Sunday, June 8, 2025

Break, slangily / SUN 6-8-25 / Beefy, as gym bros / Tall, chic woman / Hardy mountain plants / Lesser deities in Greek mythology / Spider-Man's lightning-wielding foe / Literally, "panting," in Greek / Wedding toast signals / Subject of the Liberi painting "The Birth of Love" / Some narrative homages, informally / Last-one-standing fights / Smallest discrete units of energy / Colorful feature of a lawn

Constructor: John Kugelman

Relative difficulty: Medium


THEME: "Meeting Their Match" — a puzzle depicting ANIMAL MAGNETISM (108A: Powerful force of attraction on display in this puzzle?). The idea is that two vaguely related Down answers are paired together, and their tail ends are drawn toward each other at ninety-degree angles by horseshoe magnets (depicted in the grid)—these tail ends contain the names of animals ... so the magnets draw the animals toward one another ... thus, ANIMAL MAGNETISM:

Theme answers:
  • ABS OF STEEL / ACTION STAR (EEL & RAT are magnetized) (1D: What Jason Momoa has, notably / 9D: Jason Statham or Sylvester Stallone)
  • CONGREGANT / HOUSE OF GOD (ANT & DOG are magnetized) (10D: Churchgoer / 18D: Church)
  • GREEN GRASS / PERIWINKLE (ASS & ELK are magnetized) (54D: Colorful feature of a lawn / 58D: Ground cover plant with trailing vines and five-petaled flowers)
  • NOODLE BOWL / EGG FOO YUNG (OWL & GNU are magnetized) (60D: Japanese restaurant order / 64D: Chinese restaurant order)
Word of the Day: BORK (19A: Break, slangily) —
    • verb US, politics, often pejorative To defeat a judicial nomination through a concerted attack on the nominee's character, background and philosophy.
    • verb To misconfigure, especially a computer or other complex device.
    • verb To break or damage.
    From the 1987 United States Supreme Court nomination of Robert Bork.
     (wordnik)
• • •

Gonna make this short because I have nothing nice to say. I rarely say that I outright "hated" a puzzle, but this one ... let's just say I was having real trouble finding joy. I'm still stuck on BORK. What? Also, why? I have never heard this term outside of the rejected Reagan Supreme Court nominee. And neither had the puzzle, before today. You've got two [Jurist Robert] clues back in the '90s, then a very weird (if inventive) Muppets clue from 2021: [When tripled, catchphrase of the Muppets' Swedish Chef]. And now ... this. I left the BORK / SORBATE cross blank for the whole puzzle because I just ... couldn't believe BORK could be an answer. I knew that BORK was turned into a verb meaning (roughly) "to attack a nominee" or "to thwart a nomination"—when nominations get tanked by organized campaigns and attacks, you sometimes hear that a nominee "got borked" (named after the aforementioned "jurist"). But this "break" meaning? No idea. And the clue gives no context. Apparently there's a secondary meaning of "bork" meaning "to cause to stop working; break," that seems to come specifically, or at least primarily, from the world of computers. If the clue had said so, at least I'd've known it was some specialized term I'd never heard of, and I could've acceded to BORK (ugh) more easily and moved on. But no. Looks like it didn't exist before 2003, so I may just be too old for it (my wife also had never heard of it). You could lose BORK in that corner so easily. Change it to BORN, and cross it with [Carry-ONS], so much simpler and more accessible, and above all, less distracting. Or go with ASTA / ANS. (short for "answer") if that's more to your liking. Just for god's sake get rid of BORK. If the theme is putting huge pressure on your grid already (and it is), you really should make things smooth and clean wherever you can. If the rest of the puzzle had worked, I doubt I'd be so annoyed at BORK, but it's emblematic of the rest of the puzzle, which is loaded with ... puzzling decisions. Why would you choose BORK? In an already weak corner (SRAS, OBI, ASTO, SORBATE)? So much unappealing fill today, including (apparent) Across answers that are total nonsense (TEEL, DOGF, ELKN, etc.). And then DO A JIG? GLAMAZON??? It's ick everywhere I look. OLESTRA is always an "ew." ZIP TIES just make me think of all the I.C.E. raids happening around the country right now. Grim and off-putting stuff everywhere. 


And the theme is so strange. Like, I get the "animal" part, but why are the magnetized answers paired? And in extremely weak ways??? Why is a Japanese meal paired with a Chinese meal??? Those are ... different cuisines. GREEN GRASS and PERIWINKLE are both ground cover, I guess, but ... why? Seriously, the rationale is lost on me (also, what other color would grass be??). The themer pairs are vaguely from the same universe, but they are not that tight at all. And they have nothing at all to do with the animals involved in the "magnetism," so ... conceptually, this seems like a wreck. Further, how (how!) in the world do you have a magnet that is literally attached to "STEEL" but then have it be Entirely Irrelevant To The Theme?! Bizarre. 


Is BATTLE ROYALES a themer? It looks like it wants to be a themer, or an explainer, since it's a long, centered Across answer (just like the revealer), but I think it's just regular old non-thematic fill (66A: Last-one-standing fights). I really want the actual plural to be BATTLES ROYALE, like Surgeons General. STRATO!? DAEMONS??? The fill all feels so tortured. I see why the "animal" part of this theme might be appealing, but the fact that the animals appear in nonsense fragments (RASS!), and the fact that the pairing of theme answers makes little sense, and the fact that the fill is so wobbly, all adds up to a deeply unpleasant experience. I'm just gonna go straight to bullet points now. Gah, TINGS!?!? (28A: Wedding toast signals). Dear lord, what is happening? TINGS?! Only the second appearance of TINGS since 1976.  We went forty years (!!) without TINGS (1976-2016). Those were good times. I knew 2016 was a terrible year, but I didn't realize how terrible. Let's shoot for another forty TINGS-less years! I believe in you, constructors of America! OK, seriously, moving on now.


