Thursday, July 17, 2025

Elvis Costello hit featured in "Notting Hill" / THU 7-17-25 / Search engine giant based in China / Pioneering puzzle-laden game / Characters in "There Will Be Blood" / Region known for its silk and tea / Words often appearing after a number and a hyphen

Constructor: Sam Brody

Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium


THEME: MATRYOSHKA DOLLS (7D: Compact wooden figures ... and a hint to 5-, 11-, 22- and 25-Down) — clues for the theme answers resemble MATRYOSHKA DOLLS (also known as "nesting dolls"); theme answers are familiar phrases that you assemble using three nested clues/answers:

Theme answers:
  • CULINARY ARTS (5D: (Stops (false (not any) witness) filming)) [NARY inside LIAR inside CUTS]
  • DOMAIN NAMES (11D: (Bucks' (lady's (roadside stopover) title) mates)) [INN inside MAAM inside DOES]
  • TIME MACHINES (22D: (Baseball (German (physicist Ernst) possessive) rarities)) [MACH inside EIN inside TIES]
  • PEER REVIEWS (25D: (Church (Buffalo's (minister, informally) waters) seats)) [REV inside ERIE inside PEWS]
Word of the Day: "SHE" (38A: Elvis Costello hit featured in "Notting Hill") —

"She" is a song written by Charles Aznavour and Herbert Kretzmer and released as a single sung by Aznavour in 1974. The song was written in English as a theme tune for the British TV series Seven Faces of Woman.

Aznavour also recorded it in FrenchGermanItalian and Spanish, under the titles "Tous les visages de l'amour" (English: All the Faces of Love), "Sie" (English: She) "Lei" (English: She) and "Es" (English: [She] is), respectively. He also recorded the song in a more uptempo French version with different lyrics, simply titled "Elle" (English: She).

The song peaked at number 1 on the UK Singles Chart and stayed there for four weeks; it was certified silver for shipments exceeding 300,000 units. It also reached number 1 in the Irish Charts, spending one week at the top. It was less popular outside the UK (where Seven Faces of Woman did not air); in France, the song narrowly missed the top 40, and in the United States, it failed to chart on the Billboard Hot 100 and charted on the lower end of the easy listening charts.

Elvis Costello recorded a cover version of the song in 1999. This version, produced by Trevor Jones, was featured over the opening and final sequences of the film Notting Hill and charted throughout Europe. (wikipedia) (my emph.)

[peaked at 19 in the UK ... all those "dashes" are countries (incl. the US) where it didn't chart at all]

• • •

The hardest part of this puzzle was spelling MATRYOSHKA. In my head, the word sounds like "matruschka" (ma-TROO-shka), so the middle of the grid was something of an adventure, but otherwise, this theme presented almost no problems. It was clear right away, with the first themer I encountered (5D), what was going on. I had the "C-L" part, could see that the outer answer was going to be CUTS, put the "TS" at the end, and then used a couple more crosses to put the whole thing together. After that, I never looked at a "nesting" clue beyond the outer layer. That is, I'd get the front end from crosses, I'd read the clue, I'd put the back end in from there, and then, with whatever crosses I had in place, I'd just eyeball it and write in a word. I like to get a bunch of crosses in place before I ever look at a longer clue, generally, and today, that worked well. The beginning and end of the answer, plus whatever I had in the middle from crosses, just gave me the answer easily. The concept here is clever, but for me, the fun was over fast, and the revealer was exceedingly anticlimactic. I could see they were nesting—that was obvious from the clues themselves. MATRYOSHKA DOLLS is the appropriate metaphor, but as a solver, it felt redundant. It "revealed" nothing. Gave me a "hint" to nothing. It was explaining something to me that I could already see clearly. So the puzzle didn't have the zing it might. And like I said, I didn't even need the "inner" clues of the themers.  Execution seems well done (no idea how hard it is to find answers that break into nestable parts like this). The perfect symmetry on the nested answers is impressive, and it extends to the cluing (theme clues are all composed of two-word clues, where one word is in the front half of the clue and the other in the back half). So it's architecturally interesting, but a bit of a dud to solve. Anti-climactic, for sure.


