BET, and DAD BOD/SONY READER. Those four Ss are the equivalents of cheater squares. Each could be changed to a black square and nothing of interest or value would be lost. The grid now would have a virtual black square count of 38, quite a bit higher than the average of 31.0 for Saturday puzzles (per xwordinfo.com).