Bullet points:
  • 1D: What Jason Momoa has, notably (ABS OF STEEL) — no, he doesn't have them, notably. He has chiseled abs, sure, but ABS OF STEEL, as a phrase, is a trademark exercise program from the '90s starring Tamilee Webb. Looks like it's now also some kind of fat-burning cream for your abs (!?!?). Just weird to take something brand-specific and use it like it's a generic term for "good abs."
[if apostrophes could kill...]
  • 26A: It's a cinch! (OBI) — I wanted TIE. Had trouble committing to TRAINEE for a bit because of that terminal "I." But an OBI is indeed a "cinch," in that it's a sash that you "cinch" around your kimono.
  • 32A: Some narrative homages, informally (FANFIC) — tough, insofar as the plural-seeming clue does not give you a countable plural answer ending in "S."
  • 57A: Hardy mountain plants (ALPINES) — had no idea "alpine" was anything but an adjective referring to "mountains."
  • 83A: Beefy, as gym bros (SWOLE) — ah, see, now here's some recentish "slang" that I actually know. SWOLE bros have ABS OF STEEL! Real SWOLE bros don't BORK the gym equipment. Up with SWOLE, down with BORK!
  • 99A: One-named pop star with releases on the Monkey Puzzle record label (SIA) — is that record label bit supposed to mean anything to anyone? You could've stopped this clue after [One-named pop star]. She's not ENYA-level common, as one-named crossword pop stars go, but she's up there.
  • 84D: Subject of the Liberi painting "The Birth of Love" (EROS) — don't know this painting, never heard of this artist (who has never been in the crossword, despite having a name that seems very grid-friendly). But I got EROS easily enough—inferred from "Love."
  • 121A: Smallest discrete units of energy (QUANTA) — been fourteen years since we've seen this bad boy. I idiotically (hastily, rashly, not-very-thinkingly) wrote in QUARKS here at first.
  • 14D: Literally, "panting," in Greek (ASTHMA) — did not know that. Also, misread this as [Literally "painting," in Greek]. 
  • 27D: "My man" ("SIR") — wanted "BRO," but no. Then wanted "'SUP!," but no. The seemingly formal "SIR" has, in fact, made its way round to a kind of facetiously formal informal acknowledgment akin to "my man," but you really need to hear it in context for the equivalency to be clear. On the page, not so clear.
OK, that's all. See you next time.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld

P.S. if you're looking for some fun, original, contemporary puzzles *and* you want to support US-based transgender charities (who need the support more than ever), then Good News! A new puzzle pack just dropped called "A Trans Person Made Your Puzzle"—ten puzzles of varying difficulties and sizes, all made by trans and nonbinary people, including some of the most talented, prolific, and experienced constructors I know (Francis Heaney! Ada Nicolle!). I've already started in on the pack and the puzzles are delightful. They are also, frankly, chock full o' stuff—LGBTQ-specific stuff, pop cultural stuff—that is new to me. But since the puzzles are really well made and edited, I can still solve them! Fresh, non-exclusionary puzzles! That's what I like. To get the puzzles, all you gotta do is donate at least $10 to a US-based trans charity listed on the puzzle pack's website, send your receipt to the puzzlemakers, and then they send you the puzzles. I got mine quickly—the same day. They've already plowed right through their initial fundraising goals (>$12,000 as of 6/4) and are now setting stretch goals. To read more about the project, and to get the puzzles for yourself, go here: "A Trans Person Made Your Puzzle." 

[Follow Rex Parker on BlueSky and Facebook]

150 comments:

  1. I agree with Rex in general about the puzzle (I found it forced and awkward) and in particular about BATTLE ROYALES (battles royale is the only acceptable plural).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous1:43 PM

      sadly "we" are losing that grammar battle royale. i've heard educated folks say mother-in-laws, attorney-generals, etc. it is becoming more acceptable.

      Delete
    2. @anon and @Alex in re losing the grammar battle and BATTLEs Royale. A while ago, I went all the way off on this issue in a post. Couldn’t agree more. Makes me happy not to be alone.

      Delete
    3. I’m irritated because I posted early today and my comments never made it. So here I am again agreeing that we’ve lost the battle of using proper grammar. I went all the way off on this issue a while ago. So I will join your reply and remind folks that its the noun of a noun-verb combo that gets to be plural. Battles royale, mothers-in-law, attorneys- general. Grammar is important to clear, meaningful communication. As I said in my earlier rant, that’s the hill where I plant my flag and upon which I shall die.

      Delete
    4. Anonymous10:38 PM

      There is a video game genre of “Battle Royale” (where a lobby of players compete to the last man/team standing). Collectively the genre could be called battle royales. See Fortnite, Apex Legends, PubG.

      I don’t really play “battle royales” I prefer turn based games.”

      Delete
  2. Anonymous5:57 AM

    I went to read xwordinfo this morning because I was so mad about this puzzle. The constructor said there “ Some puzzles are a dream. Others fight tooth and nail not to exist.”

    Dude, don’t fight it that hard.

    He talks about the computer programming he had to do to figure out what could work in the puzzle as paired themers. This feels like a real Jurassic Park "Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn't stop to think if they should” situation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I always read the comments before I attempt a Sunday puzzle because of the size of the grid (no, I don't consider this cheating, just don't want to lose my streak).
      My question is - if the constructor had to "research computer programming to figure out what could work in the puzzle as paired themers,"
      why should we?

      Delete
    2. Anonymous10:55 AM

      I was thinking last night that if we have Naticks for ungettable crosses, we should call crosswords like this Malcolms. Just because you can make a grid like this, it doesn’t mean you should.

      Delete
  3. The second part of the SIA clue didn't help me at all in solving it, but was an interesting fact to learn (especially when I dived down the rabbit hole and looked for where the name could have come from). I don't mind that sort of brief educational moment when solving crosswords.

    ReplyDelete

  4. Easy-Medium. Easy, once I got the "trick." I never did see the "animal" part. Liked it almost as much as @Rex did. Many of my overwrites and WOEs duplicate OFL's.

    Overwrites:
    bro before SIR for "my man" at 27D
    REp before REB for the Hebrew honorific at 49D
    prep before ELEM for the kind of sch. at 92D

    WOEs:
    CELIA Cruz at 10A
    BORK as slang for break at 19A
    ALPINE as a plant (57A)
    Singer SISQO at 107D
    STU Holden at 117D

    Me at 28A: "Please don't be TINGS ... Please don't be TINGS ... Please don't be TINGS ... D'oh!"
    I really wanted BATTLEs royale at 66A but the crosses wouldn't allow it.
    I had some trouble with 96A because I misread the clue as "Something that often changes color before it fails"

    @Rex: "what other color would grass be??" Kentucky bluegrass?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous11:20 AM

      Brown during a drought, also crunchy, looking forward to this summer, not!

      Delete
    2. ChrisS6:45 PM

      Not my fav puzz, some good more bad. In the Caribbean a delicious grapefruit soda called Ting is sold. So cluing tings in reference to these would have been fine and not the terrible clue used. If you add a shot of rum to Ting the drink is called "Ting With a Sting"

      Delete
  5. The big guy nailed it today. I like the idea of the trick but the implementation was so awkward and the resulting Sunday-sized fill was brutal. Rex highlights that NW corner and he’s spot on - ABS OF STEEL, SORBATE, FANFIC are just bad.