But back to the middle of the grid—the spelling of MATRYOSHKA. I need to take issue with one of the crosses, specifically, with "SHE," specifically with "SHE" as clued (38A: Elvis Costello hit featured in "Notting Hill"). If you have never heard of this "hit," you are forgiven. I forgot it existed, and I have seen Elvis Costello in concert ... [counts on fingers ... runs out of fingers on one hand ...] seven? Yeah, seven times, I think. 1. St Paul; 2. Ommegang Brewery (near Cooperstown, NY); 3. Turning Stone Casino (the worst; central NY); 4. Bethel Woods (NY); 5. Ithaca; 6. Syracuse; 7. Ann Arbor ... yep, seven. I own countless EC records. So when I say I could not hum "SHE" for you right now if you paid me, perhaps you'll have some idea of how much "SHE" is not a "hit." OK, I'm listening to it right now, and it's definitely familiar, so he has probably played it at least once in concert, but ... "hit???" Elvis Costello has had precisely two (2) top-forty "hits" in this country in his entire (nearly 50-year) career: "Everyday I Write the Book" (#36, 1983) and "Veronica" (#19, 1989). He has a bunch of songs that feel like hits ("Alison" "(What's So Funny 'Bout) Peace, Love and Understanding" etc.), but never actually were, by measurable standards (he made a big point about this on stage during the Syracuse concert). I think "SHE" has a lot of plays on Spotify, maybe? 1.5 million "views" on YouTube for the video (below). I guess that's something. But no, it is not a "hit" and never was. Maybe the least "hit" of any song that has ever been described as a "hit" by the NYTXW. I know of precisely one song called "SHE," and that's the beautiful Gram Parsons song, which I first heard in a cover by Chrissie Hynde (featuring Emmylou Harris). But the Elvis Costello "SHE"? No idea. Just a head-shakingly strange clue. 


I have never heard of BAIDU, but I'm guessing a lot of Chinese people have? (14A: Search engine giant based in China). Not my idea of a great answer (more ****ing tech names to memorize), but I guess if you're desperate, why not use it? On the other hand ... look how easy it is to do that corner up in more familiar (and utterly techless) fashion:


If you think the BAIDU version is better, that's fine, but we have Very different tastes. Aside from BAIDU, and "SHE" (as clued), there wasn't much that caused trouble today. I knew Jamie TARTT, but I imagine most non-"Lasso" watchers would have no idea what that character's name is, so if that eastern area of the puzzle was a challenge, I understand (36D: Jamie ___, "Ted Lasso" character). Looks like the crosses are pretty fair on TARTT, though, and nothing else in the puzzle (beyond what I've already mentioned) seems terribly taxing.


Bullets:
  • 23A: Subject of evaluation by a college panel, informally (APP) — I had "AP-" and still managed to get this answer wrong at first (I thought it was APS, as in "AP tests")
  • 30A: Characters in "There Will Be Blood" (OILMEN) — the OIL part was easy, but I wrote in ... OILERS (that's more of a hockey team)
  • 65A: Pioneering puzzle-laden game (MYST) — a game I never played, but one I know well because it is four letters long and has unusual "Y" placement and so shows up in crossword grids from time to time.
  • 23D: Region known for its silk and tea (ASSAM) — it's ASSAM Week here at the NYTXW! (see yesterday's puzzle). Crosswordese from way back. Sometimes you gotta refresh people's memory of the oldies. How else are newer solvers gonna learn? ASSAM was huge in the '70s (with a peak of nine (9) appearances in 1973). After falling out of favor in the late aughts / early '10s (only four (4) appearances total between '05 and '10), ASSAM appears to be making something of a comeback (five (5) appearances just last year).
  • 35D: Words often appearing after a number and a hyphen (IN-ONE) — the hardest clue for me to wrap my head around today. Words ... following a number ... what? But I guess people say "two-in-one" or "three-in-one" to describe ... things that have multiple purposes? The phrase ALL-IN-ONE is way (way) more familiar to me.
  • 46D: Withdraw one's testimony (RECANT) — I love this word. Why??? It's so ordinary. But it was the last thing I wrote in in the SW and I had this feeling of "oh, that's nice. That makes the corner nice." I don't always understand my emotional responses to words, and I certainly don't understand this one, but I'm smitten with RECANT today, who can say why? Shall I withdraw this testimony? Shall I RECANT? I shan't. Shall I compare thee to a summer's day? Maybe. Thou art probably pretty sweaty, if you live in the NE like I do. 