    MESH

    The 3s and 4s strewn all over the grid don’t help matters. LAS, MAAS, AVA-ANA the list goes on and on. I do like ARF and SEX I guess. PERIWINKLE and QUANTA are the winners.

    Congratulations to the wonderful Coco for her FRENCH OPEN win.

    Burrito Brothers

    This was rough.

    Robin Trower

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In case I'm not mad enough at the NYT front page for already doing this to me today, along comes Son Volt with his very own SPOILER and no alert to warn me. (Read my comment below, please.) Please remember: some of us pre-record sports event to avoid commercials and some of us never catch up!!!!!!! A little discretion next time, please. Thanks so much,

      Delete
    2. Hahahaha jeez Son Volt, you better be more careful in the future when you post about sports. How would you feel if you learned who won the Super Bowl before you were personally ready? Or what about Olympics medals? You really ought to be more considerate of the non-zero number of people on the planet who record live sporting events to watch them later, and especially the subset of those people who do things like read the news before they get around to playing back the tape.

      Delete
    3. Anonymous7:53 AM

      @Nancy I thought coming to an article about how the author solved a crossword puzzle with commenters also describing their puzzle-splving experience, then complaining about getting spoiled on said puzzle, was the most obnoxious thing I had ever seen... until I realized you were also complaining about the newspaper spoiling news. You have major issues to work on.

      Delete
  6. I had to warmly smile when I saw NOODLE in the grid, placed there by a man named Kugelman. Noodle kugel was a dish my grandmother – who I fiercely loved – made, one of my favorite childhood foods. The taste, aroma, and the feel of being around my grandmother all evoked by this tiny piece of the puzzle – priceless.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @Lewia: My Gran made a killer noodle kugel too!

      Delete
  7. Two items:
    1) In addition to its meaning in politics, "to bork" has a more generic meaning. From fastslang.com, "To 'bork' something means to mess it up or make it worse."
    2) Shouldn't the plural of battle royale be battles royale?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @Ralph A Cole; 2a) And the plural of maitre d' should be maitres d'.

      Delete
    2. Anonymous9:33 PM

      FWIW ( not sure if your joking or not)
      Maitre-d is not French
      The relevant French term maitre d’hôtel was incorporated into British English when estate owners hired French chefs and the like. Eventually, it was shortened, and in the US used in restaurants. The online dictionaries of course add the s at the end, as they should as it is an American expression.
      Battle is not French either It was anglicized centuries ago, taken from the French word, bataille.
      and pronounced very differently.
      It is not therefore a French expression but an English one, so people naturally follow English rules. Nothing wrong with that.

      Delete
  8. Anonymous6:59 AM

    I was surprised to see the paper refer to Momoa's "ASS OF STEEL" but just rolled with it. Eventually I figured out what was happening, but "SORK" made no less sense to me than "BORK."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hehe, I too had to swap that S for B to get happy music.

      Delete
  9. Points:
    • Magnets! I don’t ever remember seeing images of magnets in a grid. It’s hard to come up with something new to Crosslandia, and here it is. Furthermore, these magnets are not just for show; they perform two important functions. They draw the animals in, and they attract related theme phrases together (Asian foods, action film actors, ground cover, and church-related).
    • John’s notes in XwordInfo detail how much work went into making this, which took him about a year, involving solidifying the theme concept, coding, culling close to 4,000 phrases, grid design, and making it all work (which was very thorny). All this for a puzzle that will probably have but one day in the sun. Strong evidence to me that John is an artist, crafting something beautiful for beauty’s sake, something he hopes others will enjoy.

    Well, this was a thing of beauty to me with its intricate theme so comfortably nested the box. And I sure as heck enjoyed conquering the hills it presented, cracking its riddles, and the discoveries that emerged from it.

    This was a jewel, John. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous11:34 AM

      Thank you X 10! Did not see the relationship drawing the magnets together, perhaps if they had been turned "toward" each other.

      Delete
  10. Anonymous7:20 AM

    Puzzle was no fun. I’m a daily player for years and this is the first one I’ve just hated. DOGF? RASS? They’re supposed to make sense outside of the theme.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Rex may never have heard it before, but BORK is fairly common slang in the computing industry. Maybe we're just better at borking things than college English professors? :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maybe BORK is also geographical becaise my husbamd was a computer

      Delete
    2. @Walt: Maybe BORK is geographical computer slang because my husband, a 40+ year computer programmer, cut his teeth during the final years of ILIAC I, spent 5 years with ILIAC II and over 35 years creating small computer systems and industry specific software (lots of it educational) never heard the term. It could also be a fairly new slang term since he passed in 2018. I only knew BORK from the (thankfully) failed nominee to the US Supreme Court. Lots of slang from that nomination. Lots of ways to “BORK” or something to be BORKed” during that mercifully brief period.

      Delete
  12. Coprophagist7:22 AM

    This has to be the worst puzzle in months. I'm amazed Rex didn't call out the outlier among the themes – Noodle Bowl – as the only one where the four letters at the end is a complete word from the answer, as opposed to nonsense like Gnuy or Dogf.

    Also, will someone please enlighten me on the silly rabbit clue at 6D? Don't understand that at all.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous7:42 AM

      Trix cereal commercial: silly rabbit Trix are for kids.

      Delete
    2. Anonymous7:51 AM

      It is the slogan for Trix cereal. ‘Trix are for kids’ and the old tv commercials had a rabbit trying to sneak a bite of them.

      Delete
    3. Anonymous11:22 AM

      The slogan was introduced in 1959. Perhaps it predates you buy a couple of generations or so!

      Delete
  13. Anonymous7:28 AM

    Rex said everything I was thinking while doing this puzzle. What a hash the author has made with the fill, and those themers do not work together at all.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Anonymous7:31 AM

    I killed my streak today. After 10 minutes , I simply decided there were much better things to do. Really horrible puzzle.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous4:57 PM

      I didn’t bother to finish either. Like another poster, I kept finding myself thinking ‘don’t be that, don’t be that’.

      Obi is a sash
      Momoa? ABS OF STEEL? No
      Homages? Don't be FANFIC.
      High tail it? Don’t be LAM!

      Just gave up. Not worth my time - which says a lot. The puzzle is my weekly treat…. 😡

      Delete
  15. Anonymous7:31 AM

    Sigh. Not only is the theme forced, TOO MANY pop culture clues and proper names.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Quite possibly the worst crossword I have ever seen.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Rex nails it. The battle royales alone filled me with such incredulous disdain I almost quit solving. So many ugly little clues, obscurities, and then the magnetized gibberish. A puzzle that displays all the pain of its construction.