See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook]
=============================
❤️ Support this blog ❤️: 
  • Venmo (@MichaelDavidSharp)]
=============================
✏️ Upcoming Crossword Tournaments ✏️
=============================
📘 My other blog 📘:

66 comments:

  1. Anonymous6:33 AM

    I love learning new words. Today it was FILIAL

    ReplyDelete
  2. Bob Mills6:40 AM

    Another complicated theme whereby the answers bear no relationship to the clues (yuch!). Needed one cheat, to get TARTT. Glad it's over; looking forward to Friday.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous6:45 AM

    At first I thought it was like The Atlantic’s “Bracket City” game.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Andy Freude6:55 AM

    I’m always impressed by Rex’s ability to rewrite corners of the grid, and today is no exception. His revision to avoid BAIDU (a complete WOE for me, how about you?) would have been a big improvement, even with another brand name, IKEA, in there. That one I’ve heard of.

    Lately I’ve been enjoying the Bracket City puzzles at the Atlantic, which are similar to these MATRYuSHKA clues (yeah, I made the same mistake). There, the nested clues are the whole point. Here I just solved around them a la Rex.

    Still, a darn good puzzle for a Thursday.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Stuart7:00 AM

    My new word was BAIDU. A degree of difficulty up from OFL’s suggestion of HAIKU. (Maybe that’s why the constructor used it?)

    I gronked the gimmick immediately, and as someone who studied Russian and Russian history in college, the spelling of “matryoshka” was not a problem. In fact, I have a set of those dolls on my bookcase.

    Incidentally, this construction is identical to the “Bracket City” puzzle. I recommend it to all the word geeks out there.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The theme was easy enough to discern, but really wasn’t worth the effort - not much fun trying to keep track of all of those nested parenthetical phrases. The reveal didn’t reveal as much as it affirmed. I wasn’t even interested enough to google the proper spelling of MATRYOSHKA, so I relied on the crosses and hoped for the best.

    It may have been more interesting if the four longer (complete) theme answers like CULINARY ARTS had some relationship to one another and/or the reveal actually tied them together. However, this puzzle is much like the doll kits themselves - once you open them up and understand the little aha gimmick, they are more decorative than useful.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anonymous7:11 AM

    Did not enjoy the today’s “gimmick”. It was a bit too cutesy and , to me, unnecessarily confusing.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I don't think the theme really works (or rather, the revealer is inapt - the inner dolls/words need to be smaller than than the outer ones), but I did appreciate the challenge today.

    Strangely, growing up we called those dolls 'Chinese nesting dolls', even though we knew they were from Russia. I assume there was some reason for this; but no currently-alive family member knows what it is.

    TARTT may as well have been unclued. That one section, with TARTT plus weird clues for IN-ONE and ARMOR was a bit unpleasant in an otherwise fun solve.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous7:20 AM

    Just to be a (reverse) naysayer - I liked the themers!

    ReplyDelete


  10. When I see clues like the long downs today, I just move on and solve as if there is no theme. My mind shuts down when seeing the answers clued as (the inside (inside) the inside). I know that Rex will explain in his write up and I just don't care. That being said, most of the answer came pretty easily except the spelling of matryoshka. I know Baidu from ? and it's been so long that "airdry" was not a gimme. "

    ReplyDelete
  11. MATRYOSuKADOLLS and SuE looked totally reasonable. Just sayin'.