    ReplyDelete
  18. This was absolute torture. Saw the “STEEL” trick and thought the theme would involve things that are magnetic being pulled toward the magnets. Unfortunately, that turned out not to be the case and I never did figure out what the theme was trying to do. So basically a grid full of gibberish and garbage fill like SISQO, MAB and OPE, which makes for a long day.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Oh, I missed that the downs on the themers were loosely related, and I thought the animals were all just magnetized to the bottom of those down answers — I didn’t realize the animals were being drawn to each other. Not sure if getting that right would have made the puzzle more interesting for me. Lots of stuff here was totally out of my wheelhouse.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Andy Freude8:15 AM

    DNF. There’s a typo in there somewhere, but I’ll be damned if I track it down. Not worth the bother. Can’t believe I didn’t bail on this one when the urge hit, about a third of the way in. I’m thinking of skipping Sundays altogether.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I swore off Sundays for a number of years, Andy. Just too much real estate to cover and if it isn't really good it's just wearisome. But a few months ago I came back. Now I'm regretting that decision.

      Delete
  21. Anonymous8:22 AM

    Solved the master clue in seconds. Enjoyed the puzzle in certain parts. But on the whole found that it tried too hard to be clever. Thanks anyway for making Sunday morning a little more interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  22. This took a year to produce??! Truly awful (offal). The worst part for me was that most of the themers can't stand on their own, they are just gibberish. TEEL? GNUY? He managed with BOWL and RATS. He should have taken an extra year to work out the rest of them. Final minor point, I will always hate the use of the word "lam" as a verb. Chalk that up to Shortz.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Anonymous8:48 AM

    Gregory Hines has been dead for more than 20 years. And he wasn’t exactly a household name. Odd cluing today for sure.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous1:57 PM

      Wanted Andre, from "My Dinner With...

      Delete
    2. Anonymous10:01 AM

      And to leave out that he was a dancer felt very strange!

      Delete
  24. Anonymous8:50 AM

    Thank you Rex once again for making a horrid slog of a puzzle into a good laugh out loud write up. Really the only reason I finished this one was to get to the good part, whatever you had to say about it. And you did not disappoint. Hilarious. And I will buy those puzzles, thank you for all the recs about great ones. Yesterday the LA times was a Rafael/Rebecca masterpiece that I loved. (6/7).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:15 AM

      Yes! A masterpiece. And great fun !
      Everyone check it out for a palate cleanser after today’s.

      Delete
  25. Sometimes John Kugelman brings intense pleasure and sometimes he inflicts great suffering and this seems to be one of the suffering days. I'm about a third of the way down, without having figured out the trick, and already having cheated on BORK, and knowing that ACTION HERO won't go either backwards or forwards, so maybe it's ACTION RATS -- and I'm perfectly miserable and thinking: "Why am I doing this to myself?"

    All those names don't help. And so I'm stopping.

    Look. Here's my situation. I'm (I think, but I'm not sure) six days and 71 hours behind on watching the FRENCH OPEN which I recorded ahead of time. I just found out, six matches (I think) ahead of schedule who won the Women's Final because it was on the bleeping Front Page of the NYT. I haven't read the Sports Section in a week -- but this was unavoidable. But can I watch any matches today -- either in order or skipping ahead? Well, the weather's pretty nice right now, so I don't want to sit home watching the tube.

    The bottom line? I simply don't have three hours to burn working on this bear of a puzzle. And I didn't even mention that the Tony Awards are on tonight. I taped that too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:30 AM

      Heaven forbid the front page of a newspaper present you with news…

      Delete
    2. Anonymous12:12 PM

      It's nice to see a Black women's accomplishment considered Front Page News!

      Delete
    3. Anonymous1:05 PM

      How long should a newspaper wait for you before it publishes?

      Delete
    4. I've had that happen. Nancy. Out to dinner with my wife while I'm recording a playoff hockey game, I meet a friend in the restaurant and he spills the score. I roll my eyes and sigh and go home and watch the game anyway. Sure, I know the outcome but I also want to see how the game was played. Which players made great passes, whose goalie was better, was the power play a factor? And more. I saw a few clips of the tennis match you are talking about. Looked like a fantastic contest. I know you love tennis, so I respectfully suggest you watch it anyway to see *how* the game was won and lost.

      Delete
    5. I was probably better off back in the day when TV could only be watched live. A tennis match was like a train: if you missed it because of beautiful weather and the chance to play tennis yourself, well then you missed it. But once pre-recording became possible, I never looked back. No need to ever again watch a commercial during a changeover -- and for those of you who watch tennis on TV, you know how unbearably many ads there are.

      So I spend a fair amount of time making sure to record every single match that will be played. There is no way I'll be able to watch all of them or even most of them -- but I have no way of knowing ahead of time what I'll want to see.

      Knowing the result of the women's final means that I also know the results of all the other women's matches leading up to it. So today -- after first spending three hours in the park because I won't give up the outdoors on a beautiful day to watch TV, I opted to watch today's men's final out of all my choices. While I want to watch the woman's final and possibly both semis and also both men's semis too, this was the ONLY match that hadn't been spoiled for me. I just watched two long sets and, with the handwriting now on the wall, may not go back to the match at all. Or at least I'll fast-forward to the latter part of the 3rd set and see what's happening.

      No way I can watch any other match today -- my tennis-watching stamina has never been that great -- but, @Les, I definitely will go back and watch the women's final. Because I don't know the score and I don't know the number of sets, I will probably be able to churn up some suspense within myself if I try hard enough.

      Don't judge me so harshly, people. Pre-recording tennis matches in order to avoid commercials and then not always getting around to ever watching them is epidemic among tennis players. If I had a nickel for every time someone at the Central Park tennis courts had said to the people around them with their fingers in their ears: "Don't tell me!!!!! Don't tell me!!!!! I'm taping the match!!!!!"

      Delete
    6. ChrisS7:01 PM

      Nancy, I also record 99% of the sports I watch. I can watch a 4 hour football broadcast in an hour with way less aggravation. But I realize the occasional spoiler happens and live with it. Don't give up the men's final it's a great match.

      Delete
  26. Like OFL, I finished in the BORK corner as it took me forever to see ABSOFSTEEL going around the corner, and I've heard BORK in terms of sabotaging a nominee but not elsewhere. Actually saw the right angle turn at HOUSEOFGOD, but promptly forgot it when I put in EGGROLL and never went back to fix it, still suffering from silent paper syndrome. , so technical DNF. Oh shucks.

    Everything else I filled in correctly and I went back to find the ANIMALS as ANIMALMAGNETISM was obvious. There they were on either side of the magnets, three letters each, and that was that which made me think, that's it? Really?