    ReplyDelete
  12. MATRYOSHKA DOLLS were part of Tinker,Tailor, Soldier, Spy's imagery.

    https://origaminightlamp.blogspot.com/2014/07/matryoshka-dolls-and-tinker-tailor.html

    ReplyDelete

  13. Easy, ignoring the theme clues. But fun to de-nest them post-solve.

    Overwrites:
    elite before ATTIC for the top tier at 1A
    My 15A fish was mAhi before it was HAKE

    WOEs:
    For the second time in recent weeks I had to look up the spelling of MATRYOSHKA (7D)
    At 12D, I didn't remember AKIRA Kurosawa
    SHE as clued (38A)

    ReplyDelete
  14. Among the worst times I’ve had on a Thursday, both in minutes and enjoyment.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Seems I'm not in the majority here but I quite liked the theme. I thought the word stacks were very impressive.

    Why is REN always either REN (& Stimpy), (Kylo) REN from Star Wars or (MC) Ren of the rap group NWA? What about something like this for a change, Q: Missing from many a child. A: REN
    Too corny, I get it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:38 AM

      Not too corny. Quite clever.

      Delete
    2. I think I've also seen "___ Faire."

      Delete
  16. Anonymous8:51 AM

    This puzzle theme makes zero sense. 100% not enjoyable . I’m looking at Rex’s reveals and still don’t get it. Baseball? Huh?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous11:04 AM

      TIMEMACHINES
      >
      TIES
      MEIN
      MACH
      >
      (TI)[me]{MACH}[in](ES)

      It’s still an awful conceit and very likely shamelessly lifted from The Atlantic’s Bracket City game, though.

      Delete
  17. Anonymous9:01 AM

    Thanks for the shout out to Return of the Grievous Angel - I’ve listened to it hundreds of times.

    ReplyDelete
  18. MissScarlet9:03 AM

    If you enjoyed Nottinghill and Ted Lasso, ‘she’ and ‘Tartt’ were easy give-away.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Those were by far the easiest clues in the puzzle, well maybe FIDO was close.

      Delete
    2. SHE was my first entry. Notting Hill, boom!

      Delete
    3. ChrisS3:04 PM

      Like Rex I am a big Elvis Costello fan (only saw him 3 times) and have never heard the song She, except when I watched the movie 25 years ago. Ted Lasso is/was a good show, earlier seasons were better. Nothing Hill was an OK movie.

      Delete
  19. Hey All !
    Well, phooey. Had the Elvis song as SUE, with the DOLLS as MATRYOSuKA. Trying to get an extra U in for @M&A.

    Always thought it was MAX Ernst. What's the deal with MAC?

    Picking up for @Lewis, the West-Center and Center -South are chock full of Doubles. APP-ASSAM-SEESAW-STEER-ARRAY-PEERREVIEWS-ERRATA.
    ACCENT-ASS-FOSSIL-ASSET-DOLLS.
    Plus a few more, I SEE, ISSUE, TARTT, ATTIC.

    Different type puz. Can never remember the name of those DOLLS. The Themers at least follow the same pattern of being split two letters at a time.

    Welp, have a great Thursday!

    Two F's
    RooMonster
    DarrinV

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @RooMonster: Max Ernst: Painter - not in the puzzle. Ernst MACH: Scientist - he's the one on the puzzle. The Mach 1 speed of sound guy.

      Delete
    2. @kitshef
      Ah! Missed the H. But thanks for the different ERNSTes! (Apparently never knew MACH's first name [or it fell into the Great Brain Void {more than likely}]). 😁

      RooMonster Brain Void Guy

      Delete
  20. Easy; found the theme answers to be so clear from crosses that I didn't even bother thinking much about the conceit, which has been a sad pattern for recent Thursdays. Would be nice to have harder knots to untie than we've been getting recently.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Dreadful. The gimmick ran away with the whole thing.

    ReplyDelete
  22. The least amount of crossword fun I’ve had in a long TIME. Even after reading two different explanations/justifications, my brain does not fully comprehend the appeal of such a convoluted theme. I’m sure there will be plenty of others who loved it and will be raving about how easy it was. Bless their hearts.

    If I had seen the themer clues written out in a straight line like they are in RP’s explanation, I believe I would’ve figured it out. But with them being stacked in a column the way they are in the puzzle printout, I did not clearly see where the divisions fell. Instead of three hints, one inside the other, it looked like five consecutive hints which was how I tried to parse it, which of course got me nowhere. And it never once occurred to me to try writing the clue out in a horizontal line. Anyway, I just didn’t get it and as a result, had more frustration than fun.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I solved this one in better than my usual Thursday time without a clue to how the big downs worked. Once I realized the were fairy normal words I just worked out the crosses.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Perhaps i’m too new to puzzling (not sure if that is a word or not) but I thought it was fun. Jamie Tartt and She were possibly the easiest of clues, along with FIDO and Moana

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:39 AM

      Toby, I really enjoyed it too, and I’m surprised at the comments. But…the opposite happens with me also…people will love a puzzle and I’ll not enjoy it so much. I’d crack it up to you being new to the blog rather than the puzzle. Everyone has their own feelings and sometimes everyone matches up and other times you find yourself liking a puzzle most people strongly dislike.

      Delete
  25. Alice Pollard9:45 AM

    A slog, I tell ya. A slog!

    ReplyDelete
  26. To parse or not to parse? I say let's not.

    These are the sorts of convoluted clues that cryptic puzzle solvers wrestle with all the time. You might well wonder why. For me, while the nesting trick was clear enough from the clues -- even before seeing the revealer -- the solutions to the various nestings were completely unclear before they came in from crosses. I don't mean before they came in part of the way. I mean before they came in enough to solve by way of word pattern recognition.

    I didn't do much parsing after the fact either. Too much work -- and I already had the answer.

    I found this choppy and not all that much fun to solve, if the truth be told. YMMV.

    ReplyDelete
  27. I really liked it. Lotsa fun constructing the themers from the three nested clues. It must be a new gimmick, Rex would have said when it appeared before.

    We've seen Notting Hill several times but didn't notice the music.

    Complainers gotta complain. Extremely intricate theme but that's not enough. The constructed themers should be tied together.


    ReplyDelete
  28. Anonymous10:06 AM

    Thus puzzle gets an A+++ for cleverness, ingenuity, originality, symmetry…all in a standard 15 x 15 grid!

    ReplyDelete
  29. Outside of the total WOES BAIDU, TARTT, MYST, SHE as clued, and trouble spelling MATRYOSHKA and AKIRA, and struggling to untangle the words-within-the-words, this was delightful, except for the "delightful" part. Not on
    SB's wavelength at all, and even things like RIVETS and TIARA as clued took way too many nanoseconds to see. One of those days. I'm blaming the heat and humidity. The Granite State feels more like Swamp City these days, and the only highlight has been watching the granddaughter dive off the diving board, which will have to do.

    Ingenious construction, SB, and I'm glad some folks caught on so fast. Quite a workout, but it Sure Beats trying to do anything outdoors. Thanks for some thorny fun.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Anonymous10:18 AM

    Excel “x-sell” might be a new low in the Times’ many, many crimes against homonyms.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Russiannestingdolls didn't fit. Babushkadolls was too short, but babushkadollies wasn't. Really? What's the other name? MATRYOSHKADOLLS. No idea how i dusted that off. Thought the nesting was kind of neat, especially how the outer and next level answers were all 4 letters split in half. And enjoyed seeing what those long downs ulitmately became. Took more of a stumble in the NW than I needed to, going through Alist, ATeam, and letDRY, but the rest of this Thursday was pretty zippy.

    ReplyDelete
  32. BAIDU has been in the news a fair bit, as a competitor to all the US tech giants (Google, Amazon, etc.). Didn't occur to me immediately, but after a cross or two, no prob.

    For 23D (Region known for its silk and tea), my first thought was CHINA, followed immediately by "wait, no, could be JAPAN." So I wrote in both (as rebuses, something I do in a situation with two obvious possibilities and no crosses yet, had same thing at 40D with ORC/ENT). No joy with crosses on CHINA/JAPAN until I saw SEESAW and STEER, and finally saw ASSAM.