    TIL GLAMAZON and sort of remembered SISQO, so there's that.

    And we have the requisite ROO, although singular. Hope someone is not disappointed.

    My favorite Sunday ever, JK. Ha ha, Just Kidding. There were some moments but not that many. Thanks for some intermittent fun.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Hey All !
    Back from vacay, I did do the puz, the Mini, Wordle, Connections, and SB on my phone, but didn't have much time for reading comments or posting. I'm sure you missed me! (Oh, was he gone?)

    Interesting puz today, in case ya missed it, all the ANIMALs are three letters, with the Fourth letter as part of the Down. Hance why some aren't actual words. (Although I do like GNUY!)

    I missed that the Themer MAGNETISM were related to the connecting magnets, as pointed out by Rex. Interesting extra layer. Example: the CONGREGANT/HOUSEOFGOD pair, both relating to Church. It happens.

    Had a two letter miss, but in the spirit of keeping my Streak alive (69 Days!), I checked Rex's completed puz and found my errors. Technical DNF, but if you don't tell the computer, neither will I. Had CONGREsANT and DAEcONS/LAc.

    Hope y'all are doing great, and have an Awesome Sunday!

    @pablo, now I'm starting to feel guilty! 😁

    Nine F's - SWOLE of F's!
    RooMonster
    DarrinV

    ReplyDelete
  28. Anonymous9:30 AM

    Disagree with Rex on abs of steel. I think that's just a common phrase. But the puzzle was a slog. I had animal magnetism early on but that didn't help much. Took me a full hour to finish which is a lot longer than usual.
    But I certainly don't share the disdain of others for this one. Cluing seemed... Fine? Some of the long answers were fun (though I do understand the Battles Royale vs. Battle Royals conumdrum). Fill no worse than a typical Sunday.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Anonymous9:33 AM

    The Jargon File (a.k.a The New Hacker’s Dictionary) contains the work “borken”, defined as “Common deliberate typo for `broken'”. From there we get the verb “to bork”.

    ReplyDelete
  30. I shared Rex's general dislike of the puzzle, but with nowhere near the same level of intensity and with a different ordering on the list of worst offenders. BATTLEROYALES wounded my soul a bit, and I hated ALPINES. Right up there with the random letters inelegantly appened to the animal names in the magnet clues. Also, I was not a fan of the cluing for DAEMONS, which as I the word in Greek is something like "tutelary divinity."

    As for BORK, though, it's a word I am fairly certain I learned in my early teens playing online games on the text-only pre-web internet (telnet). So, probably circa 1993--it was something the coders would say about a feature of the game: "it's borked." Somehow, I absorbed the term and it has become a cherished piece of my vocabulary as a very useful way of dropping the F-bomb without dropping the F-bomb. (see also, "F-ed/effed" but that has the disadvantage of not working well in writing). I suggest you give it a try.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Jacke9:39 AM

    The trend of referring to a prepared dish that happens to come in a bowl as "a bowl", which tells you nothing about the actual contents of the dish and generally can be plated, is already among my pet peeves. Throwing a generic NOODLE BOWL up against an actual Chinese dish is ghastly. Do the editors know that Chinese chefs also serve noodles in bowls? Not to mention... basically everyone else.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes! I had this exact thought.

      Delete
  32. Anonymous9:40 AM

    Also, REB is not a Hebrew honorific. It’s a Yiddish one.

    ReplyDelete
  33. While we’re cataloging this puzzle’s many sins, let’s note that EGG FOO YUNG is an actual dish you can order, while “NOODLE BOWL” without any particulars is basically getting you a blank (but polite, if the server is actually Japanese) stare.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Niallhost9:44 AM

    I agree with the critiques and yet was proud of myself for finishing in average time given the obvious challenges and strange cluing. I was confused as to why RATS was a full animal answer and the other theme answers had an extra letter attached. I got past this when I realized the answer couldn't be PERIWIsKLE (ELKs) - so surrendered to the fact that it wasn't ideal and odd-looking and moved on with my life.

    SORBATE was enough for me to get BORK. I would have had no idea otherwise. Another Shortz curveball that didn't happen when he was gone.

    Shocked to finish without a mistake, which neutralized the annoyance. 32:10

    ReplyDelete
  35. OldCarFudd9:52 AM

    If you align magnets that way, won't they repel each other? If so, maybe that's why so many of us find this puzzle repellent.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Being an IT guy I wasn't thrown by bork at all. Or anything else in this puzzle, really. It may not have been the most fun I've ever had but I've certainly had other puzzles leave me feeling worse than this

    ReplyDelete
  37. Definitely I might say "the microwave is borken" [intentional misspelling of broken] and hence "I bork it" [past tense]. I'm less happy with "I'm going to go bork the microwave. Oh, looks like I already borked it." That just sounds wrong to my ear, but maybe it is indeed standard usage. A different commentator mentioned that BORK is from the computer world, which makes sense to me: it is a slang I learned, and never used often, when I was living in Silicon Valley in the aughts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:37 AM

      I vividly remember my grandmother telling me on her deathbed there’s no way that Bork could be a Supreme Court justice. “after all his name sounds like a fart in the bathtub.“ I thought that was hilarious.

      Delete
  38. Who gave this billion dollar gift to fight aids? It might have been either Bill or Melinda, but surely it was AGATES.

    What did Mary say as she left with her baby sheep? "Well, I've gotta LAM."

    When I was little, I had a pet ant named Greg. Until my vicious mother used him as an ingredient in a Tex-Mex soup: Chile CONGREGANT.

    I wish they'd clued 7D REX as [He probably won't like this puzzle].

    The French don't say "no". They're NONUSERs.

    I admire the puzzle without being able to say it was a super fun solve. Thanks, John Kugelman.



    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous9:42 PM

      @eggs - These are hilarious!

      Delete
  39. Anonymous10:22 AM

    Sometimes the only motivation to finish a puzzle is knowing that Rex’s write-up is going to be absolutely brutal and wanting to be fully informed when reading it

    ReplyDelete
  40. Anonymous10:27 AM

    I think the simplest critique i have is that if you are going to use something make believe, like Animal magnetism, there should be some indication other than ACTUAL magnets. How one even lands on this theme is beyond me, but the editing did it no favors.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Anonymous10:30 AM

    why do I even bother?

    ReplyDelete
  42. No joy today, yes, I'm with Rex. Mostly because of the NW. BORK and the other weird clues up there broke me. I finally Googled Potassium S and got the SORBATE. Then, OBI was obvi (sorry @Nancy, :-) ) and I was able to fill in the rest.