    The biggest slowdown, actually, was when I first saw the theme clues and thought for a (very brief) moment "oh, this looks like LISP programming, maybe this is gong to be one for old-school programmers of my generation." But I quickly figured "no way, far more likely something with nesting dolls… RUSSIAN DOLLS won't fit, have to remember the real name for the thing."

    Never heard SHE, (don't even really know much Costello), but two crosses were easy, leaving an obvious guess for the first letter. TARTT was the bigger problem (why can't this ever be clued as "author of The Goldfinch"?? -- American TV serials of the last three decades leave me absolutely cold; alas, this is a distinct hindrance with NYTXW.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Anonymous10:44 AM

    The Monkees' "She" is the only song of that name I'm familiar with.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Not 'complaining' @mathgent - just saying - too convoluted for me. Luckily I solved as a themeless & came here for the theme although BAIDU, MYST were WOES & didn't we just see TARTT (or was that somewhere else?)

    ReplyDelete
  35. Anonymous10:52 AM

    And what was with ‘cite’ and ‘et al’?
    Cite is short for citation? Not French for city?
    Seems lame

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, the ET AL replaces the names of authors who are "out of" the citation. Convoluted.

      Delete
  36. Anonymous11:02 AM

    I fell victim to the deception at 1-A, feeling smug that I checked the cross at 1-D and put in "A-list" rather than "elite." This led me to reject the otherwise obvious TIC and IDEA, and at first 4-D was no help. But MATRYOSHKA DOLLS

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This was me, inadvertently clicking send too soon, and not signed in.

      Delete
  37. Anonymous11:03 AM

    For Spelling Bee aficionados: Sam Ezersky missed CYCLICALITY today.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. But he seems to love ANAL as it appears so often LOL

      Delete
  38. Oops, I just inadvertently posted an incomplete message when I was not signed in. Basically, I had elite and then A-list before I finally got ATTIC. I considered A-list to be so obvious that I rejected both TIC and IDEA - but then I saw the MATRYOSHKA DOLLS, which couldn't be anything else, and the game was on. 4-D had to be CU-------TS, and the rest filled itself in. Even without the revealer, all those nested parentheses would probably have done the trick. And oonce I had the U I did remember BAIDU. Then the only hard part was noticing that the clue for 10-D was calling for a French answer.

    Second day in a row for ASSAM, welcome back, old friend!

    ReplyDelete
  39. Starting in the NE with EDAM, and, without having looked at the reveal clue, I enjoyed working out the nesting of INN within MAAM and DOES; then, moving left, ditto for placing MACH inside MEIN and TIES. But after writing in the reveal (which didn't really reveal anything at that point), I have to admit that the fun of working out the nesting began to pall: I got CULINARY ARTS and PEER REVIEWS mainly from pattern recognition, needing the nesting idea only to get the outer brackets and not bothering to analyze the innards. Fine theme phrases! But maybe too bad that it wasn't necessary to understand how the theme worked in order to get them.

    Help from previous puzzles: OILMEN, how to spell MATRYOSHKA. Help from reading the news: BAIDU. No idea: SHE, TARTT.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Medium, but if I had realized earlier that the nested clues were real things I might have finished faster. I really tried to avoid parsing the nested clues while solving because it looked liked way too much effort.

    I too did not know BAIDU.

    Very clever with very little junk, liked it.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Anonymous11:22 AM

    Surprised that no one objected to ‘gel’ as the answer for ‘come together’. Gel means to set or firm up, ‘come together’ describes a mixing, but not setting or gelling.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I’m cool with a secondary (or perhaps tertiary) definition of GEL implying that something or someone is beginning to come together and function as a unit - sort of like “the starting five has taken some time finding their footing, but lately have been starting to gel as a unit”. Similarly, “come together” has multiple meanings as well, one of which would be consistent with the example I cited.