    I solved with my usual randomizing platform, ignoring the warning that it would cause problems for me. I did see the NYT's version, with its magnets so I figured out where the turns should go but totally ignored the animals part of it, though I noticed DOG and GNU.

    My appreciation with the puzzle went up a tiny notch when I noticed that the magnetized entries have vaguely related meanings, which is nice.

    ZIP TIES aren't necessarily single-use. Some of them, you can get a screwdriver in to push down the little tab that keeps them closed and then pull the end out of the slot. I've done it.

    Thanks, John Kugelman. And thanks, @Lewis, for noting the NOODLE tie-in.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Anonymous10:40 AM

    We had a few good Sundays but apparently we're back to the S-O-S.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Were the elbow letters in the themers completely unchecked?

    ReplyDelete
  45. Anonymous10:54 AM

    Noodle bowl? Now that’s a serious streeeeeetch.

    ReplyDelete
  46. I’m glad I’m not alone here. I hated this puzzle

    ReplyDelete
  47. Worst Sunday - or any day - ever. If I wasn't such a glutton for punishment & have my priorities screwed up (re: streak) I'd of quit mid-puzzle. A frustrating waste of my time :(

    ReplyDelete
  48. Funny, I use BORK all the time. My 21yo daughter does too.

    I didn't love the puzzle but I didn't hate it nearly as much as you did.

    OLESTRA - does that even still exist?

    I did get hung up on SISQO / QUANTA.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous11:47 AM

      Had 125A been clued "choose" not to go along I might have opted for opt out and seen "mash up" but noooo....

      Delete
  49. AnonymousSteve11:25 AM

    I wasn't too crazy about the theme, but the rest of the puzzle wasn't too terrible. And at least it didn't take too long to finish.

    I don't get Rex's objection to GLAMAZON.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Mostly easy-medium except for the SE corner which was the last to fall. SISQO was not a WOE but it took some crosses to recognize him because the clue was no help. QUANTA was a WOE which remembering SISQO helped me get. STU was also a WOE.

    The center also gave me some trouble around the PERIWINKLE clue. Costly erasure in the center - oNt before IND.

    I’m with @Rex on this one. I thought I was going to have to go back and fix BORK until I got the happy music.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Anonymous11:31 AM

    Why not animals with FOUR LETTERS? Kind of a cop out with only three and than some random additional fourth. Solved it, but a poor construction.

    ReplyDelete
  52. Absolutely agree about BATTLE ROYALES. That's not how the plural of noun-plus-post-adjective is formed.

    I actually had filled in BATTLES ROYALE, thinking it a wild hunch (I only finally got around to reading the whole of Ellison's Invisible Man earlier this year, but remembered reading the Battle Royale chapter when I was in Jr High). But then had some crosses in the second half that didn't work, so erased the whole thing, only to then have crosses in the first half that *did* work, and had to fill the rest back in while gritting my teeth over the plural.

    Attorneys General
    Courts Martial

    oh, and: Gins and Tonic.

    ReplyDelete
  53. Anonymous11:38 AM

    Glad to know it wasn't just me.

    ReplyDelete
  54. Me upon reading the reveal clue: "Well, it's some kind of MAGNETISM, but it can't be ANIMAL because the pairings don't include animals." But okay, fine, I'll go back and look again. And then the AHA: an EEL magnetically attracted to RAT. And so forth...including a correction of NOODLE sOup to get me an OWL.

    Otherwise....I think I"m in a tiny minority here - I had fun solving this one - no slog factor for me AT ALL. After ABS OF STEEL + ACTION HERO, I enjoyed trying to anticipate what the other pairs might be. Engaging all the way for me, a treat of a Sunday.

    ReplyDelete
  55. I will give this one an UPVOTE because of the enjoyable theme, but there was a bit too much junk fill like MAB, OPE, SISQO, OBI, INST, ASL etc. etc…

    ReplyDelete
  56. OFFAL. Worst Sunday I can ever remember, and there's a lot of recent competition for that prize. I continue to fail at understanding why WS publishes this junk.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous1:26 PM

      I asked two people in my family what Momoa has notably and they both said Beard. Then tattoos then muscles. But never that nonsense

      Delete
  57. Anonymous12:01 PM

    I almost threw up when I saw this puzzle even before I got to the point of seeing any of the clues. It was immediately clear that this is just another WS-pleasing game posing as a crossword puzzle.
    I was going to OPT OUT, but went ahead and finished it off without pleasure. Glad to see that I'm not alone.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Good write-up; I entirely agree. Got stuck in a few places and called it at an hour. The themers were all, I thought, pretty easy. I'm ok not getting SISQO or being stuck on JOSH instead of MESH, but as a former physical chemist I can't forgive myself for not getting QUANTA. That just hurt. Thanks for the info about the trans puzzles; looks like fun and I just sent in my request.

    ReplyDelete
  59. Anonymous12:05 PM

    This is a uniquely dreadful puzzle. Made for a strikingly unfun solving experience.

    ReplyDelete
  60. Steve Mallam12:09 PM

    I’ve heard of “Bork” and am in my 50s (but I do work in computers) and “Quantum” was a gimme, but I agree on all the others - horrible fill and the theme just didn’t work

    ReplyDelete
  61. Anonymous12:30 PM

    Imagine my disappointment when GAZINGBALL turned out to be GREENGRASS.

    ReplyDelete
  62. Anonymous12:32 PM

    The puzzle would have been better if the two themers joined by the magnet were also opposites of some type to each other - as in opposites attract.

    ReplyDelete
  63. sharonAK12:51 PM

    I agree with Rex's objection to "Bork" and the lack of sense in the theme. I could see no reason for the animals that were paired by the magnets. I enjoyed some o the puzzle but I seemed to be "not on the wave length " for such of it.

    ReplyDelete
  64. Anonymous1:00 PM

    Anonymous at 10:30. Smiled at your comment. But since sports results are NOT front page worthy news, I'm with Nancy, tho for a different reason.

    ReplyDelete
  65. agreed Rex abysmal cluing easy puzzle painful to put it mildly

    ReplyDelete
  66. I rarely enjoy a Sunday very much as they just seem to be a slog, and this was, but I didn't dislike it as much as most commenters. I took a screen shot of the NYT web page, so saw the magnets and that definitely helped. I liked a few answers, like FIX IT IN POST.

    My first typeover for "It's a cinch" was BOW. Then TIE.

    ReplyDelete
  67. the extra letter on same line as each animal clue alone disqualifies this abysmal puzzle

    ReplyDelete
  68. What REX said never got the animals but got the trick

    ReplyDelete
  69. Anonymous1:44 PM

    the theme animals make no sense. none of the pairs would be battling each other...would they?