      Delete
  42. Too complicated and not fun.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Anonymous11:35 AM

    Yep, hand up for really liking this theme and it was fun for me to figure out and proper place the answers for the “nested” parenthetical clues. There were a lot of answers I didn’t know but hung in there for “the win.” I will NEVER remember the actual name or spelling of the Russian nesting DOLLS but that’s okay if crosses are fair.
    I have watched Ted Lasso and liked it but then got tired of it so I didn’t remember Jamie Tartt as a name (I remember the character). I wonder if more puzzle solvers would know Donna TARTT the author of The Secret History and The Goldfinch. Hmmm. Maybe not.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Themers that are long words clued as a bunch of nested short words. Different. Like.
    But also kinda different was the BAIDU-esque revealer, which was a total no-know, at our house. And I'd already sussed out the themers, without needin a revealer. Themers were lotsa fun and pretty e-z to suss out, btw.

    staff weeject pick: AIM. I nested in AM.

    a few faves: TIMEMACHINES. ETAL clue [the sole ?-marker clue in a ThursPuz?!].
    Nothin over 6 long, other than themers, which made the solvequest pretty e-z overall. Biggest challenge was that there hello-weird-dolly revealer.

    Thanx, Mr. Brody dude. GOJOBOD.

    Masked & Anonymo2Us

    ... look! up in the menu! it's a chicken! it's a general! no! it's ...

    "Supperman" - 7x7 themed runt puzzle:

    **gruntz**

    M&A


    ReplyDelete
  45. Anonymous11:39 AM

    Got it, but didn’t know TARTT, which made it a little harder. I was familiar with the word MATRYOSHKA.

    ReplyDelete
  46. LorrieJJ11:46 AM

    Didn't know "Tartt" so had "nib" and "Bartt" ... had to reveal to get the puzzle accepted ... Rats!

    ReplyDelete
  47. Solved but I still don't know what the funk the gimmick is and so solved using crosses only for an average time. A little too obscurantist for this dummy when the tricky bit doesn't play into the solve. Fine as a theme less with four major unclued downs and a revealer that was not revealing since it was one of the last fill-ins for me and I don't know wtf the word means. Nesting dolls, gotcha. Is that Russian? Why not just do a bunch of clues in Russian? Also French, since apparently using non-English words is how you get out of a jam as a puzzle constructor. Despite these gripes it was fine as a themeless for me.

    ReplyDelete
  48. M and Also1:00 PM

    p.s.
    Primo weeject stacks, in NW & SE, btw .. except, see below…

    @RP: Dude. If y’all are gonna rebuild us a BAIDU-less corner, U gotta add more U’s:

    Across.
    1. Caesar dressing?
    14. “___ Like It” (Shakespeare play about adding U’s)
    17. Vessel that’s a bonehead, if you alter letter #2
    Down.
    1. Univ. assts.
    2. Trojans reign here.
    3. Sch. on the other coast from 2-Down
    4. Kansas county seat that’s a state, if you alter letter #3

    M&Also

    ReplyDelete
  49. Well, I can’t say that this was very enjoyable. Not really my cup of Assam. I prefer witty wordplay and deceptive clueing to cut-and-paste letterplay that essentially establishes a set of instructions to be followed.

    Oh well, on to Friday.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Solved basically as a themeless, because the theme clues were too baffling to worry about. Then I hit the revealer, which I knew except wasn't sure where that Y fit in; my first guess was MATROYSHKA. Then I got the theme idea but decided to ignore it and just do the crosses. Figured out the "dolls" after finishing, but as many have said, it wasn't much fun. Decent idea that didn't really GEL.

    ReplyDelete
  51. I was kind of hoping that the gimmick answers somehow tied together or were related to their respective component nested clues. Without that, it just felt like extra work with no payoff.

    ReplyDelete
  52. I'm in the liked it camp although I agree with Rex that after the pattern emerged in the first themer, the other three were early week easy to fill in.

    22D (physicist Ernst) MACH is best known for his speed of sound work but was also pivotal in the mid-19th century development of psychophysics, the study of the relationship between physical stimuli and their psychological perception. He's the eponymous discoverer of MACH Bands.

    I do have one ISSUE with the theme, a NIT really, but PEER REVIEW, CULINARY ART, TIME MACHINE and DOMAIN NAME are all one letter short of their respective slots. There is, of course, an easy, convenient short cut to deal with that problem; POC to the rescue!

    ReplyDelete