    ReplyDelete
  70. I agree with ac....JUST AWFUL!

    ReplyDelete
  71. Hard beyond belief. Kinda cute puztheme, tho.

    staff weeject pick [of a mere 38 choices + menagerie of 8 weeject animals.]: LEO. Nice, vague numeric clue.

    Luved the E/W puzgrid symmetry and that it was a pangrammer puz.

    Thanx, Mr. Kugelman dude.

    Masked & Anonymo6Us

    ... M&A will see this NYT corner-turnin' theme, and raise it several extra turns ...

    "Keep Them Doggies Rollin'" - 7x7 12 min. themed runt puzzle:

    **gruntz**

    M&A

    ReplyDelete
  72. Gotta agree with @Rex and a boatload of commenters today. Pretty dismal.

    Highlights for me were a few nice clues for short answers: “Belle boy?” For BEAU at 25A and “Kids’ cries” for 100A MAAS What can I say? I’m a goat farmer.

    I sort of understand Rex’s objection to ZIPTIES but I employ them frequently (never on human beings). Instead I make temporary repairs to wire fences, hang feed boxes to those fences, tie up coils of rope and cable, etc. Loved the “Single-use binders” clue because it misdirected me toward office supplies but I have to point out that reusable ties are available.

    ReplyDelete
  73. Anonymous2:40 PM

    Rats is legitimate which makes the others really stand out. Did not like this puzzle

    ReplyDelete
  74. The most important thing I wanted to say today was to check out A Trans Person Made Your Puzzle. I was certain @Rex would mention it, but a dear friend sent it to me just yesterday. What fun!! Certainly way better than today’s NYT.

    I’m a “real” Sunday puzzle lover. Clever, dense theme, but no grid art and please make the theme work. This one just doesn’t. Period. The “animal” parts have extra letters, and the magnet thing just does not work. To me, this was a great idea for a theme reveal with theme material and theme answers that were not cohesive.

    And once again, i need my puzzle to be solvable in black and white print. Period.

    I’m going back to my cool puzzle pack now because it’s very fun. You will be happy “A Trans Person Made Your Puzzle.”

    Peace, love and puzzles❣️

    ReplyDelete
  75. Anonymous3:18 PM

    - "Battle Royales" is what people say in the video game community of people who play Fortnite and other battle royales.
    - Not a fan of the unchecked right-angle turning squares. I had GREENGLASS which was a plausible enough answer to bork the whole puzzle

    ReplyDelete
  76. Anonymous3:23 PM

    What a pile of merde. Sheesh! I want my hour back.

    ReplyDelete
  77. Anonymous3:23 PM

    The only good thing about this puzzle was your sharing about the trans puzzle pack. On my way to donate.

    ReplyDelete
  78. do l.a. times today Sunday instead its fun no b.s.

    ReplyDelete
  79. Tienes que estar bromeando.

    To no one's surprise, I'm going to be an outlier again. I had a great time with this puzzle. I had to look up BORK of course, because that's dumb. I suppose if you're in the computer industry it might mean something, but it's about as cool as WOAH was from Twitter.

    I had so much fun with the words going around the corner. I thought lots of the mid-length fill was a delight. The animals sticking together makes no sense, but the revealer tried to make something of it. Took me a typical Sunday length time and having the notion that most Sundays will be a slog anyway this came as no surprise and so I enjoyed the journey. A 43% gunk rating on a Sunday should be embarrassing to somebody. Took me half an hour to count 'em all up.

    The first corner word I ran into was EGGFOO-something and I was about to freak on EGGFOOS (plural) cuz you know they do that stuff to us sometimes, but when I figured out it just turned the corner I was delighted. My favorite was HOUSE OF DOG, er, GOD.

    As for Jason Momoa's abs, I don't know if they're made out of steel or if they're made out of pure manliness, but if I ever have the opportunity just to rub my fingers over his belly, I'm going to do it. He's so SWOLE. I will report back on my findings.

    FIX IT IN POST would be a phrase we would probably not teach a new English learner, eh? GO BANANAS is another Level 2 phrase. Where does one go to meet a GLAMAZON? I'll buy the tickets.

    I think they're more TINKS, than TINGS, but then I've been to a lot of church basement weddings where the main drinking vessel is a red Solo cup, and it's usually a drunk uncle announcing the toasts.

    The 10-word German crossword dictionary is still killing it.

    People: 26 {WOW! So unnecessary. Wrapped up with AVA, ENO, STU triple punch.}
    Places: 2
    Products: 6
    Partials: 13
    Foreignisms: 10
    --
    Gary's Grid Gunk Gauge: 57 of 132 (43%) {This is an irrationally high number on Sunday. No wonder it's getting lit on fire.}

    Funnyisms: 9 😄

    Tee-Hee: SEX. ASS.

    Uniclues:

    1 Regular Joes writing poetry about a dead comedian.
    2 Sheesk, naked people fighting over a Big Mac with cheese in France.
    3 Nervous feeling in the pit of one's stomach at church when the homily goes past noon.
    4 What one wears during a food fight in the church basement.

    1 FAN-FIC O'ER MILTIE
    2 RAW BATTLE ROYALES OMG
    3 CONGREGANT NOODLE BOWL AGITA
    4 HOUSE OF GOD EGG FOO YUNG HAT

    My Fascinating Crossword Uniclue Keepsake from Last Year: Sesame Street hero known for hosting parties for older men. BEAR TRAPS BERT.

    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for bromeando! It's been a long time since junior high Spanish class and I enjoy your intro sentences.
      And no wonder most people hate this puzzle — 43% junk!

      Delete
    2. @Gary J. I balked BORK too! If I didn’t get my daily love and current slang tutorial from my granddaughter, I’d just be waaaay old! Had to wait until the end for that one to drop because I couldn’t grok the theme until CONGREGANT.

      Delete
  80. I hate Sundays so much that I usually skip them. I almost always end up with one square (out of what, 10,000?) wrong and it takes me forever to find it, or like today, I couldn't even see it comparing it to Rex's completed puzzle. I had SISCO/CUANTA. Ugh.

    ReplyDelete
  81. Did not like this puzzle, not one bit. I agree with Rex's criticism, and then there's my own apparently individual problem: Took forever to realize "share cleanup duty" was not COED IT which I could not parse but CO EDIT. D'oh.

    ReplyDelete
  82. Anonymous4:37 PM

    I was happy to read most everyone disliked this puzzle as much as I did. As I was filling it in I just kept thinking this just doesn’t make sense. No aha moment at all. Very disappointing. do you think I got excited when I looked at the magnets and thought that this could be a very interesting solve. Not!

    ReplyDelete
  83. Anonymous4:49 PM

    This is one of the worst Sunday puzzles I have seen in many many years.

    ReplyDelete
  84. Anonymous4:51 PM

    I thought GRINAR looked wrong but I did not think it could possibly be REB. I assumed it had to be RAB as in, RABBI. Overall this puzzle was just awful.

    ReplyDelete
  85. Anonymous4:53 PM

    Interesting to see the thoughts on The puzzles for today and yesterday. I actually quite enjoyed this one, it didn't feel too difficult and I liked the themers. Some gunkiness in the fill, but nothing that really held me up.

    Meanwhile, while Rex called yesterday's puzzle "easy", I found it to be stupidly hard and didn't enjoy it at all.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous10:59 PM

      You were like, "oh yes, Reb, obviously"?

      Delete
  86. I work in IT and have heard exactly 1 person in my life use the word “Bork” - it was always in relation to a server or machine being hosed. Saw the clue, saw the grid, and said “wait, was Don using a legit term for something being broken all these years?” I always thought he just made it up or was using it almost like onomatopoeia.

    ReplyDelete
  87. Anonymous7:15 PM

    I’m a novice compared to you all. I usually do the puzzle over several days. This one I completed today but hated it. Not fun at all. I got the theme early on but didn’t enjoy much of the solving.

    ReplyDelete
  88. Anonymous10:21 PM

    Colin here (up in Cape COD so not logged in)…. Today, I knew, just KNEW how much Rex would hate this. And for once, I have to agree this theme was not well-executed. Very much forced. I did like the cluing for OBI, though. G’night!

    ReplyDelete
  89. I get lost in crosswords. They are especially helpful as I have been quite sick since December. As a result , I like virtually all the Times crosswords. But while doing this one I said , uh-oh, Rex and most commenters will not like this one! Having things like GNUY did not go over well. That was the first one I discovered. Thought it very odd but continued on. I think what many here call a slog I actually like.
    On the other hand, a lot of times I feel people are way over reacting. But I think this constructor relied too much on computer programming and people sensed it. And got turned off.
    There’s almost always something Rex complains about that makes no sense (to me) Abs of steel had absolutely no connection in my mind before today with commercial use. As far as I knew it was an often jokey expression. It was in the language ( maybe not now?). That’s why the commercial use. Didn’t see anything wrong with it in the puzzle

    ReplyDelete
  90. obsidianop10:53 PM

    This is a fun blog so I don't want to be negative, but at this point I've decided the difficulty ratings are pure trolling. If this isn't a hard Sunday - a dozen pairs that would be nasty on a Friday/Saturday plus a theme that's more inscrutable than the most arcane Thursday - then there's just no meaning to them. I'm not sure in six months of following I've seen the word "hard" appear. I'm very impressed you're all so smart, pats on the head, etc., but please stop screwing with us.

    ReplyDelete
  91. Anonymous11:19 PM

    1) This puzzle sucked. Having all the animals be the last 3 letters of 4-letter answers was very dumb.
    2) As someone who often uses the word BORK for that sense, it was one of the few clues in the puzzle I enjoyed, even though I knew it was a bad clue.
    3) Specifically in the US, BATTLE ROYALE has a particular racist connotation, and I'm amazed it was used in the puzzle.
    4) I thought the whole puzzle was pretty easy (13:18 on my timer), especially once the themer fell into place.
    5) I need to reiterate that this puzzle sucked.

    ReplyDelete
  92. Anonymous12:37 AM

    This was awful. It would've been clever if the animals "attracted" to each other had an actual connection, in nature, to each other.

    ReplyDelete
  93. Anonymous12:57 AM

    I hate to agree with Rex. But, wow, it took me forever to figure out what was happening and every answer just seemed tortured. Probably took close to 25 minutes to complete, and it was just not fun. If I didn't have a streak going I would have just quit.

    ReplyDelete
  94. Bob Mills5:30 AM

    Gave up halfway through. Just exhausting, even after I had caught on to the trick. Crossword puzzles are supposed to be fun. This was awful.

    ReplyDelete
  95. I know this is a late comment, but I have to mention that this grid design gives eight unchecked letters. For example the y in egg foo yung is only in that word. There is no crossing word to verify it with. It’s not part of the animal in this case, gnu) I thought that was a total no no.

    ReplyDelete
  96. Anonymous1:11 PM

    This is the second Sunday puzzle in a row that I abandoned before finishing because it was just plain no-fun and borderline performative. Just because one CAN create something doesn’t mean that one SHOULD. I’m beginning to think that more (hopefully not yet all) NYT crosswords are being created by a humorless AI which misses nuance and thinks it’s cleverer than it is.

    ReplyDelete
  97. Pretty tough for a Sunday, and I didn't quite get the theme. I saw the animals, but nothing reallly said 'magnetism' to me. Ah, I see - my grid had no horseshoe magnets in it. Also, I failed to see that the themers were (very loosely) paired.

    ReplyDelete
  98. I'm quite new to crosswords, never did hem before subscribing to the online New York Times in December 2024. I had this filled even though there were a few terms I didn't know, but apparently one letter was incorrect. I've heard of Palermo, but not Salerno, and I had no idea what the cross was getting at. An abbreviation of a French word? I'm guessing it's Ste. for Saint, which now seems familiar. So close.

    I was completely stuck after working about an hour, then came back to it after a few days, and a handful of answers clicked. Bork took a while, and it was one of those things where I wasn't quite sure if I remembered it correctly, but I had heard it. I'm nerdy enough that I knew Quanta right away, but needed some cross-help for Apogee.

    So newbie question: I've figured out what WOE means, but what do the letters stand for?

    ReplyDelete
  99. Maybe "What On Earth..."?

    ReplyDelete
  100. Just another stupid PPP fest...had no trouble putting it quickly into the trash...as the earlier wag aptly put it: just offal!

    ReplyDelete
  101. For once, I am in complete agreement with Rex and most other commenters. This one was a joyless slog. In part because the thematic answers were so vaguely connected, it was also time consuming, but I had zero sense of fun or achievement at the end. It's interesting to compare this puzzle with last week's "Making Arrangements" by Sam Brody. That one was clever, relatively quick, and a lot of fun. Give me fun any day!

    ReplyDelete
  102. Anonymous8:42 PM

    Glad I'm not the only one. I don't understand it even after looking up the answers.

    ReplyDelete
  103. First dnf in months. Like OFL I hated this puzzle. If you have to take almost a year using software to create a puzzle just stop and start over with a better concept.

    ReplyDelete